Yes, I'll make a video, where I rerank the idols who I think should've been either lower or higher etc. I also noticed Winters underwhelming energy some weeks ago.
Okay, the quality didn't turn out that bad😄 But the volume sounds low... Anyways Ranking these girls, where 4 of them (I think Boa is considered one) are main dancers... is the hardest thing I've done so far after the Enhypen analysis. They are truly talented, and I bet they could all take the 1st spot😅 And one more thing... Some of you might wonder why Wendy is not higher on the list. Well that's because her "overall" average is low. If "energy" was its own category, she would've skyrocketed to the top. But "energy" is categorized in "dynamics/flavors". I was about to give her an 8 in this category, but ofc "flavors" was also included. Since I didn't see much flavor from her, she got a 7. And about Seulgi getting 7 in alignment... It's mainly arm lines. I was gonna give her 7 in upper body control because of her almost "stiff" torso (couldn't do a proper wave) and messy arm lines, but she got GREAT arm control in general. They're sharp, and solid. That's why I deducted a point in the alignment category rather than "upper body". Hope you understand. About Karina: I gave her the wrong number on coordination and alignment... It's supposed to be the opposite. The correct evaluation is: Coordination: 10 Alignment: 8 😬 Another important new: The itzy ultimate dance analysis will be postponed due to some unexpected outcomes... I'll keep making shorter analysis ("who danced the best") in the meantime. Enjoy🤗
Greaaaat! I love how you highlight 2+ members for some moves. I actually agree with the ranking,maybe i would put wendy above winter(only for this choreo).Karina did really well in the dance practice,hope we can see more like that from her,her alingments indeed improved here. Overall i think they did a good job for what was given,i think this choreo,mainly de dance break,is really underwhelming...
Yes and you're really early😅 What a nice surprise. I explained why Wendy wasn't any higher on my pinned comment. So check it out :D If this was a subjective ranking, I would put Karina on first place. She really nailed this choreo. And about the dance break. Yeah It was quite underwhelming as you mentioned. The tricky part about the dance break, is the rhythm, flow and the beat. I had to analyze that part in slow motion in order to properly catch small details. The three of them actually did pretty well.
@@psychorious haha i was waiting for a new video🤭🤭🤭 I think for the dancers we have here : Boa,hyoyeon and seulgi,the dance break could be waaaay better.But their execution was nice,as you said. I dont know if you do old dances like 2018's but i would love to see a "We go up" dance analysis. From my perspective and analysis,Mark and Jeno did the best, respectivelly.
@@whysotensepottah463 Yeah, Let's hope that their next release will have a different dance break (including Karina). I will do old dances, when my channel gets bigger. Right now, I mainly focus on new releases. But yeah I love that choreo so much! It's also one of my faves. I do agree with you. Mark and Jeno were standouts. And the footwork?? What on earth-
@@psychorious Sure,it makes sense. The footwork😭😭😭😭,mark has the best footwork in nct,and jeno has a really strong and underrated footwork,i wish people would recognize the amazing dancer jeno is. For karina's score: it's ooook,at least she upgrade from 6/7 to 8 haha,10 for coordination seems right haha.
I feel like the ranking would have changed a bit if it included facial expressions. BoA is a good dancer but she had the most unclear facial expressions in every performance of this song while Hyoyeon does them perfectly. Even Wendy had better facial expressions than Winter too.
@@PureHoneyBoo I only include facials on my the bigger analysis named "ultimate dance analysis". These shorter analysis (who danced the best) are simplified.
1:46 i will give these point to boa and hyloyen cause if you see karina she is having really bad coordination means just see head is often moving, footworks are looking messy and no weight transfer
Well I make mistakes all the time. But I think the reason why I gave her that point, is because of her bounciness (which wasn't even mentioned...) It goes well with the choreo. But honestly, I was having a hard time analyzing everyone😅
Why does Winter and Wendy have the same score in dynamics+flavor? Lol. I would give Winter at least 5 points and Wendy at least 9 points for that criterion.
@@psychorious i know, but like seulgi is pretty much on all accounts better than karina. no hate to karina like she's still good at dancing but i think she has a ways to go before she's really comparable to seulgi
@@igniculusquartz1827 your reasoning makes no sense. if choreography fits exceptionally to the technique of the idol ( or dancer in general ) then of course they will be better than the one who doesn't fit that much. It also doesn't mean that a dancer who is better at one choreography is generally better. karina was better / on the same lvl than / with Seulgi in this choreography. like...it's fact. karina and her execution overall was better than Seulgi in my opinion, her style is just different from the rest, but it's obvious that Karina is generally not at Seulgi level as they have a gigantic experience gap between them.
This isn't a general ranking. For this choreo, Karina and Hyo shined the most with their flashy sharp moves, the choreo suited Karina's dancing style, so for this song only, Karina is ranked higher, but Seulgi is not way behind her. Generally speaking, Karina is still way behind Seulgi in terms of dancing, technique and strength-wise.
This isn't a general ranking. For this choreo, Karina and Hyo shined the most with their flashy sharp moves, the choreo suited Karina's dancing style, so for this song only, Karina is ranked higher, but Seulgi is not way behind her. Generally speaking, Karina is still way behind Seulgi in terms of dancing, technique and strength-wise.
![RANKING SUPERM & GOT the beat IN DIFFERENT CATEGORIES [vocal, rap, dance, etc]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3PpKkOL8VJs/mqdefault.jpg)
Boa is definitely the best dancer here. I would put Wendy above Winter. Wendy had more energy. But otherwise I agree with this ranking.
Yes, I'll make a video, where I rerank the idols who I think should've been either lower or higher etc.
I also noticed Winters underwhelming energy some weeks ago.
Okay, the quality didn't turn out that bad😄 But the volume sounds low...
Anyways
Ranking these girls, where 4 of them (I think Boa is considered one) are main dancers... is the hardest thing I've done so far after the Enhypen analysis.
They are truly talented, and I bet they could all take the 1st spot😅
And one more thing...
Some of you might wonder why Wendy is not higher on the list. Well that's because her "overall" average is low. If "energy" was its own category, she would've skyrocketed to the top. But "energy" is categorized in "dynamics/flavors". I was about to give her an 8 in this category, but ofc "flavors" was also included. Since I didn't see much flavor from her, she got a 7.
And about Seulgi getting 7 in alignment...
It's mainly arm lines. I was gonna give her 7 in upper body control because of her almost "stiff" torso (couldn't do a proper wave) and messy arm lines, but she got GREAT arm control in general. They're sharp, and solid. That's why I deducted a point in the alignment category rather than "upper body". Hope you understand.
About Karina:
I gave her the wrong number on coordination and alignment... It's supposed to be the opposite.
The correct evaluation is:
Coordination: 10
Alignment: 8
😬
Another important new:
The itzy ultimate dance analysis will be postponed due to some unexpected outcomes...
I'll keep making shorter analysis ("who danced the best") in the meantime.
Enjoy🤗
Fair! it totally makes sense.
Take your time with the ultimate Itzy analysis :)
We will patiently wait for it
Greaaaat!
I love how you highlight 2+ members for some moves.
I actually agree with the ranking,maybe i would put wendy above winter(only for this choreo).Karina did really well in the dance practice,hope we can see more like that from her,her alingments indeed improved here.
Overall i think they did a good job for what was given,i think this choreo,mainly de dance break,is really underwhelming...
Yes and you're really early😅 What a nice surprise.
I explained why Wendy wasn't any higher on my pinned comment. So check it out :D
If this was a subjective ranking, I would put Karina on first place. She really nailed this choreo.
And about the dance break. Yeah It was quite underwhelming as you mentioned. The tricky part about the dance break, is the rhythm, flow and the beat. I had to analyze that part in slow motion in order to properly catch small details. The three of them actually did pretty well.
@@psychorious haha i was waiting for a new video🤭🤭🤭
I think for the dancers we have here : Boa,hyoyeon and seulgi,the dance break could be waaaay better.But their execution was nice,as you said.
I dont know if you do old dances like 2018's but i would love to see a "We go up" dance analysis. From my perspective and analysis,Mark and Jeno did the best, respectivelly.
@@whysotensepottah463 Yeah, Let's hope that their next release will have a different dance break (including Karina).
I will do old dances, when my channel gets bigger. Right now, I mainly focus on new releases.
But yeah I love that choreo so much! It's also one of my faves. I do agree with you. Mark and Jeno were standouts. And the footwork?? What on earth-
And yeah one more thing. Karina was supposed to get 8 on alignment and 10 on coordination😬 I really did mess up there.
@@psychorious
Sure,it makes sense.
The footwork😭😭😭😭,mark has the best footwork in nct,and jeno has a really strong and underrated footwork,i wish people would recognize the amazing dancer jeno is.
For karina's score: it's ooook,at least she upgrade from 6/7 to 8 haha,10 for coordination seems right haha.
Honestly, I do believe Wendy should be a little higher on the list, but I do also agree with the ranking. Keep working😊
I explained why she didn’t get a higher score on my pinned comment😊
@@psychorious yeah I figured it out 40 sec after your reply 😅 Thanks btw
@@sweetdaemon it happens😄
I would put Wendy above Winter.
@@tyrellcorp2118 Yeah I actually agree😅
I feel like the ranking would have changed a bit if it included facial expressions. BoA is a good dancer but she had the most unclear facial expressions in every performance of this song while Hyoyeon does them perfectly. Even Wendy had better facial expressions than Winter too.
Yeah you're right. It would change a lot.
That's why I didn't include it, so we would rather focus on their execution☺
@@psychorious It's a great video~
@@likea9959 Awwe Thank you 😄
But facials should be considered when judging dancing skills
@@PureHoneyBoo I only include facials on my the bigger analysis named "ultimate dance analysis". These shorter analysis (who danced the best) are simplified.
1:46 i will give these point to boa and hyloyen cause if you see karina she is having really bad coordination means just see head is often moving, footworks are looking messy and no weight transfer
Well I make mistakes all the time. But I think the reason why I gave her that point, is because of her bounciness (which wasn't even mentioned...)
It goes well with the choreo.
But honestly, I was having a hard time analyzing everyone😅
@@psychorious oh its ok i know when in a group everyone dance with energy so it is really hard to choose one
@@Forever_2424 exactly!
0:50 at this i think these point will go for Wendy cause she has the great torso lock
I will be honest. I thought the lock wasn't prominent enough for it to get highlighted😅
In beat too
In pre- chorus hyoyeon is the best in torso and the first rap line of karina hyoyeon is the best in hips, sorry but hyoyeon is #1
My ranking would be
Boa
Hyo
Seulgi
Karina
Wendy
winter
Taeyeon
The new ranking is updated in form of "shorts"
sometimes i forget that wendy's doing all this after falling off a stage
Why does Winter and Wendy have the same score in dynamics+flavor? Lol. I would give Winter at least 5 points and Wendy at least 9 points for that criterion.
I uploaded an updated version (as shorts) :)
generally good video but will have to heavily disagree with karina being higher than seulgi lol
I mean, it's only 0,2 point difference😅
@@psychorious i know, but like seulgi is pretty much on all accounts better than karina. no hate to karina like she's still good at dancing but i think she has a ways to go before she's really comparable to seulgi
@@igniculusquartz1827 your reasoning makes no sense. if choreography fits exceptionally to the technique of the idol ( or dancer in general ) then of course they will be better than the one who doesn't fit that much. It also doesn't mean that a dancer who is better at one choreography is generally better. karina was better / on the same lvl than / with Seulgi in this choreography. like...it's fact. karina and her execution overall was better than Seulgi in my opinion, her style is just different from the rest, but it's obvious that Karina is generally not at Seulgi level as they have a gigantic experience gap between them.
This isn't a general ranking. For this choreo, Karina and Hyo shined the most with their flashy sharp moves, the choreo suited Karina's dancing style, so for this song only, Karina is ranked higher, but Seulgi is not way behind her. Generally speaking, Karina is still way behind Seulgi in terms of dancing, technique and strength-wise.
@@jaehyunsdaughter3960 yeah I guess I misunderstood the purpose of the video, I thought this was a general ranking
Karina being above Seulgi is absolutely criminal
it's only for this choreo
This isn't a general ranking. For this choreo, Karina and Hyo shined the most with their flashy sharp moves, the choreo suited Karina's dancing style, so for this song only, Karina is ranked higher, but Seulgi is not way behind her. Generally speaking, Karina is still way behind Seulgi in terms of dancing, technique and strength-wise.
Wendy , boa , winrin the best dance