This person is telling the truth. Personally, I've learned a lot from Mr.Muzamil. I'm from ex-FATA. There were no English teachers around, so I taught myself. Every day, I had to hike to the mountaintop and practice speaking to the trees and rocks. I got a job in Dubai thanks to my English proficiency. 🥰I WANT TO MEET WITH YOU MR.MUZAMIL HASAN .🤝
Very commendable 👍 I only wish there were more in Pakistan with that mindset. In the 60s and 70s, even the domestic help spoke broken English. The change happened when the appeasement of the mullahs was started by Bhutto and then accelerated by Zia. There hasn't been any brain cells spared from religious indoctrination... English is a long long shot
Just like people speaking Urdu consider people speaking pasto, punjabi, Baloch, Sindhi as inferior? In India most of the people can speak or understand English because it’s our second language. But in your case , Urdu(being a foreign/imported {from India}) is your second language and English comes 3rd. Hence the struggle is real!
Urdu is not even our language. It's a colonial project from Western Uttar Pradesh. We will happily prefer English over Urdu anytime, if our mother languages are discriminated against
agreed. More than English, our relationship with Urdu and our regional languages is confusing. We give English way too much importance thanks to colonialism. Due to this our regional languages hve suffered, even more than Urdu.
Bro you are absolutely right. I am in a European research organization. French, Italians spanish and engineers from all over Europe are working here. No one gives a shit about one's command on english. Everyone knows just enough english needed for clear communication.
Very true . Pakistanis do indeed have a confused relationship with English. But this confusion runs very deep and wide into many other areas of life. Should we love or hate the US? India? Arabs? Even overseas Pakistanis? Our own history? As an overseas Pakistani, I notice this very clearly. A country where the majority of ppl are confused on so many levels. The relationship with English is a symptom. Fix the identity you fix the nation. End of confusion. Thank you.
And what do you propose as a solution? Building identity isn’t easy when soo many ethnicities exist. As such religion acts as the only unifying force, and Pakistan has always used Islam to define its identity.
That's a good question. I can only share my experience of living in the West. We can start by teaching the young generation in schools and media, our shared history, values, tolerance towards different ideas and thoughts, our goals etc. The list goes on. Perhaps these things can build a healthy identity.
@@crazyfrog126 True. The Pakistani history that’s taught starts at the Indus Valley, skips everything, then talks about Muslim conquest of Sindh, then Mughals and so on. History shouldn’t be defined by religion. Most Pakistanis don’t even know about the rich Bhuddist, Hindu, and Sikh history they have because it’s been washed over by the Islamic one. Both are important. Both make us who we are today. It’s this notion that leads to Indians claiming our lands history… because we never claimed it. History isn’t defined by religion but by land. Our land has rich history that dates back to the world’s first major civilisation. First History, then we need to dissolve this idea of “ummah”. Most people don’t know that many Muslim countries sided with India in our wars. Most don’t know how much Pakistanis are hated in the Arab and Turkic world. This idea of “ummah” should die out. The recent events in Kyrgyzstan and the Middle East are leading to the end of this ummah idea, which presently I’ve only seen paraded in Pakistan. No other Muslim country cares, everyone is focused on themselves. We need to realise we’re Pakistanis first, Muslims/Hindus/Christians second. Next, provincialism needs to end. When you define provinces by ethnicities it leads to tensions and separatism. Its almost like we have 5 states in a single country; Most punjabis don’t know what Baluchistan is like. Most Pashtuns don’t know what Sindh is like. Pakistan should be divided into sub sectors based on a more equitable system, such as population. Grouping areas of 20 million people or so together will lead to more equitable distribution of funds and so, when economic growth takes place, those fazool ki tensions end. This also prevents one province from becoming a “monopoly” of sorts, like Punjab is today in Pakistan. Another issue this solves is that majority of provincial funds rn go to one city. In Punjab, Lahore. In Sindh, Karachi. In KP, Peshawar. Tied to this point is language. Urdu should be promoted, not forced, to everyone. People should be told that yes its great you’re learning your mother tongue, but learn Urdu and English too. I myself speak 3 languages: Seraiki, Urdu, and English. Promoting a single language will go a long way into promoting connectivity between the various ethnicities, which will lead to a strong sense of community. Coupled with a strong transport system like the one in India, this should make Pakistan a lot more cohesive. I strongly believe one of the prime reasons for the lack of a strong national identity is ethnic nationalism. If you finish ethnic nationalism, you solve a major piece of the puzzle. Next, education. Specifically education in modern science and technology. When you become a potent force in this sector automatically your country has global influence. A better image globally, one shifted from the traditional stereotypes we have, would make Pakistanis prouder a nation, which obviously contributes to national identity. Finally Islam. I’ve visited plenty Muslim countries and I’ve found the Islam in Pakistan to be the worst of the bunch. We don’t have female prayer areas, we have shrines where we worship humans, coexistence with minorities is seen as a sin, and much much more. We need a body of educated Muslim scholars (not the mullahs) to sit and decide on how to propagate true Islam, which at its core is about humanity, peace, community, and love. Extremism is a big issue here and learning the true Islamic faith can heal it. Moreover Islam is about not forcing people to believe in what you believe. Live and let live. Since Pakistan’s identity, and ideology, bases around Islam, we should at least teach the true religion in the country. Idk if all of these things just make sense to me or they do have potential. A more progressive, economically prosperous, and religiously true Pakistan can lead to the construction of a strong unified national identity. I mean we’re gonna celebrate a century of Independence soon. We’re not a new country anymore. Many said Pakistan wouldn’t survive half a decade, but it’s been eight and we’re still here. Idk who’ll ever think to this level, cuz our politicians are just busy playing their game of thrones. As a young proud Pakistani I hope to contribute to this. Apologies for the long ahh comment but Pakistan zindabad.
The economic disparity in Pakistani society has created that haterd. Basically it's not hatred against the English language, rather it's hatred of the deprived class against the privilege d class . It's htred against their superiority complex and their approach and attitudes towards the deprived.
Thank You Jitni Improvement Ap ki Podcast nay ki hain meri English ko Improve karnay may Thank you so Much Dil SE , yeah baat may english may bi likh sakta tha but Urdu may Likhnay may Aik DIl SEY FEEL hain Shukriya!
This a very balanced thought outpouring. A massive skill/talent ocean is not being tapped due to the people having this language barrier. Pakistan's huge resource is its people with a very intelligent brain but not being able understand and to utter few sounds and tone in a specific manner (English)
Yes, but that's still sad in a way that Pakistanis have to learn English and be good at it ( the language which was imposed on us by people who came to our lands from 6000 miles away and colonized us and imposed our culture on us) to find great job, or make a great career. it's so sad. We should keep improving and working on our national language ( Urdu) as well which is our identity in the world and gives us sense of belonging and comfort. People might say English is an international langauage we had to learn it either way even if britishers didn't come but they miss out on most important of points that atleast then we would not have that complex about English which currently prevails in our country. Chinese, French, Japenese ,turks, Italians etc all speak their language and when they speak english they speak on a very basic level without having an english accent while we live in complex until we master it.
That's wholesome discussion. I call it a discussion because my views ere being exchanged exactly like I wanted to. Just recently I pronounced an English word incorrectly and my team had a great laugh on it. My English is quiet good overall, but I heard this word in an Indian podcast and just repeated what they said and even though it was a common word but I mispronounced it and all of them were laughing at me while they cant even say one complete sentence in English. I have been thinking about that insult the whole weekend. But this podcast made me realize that I know it better and I can do better. The gorey clients kept quite but my own "friends/colleagues" made fun of it.
Given the global audience I aim to reach out to, I've kept my language in my videos defaulted to English. This is despite the fact that according to my YT data 74% of my viewers are from Pakistan, even though I'm not based in Pakistan! I've put up videos in Urdu but they didn't do so well, so for me I might as well stick to what works for me. My decision was based on what my data is telling me, not by what random a-holes on the Internet say. So I say go by what your data is telling you. Screw what the rest say. As for those facing ridicule for mispronouncing in a language they're not fluent in, again i say screw what the rest say. You do you.
Muzzamil Bhai, The facts that you mention were so spot on and yes we all need to come out of our past experiences and try to built a growth mindset within our own skin.👍
Just my 2 cents here. I had a similar feeling with India and gave me grave uneasiness thinking that everything is going wrong with my country. It helps a lot when you realize that you are not defined by the country you were born in. And also, we need to get out of this collective mindset where every failure of our countries becomes our personal failure. Once you mentally dissociate yourself from this group thinking, it gives you peace to make your life in whatever you want it to be.
I think people don't realise that most people in the world don't speak english. It's a global language but learning 2-3 languages should be a priority for everyone in Pakistan. It's amazing how well people react when you talk to them in their native language.
Mas Shaa ALLAH Great video message Muzzamil Bhai! This opened my eyes as a person of Pakistani Origin though I speak Urdu verbally and understand comprehensively. Only thing I can't read and write though I am working on reading and writing Urdu. Reason I grew up in the US this was totally dreadful growing up. May ALLAH give us all Hidayah guidance to come up with a middle path. Especially as a multi cultural country.
Absolutely brother couldn't agree more on points raised by you thanks for being a Patriot Pakistani voice...Urdu aati hai mujhe bhi aur mujhe apni zabaan pe fakhar hai angrezi se kam alfaaz mein zyzaada bol sakte hain toh iske istemaal se waqt bachaya ja sakta hai
Thank you Muzammil bhai for this series of Dil ki baat. Every single episode is worth watching but this one won my heart! Exactly been through the same process that you’ve explained.
I think one topic you can discuss out of this current topic is that people lack of patience to listen in first place and urge to give their own opinion also triggers people judge other person language if it is not their own comfort language. Another great podcast! High five from Lithuania! 🙌
I wasn't very good at English but I watched lot of English series and learned English since then I have learned to accept more diversity in terms of language...loving the current series❤
we must learn as many languages as we can, so that we can communicate to as many people as we want. We also promote learning activities . A common person of Balochistan can speak minimum 5 and maximum 7 languages.
27:16 I personally experienced this, last year when I kept a decent-length beard people made certain assumptions about me ky ye to ab molvi bngya, prhai mai itna sharp nhi hoga, aur ye bnda cool ya hasee mazak wala nhi hai, etc. Not even strangers, but my uni friends and family made this persona about me. And now that I have trimmed my beard, people don't think about me like that anymore. I want to learn more about this behavior what is it called if anyone knows about it please tell me
Please do a podcast regarding a sexual orientation, gender identity, overall LGBT community (specifically LGBT community of Pakistan) . I know it's a sensitive topic, but it's also a part of the world. More power to u !! ✊🏼
Yes man , please do talk about the "Pakistani LGBT community ". Also , I want a solution regarding the marginalised community. Muzammil as U mentioned in a podcast earlier "Islam as a state religion" , let's suppose this happens , then how do U think it will impact the community, will LGBT community of Pakistan be able to get any rights under this sort of system!
@@SalahSalah-yt9ldLol , I'm pretty sure that's not even possible in a country where an organized religion is the state religion or a country where the majority of people are Muslims (unless the political system implemented is different). There are over 58 Muslim countries in the world and all of them are hell for their LGBT community, no rights, no representation, no freedom of expression or freedom of speech. Everyday from the past 2-3 years mostly, I could see the influence of Islam growing all over the world, In western countries due to high level of immigrants from Muslim countries, we could see that the Muslims are becoming influential, There have been Muslim led rallies in Britain and Germany regarding demand of Shariah by Muslims and last year in Canada some Muslims organised a million person march against LGBT community of Canada. Horrible!! Moreover, if you see so call red pill or manosphere sort of people they are in a lot of ways inspired by Muslims and a huge number of them are Muslims. If you ask me where the world is going, I'm confidently speaking towards the dark ages but this time led by Islam not Christianity or any other organized religion.
Idk , what could genuinely happen about this . A lot of Muslim Mullahs have promoted falsely things like the whole world that the West is promoting LGBT or things like the a lot of people are becoming Gay etc etc .. all the BS . All I care about is truth and the truth is that, no matter what your religion, what your culture is , what your race is LGBTQ individuals are a part of every society in the world, a small percentage of LGBTQ individuals exist everywhere in the world and it has always been a small percentage, it is a small percentage and it is always going to be a small percentage. If anyone had studied evolution or history, they would know what I'm talking about. No one is promoting anything for God's sake , there are just a bunch of few countries which give equal rights to LGBTQ people and the majority of countries are life threatening, life suffocating of LGBTQ community. 12 countries in the world have a death penalty for LGBTQ individuals and in more than 70 countries in the world it is illegal to identify as LGBTQ, Some people ask why pride matters, this is the reason. This world is not a good place unfortunately. There are 55-58 Islamic countries in the world ig , in all of those countries there is a very hard/ traumatizing repression of LGBTQ community. Also there are people that say that LGBTQ is something that came from the west, BS man BS , they have always been here , in every culture, they exist in every nation. Well , if there's a problem in Western style LGBTQ community, then no worries desi style mein kar lete hain Lol , woh kia hai yahan koi relate karne wala kabhi nahai tha , toh humari Pakistani LGBTQ community me westerners ko hi sunna tha, yah koi dard samajhne wala nahi tha, yahan koi role models nahi they , Yahan sirf nafraatein thein aur hain ... @ Salah Salah you asked about the solution under the Islamic state, I don't think there will be any rights under this sort of situation. As I mentioned earlier 55-58 Islamic countries are there in the world, which practice different versions of Islam but none of them considers LGBTQ rights. Also , 80% of Muslims around the world are fundamentalists, the rest 20% includes moderate Muslims and liberal Muslims and these 20% is going to be irrelevant. In my opinion the Islamism is genuinely rising all over the world, all I could see is a dystopia in the near future... No hopes left . Another thing I want to mention is that the religion of Islam is an expansionist religion, if you read the religion it promotes expansion. So , if anyone wonders why Muslims where ever they go want Islamic laws in those countries, even if they have 55-58 countries by themselves then yk.
Good thoughts. But this is true for every aspect of how people feel superior and make others feel inferior and in the long term effects of their words will affect another person. So, as a society people need to understand that what they speak should be to build others up and make them feel confident and comfortable with themselves and others around them. Its so important. The culture of building each other up will make us united and stronger and will make us a force that people will have to respect and recognize. There’s enough to go around so stop worrying about pulling someone down. Look at your neighboring country, why are they everywhere, because they have a culture of building each other up. Its high time the younger generations change the mindset of their fellow citizens as a a whole and see how everyone takes the nation to new heights. I pray that i get to see a this mindset blossom in the Pakistani people. Once again, very good topic. Way to go.
In your wife’s videos, I’ve noticed that both of you prefer to talk to your child in english . Don’t you think his thought process will always be in english as a first language ? The way you were in a modest school in your elementary days , defined how your roots will be in future ? I’m in States but I wanted my kids to learn urdu as their mother tongue . I struggle to talk in english now because I deliberately used to talk to them in urdu so they can pick the vocabulary. Language is not just a tool of communication but also one of the things that let you assimilate with the local culture and stay grounded to your roots. Why do you want your own child to be westernized from the beginning if you value your own identity ? Please take it as a genuinely curious to know question , no personal attack. Thanks
These are the modern Lawrence (s), instead of Arabia of Pakistan! Here to perpetuate their master Lord McDonald's (McCauley) very intelligent move to replace Farsi with English in whole of Hindustan. This man was indeed very intelligent the locals could not have seen how hard this one language move will hit their roots for centuries to come. Hence this guy and the likes of him even today are a living testament to the British moves of imperialism from culture, society, education and geography. To them ape like imitation of their gora master society is the most important thing to do. Check another 'plyoutube philosopher' just like him called muzammil. All selling the same merchandise i.e. east has nothing good and all thinking should be imported from the west. Many will fall prey to them but a tiny number will remember the wisdom of the east now lost to British looting and pervasive English propaganda.
Behn / bhai, bache ko ARABIC sikhaye, sath me english aur urdu bhi sikhaye. Sikhane ki zarurat nahi hai, bas bache ko aese logo ke ird gird dale jo arabic, urdu, english bol re ho. Homeschool kare. Aur states me rehte hain to din me 3 communities me bhej diya kare, aik english, aik urdu aur aik arabic. sincere advice
Muzamil, this is a very well series of dil ki bat ! I resonate with most of your points, particularly the confusion you describe and your search for solutions. It really hits home for me - I've been through similar thoughts but in a different way. Interestingly, my recent move to the USA has been a real eye-opener. It's forced me to re-evaluate things in a multitude of ways, But after hearing your perspective, I realize this feeling of confusion might actually be normal. Perhaps, it's a necessary step on the path to finding solutions.
The real matter of concern should be why Pakistanis degrade and insult such a rich language called Punjabi, we’re not even allowed to speak Punjabi in our schools , even Punjab’s CM qnd other officials only give speeches in urdu , it’s a very fkd up situation, our establishment and media is killing Punjabi just to unify Pakistan although it doesn’t make any sense
it does make sense, but you have to figure out first what's importance of Pakistan in your eyes and heart. If Pakistan don't matter to you then you can do whatever you want, but if matters to you ( I mean really matters) then you need to prioritize somethings clearly. if you unknowingly falling into somewhere in the middle, you need to get rid of confusion first before discussing this topic
@@farhanathar2256 lol so to be able to unite Pakistan we have to sacrifice our language? That’s a pretty fucked up logic , and why is it only Punjabi, why not ask pashtoons to sacrifice pashtos and sindhis , Balochis and Kashmiris to sacrifice their languages too? Also why urdu then ? Why not make Punjabi or Balochi the national language lol , tum jese logon ki wajah se Pakistan k 2 tukrray huve thay
i'm of the same opinion. From my experience, it is the North Punjabis that are not confident in themselves when they speak their language. I have been living in the Middle East for a decade and it is always Punjabis from North Punjab (Lahore, Sialkot, Sargodha etc) who don't speak Punjabi and it is because they were never taught it from a young age. Your observation is correct, I'm adding on to that. It is not only the govt, but reflection of a larger cultural problem. i have never met a seraiki, baloch or a Pashtun who didn't speak their language.
@@umerghaffar4686 yes, what you gonna do ? will fight north punjabis over it? do you realize the concept of inter marriages as well? People are having marriages outside of their cast, communities through out Pakistan and that's actually good for the country and in helping all Pakistanis become a one nation. and that's very natural and organic as well. Your concept of every Punjabi must speak punjabi is gonna die out anyway in few decades. You should be more concerned about your young guys and girls moving out marrying goras and non muslims and leaving not only their language but their culture, forgetting their roots as well as their religion. that's actually the problem to discuss and solutions should be presented.
muzamil bhai ,please aik dedicated series critical thinking aur analytical thinking pr bhi upload krdein .I will buy your courses even if you charge for those
Urdu is the language of the ashraafs, the progenies of Jahangir-and we have successfully imposed it on both Pakistanis and abos of Bharat. How is that?
@@wahmad8211actually Urdu was the language of the troops. Urdu itself means horde. Farsi was the language of the Mughal emperors and/or Sanskrit were the elite langauges for governance. Later on with Urdu i.e Hindustani evolved in Deccan, lucknow to become what it is and than during partition the elites of UP took it to Pakistan.
I've learned that you speak whatever language you speak, wear whatever type of dress you want to wear it doesn't matters until you look upon someone and stereotype him or her.
This is my personal experience no matter what anyone say . Been 7 working for years and if u speak good English u ll be listened to and people will consider ur remmarks no matter how basic it is and even dumb. But if ur English is bad nobody is gonna take u serious in any firm no matter how productive or beneficial it is thats the truth . My advice is learn the best english to be successful on some level or corporate jobs. Take it or leave it
The mockery goes both ways. And for learning anything the principle that applies is to go forth and when you find yourself not doing it correctly, learn and apply. The ego shouldn’t get in. There’s no failure only feedback
I totally agree with your comments and observations about our society!! I have seen so many people like that!! Now living abroad I realized how unfair cruel and stupid our people are!! Work with Chinese, Russians and people from so many different countries and they speak in their own unique accents and present their work with full confidence!! No one makes fun of anyone of them 😊
the thing is why we have to live ' abroad' to realize these basic things? that should be a normal way of thinking in our country and nobody should drift away from that normal thinking and make English a ' hawwa' to make fun of others or look down upon them. With internet we can search so many non english celebrities speaking english in their own ways and accents yet we somehow don't do that and keep carrying that toxic mindset
السلام علیکم بالکل بھائی مسئلہ زبان کا نہیں بلکہ مسئلہ غلامانہ سوچ کا ہے ۔ ہماری قومی زبان اردو ہے جس کو قوم کا ہر فرد سمجھتا ہے چاہے اس کی اپنی مادری زبان کوئی بھی ہو ۔ ہمارے معاشرے میں کوئی اگر بہت ہی اعلیٰ اور بہترین خیال اردو میں پیش کرتا ہے تو اس کی بات کو اہمیت نہیں دی جاتی جبکہ اگر کوئی فضول سی بات بھی انگلش میں کرے تو اس پر بڑی واہ واہ کی جاتی ہے ۔ ہمارے یہاں احساسِ کمتری پیدا کی گئی ہے English کو elite class کی زبان سمجھا جاتا ہے ۔ انگلش یا کوئی بھی زبان سیکھنا اچھی بات ہے مگر اس کو کوئی achievement سمجھنا یعنی اس کو ایسا سمجھنا کہ جیسے انگلش سیکھ کر کوئی بہت بڑا تیر مارلیا گیا ہے یہ غلط سوچ ہے ۔ انگلش نہ سمجھنے والوں کو کمتر سمجھنا غلط ہے ۔
Well actually u need to understand that the experience is different in different classes. If u speak English in lower middle class they will call burger and angreez whereas if you speak English in upper middle class you are considered prelviliage and parha lika. So it depends on classes, where u get experience.
@@Hayd4rhahahah its the sameas every pakistani loves money but everyone hate rich person and backbitting him. Everyone repects the money but then everyone is also critising him. Its the culture dude which nothing but just confused brain cells.
Thanks you Muzamil Bhai, That's my point which is the entire Pakistan thing about language is ridiculous in our society. This is understanding language as a tool not your ability of your cognitive level. I am so happy about your pretty video and content about this topic and totally agree with you!
I am waiting for your video very desperately the way you clear so much of my concepts about a lot of things is just awesome I wish u could make more legnthy videos with full of knowledge stay strong brother
بہترین وڈیو تھی آپ کی میں بھی کیوں کہ اسلام آباد سے ہوں مجھے بھی کچھ باتیں سننے کو ملتی رہی ہیں لیکن اچھی کہ تمہاری english بہت اچھی ہے ۔۔ لیکن کچھ عرسہ سے مجھے اندازہ ہوا کہ اردو ہماری زبان ہے ہی ہماری پہچان ہے ۔ میں نے ویسے تو تعلیم و تربیت ۔ ایک اردو رسالہ ہے اس کو پرھ کے اپنی اردو کو بہتر کیا ہے اور اب میں نے ایک اور اقدام کیا ہے کہ اپنے whatsapp کی ڈیفالٹ زبان اردو کردی ہے ۔ میں آپ کو lolz studios کے وقت سے جانتی ہوں ۔ آپ کم views سے ہر گز افسردا نا ہونا کیونکہ آپ کے content میں بہت میار ہے ۔ سلامت رہیں۔
Dear friend, in India, as per our educational policy, we follow the 3-Language formula. Hindi, English and language 0f the State. We have 22 Constitutionally recognized local languages. These are all on our currency notes, also. Now increasingly a trend is coming where school level (primary) children can take one more foreign language. One of my grandkids has the French language, for that matter. In addition, every State is encouraged to select another State for their school level children to learn about that State's some parts of language, like salutations, greetings, etc. And major aspects of culture. I live in Haryana .This State has made mantory for schools to help school children learn about TELGU language. The language spoken in our two States : Telangana and Andhra Pradesh. This is in addition to full detailed geography, history, and culture etc taught at the school level. Believe me, I am connected to teaching methodologies, school level children learn new languages very fast. Now a days, with RUclips, no skill is away from you, including foreign languages. There are umpteen channels teaching languages. In seventies, I am in the process of learning Tamil and Urdu. All the Best Beta. You are doing a good job. God bless you. 🙏
Although the title is alien to the content of the video yet we as Pakistani actually need to treat "English" as a language like all other languages and I almost agree with vid 👍🏻 😊
Its not like we Pakistani hate it rather its unethical and cause confusion in understanding to speak with your native ppl in other languages when u can speak your native language plus the inferiority complex thing apparently seems hating on the English language yet its not actually hate lol , we have made it overrated for no reason
I agree, title is misleading... hate wala concept tu exist hi nahi krta.. yahan English ka hawwa hai... title should have been ' English ka hawwa among Pakistanis'
Correction: @1:32 American spanish and french seekh nae rahay hutay. unko schools mein parhai ja rahi huti hai. A caveat, Eastern europeans use Russian as a overlapping language like we do with Urdu. They still hate Russians in general. UK mein bhe curriculum ka part huta hai. White Americans and English have the lowest tendency to learn a second language. A simple way to understand this is, Latin is taught in Italy but we don't see Italians talking in Latin. Same goes, Arabic is taught in Pakistan but you don't see Pakistani's speaking Arabic. That begs the question why not arabic?
Having worked at Teach for Pakistan as a science teacher in underprivileged area i agree 💯 I fought my school admin that i will only teach in Urdu ..why should a child suffer in Science if his English is weak Alhamdulillah my students did excellent and excelled in critical thinking
پاکستانی انگریزی نہیں بولتے؛ وہ englu -urdish بولتے ہیں۔ اور نتیجہ یہ ںکلتا ہے کہ وہ نہ اردو میں اہل پیں اور نہ انگریزی میں۔ عین اس میزبان کی طرح ۔ 😂😂😂
Very interesting podcast. Though i keep having a silly reoccurring thought. Why Daer rupeyea not Dhai rupeyea!!?😅 Anyways always a please to hear a sensible person speaking.
I disagree on the unified education system - people of different means will educate their children differently. We need to build an economy that will allow people to grow, naturally people with skills and abilities will nourish irrespective of their education system. I think formal education is overrated.
200 marks for English in CSS is a literal scam. I passed all other subjects with good marks (all in English) and they failed majority including me in English itself. 😅
Hen, Urdu Pakistani ki “local” language kaise ban gai bhai? It was the language of UP royals, adopted by partitioned Punjabi landlords to create a forced linguistic identity for Pakistan. Urdu is still one of the Primary languages recognized in India.
English is obviously important because education in Pakistan is completely in english. But I don't want Urdu to be corroupted by English and the decline in urdu poetry is also very heartbreaking. Not to mention, Pakistanis who understand English are often heavily influenced by the western social media and the general western trends hence the reason of decline in religion.
@@mahmad8528 Asa vasta asi kanda AA Ka Urdu di jaga ta Pakistan di Native Languages nu National Languages da darja dana Jai da wa Nal Ka Ganga Jamna di Language nu jari 24 Million Pakistaniya ta Enforce kiti hoi aa
The only problem I have with the people who cannot speak English in our country is that they have been taught this language throughout their student lives as a mandatory subject. And yet they are unable to form a basic meaningful sentence. I would have had no problem if English was only learnt by the few and only for the sake of learning an extra language but our people should have been able to speak as they have studied this language as a mandatory requirement for their course of study.
The reason people are unable to learn English is that the quality of our education is extremely poor. And secondly, I don't understand why we are still running after this language of our colonial masters, most of the rich and developed countries have everything in their own language.
The language of majority in Pakistan is Punjabi. So, it should be medium of communication in Punjab. English should be learnt as second language. Urdu is extra burden for folks.
@@Mohdaguj Ban Urdu. what next? Ban Siraki and Hindko as well? But who gonna ban cultural problems that exist between different regions? Central Punjab look down upon every other punjabi from south or from the north? Urdu is not the problem. Grow up and focus on actual problems and try to solve those in an educated manner
This person is telling the truth. Personally, I've learned a lot from Mr.Muzamil. I'm from ex-FATA. There were no English teachers around, so I taught myself. Every day, I had to hike to the mountaintop and practice speaking to the trees and rocks. I got a job in Dubai thanks to my English proficiency. 🥰I WANT TO MEET WITH YOU MR.MUZAMIL HASAN .🤝
Very commendable 👍 I only wish there were more in Pakistan with that mindset. In the 60s and 70s, even the domestic help spoke broken English. The change happened when the appeasement of the mullahs was started by Bhutto and then accelerated by Zia. There hasn't been any brain cells spared from religious indoctrination... English is a long long shot
Ur comment is really inspiring for me. I also want to learn eng. Plz can u help me in it.
Interesting idea how to talk with yourself
@@KamranKhan-ey4lh Never stop learning
@@andleebraja5678 The easiest way to learn NEVER STOP LEARNING .
the issue is not speaking English. the issue is English speaking people normally consider Urdu speaking inferior. This is the prime issue!
Just like people speaking Urdu consider people speaking pasto, punjabi, Baloch, Sindhi as inferior?
In India most of the people can speak or understand English because it’s our second language. But in your case , Urdu(being a foreign/imported {from India}) is your second language and English comes 3rd.
Hence the struggle is real!
You guys have superiority and inferiority complex at the same time, backed by a culture of victim hood!
Btw loved the AAYI AAYI ! ❤
Urdu is not even our language. It's a colonial project from Western Uttar Pradesh. We will happily prefer English over Urdu anytime, if our mother languages are discriminated against
agreed. More than English, our relationship with Urdu and our regional languages is confusing. We give English way too much importance thanks to colonialism. Due to this our regional languages hve suffered, even more than Urdu.
😂😂😂😂 phir english bhi colonial hai angrezon ke najayaz bete@@mantiquenawaz823
I am on ly at the 16-minute mark, and I must say, Bro, you have nailed it. Keep going! Pakistan really needs people like you.
Bro you are absolutely right. I am in a European research organization. French, Italians spanish and engineers from all over Europe are working here. No one gives a shit about one's command on english. Everyone knows just enough english needed for clear communication.
Very true . Pakistanis do indeed have a confused relationship with English. But this confusion runs very deep and wide into many other areas of life. Should we love or hate the US? India? Arabs? Even overseas Pakistanis? Our own history?
As an overseas Pakistani, I notice this very clearly. A country where the majority of ppl are confused on so many levels. The relationship with English is a symptom.
Fix the identity you fix the nation. End of confusion. Thank you.
And what do you propose as a solution? Building identity isn’t easy when soo many ethnicities exist. As such religion acts as the only unifying force, and Pakistan has always used Islam to define its identity.
That's a good question. I can only share my experience of living in the West. We can start by teaching the young generation in schools and media, our shared history, values, tolerance towards different ideas and thoughts, our goals etc. The list goes on. Perhaps these things can build a healthy identity.
@@crazyfrog126 True. The Pakistani history that’s taught starts at the Indus Valley, skips everything, then talks about Muslim conquest of Sindh, then Mughals and so on. History shouldn’t be defined by religion. Most Pakistanis don’t even know about the rich Bhuddist, Hindu, and Sikh history they have because it’s been washed over by the Islamic one. Both are important. Both make us who we are today. It’s this notion that leads to Indians claiming our lands history… because we never claimed it. History isn’t defined by religion but by land. Our land has rich history that dates back to the world’s first major civilisation.
First History, then we need to dissolve this idea of “ummah”. Most people don’t know that many Muslim countries sided with India in our wars. Most don’t know how much Pakistanis are hated in the Arab and Turkic world. This idea of “ummah” should die out. The recent events in Kyrgyzstan and the Middle East are leading to the end of this ummah idea, which presently I’ve only seen paraded in Pakistan. No other Muslim country cares, everyone is focused on themselves. We need to realise we’re Pakistanis first, Muslims/Hindus/Christians second.
Next, provincialism needs to end. When you define provinces by ethnicities it leads to tensions and separatism. Its almost like we have 5 states in a single country; Most punjabis don’t know what Baluchistan is like. Most Pashtuns don’t know what Sindh is like. Pakistan should be divided into sub sectors based on a more equitable system, such as population. Grouping areas of 20 million people or so together will lead to more equitable distribution of funds and so, when economic growth takes place, those fazool ki tensions end. This also prevents one province from becoming a “monopoly” of sorts, like Punjab is today in Pakistan. Another issue this solves is that majority of provincial funds rn go to one city. In Punjab, Lahore. In Sindh, Karachi. In KP, Peshawar.
Tied to this point is language. Urdu should be promoted, not forced, to everyone. People should be told that yes its great you’re learning your mother tongue, but learn Urdu and English too. I myself speak 3 languages: Seraiki, Urdu, and English. Promoting a single language will go a long way into promoting connectivity between the various ethnicities, which will lead to a strong sense of community. Coupled with a strong transport system like the one in India, this should make Pakistan a lot more cohesive. I strongly believe one of the prime reasons for the lack of a strong national identity is ethnic nationalism. If you finish ethnic nationalism, you solve a major piece of the puzzle.
Next, education. Specifically education in modern science and technology. When you become a potent force in this sector automatically your country has global influence. A better image globally, one shifted from the traditional stereotypes we have, would make Pakistanis prouder a nation, which obviously contributes to national identity.
Finally Islam. I’ve visited plenty Muslim countries and I’ve found the Islam in Pakistan to be the worst of the bunch. We don’t have female prayer areas, we have shrines where we worship humans, coexistence with minorities is seen as a sin, and much much more. We need a body of educated Muslim scholars (not the mullahs) to sit and decide on how to propagate true Islam, which at its core is about humanity, peace, community, and love. Extremism is a big issue here and learning the true Islamic faith can heal it. Moreover Islam is about not forcing people to believe in what you believe.
Live and let live. Since Pakistan’s identity, and ideology, bases around Islam, we should at least teach the true religion in the country.
Idk if all of these things just make sense to me or they do have potential. A more progressive, economically prosperous, and religiously true Pakistan can lead to the construction of a strong unified national identity. I mean we’re gonna celebrate a century of Independence soon. We’re not a new country anymore. Many said Pakistan wouldn’t survive half a decade, but it’s been eight and we’re still here. Idk who’ll ever think to this level, cuz our politicians are just busy playing their game of thrones. As a young proud Pakistani I hope to contribute to this. Apologies for the long ahh comment but Pakistan zindabad.
@@Zecos You made some excellent points. I could not have articulated them better myself. Well done sir!
@@crazyfrog126 *madam :3 but ty 💚
The economic disparity in Pakistani society has created that haterd. Basically it's not hatred against the English language, rather it's hatred of the deprived class against the privilege d class . It's htred against their superiority complex and their approach and attitudes towards the deprived.
Usually I don't comment but to appreciate you I am doing this: You are doing amazing job by educating us for real.
"Pakistan got independence, Pakistanis never got independence "
100% truth
Pakistan never got independence
It just had a change of master
Thank You Jitni Improvement Ap ki Podcast nay ki hain meri English ko Improve karnay may Thank you so Much Dil SE , yeah baat may english may bi likh sakta tha but Urdu may Likhnay may Aik DIl SEY FEEL hain Shukriya!
This a very balanced thought outpouring. A massive skill/talent ocean is not being tapped due to the people having this language barrier. Pakistan's huge resource is its people with a very intelligent brain but not being able understand and to utter few sounds and tone in a specific manner (English)
Yes, but that's still sad in a way that Pakistanis have to learn English and be good at it ( the language which was imposed on us by people who came to our lands from 6000 miles away and colonized us and imposed our culture on us) to find great job, or make a great career. it's so sad. We should keep improving and working on our national language ( Urdu) as well which is our identity in the world and gives us sense of belonging and comfort.
People might say English is an international langauage we had to learn it either way even if britishers didn't come but they miss out on most important of points that atleast then we would not have that complex about English which currently prevails in our country. Chinese, French, Japenese ,turks, Italians etc all speak their language and when they speak english they speak on a very basic level without having an english accent while we live in complex until we master it.
Very refreshing and thoughtful! Keep these videos coming!
That's wholesome discussion. I call it a discussion because my views ere being exchanged exactly like I wanted to. Just recently I pronounced an English word incorrectly and my team had a great laugh on it. My English is quiet good overall, but I heard this word in an Indian podcast and just repeated what they said and even though it was a common word but I mispronounced it and all of them were laughing at me while they cant even say one complete sentence in English. I have been thinking about that insult the whole weekend. But this podcast made me realize that I know it better and I can do better. The gorey clients kept quite but my own "friends/colleagues" made fun of it.
That was pretty good P.O.V very raw and pure from heart.
This topic was never communicated like this before. Perfect.✌️
Given the global audience I aim to reach out to, I've kept my language in my videos defaulted to English. This is despite the fact that according to my YT data 74% of my viewers are from Pakistan, even though I'm not based in Pakistan! I've put up videos in Urdu but they didn't do so well, so for me I might as well stick to what works for me. My decision was based on what my data is telling me, not by what random a-holes on the Internet say.
So I say go by what your data is telling you. Screw what the rest say.
As for those facing ridicule for mispronouncing in a language they're not fluent in, again i say screw what the rest say. You do you.
We need more people like you Muzammil. Such a quality piece of content. Stay blessed and keep educating to those need it the most :)
Muzzamil Bhai, The facts that you mention were so spot on and yes we all need to come out of our past experiences and try to built a growth mindset within our own skin.👍
Make a video on "existential crisis" because we are in the dillema of thinking that everything in Pakistan is wrong.
Great suggestion
Good idea
@Riz12315acceptance is the first step
Just my 2 cents here. I had a similar feeling with India and gave me grave uneasiness thinking that everything is going wrong with my country. It helps a lot when you realize that you are not defined by the country you were born in. And also, we need to get out of this collective mindset where every failure of our countries becomes our personal failure.
Once you mentally dissociate yourself from this group thinking, it gives you peace to make your life in whatever you want it to be.
100% agree. The problem is not the language but the mindset that people needs to change.
louder!!
another insightful video on an important topic
I think people don't realise that most people in the world don't speak english. It's a global language but learning 2-3 languages should be a priority for everyone in Pakistan. It's amazing how well people react when you talk to them in their native language.
Mas Shaa ALLAH Great video message Muzzamil Bhai! This opened my eyes as a person of Pakistani Origin though I speak Urdu verbally and understand comprehensively. Only thing I can't read and write though I am working on reading and writing Urdu. Reason I grew up in the US this was totally dreadful growing up. May ALLAH give us all Hidayah guidance to come up with a middle path. Especially as a multi cultural country.
Absolutely brother couldn't agree more on points raised by you thanks for being a Patriot Pakistani voice...Urdu aati hai mujhe bhi aur mujhe apni zabaan pe fakhar hai angrezi se kam alfaaz mein zyzaada bol sakte hain toh iske istemaal se waqt bachaya ja sakta hai
What a thought. Great Work Man!
Thank you Muzammil bhai for this series of Dil ki baat. Every single episode is worth watching but this one won my heart! Exactly been through the same process that you’ve explained.
I think one topic you can discuss out of this current topic is that people lack of patience to listen in first place and urge to give their own opinion also triggers people judge other person language if it is not their own comfort language. Another great podcast! High five from Lithuania! 🙌
I wasn't very good at English but I watched lot of English series and learned English since then I have learned to accept more diversity in terms of language...loving the current series❤
U no need to be. Good or bad thing has been dictated by grammarians who held the view of prescriptivism. Mistakes are even good for language learning.
His quality of content is really incredible. Keep it up. 💯
That's why I considered him a true teacher
this series is an absolute gem, eagerly waiting for more topics
we must learn as many languages as we can, so that we can communicate to as many people as we want. We also promote learning activities . A common person of Balochistan can speak minimum 5 and maximum 7 languages.
dialects you mean.
@@arunpatidar6335 Balochi, Birahvi, Pashto, Urdu, Farsi. these are diferent languages. Only Balochi has more than 5 dialects.
not many.. pick one english, french, german, chinese and speak with clear accent
@@arifcr6581 the more you learn 🤯
@@sitepad not necessary when your neighboring country is Afghanistan and Iran.
27:16 I personally experienced this, last year when I kept a decent-length beard people made certain assumptions about me ky ye to ab molvi bngya, prhai mai itna sharp nhi hoga, aur ye bnda cool ya hasee mazak wala nhi hai, etc. Not even strangers, but my uni friends and family made this persona about me. And now that I have trimmed my beard, people don't think about me like that anymore.
I want to learn more about this behavior what is it called if anyone knows about it please tell me
English is not a big problem now. With internet non English schools students are also getting fluent in English..
Please do a podcast regarding a sexual orientation, gender identity, overall LGBT community (specifically LGBT community of Pakistan) . I know it's a sensitive topic, but it's also a part of the world.
More power to u !! ✊🏼
Yes man , please do talk about the "Pakistani LGBT community ". Also , I want a solution regarding the marginalised community.
Muzammil as U mentioned in a podcast earlier "Islam as a state religion" , let's suppose this happens , then how do U think it will impact the community, will LGBT community of Pakistan be able to get any rights under this sort of system!
@@SalahSalah-yt9ldLol , I'm pretty sure that's not even possible in a country where an organized religion is the state religion or a country where the majority of people are Muslims (unless the political system implemented is different). There are over 58 Muslim countries in the world and all of them are hell for their LGBT community, no rights, no representation, no freedom of expression or freedom of speech.
Everyday from the past 2-3 years mostly, I could see the influence of Islam growing all over the world, In western countries due to high level of immigrants from Muslim countries, we could see that the Muslims are becoming influential, There have been Muslim led rallies in Britain and Germany regarding demand of Shariah by Muslims and last year in Canada some Muslims organised a million person march against LGBT community of Canada. Horrible!!
Moreover, if you see so call red pill or manosphere sort of people they are in a lot of ways inspired by Muslims and a huge number of them are Muslims.
If you ask me where the world is going, I'm confidently speaking towards the dark ages but this time led by Islam not Christianity or any other organized religion.
Idk , what could genuinely happen about this . A lot of Muslim Mullahs have promoted falsely things like the whole world that the West is promoting LGBT or things like the a lot of people are becoming Gay etc etc .. all the BS . All I care about is truth and the truth is that, no matter what your religion, what your culture is , what your race is LGBTQ individuals are a part of every society in the world, a small percentage of LGBTQ individuals exist everywhere in the world and it has always been a small percentage, it is a small percentage and it is always going to be a small percentage. If anyone had studied evolution or history, they would know what I'm talking about.
No one is promoting anything for God's sake , there are just a bunch of few countries which give equal rights to LGBTQ people and the majority of countries are life threatening, life suffocating of LGBTQ community.
12 countries in the world have a death penalty for LGBTQ individuals and in more than 70 countries in the world it is illegal to identify as LGBTQ, Some people ask why pride matters, this is the reason.
This world is not a good place unfortunately.
There are 55-58 Islamic countries in the world ig , in all of those countries there is a very hard/ traumatizing repression of LGBTQ community.
Also there are people that say that LGBTQ is something that came from the west, BS man BS , they have always been here , in every culture, they exist in every nation. Well , if there's a problem in Western style LGBTQ community, then no worries desi style mein kar lete hain Lol , woh kia hai yahan koi relate karne wala kabhi nahai tha , toh humari Pakistani LGBTQ community me westerners ko hi sunna tha, yah koi dard samajhne wala nahi tha, yahan koi role models nahi they , Yahan sirf nafraatein thein aur hain ...
@ Salah Salah you asked about the solution under the Islamic state, I don't think there will be any rights under this sort of situation. As I mentioned earlier 55-58 Islamic countries are there in the world, which practice different versions of Islam but none of them considers LGBTQ rights. Also , 80% of Muslims around the world are fundamentalists, the rest 20% includes moderate Muslims and liberal Muslims and these 20% is going to be irrelevant.
In my opinion the Islamism is genuinely rising all over the world, all I could see is a dystopia in the near future... No hopes left .
Another thing I want to mention is that the religion of Islam is an expansionist religion, if you read the religion it promotes expansion. So , if anyone wonders why Muslims where ever they go want Islamic laws in those countries, even if they have 55-58 countries by themselves then yk.
This is the first time I've seen any LGBT regarding discussion under Muzammil 's video 😂
@@SalahSalah-yt9ld There is no space for LGBTQ in Islam.
Good thoughts. But this is true for every aspect of how people feel superior and make others feel inferior and in the long term effects of their words will affect another person. So, as a society people need to understand that what they speak should be to build others up and make them feel confident and comfortable with themselves and others around them. Its so important. The culture of building each other up will make us united and stronger and will make us a force that people will have to respect and recognize. There’s enough to go around so stop worrying about pulling someone down. Look at your neighboring country, why are they everywhere, because they have a culture of building each other up. Its high time the younger generations change the mindset of their fellow citizens as a a whole and see how everyone takes the nation to new heights. I pray that i get to see a this mindset blossom in the Pakistani people. Once again, very good topic. Way to go.
In your wife’s videos, I’ve noticed that both of you prefer to talk to your child in english . Don’t you think his thought process will always be in english as a first language ? The way you were in a modest school in your elementary days , defined how your roots will be in future ? I’m in States but I wanted my kids to learn urdu as their mother tongue . I struggle to talk in english now because I deliberately used to talk to them in urdu so they can pick the vocabulary. Language is not just a tool of communication but also one of the things that let you assimilate with the local culture and stay grounded to your roots. Why do you want your own child to be westernized from the beginning if you value your own identity ? Please take it as a genuinely curious to know question , no personal attack. Thanks
These are the modern Lawrence (s), instead of Arabia of Pakistan! Here to perpetuate their master Lord McDonald's (McCauley) very intelligent move to replace Farsi with English in whole of Hindustan. This man was indeed very intelligent the locals could not have seen how hard this one language move will hit their roots for centuries to come.
Hence this guy and the likes of him even today are a living testament to the British moves of imperialism from culture, society, education and geography.
To them ape like imitation of their gora master society is the most important thing to do. Check another 'plyoutube philosopher' just like him called muzammil. All selling the same merchandise i.e. east has nothing good and all thinking should be imported from the west.
Many will fall prey to them but a tiny number will remember the wisdom of the east now lost to British looting and pervasive English propaganda.
Calm down, bro. It's not that deep.
Behn / bhai, bache ko ARABIC sikhaye, sath me english aur urdu bhi sikhaye.
Sikhane ki zarurat nahi hai, bas bache ko aese logo ke ird gird dale jo arabic, urdu, english bol re ho.
Homeschool kare. Aur states me rehte hain to din me 3 communities me bhej diya kare, aik english, aik urdu aur aik arabic.
sincere advice
@@bobbyeditz765 It's deep
Thank you Muzzamil Hassan Bhai❤
Very to the point and realistic overview on the topic.Well done
What's about our native languages why we should leave them we discurrage forceful imposition of Urdu.
Right
Put off your Urdu bashing for a moment and tell him why do you hate English?
Muzamil, this is a very well series of dil ki bat ! I resonate with most of your points, particularly the confusion you describe and your search for solutions. It really hits home for me - I've been through similar thoughts but in a different way. Interestingly, my recent move to the USA has been a real eye-opener. It's forced me to re-evaluate things in a multitude of ways, But after hearing your perspective, I realize this feeling of confusion might actually be normal. Perhaps, it's a necessary step on the path to finding solutions.
The real matter of concern should be why Pakistanis degrade and insult such a rich language called Punjabi, we’re not even allowed to speak Punjabi in our schools , even Punjab’s CM qnd other officials only give speeches in urdu , it’s a very fkd up situation, our establishment and media is killing Punjabi just to unify Pakistan although it doesn’t make any sense
it does make sense, but you have to figure out first what's importance of Pakistan in your eyes and heart. If Pakistan don't matter to you then you can do whatever you want, but if matters to you ( I mean really matters) then you need to prioritize somethings clearly. if you unknowingly falling into somewhere in the middle, you need to get rid of confusion first before discussing this topic
@@farhanathar2256 lol so to be able to unite Pakistan we have to sacrifice our language? That’s a pretty fucked up logic , and why is it only Punjabi, why not ask pashtoons to sacrifice pashtos and sindhis , Balochis and Kashmiris to sacrifice their languages too?
Also why urdu then ? Why not make Punjabi or Balochi the national language lol , tum jese logon ki wajah se Pakistan k 2 tukrray huve thay
i'm of the same opinion. From my experience, it is the North Punjabis that are not confident in themselves when they speak their language. I have been living in the Middle East for a decade and it is always Punjabis from North Punjab (Lahore, Sialkot, Sargodha etc) who don't speak Punjabi and it is because they were never taught it from a young age. Your observation is correct, I'm adding on to that. It is not only the govt, but reflection of a larger cultural problem. i have never met a seraiki, baloch or a Pashtun who didn't speak their language.
@@umerghaffar4686 yes, what you gonna do ? will fight north punjabis over it? do you realize the concept of inter marriages as well? People are having marriages outside of their cast, communities through out Pakistan and that's actually good for the country and in helping all Pakistanis become a one nation. and that's very natural and organic as well. Your concept of every Punjabi must speak punjabi is gonna die out anyway in few decades. You should be more concerned about your young guys and girls moving out marrying goras and non muslims and leaving not only their language but their culture, forgetting their roots as well as their religion. that's actually the problem to discuss and solutions should be presented.
Because we are enslaved nation and colonialized already!
Excellent podcast Muzamil. Though the title is a bit misleading but to get clarity watch complete podcast.
I'd still happily watch Muzamil's content even if it is in English!✌️
Amazing content, so insightful love to binge listen!
WHY THIS CHANNEL IS UNDERRATTED ?
muzamil bhai ,please aik dedicated series critical thinking aur analytical thinking pr bhi upload krdein .I will buy your courses even if you charge for those
Urdu is an Indian origin language, adopted by Pakistan
@callmefahdi just stated the fact.
@callmefahdi Fact Ganga jamna di olad
Wtf indian?
It was a subcontinent language which was adapted by Bharat and Pakistan because they were part of the subcontinent!
Urdu is the language of the ashraafs, the progenies of Jahangir-and we have successfully imposed it on both Pakistanis and abos of Bharat. How is that?
@@wahmad8211actually Urdu was the language of the troops. Urdu itself means horde. Farsi was the language of the Mughal emperors and/or Sanskrit were the elite langauges for governance. Later on with Urdu i.e Hindustani evolved in Deccan, lucknow to become what it is and than during partition the elites of UP took it to Pakistan.
your videos are the reflection of my thoughts. thankyou for being on youtube OG.
I've learned that you speak whatever language you speak, wear whatever type of dress you want to wear it doesn't matters until you look upon someone and stereotype him or her.
This is my personal experience no matter what anyone say . Been 7 working for years and if u speak good English u ll be listened to and people will consider ur remmarks no matter how basic it is and even dumb. But if ur English is bad nobody is gonna take u serious in any firm no matter how productive or beneficial it is thats the truth . My advice is learn the best english to be successful on some level or corporate jobs. Take it or leave it
muzamil bhai ,you are doing a good job. just keep going .....😍
The mockery goes both ways.
And for learning anything the principle that applies is to go forth and when you find yourself not doing it correctly, learn and apply. The ego shouldn’t get in.
There’s no failure only feedback
sir, Ap actually society k logo mila rhy hay, unity create kr rhy hay. this is called haq ki tableeg .
I totally agree with your comments and observations about our society!! I have seen so many people like that!! Now living abroad I realized how unfair cruel and stupid our people are!! Work with Chinese, Russians and people from so many different countries and they speak in their own unique accents and present their work with full confidence!! No one makes fun of anyone of them 😊
the thing is why we have to live ' abroad' to realize these basic things? that should be a normal way of thinking in our country and nobody should drift away from that normal thinking and make English a ' hawwa' to make fun of others or look down upon them. With internet we can search so many non english celebrities speaking english in their own ways and accents yet we somehow don't do that and keep carrying that toxic mindset
You explain us very clearly and everything truly thanks
best Muzzamil bhai bht hi achi Podcast thi apki. Mere Bahut se questions thy is bary main asnwer mil gy thanks a lot.
السلام علیکم
بالکل بھائی مسئلہ زبان کا نہیں بلکہ مسئلہ غلامانہ سوچ کا ہے ۔ ہماری قومی زبان اردو ہے جس کو قوم کا ہر فرد سمجھتا ہے چاہے اس کی اپنی مادری زبان کوئی بھی ہو ۔ ہمارے معاشرے میں کوئی اگر بہت ہی اعلیٰ اور بہترین خیال اردو میں پیش کرتا ہے تو اس کی بات کو اہمیت نہیں دی جاتی جبکہ اگر کوئی فضول سی بات بھی انگلش میں کرے تو اس پر بڑی واہ واہ کی جاتی ہے ۔ ہمارے یہاں احساسِ کمتری پیدا کی گئی ہے English کو elite class کی زبان سمجھا جاتا ہے ۔ انگلش یا کوئی بھی زبان سیکھنا اچھی بات ہے مگر اس کو کوئی achievement سمجھنا یعنی اس کو ایسا سمجھنا کہ جیسے انگلش سیکھ کر کوئی بہت بڑا تیر مارلیا گیا ہے یہ غلط سوچ ہے ۔ انگلش نہ سمجھنے والوں کو کمتر سمجھنا غلط ہے ۔
ہمیں اپنی زبانوں اور اردو کو ترجیح دینی چاہیے
Which Pakistanis hate English? Matlab kuch bhi. We die for English lang and culture, that's the problem
Sahi kaha wese
Well actually u need to understand that the experience is different in different classes. If u speak English in lower middle class they will call burger and angreez whereas if you speak English in upper middle class you are considered prelviliage and parha lika. So it depends on classes, where u get experience.
@@HarisKhan-5656 In both cases Pakistanis love English!!!!
@@Hayd4rhahahah its the sameas every pakistani loves money but everyone hate rich person and backbitting him. Everyone repects the money but then everyone is also critising him. Its the culture dude which nothing but just confused brain cells.
I agree title is misleading.
Thanks you Muzamil Bhai, That's my point which is the entire Pakistan thing about language is ridiculous in our society. This is understanding language as a tool not your ability of your cognitive level. I am so happy about your pretty video and content about this topic and totally agree with you!
Sir Muzamil Hasan , you are the super best personality in Pakistan. I Love U sir. My Hero, I learn a lot from your video. stay happy
I am waiting for your video very desperately the way you clear so much of my concepts about a lot of things is just awesome I wish u could make more legnthy videos with full of knowledge stay strong brother
Just make videos in English without fear of people making fun of you. More people will listen to you.
بہترین وڈیو تھی آپ کی
میں بھی کیوں کہ اسلام آباد سے ہوں
مجھے بھی کچھ باتیں سننے کو ملتی رہی ہیں لیکن اچھی کہ تمہاری english بہت اچھی ہے ۔۔
لیکن کچھ عرسہ سے مجھے اندازہ ہوا کہ اردو ہماری زبان ہے ہی ہماری پہچان ہے ۔ میں نے ویسے تو تعلیم و تربیت ۔ ایک اردو رسالہ ہے اس کو پرھ کے اپنی اردو کو بہتر کیا ہے اور اب میں نے ایک اور اقدام کیا ہے کہ اپنے whatsapp کی ڈیفالٹ زبان اردو کردی ہے ۔
میں آپ کو lolz studios کے وقت سے جانتی ہوں ۔ آپ کم views سے ہر گز افسردا نا ہونا کیونکہ آپ کے content میں بہت میار ہے ۔
سلامت رہیں۔
Dear friend, in India, as per our educational policy, we follow the 3-Language formula.
Hindi, English and language 0f the State. We have 22 Constitutionally recognized local languages. These are all on our currency notes, also.
Now increasingly a trend is coming where school level (primary) children can take one more foreign language. One of my grandkids has the French language, for that matter.
In addition, every State is encouraged to select another State for their school level children to learn about that State's some parts of language, like salutations, greetings, etc. And major aspects of culture. I live in Haryana .This State has made mantory for schools to help school children learn about TELGU language. The language spoken in our two States : Telangana and Andhra Pradesh.
This is in addition to full detailed geography, history, and culture etc taught at the school level.
Believe me, I am connected to teaching methodologies, school level children learn new languages very fast. Now a days, with RUclips, no skill is away from you, including foreign languages. There are umpteen channels teaching languages. In seventies, I am in the process of learning Tamil and Urdu.
All the Best Beta. You are doing a good job. God bless you.
🙏
Although the title is alien to the content of the video yet we as Pakistani actually need to treat "English" as a language like all other languages and I almost agree with vid 👍🏻 😊
Its not like we Pakistani hate it rather its unethical and cause confusion in understanding to speak with your native ppl in other languages when u can speak your native language plus the inferiority complex thing apparently seems hating on the English language yet its not actually hate lol , we have made it overrated for no reason
Here i disagree with your title..Pakistani's don't hate english..rather they're afraid of it..
I agree, title is misleading... hate wala concept tu exist hi nahi krta.. yahan English ka hawwa hai... title should have been ' English ka hawwa among Pakistanis'
14:00 lol it's true. I remembered my childhood listening to this.
English is the most beautiful language of the world.
Muzammil bhai, kahan sy content tayar krty hein jo week mein sochty hein usi py ap video bana dety hein, love you so much❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Correction:
@1:32 American spanish and french seekh nae rahay hutay. unko schools mein parhai ja rahi huti hai. A caveat, Eastern europeans use Russian as a overlapping language like we do with Urdu. They still hate Russians in general.
UK mein bhe curriculum ka part huta hai.
White Americans and English have the lowest tendency to learn a second language.
A simple way to understand this is, Latin is taught in Italy but we don't see Italians talking in Latin.
Same goes, Arabic is taught in Pakistan but you don't see Pakistani's speaking Arabic.
That begs the question why not arabic?
Language is just a tool. Learn Saraiki, Punjabi to conduct business. Learn English if you are in IT. I wish to learn all languages.
24:33 why won't you consider putting up English subtitles?
Having worked at Teach for Pakistan as a science teacher in underprivileged area i agree 💯
I fought my school admin that i will only teach in Urdu ..why should a child suffer in Science if his English is weak
Alhamdulillah my students did excellent and excelled in critical thinking
Thanks for promoting such mindset and working in that regard 🇵🇰❤️.
Stay blessed
The Pashtuns are often made fun of in the media for speaking bad Urdu.
You never disappoint 💯💯💯
ap sahi keh rahy being schol teacher bhot mushkil hoti hai bacho i know to hum sub subject un ko pashto man samjhaty hai then kuch samjh ata hai.
Muzamil bhaiyya legit 💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥
The title should b why we as a nation hate "URDU"?
Thank bro you've opened my mind 😊
پاکستانی انگریزی نہیں بولتے؛ وہ englu -urdish بولتے ہیں۔ اور نتیجہ یہ ںکلتا ہے کہ وہ نہ اردو میں اہل پیں اور نہ انگریزی میں۔ عین اس میزبان کی طرح ۔ 😂😂😂
Bht acha nuqta uthaya hy, bad qismati sy hamara muashra aisa ban chuka hy k mazak krny or mazak urany me farq nhi smjhta koi bhi.
Very interesting podcast. Though i keep having a silly reoccurring thought. Why Daer rupeyea not Dhai rupeyea!!?😅 Anyways always a please to hear a sensible person speaking.
I disagree on the unified education system - people of different means will educate their children differently. We need to build an economy that will allow people to grow, naturally people with skills and abilities will nourish irrespective of their education system. I think formal education is overrated.
NAYE YOUHTIAS
NAYA CHURAN 🎉
NAYA CHURANISTAN
lage raho 😅
Love ❤
200 marks for English in CSS is a literal scam. I passed all other subjects with good marks (all in English) and they failed majority including me in English itself. 😅
24:39 yes , ma Village sa hu
May be add English subtitles in your podcasts for international audience
Hen, Urdu Pakistani ki “local” language kaise ban gai bhai? It was the language of UP royals, adopted by partitioned Punjabi landlords to create a forced linguistic identity for Pakistan. Urdu is still one of the Primary languages recognized in India.
Local ni bhai Urdu Pakistan ki national language hai.
English is obviously important because education in Pakistan is completely in english. But I don't want Urdu to be corroupted by English and the decline in urdu poetry is also very heartbreaking. Not to mention, Pakistanis who understand English are often heavily influenced by the western social media and the general western trends hence the reason of decline in religion.
Urdu is not our Language it's UP Bihar
@@PunjabiMuslim510 ?
@@mahmad8528 Yar mara kan da Matlab Ka Urdu is not native language of Pakistani Peoples it's Indian Language Ganga Jamna ki Language aa
@@PunjabiMuslim510Yes.
@@mahmad8528 Asa vasta asi kanda AA Ka Urdu di jaga ta Pakistan di Native Languages nu National Languages da darja dana Jai da wa Nal Ka Ganga Jamna di Language nu jari 24 Million Pakistaniya ta Enforce kiti hoi aa
The only problem I have with the people who cannot speak English in our country is that they have been taught this language throughout their student lives as a mandatory subject. And yet they are unable to form a basic meaningful sentence. I would have had no problem if English was only learnt by the few and only for the sake of learning an extra language but our people should have been able to speak as they have studied this language as a mandatory requirement for their course of study.
The reason people are unable to learn English is that the quality of our education is extremely poor. And secondly, I don't understand why we are still running after this language of our colonial masters, most of the rich and developed countries have everything in their own language.
Your videos are amazing, Thank You So Much for all these videos
27:15 Experienced the same multiple times 😊
Thank you so much air very insightful information ❤
muzamil on fire today😀
I like your conversation chahey wo English yaa urdu my hoo❤
Very well put!
Both Najam Sethi and Ayaz Amir say that very few people knew them. They had to switch to Urdu for views/ratings.
The language of majority in Pakistan is Punjabi. So, it should be medium of communication in Punjab. English should be learnt as second language. Urdu is extra burden for folks.
I agree
Agreed 👍
True ban urdu in panjab
@@Mohdaguj Lol. Good joke
@@Mohdaguj Ban Urdu. what next? Ban Siraki and Hindko as well? But who gonna ban cultural problems that exist between different regions? Central Punjab look down upon every other punjabi from south or from the north? Urdu is not the problem. Grow up and focus on actual problems and try to solve those in an educated manner
Just consider the department of urdu in any University in Pakistan, how we have treated the national language...