I would just like point out that Pearl was TOTALLY SNUBBED during her snatch game because her Big Ang was HILARIOUS and now I feel justified. Also, I didn't think Bosco or Lady Camden were bad. I've been saying the 'adjacent' line this past week. lol
Big Ang was AWESOME and from what we saw, it seemed like she belonged in the top with Ginger and Kennedy over Katya. But the Snatch Game was pretty darn good.
I get that season 5 is iconic but I’m not at all surprised at it having the worst snatch game by your laugh count. Detox pissing on the floor and Alyssa having to formally apologize makes the snatch game absolutely abysmal by itself
@@antoineleclerc5638 That might just be personal preference honestly! Maybe its just not the smartest move to make in front of a large audience, because a lot of people don’t like it. I personally don’t find piss or fart jokes funny at all, so the Daytona Winds episode on Season 14 really didn’t amuse me at all😂
Alexis really had me cracking up with her Walter Mercado I really wish it wasn't the start of the if you're not the top you're in the bottom nonsense for the season 😭
LITERALLY like im so glad AS6 didnt do that for it's snatch game, imagine if the placements were like WIN- Shea (i think she did really well so im not gonna argue with her win) HIGH- Jujubee, Alexis LOW- Blair BTM2- Cracker and India
I hope I don't sound ridiculous but... Camdem's Shakespeare wasn't that bad, if they wanted to, she could've been edited funny. I mean, the delivery wasn't there, but the jokes were funny and her being the parody of the parody has proved in the past to be safe worthy. 🤷♂
it's probably to save willow and daya from the bottom, since they were the obvious lows next to jorgueous, and we know that she would exterminate any of them
It’s unfortunate that editing so strongly influences how we view snatch game. Multiple queens on season 5 and 8 have come out and said that Coco and Derrick were hilarious, and we just didn’t see that at all in the final product
This is also why it wasnt really properly explained why Tayce was top and Awhora bottom on the UKS2 Snatch Game.. Lots of Tayce was cut out, the bad bits of Awhora not shown
I genuinely think that they sabotaged the queens this week. I found myself laughing when there was that stupid "this sucks" sound effect that they used. RuPaul knows how to turn on the fake laugh and she deliberately chose not to. They wanted some lip sync smackdown from the beginning and saw the opportunity even though there was a clear bottom two in my opinion.
@@yupthatsme5257 There were funny jokes, but even so, a lot of the moments get cut out. The game lasts much longer than 12 minutes. Angie talked about doing all of Tammie's famous quotes, something that would usually appear in the final cut, but not a single one made it in
@@feliperissoli5319 I thought Jasmine because she had no jokes imo and Willow for similar reason along with her not doing her research. That was embarrassing.
Completely agree. One of the reasons I strongly dislike UK Season 3's Snatch Game as a whole. Everyone was asked to change their characters when Ru spoke to them in the work room (except we didn't see footage of Krystal or Vanity), and the only girls that didn't change their characters ended up in the bottom.
I thought Daya’s Ozzy, Camden’s Shakespeare, and Boscoe’s Gwenyth had AT LEAST one joke I really laughed at. It wasn’t good overall, but I can’t help but wonder what’d it feel like without production forcing the “terrible” storyline
Did you consider doing a "Laughs per minute" calculation to account for seasons with less time? Great video, but I'm wondering if the rankings would have been different. For ex: on season 6 they only got 20 laughs but it was 6 mins long (on youtube) vs season 14 which was 14 minutes long and got 25 laughs. If you divide the laughs for season 6 - 20/6 you get 3.3 laughs per minute. If you divide the laughs for season 14 - 25/14 you get 1.8 laughs per minute. This maybe shows why this felt like such a flop. we had a lot less laughs per minute we spent watching it! Thanks for compiling all the info and watching these all again for us!
Absolutely agree, and they even mention the problem with different video lenghts at the start of the video. I generally don't think that just counting Ru's laughs per game (or even per min) is the best heuristic. 1. As they said: sometimes Ru laughs AT the Queens and not with them. Laughter has a social context. 2. Sometimes she'll laugh genuinely as well even though the camera cuts to the guest judges. Excluding them doesn't seem right. Even if Ru didn't laugh then - seeing guest judges laugh makes it funnier for us viewers as well. I think a mere quantitative analysis will always fall short (and a qualitative approach would be suited better).
I’m convinced Willow manifested this edit when she said they were all performing so strong that one week they were all going to suck. I’m sure producers were losing their shit over the possibility of that many bottom placements. It’s a stage with no audience so no background laughs, Ru is refusing to laugh I’m sure they put the pressure on them and made the atmosphere so dead none of them could make any jokes land past a certain point
I appreciate the effort that went into this, my goodness! I’m so excited to see the if season 14 was judged fairly video when that time comes ahahahahaha
I think every season was judged fairly. You guys just want a fan fav to win for some reason. Regardless, if it was judged as it should be or not, the placement of any Queen is fair and so is the elimination. They signed up for exposure and their careers to be taken to the next level not really to be America's next Drag Superstar. It's just something they threw in to keep the stakes, tension and drama at all time high
@@blaze56701 Seasons 1-14 and all International spinoffs as well as All-stars 😇😇. I want you to name a Reality TV show competition that is fair?? It has no influence by production or anything and has no cast members speak out on things production turns a blind eye
Getting put in the bottom for a joke working so well that it made her want to keep doing it when other queens got zero jokes across is still crazy to me.
Imo this ranking system is flawed, since some snatch games have more queens, therefore sometimes having an advantage or disadvantage, and also sometimes rupaul gives pity laughs like when they're presenting themselves
Also I know there was the disclaimer but the fact that *all* the early seasons were in the bottom (even S5) in terms of number of laughs really shows that Ru has been slowly amping up his laughter even if the performance didn't really warrant it.
I mean he’s not a statistician but he could have just normalized the results to account for differences in time and in the number of queens.. It’s just a simple division
In defense of s5: it’s been revealed by queens on the season Alaska was great but almost all of it got cut because of how Blue her Lady bunny was. There’s some missing laughs there
@@antoineleclerc5638 blue humor is when someone’s jokes involve sex, swearing, toilet humor, etc. and is therefore is too risky to put on TV or it will scare off the advertisers
I think Snatch Game is seen as "good" not because there aren't any bad queens, but because there is a nice mix of REALLY good and REALLY bad queens. Season 14 may have apparently gotten more laughs, but none of them really stood out as especially good or even horrifyingly bad, just boring and bland, and even Deja has not much quotable, apart from the "Yeah".
I think Bianca Del Rio's Judge Judy is the most overrated snatch game performance of all time. People love to give Silky shit saying she was just playing herself when she did TS Madison, but Bianca was playing herself when she did Judge Judy so what's the difference between the two of them
I feel like the best snatch games find that happy medium between queens cosplaying other people while just acting like themselves vs acting like the celebrity and forgetting to make it funny. That’s why I think many people see Kylie’s Dolly as successful, Bianca as Judge Judy, and Jinx’ Judy Garland. 1) because you could see these queens saying/doing any of their one liners from snatch game sincerely and 2) it’s absurd to think of their character/celebrity doing or saying that, then it becomes funny.
Say what you want about Chi Chi on Allstars, but her "the caged bird sings because...I don't know why the caged bird sings" will always be funny to me. And I think she could have played out the fact that she didn't really know who she was trying to impersonate (similar to how Blue did a dirty Mary Berry).
The second hand emabarrassment I got from watching this snatch game was so strong that I almost couldn't finish it. Thank god for the speedy montage at the end.
Only 8 minutes into this, I could be wrong but I’m pretty sure Ru laughs at Jaidynn’s intro. I really feel like this isn’t a great system to use cuz there’s like, courtesy laughing, nervous laughing, along with a bird sounding laugh (Ru’s reaction to “a sensible 74”) that is worth way more to me than a giggle to me (reaction to Karen’s “bout an 11”). I’d kinda like to know the counter for awkward silence/Ru going “okay…alright” to signal an unfunny joke, but I know it’s hard to quantify these things. Edit: Just checked, Ru doesn’t laugh at Jaidynn but he does shout “OH MY GOODNESS!” I’d give that a half a point but I’m generous
For me I didn’t think the snatch game was ‘bad’ but I felt a lot of the performances were simply just average which made Deja stand out further. But I think it was also edited to give no one laughs simply for this gag of the lip sync battle.
i'm glad we as a fandom all agree that Bosco's Kumbucha joke was funny and Ru not laughing at it was bizarre. like hello??? this isn't another "Charity Kase your verse about being a bottom is so dirty :(" moment is it
Fun to see how this criteria shakes out, though a laugh can mean a lot of things. How loud was the laugh? Was it with or at the queen? How clever or unique is the point of view of the performance? Did they transcend the game? A hard thing to quantify but I appreciate your effort here. Thanks!
I honestly cracked tf up at Bosco's cumbucha joke, like so loud and so long. I don't get why there weren't laughs at that joke. I definitely think they were set up to not think they were doing well cause there were some decent jokes in there. Not the best snatch game but definitely better than it was made out to be.
I believe that a LaLa PaRuza was planned from the start of the season and the producers just waited for a challenge where people didn’t do GREAT to put everyone in the bottom
also the season 14 queens were definitely given a different runway category, I assume so Michelle could be like "this doesn't scream holy couture" if needed to. Just use the original category!
I have only one thing to say: "I've Got a Lovely Bunch of Coconuts". There is nothing like this sentence and also the one of Jinx who took an obscure character and started blabbering on about cat food And delaaa with the weird imitation of MAGGIE SMITH was genious
I understand that this was just a project to do that wouldn't conflict with your riggory of S14 video, but I disagree with this criteria being used to judge Snatch Games. You mention multiple times in the video that editing of Snatch Games has changed over time, which has definitely included an increase in laughs to make Snatch Game more entertaining. The editors have simply gotten better at editing to make it entertaining. So why would the Season 14 cast getting more laughs be indicative of how they performed? If they wanted to make it obvious that everyone bombed, they would have edited all laughs out entirely, so I think they were throwing us a bone by keeping in the laughs that Ru would force in the first place so that we were entertained. You also show how mediocre Snatch Games have gotten way more laughs than you'd expect throughout the video, which literally just proves that laughs have nothing to do with how good a Snatch Game performance is. I agree that there was probably some producer meddling going on to make Ru not respond to decent jokes, but I bet they told him to do that once they saw how bad some queens were doing. If it was the plan from the beginning, why would Ru know to laugh at DeJa's jokes?
Yeah. It simply doesn’t prove his point that basically the S14 Snatch Game was “rigged”. It is just indicative of how prominent RuPaul’s laughs are nowadays. The better metric of good snatch games is fan reception, not this kind of criteria.
They didn't just spontaneously add an entire lipsync smackdown episode because they realized right there that the queens are bombing. This was all planned well ahead. But I agree that laughs are not indicative of how good or bad a snatch game is. This S14 snatch game is objectively bad (largely due to the editing to give the impression of bombing), so that making into #10 doesn't make sense anyway. The criteria are not correctly chosen.
@@babayevsky i would describe the Snatch Game as extremely mediocre. The performances weren’t really bad, but they were not good at all. I honestly don’t think it was that difficult for the producers to make this snatch game “look bad”.
Agree. RuPaul is forcing more laughter for favored queens period in funny challenges, not just in the snatch game. It's not just the length of the segment that has changed, but also the amount of organic laughter from Ru. Maybe there should have been a poll, and it should have been considered how much the guests laughed too, since maybe they're reactions are more organic.
This is so interesting!! It really shows how everyone can judge snatch game so differently. I prefer the seasons with only a couple solid performances as opposed to one superstar icon level performance, just bc I like the queen to queen interaction and I think that’s where some of the best bits come from!
For people who are curious about where the AS7 Snatch Game falls on the list, I did the math: The game had a total of 77 laughs, snatching the 1st place on the list. If maybe you want to consider as two different snatch games because of the break to change characters, the 1st half had 37 laughs (getting the 5th place) while the second half had 40 laughs (getting the 4th place). LAUGH COUNTER: Jinkx: 21 laughs (5 + 16) Trinity: 14 laughs (4 + 10) Monet: 10 laughs (7 + 3) Jaida: 10 laughs (9 + 1) Raja: 7 laughs (4 + 3) Shae: 6 laughs (4 + 2) Viv: 5 laughs (3 + 2) Yvie: 4 laughs (1 + 3)
Great video, I don’t agree with the ranking criteria though. If one person gets 100 laughs but everyone else in that season gets none, that snatch game could easily go up the ranks. What makes a good snatch game good imo is when the majority of contestants do well overall. Otherwise statistically Deyja would be an outlier
Conspiracy theory: they thought up the lipsync episode twist before the season ever began, and purposefully 'ruined' the snatch game to A) generate all of this press which really worked, and B) justify another non-elimination episode & incorporate this pre-planned twist. How? well, an easy way to tank someone's improv performance is cut their thinking time. We don't know how much time they usually get to answer questions, but I have a hunch it's been slowly getting reduced over recent years as the snatch games are getting longer (so ru doesn't have to stand around as long) - the producers could have purposefully given these queens significantly less time so they had less chance of thinking up a funny answer (potentially why Daya was copying Bosco's answers, and how many of the queens jokes didn't fit the question in one way or another) ru could be purposefully not laughing at jokes to sell the storyline, and demoralise the queens into giving worse performances over the course of the snatch game. Maybe a condition of Daya's non-elimination was that she had to copy someone's answers if she got to snatch game? Who knows? That's why it's a conspiracy
I’m not inclined to get on board with conspiracies and claims of riggory. But something was definitely up. They had the rights cleared for 5 songs. Carson & Ross were both booked to shoot that day. And a pit crew member was there who presumably had to be medically cleared ahead of time. It’s hard for me to believe they pulled all that together overnight or even with a couple days, depending on the shooting schedule. That being said, it was a pretty bad SG in terms of its mediocrity. So maybe the opportunity for this type of drama just presented itself & they ran with it 🤷🏻♂️
I think this snatch game suffered from being Cheryl Hole’s favorite word, mediocre. Nobody pulled a Utica or a Gia or an Aiden, so it was hard to judge. And Deja absolutely was the best, but it felt more along the lines of what usually is the 2nd or 3rd best performance. It did feel like a setup though because I guess RuPaul forgot about the “Yes, and” school of acting cuz she didn’t give them ANYTHING to go off of.
Girl take off Deja and you get 12 laughs total. That's not a Top 10 SG. Also, you could've considered the duration of the SG as well to make it more accurate
I think a lot of S14’s laughs from Ru were out of pity, not from the queens being funny. Also, I genuinely laughed out loud at Deja everytime she said “YEAH”
it definitely could have been better, but i honestly don’t think Camden, Bosco, Angeria or Daya did bad enough to warrant a lipsync. I think it’s obvious that editing played a huge part (Angeria’s post seems to point this out) but if i were to judge it i’d say Deja gets the win no high queens Camden, Angeria, Bosco and Daya are safe Jorgeous is low (Bosco could go here to ig but there was at least one good joke even if it didn’t land) Willow and Jasmine in the bottom with Jasmine going home that being said, i am looking forward to the lipsync smack down
I honestly thought that jasmine would have been a stand out performance had they added the “funny” music cues and I would have put either jorgeous or bosco in the bottom with willow but im super excited for next week too lol
@@Jays6926 There were no jokes. I mean sure, Angeria can tell us all her material was edited out. But from what we saw, there was nothing funny. For me she'd be in the bottom.
Maybe I'm crazy but part of the laughs in the recent snatch game were from Ru kinda laughing *at* the queens.... like more from awkwardness than actual jokes?
it's hard for me to look at the older seasons without the nostalgia bias but i think that a part of what makes the newer snatch games so impressive is that the queens continue to do well, come up with original characters and jokes when it seems like everything has already been done. and i think it totally makes sense for the all stars 5 and 6 snatch games to be at the top, not only because of how much time the queens have had to grow & develop their comedy skills but because they're incredible casts who put in a lot of work and were able to showcase that growth by bantering with each other, being more confident to try out new things, etc. sorry this kind of got away from me but i appreciate this video it made me think a lot about the different eras of drag race!
Perhaps the problem is that, as seasons pass, the queens are expected to have a better performance every new season. It's been said many times "if you know you're casted for a season, take a sewing class and begin working on your Snatch Game because you know FOR SURE you will need those skills". So it becomes more and more upsetting when someone brings a Snatch Game character that has no jokes because it's like "girl, you had time to practice", and we become more upset when it's season 14 and we think all the cast, or the majority of it, should do great because they came prepared and then we only get a few laughs here and there. Season 13 and All Stars 6 were amazing because the majority came VERY prepared. For me it has always been more baffling when the queens are asked to change their character on the day because they at least feel some kind of connection or comfort playing that character, and unless there is someone else doing that same character, I see no point in changing what you already feel comfortable with. I always see it as Ru playing mind games with them and many times it doesn't work out for the better so I feel like we might have missed a solid couple laughs and instead we get a bad performance that only serves as drama for the judging or the elimination. BTW I also think Lady Camden did a good job.
Alaska as May West was brilliant For me it’s usually only two or three I even remember from snatch game I still say “ She popped a pill “ Robbie Turnt her thank you😳😒😊
I believe there the reason production chose to go with this storyline for the s14 snatch game for two reasons.. to justify the lipsync smackdown that was obviously pre-planned and to knock the frontrunners down a bit. I think they knew after the non elimination episode and the double save that they had to justify the existence of a lipsync episode somehow or it would just piss off fans who felt like the last few weeks have kind of stalled the season. The other side is that throughout the competition you can tell they've tried to spread out the wins but angeria Willow Bosco and lady Camden to a lesser extent have succeeded in virtually every challenge and without this twist the other 2 spots in the top 3 this week would've probably been some combination of Angie Camden and Bosco. Getting to see basically all of the frontrunners lipsync for their life will add dynamic to their storylines while also giving production a chance to gauge their lipsync abilities while keeping the stakes of them actually getting eliminated low.
I feel like counting the laughs like you said is not the best way to measure how funny the snatch game is. Specially considering Rupaul's humor is different from the overall audience (the best example being Scarlett as macaulay culkin). My favorites snatch games are season 6 and all stars 2, I feel like almost everyone did great even if Rupaul wasn't laughing that hard. Even if I agree they edited to look worse than it actually did on season 14, it's not like they were killing it either. The only one that made me laugh was Deja, everyone else I just cringed or looked bored at. Some were not horrible, like Candem or Angeria that could've been safe for me, but overall everyone had some flaws for me, so I actually didn't mind the whole lip sync smackdown twist.
S11 for me was the ONE TIME when the Lip Sync overshadowed the Snatch Game lol. For obvious reasons lol. I do feel bad for Silky, but the lip Sync between Yvie and Brooke was iconic.
I feel like you need a certain level of bad/cringe performances to make an iconic Snatch Game, because those performances are still funny, purely because of how bad they are.
Jinkx as Little Edie and Eureka as Honey Boo Boo will always be my favorite performances, but I wouldn't say they're my fav snatch games as a whole, but I do think the snatch game with Ra'jah as Latoya Jackson is probably the best one overall!
Angeria said on a live video that she had three other options turned down, including Miss Cleo. Weird that they would okay Tammy brown when I thought they weren’t supposed to do other queens anymore.
For some reason I felt the judges were the ones with weird energy. Rue usually laughs at absolutely everything. When I first watched this episode, I found it so bizarre how tough the judges were
You could use the Untucked exclusive from Season 4 as a tie breaker for seasons 3 and 4 (Willam walking off, saying "I'm going to Macy's!" and leaving a cardboard cut-out of Jessica Simpson in her place).
In my opinion season 14 is the worst snatch game because of the level of expectation with every queen, they been doing great so most of the fan of the show thought that this special challenge would be fantastic and it ended of been the worst, is not about how many times Ru laugh, is about the expectation for me.
You didn't divide the number of laugh with the duration of the Snatch game to get a number of rupaul laugh per minute ? That would solve your problem i think
My favorite underrated (in my opinion) Snatch Game performances have to be… Adore Delano (S6) - Anna Nicole Smith Pearl (S7) - Big Ang Jackie Cox (S12) - Lisa Rinna Thorgy Thor (S8) - Michael Jackson Blu Hydrangea (UK1) - Mary Berry Aja (AS3) - Crystal LaBeija Naomi Smalls (AS4) - Wendy Williams Lemon (C1) - JoJo Siwa Pythia (C2) - Grimes Elektra Shock (DU1) - Catherine O’Hara (Moira Rose) Ra’Jah O’Hara (AS6) - LaToya Jackson My favorite underrated Snatch Game BOMBS have to be… Miss Fame (S7) - Donatella Versace Asia O’Hara & The Vixen (S10) - Beyoncè & Blue Ivy Chi Chi DeVayne RIP (AS3) - Maya (lol) Angelou Liv Lux (S13) - Tabitha Brown Elliott with 2 Ts (S13) - Golden Girl No. 3 Kylie Sonique Love (S2) - Lady Gaga Roxxxy Andrews (AS2) - Alaska 5000 Milk (S6) - Julia Child Milan (S4) - Diana Ross
Plus you can tell which ones are getting the "winners edit" treatment...like blu doing austin powers despite being poor/unfu nny the amount of laughter from michelle and ru was ridiculous
Scarlett vs Jaidynn... remember that Scarlett was asked to do Macauley Culkin on the spot whereas Jaidynn prepared Raven in advance. Its like comparing apples with oranges.
I think season 14 is the worst, but not because the queens performed worse than in others, but because Ru and the editor were so mean-spirited that it ruined the experience of watching it. I want them to be on the side of the queens, show us the queens at their best. Don't gaslight them and humiliate them publicly in front of me. I'm absolutely sure that with 4 hours of footage, it's possible to do either.
This! When u see Raven in all stars 2 and season 14 the attitude is sooo much different. Like she came here to ruin the fun whereas back then she would laugh at anything
I personally agree that season 14 is amongst the worst snatch games - the raw number of laughs is a good way of measuring how "successfully" funny the queens were, but I think you also need to account for how hard each joke made Ru laugh, as well as the spread of laughter in ranking. Having one or two people carrying a whole snatch game makes it harder for other people to get laughs. This isn't just true for snatch game, but comedy in general. Following a standup comic that got no laughs is challenging as you need to get the audience on your side again. I can fully picture a scenario in the room where joke after joke kept falling flat, making it successfully harder to make Ru laugh. We have to remember that this is all edited, and comedy in the moment is funnier. We've all told a funny story and had to follow up with "ah.. well you probably had to be there" Really good video and analysis but I think there is more to consider than just the "raw data" of laughs
I feel like we all instinctively realized that s14 snatch game was rigged in order for them to do the lip synch smack down episode. That being said, I'm surprised that s14 had the 10th most laughs. The producers were working double time to make the 'worst snatch game ever' out of a decent group performance
pretty interesting video but i have to say that the type of laugh matters a lot, for instance a big laugh is much more important than a bunch of small chuckles. also editing definitely influences snatch game a lot, probably more than any other challenge. what we see might actually be better or worse than reality, based on whatever narrative the team wanted to show and who they wanted in the bottom.
I don’t mean to take away from you’re analysis because I think you have done a great job breaking this all down but I think what this mostly represents is that Ru fake laughs a lot more in recent seasons than before. The rigorry is so blatant and obvious. I wonder when all this production meddling become too much and Drag Race empire will fall.
Not a good way to determine the best or worst at all, especially if no math is being done to calculate "laughs per minute" or something since some snatch games are longer than others. Regardless, it was an interesting watch and I enjoyed hearing ur opinions on this season's snatch game from a production standpoint ^-^
Phi Phi (AS2) and Raja (S3) relied on the same schtick too, but those two (and Jaidynn) were FAR more tolerable than that awful, awful Macauley Culkin. My God that was annoying...
You should've calculated laughs per minute to solve the issue of earlier season snatch games being shorter than the newer ones. I don't think s5 would necessarily rank the lowest.
Why did you include RPDR, DRUK. DR Down Under and All Stars, but not Canada's Drag Race, DR Holland, DR Italia, DR España and DR Thailand? Jimbo, Lemon, Tormai. Sagittaria and some others had really great performances which should definitely be mentioned. DR España in particular is really strong.
I think the key to having a really iconic and 'good' snatch game is not so much how well the overall cast performs but having a big difference in performance quality. When we think of iconic snatch games, they tend to be ones with 2 or 3 really stand out performances and then a few iconically bad ones (Laganja as Rachel Zoe in the same snatch game as Bendela's Maggie Smith comes to mind). They're both iconic in their own right and end up making much better TV.
I love 6, 12, and 13! Also for judging this list i think you could divide the number of laughs by the length of snatch game so we all have a standardized score for each.
I appreciate your hard work, however, I believe that the list would have been more accurate had it been laughs per minute, as that would reflect the fact that the later snatch games are longer so they have an inherent advantage over the earlier snatch games
there should've been some sort of multiplier to account for the length of time the snatch game was edited and aired bec ofc that affects the counting of rupauls laughs. personally i think a good snatch game is when good and terrible queens are obvious on the get go and when the good queens just volley off of each other and play around.
Yano what I would say that season 7 could be one of the bests I mean it has Adele, little Richard AND big ange like that fully could of been a triple win
I would just like point out that Pearl was TOTALLY SNUBBED during her snatch game because her Big Ang was HILARIOUS and now I feel justified. Also, I didn't think Bosco or Lady Camden were bad. I've been saying the 'adjacent' line this past week. lol
Big Ang was awesome “it’s a medical mystery” 👍
Big Ang was AWESOME and from what we saw, it seemed like she belonged in the top with Ginger and Kennedy over Katya. But the Snatch Game was pretty darn good.
Literally my fav snatch game performance "i had a rough childhood okay" kills me everytime
YES !!!!!!
Honestly yes she was so quick witted!! I had a rough childhood okay I wasn’t watching fucking Batman and robin - so good !!
I get that season 5 is iconic but I’m not at all surprised at it having the worst snatch game by your laugh count. Detox pissing on the floor and Alyssa having to formally apologize makes the snatch game absolutely abysmal by itself
Not to mention that after Alyssa's performance they had to get rid of the immunity thing.
@@lune78 i hadn't even considered that snatch game season 5 is what killed immunity, thank you for this excellent addition omg
#Rupology
I thought Detox pissing was hilarious 🤣 Is something wrong with me?
@@antoineleclerc5638 That might just be personal preference honestly! Maybe its just not the smartest move to make in front of a large audience, because a lot of people don’t like it. I personally don’t find piss or fart jokes funny at all, so the Daytona Winds episode on Season 14 really didn’t amuse me at all😂
Also DID NOBODY ELSE CRACK UP AT WILLOW SAYING “i woke up at 6:60 also known as 7 o’clock” I know everyone thinks she was awful but that SENT me
That was her one and only joke. 😭
@@scorpionqueen11 aside from her lip syncing.
It was funny but I feel like it couldve been delivered/structured better
Emphasized sent YOU. Her delivery washed it away.
@@scorpionqueen11 so we've seen. Remember it's edited
Alexis really had me cracking up with her Walter Mercado I really wish it wasn't the start of the if you're not the top you're in the bottom nonsense for the season 😭
LITERALLY like im so glad AS6 didnt do that for it's snatch game, imagine if the placements were like
WIN- Shea (i think she did really well so im not gonna argue with her win)
HIGH- Jujubee, Alexis
LOW- Blair
BTM2- Cracker and India
I hope I don't sound ridiculous but... Camdem's Shakespeare wasn't that bad, if they wanted to, she could've been edited funny. I mean, the delivery wasn't there, but the jokes were funny and her being the parody of the parody has proved in the past to be safe worthy. 🤷♂
I laughed at the “fffff…. Fairytale” bit
I liked her shakespeare! It was easily safe
Camden and Angie felt like the obvious 2nd and 3rd after Deja
@@dominiqueknight6707 Me too! I thought I was the only one
it's probably to save willow and daya from the bottom, since they were the obvious lows next to jorgueous, and we know that she would exterminate any of them
It’s unfortunate that editing so strongly influences how we view snatch game. Multiple queens on season 5 and 8 have come out and said that Coco and Derrick were hilarious, and we just didn’t see that at all in the final product
i think derrick's final product was great. she did after all place high
Yesss I remember saying Coco’s Janet had funny jokes that were very dark
This is also why it wasnt really properly explained why Tayce was top and Awhora bottom on the UKS2 Snatch Game.. Lots of Tayce was cut out, the bad bits of Awhora not shown
Is that why there was weird jump cuts between Max's Sharon Needles lines and her laughing
"Mischivieous as a midnight PUCK, prince Harry, loves a good Fffffff- airytale 😃" wasn't that bad, I actually laughed at it.
I genuinely think that they sabotaged the queens this week. I found myself laughing when there was that stupid "this sucks" sound effect that they used. RuPaul knows how to turn on the fake laugh and she deliberately chose not to. They wanted some lip sync smackdown from the beginning and saw the opportunity even though there was a clear bottom two in my opinion.
nah the girls sucked. there was ZERO jokes to be found this season
@@yupthatsme5257 comedy is also subjective. I thought there were some good jokes in there therefore there was the opportunity to laugh.
@@yupthatsme5257 There were funny jokes, but even so, a lot of the moments get cut out. The game lasts much longer than 12 minutes. Angie talked about doing all of Tammie's famous quotes, something that would usually appear in the final cut, but not a single one made it in
who were the bottom 2 in your opinion?
@@feliperissoli5319 I thought Jasmine because she had no jokes imo and Willow for similar reason along with her not doing her research. That was embarrassing.
I think what we learned from this video is that RuPaul’s laughing does not a good Snatch Game make 😂
Completely agree. One of the reasons I strongly dislike UK Season 3's Snatch Game as a whole. Everyone was asked to change their characters when Ru spoke to them in the work room (except we didn't see footage of Krystal or Vanity), and the only girls that didn't change their characters ended up in the bottom.
I thought Daya’s Ozzy, Camden’s Shakespeare, and Boscoe’s Gwenyth had AT LEAST one joke I really laughed at.
It wasn’t good overall, but I can’t help but wonder what’d it feel like without production forcing the “terrible” storyline
even willows 6:60 joke was fine!
@@ajartwork9922 she literally used the same joke in her old youtube video
I thought she had a hilarious opening line. @@nikfiendluvr666
Did you consider doing a "Laughs per minute" calculation to account for seasons with less time? Great video, but I'm wondering if the rankings would have been different. For ex: on season 6 they only got 20 laughs but it was 6 mins long (on youtube) vs season 14 which was 14 minutes long and got 25 laughs. If you divide the laughs for season 6 - 20/6 you get 3.3 laughs per minute. If you divide the laughs for season 14 - 25/14 you get 1.8 laughs per minute. This maybe shows why this felt like such a flop. we had a lot less laughs per minute we spent watching it! Thanks for compiling all the info and watching these all again for us!
I agree entirely! Or taking the total laughs/the total answers to get a more accurate ratio. Comparing the seasons like this isn’t entirely fair
that's actually a great point. I'd love to see this type of calculation too
Agreed! Another option may be proportion of laughs to responses
This feel like a much more fair system. Tho I'm not one to talk because my way of judging snatchgame is kind of biased
Absolutely agree, and they even mention the problem with different video lenghts at the start of the video. I generally don't think that just counting Ru's laughs per game (or even per min) is the best heuristic. 1. As they said: sometimes Ru laughs AT the Queens and not with them. Laughter has a social context. 2. Sometimes she'll laugh genuinely as well even though the camera cuts to the guest judges. Excluding them doesn't seem right. Even if Ru didn't laugh then - seeing guest judges laugh makes it funnier for us viewers as well.
I think a mere quantitative analysis will always fall short (and a qualitative approach would be suited better).
I’m convinced Willow manifested this edit when she said they were all performing so strong that one week they were all going to suck. I’m sure producers were losing their shit over the possibility of that many bottom placements. It’s a stage with no audience so no background laughs, Ru is refusing to laugh I’m sure they put the pressure on them and made the atmosphere so dead none of them could make any jokes land past a certain point
I appreciate the effort that went into this, my goodness! I’m so excited to see the if season 14 was judged fairly video when that time comes ahahahahaha
It wasn’t…
@@blaze56701 of course not, that's the point of those videos
I think every season was judged fairly. You guys just want a fan fav to win for some reason. Regardless, if it was judged as it should be or not, the placement of any Queen is fair and so is the elimination. They signed up for exposure and their careers to be taken to the next level not really to be America's next Drag Superstar. It's just something they threw in to keep the stakes, tension and drama at all time high
@@hiltonhousekeepingxlnxc2279 name 1 recent season judged fairly…
@@blaze56701 Seasons 1-14 and all International spinoffs as well as All-stars 😇😇. I want you to name a Reality TV show competition that is fair?? It has no influence by production or anything and has no cast members speak out on things production turns a blind eye
Jaidyn got NO respect on Drag Race. she's so stunning and talented but was overlooked by the show and fandom
Getting put in the bottom for a joke working so well that it made her want to keep doing it when other queens got zero jokes across is still crazy to me.
Alexis not winning snatch game or at least being high on all stars 5 was so bullshit
Ngl I think for that episode alone it should’ve been a top 2
And the winner shouldn't even have been in that top two! (Jujubee and Alexis were clearly the best)
Imo this ranking system is flawed, since some snatch games have more queens, therefore sometimes having an advantage or disadvantage, and also sometimes rupaul gives pity laughs like when they're presenting themselves
Also I know there was the disclaimer but the fact that *all* the early seasons were in the bottom (even S5) in terms of number of laughs really shows that Ru has been slowly amping up his laughter even if the performance didn't really warrant it.
I mean he’s not a statistician but he could have just normalized the results to account for differences in time and in the number of queens.. It’s just a simple division
Plus Ginger got zero laughs in AS2 which is clearly misleading since the punchline was Ru acting concerned
This list proves Ru Paul's laughs are not the way to rank snatch games
In defense of s5: it’s been revealed by queens on the season Alaska was great but almost all of it got cut because of how Blue her Lady bunny was. There’s some missing laughs there
Blue ? 😯 Can you explain ?
@@antoineleclerc5638 blue humor is when someone’s jokes involve sex, swearing, toilet humor, etc. and is therefore is too risky to put on TV or it will scare off the advertisers
@@shuzzlinreader5339 Thank you didn't know that expression
I think Snatch Game is seen as "good" not because there aren't any bad queens, but because there is a nice mix of REALLY good and REALLY bad queens. Season 14 may have apparently gotten more laughs, but none of them really stood out as especially good or even horrifyingly bad, just boring and bland, and even Deja has not much quotable, apart from the "Yeah".
Right??? I wish she sorta changed it up once and was like OOOOKAY. Whenever Ru said something to her or something. But I completely agree!
I love that Deja finally got a win though.
no
I think Bianca Del Rio's Judge Judy is the most overrated snatch game performance of all time. People love to give Silky shit saying she was just playing herself when she did TS Madison, but Bianca was playing herself when she did Judge Judy so what's the difference between the two of them
Yeah, I really liked Bianca's performance, but it's way less funny than people make it out to be
I feel like the best snatch games find that happy medium between queens cosplaying other people while just acting like themselves vs acting like the celebrity and forgetting to make it funny. That’s why I think many people see Kylie’s Dolly as successful, Bianca as Judge Judy, and Jinx’ Judy Garland. 1) because you could see these queens saying/doing any of their one liners from snatch game sincerely and 2) it’s absurd to think of their character/celebrity doing or saying that, then it becomes funny.
Bianca brought Officer Burns with her though 😆
Say what you want about Chi Chi on Allstars, but her "the caged bird sings because...I don't know why the caged bird sings" will always be funny to me. And I think she could have played out the fact that she didn't really know who she was trying to impersonate (similar to how Blue did a dirty Mary Berry).
So what we learned from this video is that Alexis Mateo has been robbed of two wins.
The second hand emabarrassment I got from watching this snatch game was so strong that I almost couldn't finish it. Thank god for the speedy montage at the end.
Only 8 minutes into this, I could be wrong but I’m pretty sure Ru laughs at Jaidynn’s intro.
I really feel like this isn’t a great system to use cuz there’s like, courtesy laughing, nervous laughing, along with a bird sounding laugh (Ru’s reaction to “a sensible 74”) that is worth way more to me than a giggle to me (reaction to Karen’s “bout an 11”). I’d kinda like to know the counter for awkward silence/Ru going “okay…alright” to signal an unfunny joke, but I know it’s hard to quantify these things.
Edit: Just checked, Ru doesn’t laugh at Jaidynn but he does shout “OH MY GOODNESS!” I’d give that a half a point but I’m generous
For me I didn’t think the snatch game was ‘bad’ but I felt a lot of the performances were simply just average which made Deja stand out further. But I think it was also edited to give no one laughs simply for this gag of the lip sync battle.
i'm glad we as a fandom all agree that Bosco's Kumbucha joke was funny and Ru not laughing at it was bizarre. like hello??? this isn't another "Charity Kase your verse about being a bottom is so dirty :(" moment is it
Fun to see how this criteria shakes out, though a laugh can mean a lot of things. How loud was the laugh? Was it with or at the queen? How clever or unique is the point of view of the performance? Did they transcend the game? A hard thing to quantify but I appreciate your effort here. Thanks!
I honestly cracked tf up at Bosco's cumbucha joke, like so loud and so long. I don't get why there weren't laughs at that joke. I definitely think they were set up to not think they were doing well cause there were some decent jokes in there. Not the best snatch game but definitely better than it was made out to be.
I believe that a LaLa PaRuza was planned from the start of the season and the producers just waited for a challenge where people didn’t do GREAT to put everyone in the bottom
No reason to believe. They had to license the songs. You think the licensed multiple additional songs just in case?
That really shocked me to see Season 7 so low! It's my favourite Snatch Game of all time!
Right! And I’m a bit confused at Violet’s laugh count saying 0 when she had two jokes that landed (her first getting a whole scream from Tamar lol).
Shuga should have won for her utterly charming Charo on Season 11. There I said it.
Seeing Camden flop this episode really hurt my heart
also the season 14 queens were definitely given a different runway category, I assume so Michelle could be like "this doesn't scream holy couture" if needed to. Just use the original category!
It was originally "Things you worship" I believe Willow confirmed it
I have only one thing to say: "I've Got a Lovely Bunch of Coconuts". There is nothing like this sentence and also the one of Jinx who took an obscure character and started blabbering on about cat food
And delaaa with the weird imitation of MAGGIE SMITH was genious
I understand that this was just a project to do that wouldn't conflict with your riggory of S14 video, but I disagree with this criteria being used to judge Snatch Games. You mention multiple times in the video that editing of Snatch Games has changed over time, which has definitely included an increase in laughs to make Snatch Game more entertaining. The editors have simply gotten better at editing to make it entertaining. So why would the Season 14 cast getting more laughs be indicative of how they performed? If they wanted to make it obvious that everyone bombed, they would have edited all laughs out entirely, so I think they were throwing us a bone by keeping in the laughs that Ru would force in the first place so that we were entertained. You also show how mediocre Snatch Games have gotten way more laughs than you'd expect throughout the video, which literally just proves that laughs have nothing to do with how good a Snatch Game performance is.
I agree that there was probably some producer meddling going on to make Ru not respond to decent jokes, but I bet they told him to do that once they saw how bad some queens were doing. If it was the plan from the beginning, why would Ru know to laugh at DeJa's jokes?
Yeah. It simply doesn’t prove his point that basically the S14 Snatch Game was “rigged”. It is just indicative of how prominent RuPaul’s laughs are nowadays. The better metric of good snatch games is fan reception, not this kind of criteria.
They didn't just spontaneously add an entire lipsync smackdown episode because they realized right there that the queens are bombing. This was all planned well ahead. But I agree that laughs are not indicative of how good or bad a snatch game is. This S14 snatch game is objectively bad (largely due to the editing to give the impression of bombing), so that making into #10 doesn't make sense anyway. The criteria are not correctly chosen.
@@babayevsky i would describe the Snatch Game as extremely mediocre. The performances weren’t really bad, but they were not good at all. I honestly don’t think it was that difficult for the producers to make this snatch game “look bad”.
Agree. RuPaul is forcing more laughter for favored queens period in funny challenges, not just in the snatch game. It's not just the length of the segment that has changed, but also the amount of organic laughter from Ru. Maybe there should have been a poll, and it should have been considered how much the guests laughed too, since maybe they're reactions are more organic.
100%agree
I will FOREVER stan Pearl’s snatch game performance and personally I think she was the clear winner😍
This is so interesting!! It really shows how everyone can judge snatch game so differently. I prefer the seasons with only a couple solid performances as opposed to one superstar icon level performance, just bc I like the queen to queen interaction and I think that’s where some of the best bits come from!
For people who are curious about where the AS7 Snatch Game falls on the list, I did the math:
The game had a total of 77 laughs, snatching the 1st place on the list.
If maybe you want to consider as two different snatch games because of the break to change characters, the 1st half had 37 laughs (getting the 5th place) while the second half had 40 laughs (getting the 4th place).
LAUGH COUNTER:
Jinkx: 21 laughs (5 + 16)
Trinity: 14 laughs (4 + 10)
Monet: 10 laughs (7 + 3)
Jaida: 10 laughs (9 + 1)
Raja: 7 laughs (4 + 3)
Shae: 6 laughs (4 + 2)
Viv: 5 laughs (3 + 2)
Yvie: 4 laughs (1 + 3)
Great video, I don’t agree with the ranking criteria though. If one person gets 100 laughs but everyone else in that season gets none, that snatch game could easily go up the ranks. What makes a good snatch game good imo is when the majority of contestants do well overall. Otherwise statistically Deyja would be an outlier
Conspiracy theory: they thought up the lipsync episode twist before the season ever began, and purposefully 'ruined' the snatch game to A) generate all of this press which really worked, and B) justify another non-elimination episode & incorporate this pre-planned twist.
How? well, an easy way to tank someone's improv performance is cut their thinking time. We don't know how much time they usually get to answer questions, but I have a hunch it's been slowly getting reduced over recent years as the snatch games are getting longer (so ru doesn't have to stand around as long) - the producers could have purposefully given these queens significantly less time so they had less chance of thinking up a funny answer (potentially why Daya was copying Bosco's answers, and how many of the queens jokes didn't fit the question in one way or another)
ru could be purposefully not laughing at jokes to sell the storyline, and demoralise the queens into giving worse performances over the course of the snatch game. Maybe a condition of Daya's non-elimination was that she had to copy someone's answers if she got to snatch game? Who knows? That's why it's a conspiracy
I’m not inclined to get on board with conspiracies and claims of riggory. But something was definitely up. They had the rights cleared for 5 songs. Carson & Ross were both booked to shoot that day. And a pit crew member was there who presumably had to be medically cleared ahead of time. It’s hard for me to believe they pulled all that together overnight or even with a couple days, depending on the shooting schedule. That being said, it was a pretty bad SG in terms of its mediocrity. So maybe the opportunity for this type of drama just presented itself & they ran with it 🤷🏻♂️
I think this snatch game suffered from being Cheryl Hole’s favorite word, mediocre. Nobody pulled a Utica or a Gia or an Aiden, so it was hard to judge. And Deja absolutely was the best, but it felt more along the lines of what usually is the 2nd or 3rd best performance. It did feel like a setup though because I guess RuPaul forgot about the “Yes, and” school of acting cuz she didn’t give them ANYTHING to go off of.
Girl take off Deja and you get 12 laughs total. That's not a Top 10 SG. Also, you could've considered the duration of the SG as well to make it more accurate
no one talks about how pearl was stolen in the snach game, it was much better than katya
I think a lot of S14’s laughs from Ru were out of pity, not from the queens being funny. Also, I genuinely laughed out loud at Deja everytime she said “YEAH”
it definitely could have been better, but i honestly don’t think Camden, Bosco, Angeria or Daya did bad enough to warrant a lipsync.
I think it’s obvious that editing played a huge part (Angeria’s post seems to point this out) but if i were to judge it i’d say
Deja gets the win
no high queens
Camden, Angeria, Bosco and Daya are safe
Jorgeous is low (Bosco could go here to ig but there was at least one good joke even if it didn’t land)
Willow and Jasmine in the bottom with Jasmine going home
that being said, i am looking forward to the lipsync smack down
I honestly thought that jasmine would have been a stand out performance had they added the “funny” music cues and I would have put either jorgeous or bosco in the bottom with willow but im super excited for next week too lol
Imo Angeria is either low or lip syncing to me, her Tammie Brown was like an off off brand Cher
@@coppagh8040 Angeria was bad… edit or not. She was just not tammie brown
Imo Jasmine, Daya and Camden could of all been edited safe but the producers clearly wanted a shock so edited it how they did
@@Jays6926 There were no jokes. I mean sure, Angeria can tell us all her material was edited out. But from what we saw, there was nothing funny. For me she'd be in the bottom.
Maybe I'm crazy but part of the laughs in the recent snatch game were from Ru kinda laughing *at* the queens.... like more from awkwardness than actual jokes?
it's hard for me to look at the older seasons without the nostalgia bias but i think that a part of what makes the newer snatch games so impressive is that the queens continue to do well, come up with original characters and jokes when it seems like everything has already been done. and i think it totally makes sense for the all stars 5 and 6 snatch games to be at the top, not only because of how much time the queens have had to grow & develop their comedy skills but because they're incredible casts who put in a lot of work and were able to showcase that growth by bantering with each other, being more confident to try out new things, etc. sorry this kind of got away from me but i appreciate this video it made me think a lot about the different eras of drag race!
The investigation continues.... with the Drag Detective 🤣😍
Perhaps the problem is that, as seasons pass, the queens are expected to have a better performance every new season. It's been said many times "if you know you're casted for a season, take a sewing class and begin working on your Snatch Game because you know FOR SURE you will need those skills".
So it becomes more and more upsetting when someone brings a Snatch Game character that has no jokes because it's like "girl, you had time to practice", and we become more upset when it's season 14 and we think all the cast, or the majority of it, should do great because they came prepared and then we only get a few laughs here and there. Season 13 and All Stars 6 were amazing because the majority came VERY prepared.
For me it has always been more baffling when the queens are asked to change their character on the day because they at least feel some kind of connection or comfort playing that character, and unless there is someone else doing that same character, I see no point in changing what you already feel comfortable with. I always see it as Ru playing mind games with them and many times it doesn't work out for the better so I feel like we might have missed a solid couple laughs and instead we get a bad performance that only serves as drama for the judging or the elimination.
BTW I also think Lady Camden did a good job.
The fact you went through every snatch game and analysed each one deserves a round of applause 👏 👏👏👏👏👏
i really don’t know how u do it, talking about a small topic for 30+mins and keeping me hooked the whole time!!
Alaska as May West was brilliant For me it’s usually only two or three I even remember from snatch game I still say “ She popped a pill “ Robbie Turnt her thank you😳😒😊
"phone, my home." killed me. Willow was p funny
I believe there the reason production chose to go with this storyline for the s14 snatch game for two reasons.. to justify the lipsync smackdown that was obviously pre-planned and to knock the frontrunners down a bit. I think they knew after the non elimination episode and the double save that they had to justify the existence of a lipsync episode somehow or it would just piss off fans who felt like the last few weeks have kind of stalled the season. The other side is that throughout the competition you can tell they've tried to spread out the wins but angeria Willow Bosco and lady Camden to a lesser extent have succeeded in virtually every challenge and without this twist the other 2 spots in the top 3 this week would've probably been some combination of Angie Camden and Bosco. Getting to see basically all of the frontrunners lipsync for their life will add dynamic to their storylines while also giving production a chance to gauge their lipsync abilities while keeping the stakes of them actually getting eliminated low.
i 100% believe they're doing the mega lip sync thing to fix so many non elimination episodes
I feel like counting the laughs like you said is not the best way to measure how funny the snatch game is. Specially considering Rupaul's humor is different from the overall audience (the best example being Scarlett as macaulay culkin). My favorites snatch games are season 6 and all stars 2, I feel like almost everyone did great even if Rupaul wasn't laughing that hard. Even if I agree they edited to look worse than it actually did on season 14, it's not like they were killing it either. The only one that made me laugh was Deja, everyone else I just cringed or looked bored at. Some were not horrible, like Candem or Angeria that could've been safe for me, but overall everyone had some flaws for me, so I actually didn't mind the whole lip sync smackdown twist.
S11 for me was the ONE TIME when the Lip Sync overshadowed the Snatch Game lol. For obvious reasons lol. I do feel bad for Silky, but the lip Sync between Yvie and Brooke was iconic.
Seeing everyone's different opinions is so interesting, bc this episode has had the most varied opinions I've seen from fans
S7 is my favorite and I'm disgusted that it is lower than S11 and S14
That Macaulay Culkin was HORRIBLE. I really don't understand how it was even attempted to be shown as funny
I feel like you need a certain level of bad/cringe performances to make an iconic Snatch Game, because those performances are still funny, purely because of how bad they are.
Jinkx as Little Edie and Eureka as Honey Boo Boo will always be my favorite performances, but I wouldn't say they're my fav snatch games as a whole, but I do think the snatch game with Ra'jah as Latoya Jackson is probably the best one overall!
i would rather a hilarious diamond in the rough, than a bunch of semi-unmemorable, yet mostly funny queens, any day
in my opinion the six season works so well for me because of some of those flops because without Gia we wouldn’t get some of Bianca’s lines
Season 14 is the worst because no one was iconically great or bad. Ru laughing and the mild laugh track aint gonna save it.
Angeria said on a live video that she had three other options turned down, including Miss Cleo. Weird that they would okay Tammy brown when I thought they weren’t supposed to do other queens anymore.
“Everyone EXCEPT jasmine does get a laugh” gives the same energy as “and none for gretchen weiners”
For some reason I felt the judges were the ones with weird energy. Rue usually laughs at absolutely everything. When I first watched this episode, I found it so bizarre how tough the judges were
You could use the Untucked exclusive from Season 4 as a tie breaker for seasons 3 and 4 (Willam walking off, saying "I'm going to Macy's!" and leaving a cardboard cut-out of Jessica Simpson in her place).
the amount of effort in this video, this is amazing! thank you so much for what you do
This film reminded me of why I dislike Scarlett Harllet and the favoritism
Omg I cannot imagine the dedication to this video! Thank you for this!!!
Haven't watched the video yet but expecting the worst one to be Down Under lmao
Aside from season 14, DU and Canada Season 2 were some of the hardest to sit through.
In my opinion season 14 is the worst snatch game because of the level of expectation with every queen, they been doing great so most of the fan of the show thought that this special challenge would be fantastic and it ended of been the worst, is not about how many times Ru laugh, is about the expectation for me.
You didn't divide the number of laugh with the duration of the Snatch game to get a number of rupaul laugh per minute ? That would solve your problem i think
My favorite underrated (in my opinion) Snatch Game performances have to be…
Adore Delano (S6) - Anna Nicole Smith
Pearl (S7) - Big Ang
Jackie Cox (S12) - Lisa Rinna
Thorgy Thor (S8) - Michael Jackson
Blu Hydrangea (UK1) - Mary Berry
Aja (AS3) - Crystal LaBeija
Naomi Smalls (AS4) - Wendy Williams
Lemon (C1) - JoJo Siwa
Pythia (C2) - Grimes
Elektra Shock (DU1) - Catherine O’Hara (Moira Rose)
Ra’Jah O’Hara (AS6) - LaToya Jackson
My favorite underrated Snatch Game BOMBS have to be…
Miss Fame (S7) - Donatella Versace
Asia O’Hara & The Vixen (S10) - Beyoncè & Blue Ivy
Chi Chi DeVayne RIP (AS3) - Maya (lol) Angelou
Liv Lux (S13) - Tabitha Brown
Elliott with 2 Ts (S13) - Golden Girl No. 3
Kylie Sonique Love (S2) - Lady Gaga
Roxxxy Andrews (AS2) - Alaska 5000
Milk (S6) - Julia Child
Milan (S4) - Diana Ross
Plus you can tell which ones are getting the "winners edit" treatment...like blu doing austin powers despite being poor/unfu nny the amount of laughter from michelle and ru was ridiculous
Scarlett vs Jaidynn... remember that Scarlett was asked to do Macauley Culkin on the spot whereas Jaidynn prepared Raven in advance. Its like comparing apples with oranges.
I think season 14 is the worst, but not because the queens performed worse than in others, but because Ru and the editor were so mean-spirited that it ruined the experience of watching it. I want them to be on the side of the queens, show us the queens at their best. Don't gaslight them and humiliate them publicly in front of me. I'm absolutely sure that with 4 hours of footage, it's possible to do either.
This! When u see Raven in all stars 2 and season 14 the attitude is sooo much different. Like she came here to ruin the fun whereas back then she would laugh at anything
Great video! Keep up the great work! I still think that season 7 is my favourite snatch game with season 6 close behind 💕
...I smell a stunt
I personally agree that season 14 is amongst the worst snatch games - the raw number of laughs is a good way of measuring how "successfully" funny the queens were, but I think you also need to account for how hard each joke made Ru laugh, as well as the spread of laughter in ranking.
Having one or two people carrying a whole snatch game makes it harder for other people to get laughs. This isn't just true for snatch game, but comedy in general. Following a standup comic that got no laughs is challenging as you need to get the audience on your side again. I can fully picture a scenario in the room where joke after joke kept falling flat, making it successfully harder to make Ru laugh.
We have to remember that this is all edited, and comedy in the moment is funnier. We've all told a funny story and had to follow up with "ah.. well you probably had to be there"
Really good video and analysis but I think there is more to consider than just the "raw data" of laughs
I feel like we all instinctively realized that s14 snatch game was rigged in order for them to do the lip synch smack down episode. That being said, I'm surprised that s14 had the 10th most laughs. The producers were working double time to make the 'worst snatch game ever' out of a decent group performance
pretty interesting video but i have to say that the type of laugh matters a lot, for instance a big laugh is much more important than a bunch of small chuckles. also editing definitely influences snatch game a lot, probably more than any other challenge. what we see might actually be better or worse than reality, based on whatever narrative the team wanted to show and who they wanted in the bottom.
I don’t mean to take away from you’re analysis because I think you have done a great job breaking this all down but I think what this mostly represents is that Ru fake laughs a lot more in recent seasons than before. The rigorry is so blatant and obvious. I wonder when all this production meddling become too much and Drag Race empire will fall.
Not a good way to determine the best or worst at all, especially if no math is being done to calculate "laughs per minute" or something since some snatch games are longer than others. Regardless, it was an interesting watch and I enjoyed hearing ur opinions on this season's snatch game from a production standpoint ^-^
Phi Phi (AS2) and Raja (S3) relied on the same schtick too, but those two (and Jaidynn) were FAR more tolerable than that awful, awful Macauley Culkin. My God that was annoying...
You should've calculated laughs per minute to solve the issue of earlier season snatch games being shorter than the newer ones. I don't think s5 would necessarily rank the lowest.
Why did you include RPDR, DRUK. DR Down Under and All Stars, but not Canada's Drag Race, DR Holland, DR Italia, DR España and DR Thailand? Jimbo, Lemon, Tormai. Sagittaria and some others had really great performances which should definitely be mentioned. DR España in particular is really strong.
All Stars snatch games have by far been my favorites! 5, 2, then 6. They’re all videos I find myself re-watching when I need a good laugh.
OMFG i loved S7 snatch game... even JDF who was in the bottom did good
I think the key to having a really iconic and 'good' snatch game is not so much how well the overall cast performs but having a big difference in performance quality. When we think of iconic snatch games, they tend to be ones with 2 or 3 really stand out performances and then a few iconically bad ones (Laganja as Rachel Zoe in the same snatch game as Bendela's Maggie Smith comes to mind). They're both iconic in their own right and end up making much better TV.
I love 6, 12, and 13!
Also for judging this list i think you could divide the number of laughs by the length of snatch game so we all have a standardized score for each.
I appreciate your hard work, however, I believe that the list would have been more accurate had it been laughs per minute, as that would reflect the fact that the later snatch games are longer so they have an inherent advantage over the earlier snatch games
it’s honestly very impressive that you made this whole thing in under five days. props to ya mawma!
there should've been some sort of multiplier to account for the length of time the snatch game was edited and aired bec ofc that affects the counting of rupauls laughs. personally i think a good snatch game is when good and terrible queens are obvious on the get go and when the good queens just volley off of each other and play around.
Am I the only one who thought jasmines “I’ll answer that next week” was really funny lmaooo
Yano what I would say that season 7 could be one of the bests I mean it has Adele, little Richard AND big ange like that fully could of been a triple win
Season 6 is so low! I thought that was by far the best snatch game ever
omg Juju as Kimora Lee with the ring around her necks... or Jessica as a cracked out Ru. fave!