God, i know that it's normal for seulgi's arm lines and hand gestures to be insanely precise after training for the naughty choreo along with irene but it still surprises me how just. Precise she got.
@@aesthetically_kpop1982 it’s the hair we NEED BLONDE winter back, like she was feeling herself and giving stage presence, then they gave her the bob and her presence disappeared
@@anthonymagana3181 IVE BEEN SAYING THIS. she had more presence with the longer hair. even when she had long hair from time to time during next level, her presence was better
Kinda glad Karina was in the group. Aespa’s choreo don’t make her skills shine tbh BUT HERE? Wow. I knew she was a good dancer from the start but she proved herself here and I’m glad people are noticing it too! She got a lot of hate for her main dancer position in Aespa, hopefully the haters will look at her differently now.
She's so discredited for her dancing. She's not even bad yet people are being over-dramatic when she's nervous and stiff like she's the worst dancer alive or smth💀
@@minaballerina I do think that you can be popular and underrated. Karina has been criticized multiple times for her dancing when it was never bad from the start. And as a fellow once, you should know another example of popular yet underrated idols: TWICE themselves are seen as less than capable of singing live however if you just check their concerts performance you would know that it's not really fair to say that from the start
@@horus7416 true but I think the reason she gets criticized for her dancing skills is because of the lack of stage presence and her mama performance was such a letdown
I always thought Karina was underappreciated when it comes to dancing, but to be honest even I didn’t expected her to be this good alongside other main dancers. Everyone was saying she’s nowhere near Seulgi or Hyoyeon in terms of potential. I am surprised and very proud of her.
karina seulgi and boa were def stand outs for me in this choreo. Even tho she wasn’t highlighted at that moment , I love karina’s way of executing the frat boy both arms move , she does it with a lot of swag. And I really like how seulgi and boa do the second part of the chorus where they like have their hands over their heads and they go back and forth. and also one last thing ( even tho again she wasn’t highlighted ) I think karina did such a great job on her center part In the bridge , she blew me away!
In case someone wants to know. This is the amount of times, each member was highlighted: Seulgi - 17 Karina - 16 Boa - 15 Hyoyeon - 12 Wendy - 4 Winter - 3 Taeyeon - 2 This isn't a dance ranking. Some people just want to know how many times each member was highlighted Side note: Seulgi really popped up after that dance break
karina really said "I'm aespa's main dancer go cry about it" so glad karina was a part of GOT this time around she really separated aespa karina from GOT karina
I had no idea Wendy had NO DANCE POSITION but she really holds her own against these powerhouses Loads of energy, she looks like she’s having fun which made the performance enjoyable for me!
Wendy is just energetic when dancing which is good, but in terms of fluidity, sharpness, power and etc. she's weak. Most of the time she overdance too and skip some movements.
@@seulgientertainment5752 Not exactly true, but go ahead and keep lying to yourself. Wendy is so much more than just energetic. Wendy has improved her sharpness and fluidity and doesn't skip as many movements like a couple other members in her group. She's also more fluid in her hip area than Seulgi along with Irene, who is the most flexible member. If you look at the dance break with BoA and Hyoyeon you'll see what I mean about Seulgi's hips. In RBB choreography when they line up and rotate their hips right before the bridge Irene and Wendy execute that movement the best. Wendy also does a lot of pops and locks in her movements and some people mistake that for stiffness. She even showcases that a couple of time in Step Back choreography. You can see this locking on RBB when she and Seulgi go down to the floor on the bridge. She does that tut dance the best. While you are criticizing Wendy there is room to criticize them all. Wendy is third best dancer in Red Velvet and CAN execute some movements better than dance line. She has the best stage presence and charisma along with Seulgi. She is energetic, but she's improved a lot and is more sharp and detailed in her dancing nowadays. When next to Karina and Seulgi in this choreography she does not stick out like a sore thumb and is rather in sync with them and adds her own flair to the movements like the main dancers do. Stop trying to shade her improvements. So many people are praising her improvements and stating she is one of the best performers in this unit. I'm super proud of her and Seulgi. I feel like they are two of the best performers in this unit and Seulgi of course one of the best dancers. Wendy is holding her own very well next to the powerhouse dancers in this group. Much better than Winter, who actually has a dance position. Also, Wendy has a lot of power when she dances. Have you not seen her step back challenge with Winter? It is so obvious she has power. Look at her next to Karina and Seulgi when they are grouped together. Wendy is not lacking power at all. Even at the start of Step Back she and Karina are hitting their movements with power. Wendy did not overdance in this choreography because she stood next to some powerful dancers, which no offense to Irene, Joy, and Yeri, but they are inconsistent with energy and stage presence, so of course Wendy would look like she is overdancing. Look at Wendy on the Way To Go performance with the 4th generation idols. Most of the comments are about her and her dancing is praised along with her energy and charisma. It isn't just about her vocals. I saw no one under that video accusing Wendy of overdancing because again she was standing next to Chaeryeoung, Yuna, Yoon, Sieun... Now ask yourself how come there were no comments about her overdancing on that stage as well?
@@shujinko2944 Irene is a better dancer than Wendy. Her technique is sharper, cleaner, and more fluid. Wendy still has some details she needs to work on, but you can see that she is doing exactly that. Wendy's stage presence and charisma stands out more, but Irene has her charms as well. A stare into the camera sends me in a frenzy 🤣🤣🤣 As for vocals I honestly wouldn't compare Wendy and Irene. It is unfair to compare Wendy's vocals to Irene. Irene has her strengths as a vocalist and I really love how she harmonizes with the vocal line. As for rapping, I absolutely love Irene's rapping. She is a really good idol rapper and has a nice tone. She's so smooth with it. I love Wendy's swagger and diction when she raps. She almost broke into a rap after Taeyeon's high note in Step Back. You can tell Wendy can spit fire! I just felt it was unfair for the comment to say Wendy is only energetic when she was slaying right next to Seulgi and Karina and did not look awkward or out of place next to freaking BoA and Hyoyeon. She deserves more credit than being labeled an energetic dancer. She can gold her own against the dance line. She has improved so much!
@lawitchi Why was Wendy shaded to begin with under a comment that was praising her? Why didn't you defend Wendy? Just saying. Typical Reveluv behavior.
What do you think about Wendy's dancing? I don't really keep up with Red Velvet, but she seemed to have improved quite a lot (she was pretty much bashed for her 'bad' dancing) and didn't seem all to troubled to keep up with the rest.
I saw on a dance ranking vid that Wendy is actually the third best dancer in RV so I'd say it's not badxD that means she's after the main and lead dancer
I absolutely love Wendy's dancing. People sleep on her dancing so much. She's actually my favorite dancer in Red Velvet in spite of me ranking her third in dance. I just love the way she moves the best.
She was definitely definitely not as good when she was a rookie, she was really last in terms of dancing, and then she rose to #3 right after Irene after red flavor I believe.
I'm really impressed by boa and Karina , it's incredible the difference between the two by the experience but still slay the song like they were main and lead dancers
Karina isn't just your typical main dancer she may be no better than hyoyeon and seulgi but she is karina and she dances like karina she has originality in her and I say it all the time but she is going to be the next taeyong a girl version of him their looks,dance,rap everything about them screams ACE!!
- This is just my observation, I watch a lot of dance videos in generals to improve my own dancing skills in general. I tried dancing to step back (as a 6'2" tall male it's a bit harder than I expected, but I tried my best to do as best as I can.) Don't take thie seriously, its just an opinion and no bashing. Honestly all of them are in my bias line from their respective groups, so why should I bash them. If something sounds bashful, tell me nicely. Please give me some opinions too. BoA- just a queen, hands down. She is such an insane dancer and for her first group performance, she blended in very well. Karina - Honestly, I feel bad for her. She often times gets shit on, because people have way too high expectations for main dancers. They saw how talented ITZYs dance line is and said Karina is a bad main dancer. I honestly prefer her dancing over Yeji's and Aespas underwhelming choreographies don't do her justice. Seulgi - same with Karina, Red Velvet's choreographies just aren't good enough for her to show off. I once saw a video of her dancing to Make a wish with Taeyong and oh my gosh, she was so phenomenal. Comfortable clothes and 'boygroup-ish' types of dances and Seulgi is showing off. Hyoyeon - Honestly, I feel like she holds back in this stages. We all know, what a beast Hyo is, but in Step Back performances, she kind of is underwhelming to me. Maybe she just holds back to not outshine everyone, she has some bad days, or she doesn't like this choreography. Sti Hyo is at the top of the best dancers and just this one era shouldn't define her dancing abilities. Wendy - Honestly Lead Dancer material. She has so much stage presence and her skills are so solid, I honestly love her. She improved so much and seems so happy to be back on stage. A true, passionate idol. Stan Wendy. Winter - One moment she slays, the other she is underwhelming (both in dancing and stage presence). Her strength definetly are her vocals. She probably was very tired too, because of the Dreams Come True promotions at the same time. I love her dancing, but I was kind of underwhelmed during Step Back, because we all know she can do better, if she wants to. I love her leg moves during the pre chrous with the "LevEeeLLLL!" She does it so smoothly. Taeyeon - Fun Fact" The first video I watched of SNSD was "Lil Touch". I honestly thought she was the main dancer and she actually is a solid dancer. Step back is just too hard of a choreo (especially pre chorus and chorus). She didn't stand out much and most of the time was the only one, who didn't execute most of the moves like the others did, but still she didn't stand out in a bad way. She managed to blend in and had good presence.
I agree with most of your observations with the exception of Karina over Yeji, though that's a personal choice. People think I'm crazy when I say I prefer Wendy's dancing over Seulgi's as well 🤣🤣🤣
I’ve noticed that Seulgi has impeccable angles when she dances so she’s really satisfying to watch, Hyoyeon has really good body control (as seen in the fact that her body rolls are so dang good) and Boa is amazing at extension and using her whole body cohesively when she dances (she’s amazing!). Karina also has really good musicality. Wendy also impressed during her parts!! Center Wendy is amazing! I like the way she does the trio part the most all the way through because I feel like she rides the beat the most whereas Winter may be more precise, but she does it more robotically
I agree wholeheartedly! I've defended both Karina and Wendy on multiple occasions. People are convinced thru are weak dancers and they are soooo not weak dancers. They are much better than credited.
I feel like this type of dance fits karina well, she have strong lower body and good at footworks the only prob is about her shoulders posture it's a bother coz it kinda bent.But It can be fix tho.
@@everythingsfinett3903 u can barely see it bcs they dress her good. Or they make her hair cover it. But this savage era they make it look obvious. Look closely it's kinda bent. I know there's issue in her shoulder bcs we have the same.
GOT made me a fan of Seulgi tbh. It's amazing how she and Karina can catch up with Hyoyeon and BoA's dance prowess. Performing with 2 legendary dancers isn't easy.
It's because Seulgi is very textbook style. She is super clean and has perfect control of her body locks but lacks flexibility and if quite stiff around the hips and torso. But her execution is just👌
I know this GOT is a rotational group, but I'm so obsessed with this lineup. Top notch dancers and top notch vocalists. I hope SM decides for GOT The Beat to record and perform more songs! 🙏🏿😭😭
I don't understand the Karina dance slander. I've always noticed she's such a good dancer and I'm not even a big Aespa fan. Imo the only time time where her dance ability is questionable is during pre-debut days when she danced with Kai and her solo debut teaser. After debut she ATE though🤷🏻♀️
The only person which astonishes me is Boa,cause I saw her for first time even after so many years her body in being perfect shape and moves crisp and sharp is a thing I can't help but appreciate so much. Everyone else is either active in some way or are in active groups they are not the surprises for me but Boa is 😅 Will still mention Seulgi is my bias but many others at different time certainly made me distract from her. Karina is a revelation, she needs some next choreo in her songs to blow us,always thought with Aespa why is she main dancer guess she answered with quite some intensity.😅
I was looking at winter the whole time in the official dance practice video bcz someone said that she look stiff and i can't unsee it💀 i expected to much from her but that can't change that she is technically good dancer. About Karina the only thing i can say is 'go girl, prove your position'
My girl Karina improved so much during this era. After all of the criticisms ( and probably some hate comments) she got before, seeing her shine even while being in the same frame as Seulgi and Hyoyeon makes me cry😭 Every time i see positive comments about Karina's dancing during this Step Back era, I remember the Reddit post which was about how satisfying it is seeing your faves improve and goddamn were they so right😭 Ok u can take the mic back now
Charisma/Stage Presence: BoA Rap: Hyoyeon Dance: Seulgi (She literally doesn't have a bad angle. She was the only one who did the "너 때문에 Border line" part well imo.) Vocals: Idk lmao they all good
That's the point. People put others lead dancers of the 4th generation girl groups above Karina. But they do not realise she's THE MAIN DANCER. She's amazing, her technique is amazing. But just because her group doesnt have energetic choreos people think she's not good. Oh c'mon look at her
I thought it was strange winter not being at least in 4th position, she dances very well, but that doesn't mean anything either. As for Karina, it just proves that she really deserves the position of main dancer. (although underrated)
I'm not a dancer so my opinion is based on what I can notice. At least for me, BoA and Seulgi have similar dance styles while Hyoyeon and Karina both have a singular style. Is hard to say whose better from this, since you can see that sharp moves are better for Karina, specifics is more of Seulgi's thing, fast moves are better in BoA while Hyoyeon does better is smooth steps like body rolls. They really complement each other
Well maybe when you wear too big/loose clothes that covers your movements then it may look a bit messy, also tight clothes block movements which mostly end up with the dance looking half assed and not precised
Some maybe. Perhaps if they're a bit clunky or actually hard to move in? Or perhaps if the movement of the clothes ruins certain timing? I can't think of an example at the moment though sadly
God, i know that it's normal for seulgi's arm lines and hand gestures to be insanely precise after training for the naughty choreo along with irene but it still surprises me how just. Precise she got.
U too
🚶 and the up 🚶🚶🚶 in 🚶
🚶 and then
I feel like this group helped Karina a lot. Both in showing her potential aswell as to improve
I totally agree honestly same for winter like doing those she shined they both were literally amazing
Imo, Winter lacked in stage presence. I honestly didn't feel her even in the performance video.
@@mashihodpotatoetm4572 yup true her stage presence during Black mamba was better but now idk what happened to her she started to losing sp on stage
@@aesthetically_kpop1982 it’s the hair we NEED BLONDE winter back, like she was feeling herself and giving stage presence, then they gave her the bob and her presence disappeared
@@anthonymagana3181 IVE BEEN SAYING THIS. she had more presence with the longer hair. even when she had long hair from time to time during next level, her presence was better
Kinda glad Karina was in the group. Aespa’s choreo don’t make her skills shine tbh BUT HERE? Wow. I knew she was a good dancer from the start but she proved herself here and I’m glad people are noticing it too! She got a lot of hate for her main dancer position in Aespa, hopefully the haters will look at her differently now.
She's so discredited for her dancing. She's not even bad yet people are being over-dramatic when she's nervous and stiff like she's the worst dancer alive or smth💀
Karina is not that bad dancer 🔥
As some toxic fans think she is not
Good for main dancer😏
Not a dancer, but what I got from this video is that Karina is underrated as hell. Deserves her position
she’s one of the most popular idols right now. i wouldn’t call her underrated
@@minaballerina for her dancing skills she is
@@minaballerina I do think that you can be popular and underrated. Karina has been criticized multiple times for her dancing when it was never bad from the start.
And as a fellow once, you should know another example of popular yet underrated idols: TWICE themselves are seen as less than capable of singing live however if you just check their concerts performance you would know that it's not really fair to say that from the start
@@minaballerina She is one of the best dancers of the 4th gen and her dancing skills are pretty under appreciated
@@horus7416 true but I think the reason she gets criticized for her dancing skills is because of the lack of stage presence and her mama performance was such a letdown
3:15 I JUST WANNA MENTION HOW SATISFYING HYOYEON'S BODY POPS WERE AND THEY WERE ON BEAT TOO
For sure! She truly felt the beat I had to give it to her!
@@soshimochi556 Oh and also, I wanna ask if Seulgi deserves her main dancer title. What are your thoughts on her techniques
@@shujinko2944 She also lacks energy in comparison to BoA and Hyoyeon.
Hyoyeon's body is so fluid from start to finish
That little section is exactly the type of dance that hyoyeon really excels in
I always thought Karina was underappreciated when it comes to dancing, but to be honest even I didn’t expected her to be this good alongside other main dancers. Everyone was saying she’s nowhere near Seulgi or Hyoyeon in terms of potential. I am surprised and very proud of her.
It’s mostly due to the fact that Aespa’s choreos don’t let her shine and tend to be quite awkward
karina seulgi and boa were def stand outs for me in this choreo. Even tho she wasn’t highlighted at that moment , I love karina’s way of executing the frat boy both arms move , she does it with a lot of swag. And I really like how seulgi and boa do the second part of the chorus where they like have their hands over their heads and they go back and forth. and also one last thing ( even tho again she wasn’t highlighted ) I think karina did such a great job on her center part In the bridge , she blew me away!
In case someone wants to know. This is the amount of times, each member was highlighted:
Seulgi - 17
Karina - 16
Boa - 15
Hyoyeon - 12
Wendy - 4
Winter - 3
Taeyeon - 2
This isn't a dance ranking. Some people just want to know how many times each member was highlighted
Side note: Seulgi really popped up after that dance break
I felt like there were more karinas and boa when I watched this xD but it was close.
honestly the dance break was really hard but seulgi was just really sharp and clean with her shape head to toe
@@igot7-lu yeah. I thought it's more Karina, but less Hyoyeon.
Karina really surprised me, in a good way.
@@mxxnlight_2858 yeah I think she showed her skills well in this
2:37 Karina really stood out in this part in the video too
I agree it's one of her strongest moments!
Her power while she's at the back😣
hyeyeons subtle but full body roll was SO MESMERISING OH MY GOOOD
Karina is literally on the next level. She is gorgeous in such choreographies
She is ALWAYS on the next level
1:23 Idk why watching BoA and Karina doing this step is so satisfying?
karina really said "I'm aespa's main dancer go cry about it" so glad karina was a part of GOT this time around she really separated aespa karina from GOT karina
I had no idea Wendy had NO DANCE POSITION but she really holds her own against these powerhouses
Loads of energy, she looks like she’s having fun which made the performance enjoyable for me!
Wendy is just energetic when dancing which is good, but in terms of fluidity, sharpness, power and etc. she's weak. Most of the time she overdance too and skip some movements.
@@seulgientertainment5752
Not exactly true, but go ahead and keep lying to yourself. Wendy is so much more than just energetic.
Wendy has improved her sharpness and fluidity and doesn't skip as many movements like a couple other members in her group.
She's also more fluid in her hip area than Seulgi along with Irene, who is the most flexible member. If you look at the dance break with BoA and Hyoyeon you'll see what I mean about Seulgi's hips.
In RBB choreography when they line up and rotate their hips right before the bridge Irene and Wendy execute that movement the best.
Wendy also does a lot of pops and locks in her movements and some people mistake that for stiffness. She even showcases that a couple of time in Step Back choreography.
You can see this locking on RBB when she and Seulgi go down to the floor on the bridge. She does that tut dance the best.
While you are criticizing Wendy there is room to criticize them all.
Wendy is third best dancer in Red Velvet and CAN execute some movements better than dance line.
She has the best stage presence and charisma along with Seulgi. She is energetic, but she's improved a lot and is more sharp and detailed in her dancing nowadays.
When next to Karina and Seulgi in this choreography she does not stick out like a sore thumb and is rather in sync with them and adds her own flair to the movements like the main dancers do.
Stop trying to shade her improvements. So many people are praising her improvements and stating she is one of the best performers in this unit. I'm super proud of her and Seulgi. I feel like they are two of the best performers in this unit and Seulgi of course one of the best dancers. Wendy is holding her own very well next to the powerhouse dancers in this group. Much better than Winter, who actually has a dance position.
Also, Wendy has a lot of power when she dances. Have you not seen her step back challenge with Winter? It is so obvious she has power. Look at her next to Karina and Seulgi when they are grouped together. Wendy is not lacking power at all.
Even at the start of Step Back she and Karina are hitting their movements with power.
Wendy did not overdance in this choreography because she stood next to some powerful dancers, which no offense to Irene, Joy, and Yeri, but they are inconsistent with energy and stage presence, so of course Wendy would look like she is overdancing.
Look at Wendy on the Way To Go performance with the 4th generation idols. Most of the comments are about her and her dancing is praised along with her energy and charisma. It isn't just about her vocals. I saw no one under that video accusing Wendy of overdancing because again she was standing next to Chaeryeoung, Yuna, Yoon, Sieun...
Now ask yourself how come there were no comments about her overdancing on that stage as well?
@@eyebrowstj I would put Wendy > Irene in dancing.
Dance: Wendy > Irene
Vocal: Wendy >>>> Irene
Rap: Wendy >> Irene
OOF 💀
@@shujinko2944
Irene is a better dancer than Wendy. Her technique is sharper, cleaner, and more fluid. Wendy still has some details she needs to work on, but you can see that she is doing exactly that. Wendy's stage presence and charisma stands out more, but Irene has her charms as well. A stare into the camera sends me in a frenzy 🤣🤣🤣
As for vocals I honestly wouldn't compare Wendy and Irene. It is unfair to compare Wendy's vocals to Irene. Irene has her strengths as a vocalist and I really love how she harmonizes with the vocal line.
As for rapping, I absolutely love Irene's rapping. She is a really good idol rapper and has a nice tone. She's so smooth with it.
I love Wendy's swagger and diction when she raps. She almost broke into a rap after Taeyeon's high note in Step Back. You can tell Wendy can spit fire!
I just felt it was unfair for the comment to say Wendy is only energetic when she was slaying right next to Seulgi and Karina and did not look awkward or out of place next to freaking BoA and Hyoyeon.
She deserves more credit than being labeled an energetic dancer. She can gold her own against the dance line. She has improved so much!
@lawitchi
Why was Wendy shaded to begin with under a comment that was praising her?
Why didn't you defend Wendy?
Just saying.
Typical Reveluv behavior.
Karina showing that she's not less than their main dancer predecessors (Seulgi, Hyoyeon and BoA), contrary to what people say....
I mean she is not on the same level but that is fine. She is a rookie and she has potential!
@@shineexokpop6824 yea she’s not on the same level but she will be and better probably lol
@@froglover00000 I mean it's kind of hard to surpass Hyoyeon and BoA.
Yes. She is a really good dancer
Boa and Karina having a moment rn
What do you think about Wendy's dancing? I don't really keep up with Red Velvet, but she seemed to have improved quite a lot (she was pretty much bashed for her 'bad' dancing) and didn't seem all to troubled to keep up with the rest.
I saw on a dance ranking vid that Wendy is actually the third best dancer in RV so I'd say it's not badxD that means she's after the main and lead dancer
I absolutely love Wendy's dancing. People sleep on her dancing so much. She's actually my favorite dancer in Red Velvet in spite of me ranking her third in dance. I just love the way she moves the best.
To me she's always been a great performer and a solid dancer! In this group she's near the bottom but I consider her third dancer in RV for example
She was definitely definitely not as good when she was a rookie, she was really last in terms of dancing, and then she rose to #3 right after Irene after red flavor I believe.
And the fact that she had surgery n can still dance this well omg
karina is main dancer for a reason, i pity those hater saying she can't dance.
She is not only main dancer but also she is MAIN RAPPER in the GOT
What an ace
I'm really impressed by boa and Karina , it's incredible the difference between the two by the experience but still slay the song like they were main and lead dancers
This group’s dancing is just so satisfying
Karina is actually a pretty awesome dancer. She deserves her position for sure
The way Boa does that leg thing is so satisfying
Karina isn't just your typical main dancer she may be no better than hyoyeon and seulgi but she is karina and she dances like karina she has originality in her and I say it all the time but she is going to be the next taeyong a girl version of him their looks,dance,rap everything about them screams ACE!!
- This is just my observation, I watch a lot of dance videos in generals to improve my own dancing skills in general. I tried dancing to step back (as a 6'2" tall male it's a bit harder than I expected, but I tried my best to do as best as I can.) Don't take thie seriously, its just an opinion and no bashing. Honestly all of them are in my bias line from their respective groups, so why should I bash them.
If something sounds bashful, tell me nicely. Please give me some opinions too.
BoA- just a queen, hands down. She is such an insane dancer and for her first group performance, she blended in very well.
Karina - Honestly, I feel bad for her. She often times gets shit on, because people have way too high expectations for main dancers. They saw how talented ITZYs dance line is and said Karina is a bad main dancer.
I honestly prefer her dancing over Yeji's and Aespas underwhelming choreographies don't do her justice.
Seulgi - same with Karina, Red Velvet's choreographies just aren't good enough for her to show off. I once saw a video of her dancing to Make a wish with Taeyong and oh my gosh, she was so phenomenal.
Comfortable clothes and 'boygroup-ish' types of dances and Seulgi is showing off.
Hyoyeon - Honestly, I feel like she holds back in this stages. We all know, what a beast Hyo is, but in Step Back performances, she kind of is underwhelming to me. Maybe she just holds back to not outshine everyone, she has some bad days, or she doesn't like this choreography.
Sti Hyo is at the top of the best dancers and just this one era shouldn't define her dancing abilities.
Wendy - Honestly Lead Dancer material. She has so much stage presence and her skills are so solid, I honestly love her. She improved so much and seems so happy to be back on stage. A true, passionate idol. Stan Wendy.
Winter - One moment she slays, the other she is underwhelming (both in dancing and stage presence). Her strength definetly are her vocals. She probably was very tired too, because of the Dreams Come True promotions at the same time. I love her dancing, but I was kind of underwhelmed during Step Back, because we all know she can do better, if she wants to.
I love her leg moves during the pre chrous with the "LevEeeLLLL!"
She does it so smoothly.
Taeyeon - Fun Fact" The first video I watched of SNSD was "Lil Touch". I honestly thought she was the main dancer and she actually is a solid dancer. Step back is just too hard of a choreo (especially pre chorus and chorus). She didn't stand out much and most of the time was the only one, who didn't execute most of the moves like the others did, but still she didn't stand out in a bad way. She managed to blend in and had good presence.
Agree with everything minus the Yeji part hahahaha. Either way to each their own 😌
@@sseblante same lol
Thanks for sharing I love this kind of stuff!
I agree with most of your observations with the exception of Karina over Yeji, though that's a personal choice.
People think I'm crazy when I say I prefer Wendy's dancing over Seulgi's as well 🤣🤣🤣
GOT indeed helps Karina to showcase her dance ability more
Karina is so good
I really love wendy when she performs. She seems to enjoy so much and it's fun to watch her. Karina improved a lot too.
Karina definitely holds her own, it's time she got the recognition she deserves as a dancer
Karina Main Dancer 🤩
BoA is literally above everyone in this choreography, even Hyoyeon, as if it was made for her 👑
I’ve noticed that Seulgi has impeccable angles when she dances so she’s really satisfying to watch, Hyoyeon has really good body control (as seen in the fact that her body rolls are so dang good) and Boa is amazing at extension and using her whole body cohesively when she dances (she’s amazing!). Karina also has really good musicality. Wendy also impressed during her parts!! Center Wendy is amazing! I like the way she does the trio part the most all the way through because I feel like she rides the beat the most whereas Winter may be more precise, but she does it more robotically
yessss our dancing queen seulgi!!! she IS precision 🙌🙌🙌
0:56 OMG actually my eye caught wendy in here too, so she really was the best in that part
You said seulgi have a unique dance, cause she still practicing when everyone taking a break.. I'm not seulgi fans but i really really appreciated her
I'd say it again, Karina and Wendy are underrated dancers
I agree wholeheartedly! I've defended both Karina and Wendy on multiple occasions. People are convinced thru are weak dancers and they are soooo not weak dancers. They are much better than credited.
I’m obsessed with Hyo’s body rolls every time!!!!
For BoA's first dance practice video ever, I'm proud of her. 👑
2:36 how can she move like that??? She's sooooo good
For me, BoA, Hyoyeon and Karina really stood out
1:38 they look like they’re having so much fun here, that’s why i love this group haha
Wendy is my favorite since I really love her parts
Boa, Hyo, Karina and Seulgi QUEENS 😍
The way Boa moves just hits different for me 🤧🤧🤧
Hyo the nation's dancing queen for a reason
boa is such a queen tbh
Boa and Karina are my fav !
Seulgi is perfect
if there's anything i want for GOT, it's that newer international fans really get to know how insane, talented, and consistent boa is as an artist.
Wendy was sooo good
Karina great shape help her make big movements which looks really nice
I feel like this type of dance fits karina well, she have strong lower body and good at footworks the only prob is about her shoulders posture it's a bother coz it kinda bent.But It can be fix tho.
There’s no issue with her shoulders bruh
@@everythingsfinett3903 yes there is
@@everythingsfinett3903 u can barely see it bcs they dress her good. Or they make her hair cover it. But this savage era they make it look obvious. Look closely it's kinda bent. I know there's issue in her shoulder bcs we have the same.
@@SVIVI-rz1lv That’s just how her shoulders are naturally, not everyone has those 90° shoulders
@@everythingsfinett3903 yes that's just some back problems
Really Karina improves sm I'm really proud of her
BoA being 20+ years be an idol not for nothing, she is the queen of kpop for sure..
boa’s body placements are the best tho, her body’s never in awkward positions. she’s just a dancer
BoA at this age still be slaying, I’m not even 20 yet and I already have back pain
GOT made me a fan of Seulgi tbh. It's amazing how she and Karina can catch up with Hyoyeon and BoA's dance prowess. Performing with 2 legendary dancers isn't easy.
even boa is ageing her skills are just getting better every time love the queens
1:52 for me Karina is doing the best at this move
3:37 for me this part Karina and Boa did well the way they executed the step ang the rotation of their hips
I've noticed that so many people on youtube make dance's analysis for step back, but Seulgi always got the most best executed move in those videos.
It's because Seulgi is very textbook style. She is super clean and has perfect control of her body locks but lacks flexibility and if quite stiff around the hips and torso. But her execution is just👌
@@shujinko2944 sorry I meant her body locks are good.
How there's still People Who Says Karina is a weak main dancer
@@shujinko2944 she’s still a rookie so it’s very good sign. She’ll get there.
istg 4th gen stans need to stop discrediting karina's dance skills smh
I know this GOT is a rotational group, but I'm so obsessed with this lineup. Top notch dancers and top notch vocalists. I hope SM decides for GOT The Beat to record and perform more songs! 🙏🏿😭😭
I don't understand the Karina dance slander. I've always noticed she's such a good dancer and I'm not even a big Aespa fan. Imo the only time time where her dance ability is questionable is during pre-debut days when she danced with Kai and her solo debut teaser. After debut she ATE though🤷🏻♀️
The only person which astonishes me is Boa,cause I saw her for first time even after so many years her body in being perfect shape and moves crisp and sharp is a thing I can't help but appreciate so much.
Everyone else is either active in some way or are in active groups they are not the surprises for me but Boa is 😅
Will still mention Seulgi is my bias but many others at different time certainly made me distract from her.
Karina is a revelation, she needs some next choreo in her songs to blow us,always thought with Aespa why is she main dancer guess she answered with quite some intensity.😅
I just wanna bop bop to stepback
pun intended?
@@falsefaithyx obv
Hyo's body locks are just 🔥🔥🔥
2:35 karina is really a great dancer
people always bashing karinas dancing when really its just the concept sm has the girls doing here you can see she is not "stiff" at all
I wanna dance like Karina 😭
Love how boa blended with the group, I can imagine it being not so easy after all this time as a soloist
Seulgi, karina , wendy , hyoeyon , taeyeon , boa, winter
such iconic ladies, my god.
Pls watch Hyoyeon in Hit the stage and Dacing with the stars. She is queen
Queen BoA never disapointed
I was looking at winter the whole time in the official dance practice video bcz someone said that she look stiff and i can't unsee it💀 i expected to much from her but that can't change that she is technically good dancer. About Karina the only thing i can say is 'go girl, prove your position'
My girl Karina improved so much during this era. After all of the criticisms ( and probably some hate comments) she got before, seeing her shine even while being in the same frame as Seulgi and Hyoyeon makes me cry😭
Every time i see positive comments about Karina's dancing during this Step Back era, I remember the Reddit post which was about how satisfying it is seeing your faves improve and goddamn were they so right😭
Ok u can take the mic back now
So Hyo = body roll goddess
just noticed how difficult dancing to a choreo can really be omg
I have a love and hate relationship with BoA's execution in that move. Only she tries it but her legs/feet are too distant and asymmetrical.
Charisma/Stage Presence: BoA
Rap: Hyoyeon
Dance: Seulgi (She literally doesn't have a bad angle. She was the only one who did the "너 때문에 Border line" part well imo.)
Vocals: Idk lmao they all good
That's the point. People put others lead dancers of the 4th generation girl groups above Karina. But they do not realise she's THE MAIN DANCER. She's amazing, her technique is amazing. But just because her group doesnt have energetic choreos people think she's not good. Oh c'mon look at her
They have such iconic dance leaders
I thought it was strange winter not being at least in 4th position, she dances very well, but that doesn't mean anything either. As for Karina, it just proves that she really deserves the position of main dancer. (although underrated)
Yeah and she has a lead dancer position in aespa, expected a lot more from her
Wendy and Taeyeon are clearly stronger dancers than Winter.
@@eyebrowstj not really, winter has better technique than those two. Wendy=energy based
taeyon=hip and body lines are great
@@eyebrowstj Lol technique wise? No they are not
@@tyrannosaurus6328 Explain and describe about how winter's technique is better.
Love this concept of videos it’s really interesting
i was waiting for this thank you so much.
Hyoyeons body rolls are crazy
Wendy doesn't have a dance position in rv but stands out more than Winter, the lead dancer of aespa. she really is an ace
I agree. Wendy held her own next to BoA, Hyo, Seulgi, and Karina.
winter is still a better dancer but wendy has incredible stage presence, she always performs like she's so happy to be there
@@khyaeluvs3236
I disagree. I don't think Winter is a better dancer. Wendy clearly is a better dancer throughout this video.
@@eyebrowstj agree
@@eyebrowstj No technique wise Winter is better, she has a better body control overall.
The choreography for this song is so fun to watch. Your thoughts are interesting to know even if I don't understand much of what you say.
Karina might not be the best dancer here but I love her moves and posture
Karina proving she deserves the main dancer title in her group .
hyo's body control is insane
I love the intro, hehe VIVIZ Bop Bop's intro
Amazing!
4:00 so seulgi is the ending fairy
Hyeoyeon 💅
I'm not a dancer so my opinion is based on what I can notice. At least for me, BoA and Seulgi have similar dance styles while Hyoyeon and Karina both have a singular style. Is hard to say whose better from this, since you can see that sharp moves are better for Karina, specifics is more of Seulgi's thing, fast moves are better in BoA while Hyoyeon does better is smooth steps like body rolls. They really complement each other
Omg, Taeyeon's shoes so beautiful. Does anyone know the shoes' brand?
I’ve always had a question: Do certain clothes make a dancer look messy? If so what type of clothes?
Well maybe when you wear too big/loose clothes that covers your movements then it may look a bit messy, also tight clothes block movements which mostly end up with the dance looking half assed and not precised
Some maybe. Perhaps if they're a bit clunky or actually hard to move in? Or perhaps if the movement of the clothes ruins certain timing? I can't think of an example at the moment though sadly
You got a hawk eye for this vid.