I disagree if he's assisting people to kill themselves legally he's aiding in a murder. He's not called death for nothing. Why does someone like him who probably doesn't even understand what these people go through, be able to say that they should or should not have the right to commit suicide. If you just watch it happen and not offer help and only offer a permanent solution. Life is to be protected. We should not encourage human beings to kill themselves 😢
How do you think the doctor or you are going to feel when judgement day comes and God tells you himself you're a murderer and that by helping that person kill themselves. You're sending people into eternal hell fire. This is not okay. It's irreversible. & when that day comes and you and him understand you caused 1000× more pain to that person by assisting their suicide. It's wrong. You don't know where people go so you can promise they will stay out of pain. What if he's sending everyone who does this to hell by association? The blood will be on his hands
I @@mytruthmylife8725 I don't think the doctor was suggesting that he could say whether or not someone had the right to commit suicide - suicide is not illegal and not considered to be murder. He simply wanted to be of assistance (legally) to those who wanted to end their life and my thoughts are that this is a compassionate act.. For some people, life is just unbearable. I agree with you that 'life is to be protected' provided that is what an individual wants. I also agree that we should not encourage people to 'kill themselves' and as far as I could sense, the doctor wasn't doing that. To deny someone the option of ending life despite untold pain and distress strikes me as being rather cruel and hard hearted. Perhaps I'm being a bit 'soft' and perhaps people who are suffering from untreatable pain and misery should 'grin and bear it' as your sentiments seem to suggest.
@@mytruthmylife8725 you have happy life but not all people get that life. if your body works perfectly so you not need that machine but nature or god makes all the things perfectly if you are in bad health conditions and also you have ugly face. You don't want to live this f**king world. so you don't have rights to make a decision someone life . Its like very cheap behaviour. If someone was affected by health conditions they decide to die or live. If they decide to you to go that machine and die then you will comment it. Why people having worst behaviour. They do not help someone and cure diseases but says why you choose to suicide live happily it's just like why you have asthma there is so much air like concept 😮💨
I was diagnosed with Stage IV Grade 3 cancer in May of 2017. Apparently, I have approximately 2 years left 🤷♀️ I am a Veterinary Nurse, and did my entrance paper on how we, in Veterinary medicine, are fortunate to be able to proceed with euthanasia in terminal cases when Suffering is all that's left. I'm not in a state that permits assistance with Death. I will seek it out if necessary. I have 4 children & 2 grandbabies who I don't want to burden AND leave with horrible memories of me wasting away rather than the Beautiful memories we're making Now! 💖🙏💞
@@AndrewGold1 I'm loving Life & learning wonderful things I would have never learned 🎶💃 Thanks for your kind response & for shedding light on this important topic 👍 I just found your channel through Shaun Atwood's. I'm looking forward to watching more of your work 😊 💖🙏💞 💖🙏💞
@@Stacey0909 Thanks Stacey. Shaun is coming on my podcast soon, so there'll be more from the two of us. And yes, learning and curiosity is the whole meaning of life imo, so I'm pleased you're keeping at it! Hope we get to interact a lot on here :)
Deeply sorry that you are going through such a thing and sincerely hope you find the conclusion you deserve, i guess if nothing else being a veterinary nurse comes with its perks in these unfortunate situations.
It brought me some satisfaction that the doctor who refused to sign saw the documentary and felt horrible, as he should. It was a sad story and could’ve been preventable had medical professionals did their duty and lived by the oath they took in the first place.
Killing someone instead of caring for them and sympathising genuinely with their pain is wrong. You can casually dismiss their pain as 'their' personal problem and think you can just wash your hands of caring and being responsible for them. To do so is wrong.
@@AndrewGold1 That approach is too convenient. It means you can just withdraw into your private escapist world and you dont have to bother about the other person.
No, you try to help them. No one is suggesting assisted suicide for hungry people. And Philip specifically says it'd only used for adults. Ones who choose to opt out of life - usually because they suffer with an incurable illness. Anyway I respect your opinion!
@@AndrewGold1 agreeing that someone needs to be killed is a principle or general rule. Once established for individual cases you cant limit how the rule will be applied in the future. It's like 'natural' selection for humans. Your life is not worth living and there isnt anyone strong enough or willing to share the pain - even family members want the convenience of your death. A child dying from famine becomes another such inconvenience.
@@robi9558 Again, I think you're misunderstanding. This isn't other people deciding someone needs to be killed. It's the person themselves having the right to opt out of their own life should they so want. Some people are suffering terribly with illnesses. As someone else said, if you've seen a loved one go through a slow and painful death...I've certainly seen that, with people who just wanted to opt out a few months earlier rather than suffer the torture and indignity of what happened to them.
@@AndrewGold1 No. The misunderstanding is that this is only a personal choice. You are promoting the view that it is ok to have social and family attitudes that believes it is ok to get someone killed - even someone they know and should value. They put pressure on the ill person to die. The ill person is made to believe he or she should die so that others dont have to cope with the care needs of the person who is ill.
I am troubled that you let this destructive view be heard so that the attitude (here is an acceptable way to kill people) becomes normalised and accepted.
So you had cancer, did you saw people get so swelle so much that they are irreconocible, have you heard the screams of people that are in so much pain and there is nothing you or morphine can do?
I know this was a month ago but I missed it - sorry. I am sorry if you went through those things. I did myself too. And you're right it's not nice! Hope you enjoyed this video - I find that guy fascinating!
Hi Rob, it's a tough one really. I think one of the people who replied to this echoes my thoughts. When you really see someone suffer, you understand the need for this stuff. It can't be more moral to just leave someone to suffer like that, can it? Thanks anyway for watching and commenting.
MAYBE IF YOU END UP WITH CANCER AND NO AMOUNT OF PAIN MEDICATION RELIEVES YOUR SUFFERING YOU MIGHT THINK TWICE!!!! A SLOW AGONIZING DEATH!!!! THE IGNORANCE OF PEOPLE LIKE YOU MAKE ME LAUGH!!!!
@@AndrewGold1 The reasoning is that you start to devalue some individuals as not worthwhile and should be dead. What is the reasoning for saying someone needs to die?
@@robi9558 Would you rather have people being forced to continue living and suffering instead of them choosing to end their suffering with medical assistance?
@@robi9558 I don't think that death devalues a person. I don't think that assisted suicide devalues a person. You're proof of that. Many strangers have been assisted in their suicides before I posted this, yet you value them no less. I think that assisted suicide has nothing to do with stating that someone needs to die. I think it has everything to do with avoiding inhumane types, frequencies, and levels of pain.
I think we should be allowed our own personal given right IF we are of sound mind and in terrible pain and suffering to have the right to access proper genuine strength Nembutal to go home drink the soloution and pass away peacefully. This would rule out the horrendous scammers online ripping people off selling fake Nembutal and also horrendous costs to go to Europe for an assisted suicide also. We have paid our taxes all our life. When one is healthy and happy no one wants to end their life.
Dr Nitschke is a legend and a great human. We need more like him.
Thanks, hope you enjoyed, and do sub to the channel!
I disagree if he's assisting people to kill themselves legally he's aiding in a murder. He's not called death for nothing. Why does someone like him who probably doesn't even understand what these people go through, be able to say that they should or should not have the right to commit suicide. If you just watch it happen and not offer help and only offer a permanent solution. Life is to be protected. We should not encourage human beings to kill themselves 😢
How do you think the doctor or you are going to feel when judgement day comes and God tells you himself you're a murderer and that by helping that person kill themselves. You're sending people into eternal hell fire. This is not okay. It's irreversible. & when that day comes and you and him understand you caused 1000× more pain to that person by assisting their suicide. It's wrong. You don't know where people go so you can promise they will stay out of pain. What if he's sending everyone who does this to hell by association? The blood will be on his hands
I @@mytruthmylife8725 I don't think the doctor was suggesting that he could say whether or not someone had the right to commit suicide - suicide is not illegal and not considered to be murder. He simply wanted to be of assistance (legally) to those who wanted to end their life and my thoughts are that this is a compassionate act.. For some people, life is just unbearable. I agree with you that 'life is to be protected' provided that is what an individual wants. I also agree that we should not encourage people to 'kill themselves' and as far as I could sense, the doctor wasn't doing that. To deny someone the option of ending life despite untold pain and distress strikes me as being rather cruel and hard hearted. Perhaps I'm being a bit 'soft' and perhaps people who are suffering from untreatable pain and misery should 'grin and bear it' as your sentiments seem to suggest.
@@mytruthmylife8725
you have happy life but not all people get that life. if your body works perfectly so you not need that machine but nature or god makes all the things perfectly if you are in bad health conditions and also you have ugly face. You don't want to live this f**king world. so you don't have rights to make a decision someone life . Its like very cheap behaviour. If someone was affected by health conditions they decide to die or live. If they decide to you to go that machine and die then you will comment it. Why people having worst behaviour. They do not help someone and cure diseases but says why you choose to suicide live happily it's just like why you have asthma there is so much air like concept 😮💨
I was diagnosed with Stage IV Grade 3 cancer in May of 2017. Apparently, I have approximately 2 years left 🤷♀️
I am a Veterinary Nurse, and did my entrance paper on how we, in Veterinary medicine, are fortunate to be able to proceed with euthanasia in terminal cases when Suffering is all that's left.
I'm not in a state that permits assistance with Death. I will seek it out if necessary.
I have 4 children & 2 grandbabies who I don't want to burden AND leave with horrible memories of me wasting away rather than the Beautiful memories we're making Now!
💖🙏💞
Wow. Stacey thanks so much for sharing this. I'm so so sorry for what you are going through and wish you and your family all the best.
@@AndrewGold1 I'm loving Life & learning wonderful things I would have never learned 🎶💃
Thanks for your kind response & for shedding light on this important topic 👍
I just found your channel through Shaun Atwood's. I'm looking forward to watching more of your work 😊
💖🙏💞
💖🙏💞
@@Stacey0909 Thanks Stacey. Shaun is coming on my podcast soon, so there'll be more from the two of us. And yes, learning and curiosity is the whole meaning of life imo, so I'm pleased you're keeping at it! Hope we get to interact a lot on here :)
@@AndrewGold1 🤗🥳😎
Deeply sorry that you are going through such a thing and sincerely hope you find the conclusion you deserve, i guess if nothing else being a veterinary nurse comes with its perks in these unfortunate situations.
People are screwed! What a odd time to be alive. I hate life!
Where can i get this machine, I need one.
How sad is this story? Would making it legal have helped?
It brought me some satisfaction that the doctor who refused to sign saw the documentary and felt horrible, as he should.
It was a sad story and could’ve been preventable had medical professionals did their duty and lived by the oath they took in the first place.
Thank you for this! Nice talk. Subscribed!
ah thank you aryn! look forward to chatting on here!
This world needs Jesus..
No one is preventing Jesus from coming back...
Lord God please send the Demons to hell that fill these peoples souls in the mighty Nme of Jesus
Killing someone instead of caring for them and sympathising genuinely with their pain is wrong. You can casually dismiss their pain as 'their' personal problem and think you can just wash your hands of caring and being responsible for them. To do so is wrong.
Ah here - but surely we should allow the person suffering to decide?
@@AndrewGold1 That approach is too convenient. It means you can just withdraw into your private escapist world and you dont have to bother about the other person.
@@robi9558 Yeh I do get what you're saying. Thanks Rob!
You clearly haven’t cared for someone who is dying from cancer.
@@TheIsopod06 I think you're talking to Rob, not sure. But I have indeed, and it was horrific. A machine like Philip's might have helped a lot.
When you hear a child scream with pain due to famine and drought, you don't kill the child.
No, you try to help them. No one is suggesting assisted suicide for hungry people. And Philip specifically says it'd only used for adults. Ones who choose to opt out of life - usually because they suffer with an incurable illness. Anyway I respect your opinion!
@@AndrewGold1 agreeing that someone needs to be killed is a principle or general rule. Once established for individual cases you cant limit how the rule will be applied in the future. It's like 'natural' selection for humans. Your life is not worth living and there isnt anyone strong enough or willing to share the pain - even family members want the convenience of your death. A child dying from famine becomes another such inconvenience.
@@robi9558 Again, I think you're misunderstanding. This isn't other people deciding someone needs to be killed. It's the person themselves having the right to opt out of their own life should they so want. Some people are suffering terribly with illnesses. As someone else said, if you've seen a loved one go through a slow and painful death...I've certainly seen that, with people who just wanted to opt out a few months earlier rather than suffer the torture and indignity of what happened to them.
@@AndrewGold1 No. The misunderstanding is that this is only a personal choice. You are promoting the view that it is ok to have social and family attitudes that believes it is ok to get someone killed - even someone they know and should value. They put pressure on the ill person to die. The ill person is made to believe he or she should die so that others dont have to cope with the care needs of the person who is ill.
@@robi9558 Yeh I get that side of it. Fair point. It's hard, because some people really do want to die.
I am troubled that you let this destructive view be heard so that the attitude (here is an acceptable way to kill people) becomes normalised and accepted.
So you had cancer, did you saw people get so swelle so much that they are irreconocible, have you heard the screams of people that are in so much pain and there is nothing you or morphine can do?
I am troubled by people who procreate and increase the amount of sentient beings who suffer
I know this was a month ago but I missed it - sorry. I am sorry if you went through those things. I did myself too. And you're right it's not nice! Hope you enjoyed this video - I find that guy fascinating!
Hi Rob, it's a tough one really. I think one of the people who replied to this echoes my thoughts. When you really see someone suffer, you understand the need for this stuff. It can't be more moral to just leave someone to suffer like that, can it? Thanks anyway for watching and commenting.
MAYBE IF YOU END UP WITH CANCER AND NO AMOUNT OF PAIN MEDICATION RELIEVES YOUR SUFFERING YOU MIGHT THINK TWICE!!!! A SLOW AGONIZING DEATH!!!! THE IGNORANCE OF PEOPLE LIKE YOU MAKE ME LAUGH!!!!
assisted suicide doesnt 'go wrong', it is wrong.
Thanks for watching Rob T. All opinions welcome here. Out of interest, what is your reasoning for it being wrong? Andrew
@@AndrewGold1 The reasoning is that you start to devalue some individuals as not worthwhile and should be dead. What is the reasoning for saying someone needs to die?
@@robi9558 Would you rather have people being forced to continue living and suffering instead of them choosing to end their suffering with medical assistance?
@@robi9558 I don't think that death devalues a person. I don't think that assisted suicide devalues a person. You're proof of that. Many strangers have been assisted in their suicides before I posted this, yet you value them no less. I think that assisted suicide has nothing to do with stating that someone needs to die. I think it has everything to do with avoiding inhumane types, frequencies, and levels of pain.
It's not wrong.
If someone isn't gonna help me, I'll just do it myself.
I think we should be allowed our own personal given right IF we are of sound mind and in terrible pain and suffering to have the right to access proper genuine strength Nembutal to go home drink the soloution and pass away peacefully.
This would rule out the horrendous scammers online ripping people off selling fake Nembutal and also horrendous costs to go to Europe for an assisted suicide also. We have paid our taxes all our life.
When one is healthy and happy no one wants to end their life.
yes absolutely!
Hi Andrew its a complete joke the whole system. Regulate the Nembutal give people the personal choice
@@MP-po6fj I agree! Total BS!!!