her calling him "Knightley" instead of "Mr.Knightley" and also adressing her husband with an italian nickname to show off her skills, is very ill-mannered in those times and obviously basically saying that the vicar "left Emma behind" when it was the other way around makes her even more unlikeble.
@@rachaelpoulin1997I think those are more from the 1840s (at least in this scene) which is 30 years after the Regency Period. This would be like having folks wearing Y2K fashion on That 70s Show.
This rendition of EMMA is different from all previous due to the abnormal behavior of every character. Not one is "normal". Thus, it is ever so much fun to watch. Well Done!
Yes well, they created a satire that is deliberately over the top. 😆 Except for Miss Taylor, who's in fact wonderfully normal, everyone's a caricature bursting of eccentricity.
@@NiVi192 Word. It feels more like a parody of Jane Austen's book than an adaptation. That, and I loved the fact that movies like the (by now classic?) BBC Pride&Prejudice version didn't insist stuffing the characters into the 1995 fashion. To me that feels like respect towards the audience: _Hi there, we think you are capable of recognizing that a woman is pretty even if we don't put _*_glaringly obvious lipstick_*_ onto her._
This role perhaps a bit more like Charles, but if you want to see Josh O'Connor's acting range, see him in "God's own country". He almost physically transforms.
I love the bit with the pews. The struggle is so real. And that neck ruffle on Mrs. Elton. It looks like she cut her own head off and now it's just floating above her shoulders.
We once visited a church, having recently moved. We had no idea there were seatings that church goers prized and felt very protective of. Wouldn't you know it, we chose, by accident, a pew that "belonged" to a family in the old guard, so to speak. We had no idea. Needless to say, we never went back. A kind deacon did tell us as we left after the service that generally long standing members sat in certain places. I said, "Well, we're sorry to have upset the apple cart. We do wish someone would have told us. We never would have taken their seats. In all fairness though, we thought we were in God's house, not theirs."
@@NanaPapa123 We used to sit in front of an older couple who proudly informed us one Sunday that they had chased off some visitors who tried to sit in "our" pew. We never sat there again!
@@cathipalmer8217 Isn't that something? I'm sure you didn't even know what to say. I wouldn't have thought of a decent reply (until maybe 2 AM, lol) I wish people wouldn't do things like this. :-(
I saw it more as a social hierarchy being displaced. You can see that Emma and Mr. Woodhouse and the Weston's were on one side down the front. They are the landed gentry in the village - they don't have to work. Mr and Mrs Cole are on the aisle across from them down the front, as well Mrs Bates and Miss Bates, with Jane Fairfax. They are the gentry that come from work. Down the back you see Mrs Goddard's school with her girls on the side of Emma's aisle. This is usually because Mrs. Goddard is school for young ladies. Then on the other side the other people of the town. By Mrs. Elton showing up and taking that first row, it upsets the hierarchy. First, because she is now the pastors wife. Second, because she is a new bride. But thirdly, it knocks Emma down a peg for not having the most important seat in the church.
@@stephaniejane306but in the book, Knightley tells Emma that Miss Bates used to have as much status as Emma now has, and it is in poor taste to show her disrespect. Sounds like she's Old Money who came down in the world.
I just noticed Mrs. Elton has what looks a bit like crazy 1830's hair stuck up bun/bow-thing in 1815! I guess they did they to make her look overly into fashion to the point of silliness. EDIT: Also … How the hell did she fit that under her bonnet ?!? (Note: Major bonus points to Emma for NOT LEAVING OUT THE BONNETS as may films set in the regency or other eras of the 19th century do!)
Apart from the weird frilly thing around her neck, I'd say that's a realistic regency evening outfit. It makes about as much sense as Emma Woodhouse wearing a ostrich-feather decorated riding hat at a small town church service. So bascially: Emma get's ridiculously pimped up, but in a way to look good to a 21st century audience. The Eltens get ridiculously pimped up, but in a way to look bad to a 21st century audience. I do wish they'd published this movie as "Wes Anderson's Emma", just as a heads-up.
i love how angry some people are over this perfectly charming movie, not being in the know is my greatest boon when it comes to harmless media consumption
Especially when it comes to anything remotely historical. Background knowledge really kills off willing suspension of disbelief when a a stick-thin Elizabeth Bennet mouth-breaths her way through a regency-era story. And that's _before_ she strolls through the landscape in her PYs.
@@Julia-lk8jn Please know that I agree with you pretty much point for point, and I have MANY gripes with the 2005 movie, but! Keira Knightley being thin is actually one of the few things that I think they got right. We’re given several indications that Elizabeth is thinner than ideal by the beauty standards of the time: Mr Darcy’s second impression of Elizabeth: “Though he had detected with a critical eye more than one failure of perfect symmetry in her form, he was forced to acknowledge her figure to be light and pleasing.” In comparison with Georgiana: “Miss Darcy was tall, and on a larger scale than Elizabeth; and, though little more than sixteen, her figure was formed, and her appearance womanly and graceful.” Caroline, when insulting Elizabeth’s appearance, says: “Her face is too thin”. And finally, in comparison with Jane, who we can assume is more or less the ideal of statuesque beauty: “Jane, who was not so light, nor so much in the habit of running as Elizabeth, soon lagged behind”. Jane Austen was never very descriptive when it came to her characters, so it’s hard to say exactly how thin Elizabeth is-but I think it’s fair to say that she’s probably closer to Knightley than Ehle. Sorry for this mini essay more than a year after your comment, I’m just very attached to the fact that Elizabeth is unconventionally attractive by the standards of her time!
@@kenna163 my other favourite is Julia Stevenson 💕 This one wasn't as sneering, or as ponderous as Julia's version, both of which I loved 😄 Julia was just a bit older for the part, or so she seemed 💓
I love her 1830s hair style. That and the color of the dress are so out of keeping with the 1820s styles and sombre palette of the rest of the characters that it makes her stand out even more as new money and a wannabe. She is like an influencer trying to name drop and be a trendsetter.
I love this version ,every character fits, I almost did not recognize at first Mia Goth.. And Anya is not as beautiful as her role in Queen Gambit......But I love Anya as Emma
So Prince Charles and Lily were there to have a game with Harmond. Lestrade is also there so perhaps someone bad happened, but Miranda’s presence made me feel like this is comedic 🤔 hmm. I am so confused.
Best Movie.... So good directed, great casted and scripted... It was time for Emma re-do cause the other ones are extremely doll and boring even cringe.
i believe it's supposed to be a joke... because she's "old" and probably has bad hearing she probably misheard that they were supposed to rise or something
I know through friends that these two actresses always used to go up for the same roles. Feels like a nod to other adaptions where she looks like Emma.
Immortal Miss Jane Austen at her sateric style at BEST..Was school text for "O" levels!! None have yet created a Matching character for Mrs. Augusta Elton
The most enjoyable parts of this movie are the servants who keep rolling their eyes to oblivion at how ludicrous these gentle folk are
Yes, the eye rolls😂
🙄 No it’s a really lowbrow joke which drags the whole thing down
@@hannahs1683Nah, it's most realistic and terribly amusing.
Wouldn’t have happened though, the working class wouldn’t have been able to read or write, they had no education at all.
@@jemmajames6719 They had ears though. 😅
Emma's father with the tea-cup and the servant is just fantastic lol He looks so stunned by her like "Oh my god...what...what is this woman..."
Ya gotta love Bill Nighy. Always a fabulous performance!
her calling him "Knightley" instead of "Mr.Knightley" and also adressing her husband with an italian nickname to show off her skills, is very ill-mannered in those times and obviously basically saying that the vicar "left Emma behind" when it was the other way around makes her even more unlikeble.
Have you read the book?
Preciselyyyyyy
"for in thy sight!" 😂😂😂
This movie was one of the best things that happened in 2020.
And Mrs. Bates caught the spirit there for a sec cause she had to stand up.
That is an incredibly low bar to clear, good things in 2020 were very scarce.
I love how quirky this adaptation is.
The highly stylized costumes, direction and acting are a real joy.
The costumes are not even that stylized, the regency period just looked like *that* lol
@@rachaelpoulin1997I think those are more from the 1840s (at least in this scene) which is 30 years after the Regency Period. This would be like having folks wearing Y2K fashion on That 70s Show.
@@jonathanbowers8964please know your fashion and don’t talk nonsense, more over this movie has perfect period fashion, 1817 fashion.
This rendition of EMMA is different from all previous due to the abnormal behavior of every character. Not one is "normal". Thus, it is ever so much fun to watch. Well Done!
I couldn't agree more, British period drama/comedy at its best with a dash of dark humour always a tad over-the-top.
i agree! the casting is also very good, all of the actors have a very severe look about them.
Yes well, they created a satire that is deliberately over the top. 😆 Except for Miss Taylor, who's in fact wonderfully normal, everyone's a caricature bursting of eccentricity.
@@NiVi192 Word. It feels more like a parody of Jane Austen's book than an adaptation. That, and I loved the fact that movies like the (by now classic?) BBC Pride&Prejudice version didn't insist stuffing the characters into the 1995 fashion.
To me that feels like respect towards the audience: _Hi there, we think you are capable of recognizing that a woman is pretty even if we don't put _*_glaringly obvious lipstick_*_ onto her._
Emma is meant to be a comedy lol also I’m confused. Are you saying you dislike this movie?
the way I am HOWLING with laughter every time at the way the old lady stands up
She caught the spirit. She had to praise the Lordt.
Me too
It's so hard to unsee him as Charles and be amazed by his behavior.
Charles Who?
@@daffodilsanddogwoods9695 Charles, the prince of Wales
Yes!! Me too! Are you also a fan of The Crown??
Yes! Thank you because I couldn’t figure out where I have seen him before
This role perhaps a bit more like Charles, but if you want to see Josh O'Connor's acting range, see him in "God's own country". He almost physically transforms.
The way Augusta slaps Rev.s hand down while he's reaching for another cupcake!
I also loved how attentive the butler is to Emma's father
I'm dying over the vicar's huge sleeves.
Ok, the level of eccentricity in that room is through the roof, even for British standards. 😂
The way he eats the cake 1:35 is just mood, not a nibble but the whole thing. 😂
john o'connor just having the time of his life hamming it up
I love the bit with the pews. The struggle is so real.
And that neck ruffle on Mrs. Elton. It looks like she cut her own head off and now it's just floating above her shoulders.
We once visited a church, having recently moved. We had no idea there were seatings that church goers prized and felt very protective of. Wouldn't you know it, we chose, by accident, a pew that "belonged" to a family in the old guard, so to speak. We had no idea. Needless to say, we never went back. A kind deacon did tell us as we left after the service that generally long standing members sat in certain places. I said, "Well, we're sorry to have upset the apple cart. We do wish someone would have told us. We never would have taken their seats. In all fairness though, we thought we were in God's house, not theirs."
@@NanaPapa123 We used to sit in front of an older couple who proudly informed us one Sunday that they had chased off some visitors who tried to sit in "our" pew. We never sat there again!
@@cathipalmer8217 Isn't that something? I'm sure you didn't even know what to say. I wouldn't have thought of a decent reply (until maybe 2 AM, lol) I wish people wouldn't do things like this. :-(
I saw it more as a social hierarchy being displaced. You can see that Emma and Mr. Woodhouse and the Weston's were on one side down the front. They are the landed gentry in the village - they don't have to work. Mr and Mrs Cole are on the aisle across from them down the front, as well Mrs Bates and Miss Bates, with Jane Fairfax. They are the gentry that come from work. Down the back you see Mrs Goddard's school with her girls on the side of Emma's aisle. This is usually because Mrs. Goddard is school for young ladies. Then on the other side the other people of the town. By Mrs. Elton showing up and taking that first row, it upsets the hierarchy. First, because she is now the pastors wife. Second, because she is a new bride. But thirdly, it knocks Emma down a peg for not having the most important seat in the church.
@@stephaniejane306but in the book, Knightley tells Emma that Miss Bates used to have as much status as Emma now has, and it is in poor taste to show her disrespect.
Sounds like she's Old Money who came down in the world.
I love how Wes Anderson-esque this movie is ❤
When the old lady stands, she's the same height as everyone else & they're seated😂
Forgive me, the grammar is when she stood..
Give that woman’s laugh an Oscar.
I just noticed Mrs. Elton has what looks a bit like crazy 1830's hair stuck up bun/bow-thing in 1815! I guess they did they to make her look overly into fashion to the point of silliness.
EDIT: Also … How the hell did she fit that under her bonnet ?!? (Note: Major bonus points to Emma for NOT LEAVING OUT THE BONNETS as may films set in the regency or other eras of the 19th century do!)
It reminds me of the stepsisters in the Disney Cinderella. I didn't know that was an actual fashion.
I thought of Olive Oyl. 🤣
@@deniseleaps exactly 😅
She's very fashion forward. Clairvoyant even 😂😂😂
Apart from the weird frilly thing around her neck, I'd say that's a realistic regency evening outfit. It makes about as much sense as Emma Woodhouse wearing a ostrich-feather decorated riding hat at a small town church service.
So bascially:
Emma get's ridiculously pimped up, but in a way to look good to a 21st century audience.
The Eltens get ridiculously pimped up, but in a way to look bad to a 21st century audience.
I do wish they'd published this movie as "Wes Anderson's Emma", just as a heads-up.
Lol her assuming Emma’s dad was hard of hearing
The more times I watch this movie, the more hilarious Emma’s father becomes. By now I’m practiclly howling. 😂
i love how angry some people are over this perfectly charming movie, not being in the know is my greatest boon when it comes to harmless media consumption
Especially when it comes to anything remotely historical. Background knowledge really kills off willing suspension of disbelief when a a stick-thin Elizabeth Bennet mouth-breaths her way through a regency-era story. And that's _before_ she strolls through the landscape in her PYs.
I award you 100 points for correctly using the word boon⭐️
@@Julia-lk8jn Please know that I agree with you pretty much point for point, and I have MANY gripes with the 2005 movie, but! Keira Knightley being thin is actually one of the few things that I think they got right. We’re given several indications that Elizabeth is thinner than ideal by the beauty standards of the time:
Mr Darcy’s second impression of Elizabeth: “Though he had detected with a critical eye more than one failure of perfect symmetry in her form, he was forced to acknowledge her figure to be light and pleasing.”
In comparison with Georgiana: “Miss Darcy was tall, and on a larger scale than Elizabeth; and, though little more than sixteen, her figure was formed, and her appearance womanly and graceful.”
Caroline, when insulting Elizabeth’s appearance, says: “Her face is too thin”.
And finally, in comparison with Jane, who we can assume is more or less the ideal of statuesque beauty: “Jane, who was not so light, nor so much in the habit of running as Elizabeth, soon lagged behind”.
Jane Austen was never very descriptive when it came to her characters, so it’s hard to say exactly how thin Elizabeth is-but I think it’s fair to say that she’s probably closer to Knightley than Ehle. Sorry for this mini essay more than a year after your comment, I’m just very attached to the fact that Elizabeth is unconventionally attractive by the standards of her time!
She is a perfect Mrs. Elton 😂
Christina Cole is
I agree. Tanya did a fantastic job playing as her 🤣
@@kenna163 my other favourite is Julia Stevenson 💕 This one wasn't as sneering, or as ponderous as Julia's version, both of which I loved 😄 Julia was just a bit older for the part, or so she seemed 💓
The best Jane Austen Film I have ever seen, so brilliant and perfect in absolutely every way!
My favourite Lily.
Wish she does many many more projects.
This adaptation was such a gem
The vicar has major Lady Gaga vibes
Maple grove check
Mr. E. check
Knightley check
Caro sposo check
Jane Austen subtlety out, Wes Anderson quirkiness in - double check
Not enough Maple Grove. In the books she talked about it so much I wanted to scream
i feel like Josh o Conner wouldve slayed in that vicars robe at Met Gala!
I could watch this scene on a loop and still laugh as if it the first time I saw it.especially the ( but in thy sight) when the old lady stands up.
I didnot even know this version of Emma exist. Now I have to see it.
It's on netflix~
Love it
It really is quite good
It came out in 2020
i mean seriously, the silhouettes of the costuming are amazing in this movie
I do love how the first convocation with Emma and Mrs Elton is full of so many social errors.
And the decor colors are dazzling.
I love her 1830s hair style. That and the color of the dress are so out of keeping with the 1820s styles and sombre palette of the rest of the characters that it makes her stand out even more as new money and a wannabe. She is like an influencer trying to name drop and be a trendsetter.
Augusta is funny! Can't help but laugh when she speaks 🤣
The Eltons are so perfectly...Spaaaace Alien in this one. So good!
I love how cartoony the characters look. She looks like a poodle 🐩
This vicar new wife is an entertainment itself 😅
If this was made in the 70s-80s Shelly Duvall would play the Vicar's wife
Well then, this actress would be a good Olive Oil in Popeye.
"for in thy sIGHT!!" lmfao
impressive atmosphere and colour combination indeed.
Can we just appreciate the make artist please? Seriously,
hands on🙌🙌
Yep, that's a perfect 2020 look in a regency era story, no question. Oh joy!
Josh O'Connor's delivery always makes me lose it. "For in THY SIGHT" and "Innoe -cence" are so funny
No one wants to be the Mrs. Elton of the group yet somehow…
all those brilliant stars actors. my goodness!
This actress was used to read out the Emma audiobook and it is stunning - like a one woman play
why is prince charles transported to the regency era? time machine? and where's camilla?
She would fit in there perfectly.
Maybe under-cover as Mrs Elton?
I saw this movie when it came out and had forgotten how funny it was.
I love this movie version!
I love this version ,every character fits, I almost did not recognize at first Mia Goth.. And Anya is not as beautiful as her role in Queen Gambit......But I love Anya as Emma
Remind me not to invite the vicar and his wife to any function at my house. :)
,poor guy. Wasn't allowed to take a cookie!
I like the vicar's wife: she doesn't pretend to be anything she isn't, just to please the others
Mrs Elton is my favourite snob in the Jane Austen world.
Я понимаю, что по контексту она ведёт себя не очень воспитанно, но чёрт, как же прекрасно льется её речь. Просто молодец актриса)
I forgot how funny this movie is
The vicer's wife is always annoying in each version.
When she runs down, do you twist that thing on top of her head to wind her up again?
I never thought that I could be more attracted to Josh O’Conner than I already am. But, that collar is doing it for me…
Mia Goth and Anya T-J in the same gorgeous movie!
They were also together in the psychological thriller, Marrowbone.
Tanya Reynolds characters are always " Different " ! Love this one !
We all know somebody like Mrs Elton amongst our acquaintances.
I forget how much of a masterpiece this movie was
I enjoyed her character haha
Dear sweet mother of all that's holy, WHAT IS THAT ON HER HEAD?!!
The bow? It’s her hair.
Latest fashion of the day 😅
@@mariar3767 1830s actually but it still works so well for mrs. elton bc it's so ridiculous
@@avengerwidow9 she was ahead of her time.
@@ameliecarre4783 she truly was lol 😂
Historical question: were church services really that small (2-3 dozen people) for that class of people back in those times?
Yes. UK country churches are rather small, as they tended to only need to support villages and smaller communities.
yes. Highbury was not meant to be a big village. Pretty much every estate and village had a church, so they only needed to support the locals.
The old lady looks so much shorter standing next to miranda😂
In thy SIGHT!!
0:18 she’s actually really pretty 😍
Is there like two wedding cakes in the room during tea? Like theres one behind Ms Smith and another behind the Eltons. Who needs THAT much cake
So Prince Charles and Lily were there to have a game with Harmond. Lestrade is also there so perhaps someone bad happened, but Miranda’s presence made me feel like this is comedic 🤔 hmm. I am so confused.
That interpretation makes this movie *so* much better!
Ok, I don't want to like this twee, self-aware, 'aren't we so clever' vibe, but Mrs. Elton is hilarious.
I am currently very amused.
A good actress!
I want to try the cakes. Close ups of the cakes would have been marvelous
When be surprise is « not acceptable » and you have to hide this expression … this scene all in silence will be tornade i our modern etiquette! 😂
Mrs. Elton is incredibly convincing
,
Best Movie.... So good directed, great casted and scripted... It was time for Emma re-do cause the other ones are extremely doll and boring even cringe.
Agree.
The sets are awesome.
Lily? Is that you?
The look of martyrdom on the groom
I really really enjoyed this movie and visually what a treat!
Be upstanding!
When an Officer walks into the room
Why did the old lady stand up when he shouted SIGHT?
i believe it's supposed to be a joke... because she's "old" and probably has bad hearing she probably misheard that they were supposed to rise or something
@@annacarollina7703 aaah, I see! Thanks Anna
In the liturgy e.g. when the epistle is read everyone stands up.
@@susannabonke8552 ah, thank you
Beth Harmon meets Maxxxine/Pearl meets Prince Charles meets Lily
The Vicar is the best
is that the guy from challengers
Yes
I know through friends that these two actresses always used to go up for the same roles. Feels like a nod to other adaptions where she looks like Emma.
Immortal Miss Jane Austen at her sateric style at BEST..Was school text for "O" levels!!
None have yet created a Matching character for Mrs. Augusta Elton
This scene looks like it's from a children's show.
Loved this film!
I like the wife °'•~.♡.~•'°
She was insulting Emma the entire time
Love the decor can anyone tell me the century??
This gentle people are weird af 😂
this is the vibe and feel I wanted to see in bridgerton
Admire the costumes
Possibly the worst version of Austen ever made.
I desperately want to watch this with a big bag of popcorn and a grape Slurpee 🍿🥤
Simply hilarious.