Total KIA REVEALED - But It is NOT That Simple - Ukraine Map Analysis & News Update
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- G'day Legends, I hope you're doing well,
Today we talk about the Russia's offensive and look at the war map updates.
If you're new here thanks for coming across, I served in the Australian Infantry from 2014-2021, With specialist qualifications in Heavy Weapons/Anti-Armour, Combat First Aid, With a tour to Afghanistan as a crew commander of a Armoured Mobility Vehicle.
Upon my Return I was unexpectedly diagnosed with a Incurable and Inoperable Brain tumour that is slowly killing me. I was also awarded the Queens Order of Australia Medal (OAM) hence the post nominals after my name. Then Being medically separated from the Army I flew to Ukraine in 2022 for 6.5months and now make content full time. I really appreciate you being here Thankyou
As an independent reporter you make this possible, To support the channel directly.
/ willybeatingcancer
www.paypal.me/...
MERCH
www.willyoam.com/
Telegram:
t.me/Willy_OAM...
Socials:
Instagram: / willy.beating.cancer
Rumble: rumble.com/c/c...
Telegram: t.me/Willy_OAM...
Business Email:
williams.mattphoto@gmail.com
Spotify Podcast:
open.spotify.c...
Highlights Channel:
/ @willyclips7517
Regarding the end piece from Deep state that brings light to MAJOR issues around Avdiivka.
Failures and systemic issues like this will be ignored by the bloggers who've found relevance and wealth from this conflict pushing the 'Everything is fine' narrative, even if that is counter productive to the boys at the front... Who apparently they support...
'Sunlight is often the best disinfectant'
Hey Willy, did you see the the Ukrainian s-300 crew, who painted half of the Rus airforce on the fuselage?, I mean, this guys have downed more planes than the Ghost of Kiev, why have we never hear of them XD... on a more serious note, I don't think lying for twitter clout, would be wise on the long run....
Why does no one talk about the POW numbers 🔥
again, why are you pushing the narrative that over 500k russsians got killed when this number represent kills and injured that were "recorded" ?
Your a dud m8
Willy I mean
I don’t think Willy seriously believes Ukrainians losses are anywhere near as low as 53000 , it’s funny how he predominantly uses pro Ukrainian sources and occasionally sprinkles in the odd independent or pro Russian info . Well presented nevertheless but disappointing it’s biased still
When someone speaks fast to try to cram in a lot of information, they're usually full of 💩while trying to hide something. It's no different than those commercials that try to sell you something, then at the end, there's that disclaimer that's sped up that nobody can understand. Smart people speak clear and concise so that their audience can digest the information.
If he would openly go out and admit that Ukrainian media is total BS, than his channel gonna be cancelled, RUclips won't recommend his channel for his own subscribers anymore
@@STARGUN8687 So bend over and kiss the ring is what you suggest? Plenty of channels who go against the grain get demonetized for not bending the knee. So they go cash app, paypal, etc.
I read that as Kia, the car company. I was so confused.
They through they sold nearly 600k in Ukraine and 70k in Russia.
When you openly admit that 80% of your casualties are from artillery and your opponent has 2 to 10 times the artillery as you.... well you can decide for yourself if Ukraine is coming out on top in terms of casualties.
Id assume a 5 year old would come up with such a simplistic assumption or false equivalence . Let's completely ignore the complexities of military strategy and the multitude of factors that affect outcomes in warfare, shall we?
Well I work out for myself that Ukraine are doing great. 👍
But muh human wave assaults
@@yeahnah7220 you sound like Trudeau: lots of words and no point made, no facts provided
@@yeahnah7220 Yes, F-16's are needed now to reverse all losses because artillery will mean nothing then
Math doesn't work - if Ukraine lost only 50K why such a shortage of troops that they want to conscript 500K? Not to mention that they are catching people at the streets as animals.... Also if Prigojin did not lie about his losses, why he would be lying about Ukraine's?
A response.
How would you know the numbers of any casualties.
Its pretty simple. Lets say you and a buddy get in a fight with another 2 guys. Your buddy gets knocked out and one of your opponents also gets knocked out. You see 8 more opponents coming down the street. If you call your friends and say "Hey I want 15 guys down here to help" it doesn't mean you lost 15 you just want overmatch or to equal the enemy. They counted 51k that doesn't mean that is all they lost but it doesn't mean its 1/10th either.
They lost more than 50k in two months during the counter offensive.
The answer.
You don't.
These are all fantasy figures.
Day after day talking out of your derriers.
50,000.
In 1 month.
How, pray, do you know this?
Please tell.
I'm all ears.
Willy... get a grip, we have all seen the Uke cemetery videos...
Ha-ha that is hilarious. And exactly how many graves with soldiers since 2014 did you see? Can you estimate how much space 750 funerals take in one cemetery. If all you see are the flags - then how many did you see? Eye estimations of pictures of cemeteries - cmon a little professionalism would be a nice thing. Exact numbers are impossible. When an AFV with 8 Russians inside and 7 on top gets hit by 3 fpv drones - how many dead, how many wounded, how many unharmed? In some places the Ukrainian drone-pilots hunt down every single soldier that tries to escape from a broken vehicle and sometimes they don't. On the Ukrainian side reported numbers from the frontline are estimations and from the Russian side - unknown and if they say something it is always lies. Even after real scholars have received access to the military records, their results will not produce exact numbers. Simplest conclusion with a few grains of realism in it - Russian soldiers have died like flies since the war begun because the military don't care much and on the Ukrainian side many times less soldiers have died because they think it is a tragedy when every single one dies. That is why they never sit and wait for Russias old tactical bombardments of an area. The retreat and then they counter... and so on. They don't mind to loose 100 meter of ground if they can kill 1000 Russians for it.
BBC counted graves, memorials and inheritance claims from both sides.
In March it was 48k Russian dead, 46 Ukrainian dead. Not including Wagner PMC (30k) and the conscripts from Donetsk and Luhansk or foreign fighters from Africa, Nepal, Cuba…..
@@user-ed6ch1zv1e 500k cope incoming
BBC counted graves, memorials and inheritance claims from both sides.
In March it was 98k Russian dead, 46 Ukrainian dead. Not including Wagner PMC (30k) and the conscripts from Donetsk and Luhansk or foreign fighters from Africa, Nepal, Cuba…..
@@user-ed6ch1zv1e factually wrong. Ukraine fights with meat, Russia fights with machines. We saw this from day 1, back when Ukraine had more troops in the conflict.
Well Ukrainian meat was met by Russian shells, missiles, drones and air strikes. Many Ukrainians died without ever seeing a Russian with their own eyes. The same story comes from all the western mercs that came and went. They talk of wanting to help, but the AFU was such a disorganised mess they ended up leaving again once they saw how hopeless the situation at the front was. 😊
Zelenskey :"We lost 31.000 soliders the whole war"🤡
The zelensky on the run...
For the rest of his Life......
And why are they missing troops? 🥸😵💫
That's only what they lost, not the number killed by Russians
3rd or 4th mobilisation so far? And olnly 31k 😂 fools who believe this
Zelensky wouldnt have come up with this lie on his own. His masters probably told him to say that in order to sell the war more 😂
The problem with the numbers you are citing whether its the Mediazone numbers on Russian casualties or the Ukraine loss stats, both the groups doing the counting are Pro-Ukrainian. Interestingly, only one army is suffering chronic manpower shortages.
Right but they have a population substantially smaller than Russia's, the man power shortages are also clearly political in Ukraine, while they clearly have a bearing on casualty figures, taken in isolation it's not a particularly helpful metric
Winter war against Finland.
3 months.
Between 64,000 to 127,000 Soviet dead depending on your source.
Apparently Stalin didn't know how many died following his orders.
A much less lethal environment than today.
On Colonel Daniel Davis' YT(Deep Dave) channel, who interviews ex. senior US military and ex. CIA analysts and many others with knowledge on the subject. Some of these in interviews are with Colonel Jacques Baud who worked on a NATO mission in Ukraine for a few years. Baud has also worked with several UN missions. In one of these YTs they go through how the conflict started and in another about Russian military strategy which showed that NATO is far behind in that particular area. To mention one detail briefly, it's not about conquering territory, it's about destroying as many enemies as possible with the least possible losses. It explains that the kill ratio is 1 to 5 in Russian favor still, about the same as the leaked Pentagon documents in 2023.
Think that if NATO did not oppose the Minsk agreement or the peace draft in Istanbul in 2022, there would have been peace in Ukraine and over 600,000 Ukrainian soldiers would have been alive today.
This may partly explain why Ukraine has a shortage of military personnel today.
Why dont they count the Current CEMETRIES in Ukraine ,10s of thousands, all with flags, Photos of them in uniform!
Considering the amount of time I have spent in Ukraine and yes there are new military cemeteries but no where near the scale you are describing
@@TimD-ny6ksconsidering the amount of time I've spent in ukraine, yes their are a ton of new graveyards popping up all over. So stop the lies.
BBC counted graves, memorials and inheritance claims from both sides.
In March it was 98k Russian dead, 46 Ukrainian dead. Not including Wagner PMC (30k) and the conscripts from Donetsk and Luhansk or foreign fighters from Africa, Nepal, Cuba…..
@@TimD-ny6ksbullshit you're lying. There's new cemeteries popping outside of big cities like Kiev and lyviv because the graveyards in the city are filled.
@@TimD-ny6ks you’re nose is growing Pinocchio
lol Ukraines army should be around two million people by now using those numbers. Who are the idiots who even consider this as possible?
So on the bloodiest day Wagner lost 213 men. German intelligence at the time reported Ukrainian losses at almost 1,000 men per day and were horrified at the losses.
Since when were they collecting the data? Srs question
Blödsinn.
@@strafniki1080 every intelligence agency on the planet that can collect data on this war has been doing so since day 1.
@@strafniki1080 German and other Military intelligence from NATO has a lot of people “in situ” as they say.
Why people want to cope over confirmed figures is beyond me, very Hitler in the bunker feeling.
The Russians lose a lot of people too but they enjoy a complete overall equipment supremacy so ofc they’ll lose less than Ukrainian untrained recruits without heavy equipment.
This is a very sad state of affairs for all involved but you solve nothing for your side by lying and refusing to see the problem.
How can you improve or even solve problems if you act like a Western politician and refuse to recognize reality?
lost means incapable of fighting. Some are MIA, KIA, depending on wounds and times until aid is provided, surgeries etc. Prigo was running his presidential campaign via his videos btw. Narcissist.
I can't believe you are still quoting Ukraine numbers on losses. You must be gullible.
But you would quote Russian figures or pro Kremlin numbers?
You would.
And by the way, the UK MOD is one of the most reliable sources of total bullshit 😂
yes they're consistent... consistently full of shit.
And yet Willy consistently uses their MOD reports
At least they're not as bad as the Russian mod, even if they are bad. But i guess that's hard to do
Ush ush Willy 🤫🤫🤫 Ukraine lost just 31 soldiers No more 🤫🤫🤫 This is why Ukraine need 2 millions new soldiers 🤭
use some more smileys, it will make the number (2 million) that you just pulled out from your behind more believable
@@Dungeontai just like the figures pulled out from Kiev's bum bums 🤫🤫🤫🤭🤭🤭
Russians butthurt dw about them@@Dungeontai
@@Dungeontai he is being really exaggerate about 2 million but Zelensky had said that he is putting togather 1 million soldier army to fight Russia Federation. This is not BS. Why do you think suddenly the force recruit age get drop and all male is now ban from leaving Ukraine? Have more faith in other people word man, this is war and everyone bleed.
BBC counted graves, memorials and inheritance claims from both sides.
In March it was 98k Russian dead, 46 Ukrainian dead. Not including Wagner PMC (30k) and the conscripts from Donetsk and Luhansk or foreign fighters from Africa, Nepal, Cuba…..
If Ukraine is outmatched at least 10 to 1 in Artillerie pieces, shouldn't their losses be 10 times higher?
That's nothing more than simplistic assumption or a false equivalence. It overlooks the complexities of military strategy and the multitude of factors that affect outcomes in warfare.
I wonder, Ukraine claims 500k+ russian soldiers have died. What if they post their own deaths and say they are Russian deaths?
They are
Studies on past wars have given 70% of the losses are from artillery. Numerous interviews from this conflict also suggest this same. Such as the interviews of a British TA man. He was very entertaining to listen to. Look it up if you haven’t heard his stories.
It is very difficult not to come to the conclusion that the side with less firepower incurs more losses.
ordinarily one would use a degree of logical inference to ball park casualty figures. But west Ukrainians despite being ultra-nationalists are being supported by western media, so DIVIDE by 10 and subtract at least half as its expected that most casualties are not in fact losses and are merely misplaced, probably just nipped out for a smoke.
Back in Jan a Former Minister of defense of Poland came back from Ukraine and said the number of Ukrainians gone was over a million. you can google the article
Definitely a scare factor. Neither side has surpassed 100k dead, it’s merely propaganda on both sides. Casualty totals (so including Injured) probably reach 200-300k
That number sounds closer to the truth.
Wtf?
@@ZOV24-2-22 These numbers are from 2022, what happened since bakhmut is that Russia achieved a much greater arty/bomb supremacy while 70-90% of casualties are from fragmentation. I think casualty rate is 10-30% greater on the side of Ukraine and it didnt slow down, so the numbers are just over 300k dead for UA while russians are at 250k or so.
Evidence of conscription rates in Ukraine would support these claims. Ukraine is desperate to get more boys and old men to replace the fallen.
Ah ..losses- anyone with any sign of common sense could have a rough idea regarding how much lost from each side. One side is using hundreds of gliding guided bombs daily, dozens of lancet strikes, LMUR missiles- daily, MLRS flame throwers- all time, close support aviation and strike helicopters, artillery and mine launchers of all sizes. Just guiding bombs would give about 500 killed per day, flame throwers and other artillery- another 300, Aviation - may be 20- 30 per day, close combats- lets say 30- so roughly about 1000 per day- minimum!!! - 300 000 per year!!- and it's 3- rd year!!!- and that is a lower estimation.
BBC counted graves, memorials and inheritance claims from both sides.
In March it was 98k Russian dead, 46 Ukrainian dead. Not including Wagner PMC (30k) and the conscripts from Donetsk and Luhansk or foreign fighters from Africa, Nepal, Cuba…..
Slow down - glide bombs (at least 500kg) only become widespread about since october 2023 and mainly used against strongpoints. LMUR is scarcely used untill now - more like field testing. And heavy equipment used to bombard wast areas can hit only as many people as there were - if there 30 people in trench network, you will not get 150 bodies even using TOS.
Some days may bring few thousands and some less then few hundreds, you cant just multiply calendar and numbers you invented.
Most likely 600-900k
These are just nonsense numbers that you invented right now.
You can't really get an accurate number by saying how many a system could kill. But a lot of people are getting killed and it is not being reported. The numbers are hidden.
I hope there is an independent international media like media zona to count the number of graves in Ukraine. Just like the media zona did.
They’ll probably arrest them if they tried. Like the videos of the Patriot missiles failing. Those they filmed it were arrested
BBC counted graves, memorials and inheritance claims from both sides.
In March it was 48k Russian dead, 46 Ukrainian dead. Not including Wagner PMC (30k) and the conscripts from Donetsk and Luhansk or foreign fighters from Africa, Nepal, Cuba…..
Search satellite imagery and start counting.
BBC counted graves, memorials and inheritance claims from both sides.
In March it was 98k Russian dead, 46 Ukrainian dead. Not including Wagner PMC (30k) and the conscripts from Donetsk and Luhansk or foreign fighters from Africa, Nepal, Cuba…..
There is one..
The true losses for both sides won’t be known for years . Both sides will have their own agendas as to what will be disclosed .
It’ll never be known.
There is a quite accurate mediazona to keep up the casulty count on Russia side, and you must also account for the MIA. There is no equivalent for Ukrainain side.
FINALLY someone with a logical mind not repeating the pro-Russian narrative of "Ukrainian losses: 500k and Russian losses 30k".
What we all know for sure is that way too much Ukrainian and Russian blood has been spilled during these years...
The true losses are very apparent on the Ukrainian side.
They are mining their Western borders to prevent males from escaping, constantly lowering and increasing age of conscription, beating and dragging young men to military service, removing all requirements for foreign volunteers (before you needed military/police experience, now just need to pass fitness test and have no mental illness.), asking Western nations to deport Ukrainian males back to Ukraine.
They had close to 400k troops pre-2022 due to the civil war. They apparently conscripted 1.4 million more troops after 2022. Z was boasting about his million man army.
Where are all these troops? Where is the million man army?
According to the Western media, Ukraine only lost 30,000 troops. I need to know where the other 1.37 million of them are hiding.
BBC counted graves, memorials and public inheritance claims from both sides. It’s a low ball estimate. In March it was 98k Russian dead, 46 Ukrainian dead. Not including Wagner PMC (30k) and the conscripts from Donetsk and Luhansk or foreign fighters from Africa, Nepal, Cuba…..
16:57 Dima said that location with the photo of the Russian flag is the townhall.
I go to church with a guy who recently moved to the states with his family (his wife and son literally just got here). He told me that taking videos and pictures of cemeteries in Ukraine is illegal and then he showed me a video of one that he secretly took. It just went on and on and on. He thinks over a generation are dead.
Zelensky reminds me The Black Knight from Monty Python and the Holy Grail priceless scene.
"Your arm's off!"
"No it isn't!"
“Look you stupid bastard you’ve got no arms left!”
"It's a flesh wound. I've had worse.
"Well what's that then?"
"I’m invincible!”
“You’re a looney.”
“Alright, we’ll call it a draw!
He reminds me of the rabbit 🐇 beast
"According to our calculations, the Ukrainian army loses about 50,000 people a month. But these are sanitary and irretrievable losses. Both. Although they are irrevocable and sanitary, about 50x50," Putin said at a meeting with the editors-in-chief of foreign news agencies at the St. Petersburg Economic Forum.
According to him, the ratio of irretrievable losses of the Russian Federation and Ukraine is about one in five.
"If that's all you're interested in, I can say that, as a rule, no one ever talks about it at all. And if they do, then, as a rule, they distort the real figures," Putin said at a meeting with the editors-in-chief of foreign news agencies, answering a relevant question.
"I can tell you with complete confidence that our losses, especially if it concerns, unfortunately, irreparable losses, they are certainly several times less than on the Ukrainian side," Putin said.
So near half a mil Ukrainian troops dead
50,000 Russians seems realistic as 500,000 Ukrainians seems realistic. Hence Ukraine running out of men ongoing conscription. Russia no need to conscript as plenty of volunteers. Prisoner losses high but survivors gain freedom.
never taking into consideration it takes 3 to 1 in an offensive compared to defense.....
Yep logic says you are correct, particularly with Russia's 10 to 1 Arty advantage, FABs, TOS-1 etc, many of the Ukrainian bodies would be vaporized ie nothing to bury, also accounts of vast numbers off losses being hidden so the Uki Govt didnt have to payout the families 🤷🏼♂
@@SinkingShips1998 I swear to God you idiots throwing 3 to 1 ratio everywhere
if a superpower invades a bunch of tribesmen in Africa, do you think 100 guys with spears are gonna inflict 300 loses on a US Infantry company for example?
See how this ratio would differ depending on the situation? Germans had a 5 to 1 K/D ratio throughout most of the war and most of the war they were the attacker killing almost 30 million soviets.
It all depends on the difference in power. You can judge for yourself which side has a power superiority
@@SinkingShips1998 Not 3:1 losses, it's 3 to 1 force. As in, a company attacking a platoon of a peer or near peer, a battalion attacking a company, etc. Historically losses then come out to roughly 1:1, quite frequently less (in attacker's favor), sometimes more (in defender's favor). You could also achieve it with firepower, meaning you could have 3 times fewer men, but if you have 10 times the firepower attack would still be doable.
3-1 is literally the war like ukraine russian war - traditional war.
whereas Afghanistan could be 1-10 yet 1 is enough to scare americans away from Afghanistan.
If Ukraine has only lost 50k soldiers why do they need to press gang 30k a month off the streets?
Lets not forget that most of those missing in action are also dead but their families didn't see a cent of compensation
But the Ukrainian commanders still get pay from MIA by not reporting them missing.
This is all so unnecessary and it was totally avoidable... we are being lied to daily, but what is new?
Exactly, its time Humanity woke up.
if Russians lost 54K than the ukrainians lost at least 300k. Why do i say that? Simple. Both side acknowledged that the 80% of the casualties are from artillery. The Russians are firing between 1-5 to recently 1-15 ratio more artillery shels and we dont even talk about the 500-3000kg 20-100 fabs a day.
Haven't seen them use fab 3000.. I've seen them use 1500 many times but never 3000
you wish, dont you?
From previous wars, we know that for every 1 that is killed, 3 is injured. So is 900k injured.
Simple as simple thinks
The difference is, ruzzians don't hit a lot. Thanks to Wodka 🤣🤣🤣
The use of prisoners was actually very smart:
Zelensky sacrificed tens of thousands of experienced soldiers in Bakhmut to kill inexperienced soldiers/prisoners, while Prigozhin used experienced soldiers for counteroffensives and night attacks.
That's a big part of it but in al wars prisoners fight the hardest because they have things to prove.
Dumb to think war would change a criminal for the better. Don’t let these guys free.
@@mw9297 In your simple example, you're right. But if around 90% of these prisoners die in the war, your calculation doesn't hold up.
The prisoners were almost always put on the front line.
It is a common practice for the Ukrainian commanders to claim most of their KiA as MiA. Salaries keep going, no reimbursement for the family - life is beautiful... A month or so ago I have read somewhere info about the fresh graves in Ukraine. Someone made an effort to count the graves and and the number was 420K+
It is not like people cease to live only due to military reasons. Life become more grim for all ukraineans so it is expected to have more graves. On the other hand - not everyone retrieved from battlefield, I am sure that tens of thousands are somwhere there in collapsed trenches and forest patches.
It's a good thing noone is investigating Russia here.
Could you imagine the hysteria that would cause.
@@bumble-g2j yea like how they investigated that $40m meant for shells was stolen when there was a shell shortage
@@bumble-g2j Well, it is not going to happen.
First, the Russians have quite high tolerance for war casualties. Contrary to the Western ones, their society is not spineless and castrated.
Second, the Russians accept that this is a war for the very survival of their country as independent one.
So, even if the fantasies of the Ukrainians were true, the effect in Russia would not be as one in a Western country.
Easily. Now think how many bodies are still laying out in the fields, turned among the mud and bramble
From 3/18/24: ‘Senator Lindsey Graham has been criticized for his call to Ukrainian lawmakers to quickly pass legislation that will draft more citizens to fight against Russia.’
From 6/9/24: ‘Lindsey Graham Urges Support For Ukraine Over Untapped Trillion Dollars Resources’
It’s all about making money for corporations. They couldn’t care less about people’s lives.
Who cares what a maga politician wants.
You don't say?
Сemeteries beyond the horizon dotted with yellow and blue flags are an indicator that cannot be hidden
Never again, lest we forget, and wait a generation, like the last 15000 years
I don't always agree with you about ukraine, especially since they couped their government with nato weapons and coordination in 14. However, I do appreciate your willingness to consider all sides in this conflict.
What coup.
Yanukovych broke his mandate and revealed himself as an agent for Putin.
The people of Ukraine sacked him.
He ran home to Vladimir Vladimirovich.
The government was not overthrown.
Only Yanukovych left. A new leader with the existing government was elected.
Democratically.
If anything Yanukovych tried to hand Ukraine over to the Russians.
Now THAT'S a coup.
So what happened next.
Politics didn't work so the Russian army was put to work.
Two things is sure. First Russia with all of those loses that the west claims couldn't have done all of those offensive and defensive action what they did in the past 6 month. The second if Ukraine had a 800k army what Ukraine and the west claimed without major major losses the've should stopped every Russian breaktrough in the past months. Yet they need to play monopli with their military strenght. In the end the party who runs out of meat and equipment gonna loose. And Russia so far feels pretty confident right now. Ukraine struggles with force mobilisation while Russia avg people volunteers for the army. Deep inside everyone kwnos who is loosing very fast but it's a hard pill to swallow.
Winter war against Finland.
3 months.
Between 64,000 to 127,000 Soviet dead depending on your source.
Apparently Stalin didn't know how many died following his orders.
A much less lethal environment than today.
Is Zelensky still pretending to be in charge?
As much as Bunker Grandfather is trying to prove to the world he is not using VIAGRA my little gopnik
👍
10:1 artillery advantage but 10:1 more Kia? Unless you believe that all Russian shells are duds those figures don’t make any sense
2x in Russia’s favor at minimum given that it has anywhere from 3-12x the firepower
On April 15, 2022, Kyiv and Moscow had a peace treaty. B. Johnson arrived and told Zelensky "go fight." It would be very interesting to know what else B. Johnson said in case Zelensky refused.
in 1991 Ukraine and Russia had a security agreement and a treaty. Russia still invaded Ukraine in 2014 not giving a single fk about such treaty. You reap what you sow and Russia is suffering the economic and militar consequences of bullying their way to influence other countries.
@@JAAPJXBIT The Budapest Memorandum of 1994 was a guarantee of Ukraine's security from the West and the Russian Federation. The essence of this document was that Ukraine would adhere to a policy of military and economic neutrality. The word "neutrality" was not in the document, but the essence of the Budapest Memorandum was to adhere to a policy of neutrality. In 2008, Kyiv applied to join NATO. This was reflected in internal public relations.
@@JAAPJXBITagreements mean squat when national security is threatened.
Consult Victoria “fat lady” Nuland for her contribution to hostilities
Lies, damn lies, and statistics.
Seen interviews with ordinary people on the streets in Ukraine, when asked the question about losses 7 of 10 were pretty sure Ukrainian MOD numbers were bullshit, and that they have had a lot more casualties. the rest pretty much didn't want to answer the question(afraid of punishment?). So if the people in Ukraine doesn't believe their own governments numbers, i wouldn't either.
I know at this point, losses will be well over 100,000 for each side, 400,000 defiantly possible. Now, we fall on the same reality again and again. Ukraine cannot replace their losses as well as Russia can. Even if you except the losses stated by Ukraine, it still isn't stopping Russia from advancing. Ukraine can state whatever they want, but it doesn't matter if Russia keeps advancing. You don't wage war like this, and not expect heavy loses. I'm referring to deaths, not people taken out of combat entirely due to severe injuries.
If you genuinely think Ukraine only has 50k KIA you genuinely need a brain checkup. Why the hell would they be forcing dudes on the front if only 50k died????
Wagner lost 10k men throughout their whole battle starting from Popasna, going through Soledar and ending with Bakhmut. For that same period natonazis lost over 80k in those battles.
You mean Putlers Fascist orcs.🤣🤣🤣 Had to correct you there.
Wagner lost 21 000 in bakhmut alone...you're dumb
@@TheCheshireTree typical comment from a mad nafonazi bot with brainrot
In late may '23, Prigozhin also confirmed that Wagner has lost over 20,000 KIA .
@@yeahnah7220 source: sky news & the sun 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Basically, Mediazona is a guess, but it's evidence-based and likely to be reasonably accurate. Ukraine gives no evidence for its claims. For Ukraine losses, you just have to look at the fact that the vast majority of losses are from artillery and missiles. That means the loss ratio will mirror the artilley ratio. To conclude anything else is to ignore facts. That means that Ukraine losses must be at least 5 times those of the Russians. Simple logic.
The defending force losses thing is a myth , what about Vietnam
You’d think after Nam people would learn firepower and tactics take precedence. UA has the disadvantage in both. 2x in Russia’s favor minimum given that it has anywhere from 3-12x the firepower and better generals
Could be dramaticly HIGHER as I understood. Not lower (BBC Media Zone)
According to John Kirby on Fox News Russian forces lost 350.000 troops so this 54.000 is a bit of a contrast. Those Ukraine loses of 54.000 doesn’t make sense if they have serious manpower problems,,?
Probably more accurate when you flip the numbers. This war like covid lock downs has highlighted the divide between people who believe the media and the people who dont
Prigozhin wasn’t lying. How shocking.
Zelensky on the other hand.
It's incredible how many politically fueled comments there are on Willy's channel. Willy is the only journalist who seems to try to report facts, why do people commenting have to pollute the comments section with their pro-Russian/pro-Ukrainian BS
Pro-Willy BS
There are some others too if you look harder. But there will always be a small bias towards one or the other because it's just human nature. 100% neutrality is fantasy. Still, this is one of the good channels out there for reports on the Ukraine-Russia war.
Willy has a bias. You must consume a huge % of the propoganda the US puts out to think Willy has no bias. You sound vaxxed and boosted.
Dude he is not reporting *facts*, no body has that kind of knoweledge. The reason people react to his info the way they do is because he is one of the few people in the independent media that is still keeping a straight face when discussing anything from the Ukrainian side, which is admirable in its own right i guess..
Patrick report many video footage on Russia and repeatedly telling everyone to watch all news source and not be sheep.
Are you ever gonna tell about the Ukrainian loses? Never
I always wondered why they have not made rec tanks both the west and the south east
If properly done it would be like playing war thunder and since it’s auto loaded helps a lot just need some external camera and a drone over head for scouting targets
Am I right ?
Lol if Ukie losses are so low why none wants to sign up nomore?
UAlosses says in their about section: "All names included in the list are sourced. As only data that is available online is considered, the real level of losses is estimated to be considerably higher. In particular, available data is scarce for large cities, Transcarpathia, and most localities in the east and south; as a result, the casualties listed here are likely only a fraction of the real toll."
Mediazona likewise estimates that their figure represents around half, or 40-60% of the total. So between 90-135.000, and does not include DNR/LNR losses from 2022.
Willy, keep it up mate
Shovels and washing machines made all the difference🤫🤫🤫 2023 🤫🤫🤫
Imagine making fun of something that is true. Its fun that russia has so much more forces but still cant break through. It only servers as evidence for the shovels claim. However, when having many many many soldiers with shovels, they can still overcome much little force. It is sad reality, russia has numbers.
@@frodolucaniusHmm Russia has been taking ground daily over the last 9 months. Ur not being honest
@@frodolucaniusthose Ukrainians are fighting for their lives. They literally can’t be anywhere else. Same as the Russians. Ukraines outnumbered with better tech and equipment. Yes they can hold ‘em but not forever
@@safeprisonoffice6259 It took a ground, I have no problem to admit that, but if it took really that much ground, situation would look different. I really dont know how, maybe it is really all the western support, but I have nothing but admiration for Ukraine for standing so long against a bully that has so many more men. The world will once be free, I hope, without regimes like russia, without the repression and all. I really hope.
At some point during the Vietnam war, every american knew someone who was killed or wounded in Vietnam, 58,220 Americans died there. Ukraine is even a smaller country, so each death really makes an impact, specially with social media. A youtuber called Memeable media made a video about it 5 months ago and had an estimate of 172 thousand. Funny fact is that this number was reached by following PNAS study which concluded that Ukrainian official sources will over estimate Russia's losses at a rate of 1.9x while Russians estimate Ukrainian losses by 4.3x. Turns out, giving Medianoza's work, seems that they were right. Turns out that a lot of people died and got injured, but it isn't what neither side is stating.
Winter war against Finland.
3 months.
Between 64,000 to 127,000 Soviet dead depending on your source.
Apparently Stalin didn't know how many died following his orders.
A much less lethal environment than today.
If Putin is not funding this channel, how does Willy explain his fancy new wardrobe?
Connect the dots, people.
He sells his noods on his tg. Don't tell anybody.
Russian casualties are obviously nowhere even remotely close to 520,000, but also obviously higher than 50,000. Probably around 150-200,000.
No democratic country can sustain the number of losses in a war and still remain in that war . This is just too much despite having superior weapons
Has anybody remembered that Ursula Von said in december 2022 that Ukraine had suffered more than 100.000 deaths ?
They have both suffered over 100 k casualties
@@uri-uf5hd Hard to belive that Russia has suffered that, the BBC, in november of the last year, released a MI6 report stating that the Russian armed forces had 50k dead, wich considering that this source is pro-ukraine leads commom sense to belive that the losses are indeed fewer than presented by the British intelligence.Also, take note that Russia has 10 to 2 artillery advantage, more drones, much more professional soldiers, more ammo, tanks, missiles, air defenses, they are using more aircraft and FAB bombs, so its just natural and logical to conclude that Ukraine has endure a greater level of losses than Russia.
@@impaler7580 Watch any interview of Russian soldiers . They fear Ukrainians drones more than artillery. It’s the only reason Ukraine are still in this fight . The Ukrainians have take modern warfare to a new level despite not having artillery or the weapons of the Russians.The drones are the reason Russian regiments are not pushing too hard inward into Ukraine . You would be picked up by drones .
@@uri-uf5hd I don't really take those interviews as truth at first sight, i take them with a grain of salt, but, yes, the only thing the AFU still has and its deadly is FPV drones.However, Russia still has the edge in FPV drones (like the Lancet and Shaheed), EW capabilities and the Turtle tanks are somewhat effective in taking many drone hits.Advancing in ground doesn't count as much when the fight is a war of atrition, the first russian objective is not take ground, it is destroy the AFU manpower, reserves, capabilities, equipments and push them to near collapse.
Dude, it's not that complicated! Africans aren't being recruited to go fight in Ukraine, thay are for local defense in Africa, in case the Frenchies try to invade
They are likely recruiting for both. Russia has recruited a unknown number of foreign fighters not just from Africa, from India and South America and other places.
@@greenspiraldragonA few hundred Gurkhas joined as well. Likely ones who failed the overly zealous recruitment parameters for the UK Ghurka brigade.
@@greenspiraldragon Have you seen Ukrainians release any videos with killed or captured foreigners, serving with the Russians?
There are claims that many AFU losses are reported as missing, left somewhere in steppes of Ukraine. If person is missing, there is no obituary, no funeral...
And no payout for the Family
Or course there are. Blown to bits, Buried, missing.
Ukrainian claimed 😂😂😂😂 … why u can’t discuss about Ukrainian losses … western are very good in social media propaganda
As good on internet as your GF is on that Only for Fans web site we see her GOLYY on tovarisch ?
Russia recruiting in Africa - here is another take. Putin wants locals to be part of the Russian forces down there. They offer full regular army and Russian passport, so they break then out of local affiliations. Until we know those are sent to the frontline in significant number - I would not throw away that Russia is just trying to be sensibly with forces in the bases they build up there. The US has relied on locals repeatedly - but mostly betrayed them and never offered them passports en mass.
I believe that the Russians are recruiting Africans, but only to work with Wagner in Africa. do you even understand that on the mainland, where there is not a single black person, how it will look and how many photos will be in telegram
Russia is a massive country with many parts that is sparsely populated or completely unsettled.
Trying to populate these parts is probably a good move in the long term but they should be careful that these cultures can assimilate and adopt the Russian way, Russian traditions or they will have a similar problem as some parts of Western Europe now has.
Most of Willy's facts are based on data from such admirers of "pravda" as BBC, or CNN. And there is already a meme about Bloomberg: "some Bloomberg said."
African mercs in Russian … what could go wrong
@@scroopynooperz9051 I think Russia does diversity more intelligently than the West. Assimilation is a much bigger, less controversial requirement.
Think less "blue haired Western HR" and more "Roman Empire"
If 70% of casualties are caused by artillery and Russia has a big advantage in artillery power (and air power), how can Russia have higher casualties than Ukraine?
And Ukraine has an acute shortage of soldiers. Were is the massive army they had at the start of the war? And all the people they gathered and sent to the front?
Accuracy? Russia also more time on the assault? I you think Ukraine numbers are higher than reported. Like every one else I don't know either
Why are they letting Russia continue with their pincer moves all the time?
Because Ukraine is retreating as Russia hammers them
Because the Ukrainians are being lead by NATO and NATO command have no idea what is going on the front.
Because their doctrine is to defend every square inch of land, which obviously is crippling to Ukraine, it would be so much better of they switched back to guerrilla warfare because then they would've have to send inexperienced soliders to get FAB'd in random trenches
They continue to get outgunned and outmanned.
AFU has no choice. They are out of manpower.
Хех. Об украинских потерях хорошо расскажет трехчасовое видео украинских кладбищ
No 3 hour documentaries about Russian cemeteries I see.
That's good.
The Mediazona numbers for Ukrainian KIA's is out by a factor of around 10.
No one know how many were killed from both sides. Don't guess. Wait until the end.... really .
It might take decades for the real numbers to come out . No doubt hundred thousands have died on both sides
Funny thing is the BBC admitted in a news post around the middle of last year (somewhere between mid June & the beginning of August), that according to open source data on military obituaries, Ukraine had 284,000 military fatalities by then, so they decided to do similar research on Russia & claimed they found confirmation of some 28,000 military obituaries there, but then added it’s probably double, without providing any information to back up the reason why “it’s probably double”. Either way the difference is stark.
Winter war against Finland.
3 months.
Between 64,000 to 127,000 Soviet dead depending on your source.
Apparently Stalin didn't know how many died following his orders.
A much less lethal environment than today.
These figures would line up with Russia’s artillery advantage of 5 to 10 for every 1 from UA. double figure that the bbc pulled out of its azz = 5 Ukrainians for every 1 Russian. I figured worst exchange rate for Russia is 2:1 given its edge in firepower
I reckon these figures only line up when you're over the dunny right at about the exact moment you realise the content is just one ginormous bbbrrghFART.
а можно такое же расследование по украинским потерям?
Looking at the evidence from Graveyards across the Ukraine, I cannot accept that Ukraine's dead amounts only to approx 50,000. Looking at the number of new graves and new cemeteries across Ukraine, their dead certainly exceed 250,000 - 300,000. Looking at just how stretched is the Ukraine's Army over the past 6 months, I tend to believe that the Ukraine's dead are clearly in excess of 250,000.
neither willy nor the site is claiming that is the real number that is just the number they were able to verify ....people who have no one to post about their death... people whose close ones do not post about their death ... people who are MIA ... those can not be verified as dead and as such can not be in that number ....
Same goes for the Russian number ....
Talk to a guy from ukraine! everybody belives theres well over 300000+
You fight for a country, you survivr, you get citizenship - you earned it, this has been going on in at least ww1 & ww2, Gurkas - good honourable men, great fighters, still got screwed in the end by UK gov.
Willy is once more trying to fill up on that uke copium. Want some realistic numbers? I'd wager Russian irreversible losses are getting close to a 100k and Ukrainian losses are around 550k.
Facts not farts please.
2x in Russia’s favor minimum given that it has anywhere from 3-12x the firepower
It’s the same.
@@bumble-g2j universally recognized fact is that Russia outguns Ukraine 5 to 1 in artillery and has an absolute advantage in air support capabilities. So unless those ukrainians developed some superhuman resistance to explosives they're definitely losing more people. Likely losses are proportionate to equipment and firepower ratios.
Winter war against Finland.
3 months.
Between 64,000 to 127,000 Soviet dead depending on your source.
Apparently Stalin didn't know how many died following his orders.
A much less lethal environment than today.
Hahahaha, Ukraine not doing so well hmmmm?
Everyone joking that Prigozhin was trolling, but he was actually spitting facts.
Whereas Putin spits bullets.
Whereas Putin spits bullets.
Why aren't the Mediazona doing the same on Ukrainian casualties one might wonder?
Ukraine? Never heard of it.
*Western Russia
Hello, I found your channel last month and I watch your videos every day. Your coverage of the war is the best. Thanks for the work you put into these videos. Have a great day.
Nice suit Willy
Joking 😅
During your last interview, your guest was very proud about low casualties in their battalion: out of 750 people during 14 months they lost: 57 killed, 250 critically injured, 400 wounded. So 90% casualty rate is considered good.
So basically the prisoners have a 60/40 chance of surviving. That is wild.
Also they can write down a name of person who gets $55k in case they die. Some of them have actually written down names of their victims
@@DarkVadimjke wow now that is wild!
Prigozhin on his recruitment tour told them straight " You stand a high chance of being killed , but if you do survive you're free " . . The same programme stated that the chances of a lifer surviving in a Russian prison until their release date was also very poor . They had a choice between rotting for15 years in a dog eat dog prison ,if they survived that long , or die under the open skies , with the slim chance that if you were lucky you'd be out and free in six months .
@@leynagh yeah, it was a fair deal. Prigozhin didnt sugarcoat it
@@DarkVadimjke They aren't the kind of men you lie to, then hand machine guns
There are 3x millitery age Ukrainian men in the EU than in the Ukraine Army. Voted with their feet.
Russians did too.
Remember?
No general mobilisations either.
Oh it's hard supporting an imperialistic fascist Russia isn't it.
All these pesky contradictions leaping out unexpectedly.
Bakhmut was a meat grinder of prisoners not soldiers
Nooo it was those ruzzian elite soldiers with their high end equipment and precision strikes 🤣🤣🤣🤣 This comment section is like the creator of the video very disillusioned.
@@TheCheshireTreeand not a single ukrainian right 😂😂😂😂
@@TheCheshireTreeHauptsache du hast Recht 😂😂
Bullshitttt
What everyone forgets are DPR/LPR soldiers, those were practically Ukrainians too but they fought with Russians.
That remote control vehicle is a captured ukrainian tank called the T-72AMT, not a russian one , theres around 50 or so of these tanks within Ukraine, Russia has captured 2, Russia does have drone tank technology tho.
Keep coping hard, Ukraine lost close to a million of military man, and just by obituaries there are 500 000 dead
You have absolutely nothing to go on.
Nobody likes to look at Ukraine's losses
Why do people criticize Ukr for saying they only lost 31k but now they need more and more? Let me clear it up for you: Ukr has won every battle since Feb 2022. Thus, their previous 500k soldiers have been promoted to higher being. It's only natural that they need more soldiers now to celebrate the victory.
😅
😂
😂
Due to the fact that in Australia the clock hands rotate in the opposite direction, there is always some confusion.
lol you have no idea what you're on about
What a horrible loss of life. I know it’s been happening since humans existed but damn…
Hello from kiwi land. Keep up the good work
That was in my mind a year ago , that you can remote control these Russian tanks pretty easy . Cause of the auto loader , this should be no problem for them .
Lot of pidarussian bots in the comment section lately
Keep up with good work Willy, greetings from Italy
Lots of bots from both sides by your logic. There are lots of genuinely ill founded comments. However it’s too simplistic to call people with different opinions bots. This has been one of the main points Willy has been making.
@@zengfamily8390 well, maybe you are right but I see the same comments posted over and over again
@@Hashashinist you could be right too
@@zengfamily8390 90% of the comments are pro-Russian shitting on and joking about Ukraine video after video after video. It's the truth, look at the comment section yourself
And there are fewer and fewer bot catchers... You have to try harder, buddy, your hard work brings victory closer)
Not a peep of Ukrainians losing over 500,000 men. Willy should know by know that they try to mirror whatever what is really happening. It’s Russia with 50,000 KIA and the AFU with 500,000 KIA, not the other way around. And Willy is slipping back into NAFO territory by focusing only on AFU strikes.
Natonazis have lost over 500k ppl while Russia hasn't even hit 80k lol thats embarrasing for nato
You mean ruzzian Neonazis, you accidentally wrote NATO 🙄🙄😑
"Natonazis"😂😂 Ironically there are more nazis in Wagner group alone than in all of Ukraine's armed forces. Even the founder of Wagner PMC was a literal nazi
@@jrh7178 Cope harder, nafo bot
@@jrh7178no stop your bs
At least half of ukriane troops are ultranationalist nazis
@@iwams1 "When the person you're debating with starts insulting you instead of providing a legitimate answer to your argument, you know you've won the debate"
The numbers are all bullshit. On the Ukraine war maps, they total between 100-200 engagements per day along the front like, judging from the footage its not too hard to assume that each engagement has about 3-6 KIA. so 300-1200 Ukies are dying every day. And these are just low estimate averages.
You could assume that the Russian's are taking similar losses. Even though they have the numbers advantage, this isn't an Asymetric war, its fucking bloody on both sides. So we have a modest estimate of 2k white christian Slavs dying every day.
EDIT: 37 have died while watching Willy's video.
Willie knows.....
No to Naziukropnato 🤗💖🇷🇺👍
But did YOU know that the majority of nazis in Ukraine were on the Russian side when Wagner and the Rusich group were inside the country 😂😂
@@jrh7178 You sound like a bandarite....😁🇷🇺👍
@@jrh7178 You must be one of those ukrop bots....😂
@@DARKSTAR-mn8ee Can you kids actually give me some counter arguments instead of accusing me of being a "ukrop bot" for pointing out literal facts you can look up yourself 😂😂 Do you even know what Rusich group is, or who Dmirty Utkin was??
@@jrh7178 I've been reading some of you're previous comments, you like calling people russian bots but don't like it when applied to you...
Not very bright are you.....
Also important to keep in mind that military units have historically been peopled by convicts. The British Army is a prime example, as Wellington noted ("the scum of the earth"--most recruits; those who were not pressganged, were poor 18-20 year olds or criminals). Max Hastings infamously claimed that much of the Canadian Army before conscription in WW2 was composed of convicts, especially American convicts (much like the Americans who are escaping prosecution now by fighting for Russia). Why? Simple: dying is bad, so nations kill the poor and criminals first, before conscript soldiers.
Z
Is that all you got GLUPPY GOPNIK, how about Za Tsar Putin or Maybe try a ' Prodvinutyye pedaristy '
Ran across one of your old videos and was wondering if you passed. The median survival time for adults with glioblastoma is 15 months. You look healthy...Guess they misdiagnosed you or something... Anyways, Slava Ukraine! Cheers!
It’s not wounded. I know some of you don’t do math, but I do. And the mathematics were talking about her actually pretty basic. The BBC can’t count the dead because it’s a criminal offense to disclose or publish that information. We know by the fact that Ukraine admitted to having 25,000 amputees in September 2023 they cannot have any less than 250,000 killed an action as of September 2023. That’s based on the ratio the United States had in the Vietnam war, but Ukraine lacks helicopter evacuation, and so their ratio of killed to amputee is going to be significantly higher. There is absolutely no way that their battlefield medicine is equal to Americas in Vietnam.
Ukraine would not be drafting another 300,000 men with an army of just 450,000 now if they had suffered only 50,000 dead. I know that you’re trying to be neutral and that you can’t tell the truth unless you want to lose the Ukraine fanboys, but you really should anyway. The BBCs numbers are statistically implausible.
There has never been an artillery war at any point in history in which the side with 10 times less firepower inflicted more casualties. It’s a joke.