The History of Transgenderism | Helen Joyce
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 апр 2024
- In this video, Helen Joyce breaks down the history of transgenderism.
Helen Joyce was Britain Editor at The Economist, where she worked for over 15 years before she
joined the gender-critical campaign group Sex Matters as a director. She is the author of Trans:
When Ideology Meets Reality.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Conversations feature John Anderson, former Deputy Prime Minister of Australia, interviewing the world's foremost thought leaders about today's pressing social, cultural and political issues.
John believes proper, robust dialogue is necessary if we are to maintain our social strength and cohesion. As he puts it; "You cannot get good public policy out of a bad public debate."
If you value this discussion and want to see more like it, make sure you subscribe to the channel here: / @johnandersonconversat...
And stay right up to date with all the conversations by subscribing to the newsletter here: johnanderson.net.au/contact/
Follow John on Twitter: / johnandersonac
Follow John on Facebook: / johnandersonac
Follow John on Instagram: / johnandersonac
Support the channel: johnanderson.net.au/support/
Website: johnanderson.net.au/
Podcast: johnanderson.net.au/podcasts/
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
x.com/HJoyceGender
- A child cannot buy cigarettes until he is over 18 years old.
He cannot get a tattoo until he is over 16 years old.
He cannot drink alcohol until he is 21 years old.
- He cannot enter nightclubs until he is over 18 years old.
- He cannot open a bank account on his own until he is over 18 years old.
- Only someone over 16 years old can drive a car.
He cannot vote or play a political role unless he is 18 years old.
But he can undergo a gender reassignment, take medications, and undergo surgery between life and death at the age of 12 years.🤪😆
It is insane to believe that a kid has the same reasoning as an adult.
There is an agenda behind this from the Western Govts of the world. Pushed by the WEF etc.
Your problem as it does not affect my group. So 😆.
Are we living out a movie scene ?
Idiocracy
It’s soo good when someone like this wonderful lady can articulate perfectly what most of us feel about this ideological movement called transgenderism but can’t articulate! Bravo!
If there has always been trans people, how did they manage before people started wearing clothes?
The 🐂💩 does not work if you ask questions. You suppose agree to everything without thinking and call anyone who does not agree to current talking point s as anti-XYZ.
That's transphobic!
Why doesn’t someone conduct and deep investigation into the adults who aren’t having transgender feelings but who promote it in vulnerable children. They are the serious issue here.
Munchausen by proxy moms.
Because those very ones are in the ruling class, the men with a tr@nsvestic f3tish. The recrutiment of children normalizes the f3tish, allows them to pass it off as what it's not; and makes their f3tish look "venerable."
💰 🗣️ 🐂💩 🚶🏼♂️
I've met three very disturbed single-mothers in recent years who were proudly transitioning their sons.
It's revenge against the fathers by proxy and it's encouraged!
I've never seen a venerable child. I don't believe they exist.
Confusion is not a bug, it’s a feature. By keeping people confused, you make them vulnerable to influence.
This is classic cult programming. Destabilize the target, break down their identity, then rebuild their identity as a member of the cult.
What a brilliant succinct statement of the madness we are all supposed to follow.
(Contrast that with the verbal fumbling that happens whenever an activist is asked to define a woman.}
And if the can't define a woman why bother changing to one ,which brings us back to leftist agenda .
its really easy to understand. cosmetic surgery clinics and the mental health industry are making a fortune from it
But, why are people who gain nothing from this, i.e. activists, pushing it so hard? What is their motive?
@@scottshanahan3827 FITH syndrome
Stupidity@@scottshanahan3827
Years ago these people would keep quiet and not get militant and be tolerated with humour .Now they get up everyone"s nose and are completely ridiculous .
Years ago, it was some girls teasing a guy to wear dresses. A guy letting a Tomboy be rough, as they understand and can be trusted enough to not report each-other for some rough and tumble as they understand eachother's status and character.
It's all about the $ !!!!!. Pharmaceutical companies want your $. Plain and simple.
Yeah, I learned that the hard way. I was way worse on psychiatric drugs than I have ever been. But, they've 'normalized' it now that if you have any problem, just take a pill and our treatments.😮
Wonderful coherent woman. So reassuring to know people like her exist.
"We have to accept it"? What kind of answer is that? She answered nothing but complacency and I can't agree with that.
Comes from LGBT ideologists Foucault and Judith Butler .
I'm amazed at how easily adults on the left go along with prevailing thought, so just think about kids on Social Media who are even more easily influenced. It shows something about human nature that it has gone this far with very few adults being skeptical enough to make sure kids are getting solid medical treatment. They're so afraid of being a bigot, being called a bigot they sat on their hands.
I mean, it is hard to go against it. We live in pressuring environments, Even something as precious as love and relationships often happen because of the social pressure somebody else started, or astrology is another possibility.
One of the great features of RUclips is the ability to select Do not recommend channel. What have these people ever done to you?
Trans 30 years ago was one in 4000 mainly in males. Femininity in men and masculinity in women
She did not answer the question. "When did this begin?" What time, what period in time?
Pre history gods.
All ancient religions had "trans" beings.
No confusion here. Gender is a function of grammar where nouns are either male or female - a la francaise! Simples.
😆. What happened to you people in the cave? You guys came out of it weird.
Jenner a 6-4 dudes puts on a playboy bunny costume…he’s lost his mind.
And wins a woman's prize on a magazine cover after a year. Pity the poor woman who slogged out periods, cramps, pregnancies for 50 years.
@@carolynbrightfield8911 You've reminded me that I was blocked for a time by a Canadian morning tv show hosted by Tracy Moore. Her guest in 2023 was 'Trans Woman' Jamie Pandit. (You can surely find 'her' online presence.) /I'd watched Tracy's segments for a few years, and saw her as a genuine champion of Women - of all the varieties we females are. Seated in Tracy's live studio audience were authentic women. Mothers, maybe some who had miscarried, or battled with IVF, Grandmothers, immigrant women - some whose hard work showed in their faces and bodies. /I wrote that the show had this audience clapping Jamie Pandit like 'performing seals'. Jamie - looking Hollywood to 'her' last eyelash - tearing up about the process of explaining his transexual identity to his conservative Indian parents. How hard that journey had been. To my eye, an immensely expensive amount of plastic surgery had created this vision before us. We were treated to lots of glossy images and fashion shoots from Jamie's RUclips channel. So, a person who is monetising their trans identity as a career! /Tracy interviewed Jamie with great support and empathy. I was not insulting or abusive in what I wrote. But I WAS struck by the deep incongruity of an audience, with the lived experience, compelled to applaud an exceptionally attractive, Hollywood version of a woman. /I felt disappointed that noone from the show would have any communication with me. Just summarily blocked. It was kind of shocking at the time.
at this point im suprised when comments are actually on for yt videos of non left wing views or facts. so far today most of the interesting things ive clicked on have had comments off on channels that never do that themselves. yt has really been working on the next level of shutting down comments and discussion or the social aspect of their media.
Oh yes, I have had many comments mysteriously deleted.😮
I am not being funny here, it's a genuine compliment, I hope: John seems to me to be one of the best listeners I've come across in the RUclips/Podcast world.
Good point what she said at the end there!
Why would you have to modify your body if your body doesn't say anything about your "identity"?
Doesn't make any sense.
18 years. Why does the government make the law that a child shouldn’t make an adult decision until they turn 18! Why? Is it because children must grow up and mature to make sensible decisions? Our children have to learn from their parents. Certainly adults. The law needs to protect the sane
Rough approximation . Well said .
Tough topic, interesting discussion
Less a history and more a status quo of things. But I am here for it.
Keep fighting the good fight you two...spread this as far as you can. Tides are going to turn if they haven't already. John, I've been an interested observer since first running across your videos. 👍
The world is crazy to put a finer point on it
Stimulus + Reward = Learned Behavior
Thank you.
If you are not allowed to question it, it is not science but dogma.
Excellent summary and articulation, Helen & John
Short version, they're in sayn. ( need to spell or utube cancels you)
There are a lot of worried "doctors" around the world right now I guess and rightly so.
That is the real issue - the fact that feminine and masculine traits exist in all people. Sexuality is a secondary issue depending on how far those feminine or masculine traits carry them. Tomboys and sissies were the terms back in the day. That said, you cannot hide from your biological gender. The argument is a spiritual one. The Indians refer to the "two-spirit" individual. In Zen, yin and yang. Honestly, the semantic debate is utterly ridiculous.
Is it only me that feels so much disgust+fear at the sight of them, and don't get it why this monstrosity is being promoted and celebrated worldwide???
No. We evolved to feel off-put by anything in the uncanny valley. Maybe if you felt those things from seeing some completely normal-looking dude who just says the words "I'm trans," you'd be in the wrong... maybe. But you're definitely not a bigot for following your own genetic programming.
Remember Anderson old mate it was your LNP mates rooting in the "Prayer room" at Parliment House..
Sounds like a gnostic belief…
The new religion of the state along with the other one of whyte privetage. Unfortunately miss spellings are good now. If the state can get the populus to believe in those two things, then we will believe anything.
That last little bit about how we're not supposed to understand it and we're supposed to just accept it sounds a lot like religion.
My bad. I thought this was a History of Trains. Can I have my sanity back please?
Oh, I thought you were going to take us back millennia in history, and not just skim over the very recent developments as you've done here. The fact is, we're dealing with a very ancient phenomenon. The character, Baphomet, for example, is typically depicted as androgynous, and the satan worshipers seem to love that sort of thing.
No, you haven't even scratched the surface here, and my guess is that you very much don't want to.
First it was steam trans, then diesel and finally electric trans. Bullet trans will be handled in another episode.
Magnus Hirshfield.
Thats where it all starts.
You can mock God’s design but God will not be mocked!
His creation of male XY and female XX made in God’s image is Holy.
Exactly! "For God is not a God of confusion but of peace". 1 Corinthians 14:33 The XX, XY model has served humanity for millenia throughout the entire world. Why is it an issue now all of a sudden in areas that are supposed to be the most advanced?
@@ncrob391 Communist Takeover / WEF.
Once Christian countries have turned away from God.
i love that you think that tans is a cult when you start preaching from the bible, which is also a cult
@@johnnybertrand2039 When did I say trans is a cult?
@@johnnybertrand2039 As clear as the nose is on your face, after your death you will kneel before God, Jesus Christ and give an account to Him of your every word and deed - He is your Judge - Jesus Christ will decide your eternity.
Our society is doomed.
All brought to you by the small hat club member Magnus Hirschfield
Trans means whatever satan wants it to mean, so long as it is against Yeshua.
And almost in totality, the whole kerfuffle is RUBBISH.
All people have masculine and feminine traits. Our true identity comes from God. We were created in God’s image.
Baphomet
My whole family took a tran across country and enjoyed all the different views... oh, wait, I mean train. Never mind.
Research neo-Gnosticism.
Don't forget Marx and Soros.
This is just a fad...Complete nonsense never stick...
Imagine getting so worked up over someone else’s personal decisions about themselves 😂😂
No one cares.. but they have to tell everyone that they’re special..
Sin is SIN !
'History of Cross Dressers' is more accurate title
Cosmetic surgery.😢
don't feed the demon and move on, simple as that😶
Golly does she distort the argument, or what?
i can tell you about all this, both as a trans person and a scholar. first all, i doubt any of you know anything about the civil war!. second, "the west" is a completely new development compared to the rest of the world, which the WHOLE world has always had transgender people, since pre-civilizations. trans people were part of shaping civilization itself. the thing about the "west", is that its attempts to nationalize race, "gender", and everything is based on archtyple constructive powers of classifying the objective natural world. that's what english is, a language of classifying the natural world. but the "west" and king james english is focused on male virility and contempt for "feminine" powers. the northern west, germanics, russians, their history is the ONLY people who don't have a transgender social history, in the entire world. that is due to 1. harsh environments that are difficult to "cultivate" 2. the relatively small and isolated environment as compared to the rest of the civilized world. 3. the psychology of "caves" and insurmountable mountains 4. the need to utterly destroy the natural world.
it all comes down to "scarcity". but here we are, in the most developed and advanced, and RICH country in the world, and its still a young "national" development, with all that convenience, access, wealth, comes the feeling of "scarcity". our population is reverting or regressing to older ways. people behave like toddlers. WE use to "cultivate" this country.
in the end, you are you, and trans people are trans people. the sexes are real. so is gender. you can spin it however you want. doesn't change nature though.
im not gettting into my college access of trans studies around the world. there were heaps of them. "MOUNDS", but it included the chinese.
Ergi (noun) and argr (adjective) are two Old Norse terms of insult, denoting effeminacy or other unmanly behaviour. Argr (also ragr) is "unmanly" and ergi is "unmanliness"; the terms have cognates in other Germanic languages such as earh, earg, arag, or arug, among others
It’s a disgrace
Overthinking
I wish you weirdos would just stop stalking us and go live your own obviously fabulous lives.
Just like religion and politics. Don’t ask questions just accept it.🫤
It all started in a sanatorium, obviously.