I lived in Nashik for 3 years. Went to grape orchard and saw them dipping each of it into chemicals. I mean it’s so sad eating chemicals and thinking about the benefits of the fruit you consumed. Hope more farmers take up organic farming.
It's kinda sad that we'll probably never get to eat these good quality grapes even though we live in India. All the good stuff is being exported and the rest is being left for us
True. However, if the local market is willing to pay the premium price for the same grapes, we as farmers are more than happy to provide the quality produce ❤️. We are trying our best to divert our market preference locally, but the quality of our produce demands price premium.
Because one size doesn't fit all.. And quite bruising to all of the non-farmers who lo-lo-love those laws, the release of this report is just-another substantiation that Scroll® is not part of any "anti-national" whatchamacallit and the Messiah's henchpeople singling-it-out alongwith few others is just-another stamping of their despotism: Obviously the ideal for World's Largest Anocracy. Now back to your derivative topic: As I said, "one-size-doesn't-fit-all" so unlike the farm-laws would hope to make a reality, these farmers don't have to face ever-more-unrestrained Big Corporate with their only competition being a State-administered, regulated-market - even though it's the State which paradoxically gave unmatched upper-hand to all of the Big Corporate.
@@maazkalim Your first para was a comment on political policy and not much to do with farm laws, anocracy or not, and hence was irrelevent. Big corporate is everywhere and nobody can be assured a 100 percent market for their goods in this globalised world including MSME or any other big industry. One has to study the market and plan. The farmers shown here too aren't guaranteed a purchase but they chose risk weighing the reward and as stats show only 12 percent do qualify. The government is not forever obliged to purchase grains when their storage facilities are full. The farmers should grow that which is needed in market and they will get good earnings. Though this may take some time to get trained, its the best way forward.
First of all, Thanks a ton for your civil - if not polite, reply. Sincerely. It's so rare, that it's always refreshing when somebody talks in this way not just in any nook-&-corner of "RUclips® comments[-section]", but across the 'pop-Interweb' multiverse, "@@lolvivo8783". Yes, I see your point. I heard you. HOWEVER.. I disagree with your fundamental proposition THAT "Big Corporate" is everywhere. Need I expand on that? Since a-gain.. That might obligate me to go places where you may find that it's a “commentary on political policy” or something, in other words: No continuation of firmly burying one's hand in the sand. *The bottom-line:* Your assertion that Big Corporate has tapped into every single industry and/or line-of-trade there is and are being born, is false. As for the “globalised world”: Funny YOU say that.. Because it's exactly those kind of folks who go into such poetry of “globalised world” and all over economic-affairs that they also turn-out to be believers in anti-Globalist conspiracy-theories like "the NWO", "Illuminati" and what-not. Need I spell-out the label, even? And puh-lease.. In the jurisdiction where far too many of the populace goes hungry each day and night, this is obviously an incompetence that their godowns are “full”. So yes.. I do concur with you on quite the ancient State incompetence virtually everywhere. Since as somebody not just with indirect familial-agriculture background but also the one who still manages to follow the news, the abominable storage-conditions of storage and sheer wastage of the commodities is a recurring feature of [sociopolitical ]news-stories since past few decades before the existence of APMC because the buzz. However.. Your propagation of so-called "public choice theory" that the Big Corporate must be allowed to have untied-leash, like a Wild Wild West of Free Market Capitalism is, and I assert: Only predicated to have worse ramifications for not just farmers themselves, but even consumers. You sound like if there's no pre-existing place at the table for Big Corporate when that hasn't been the case. Untrue. And yes: Your assertion that all of the protesting-farmers are somehow growing unpopular crops and lentils and that's why require _their turf_ protected based on "demand _vs_ supply" is another deplorable assumption on your part. Lemme put it this way.. All industries are just not equal. Without going academic, whether it fits in your simplistic, theoretical worldview of binaries or not - is perfectly-irrelevant. So given how pertinent agriculture is to the very survival of Human Civilization, I say why not keep the door for both of the APMCs and the Corporates open?! Market-forces, right? If the Capitalists indeed do bring a lot more value to the table, then I'm sure the sellers would prefer them over the State-run APMCs? It's the basics of how incentives work.
@@mangeshchalan8786 Didn't Modi say that that Bill is needed for farmers to sell to anyone they want? Then how are these folks able to sell to whoever they like even without the Bill? If they can sell before the Bill is implemented, then what exactly is this new bill for? Does this mean that Modi was lying when he said farmers can sell to anyone they like without his bill?
I lived in Nashik for 3 years. Went to grape orchard and saw them dipping each of it into chemicals. I mean it’s so sad eating chemicals and thinking about the benefits of the fruit you consumed. Hope more farmers take up organic farming.
India fruits are the best quality in the world especially mangoes very sweet and juicy thus India is known as world 1 producer of mangoes
Great Happy to see commited people for
Quality produce from India 🇮🇳👏
Yet another great mini docu from scroll! Keep it up guys!
Thanks for the valuable knowledge
Great work .👏👏
Sharing, Justice and Peace for All.
I wait every Sunday for this bliss 😍
I need cuttings arra 33,34,32,35, 36, do you have???
What is the best time to place order ?
How do i contact you to learn this techniques of less chemical farming
So we export all the non toxic food to foreign land and we consome and toxic overused chemical ones.
Outstanding
Thanks for sharing
And helping farmers
Please do share health practices
I felt relaxed....💐
This seems if the produce has lot of crap leave it to indians they will eat for other countries they should be clean and good
I suggest they teach the methodology to other growers also
Opportunity costs..°
It's kinda sad that we'll probably never get to eat these good quality grapes even though we live in India. All the good stuff is being exported and the rest is being left for us
arid?
How come grapes exported have to meet very stringent FDA standards, while the Aam Aadmi in India gets whatever is grown. Double Standards as always.
True. However, if the local market is willing to pay the premium price for the same grapes, we as farmers are more than happy to provide the quality produce ❤️. We are trying our best to divert our market preference locally, but the quality of our produce demands price premium.
Rubi roman yacha bij kivha roop kute bhelet
Wonder why they are not at Singhu border protesting Modi's farm laws??🤔
Because they are doing what modi made the bill for! Direct selling! To whoever you want!
Because one size doesn't fit all..
And quite bruising to all of the non-farmers who lo-lo-love those laws, the release of this report is just-another substantiation that Scroll® is not part of any "anti-national" whatchamacallit and the Messiah's henchpeople singling-it-out alongwith few others is just-another stamping of their despotism: Obviously the ideal for World's Largest Anocracy.
Now back to your derivative topic: As I said, "one-size-doesn't-fit-all" so unlike the farm-laws would hope to make a reality, these farmers don't have to face ever-more-unrestrained Big Corporate with their only competition being a State-administered, regulated-market - even though it's the State which paradoxically gave unmatched upper-hand to all of the Big Corporate.
@@maazkalim Your first para was a comment on political policy and not much to do with farm laws, anocracy or not, and hence was irrelevent.
Big corporate is everywhere and nobody can be assured a 100 percent market for their goods in this globalised world including MSME or any other big industry. One has to study the market and plan. The farmers shown here too aren't guaranteed a purchase but they chose risk weighing the reward and as stats show only 12 percent do qualify.
The government is not forever obliged to purchase grains when their storage facilities are full. The farmers should grow that which is needed in market and they will get good earnings. Though this may take some time to get trained, its the best way forward.
First of all, Thanks a ton for your civil - if not polite, reply.
Sincerely. It's so rare, that it's always refreshing when somebody talks in this way not just in any nook-&-corner of "RUclips® comments[-section]", but across the 'pop-Interweb' multiverse, "@@lolvivo8783".
Yes, I see your point. I heard you.
HOWEVER.. I disagree with your fundamental proposition THAT "Big Corporate" is everywhere. Need I expand on that? Since a-gain.. That might obligate me to go places where you may find that it's a “commentary on political policy” or something, in other words: No continuation of firmly burying one's hand in the sand. *The bottom-line:* Your assertion that Big Corporate has tapped into every single industry and/or line-of-trade there is and are being born, is false.
As for the “globalised world”: Funny YOU say that.. Because it's exactly those kind of folks who go into such poetry of “globalised world” and all over economic-affairs that they also turn-out to be believers in anti-Globalist conspiracy-theories like "the NWO", "Illuminati" and what-not. Need I spell-out the label, even? And puh-lease.. In the jurisdiction where far too many of the populace goes hungry each day and night, this is obviously an incompetence that their godowns are “full”. So yes.. I do concur with you on quite the ancient State incompetence virtually everywhere. Since as somebody not just with indirect familial-agriculture background but also the one who still manages to follow the news, the abominable storage-conditions of storage and sheer wastage of the commodities is a recurring feature of [sociopolitical ]news-stories since past few decades before the existence of APMC because the buzz. However.. Your propagation of so-called "public choice theory" that the Big Corporate must be allowed to have untied-leash, like a Wild Wild West of Free Market Capitalism is, and I assert: Only predicated to have worse ramifications for not just farmers themselves, but even consumers. You sound like if there's no pre-existing place at the table for Big Corporate when that hasn't been the case. Untrue. And yes: Your assertion that all of the protesting-farmers are somehow growing unpopular crops and lentils and that's why require _their turf_ protected based on "demand _vs_ supply" is another deplorable assumption on your part. Lemme put it this way.. All industries are just not equal. Without going academic, whether it fits in your simplistic, theoretical worldview of binaries or not - is perfectly-irrelevant. So given how pertinent agriculture is to the very survival of Human Civilization, I say why not keep the door for both of the APMCs and the Corporates open?! Market-forces, right? If the Capitalists indeed do bring a lot more value to the table, then I'm sure the sellers would prefer them over the State-run APMCs? It's the basics of how incentives work.
@@mangeshchalan8786 Didn't Modi say that that Bill is needed for farmers to sell to anyone they want? Then how are these folks able to sell to whoever they like even without the Bill? If they can sell before the Bill is implemented, then what exactly is this new bill for? Does this mean that Modi was lying when he said farmers can sell to anyone they like without his bill?