I don't think most people going for compotent story telling with what if scenarios based in Pokemon are limitting themselves to writing from the perspective of the later generations not existing or at least being known of so I see absolutely nothing wrong with, like the leagues or big contests of other regions would likely be televised in a consistent setting. Oh also I am in agreement that non kantonian mons showing up in kanto is more realistic than Kanto just somehow being locked from the outside or something. I do think you may have depended on your wheel or chance a bit too much in this first part, though its still a fun idea. Maybe a better premise would be what if Ash's journey was through some of the more competitive/difficulty based ROM hacks like Radical Red. That one is just Fire Red but its updated with mons up to Hisui, has all the types, physical/special split etc, and each route is stuffed with mons that aren't kanto native. Just a thought, hope you keep it up. Oh and protip, don't try to record your lines in one-take.
I see the "Roll the wheel and catch the pokemon" thing using game mechanics, and I'm forced to point out that the anime has /always/ used legends arceus mechanics. If the pokemon is aware of the ball coming and not interested in being caught, they just smack the ball away without even giving it the chance to catch them. These mechanics of "just slap the ball away" have been consistent all the way up into Journies, it's just taken decades for the games to catch up.
i agree with the notion that ash's knowledge of pokemon was unacceptable. It also made no sense, Ash was a fan of the pokemon league and later material really retcons his interaction with pokemon early on. As a fan of the league alone he should have known how battles and type match ups work. It sucks cause it feels like the writers made him carry the idiot ball around as an easy way to get out exposition to the audience
Yeah I agree completely. He dosent need to be a pro, but with a professor who likes him in town and a huge fan it really is un-acceptable. We have two more parts our, and the 4th one will come out soon! So theirs plenty for you to check out.
@@smdbzxproductions9868 if this Ash goes into another región he can keep the ones he caugth from the first región And use them in case of Team Rocket or against Legendary Pokémon in self-defense and use the new ones for the leagues in Johto or another región.
Really enjoyed this. I would definitely address the whereabouts of important side characters even if it’s just a note. I would also recommend updating the Kanto region just to make it more interesting and develop the Pokémon further. And only thing on a improvement note would just be be a little bit louder as the audio could be hard to hear at times
Well i've already written the third part so...Kind of a little late for that. I guess I can do that if I get to Johto. As for my audio your right, I cant do much about it though. Other people in the house, a naturally quiet voice. You know how it is. I'll try my best though!
I like to point out how much of a big jerk Misty was to ash. I mean I get that ash used to be an idiot back in the first season but still she goes a bit overboard sometimes
nice video bro some tips u could follow : speak a little loud and show ur confidence change the story add some events (based on your own creativity ) for some hype give ash better pokemon as your video is based on ash as a competitive trainer u can increase battle difficulties I don't think many companions will do good because u may miss on many ash stuff if u cover side characters u can include team rocket members like proton ariana petrel its totally up to u to take my comment
... dude. My god. Professor oak didn't expect ash to get far with pikachu? THE TIMELINE! Professor oak is a time traveler remember! If he doesn't have pikachu when he meets up with ash as a child, there's suddenly a paradox. Oak should be surprised and ALARMED that pikachu didn't get along with him.
@@smdbzxproductions9868 ... dude, it's not like it's hidden lore, it's a feature length film that showed up in movie theaters. I can understand not catching the reason Oak gave ash the GS ball or why he was surprised when nothing happened with it, but not knowing Oak went on a time travel adventure with Ash? Dude. That's like not knowing mewtwo is a clone of mew.
@@animorph17 I haven't watched any of the movies in year's. And to be quite frank I'm not gonna re-watch a bunch of movies and 1000+ episodes just to start a what-if. So I don't know what movie your talking about. And again, your the only person to bring this up...so I am inclined not to believe you. no offense.
@@smdbzxproductions9868 Bulbapedia is right there, wikipedia is a google away, even if you're not going to binge the whole series it still isn't that hard to just look at the titles. Not sure why you trust "No one else brought it up" more than a google search, this is a video with 210 likes at point of writing. How many people do you expect to reply to it? How many people do you expect to have actually watched all the movies and binged through the anime? Heck, how many fans ignore the anime entirely and just use the games as their exclusive reference? Offense not taken, but fucking hell you are poorly qualified here.
@@smdbzxproductions9868Late I know, and probably you know of this already, but this guy is talking about the celebi movie third or fourth movie I am pretty sure. In the movie A young Samuel Oak travelled to the future in the time of Ash he and Ash met and so on blah blah skipping to the point the movie is canon to the main story I am pretty sure, can't be certain tho.
It'd be cool to mention Abilities. When they're necessary y'know like, if they have Static and get touched in battle, and you just mention how Static just happened. Or Intimidate or whatever. It kinda feels like they don't hardly exist in the show which is sad lol ^^' But might be too late to add them into your story 🤔 idk, whatever's comfortable for ya
Abilities weren’t introduced til gen 3, so if we’re pretending this “competent” Ash anime aired in 1997, it wouldn’t make sense for them to know what abilities are.
have him evolve pikachu i know pikachu didnt like evolving but yeah evolution means the pokemon is able to use its max potnetial pikachu won due to plot due to sticking its tail on the ground lt surge in an honourable man wont cheat ateleast in the anime have him evolve squirtle and bulbasaur
Bwah!? The Champion himself has subbed!? Im more nervous already! Part two is already up, so feel free to watch that too! I'll check you out if I have time.
Ah yes, because "if i was smarter, I would already be the best trainer in the world." Is how you describe the 2nd highest ranked trainer in a world wide competition.
I mean if you want to prove me wrong, feel free. But Its fairly safe to say that if you dont even know how to get into the Leauge you've been watching your whole life, dont understand basic-typing, and dont know a pokemon species that lives within view of your house, you can be considered incompetent.
I don't think most people going for compotent story telling with what if scenarios based in Pokemon are limitting themselves to writing from the perspective of the later generations not existing or at least being known of so I see absolutely nothing wrong with, like the leagues or big contests of other regions would likely be televised in a consistent setting.
Oh also I am in agreement that non kantonian mons showing up in kanto is more realistic than Kanto just somehow being locked from the outside or something. I do think you may have depended on your wheel or chance a bit too much in this first part, though its still a fun idea. Maybe a better premise would be what if Ash's journey was through some of the more competitive/difficulty based ROM hacks like Radical Red. That one is just Fire Red but its updated with mons up to Hisui, has all the types, physical/special split etc, and each route is stuffed with mons that aren't kanto native. Just a thought, hope you keep it up.
Oh and protip, don't try to record your lines in one-take.
I see the "Roll the wheel and catch the pokemon" thing using game mechanics, and I'm forced to point out that the anime has /always/ used legends arceus mechanics. If the pokemon is aware of the ball coming and not interested in being caught, they just smack the ball away without even giving it the chance to catch them. These mechanics of "just slap the ball away" have been consistent all the way up into Journies, it's just taken decades for the games to catch up.
i agree with the notion that ash's knowledge of pokemon was unacceptable. It also made no sense, Ash was a fan of the pokemon league and later material really retcons his interaction with pokemon early on. As a fan of the league alone he should have known how battles and type match ups work. It sucks cause it feels like the writers made him carry the idiot ball around as an easy way to get out exposition to the audience
Yeah I agree completely. He dosent need to be a pro, but with a professor who likes him in town and a huge fan it really is un-acceptable.
We have two more parts our, and the 4th one will come out soon! So theirs plenty for you to check out.
@@smdbzxproductions9868 if this Ash goes into another región he can keep the ones he caugth from the first región And use them in case of Team Rocket or against Legendary Pokémon in self-defense and use the new ones for the leagues in Johto or another región.
Update the region and definitely add abilities!! enjoyed this for sure
Well their are 4 parts to enjoy!
Really enjoyed this. I would definitely address the whereabouts of important side characters even if it’s just a note. I would also recommend updating the Kanto region just to make it more interesting and develop the Pokémon further. And only thing on a improvement note would just be be a little bit louder as the audio could be hard to hear at times
Well i've already written the third part so...Kind of a little late for that. I guess I can do that if I get to Johto.
As for my audio your right, I cant do much about it though. Other people in the house, a naturally quiet voice. You know how it is. I'll try my best though!
Very well done, I’m subscribing to see more of this!
Feel free! Recording part 4 today!
If Ash was a Competent Trainer, then he'd be Red, not Ash :D
You are goated i like this more than other what if's
I like to point out how much of a big jerk Misty was to ash. I mean I get that ash used to be an idiot back in the first season but still she goes a bit overboard sometimes
this is officially my favorite comment.
Plus how many times has a new trainer in the anime not been and idiot the only time it was dumb was unova ash
@@VanshPatel-rd9of ohhh don’t even get me started with unova, that’s probably the worse season ever in the series, in my opinion at least
Me personally, I think it had alot of good. But the lows outplay the highs.
I like to point to the Tepig episode for an example.
Just gotten randomly and it's pretty good !!!! ❤️🔥🔥🔥
I love this !
So his sandshrew when the training is going on... is basically regigigas with slow start.
he is a loaf.
nice video bro
some tips u could follow :
speak a little loud and show ur confidence
change the story
add some events (based on your own creativity ) for some hype
give ash better pokemon
as your video is based on ash as a competitive trainer u can increase battle difficulties
I don't think many companions will do good because u may miss on many ash stuff if u cover side characters
u can include team rocket members like proton ariana petrel
its totally up to u to take my comment
... *GRUNTY BOII IS A GREAT TRAINER HIS TEAM IS STRONGER THAN GIOVANNI WHEN HE DID THE RAINBOW ROCKET STORY IN USUM.*
This Ash in Journeys:Leon, you have Lost? Because my Pikachu Will use your charizard to sweep the asphalt**
Loved it.
Well theirs plenty more to watch!
Good job man
so instead of dice gods in D&D, we gotta rely on the wheel/rhoulette gods fun
Abilities should be added yes. An kanto pokemon should be updated.
Nice video could u say when pt 2 would come out?
... dude. My god. Professor oak didn't expect ash to get far with pikachu? THE TIMELINE! Professor oak is a time traveler remember! If he doesn't have pikachu when he meets up with ash as a child, there's suddenly a paradox. Oak should be surprised and ALARMED that pikachu didn't get along with him.
Um...no. Infact I have no idea what your talking about. And on top of that, you are the only person who's brought that up.
@@smdbzxproductions9868 ... dude, it's not like it's hidden lore, it's a feature length film that showed up in movie theaters. I can understand not catching the reason Oak gave ash the GS ball or why he was surprised when nothing happened with it, but not knowing Oak went on a time travel adventure with Ash? Dude. That's like not knowing mewtwo is a clone of mew.
@@animorph17 I haven't watched any of the movies in year's. And to be quite frank I'm not gonna re-watch a bunch of movies and 1000+ episodes just to start a what-if. So I don't know what movie your talking about.
And again, your the only person to bring this up...so I am inclined not to believe you. no offense.
@@smdbzxproductions9868 Bulbapedia is right there, wikipedia is a google away, even if you're not going to binge the whole series it still isn't that hard to just look at the titles. Not sure why you trust "No one else brought it up" more than a google search, this is a video with 210 likes at point of writing. How many people do you expect to reply to it? How many people do you expect to have actually watched all the movies and binged through the anime? Heck, how many fans ignore the anime entirely and just use the games as their exclusive reference? Offense not taken, but fucking hell you are poorly qualified here.
@@smdbzxproductions9868Late I know, and probably you know of this already, but this guy is talking about the celebi movie third or fourth movie I am pretty sure. In the movie A young Samuel Oak travelled to the future in the time of Ash he and Ash met and so on blah blah skipping to the point the movie is canon to the main story I am pretty sure, can't be certain tho.
Good vid
Thank you! I hope to see you again!
Update the kanto rejoin
He use thunderchock against a ground type , you can only say that
and a randomizer to ohohoho
What is the what if that is being referenced in the vague post?
Bro speaking Yappanese.
Thank you
hey can i ask how you made this video??
you need to be a bit more specific then that bud
@@smdbzxproductions9868 i mean how did you make the transitions and where did you make the template that shows pc and on hand
The template I made with Canva. The transitions were made in edit eith Davinci Resolve.
can you do what if Deadpool was in dragon ball
No.
@@smdbzxproductions9868 how come?
Dosent sound interesting to me.
@@smdbzxproductions9868 fair enough but I do have some more crossover what if ideas
Lay em on me then. Or maybe you could make them yourself.
It'd be cool to mention Abilities. When they're necessary y'know like, if they have Static and get touched in battle, and you just mention how Static just happened. Or Intimidate or whatever.
It kinda feels like they don't hardly exist in the show which is sad lol ^^'
But might be too late to add them into your story 🤔 idk, whatever's comfortable for ya
Yeah it's a little late. We'll introduce them in the next arc.
Abilities weren’t introduced til gen 3, so if we’re pretending this “competent” Ash anime aired in 1997, it wouldn’t make sense for them to know what abilities are.
have him evolve pikachu i know pikachu didnt like evolving but yeah evolution means the pokemon is able to use its max potnetial pikachu won due to plot due to sticking its tail on the ground lt surge in an honourable man wont cheat ateleast in the anime have him evolve squirtle and bulbasaur
If your going to use tm rules then I say rock the abilities
Is Pikachu a male or female?
male.
Love this. On my channel I'm doing something similar. You got a sub out of me friend
Bwah!? The Champion himself has subbed!? Im more nervous already!
Part two is already up, so feel free to watch that too! I'll check you out if I have time.
@@smdbzxproductions9868 For sure I will. You made me laugh so hard fir real.
Ah yes, because "Decent, if not really good" is how you describe the 2nd highest ranked trainer in a world wide competition.
Ah yes, because "if i was smarter, I would already be the best trainer in the world." Is how you describe the 2nd highest ranked trainer in a world wide competition.
@@smdbzxproductions9868 way to prove my point about you types of so called fans.
I mean if you want to prove me wrong, feel free.
But Its fairly safe to say that if you dont even know how to get into the Leauge you've been watching your whole life, dont understand basic-typing, and dont know a pokemon species that lives within view of your house, you can be considered incompetent.