The cameos ! Yes, SM used to do cameos of either their current (favorite) trainees or newly debuted groups. eg. Victoria in Replay, Minho in Gee, EXO in Twinkle. Like EXO were babies when Twinkle came out and it was a fun way to get them more exposure because SNSD were at the height of their career here. I, too, wish SM still did cameos because they're so fun ! Also, TaeTiSeo kills it always. Some of the best female vocal powerhouses in SM
Minho was actually in Gee, Chanyeol was in Genie, Exo-K were in Twinkle. I knew you were gonna lose your brain when watching Exo cameo in Twinkle. For TTS is one of the best subnit ever besides CBX. Both of their debut songs are my favorite. Also please check out TTS and Exo collaboration song "DJ got us fallin' in love". Exo and SNSD even had more stage together like "Marry you" and "Crazy in love". Also fun fact, Baekhyun and Taeyeon used to date.
TTS were THE GIRLS to me tbh. Taeyeon is my KING, but Seohyun is a close second. Her voice is SO FREAKNIG GOOD. Tiffany is Tiffany - she's so talented and her voice, GAH. These three honestly killed me as a sub-unit.
sm used to do cameos in their mvs to promote their rookie groups and it’s so fun. At first you drc bc you don’t know them but later on It’s like watching a sitcom and then they show the celebrity guest stars and you’re like “what are you doing here??????” LOL
GIRLLLL i had to drop everything when i saw this!!! cait thank you so much!! girls generation and tts have been such a big part of my kpop journey so i'm so happy you get to experience it too!!
Gurlll I thoroughly enjoyed this reaction. I loved when you discovered EXO members cameo in Twinkle.🤭 Would love to see your reaction to their “Dear Santa” mv (also has eng ver.)!!! Right in time for Christmas!!!! Lots of love 🫶🏼
I was about to have lunch and I saw the video notification and I put the food on the plate as quickly as I could hahaha That's the magic that Caitlin's videos bring 😆☺️
Loved this reaction, and you are right, the 3 are the vocal line from Girls Gen!! Taeyeon is the main vocalist, Tiffany & Seohyun are lead vocalist. They made a cover from Destiny Child, their version became really popular in Korea so I recommend this one.
You are not wrong with the Forever 1 resemblance, Forever 1 was an MV filled with hints and inspiration from their 15 year career, it's pretty much and MV made of the concepts of their previous MVs.
lollll gurl i had the same reaction when i saw chan i was like: ARIANA WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE?? It was so much fun seeing them appear one by one. also this song is great, snsd never disappoint with this vocals!!
Snsd is my favorite group and one of my favorite songs is Baby Steps by TTS, I'm simply in love with this song. As well as Adrenaline live ver and Winter Story (yes, a Christmas song, I love it). I recommend.
Hi Caitlin, Long time listener, first time caller here! Love that this dropped during my workout and gave me a boost I needed for the last 20 min. Anyways, I'm glad you picked up on twinkle and forever 1. F1 does have a lot of callbacks to their entire discography and I thought exactly the same when I saw some of the F1 sets. As for the cameos, it was so normal and just expected for SM to place a soon to debut trainee or a recently debuted artist (recording artist or actor) into another established artist's MV. A few examples are Shinhwa showing up on an SES MV, Yoona of SNSD popping up on an SJ MV, Yunho of TVXQ was on Dana's MV, etc. Basically if they put emphasis on someone other than the artist/s then we knew we would see more of them eventually. Also fun fact, Chanyeol and Minho showed up on SNSD's MVs b/c the girls really adore those guys and wanted to give them exposure (I forget where they said this , but it exists somewhere). SM eventually started to phase out the cameos about 10 yrs ago (of course there are exceptions) but I thought it was a fun way to get us hyped about a potential new artist.
I love tts and it's okay if you don't listen to the album but they do have some banger songs like adrenaline, baby steps, omg, stay, etc. So if anyone if interested in them after watching this reaction make sure to check those songs out 👍👍
I remember I watched all the live performances of Holler, even in the awards shows. I was obsessed! And I still remember all their outfits and the one where Taeyeon fall into that stage 🥲. It's one of my all time favortie song
When sm got trainees that are ready for debut they somehow make them into sm artists mvs. Like shinee minho in girls generation 'Gee', fx Krystal in shinees juliette, Irene in shinees why so serious, girls generations Jessica in shinees sherlock, aespas karina in taemins want. And exo members in twinkle. Prolly more than those but can't recall now.
Thank you for reacting to TTS! So fun watching with you. And this reminded me about EXO and TTS collaborations Crazy in love at an award show And DJ got us falling in love at an SM concert. Feel free to check it out if you want!
Bcs it's december, I recommend you their Christmas song called "Dear Santa" with the MV korean ver. & Eng version Anw, chanyeol also appeared in the girls' generation "Genie" japan version MV
The SM cameos were always so fun to spot in music videos 🥲 I feel like we get them slightly less regularly in recent years, but it does technically still happen!
sm music videos used to be like this where artists or trainees are like easter eggs in their senior's music videos! it's always fun to look at them, and the moment i realized you're watching twinkle i was like "oh, she's gonna freak out seeing exo"
MV cameos were normal for SM/kpop back in the day. Victoria, Jessica and Krystal have been in SHINee videos. Minho was in SNSD - Gee. Exo Members were in this. So On and So Forth. It was real fun times. lol.
I miss SM making their newly debuted or soon to debut idols feature on their current big names MVs. Yoona(SNSD) on Super Junior's U Irene(Red Velvet) on Henry's 1-4-3 Victoria (f(x)) on SHINee's Replay Minho(SHINee) on SNSD's Gee Baekhyun, Kai and Sehun(EXO) on TTS' Twinkle Chanyeol(EXO) actually appeared on two SNSD's MVs: TTS - Twinkle and SNSD's Genie (Japanese Version). Also I think Karina(aespa) was a backup dancer on Taemin's - WANT Jungwoo(NCT) on Yesung's (Super Junior) - Paper Umbrella Yeri appeared on Red Velvet's debut before being added to it. Some NCT members made cameos on other NCT MVs before making their debut: Winwin on Without You
Hi Caitlyn, I love your reaction 😁 Holler is my favorite of the TTS songs but it was Twinkle that made me really like TTS Thank you for your reaction, I hope you can react more to SNSD's songs because they are an amazing girl group ❤
You disrupted my morning routine. :P The second I saw you reacted to TTS, I was like, "oh my gosh, she's going to lose it" and had to drop what I was doing to watch. lol I'm so glad you had fun! They really do have insane voices! It's actually really funny to rewatch these because back when they first came out, I didn't know who the EXO boys were, but since they were given such a focus, I was like, "should I know who these boys are???" xD It was a great way to cross-promote artists!
😂😂 well if you say you can’t handle a whole mini album, I’ll just recommend one of their b-sides Adrenaline. It never fails to make me wanna get up and move
un/officially the positions went (1= lead 2=main 3=supp) 1.) taeyeon - leader/lead vocal 2.)tiffany-lead vocal (english translator) 3.)seoyeon- maknae main & supp vocal 4.)hyoyeon- lead dancer/lead rapper 5.)sooyoung- supp vocal/lead dancer -(japanese main translator) 6.)jessica- supp dance/ lead vocal(unoffically 2nd center 2nd 3ng translator) 7.)sunny- supp & main vocal (i call her the *center of the group* in skills) 8)yuri- main dancer /supp vocal /supp rapper 9.)yoona- center/ supp vocal/ supp dance (face of the group) ==not really sure cuz this is all from memory but ....
12:15 the reason why that doesn't happen anymore is because fans are so immature and crazy about idols interacting with the opposite sex. I mean fans were like that back in 2012 when Twinle came out too, but at that point EXO hadn't debuted yet
idk if anyone told you yet but Tiffany was in charge of most of the creative process for this comeback... she was choosing the looks, the sets and tons of shit... SHE WAS BUSY BUSY
Baekyeon was Taeyeon's secret BF at the time, or at least officially a year later. Why EXO? It was just before their debut. They used every one of these costumes over the course of their promotions, which ran a lot longer than planned. TTS was so successful they started promoting other songs from the EP, 2 of which can be heard at the beginning and end of the Twinkle MV. Holler was totally Tiffany's baby. She got nearly full control of everything, especially the wardrobe. Holler would have been a monster hit if not for the Kpocalypse (i.e. Sica-gate). The MV ends with a taste of Adrenaline and it's worth a watch.
It’s ok if you don’t reach to the album Caitlin, but at least watch the live stage for Adrenaline, it is a classic that you don’t want to miss I promise! Plus that was my favorite song out that album when it was released, so much fun!
This is the positions if they would be a group and not a sub-unit, Imo. Taeyeon: Leader, Main vocalist, FOTG Tiffany: Main rapper, Lead vocalist, Center Seohyun: Main dancer, Lead vocalist, Visual, Maknae
![Quando Rondo - Grow Up [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8zFnCg3BO4Q/mqdefault.jpg)
Holler live, Adrenaline live and Cater to You on Sketchbook! Ty, ty Caitlyn. TTS at Christmas Dear Santa is classic!
Up
UPPPP
Up up upppp
Uuuppppp
uppp
The cameos ! Yes, SM used to do cameos of either their current (favorite) trainees or newly debuted groups. eg. Victoria in Replay, Minho in Gee, EXO in Twinkle. Like EXO were babies when Twinkle came out and it was a fun way to get them more exposure because SNSD were at the height of their career here. I, too, wish SM still did cameos because they're so fun !
Also, TaeTiSeo kills it always. Some of the best female vocal powerhouses in SM
Sameeeeeeee I miss the cameos the last cameo we got was baby Karina in that Taemin song, Move, and that was both the mv and the music stages
not just within sm. A few exo members were in other artists mv such as Jin (lovelyz), Kwill, and Jo Kwon
there's a rumor that the new sm girl group will make a cameo in riize's next comeback, so excited for that
The Sica was in Sherlock and Super Junior M's Super Girl!
Seohyun in the Oh My Goddess! MV too~ ❤
The Twinkle MV is what made BamBam fall in love with Taeyeon, and honestly he's so correct for that LMFAOOOOO
LMAO
"Is that Chanyeol?! I saw his ears"😂
lol 😂😂😂
True that! 😂😂😂
Minho was actually in Gee, Chanyeol was in Genie, Exo-K were in Twinkle. I knew you were gonna lose your brain when watching Exo cameo in Twinkle. For TTS is one of the best subnit ever besides CBX. Both of their debut songs are my favorite. Also please check out TTS and Exo collaboration song "DJ got us fallin' in love". Exo and SNSD even had more stage together like "Marry you" and "Crazy in love". Also fun fact, Baekhyun and Taeyeon used to date.
They won soooo many awards for these songs! Best vocalists and performers in kpop. ❤
TTS were THE GIRLS to me tbh. Taeyeon is my KING, but Seohyun is a close second. Her voice is SO FREAKNIG GOOD. Tiffany is Tiffany - she's so talented and her voice, GAH. These three honestly killed me as a sub-unit.
TTS Dear Santa is a must reaction!
You think TTS had vocals in Twinkle and Holler?
Dear Santa is when they have fully developed their vocal skills.
OHHH.. YOU SHOULD LISTEN TO THEIR ALBUM.. ITS SOO FRICKIN GOOD.. YOU'RE NOT GONNA REGRET IT 👍🏻
YESSSS I STILL LISTEN TO THE ALBUM TO THIS DAY
sm used to do cameos in their mvs to promote their rookie groups and it’s so fun. At first you drc bc you don’t know them but later on It’s like watching a sitcom and then they show the celebrity guest stars and you’re like “what are you doing here??????” LOL
GIRLLLL i had to drop everything when i saw this!!! cait thank you so much!! girls generation and tts have been such a big part of my kpop journey so i'm so happy you get to experience it too!!
Gurlll I thoroughly enjoyed this reaction. I loved when you discovered EXO members cameo in Twinkle.🤭
Would love to see your reaction to their “Dear Santa” mv (also has eng ver.)!!! Right in time for Christmas!!!!
Lots of love 🫶🏼
The first and one of the most successful sub-unit ever created in kpop. Legendary
I was about to have lunch and I saw the video notification and I put the food on the plate as quickly as I could hahaha That's the magic that Caitlin's videos bring 😆☺️
Loved this reaction, and you are right, the 3 are the vocal line from Girls Gen!! Taeyeon is the main vocalist, Tiffany & Seohyun are lead vocalist. They made a cover from Destiny Child, their version became really popular in Korea so I recommend this one.
You are not wrong with the Forever 1 resemblance, Forever 1 was an MV filled with hints and inspiration from their 15 year career, it's pretty much and MV made of the concepts of their previous MVs.
lollll gurl i had the same reaction when i saw chan i was like: ARIANA WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE?? It was so much fun seeing them appear one by one. also this song is great, snsd never disappoint with this vocals!!
Now you know they always has the class that we're kpop proud of! The Girls' Generation!
Snsd is my favorite group and one of my favorite songs is Baby Steps by TTS, I'm simply in love with this song. As well as Adrenaline live ver and Winter Story (yes, a Christmas song, I love it). I recommend.
the best sub unit ever has arrived on caitlin's channel im so happy
Wow. Holler is really my favorite song from Holler album
Hi Caitlin, Long time listener, first time caller here! Love that this dropped during my workout and gave me a boost I needed for the last 20 min. Anyways, I'm glad you picked up on twinkle and forever 1. F1 does have a lot of callbacks to their entire discography and I thought exactly the same when I saw some of the F1 sets. As for the cameos, it was so normal and just expected for SM to place a soon to debut trainee or a recently debuted artist (recording artist or actor) into another established artist's MV. A few examples are Shinhwa showing up on an SES MV, Yoona of SNSD popping up on an SJ MV, Yunho of TVXQ was on Dana's MV, etc. Basically if they put emphasis on someone other than the artist/s then we knew we would see more of them eventually. Also fun fact, Chanyeol and Minho showed up on SNSD's MVs b/c the girls really adore those guys and wanted to give them exposure (I forget where they said this , but it exists somewhere). SM eventually started to phase out the cameos about 10 yrs ago (of course there are exceptions) but I thought it was a fun way to get us hyped about a potential new artist.
Girl I was singing at the top of my lungs during Holler LOL I love TTS so so much, it was literally so iconic when they first released these.
THIS WAS FOR ME, THANK YOU CAITLIN ❤❤❤❤
I LOVE YOU😭❤
Gosh! Now i missed TTS! hope they can comeback one day too.😊 indeed the most awarded kpop sub-unit for a female group❤
I love tts and it's okay if you don't listen to the album but they do have some banger songs like adrenaline, baby steps, omg, stay, etc. So if anyone if interested in them after watching this reaction make sure to check those songs out 👍👍
I remember I watched all the live performances of Holler, even in the awards shows. I was obsessed! And I still remember all their outfits and the one where Taeyeon fall into that stage 🥲. It's one of my all time favortie song
I didn’t expect that I need this reaction. Lol I love it Caitlin!! 🥰
When sm got trainees that are ready for debut they somehow make them into sm artists mvs. Like shinee minho in girls generation 'Gee', fx Krystal in shinees juliette, Irene in shinees why so serious, girls generations Jessica in shinees sherlock, aespas karina in taemins want. And exo members in twinkle. Prolly more than those but can't recall now.
You guys should check Holler live performance in You Hee yeol's Sketchbook. It"'s their greatest Holler performance ever!!!!
Twinkle is a bop! I just remember myself dancing to this song back then and its still a bop!
Thank you for reacting to TTS!
So fun watching with you.
And this reminded me about EXO and TTS collaborations
Crazy in love at an award show
And DJ got us falling in love at an SM concert. Feel free to check it out if you want!
UPPPPP!
thank you cait, now i got a reason to watch a reaction video cause it's SNSD! 🥰
omg, couldn't believe my eyes!!!! TTS the best unit and Caitlin my favorite reactor, never even dreamt that this could happen.
Bcs it's december, I recommend you their Christmas song called "Dear Santa" with the MV korean ver. & Eng version
Anw, chanyeol also appeared in the girls' generation "Genie" japan version MV
Enjoyed your reaction!! Brings back memories to when it first released and how I loved then and now. Such a classic piece for TTS!
"I saw his ears" yep that's my chanyeol 😂
Holler is a hidden GEM of a song
Fr. It's underrated. It doesn't get much appreciated as other songs when it has everything in it. Even the bsides are so good.
Gurll TTS- Dear Santa was the best vocally complex song they ever made😉 please check it out!
This sub-unit just insane, especially their live stage, you gotta watch i guess
I hope to watch TTS again and this time watch the song (Cater 2 U )and the song (Adrenaline)❤❤
All songs from Holler’s album are amazing! You need to hear it, i promise you’ll like the songs
If you ever check out Girls Generation Genie Japanese Version Music Video, Chanyeol is in it too. And he was a BABY. Like in his TEENS.
YOU GOTTA REACT TO “DEAR SANTA” - TTS PLEASE perfect reaction for this holiday season!!!!!!!
The SM cameos were always so fun to spot in music videos 🥲 I feel like we get them slightly less regularly in recent years, but it does technically still happen!
sm music videos used to be like this where artists or trainees are like easter eggs in their senior's music videos! it's always fun to look at them, and the moment i realized you're watching twinkle i was like "oh, she's gonna freak out seeing exo"
MV cameos were normal for SM/kpop back in the day. Victoria, Jessica and Krystal have been in SHINee videos. Minho was in SNSD - Gee. Exo Members were in this. So On and So Forth. It was real fun times. lol.
Since it's almost christmas, you should watch and listen "Dear Santa", it's really goooooood song and music video
I'm mentally preparing myself for this comeback cause wow😳
Since it's holiday season, u need to react their xmas song Dear Santa english version. Best intro in history!
I miss SM making their newly debuted or soon to debut idols feature on their current big names MVs.
Yoona(SNSD) on Super Junior's U
Irene(Red Velvet) on Henry's 1-4-3
Victoria (f(x)) on SHINee's Replay
Minho(SHINee) on SNSD's Gee
Baekhyun, Kai and Sehun(EXO) on TTS' Twinkle
Chanyeol(EXO) actually appeared on two SNSD's MVs: TTS - Twinkle and SNSD's Genie (Japanese Version).
Also I think Karina(aespa) was a backup dancer on Taemin's - WANT
Jungwoo(NCT) on Yesung's (Super Junior) - Paper Umbrella
Yeri appeared on Red Velvet's debut before being added to it.
Some NCT members made cameos on other NCT MVs before making their debut: Winwin on Without You
THANK YOU CAITLIN FOR THIS
their Live Performance was fire tho😘
Holler was one of my first kpop songs!!! so glad u reacted to it omg 🫶
Hi Caitlyn, I love your reaction 😁
Holler is my favorite of the TTS songs but it was Twinkle that made me really like TTS
Thank you for your reaction, I hope you can react more to SNSD's songs because they are an amazing girl group ❤
I’m so happy u covered them!! I love girls generation 🤭🤭🤭
thank you caitlin. you made my day!💗
Chanyeol also made a cameo in SNSD‘s Genie, the Japanese version iirc
You disrupted my morning routine. :P The second I saw you reacted to TTS, I was like, "oh my gosh, she's going to lose it" and had to drop what I was doing to watch. lol I'm so glad you had fun! They really do have insane voices! It's actually really funny to rewatch these because back when they first came out, I didn't know who the EXO boys were, but since they were given such a focus, I was like, "should I know who these boys are???" xD It was a great way to cross-promote artists!
As a nctizen, I recommend you to listen to TTS album too😂😂😂😂
QUEENS NEVER DIE
Hope to see your "Dear Santa" MV reaction!
I love seeing people’s reactions when chanyeol pop up while watching twinkle MV😂
😂😂 well if you say you can’t handle a whole mini album, I’ll just recommend one of their b-sides Adrenaline. It never fails to make me wanna get up and move
I miss TTS so much, I need my expensive queens back in kpop.
thank you for this reaction!!
SM really ate and still eating with those bridges
I miss tts so much thanks for u reaction ♥️
That's what I'm waiting for. Thank you Caitlin.
ADRENALINE JUSTICE! MY FAVE TTS SONG
you have to listen the 2nd mini album it so good!!
Hahahaha
I love your reaction
EXO are so baby in MAMA era
TTS SO GORGEOUS
Oh my god I never thought I would see Caitlyn react to tts😭😭
Pleaaaase watch their Karma Butterfly live on tokyo dome, its art
yass my girls TTS
It would be great if you could react to girls generation's solo debuts, they are too iconic ❤
Love TTS so much!
MY FAVOURITE GROUP EVER!!
I LOVE WHEN YOU REACT TO SNSD!!
the queens!!!👑
Chanyeol the hidden member of GG 😂 I remember chanyeol attending Tiffany's birthday with the GG members and its private too
un/officially the positions went (1= lead 2=main 3=supp)
1.) taeyeon - leader/lead vocal
2.)tiffany-lead vocal (english translator)
3.)seoyeon- maknae main & supp vocal
4.)hyoyeon- lead dancer/lead rapper
5.)sooyoung- supp vocal/lead dancer -(japanese main translator)
6.)jessica- supp dance/ lead vocal(unoffically 2nd center 2nd 3ng translator)
7.)sunny- supp & main vocal (i call her the *center of the group* in skills)
8)yuri- main dancer /supp vocal /supp rapper
9.)yoona- center/ supp vocal/ supp dance (face of the group)
==not really sure cuz this is all from memory but ....
TTS! WOO! ☺️
7:16 she exactly knows what this is all about
12:15 the reason why that doesn't happen anymore is because fans are so immature and crazy about idols interacting with the opposite sex. I mean fans were like that back in 2012 when Twinle came out too, but at that point EXO hadn't debuted yet
OH WOW I DID NOT EXPECT THIS FJSJXNKAJZ
OMG YES TTS
You need to listen to the 2nd mini album. One of the best minis I’ve heard.
"I saw his ears. THATS HIM!" 🤣🤣😭
idk if anyone told you yet but Tiffany was in charge of most of the creative process for this comeback... she was choosing the looks, the sets and tons of shit... SHE WAS BUSY BUSY
Holler live is insane
Baekyeon was Taeyeon's secret BF at the time, or at least officially a year later. Why EXO? It was just before their debut. They used every one of these costumes over the course of their promotions, which ran a lot longer than planned. TTS was so successful they started promoting other songs from the EP, 2 of which can be heard at the beginning and end of the Twinkle MV. Holler was totally Tiffany's baby. She got nearly full control of everything, especially the wardrobe. Holler would have been a monster hit if not for the Kpocalypse (i.e. Sica-gate). The MV ends with a taste of Adrenaline and it's worth a watch.
It’s ok if you don’t reach to the album Caitlin, but at least watch the live stage for Adrenaline, it is a classic that you don’t want to miss I promise! Plus that was my favorite song out that album when it was released, so much fun!
U NEEEEEEED TO SEE GIRLS' GENERATION'S GENIE AT THEIR PHANTASIA TOUR OR THEIR MADISON SQUARE GARDEN ONE!!!
I MISS TTS SO MUUUUCH
MORE SNSD AND TTS PLS🙌🏻🤭
YOU DID NOT JUST REACTED TO THE BEST GG SUB UNIT 😭😭😭 I LOVE YOU SO MUCH
H2O and bubbles! Caitlin’s favorite 😂
This is the positions if they would be a group and not a sub-unit, Imo.
Taeyeon: Leader, Main vocalist, FOTG
Tiffany: Main rapper, Lead vocalist, Center
Seohyun: Main dancer, Lead vocalist, Visual, Maknae
When I clicked this I was expecting her reaction to the EXO K cameos and girl you did not disappoint HAHAHA
Taeyeon is another ❤