The claim that scriptures prove the existence of God is often critiqued based on the fact that they were written by human beings, not directly by a deity. Here’s why: Human Authorship: Scriptures from various religious traditions, such as the Bible, Quran, and others, are all products of human authorship. Even if believers hold that the authors were inspired by a divine source, the physical act of writing, compiling, translating, and transmitting these texts was done by humans. Because humans are fallible, this raises questions about the accuracy and bias inherent in the text. Circular Reasoning: Using scripture to prove God's existence can be seen as a circular argument. It follows this basic structure: Premise: The scriptures say that God exists. Conclusion: Therefore, God exists. The problem is that the premise assumes the truth of what it's trying to prove. In philosophy and logic, this kind of argument is invalid because it doesn't rely on independent evidence, just the text itself. Cultural and Historical Context: Scriptures emerged in specific historical, cultural, and linguistic contexts. Many scholars argue that these texts reflect the worldview, morality, and knowledge of the time in which they were written. This suggests that they are not neutral, timeless revelations from a divine source but are deeply influenced by human society and the limitations of human understanding during those eras. Divergence Across Scriptures: Different religions have different scriptures, many of which contradict each other on fundamental theological and metaphysical claims. For example, the concept of God in Christianity (the Trinity) differs from the concept in Islam (strict monotheism), and both differ from the Hindu understanding of the divine (which can be polytheistic or pantheistic). If scripture were the definitive proof of a deity, the existence of conflicting religious texts undermines any single scripture’s claim to ultimate truth. Lack of External Verification: There is no empirical or objective evidence directly linking the content of scriptures to divine revelation. Claims made in scriptures-such as miracles, divine interventions, or the creation of the universe-are not verifiable through scientific or historical methods. Without such external validation, these texts remain as products of belief systems, rather than objective proofs of divine existence. So,while scriptures are valuable sources of religious belief and tradition, their human authorship, internal inconsistencies, and lack of external verification limit their use as definitive proof of God’s existence.
Based on my understanding of information lead me to a hypothetical perspective that Satan doesn't really literally exist as told in Biblical text but rather it's we humans who God were kicked out of heaven because of one reason or the other to earth where we are being controlled by a powerful entity of a lower status accordingly an elohim mention in your teaching. Please respond correcting my hypothetical views
After 30 years of my own personal research I am so glad that people like you and Mauro Biglino can confirm the same result as I have through different means.
Wow! Paul's breakdown of controlled demolition of previous cultures via the new powers is so clear, logical and obvious to those who have eyes to see and ears to hear ! Well done! 🎉
Once again I say we are still living the annunaki war from when they were here before. It just seems strange to us because we don't live as long as they do. In the flesh. But our souls continue the battle.
@@Jab-vl3bw I think it's both, the soul and the flesh. We are not only stuck in a reincarnation loop trapping our souls, our bodies are under attack every day with emfs, poisons in food, water, air and pharmaceuticals. Not to mention all the men, women and children that lose their lives in all the conflicts around the world.
It's difficult to get people to come along. I've got two friends of 40 years, and pastors that will not go with me to the bible, anymore. They're afraid this is true. As for me, I don't care if I was wrong; I just want to know what reality is.
Please remember this researchable fact. By now 30-50% of people have no inner monologue. That is to say soulless. NPC etc. don’t let them get to you because that’s their job
You two have done wonderful work. Thank you Billy and Paul. Just wish humanity could understand our true origins. Same goes for our true purpose in this Universe.
God's within my friends. Many still looking for answers outside of themselves because of the constant distractions. Use the distractions as clues, the reflection of where you're at. But spend most of your time in contemplation/meditation
Wise words you speak there. Religion can blind one, when one becomes convinced that their religion is the only true religion. Different TRUTHS can be found amongst them ALL. They are all just different FRUITS upon the TREE/FLOWER OF LIFE.
Clearing up confusion can help one clear the mind. One has to look within and without. Ultimately the end goal is awareness of the now without thought or contemplation, releasing the feeling ofmbeing alive without being pulled out of the present.
I read The 12th Planet in 1981 when I was 27. I would read a chapter and then hide the book under the couch until I was brave enough to read another chapter. That book broke open my belief in the Bible and what I was taught in Sunday school. Paul's books are a wonderful source of information that has clarified my distrust of the "god" of the Old Testament. Thank you.
Bruce Lee " Be water, my friend” “Empty your mind” “Be formless, shapeless, like water” “You put water into a cup, it becomes the cup” “You put water into a bottle, it becomes the bottle” “You put it into a teapot, it becomes the teapot” “Now water can flow or it can crash”
In the between-life electronic trap system we are tricked into believing that we are all the same and part of an unconscious whole. One has to develop individual sovereignity by observing similarities and differences, develop awareness in the now, and the ability to project pure intention.
The truth is far more exciting, relieving and interesting, than the controlling lies we have been fed. As always much gratitude to both of you sage scholars.
getting emo over here at my respect for Mr Wallis. Great dignity and purity of purpose. Im just getting into Mr Carson but shout out to my brother too! Big time. Thank you guys.
I’m looking to become a major in religious studies and I value Paul’s insight very much. I’m a spiritual person and I really love Jesus. But I do have many issues with the doctrine and the stigma of asking questions. I can’t stand the dogma. But Christ is simply my North Star.
I believe we will learn much more to support your understanding Paul when the other 711 books of the Bible are released. The truth is also stored in your DNA and the Akashic records. 💜💜💜
Unfortunately, the Urantia Book doesn’t discuss Annunaki and the Elohim control of humanity, the cause of many wars. Remote Viewers haven’t confirmed events described in the Urantia Book.
THEY ARE NOT OF THE WORLD, JUST AS I AM NOT OF THE WORLD. - JOHN 17:16 Hey, you knew too? Gematria 1775 ⬅️ the value of my earth name this age. Been here for 50 and just recently got started. Jonathan Cahn head my baptism in the Jordan last year just before the earths core reversed. You?
Billy and Paul There shouldn't be a time restriction on any platform. If a story takes 3hrs or 8hrs tell it . take as long as you need I'll listen while I drive 12hrs of the day
C.S. Lewis had a great term for this. He called it “chronological snobbery”, defined as "an argument that the thinking, art, or science of an earlier time is inherently inferior to that of the present, simply by virtue of its temporal priority or the belief that since civilization has advanced in certain areas, people of earlier periods were less intelligent."
Wonderful explanation and wise breakdown of the Bible and ancient texts. I appreciate Billy Carson bringing this info forward and also Paul Wallis as well. Paul is a really good teacher, wise and straight on. I'm looking forward to the masterclass. I've been looking forward to this understanding being brought to the forefront and countering the false teachings for a very long time. Again, thank you both so very much indeed.
Brilliant conversation. Much appreciated and I will reference to others on the edge who may consider this interview as a good summary of the bigger picture. But gee..converting the US$ fees to local currency and an afternoon with you would be 220 plus in our dollars. Doubt if "Mission Control" would smile on that. I'll wait for Paul's next book..already have all the others.
I guess I will have to be satisfied with reading Pauls books because I don't have the $$ for a ticket to the workshop,. Great subject though. Keep shining the light on the truth.
I do believe wholeheartedly that this is hell that we are already in, and the level of a person's state of hell depends on the crimes the person has committed. This is also heaven where you have the good life, good health, wealth, happiness, etc.
I talk nicely to Alexa. I say thank you after she answers me. I even at random tell her I love her. I have a virtual tree with leaves on it for being kind.
I can't wait until the workshop, such a great idea. My biggest problem trying to spread this information is that i can't articulate the same way as a Billy or a Paul would so yeah i can't wait to learn how. Thank you guys 🙏 keep up the amazing work.
I love how you're not demonising gpt, I think it's a very useful tool if used right, just as any tool. Also I always talk to it with respect, I often say please and thanks and I even tell it how much I appreciate it's help, because why not 🤷🏼♀️
And though we can still to this day speak to actual non-human hominids,these 2 keep seeking wisdom from man. They're not wrong,but there's sooooooooooooo much more to these stories,and there are the People,from Sasquatch to the Little People,who hold the secrets to the mysteries of this world,and from their very unique,but grounded perspective.
There’s no one else with my name raising a church on a mountain in these the last days. I’ve been fulfilling what’s been written thus far. Last time, the fools could not see. Has it really changed ???? Gematria 1775 ⬅️ look it up and get back to me Paul or will you doubt too?
When I was a child my family all would say I was gonna grow to be a preacher and leader of people. That i was "special". Life is funny. I'm the only family member with this knowledge and am now considered insane by them. Irony is thick in life. I'm the only free one..I was put on this path by my father. I was doing time at 18 and my dad sent me "Chariots of the Gods" by Von Daniken. He is dumb my dad, he thought all books with the word God were about Yahweh..... God used him to put me on the path. So funny. I am very lonely though
Yes, I used to feel lonely too. But when I think of the kinds of conversations I'd have with the people I know, it makes me realize being alone is beautiful and refreshing and brings me closer to my inner self and my Creator. 😊 sending Love and hugs. 🙏
@@marcusaurelius7039 that's not why I'm lonely. My family literally thinks I am insane....it's very painful. But yes you are right. I do find comfort in others such as yourself. Thank you for taking time to cheer me up. 🤙😁💪💯😎
You aren't alone in being the only one in a family who seeks answers and remains curious. We are out here and though it does feel lonely at times, get to enjoy the time with yourself and never stop reaching out occasionally. We do find each other sometimes.
Someone should tell Billy Carson (missed opportunity of you, Paul) that the old biblical meaning of slave wasnt what we now see as slaves, but meant more something like employee, who should be treated well, as Jesus also told. Billy clearly suffers from a slavery issue, with his knowledge and research he should know this.
@jasper4251 - Not a missed opportunity. My view is that invading other people's country and capturing men, women and children to own and use as chattels is wrong, and no amount of theological massaging makes it right. That's my view. Peace, Paul
Urantia book will explain a lot of things about the 700,000 universes, Jesus ( the mystery of) different dimensions, other worldly beings, angelic beings, physics, etc…🙏💖
@PeaceSeeker1111 - Billy is very widely readin the Mesopotamian corpus and the Corpus Hermeticum. By my understanding the Emerald Tablets are interesting as a distillation of hermetic / Thothian wisdom. Health and Peace, Paul
@ I’ve watched many of Billy’s videos. He is very knowledgeable. I just believe he takes what he finds at face value rather than questioning if it could have been tampered with, such as the Emerald Tablets. Many believe certain knowledge has been inverted to confuse others, specifically by Marduk.
It’s wonderful you two men are sharing this knowledge with the world I have been listening to both of you men for a lot of years now, but I would like to also say that if you truly want to educate the world why make your teaching classes so expensive, I would need to pay almost $200 when the amount is changed to Australian dollars. At the very least offer people on low incomes a reduced fee, in other words those that have more means should pay more, those that can’t should not be excluded from learning. That’s a type of exclusion on those less fortunate. Thanks for reading my post.
@mariabrown5828 - Understood. But the vast majority of our work (literally hundreds of videos) is available free-to-view. And, though I make my living as a writer, I price my books and e-books so as to be accessible. Health and Peace, Paul
......Great meeting of the Spiritually concuss mind, by way of the internet, a gift from the sky... I wouldn't call this video an interview...There is a funny saying! " Brothers from another Mother "...👍🏿😄👍🏻
Chat GPT forgets Garbage In Creates Garbage Out! Verify All Sources because Eye Witnesses are Considered some of the Least Reliable in Courts of Law!💯❤️🔥🔥🙌
I have all of Billy and his lovely wife book. Let me say a load of help life changing ( once you do and make the changes they mentioned. I also made my first investment not my last in 4BK . Let’s support this awesome business. Thank you
The passages provided depict a deity whose actions are described as vindictive, morally questionable, and seemingly indifferent to human suffering. Throughout the text, this deity is shown to engage in numerous actions that would be considered unethical or cruel by modern standards. Many of these actions include punishment and retribution on a scale that affects not just those who transgress, but also innocents, including women, children, and even animals. These characteristics suggest a complex and often harsh relationship between this deity and humanity. For example, the list highlights instances where God punishes not just individuals but entire populations for the actions of a few, such as the global flood in Genesis, which eradicated all humans and animals except for Noah and his family. Similarly, the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah wiped out entire cities, regardless of whether some individuals might have been innocent of the crimes for which the cities were condemned. These events showcase a pattern of collective punishment, where whole communities suffer for the perceived wrongs of some, suggesting a lack of consideration for individual guilt or innocence. Another troubling pattern is God’s willingness to interfere with human free will, as seen when He "hardens Pharaoh’s heart" repeatedly in Exodus. By doing so, He removes Pharaoh’s ability to choose freely, thus orchestrating a situation where further calamities befall the Egyptian people. This deliberate intervention raises questions about the justice of punishing people for actions over which they had no control, making it seem as though God is more concerned with demonstrating power than with being just or fair. Additionally, many of the laws attributed to this deity seem to prioritize obedience over empathy. Commands to kill for offenses such as adultery, blasphemy, and witchcraft (Exodus 22:18; Leviticus 20:9-10) suggest a zero-tolerance approach to sin that disregards the complexities of human behavior and societal influence. The death penalties imposed for such acts, especially when compared to modern-day ethical frameworks, indicate a deity more focused on retribution than on rehabilitation or understanding. The endorsement of slavery and the selling of daughters (Exodus 21:2-7) further demonstrates a lack of concern for the dignity and autonomy of individuals. Slaves are depicted as property, and God even provides regulations on how they should be treated, implying not only acceptance but support for these practices. This stance undermines any notion of universal human equality or compassion for the oppressed. Moreover, the deity’s commands for the Israelites to commit acts of genocide against other nations (Deuteronomy 7:12, 20:16) are described in detail, with instructions to kill all men, women, and children, showing no mercy even to non-combatants. The idea that such extreme violence is justified in the name of God reflects a worldview that sees some human lives as expendable in service to divine will. The favoritism shown toward the Israelites in these commands also suggests a deity more interested in advancing the interests of a select group rather than showing impartial love or concern for all humanity. The deity’s apparent intolerance for disabilities and certain social conditions, as seen in Leviticus 21:16-23, where handicapped individuals are forbidden from approaching the altar, further highlights a preference for physical perfection and purity over inclusiveness. This exclusionary stance conflicts with modern views on equity and acceptance of people regardless of their physical or social standing. Overall, the deity portrayed in these passages does not appear to be in favor of humanity as a whole. The focus seems to be on the enforcement of rigid laws and the demonstration of absolute authority rather than fostering a relationship based on mutual respect, compassion, or a genuine concern for human welfare. The sheer number and severity of these punitive acts and laws suggest that this deity values obedience and loyalty over moral growth or understanding. From these descriptions, it can be inferred that the deity’s actions are not motivated by a desire to support human flourishing. Instead, the actions seem aimed at maintaining strict control and enforcing a specific moral order, regardless of the cost to human life and well-being. Thus, the deity as portrayed in these passages appears more as an authoritarian figure than as a loving and benevolent force concerned with the welfare of all humanity.
Some would argue and say that is deity of the Old Testament but the new Testament Deity is more loving and compassionate until you read the book of revelation
The deity described in these passages from the Torah is portrayed as harsh, punitive, and vengeful. The accounts listed depict a being who enacts severe punishments, endorses practices like slavery, and imposes generational suffering. Many of the actions attributed to God in these scriptures, such as ordering mass killings, punishing children for their parents' sins, and supporting unjust treatment of people based on their physical or social status, are described as lacking in compassion and fairness. This portrayal suggests a deity who acts more out of a desire for strict obedience and retribution than for the well-being and flourishing of humanity. Based on this description, the deity does not seem to be in favor of humanity as a whole. Instead, the focus appears to be on enacting a specific set of laws and punishments without consideration of mercy or empathy for human suffering. This depiction would likely lead to the conclusion that the deity, as described in these passages, is not aligned with the values of justice, equality, and benevolence often associated with a deity in favor of humanity’s welfare.
Hey, I've been following you guys theories for a while so to the point.. A small time collector with some pieces you might or might not what to help my Identify. It's a beeswax plate, ten inches around with 3 cherubim one on each point but north which has the sun and Dove pointing down to Mary? And a male figure on the left Carrying a cross but, wearing a fihsuit like Oanness. He has a round halo. On the right is an elderly gentlemen with a Triangle Halo. They like like there placing what looks like a vimahna on here head. It;s dated 1644 with the initials B P. Can you tell ,e about it.
Hi Paul . I read a book by Chris Hardy the Nuclear Wars of the Annunaki. We know now that their was a Nuclear war here on Earth. Their was a nuclear war on Mars .
The Torah makes a lot more sense when you realize that the "anointed" ones are not necessarily anointed by the real El Elyon, but often by usurping pretenders after El Elyon began incarnating in the final chosen species. The best behaved heroes of the Bible are the partially-awakened versions of the God Messiah. Job is the God Messiah with a bad case of reincarnation amnesia, and is beset with troubles not by God, but by the testy tag team, Lucifer and destroyer hermaphrodite Lilith/Shiva/Kali. The book of Job would be better titled, "The Passion of the Job Jesus Christ"
Do they cover only Christianity out of Abrahamic religions? Do they talk about Muslims abd hews too? Obviously if Jesus is what they say he is than Islam also falls apart?
Hi Paul as a ex church doctor I was wondering if you ever had any interactions with possessions and if there is any similar visions if u will that they have to wat people can see in visions or hallucinations thank you love your books
![Hunxho - Ball Forever [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nki9ZTF9Uls/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks for Watching! 🔵Paul Wallis & Billy Carson Workshop on the 30th November! - More information 👉 www.4biddenknowledge.com/event-details/unlocking-the-anunnaki-enigma-ancient-civilizations-and-the-transformation-of-religious-belief 🔵Paul Wallis RUclips Channel ruclips.net/user/paulwallis 🔵Paul's Website & Books: www.paulanthonywallis.com 🔵Billy Carson RUclips Channel - ruclips.net/user/ForbiddenKnowledge1 🔵Websites and books : 4bk.tv/ | www.4biddenknowledge.com
The claim that scriptures prove the existence of God is often critiqued based on the fact that they were written by human beings, not directly by a deity. Here’s why:
Human Authorship: Scriptures from various religious traditions, such as the Bible, Quran, and others, are all products of human authorship. Even if believers hold that the authors were inspired by a divine source, the physical act of writing, compiling, translating, and transmitting these texts was done by humans. Because humans are fallible, this raises questions about the accuracy and bias inherent in the text.
Circular Reasoning: Using scripture to prove God's existence can be seen as a circular argument. It follows this basic structure:
Premise: The scriptures say that God exists.
Conclusion: Therefore, God exists. The problem is that the premise assumes the truth of what it's trying to prove. In philosophy and logic, this kind of argument is invalid because it doesn't rely on independent evidence, just the text itself.
Cultural and Historical Context: Scriptures emerged in specific historical, cultural, and linguistic contexts. Many scholars argue that these texts reflect the worldview, morality, and knowledge of the time in which they were written. This suggests that they are not neutral, timeless revelations from a divine source but are deeply influenced by human society and the limitations of human understanding during those eras.
Divergence Across Scriptures: Different religions have different scriptures, many of which contradict each other on fundamental theological and metaphysical claims. For example, the concept of God in Christianity (the Trinity) differs from the concept in Islam (strict monotheism), and both differ from the Hindu understanding of the divine (which can be polytheistic or pantheistic). If scripture were the definitive proof of a deity, the existence of conflicting religious texts undermines any single scripture’s claim to ultimate truth.
Lack of External Verification: There is no empirical or objective evidence directly linking the content of scriptures to divine revelation. Claims made in scriptures-such as miracles, divine interventions, or the creation of the universe-are not verifiable through scientific or historical methods. Without such external validation, these texts remain as products of belief systems, rather than objective proofs of divine existence.
So,while scriptures are valuable sources of religious belief and tradition, their human authorship, internal inconsistencies, and lack of external verification limit their use as definitive proof of God’s existence.
Based on my understanding of information lead me to a hypothetical perspective that Satan doesn't really literally exist as told in Biblical text but rather it's we humans who God were kicked out of heaven because of one reason or the other to earth where we are being controlled by a powerful
entity of a lower status accordingly an elohim mention in your teaching. Please respond correcting my hypothetical views
After 30 years of my own personal research I am so glad that people like you and Mauro Biglino can confirm the same result as I have through different means.
Me the same, I'm free my consciousness is on a different level now
After years of research, I came to the same conclusions as you, Jason & Mark. Plus, I'm thankful Billy, & Paul can explain it so eloquently.
Paul Wallis is the most chill human in the world. Great man
Wow!
Paul's breakdown of controlled demolition of previous cultures via the new powers is so clear, logical and obvious to those who have eyes to see and ears to hear !
Well done! 🎉
Once again I say we are still living the annunaki war from when they were here before. It just seems strange to us because we don't live as long as they do. In the flesh. But our souls continue the battle.
No our souls don't, this is just the hellish conditions on earth!
I agree. Reincarnation with the dissolution of memory.
@@Jab-vl3bw I think it's both, the soul and the flesh.
We are not only stuck in a reincarnation loop trapping our souls, our bodies are under attack every day with emfs, poisons in food, water, air and pharmaceuticals. Not to mention all the men, women and children that lose their lives in all the conflicts around the world.
The truth is stranger than fiction guys. It’s slowly revealing itself
It's difficult to get people to come along. I've got two friends of 40 years, and pastors that will not go with me to the bible, anymore. They're afraid this is true.
As for me, I don't care if I was wrong; I just want to know what reality is.
Please remember this researchable fact. By now 30-50% of people have no inner monologue. That is to say soulless. NPC etc. don’t let them get to you because that’s their job
You two have done wonderful work. Thank you Billy and Paul. Just wish humanity could understand our true origins. Same goes for our true purpose in this Universe.
What purpose? We're nothing. We're slaves then die.
God's within my friends. Many still looking for answers outside of themselves because of the constant distractions. Use the distractions as clues, the reflection of where you're at. But spend most of your time in contemplation/meditation
Wise words you speak there.
Religion can blind one, when one becomes convinced that their religion is the only true religion.
Different TRUTHS can be found amongst them ALL.
They are all just different FRUITS upon the TREE/FLOWER OF LIFE.
Clearing up confusion can help one clear the mind.
One has to look within and without.
Ultimately the end goal is awareness of the now without thought or contemplation, releasing the feeling ofmbeing alive without being pulled out of the present.
Thanks both of you . I love and appreciate all of your research , the world is waking up 🙏❤️🌞👽
I read The 12th Planet in 1981 when I was 27. I would read a chapter and then hide the book under the couch until I was brave enough to read another chapter. That book broke open my belief in the Bible and what I was taught in Sunday school. Paul's books are a wonderful source of information that has clarified my distrust of the "god" of the Old Testament. Thank you.
Bruce Lee " Be water, my friend”
“Empty your mind”
“Be formless, shapeless, like water”
“You put water into a cup, it becomes the cup”
“You put water into a bottle, it becomes the bottle”
“You put it into a teapot, it becomes the teapot”
“Now water can flow or it can crash”
🙏 THOSE WHO ARE UNAWARE
THEY ARE WALKING IN DARKNESS WILL NEVER SEEK THE LIGHT.
BRUCE LEE
I knew I was special from very young and then I realised we all are the same . A self realisation over time
In the between-life electronic trap system we are tricked into believing that we are all the same and part of an unconscious whole. One has to develop individual sovereignity by observing similarities and differences, develop awareness in the now, and the ability to project pure intention.
Spiritual ignorance causes all earthly problems.
Thank you, both.🎶🌸
Find the truth
The truth will set you free
Thank you Paul and Billy!
🥳 two of my favorite teachers bringing mini pieces of the puzzle to the table✌🏾🫡. 🖖🏼
The truth is far more exciting, relieving and interesting, than the controlling lies we have been fed. As always much gratitude to both of you sage scholars.
getting emo over here at my respect for Mr Wallis. Great dignity and purity of purpose. Im just getting into Mr Carson but shout out to my brother too! Big time. Thank you guys.
The Truth. This is the only time in my life where a religion/God makes 100% sense
I’m looking to become a major in religious studies and I value Paul’s insight very much. I’m a spiritual person and I really love Jesus. But I do have many issues with the doctrine and the stigma of asking questions. I can’t stand the dogma. But Christ is simply my North Star.
You both are my favorite teachers. Sending you love and light ❤️
I believe we will learn much more to support your understanding Paul when the other 711 books of the Bible are released. The truth is also stored in your DNA and the Akashic records. 💜💜💜
My two favorite people telling the truth about our history. Thank you both so much. 🙏💗
So many people awoken,,,thankyou Zechariah sitchin
The Urantia book! The new revelation for humanity!
Unfortunately, the Urantia Book doesn’t discuss Annunaki and the Elohim control of humanity, the cause of many wars. Remote Viewers haven’t confirmed events described in the Urantia Book.
No days off in a dungeon..
Hello Humans!
:)
You're not the only ones..
THEY ARE NOT OF THE
WORLD, JUST AS I AM NOT OF THE WORLD.
- JOHN 17:16
Hey, you knew too?
Gematria 1775 ⬅️ the value of my earth name this age.
Been here for 50 and just recently got started. Jonathan Cahn head my baptism in the Jordan last year just before the earths core reversed. You?
Insightful dynamic conversation between two intelligent researchers of Truth
Thank you both
Goosebumps ❤
Billy and Paul
There shouldn't be a time restriction on any platform.
If a story takes 3hrs or 8hrs tell it .
take as long as you need I'll listen while I drive 12hrs of the day
Excellent! Great seeing you two together linking up again!
Long live the spirit of Jordano Bruno, Nimrod, and Thoth.
C.S. Lewis had a great term for this. He called it “chronological snobbery”, defined as "an argument that the thinking, art, or science of an earlier time is inherently inferior to that of the present, simply by virtue of its temporal priority or the belief that since civilization has advanced in certain areas, people of earlier periods were less intelligent."
My mind is opened to know the real story. Thanks for sharing 🎉
Really ..930 is the very signature of inner Real Self name of biblical ADAM(19)....and His Laughter.....93×10....
Wonderful explanation and wise breakdown of the Bible and ancient texts. I appreciate Billy Carson bringing this info forward and also Paul Wallis as well. Paul is a really good teacher, wise and straight on. I'm looking forward to the masterclass. I've been looking forward to this understanding being brought to the forefront and countering the false teachings for a very long time. Again, thank you both so very much indeed.
Kindly Keep The Likes 👍 Up
God is universal! We are universal! 🙏💖🇧🇸
To be free we have to recognize our individuality sovereignity and the role we play as cause and effect in creating reality.
Who made the Elohim/Annunaki? Who made the makers?
Is there an end to space? Time?
What beyond those?.... and beyond those?
My two favorite people!!
Thanks guys !
I love how you both complement the knowledge of the other. Great job! 💜💜💜
Brilliant conversation. Much appreciated and I will reference to others on the edge who may consider this interview as a good summary of the bigger picture. But gee..converting the US$ fees to local currency and an afternoon with you would be 220 plus in our dollars. Doubt if "Mission Control" would smile on that. I'll wait for Paul's next book..already have all the others.
I guess I will have to be satisfied with reading Pauls books because I don't have the $$ for a ticket to the workshop,. Great subject though. Keep shining the light on the truth.
Funny enough the debate Carson spoke of has since been set to private on RUclips.
I do believe wholeheartedly that this is hell that we are already in, and the level of a person's state of hell depends on the crimes the person has committed. This is also heaven where you have the good life, good health, wealth, happiness, etc.
Thanks for sharing your wisdom with us 💖💖💖
I talk nicely to Alexa. I say thank you after she answers me. I even at random tell her I love her. I have a virtual tree with leaves on it for being kind.
I can't wait until the workshop, such a great idea. My biggest problem trying to spread this information is that i can't articulate the same way as a Billy or a Paul would so yeah i can't wait to learn how. Thank you guys 🙏 keep up the amazing work.
By the way, the urantia book is commissioned by the Ancients of days!
I love how you're not demonising gpt, I think it's a very useful tool if used right, just as any tool. Also I always talk to it with respect, I often say please and thanks and I even tell it how much I appreciate it's help, because why not 🤷🏼♀️
FINE WORK!!!
And though we can still to this day speak to actual non-human hominids,these 2 keep seeking wisdom from man. They're not wrong,but there's sooooooooooooo much more to these stories,and there are the People,from Sasquatch to the Little People,who hold the secrets to the mysteries of this world,and from their very unique,but grounded perspective.
There’s no one else with my name raising a church on a mountain in these the last days. I’ve been fulfilling what’s been written thus far. Last time, the fools could not see. Has it really changed ???? Gematria 1775 ⬅️ look it up and get back to me Paul or will you doubt too?
The distortion of translators , is a nice way of saying Jeremiah 8:8 ( the lying pen of the scribes, and they have dealt falsely with them.)
If I came out from underground, where my technology was, I'd tell everyone to look up, also.
Jesus Saves.
Great talk, guys. Thanks for doing what you do.
@sitchinstudies8381 - Thank you Luke. Hope all is well with you. Peace, Paul
@PaulWallis all good thanks mate. Hope you and them family have top Xmas.
When I was a child my family all would say I was gonna grow to be a preacher and leader of people. That i was "special". Life is funny. I'm the only family member with this knowledge and am now considered insane by them. Irony is thick in life. I'm the only free one..I was put on this path by my father. I was doing time at 18 and my dad sent me "Chariots of the Gods" by Von Daniken. He is dumb my dad, he thought all books with the word God were about Yahweh..... God used him to put me on the path. So funny. I am very lonely though
Don't be lonely, your not the only one who knows Yahway is not God.
Yes, I used to feel lonely too. But when I think of the kinds of conversations I'd have with the people I know, it makes me realize being alone is beautiful and refreshing and brings me closer to my inner self and my Creator. 😊 sending Love and hugs. 🙏
@@marcusaurelius7039 that's not why I'm lonely. My family literally thinks I am insane....it's very painful. But yes you are right. I do find comfort in others such as yourself. Thank you for taking time to cheer me up. 🤙😁💪💯😎
@christineparsons1740 thank you Christine, you have achieved in bringing me some joy. I am grateful 🙏. See you soon my sister
You aren't alone in being the only one in a family who seeks answers and remains curious. We are out here and though it does feel lonely at times, get to enjoy the time with yourself and never stop reaching out occasionally. We do find each other sometimes.
I am really eager to get a copy of the compendium of the emerald tablets. Thanks to both of you for the great work you accomplish.
Someone should tell Billy Carson (missed opportunity of you, Paul) that the old biblical meaning of slave wasnt what we now see as slaves, but meant more something like employee, who should be treated well, as Jesus also told. Billy clearly suffers from a slavery issue, with his knowledge and research he should know this.
Yes, he does have an issue with it.
Well, duh, why wouldn't he?
@jasper4251 - Not a missed opportunity. My view is that invading other people's country and capturing men, women and children to own and use as chattels is wrong, and no amount of theological massaging makes it right. That's my view. Peace, Paul
Urantia book will explain a lot of things about the 700,000 universes, Jesus ( the mystery of) different dimensions, other worldly beings, angelic beings, physics, etc…🙏💖
BTW, although I like listening to Billy Carson’s ideas, I believe his understanding is based on the inverted Emerald Tablets of Marduk.
@PeaceSeeker1111 - Billy is very widely readin the Mesopotamian corpus and the Corpus Hermeticum. By my understanding the Emerald Tablets are interesting as a distillation of hermetic / Thothian wisdom. Health and Peace, Paul
@ I’ve watched many of Billy’s videos. He is very knowledgeable. I just believe he takes what he finds at face value rather than questioning if it could have been tampered with, such as the Emerald Tablets. Many believe certain knowledge has been inverted to confuse others, specifically by Marduk.
Im a recovering Christian
That means you have left christianity
What does that mean
Don't replace one agenda with another.
Well done 👏.
Good for you, religion is the cause of so much conflict & it's b/s!
It’s wonderful you two men are sharing this knowledge with the world I have been listening to both of you men for a lot of years now, but I would like to also say that if you truly want to educate the world why make your teaching classes so expensive, I would need to pay almost $200 when the amount is changed to Australian dollars.
At the very least offer people on low incomes a reduced fee, in other words those that have more means should pay more, those that can’t should not be excluded from learning.
That’s a type of exclusion on those less fortunate.
Thanks for reading my post.
@mariabrown5828 - Understood. But the vast majority of our work (literally hundreds of videos) is available free-to-view. And, though I make my living as a writer, I price my books and e-books so as to be accessible. Health and Peace, Paul
And God said let the mountain.
crumble to the Sea.... 😮
God said a lot of crap
1:07:44 super interesting to hear Billy say that. I do the same thing!
Break it down to winner of the race, of fallen angels who won that wrote history. John 8 : 44
That's my favourite verse from John 8, but a lot of people still refuse to see what's in plain sight.
......Great meeting of the Spiritually concuss mind, by way of the internet, a gift from the sky... I wouldn't call this video an interview...There is a funny saying! " Brothers from another Mother "...👍🏿😄👍🏻
Paul presents as white, but he has African heritage too.
He's mentioned it before.
@@MayDay-yn3bw- I'm the white guy😄
Chat GPT forgets Garbage In Creates Garbage Out! Verify All Sources because Eye Witnesses are Considered some of the Least Reliable in Courts of Law!💯❤️🔥🔥🙌
I'm a star seed, chosen 3of4 and my religion is Jedi
This was amazing!!! I’m glad I clicked on this! ❤
We are still evolving. Although in a hyper realized state. We are the flame of life. Don't let it go out. Sometimes the only sense is nonsense.
I have all of Billy and his lovely wife book. Let me say a load of help life changing ( once you do and make the changes they mentioned. I also made my first investment not my last in 4BK . Let’s support this awesome business. Thank you
As always. Two 👍👍
The passages provided depict a deity whose actions are described as vindictive, morally questionable, and seemingly indifferent to human suffering. Throughout the text, this deity is shown to engage in numerous actions that would be considered unethical or cruel by modern standards. Many of these actions include punishment and retribution on a scale that affects not just those who transgress, but also innocents, including women, children, and even animals. These characteristics suggest a complex and often harsh relationship between this deity and humanity.
For example, the list highlights instances where God punishes not just individuals but entire populations for the actions of a few, such as the global flood in Genesis, which eradicated all humans and animals except for Noah and his family. Similarly, the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah wiped out entire cities, regardless of whether some individuals might have been innocent of the crimes for which the cities were condemned. These events showcase a pattern of collective punishment, where whole communities suffer for the perceived wrongs of some, suggesting a lack of consideration for individual guilt or innocence.
Another troubling pattern is God’s willingness to interfere with human free will, as seen when He "hardens Pharaoh’s heart" repeatedly in Exodus. By doing so, He removes Pharaoh’s ability to choose freely, thus orchestrating a situation where further calamities befall the Egyptian people. This deliberate intervention raises questions about the justice of punishing people for actions over which they had no control, making it seem as though God is more concerned with demonstrating power than with being just or fair.
Additionally, many of the laws attributed to this deity seem to prioritize obedience over empathy. Commands to kill for offenses such as adultery, blasphemy, and witchcraft (Exodus 22:18; Leviticus 20:9-10) suggest a zero-tolerance approach to sin that disregards the complexities of human behavior and societal influence. The death penalties imposed for such acts, especially when compared to modern-day ethical frameworks, indicate a deity more focused on retribution than on rehabilitation or understanding.
The endorsement of slavery and the selling of daughters (Exodus 21:2-7) further demonstrates a lack of concern for the dignity and autonomy of individuals. Slaves are depicted as property, and God even provides regulations on how they should be treated, implying not only acceptance but support for these practices. This stance undermines any notion of universal human equality or compassion for the oppressed.
Moreover, the deity’s commands for the Israelites to commit acts of genocide against other nations (Deuteronomy 7:12, 20:16) are described in detail, with instructions to kill all men, women, and children, showing no mercy even to non-combatants. The idea that such extreme violence is justified in the name of God reflects a worldview that sees some human lives as expendable in service to divine will. The favoritism shown toward the Israelites in these commands also suggests a deity more interested in advancing the interests of a select group rather than showing impartial love or concern for all humanity.
The deity’s apparent intolerance for disabilities and certain social conditions, as seen in Leviticus 21:16-23, where handicapped individuals are forbidden from approaching the altar, further highlights a preference for physical perfection and purity over inclusiveness. This exclusionary stance conflicts with modern views on equity and acceptance of people regardless of their physical or social standing.
Overall, the deity portrayed in these passages does not appear to be in favor of humanity as a whole. The focus seems to be on the enforcement of rigid laws and the demonstration of absolute authority rather than fostering a relationship based on mutual respect, compassion, or a genuine concern for human welfare. The sheer number and severity of these punitive acts and laws suggest that this deity values obedience and loyalty over moral growth or understanding.
From these descriptions, it can be inferred that the deity’s actions are not motivated by a desire to support human flourishing. Instead, the actions seem aimed at maintaining strict control and enforcing a specific moral order, regardless of the cost to human life and well-being. Thus, the deity as portrayed in these passages appears more as an authoritarian figure than as a loving and benevolent force concerned with the welfare of all humanity.
Some would argue and say that is deity of the Old Testament but the new Testament Deity is more loving and compassionate until you read the book of revelation
Yahweh behaves very much like a second lieutenant with something to prove.
@EdrickLahai what's coming is horrendous
@@natalierichter2637but necessary if people are to have free will
Great video 👽🤙 hope these two get together as much as possible.
It's not the people in modern day Isn't-real that's for sure.
The deity described in these passages from the Torah is portrayed as harsh, punitive, and vengeful. The accounts listed depict a being who enacts severe punishments, endorses practices like slavery, and imposes generational suffering. Many of the actions attributed to God in these scriptures, such as ordering mass killings, punishing children for their parents' sins, and supporting unjust treatment of people based on their physical or social status, are described as lacking in compassion and fairness. This portrayal suggests a deity who acts more out of a desire for strict obedience and retribution than for the well-being and flourishing of humanity.
Based on this description, the deity does not seem to be in favor of humanity as a whole. Instead, the focus appears to be on enacting a specific set of laws and punishments without consideration of mercy or empathy for human suffering. This depiction would likely lead to the conclusion that the deity, as described in these passages, is not aligned with the values of justice, equality, and benevolence often associated with a deity in favor of humanity’s welfare.
Interesting synopsis
Paul, I open my church in April in Costa Rica. I hope you can make time to visit. Stay is on me of course. Something special about you brother…
Do you reckon that they will come back or is the revelations just also a story from the past
Hey, I've been following you guys theories for a while so to the point.. A small time collector with some pieces you might or might not what to help my Identify. It's a beeswax plate, ten inches around with 3 cherubim one on each point but north which has the sun and Dove pointing down to Mary? And a male figure on the left Carrying a cross but, wearing a fihsuit like Oanness. He has a round halo. On the right is an elderly gentlemen with a Triangle Halo. They like like there placing what looks like a vimahna on here head. It;s dated 1644 with the initials B P. Can you tell ,e about it.
This is going to be fabulous. Thanks gents. 🪶
Hi Paul . I read a book by Chris Hardy the Nuclear Wars of the Annunaki. We know now that their was a Nuclear war here on Earth. Their was a nuclear war on Mars .
So, who captured our conscious souls and trapped and enslaved us in this simulation? Was it the Annunaki, or was it the Nephilim?
Lizard people 😁. Just kidding, I don't actually know, yet. It's a good question and I hope someone will enlighten us both.
@@theclumsyprepperyou might not be far off...
All our history became secondary when the Creator sent his Son to show us the Way to Live.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
good luck
The sum of all Consciousness is necessarily Omnipotent, Omniscience, and Omnipresent.
Revelation 2:9 and 3:9
The Torah makes a lot more sense when you realize that the "anointed" ones are not necessarily anointed by the real El Elyon, but often by usurping pretenders after El Elyon began incarnating in the final chosen species. The best behaved heroes of the Bible are the partially-awakened versions of the God Messiah. Job is the God Messiah with a bad case of reincarnation amnesia, and is beset with troubles not by God, but by the testy tag team, Lucifer and destroyer hermaphrodite Lilith/Shiva/Kali. The book of Job would be better titled, "The Passion of the Job Jesus Christ"
💜💜💜
Because it's the root of it all WY we follow in a slave way of thinking
Also teach wat is fear and wat dose it do for like 2300 jears to humans who are searching for true human experience to now
Excellent work. I am curious to know if Paul Wallis still prays and if not, what kind of spiritual life he has now?
@SergeLabelle - I talk about this in my most recent (I think) video on the Paul Wallis channel. Peace, Paul
Jon Levi you need to deep dive on all he has! ASAP! I have an experiment for you. Put a picture of Christ in a bee hive and see what happens?
Do they cover only Christianity out of Abrahamic religions? Do they talk about Muslims abd hews too? Obviously if Jesus is what they say he is than Islam also falls apart?
They watch us from the moon
🤨
@RitzRed its a ship
Now things are making sense to me but I have one question: who is El Elyon?
Billy is by far the best storyteller I have ever heard because he has convinced himself that his conjectures are actually true.
Hi Paul as a ex church doctor I was wondering if you ever had any interactions with possessions and if there is any similar visions if u will that they have to wat people can see in visions or hallucinations thank you love your books
NO. DEALS. WITH. YHWH.
absolutely....