I don't care how much spam Suefshark tries to shove down my throat or if they sponsor every single video in every channel in YT, I'm still NEVER using their stupid fucking VPN. And Raid's Law states that any app/product that spends as much time and money in marketing as Raid: Shadow Legends does is either utter garbage, filled with predatory microtransactions or both.
Kamal Atajew was a Sabatian jew and a direct descendant of the false messiah Sabatai Zwi. He was indoctrinated with the cabalistic indoctrination by his cabalist jewish teacher/priest Şemsi Efendi(real name Simon Zwi who was also a descendant of Sabatai Zwi) in his school from the time he began studying there. Only the Jewish students were admitted and studied in Simon Zwi's school as it was a religious school with the aim to educate or rather indoctrinate the children of the Sabatean Jewish families. The journalist Hasan Tahsin(aka Osman Nevres) and the finance minister Cavit bey were also Sabatian jews who studied in Simon Zwi's school. Şemsi Efendi was a father figure for kamal atajew who assisted him to get acquainted with the other Sabataist jews while they walked the same path in the enmity and hatred of Islam. Later on in his life kamal atajew was a british agent to dismantle caliphate and destroy Ottoman when Ottoman was weakened after kamal atajew fled the Palestine front by retreating and retrieving the 7th army without informing the 4th and 8th army commanders that helped british besiege and entrap the 4th and 8th armies and enabled british to take over Palestine that would initiate the destruction of Ottoman for being forced to sign Montreux and the delegate to sign Montreux was kamal atajew's close friend Rauf Orbay advised strictly by kamal atajew in a top secret telegraph from Bahçe the subcity of Adana that was to be after forming Izzet Pasha cabinet. The british agent kamal atajew is a deceptive crypto jew and a fierce enemy of islam.
Ataturk is the greatest Turk after the Ottoman Empire. Without the leadership of Ataturk turkey would have been divided by the European forces but he proved them wrong.
Yeah he was a necessary evil because Ottomans works with the principles of Islam, and it's not Islam fault in that. When Ottoman participate in WW1 as axis power, they got a bad reputation. World view them as something evil after WW1. Some even think their culture is evil and their religion too. To make his people stand up he abolished Islam and Ottoman culture to made the European think, “hey we're not like Ottomans we're “modern” now”. IMO abolishing religious values and practices is bad as Europeans never saw their religion as bad and backwards they put religion and culture aside, and modern advancement aside. But Ataturk make culture and religion gone and make something only for Turks not for anyone
Turks are very nationalistic… i find this strange, even those who are practicing muslims feel very strongly towards their “father”…in other parts of the muslim world, you wont really see this kind of nationalism amongst other muslims.
@@Handle0108 As opposed to indoctrinating children about how muho and his book is the greatest thing ever and you will burn in hell eternally if you deny it?
@@Handle0108 He never made the people idolise him, if he wanted to he would declare himself something divine like they do in other countries like North Korea for example. All those that call him an infidel are ancestors of those who were raped/oppressed by infidels.
yeah, by murdering anyone who opposed his way of thinking, by hanging anyone not wearing a british hat, by killing imams, by killing anyone who theached our old alphabet. by not doing any elections, by sending away the parlement, by killing people from the parlement, by bombing cities with a fucking warship, and by forcefully taking peoples children and giving them away to other people, sorry, but mustafa kemal was the greatest bastard of all time, no one was as disgustingly evil as him, and if you ask me, anyone who thinks like him should be killed on the spot
Ataturk might have done some good things to the Turks but he abolished their great empire with the help of the West to weaken Islam and build a racist nationalist western like society that despise other races while forgetting that Turks themselves are a mixed ethnic group of Arabs, Mongols and others Asian and European ethnicities .. Turks weren’t even a country that had any impact in the Middle East during the 70s up till the 2014 when Erdogan with an Islamic party turned Turkey upside down and made something out of it .. Today Turks should be more idolizing Erdogan than ataturk who brought them the fake superior race ideas that brought them nothing but isolation from the world .. I can’t find a single turk that speaks English or any other foreign language yet they claim to be secular and educated and want to be in the European Union 😂
Reading about Ataturk, although he was our enemy in the First Balkan war (but later a very good friend of Yugoslavia and our king), this man had it all a good commander, a reformist, intelectual that left an impression he was a Hollywood actor. Truly one of the greatest and complete characters in history.
El hamdullillah we are otherwise we would be at the mercy of religion merchants more than we are. There is even a popular song text in Türkiye talking about this "Shame on those wo believe in believers".
It also depends on region. Turks on western coast are very progressive and secular. Turkmen in the south or eastern Anatolia are pretty religious and nationalist.
@@afah6850 If There's No Attaturk there's no islam in Anatolia btw. it could be a heavy Armenian State in the Eastern Turkey and Megali Grecce in Western Turkey and between them a puppet state just like kosovo ... Attaturk Is A hero he save his own people from a big genocides ...
He is our father❤you are not turkish and normally u dont like him.bec he gave us freedom republic and everything.even after 1000 years turks will follow his father Atatürk! Know your place!
@HardCore_Islamist May Allah give strength to Ataturk as this guy is trying to bring back Islam into Turkey but ofcourse the Kemalists is preventing such thiings
Absolutely foolish comment to make. He was responsible for the decline of Islam in turkey and for some odd reason the Turks think they see an advanced people when they nothing but looked down on by nations who are in the developed world today
@@ishmaeltalks so u think Turkey would have been better without his policies? Dude, Turkey would have been another rump state like Pakistan, and Greece would have retaken Constantinople. Just like how India bullies Pak.
@@ishmaeltalks I am no fan of Ataturk's secularism but you have to give him credit, without the Turkish war of Independence Turkey wouldn't have been half of what it is now.
There's a lot to say about Kemal Ataturk. Yet I will keep it in a few phrases. His efforts and vision transformed people of Türkiye from subjects to citizens, and the war-torn, completely exploited remnants of the empire, into a functioning country. There are people in the Muslim world who, for ideological- religious dogmatic reasons, hate this great man. Like any other great leader, Ataturk had his flaws, mistakes and shortcomings. However, Türkiye is different and more progressive than most Muslim-majority countries for the very reason that it started the forming 20th century with a leader like Ataturk.
Subjects? LOL im süre the Pope in europe is thought of the same way... 😂 let öne leader remove the Pope from europe and sen if europeans worship that leader.... the amount of brainwash is insane in NATO occupied Türkiye
"I do not leave any verses, any dogmas, nor any frozen and moulded principles as spiritual heritage. My spiritual heritage is science and reason." Mustafa Kemal
I was in Istanbul about 3 weeks ago, he definitely left behind a lot of things there besides ‘sCienCe aND rEAsoN’, namely a concerning amount of flags with his face on it
@@1karaca2 en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anıtkabir Why is he buried here then? If his heritage is science and reason why does he need a türbe like a sultan? He should have been buried in a regular cemetery like the rest of his people but you Turks treat him like he is a god or a prophet
I am a pakistani here. Our country is destroyed by radical islam. Ataturk was a hero. You were lucky to have him. But were not that fortunate. Today my country is in turmoil. I will try to movie in a european country in future.
Pakistan with all do respect is practicing the wrong version of Islam the islam version of Pakistan is radical Islam and terrorist group that kills people in the name of Islam that's why Pakistan is way behind but Islam is not the reason the reason is the misused form of Islam and ignorance because if Islam is used in a wise way no doubt Pakistan will prosper and corruption and any threats will be no nullified
its nice to see a seculsr pakistani person here. i hope you will be happy man. also i have an advice to you. make lots of secular children and educate them as secular pakistani people. fight for your country
@@sarpkaraba9057lmao most don’t care about him. Only reason he’s even relevant outside of Türkiye is the Ottomans. Plus religiousity and extremist views amongst younger Muslims is on the rise.
All Muslım World have to follow Atatürk, if they want to live with independent İf you be secular You will independent You will have wealth Your science knowledge will immediately increase Your education system will get perfect
@@nakzadi4015 you confused Two subject unfortunately. (İf you read )Endülüs era ,when it was İslam and science were living golden Era. True. But after this Era science, philosophy and culture blocked by Religous autorithy.İnfact this autorithy was knowing their blocking was wrong but for their politicial future they lived all Müslim World dark age.Still out of Türkiye ,other countries live this dark age. Turkiye found true religional life and science and culture and WOMAN RİGHTS! Thanks to the ATATÜRK ❤️! Read Atatürk's revolutions.İ mean As we Türkiye we are so chancefull. Secularity in these century so big needing.Follow Türkiye.Follow Atatürk ❤️
@@1035Ghuraba You sin by slandering ! God knows !!! Read Atatürk and İslam books. .Then make comment. You sin by slandering! BECAUSE READ Müslim World was dying under British İmperialism. Atatürk saved Türkiye from British,Greek,France, İtalian invade. Müslim World surprised.First times West lost aganist Müslim.Ataturk didn't let Western soldiers enter the mosques.in the 20.th century Best believer was Atatürk !God knows ! Because there was a Leader of Turks ATATÜRK ❤️! ATATÜRK relaized that neccesary was Secularity.When ATATÜRK start to secular revolution British get worried ! But Atatürk was so decidefull. Education,religion,defence,economy.health and woman rights !!!! Until this time Türkiye is first and unique country in the 55 Müslim contries! thanks to Atatürk❤️!!! Atatürk was knowing İslam so well. He read 3997 books! All world leaders came to hım for see. Please Read Atatürk's .Best believer. İf you are pure Müslim you read.Don't jeal to us.We are modern.Follow to Atatürk.Great Müslim.
I think Ataturk wanted Turkey to grow but under his ideals, he was in his mind guiding the people towards the right path, and wanted to enable them to eventually prosper as a modern republic. But for then when the state was young, like a child has to be often punished and guided by parents, he had to take control often and guide his nation towards the 'right' path.
yeah, by murdering anyone who opposed his way of thinking, by hanging anyone not wearing a british hat, by killing imams, by killing anyone who theached our old alphabet. by not doing any elections, by sending away the parlement, by killing people from the parlement, by bombing cities with a fucking warship, and by forcefully taking peoples children and giving them away to other people, sorry, but mustafa kemal was the greatest bastard of all time, no one was as disgustingly evil as him, and if you ask me, anyone who thinks like him should be killed on the spot
He basically gaved us a choise to determine our own future just to later we found out it was not us alone and we just found out we were determining nothing at all this time.
Ataturk might have done some good things to the Turks but he abolished their great empire with the help of the West to weaken Islam and build a racist nationalist western like society that despise other races while forgetting that Turks themselves are a mixed ethnic group of Arabs, Mongols and others Asian and European ethnicities .. Turks weren’t even a country that had any impact in the Middle East during the 70s up till the 2014 when Erdogan with an Islamic party turned Turkey upside down and made something out of it .. Today Turks should be more idolizing Erdogan than ataturk who brought them the fake superior race ideas that brought them nothing but isolation from the world .. I can’t find a single turk that speaks English or any other foreign language yet they claim to be secular and educated and want to be in the European Union 😂
Ataturk was greater than Sultan Mahmut the Second cause he achieved the reform of alphabet that Mahmut the Second wanted to do so in order to promote the Turkish language ( Cause Latin alphabet is much more adapted to transcript Turkish language than Persian alphabet )
Ataturk didn't dissolve 2nd parties out of fear, especially the fear of Islamists. 1924 the problem was eastern local revolts(mainly kurdish and small local rebellions), 1929 the problem was the economic decline in USA, the great Depression. 1934 the problem was Hitler's goverment and his vision that there will be a 2nd world war. So please try to inform your audience for the better. Secularism in Turkey as in practice is not Atheism. Thank you for your content. Have a nice day :)
@@azmolhossain9244 In what world can you change your country's ruling system to your ideologic way of ruling to full extent in one day? Simple as that. Things need time.
Fun anecdote: Ataturk questioned an Imam about Islam and realized he was not a real one but forgave him because of his honesty. Ordered him to study properly saying'' This place is a touristic location, what would you say when a Non Muslim would want to learn more about Islam? I will test you again next time I am here''
@@makmet3024The conversation went like this: Atatürk asked the Imam, "Would you like a pint of beer on this hot day?". The Imam rejected the beer saying "It is haram sir. I cannot drink beer." Atatürk, curious, asked him "Why is it Haram?". The Imam, confused, replied "Because it is sir." In response, Atatürk asked "Is there no verse in the hadith or Qur'an that says Alcohol is prohibited? If so, which ones?" The Imam which couldn't answer the question said "Sir, I do not know how to read or write. I became an Imam because I had no job and I went to a Mektep when I was young." Atatürk, said in response, "Thank you for your honesty Hodja, we will give you the resources to study and teach the Qur'an." He then turned to the person next to him, Fevzi Çakmak, and said: "This is why I want to translate the Qur'an to Turkish. So people know what they are reading."
@@makmet3024 Atatürk knowingly said, "Imam, wouldn't a cold alcohol be nice in this heat?" The imam said, "No way, it is haram." Atatürk asked, In which verse or hadith does it state that it is haram? The imam could not answer.
What?....... Qur'an 4:43, O you who have believed, indeed, intoxicants (khamr), gambling, [sacrificing on] stone altars [to other than God], and divining arrows are but defilement from the work of Satan, so avoid it that you may be successful.
@@makmet3024 My comment has been deleted fully answering the thing but the Imam was illiterate and went to a Qur'an course in his childhood. He did not understand the Qur'an so when Atatürk asked him the question he could not give an answer on WHY it was Haram.
yeah, by murdering anyone who opposed his way of thinking, by hanging anyone not wearing a british hat, by killing imams, by killing anyone who theached our old alphabet. by not doing any elections, by sending away the parlement, by killing people from the parlement, by bombing cities with a fucking warship, and by forcefully taking peoples children and giving them away to other people, sorry, but mustafa kemal was the greatest bastard of all time, no one was as disgustingly evil as him, and if you ask me, anyone who thinks like him should be killed on the spot
Eternal respect to Ataturk from me-a Nigerian and a Christian-for having vision, resolve and determination to build his nation into a strong, nationalist and modern entity that cherished it's heritage but would not be stifled and hindered by it. Really amazing how such a leader like him accomplished so much despite the real threat of hard-line islamic fundamentalism and foreign interference potentially ending his life and undermining everything he worked for. It is undeniable that modern Turkey owes him and his cohorts a great debt. He is like Seretse Khama.
@@ibro8855 like Communist did in europe. He may have supressed religion for a while but religion never dies and certianly not Islam. It will always existed. It just keeps getting stronger. When you supress Islam it will only come back stronger and even more hardcore. Afghanistan and Iran are one example.
@@Beyonder1987 He did not supress religion in a way you think he did. He just toned down Religion's influence over society, which should be done in every country.
@@Agentblue009 Tone down? i think he did go far as replacing Written language from Arabic to Latin which is really insane to come think of it as the Turks have always known Arabic script. Added to that he brought into laws where Muslims cannot call to prey in Arabic which is the basis of all islamic teaching. He wanted it in turkish which is not acceptable in Islam. There are better ways to modernise a nation that be very aggressive. You take small steps, not a 100 steps. Others muslim leaders such as in Afghanistan and Sha of Iran tried to do what Kemal did but with a more aggressive tone which caused its downfall.
We can die for Ataturk's revulation. He did hard works at his time. Turkiye is secular country. One day will go away someones but he never... There is something that those who live in Turkey and hate it do not know. They will not be able to show the same hatred in Afghanistan...
Don't forget the little-known conflict between one Kurdish tribe who mostly traded in dairy and another tribe who mostly traded in citrus fruits. So it was basically cheese Kurds vs. lemon Kurds 🥁
The Ottoman Empire always had a secular branch of government so secularism in Turkey isn’t entirely a new thing but ataturk pushed secularism even further
Your review is so much flawed and miss so many points. Why did you not talk about his reforms in laicism section? He ordered translating muslim's holy book Kur-an. He dissolved cults, he cut privileges of sheiks and zealots, he gave women equal rights. Other sections are so shallow as well.
Ataturk was the Ulysses S. Grant and Robert E. Lee of Modern day Turkey who helped shape the country into what it is today! Ataturk had great Commanding and Charismatic leadership skills like Ulysses S. Grant, while also possessing the brilliant tactical and strategical mindset skills like Robert E. Lee! Combined, Ataturk and his soldiers beat the odds that were stacked against them, fighting a multi-front war. Winning not just the battle, but the War itself And the Turks deserve my commendmoration,admiration, and my utmost respect!!! Greetings and Respect from U.S. :)
Why do you block the Turkish symbol on the thumbnail, crescent and star have nothing to do with islam since it's a paganic symbol. Look at any arab country's flag (except north africa) nobody uses that symbol lol
@@HikmaHistory Jinnah and Ataturk had so many similarities. Both were certainly paradoxical. At least Ataturk made no attempts to hide his disdain of the Islamists and tried to mould the state accordingly while Jinnah was hobnobbing with the very folks he despised the most. He ate pork, drank like a sailor and yet he made a state in the name of Islam. Would love to see your video on Jinnah and would be happy to help in any way I can. I’ve read a lot about Jinnah and his metamorphosis.
@@HikmaHistory You could make one about Bangabandhu too. He separated East pakistan from West or modern day pakistan and created a new country called Bangladesh
He never claimed to be the Leader of Islam, he refused to be a Sultan when Kazim Karabekir and Ismet Inönü asked him to be the next Sultan... All his words are against all religions not exclusively against Islam.
Türk milleti ( Anadolu + Trakya ) hiçbir zaman sömürge ( dominyon ) olmamıştır , Emperyalist ülkeler ( Büyük Britanya, Fransa , İtalya ) Araplar ve diğer uluslar gibi sömürmemiştir; daima bağımsız olmuştur , Arap Sermayesinin sömürgesi olmayacaktır .
Long live Attatürk! The Muslim World need more men (or women) like him. He's among the few dictators (or authoritarian leaders) I respect. The others are: Gadaffi, Tito, Nasser, Lee Kwang Yeh and Rojas Pinilla from Colombia.
Ataturk was evil. He oppressed conservatives greatly and disrespected islam by turning mosques into animal farms and night clubs and many other evil things.
Based on the comments written here, and in response to some points the narrator didn't understand, I will provide a brief summary: Although Atatürk may seem like a leader with complex and inconsistent thoughts, the key to understanding lies in the political rhetoric prevailing worldwide during his time, such as fascism and ethnic nationalism. What makes Atatürk great is not only his planned reforms and military background but also his pragmatic success in implementing these reforms. Also, in comments section I saw some unrealistic stances (muslim out-siders), saying that "let's not abolish the caliphate, but rather establish a softer form of secularism". Well, this would have had disastrous consequences in the uneducated and susceptible society inherited from the Ottoman era(less than 10% literacy) turning Turkey into a mere cesspool in the Middle East. Last but not least: I can talk with you about this topic until morning. I have read more than 10 books about Atatürk, and currently, I am studying political science :)
Who kicked earthquake effected people out of thier homes and who is standing with pkk and the one who is trying to seperate turkish people by saying he's an alawait
being modern does not mean stopping piety or disregarding Islam, it means to move ahead and have progress and piety at the same time this is very much possible your nation can be a religious and modern nation at the same time #SaynotoSecularism
@@RusselKabirTR These examples will not change the size of his balls you know. And our brothers should have stayed vigilant and strong. Always possible to see a new stalin, mao or kuteybe around.
@@RusselKabirTR Atatürk is a person who fought for his nation's independence, even If u don't agree with his reforms u have to accept that he is not like those. It's sad that some people learn about Atatürk from erdogan sponsored sources.
@@RusselKabirTR Are you referring to the ethnic minorities that committed treason by supporting the invading troops of hostile countries during wartime ?
Well, made it secular...for a while. Doesn't seem like his successors are doing so good at that lately. What with the undermining of the democracy, secularism and gender equality parts Literally, like two days ago the Turkish government censored the opposition on twitter ahead of an election.
@@RusselKabirTR Actually, you’ll often find a lot of people in the US objecting to what they perceive as Christians imposing their views in others, like what happened after Roe v. Wade was overturned.
Although Atatürk is a flawed person with questionable action he still lead the Turk to independence and modernity. May he rest in Peace. One of my favourite quotes of him is: "Peace at home, Peace in the world" Such a remarkable person.
@Momana Sideka get rid of secularism, get rid of some liberalism, and republicanism. Sure he will be remembered, but getting rid of those thingsnhe implemented is reversing the most important things he did.
1:50 Er musste erstmal die Reformen umsetzen und das System gestalten, es war ein Prozess, sein Ziel war es dort hinzukommen, in einem Prozess bist du nicht sofort von A nach B
At 2:10, bro has no information about how anatolian people was ignorant an the time, in additional he used to try to open new parties like 'free republic party' and 'progressive republic party'. Both of the these parties indirectly caused to Menemen Incident and expansion Sheik Said rebellion (we lost the chance of retake mosul from British). As you see, Ataturk wanted to establish a democratic govenrment but he always encountered with ignorance and slavish believe to islamic rumors. This thing still exist with a party called AKP (justice and development party). They did everything except justice and development.
Turkey's flag doesnt represent islam it represents blood of the martyrs at the night , legend here , you can search on the internet : According to legend, the red on the flag is blood red and represents the shed blood of the martyrs. At midnight, the image of the Turkish flag is formed with the crescent moon and a star reflected on these bloods. It is said that this legend took place in the First Battle of Kosovo, which took place in 1389.
As a Turk my nationality comes first and I believe in Tengrizm not Islam.We strictly believe Government and (ANY)Religion should be separated due to historical facts about the outcome which ended up mostly crumbling the Uygurs Selcuks and so many examples.
Well i have huge respect to the turkish people, but Look what nationality did to Balkan The problem with nationality is that lead ultranationalist which is basically racism You will feel your nationality crumble when you reside in high economic country I telling this because i experienced it I really sorry i did come out negative and pushing I am so sorry 🇲🇷❤️🇹🇷
@@ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273 Turkey is to blame for the balkans. They are the reasons why the balkans was a warzone in the first place...500+ years of ottoman slavery in the balkans...
He had the option of becoming a Caliph, and having all the privileges associated with such a position. He rejected it because it did not align with his vision of the future of the country he was trying to build. Even if he had preserved it- what good would such a position be in the political context of the middle east in the 20th century? The Gulf Arabs wouldn't listen and would have used their wealth to overthrow and destabilise the country. In that sense, he did what had to be done and that is history, and the consequences are felt today. The Turks have good reason to thank him for the decision he made and the state of Turkey today.
Thank you for the reference - I'm a big fan of post-1800 Latin American history; admittedly it's mainly the Hispanic countries. Will be researching Vargas more!
@@mgigachad3170 He didn’t ban islam he just said go practice it in mosques and stop using a religion to further your political and social agendas. So if you want a enemy of Islam blame the individuals who aims to use Islam’s followers for political power and praise Atatürk for keeping Islam what it is a religion, that everybody has a right to belive or not to believe in their private life.(I believe Islam also endorses in peoples freedom to believe or not to believe)
@@egetansk4170 I didn't say ban islam did I his policy against it is what I am referring to for example he turned some mosques into pubs and casino,stables for pigs and horses and banned the hijab forced the Muslims to pray salah in turkish which in our religion is not right.
@@willgibbons1733 Yeah it's not a bad thing to bastardize your folk, it's not a bad thing to make them suffer such stupidly needless complexes, it's not a bad thing to break up your society by screwing up your youths.
Ataturk was a great leader. Can you show a single country that developed with Islam? Today, children are being abused in the institutions you praise. Those who say they want to be governed by Sharia immediately move to the West, where Islam is not common. If Ataturk had been against Islam, there would not be a single believer left in Turkey. Almost all of the Islamic organizations are supported by either Europe, England or America. Those are the first places they go. Do you know where those who tried to spread Sharia ideas under the name of Islam in Turkey in the 1950s came from?
The steel-colored brightness of [his] eyes shines out of the warrior-like, sunburned brown of [his] face with an uncanny, captivating power. Eyes, within which the supple power and the ruthless will of self-assertion of the Turanian grey wolf twin- kles." Be it Aryan, Turanian, or even Mongolian, or, again perhaps obviously, Prussian-when, in the narratives, Atatürk meets the Kai- ser, Hindenburg, and Ludendorff in 1917-what his appearance and actions reaffirmed was the awakening and the "triumph of race." Schopen concluded: He is nothing less than the incarnation of all warrior-like na- tions. The Turk is, in his moral qualities, one of the best sol- diers of the world. For him the victorious military Führer stands above everything else. And Mustafa Kemal, mathematician and carrier of soldier blood from his father's line, was a genius of the strategic idea."7 For most of these texts, Atatürk was the ultimate warrior-"battle was his nature."+ Froembgen described him as "a thunderstorm turned man." Melzig said in his Atatürk biography: "In him a he- roic spirit rose to the light from the depth of thousands of years." Froembgen also stressed, "He is a soldier the like of which seldom comes along." Atatürk's prowess in battle was stressed time and again: "The soldiers hesitated to throw themselves into the rain of death. Mustafa Kemal knows, here no order will be enough, here one needs to be a role model, to be a Führer."52 The Führer as a role model for everybody-in battle, for the Turkish farmer with his model farm, but also for the ordinary Turk, when it comes to demeanor, dress, and indeed everything-was a constant theme of these texts.53 Descriptions of Atatürk's aura elevated him to messianistic levels. With his deeds at Gallipoli during World War I, Atatürk emerges in these narratives not only as the imminent savior of Constantino- ple but as a transcendental "savior." Indeed, the formula "savior and Führer" was frequently put forward by some texts. Some stressed that one could feel a special aura, "a magic circle," in his presence he was "the chosen one."
@@Mizar4😂 todays Greece and lots of other countries were ottoman lands and everywhere Turkish people was living. His patents and ancestors are Turkish nomads in Anatolia.
Yaşasın Türkiye Cumhuriyeti 1923 - 202oo, Yaşatılsın Ulu Önder Gazi Mustafa Kemal Atatürk. 1881 - 193oo.🇹🇷💐🙏 Long Live the Republic of Turkey 1923 - 202oo, Long Live the Great Leader Gazi Mustafa Kemal Atatürk. 1881 - 193oo.🇹🇷💐🙏
I was a student of Bediüzzaman or talabun nur for 4 or 5 years. And the most disturbing thing about him is his view towards Theory of Evolution or people who holds the theory to be true.
I find surprising that in Turkey no conservatory Islamist fringe of society tried to make the government fall because of all that sudden secularism ( apart from the Kurds , but they were a minority that were against their turkification). In Iran the attempts of the Shah to secularize the country rapidly lead to the 1979 Revolution ( although I know that in Iran there was also the problem that the Shah was seen as a puppet of the Western countries) .
*On one hand* I hate his views on history, religion, culture and nationalism. He didn't only abmiar the west, according to him western civilisation is literally the only civilisation and anything that is not considered western is barbaric. To me that's mental sickness *On the other hand* without him turkey wouldn't exist today, he literally defeated 5 armies at the same time by himself!! And his reformers to econmy army and infrastructure can't be denied, I understand why turks love him he literally created their country As an arab muslim I don't know how to feel about him , he's a very complex person. I'm very interested in reading and learning more about him. His ideas for the better or worse shaped and influenced a lot of leaders throughout the islamic world to this very day
@@oktaythegreat Selamun aleyküm ، i'm from iraq, do you have any books you recommend about atatürk, or the establishment of the Turkish republic? It would be much appreciated
It's been a while since your comment, but can u elaborate on the first paragraph you wrote? What do you hate about his views on history, religion, culture and nationalism? I think you Arabs are really looking at the situation one-sidedly, I say this because I have not come across any Arab who could understand Ataturk's vision. You look positive from one side that he defeated 5 armies same time by himself as u said. You know these 5 armies are western imperial powers that want to divide our lands, right? Do u think a nationalist man who fought against the West itself admired the West because it was the West, or did he turn his face to the West because development and prosperity were in the West? Isn't it your prophet who says seek knowledge even if you have to go to as far as China?
What war of independence? The Ottoman Empire was defeated in WWI and had to bear the consequences. Its territory was divided among the winners -Britain, France, Italy and Greece, just as Germany was divided in 4 parts after WWII. If a German general had organized a resistance movement aiming at kicking out the Americans, the British, the French and the Soviets would you talk about a "war of independence"? 😃
@@loseyourself5023 Ironic. A turk talking about invading homes and kicking out people...The ottomans did that for 500+ years in the balkans,middle east and africa...
"If a German general had organized a resistance movement aiming at kicking out the Americans, the British, the French and the Soviets would you talk about a "war of independence"?" Of course lol
Kurdish people have their own culture n language, it should be respected n they in return should love n respect the countries they live in ,at the end of the day we are brothers in Humanity who have Islamic affinity with non kurdish Muslims,so let us have mutual respect for all .
in nutuk (ataturks otobiography) he accepted he done some things he dont like about ethnic groups , but u have to understand why he make such things. Look at the history when ever turks lost an area or a war there is always another ethnic group lives under turkic goverments the closest trought the history is şeyh said rebellion. in 1925 turkey and england is going to war for the city mosul ,ataturk give eastern army to 12.500 man to take the city while brits make some agreements with şeyh said . İn that time şeyh said never said ' he was gonna freed kurds' but he said ' ı am mehdi ' to gain power after that turks lost the city mosul şeyh said dead and the army find british golds inside his house . this is why atatürk does such things even do he not proud of these things.
@@efeaydinli25Yes Ataturk admitted that he wasn't proud or happy about some of his methods but felt that it was necessary to protect the mother land from potential traitors. It was mere political strategy.
Islam is not outdated. Islam allows for religious freedom. Kemal just went too hard on secularism and actually banned the Arabic Adhan and the Wearing of hijab.
I am from Pakistan and in recent years our best leader I ran Khan also seems to be the most religious while the other leaders only care about getting as much of people taxpayer money to buy there luxury apartments on the other side of the world
I admire Ataturk but I think he went a bit too far in adopting a harshly secular model for his republic (incidentally, the Turkish word "laiklik" is taken from the French "laicite"), even going as far as forcing mosques to call prayers in Turkish instead of Arabic, which is why a conservative-populist party AKP still popular among many Turks. Would he instead adopt the US model of separation between the church and state which is a softer approach when dealing with religion and politics, religious conservatives of Turkey wouldn't have much to complain about. Still, he did far more good for his country than bad cause he managed to save his country from partition by the Entente powers, developed the economy and introduced much-needed societal reforms, especially when it comes to women's rights.
This was quite difficult to watch. To summarize, he saw weakness in the technology, economy, education, and unity of the country. Ataturk's solution to the education problem of the religious people was to hinder the education of religious people by requiring them to abandon their clothing, their day of rest, and their system of morality if they wished to get an education. He also changed the writing style rather than educating the people in how to read it, so that they would be cut off from centuries of philosophy, religion, and political thought. Basically, he severely limited the ability for people to hold different ideas from him. He sought to remove the connecting idea of brotherhood across the Muslim world, and instead focus back on a form of tribalism called "nationalism", where he forced anyone currently in the country to pretend they were part of his tribe. We had modernists in Pakistan, as well, and Quaid-e-Azam, the founder of our country, was a modernist. However, Ataturk would be considered extreme. His actions as described in this video are far closer to the fascism which was sweeping Europe at the time, and I believe since he tied his goals to imitating Europe, he would be easily swayed by those philosophies. After all, fascism did abandon much in favor of "nationalism", technological development, and extreme unity. Germany and Italy both greatly advanced their technological capabilities. Thank God that Turkiye never fully followed in those footsteps. I truly hope Turkiye elevates itself from this petty Kemalism.
Great comment. Regarding the change of the alphabet I thought the motive behind it was just the same as it was when he changed the call to prayer from Arabic to Turkish: hatred of Arabs and everything that's associated with them. But your conclusion that he wanted to limit the sources of information that didn't allign with his ideology, appealed to my common sense right after I read it. It is genius but diabolical at the same time. And he succeeded, overall Turkish Muslims are one of the least religious Muslims out there only surpassed by Muslims from ex communist countries.
@@drt-tv7ct It makes me laugh, I see Turks in the UK with tattoos, eating pork, drinking alcohol. I ask them are you Muslim they say yes, I say to them your not Muslim and they get angry. Nothing about them is Muslim but they insist they are Muslims. Even when I go to the Turkish mosque it is so different how they pray and behave.
Arabic traditions&living culture is not religion itself. Atatürk tried to create a Turkish Nation from the wreckages of ummah ideology which is strongly embedded with Arabic traditions. Today, existing goverment is trying to change the course but the youth overwelmingly chosed Atatürk 's ideology despite all the efforts to create medresah education again. I think, consequences can be visible within a decade. Pakistan and Iran should follow the same route, otherwise they feel pain when they recognise how much behind they are in all fields.
@@freemillenniumideas if it was just culture he wouldn't be so controversial. Secularism and Islam exclude each other. If you have ever read the Quran you know that it's full of commands and punishments for this world. And that it has nothing to do with todays feminism and things like that. The Hadith have even more of that. And a caliph is also part of a Muslim country. But he removed all of it. Even European countries like Belgium, Spain and England didn't go so far and kept their King. He was a hardcore reformist and not only allowed haram things but even prohibited halal things like marrying more than 1 woman or changed the day people don't work from Friday to Sunday i. e. things that you can't justify with logic
Watching all these videos made me realize why the Arabic nations cannot move forward, every time a revolutionary leader wanted to modernize their country, Islamist will deter it from happening. Maybe the islamic world need a renaissance?
Ataturk was a visionary and saw that a conservative or Islam based society can't thrive in this day and age. For example Saudi's wouldn't be rich if they were no oil. He is a dictator but a democratic one at that. He ruled by popular rule also the said parties were filled with Islamists this lead to the speculation that they will undo the changes that was made to modernise the republic. Said Sufi orders and other sects that were active in Ottoman Empire was pretty cooperative with the occupation forces and they were a nuisance that always bugged the Ottoman Empire. They were the cause of many Janissary revolts. They also tried to form a nation in a nation. They were not some great organisation that helped Islam no. They were opportunistic institutions that just took the power away from the state and caused public unrest. Ataturk aimed at destroying one thing that held the people among lines that they did not wish to be a part of. Alevi's and Sunni's Shia's and Yezidi's. These lines established by the local religious influences divided Anatolia and its people. Change was needed so Ataturk greatly isolated religion from politics. Turks are not like the Arabs. The were nationalistic even before Ataturk and they were proud of it. I am a person who descended from Alevis living in Anatolia. Because of that I know the dangers of a divided society. Cultural nationalism was needed and one culture society lead us to prosperity that we've didn't saw in Anatolia for a very long time. Germans wrote about our backwardness and so did the other powers. We were seen as backwards as the Turks and as the Ummah. Ataturk's reforms were needed and those who've resisted these reforms were stopped. I have many Kurdish friends not just or two. I lived in a ethnically diverse place that had many ethnicities living together. We were united with one cultural identity but our values were not lost. We had our own cultures as branches of this countries dominant culture. Our cultures didn't went extinct but were integrated into the Turkish identity as a whole. A mix of Arabic and Persian alphabets were not suitable for the Turkish language so a more suitable alphabet was chosen. During the Great Depression many liberal economies suffered while Turkish economy based on domestic production survived. Dersim Rebellion and other rebellions before that was needed to be destroyed because rebellions as we know is not something that has place in a nation. They were crushed and the regions were pacified. I am saying this as person who is of Alevi descent you people that love the idea of Caliphate that much suppressed us for many years. We've suffered under the caliphate rule and you know what? Ataturk gave our rights we've praised our lord in the ways we wanted. We were not killed like in the old times we were given religious freedom like many other Islamic groups in Anatolia. Though i still have a good laugh when seeing people who think all of these are Ataturk's ideas. These things we talk about is not even originated from Ataturk mostly. These are of a long standing tradition that started with II. Mahmud. After that reforms continued and Ittihadists took control. Ataturk had his own party before the formation of ITF but he choose a more popular option and over time his views were influenced by Ittihadism. Kemalism is a continuation of reforms that started in 1800's and the ideology of Ittihadism. I am a Turkmen Alevi in ethnicity but i don't call my self "Alevi" i call myself "Turk" even though its not encouraged in schools anymore. Arabs and Berbers at that times were under colonies created by their French and British overlords while Turks were prospering under a new system. Thats the duality of these kind of video when it comes to information regarding 6 pillars of Kemalism and Mustafa Kemal Ataturk himself. Tengri Biz Menen!
Are joking turkey was shithold no body knows about before Erdoğan. A friend was traveling through turkey in 90. He told it was dirty shithole. But look at turkey now days
So basically you claim Erdoğan is kind of a savior that saved this country while you know nothing? Its still the same place that your place saw plus he is not a native like me. So his opinion would be more biased and he would of course not like the state of this country because after all he came to this country easily and ate and drank what he/she wanted for a pretty low price. You guys really need to think about it.
@@Atabey381 could baised but I don't what motivation he had to lie for me, but it pretty well stableshed that time Istanbul had problems with electricity, water and pretty much all public infrastructure. Also side note inflation in turkey was much higher before remember you had very high currency nomination up to millions also unemployment was much higher. I get everyone will sick of same guy in power 20 years but you have give the guy at least some credit. I my self live in Kocaeli but moving to Africa. But a decade ago no one could point Türkiye on the map it was i unrelevant place and least known places. You would differ but ask around. My friend didn't came to eate and drink, he come here unvulentry and by change and left as soon as he had the chance for Syria just to finish his business from and also said Syria was much of better place, 20 years later he visited again and said this can rival Europe and I agree very much. We are both Norwegian citizens.
@@jaqafle See my point here? Norwegians citizens can't really understand the general being of Turkey. I am a native who lives in these lands and let me tell you the inflation that me and my family experienced was not worse than the current thing we are experiencing. We had a job a steady income and Americans just ruined everything by embargos but we weren't hungry. Now i live on a diet based of pasta and if i am luck some vegetables. My body needs protein but i can't get much of it unless my roommates get us some food from their parents or great parents. Today I "Poğaça" a pastry that has nothing inside for me to consume. No cheese no chocolate or anything that you can think of. I ate something that has near to the things i need to upkeep my body. This evening as we speak of i am eating a instant noodle because with the money i had in my pockets that the highest thing i can get. Our electricity gets cut every 3 months and sometimes its lowered to 2 months. Eating from the cafeteria is impossible and we use a place we know to wash our clothes. We use public showers to get cleaned and we use communal bathrooms with no privacy and with little time. Look friend because you have money in a country that has a crippling economy doesn't mean that the country you are talking about is in great condition. Well there is more i want to say but it would go into more "private" matters so i am not willing to tell more
![DDG & G Herbo - Nosey [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I9Ra0Zc2NlQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Get an exclusive Surfshark deal! Enter promo code HIKMA for an extra 3 months free at surfshark.deals/hikma
A little heads up that Crescent doesn't mean Islam. It always existed but it was just Ottomans which made it popularly associated with Islam.😊
The post-revolutionary minority has a sickening tradition of looking down on Muslims.
I don't care how much spam Suefshark tries to shove down my throat or if they sponsor every single video in every channel in YT, I'm still NEVER using their stupid fucking VPN.
And Raid's Law states that any app/product that spends as much time and money in marketing as Raid: Shadow Legends does is either utter garbage, filled with predatory microtransactions or both.
Kamal Atajew was a Sabatian jew and a direct descendant of the false messiah Sabatai Zwi. He was indoctrinated with the cabalistic indoctrination by his cabalist jewish teacher/priest Şemsi Efendi(real name Simon Zwi who was also a descendant of Sabatai Zwi) in his school from the time he began studying there. Only the Jewish students were admitted and studied in Simon Zwi's school as it was a religious school with the aim to educate or rather indoctrinate the children of the Sabatean Jewish families. The journalist Hasan Tahsin(aka Osman Nevres) and the finance minister Cavit bey were also Sabatian jews who studied in Simon Zwi's school. Şemsi Efendi was a father figure for kamal atajew who assisted him to get acquainted with the other Sabataist jews while they walked the same path in the enmity and hatred of Islam.
Later on in his life kamal atajew was a british agent to dismantle caliphate and destroy Ottoman when Ottoman was weakened after kamal atajew fled the Palestine front by retreating and retrieving the 7th army without informing the 4th and 8th army commanders that helped british besiege and entrap the 4th and 8th armies and enabled british to take over Palestine that would initiate the destruction of Ottoman for being forced to sign Montreux and the delegate to sign Montreux was kamal atajew's close friend Rauf Orbay advised strictly by kamal atajew in a top secret telegraph from Bahçe the subcity of Adana that was to be after forming Izzet Pasha cabinet. The british agent kamal atajew is a deceptive crypto jew and a fierce enemy of islam.
Arap fars tokumlardan bıktım
Ataturk is the greatest Turk after the Ottoman Empire. Without the leadership of Ataturk turkey would have been divided by the European forces but he proved them wrong.
Yeah he was a necessary evil because Ottomans works with the principles of Islam, and it's not Islam fault in that. When Ottoman participate in WW1 as axis power, they got a bad reputation. World view them as something evil after WW1. Some even think their culture is evil and their religion too. To make his people stand up he abolished Islam and Ottoman culture to made the European think, “hey we're not like Ottomans we're “modern” now”. IMO abolishing religious values and practices is bad as Europeans never saw their religion as bad and backwards they put religion and culture aside, and modern advancement aside. But Ataturk make culture and religion gone and make something only for Turks not for anyone
Kurdistan will be freed Inshallah
@@LeixWUxLong Not even in your wet dreams
@@jackholler3572 Soon Inshallah
@@LeixWUxLong Soon all the backwards in Turkey will leave Turkey forever.
Turks are very nationalistic… i find this strange, even those who are practicing muslims feel very strongly towards their “father”…in other parts of the muslim world, you wont really see this kind of nationalism amongst other muslims.
It’s brainwashing, Ataturk created a whole system which raises everyone in the society to idolise him.
@@Handle0108 As opposed to indoctrinating children about how muho and his book is the greatest thing ever and you will burn in hell eternally if you deny it?
@@varun76890 lindu spotted
@@chadmapping3401 I'm Türk
@@Handle0108 He never made the people idolise him, if he wanted to he would declare himself something divine like they do in other countries like North Korea for example.
All those that call him an infidel are ancestors of those who were raped/oppressed by infidels.
Father of us, Turks. Not Muslims.
Cuz you’re not muslim congratulations hell is waiting for you
I think after ottoman collapse all are muslim there so all turks are muslim in. Past at time ataturk
father of donme jews and alevi kabab kafirlarlar
Ok so you are not related to mehmet the conqueror as he disowned you already 😂
@@abdullahelwan405whatever happen Mehmet the Conqueror is my ancestor, whether i am a muslim or not he is Turkish and he's my ancestor.
Thanks to Ataturk Turkey exists today.
They have every right to be nationalistic and proud of him.
yeah, by murdering anyone who opposed his way of thinking, by hanging anyone not wearing a british hat, by killing imams, by killing anyone who theached our old alphabet. by not doing any elections, by sending away the parlement, by killing people from the parlement, by bombing cities with a fucking warship, and by forcefully taking peoples children and giving them away to other people, sorry, but mustafa kemal was the greatest bastard of all time, no one was as disgustingly evil as him, and if you ask me, anyone who thinks like him should be killed on the spot
Exactly
Ataturk might have done some good things to the Turks but he abolished their great empire with the help of the West to weaken Islam and build a racist nationalist western like society that despise other races while forgetting that Turks themselves are a mixed ethnic group of Arabs, Mongols and others Asian and European ethnicities .. Turks weren’t even a country that had any impact in the Middle East during the 70s up till the 2014 when Erdogan with an Islamic party turned Turkey upside down and made something out of it .. Today Turks should be more idolizing Erdogan than ataturk who brought them the fake superior race ideas that brought them nothing but isolation from the world .. I can’t find a single turk that speaks English or any other foreign language yet they claim to be secular and educated and want to be in the European Union 😂
We are proud of having a modern and western revolutionary leader like him founding our country.
Istanbul would still be called Constantinople if it weren't for the Muslims. Try to give credit where credit is due.
Reading about Ataturk, although he was our enemy in the First Balkan war (but later a very good friend of Yugoslavia and our king), this man had it all a good commander, a reformist, intelectual that left an impression he was a Hollywood actor. Truly one of the greatest and complete characters in history.
Just yesterday my friend and I were talking about how a lot of youths in Turkey are very secular.
Speaking of secular youths
Nowhere on earth matches Iranian youths nowadays.
El hamdullillah we are otherwise we would be at the mercy of religion merchants more than we are.
There is even a popular song text in Türkiye talking about this "Shame on those wo believe in believers".
@@samiatash2160 yes! Shia republic of Iran is on steroids. Soon it will collapse most possibly.
Secular means dishonest to one's own faith
It also depends on region. Turks on western coast are very progressive and secular. Turkmen in the south or eastern Anatolia are pretty religious and nationalist.
Based Attaturk !
Respect to Turks from Morocco
he destroyed islam wdym bro? ataturk is lucky he didn't live in the same era as i did
@@afah6850 If There's No Attaturk there's no islam in Anatolia btw.
it could be a heavy Armenian State in the Eastern Turkey and Megali Grecce in Western Turkey and between them a puppet state just like kosovo ...
Attaturk Is A hero
he save his own people from a big genocides ...
@@afah6850 what would you do to Atatürk he is one of the best persons in History he was genius you are prob a poor muslim go cry
@@afah6850 why so? What he has to fear from you?😂😂
@@afah6850😂😂😂😂 you're pathethic
Turkey should be secular
@momanasideka3962 well it won't less long if Erdogan keeps import Islamist from all around the Afghanistan, Pakistan and Syria
He is our father❤you are not turkish and normally u dont like him.bec he gave us freedom republic and everything.even after 1000 years turks will follow his father Atatürk! Know your place!
No he made turkey secular
Turkey is a secular country and it will stay secular!
For a few more years
@Momana Sideka nonsense erdogan has won already
It stil is muslim so are their people you hear the adan there so its a muslim country
@@terrybogars8933 you can hear adan in some parts of russia does that make them a muslim country?
@@zayedbinimran957 those regions where you can hear it yes
Turkiye, democratic, secular, modern, forever. Thank you father Ataturk❤🇹🇷🐺🇦🇿
@HardCore_Islamist May Allah give strength to Ataturk as this guy is trying to bring back Islam into Turkey but ofcourse the Kemalists is preventing such thiings
Lanat on atajew
@HardCore_Islamist Better than arabs, at least they clearly act as who they are.
Impressive that he stopped Turkey from becoming even more of a rump state, against numerous nations at once
Even more?
You mean country with many coup and oppression to people who practice they religion
Absolutely foolish comment to make. He was responsible for the decline of Islam in turkey and for some odd reason the Turks think they see an advanced people when they nothing but looked down on by nations who are in the developed world today
@@ishmaeltalks so u think Turkey would have been better without his policies? Dude, Turkey would have been another rump state like Pakistan, and Greece would have retaken Constantinople. Just like how India bullies Pak.
@@ishmaeltalks I am no fan of Ataturk's secularism but you have to give him credit, without the Turkish war of Independence Turkey wouldn't have been half of what it is now.
There's a lot to say about Kemal Ataturk. Yet I will keep it in a few phrases. His efforts and vision transformed people of Türkiye from subjects to citizens, and the war-torn, completely exploited remnants of the empire, into a functioning country.
There are people in the Muslim world who, for ideological- religious dogmatic reasons, hate this great man.
Like any other great leader, Ataturk had his flaws, mistakes and shortcomings. However, Türkiye is different and more progressive than most Muslim-majority countries for the very reason that it started the forming 20th century with a leader like Ataturk.
Ağzına sağlık
lgbtqi and open fornication is progressive to you.
Subjects? LOL im süre the Pope in europe is thought of the same way... 😂 let öne leader remove the Pope from europe and sen if europeans worship that leader.... the amount of brainwash is insane in NATO occupied Türkiye
@@alex-lu8mi Europeans already atheists. Nobody cares woke pope anymore...
ja ja wie Hitler der Führer🤦♂️
"I do not leave any verses, any dogmas, nor any frozen and moulded principles as spiritual heritage. My spiritual heritage is science and reason."
Mustafa Kemal
I was in Istanbul about 3 weeks ago, he definitely left behind a lot of things there besides ‘sCienCe aND rEAsoN’, namely a concerning amount of flags with his face on it
@@AttaBek1422 that's not about ataturk. is ataturk said put my head and the turkish flag on the streets? ataturk always followed science and reason
@@1karaca2
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anıtkabir
Why is he buried here then? If his heritage is science and reason why does he need a türbe like a sultan? He should have been buried in a regular cemetery like the rest of his people but you Turks treat him like he is a god or a prophet
@@AttaBek1422 Atatürk's will was not a mausoleum for him. It was the conservative DP government that built the monument. you know nothing.
"My people can bury me wherever they want." Atatürk said. you can check it up. YOU DONT REALLY KNOW NOTHING
impressive how Ataturk overturned centuries of Islamic rule in just 15 years.
Turkey is a big country and sadly, a very polarised one.
It's culture war and one of the legacies of Ataturk.
Ata turk is one of the very few muslim leaders who are respected by non muslims.
He is not muslime
@@codez1711 he was Muslim. if not what he was?
@@bulu9214 maybe jew or atheist this guy is against Islam
he gave them what the wanted so of course they respected him
I am a pakistani here. Our country is destroyed by radical islam. Ataturk was a hero. You were lucky to have him. But were not that fortunate. Today my country is in turmoil. I will try to movie in a european country in future.
if Ataturk lived a few more decades he could have inspired and spread secularism and modernism to other muslim states across the world
Pakistan with all do respect is practicing the wrong version of Islam the islam version of Pakistan is radical Islam and terrorist group that kills people in the name of Islam that's why Pakistan is way behind but Islam is not the reason the reason is the misused form of Islam and ignorance because if Islam is used in a wise way no doubt Pakistan will prosper and corruption and any threats will be no nullified
Most of the people who hate K Ataturk are Pakistanies
its nice to see a seculsr pakistani person here. i hope you will be happy man. also i have an advice to you. make lots of secular children and educate them as secular pakistani people. fight for your country
@@sarpkaraba9057lmao most don’t care about him. Only reason he’s even relevant outside of Türkiye is the Ottomans. Plus religiousity and extremist views amongst younger Muslims is on the rise.
All Muslım World have to follow Atatürk, if they want to live with independent
İf you be secular
You will independent
You will have wealth
Your science knowledge will immediately increase
Your education system will get perfect
I’m sorry, but need to study History correctly. Look up Golden Ages, Science in Islam, etc.
@@nakzadi4015 you confused Two subject unfortunately.
(İf you read )Endülüs era ,when it was İslam and science were living golden Era. True. But after this Era science, philosophy and culture blocked by Religous autorithy.İnfact this autorithy was knowing their blocking was wrong but for their politicial future they lived all Müslim World dark age.Still out of Türkiye ,other countries live this dark age.
Turkiye found true religional life and science and culture and WOMAN RİGHTS! Thanks to the ATATÜRK ❤️!
Read Atatürk's revolutions.İ mean
As we Türkiye we are so chancefull.
Secularity in these century so big needing.Follow Türkiye.Follow Atatürk ❤️
that way will led a path to the hellfire, may Atajew burn in eternity
@@1035Ghuraba You sin by slandering ! God knows !!!
Read Atatürk and İslam books.
.Then make comment.
You sin by slandering!
BECAUSE READ
Müslim World was dying under British İmperialism.
Atatürk saved Türkiye from British,Greek,France, İtalian invade.
Müslim World surprised.First times West lost aganist Müslim.Ataturk didn't let Western soldiers enter the mosques.in the 20.th century Best believer was Atatürk !God knows ! Because there was a Leader of Turks ATATÜRK ❤️!
ATATÜRK relaized that neccesary was Secularity.When ATATÜRK start to secular revolution British get worried ! But Atatürk was so decidefull.
Education,religion,defence,economy.health and woman rights !!!!
Until this time Türkiye is first and unique country in the 55 Müslim contries! thanks to Atatürk❤️!!!
Atatürk was knowing İslam so well.
He read 3997 books! All world leaders came to hım for see.
Please Read Atatürk's .Best believer.
İf you are pure Müslim you read.Don't jeal to us.We are modern.Follow to Atatürk.Great Müslim.
@@1035Ghuraba allah yok
We need more secularism in Turkey 🇹🇷⚛️
We need the precise opposite
@@usayeed727 porlistanis want. if islam has destroyed your country, dont let it destroy ours
@@usayeed727 I won't talk to an Islamist who calls the solar language theory stupid
I think Ataturk wanted Turkey to grow but under his ideals, he was in his mind guiding the people towards the right path, and wanted to enable them to eventually prosper as a modern republic. But for then when the state was young, like a child has to be often punished and guided by parents, he had to take control often and guide his nation towards the 'right' path.
yeah, by murdering anyone who opposed his way of thinking, by hanging anyone not wearing a british hat, by killing imams, by killing anyone who theached our old alphabet. by not doing any elections, by sending away the parlement, by killing people from the parlement, by bombing cities with a fucking warship, and by forcefully taking peoples children and giving them away to other people, sorry, but mustafa kemal was the greatest bastard of all time, no one was as disgustingly evil as him, and if you ask me, anyone who thinks like him should be killed on the spot
The right path is Islam.
@@mradamdsmith A book cannot just cover what "right" is.
@@eturkoz If it's a book from the Almighty then it definitely can.
@@shafayatmohammadfardeen6480 If a book is almighty, then go to a library and read them all.
Secular: not subject to or bound by religious rule; not belonging to or living in a monastic or other order.
He basically gaved us a choise to determine our own future just to later we found out it was not us alone and we just found out we were determining nothing at all this time.
Ataturk might have done some good things to the Turks but he abolished their great empire with the help of the West to weaken Islam and build a racist nationalist western like society that despise other races while forgetting that Turks themselves are a mixed ethnic group of Arabs, Mongols and others Asian and European ethnicities .. Turks weren’t even a country that had any impact in the Middle East during the 70s up till the 2014 when Erdogan with an Islamic party turned Turkey upside down and made something out of it .. Today Turks should be more idolizing Erdogan than ataturk who brought them the fake superior race ideas that brought them nothing but isolation from the world .. I can’t find a single turk that speaks English or any other foreign language yet they claim to be secular and educated and want to be in the European Union 😂
Atatürk’s ideology and aims were almost same with Mahmud II 👀
Nohhh!!! You can't compare a Gazi with an unofficial Murtad.
And your gay lol
Don’t compare him to Mahmud II
Mahmud II was greater then him
Ataturk was greater than Sultan Mahmut the Second cause he achieved the reform of alphabet that Mahmut the Second wanted to do so in order to promote the Turkish language ( Cause Latin alphabet is much more adapted to transcript Turkish language than Persian alphabet )
Atatürk zaten 2. Mahmut'un çabalarının bir eseridir. En iyi Osmanlı Padişahlarından biri 2. Mahmut
Ataturk didn't dissolve 2nd parties out of fear, especially the fear of Islamists. 1924 the problem was eastern local revolts(mainly kurdish and small local rebellions), 1929 the problem was the economic decline in USA, the great Depression. 1934 the problem was Hitler's goverment and his vision that there will be a 2nd world war. So please try to inform your audience for the better. Secularism in Turkey as in practice is not Atheism. Thank you for your content. Have a nice day :)
what is it then. tomato , tommato.
@@azmolhossain9244 In what world can you change your country's ruling system to your ideologic way of ruling to full extent in one day? Simple as that. Things need time.
You cannot expect something different from a declared islamist like the owner of the channel
Baba bunlar Islam ile kafayi bozmus anlayamazlar Ata'mizin bizim icin yaptiklarini
1934de hangi parti kapandı? Cevap verirseniz sevinirim
Fun anecdote: Ataturk questioned an Imam about Islam and realized he was not a real one but forgave him because of his honesty. Ordered him to study properly saying'' This place is a touristic location, what would you say when a Non Muslim would want to learn more about Islam? I will test you again next time I am here''
Hmm? What did he ask this imam?
@@makmet3024The conversation went like this:
Atatürk asked the Imam, "Would you like a pint of beer on this hot day?". The Imam rejected the beer saying "It is haram sir. I cannot drink beer."
Atatürk, curious, asked him "Why is it Haram?". The Imam, confused, replied "Because it is sir." In response, Atatürk asked "Is there no verse in the hadith or Qur'an that says Alcohol is prohibited? If so, which ones?" The Imam which couldn't answer the question said "Sir, I do not know how to read or write. I became an Imam because I had no job and I went to a Mektep when I was young." Atatürk, said in response, "Thank you for your honesty Hodja, we will give you the resources to study and teach the Qur'an." He then turned to the person next to him, Fevzi Çakmak, and said: "This is why I want to translate the Qur'an to Turkish. So people know what they are reading."
@@makmet3024 Atatürk knowingly said, "Imam, wouldn't a cold alcohol be nice in this heat?" The imam said, "No way, it is haram." Atatürk asked, In which verse or hadith does it state that it is haram? The imam could not answer.
What?.......
Qur'an 4:43, O you who have believed, indeed, intoxicants (khamr), gambling, [sacrificing on] stone altars [to other than God], and divining arrows are but defilement from the work of Satan, so avoid it that you may be successful.
@@makmet3024 My comment has been deleted fully answering the thing but the Imam was illiterate and went to a Qur'an course in his childhood. He did not understand the Qur'an so when Atatürk asked him the question he could not give an answer on WHY it was Haram.
If you learn more about him, you can read Nutuk which is journal and which he noted what he experinced
yeah, by murdering anyone who opposed his way of thinking, by hanging anyone not wearing a british hat, by killing imams, by killing anyone who theached our old alphabet. by not doing any elections, by sending away the parlement, by killing people from the parlement, by bombing cities with a fucking warship, and by forcefully taking peoples children and giving them away to other people, sorry, but mustafa kemal was the greatest bastard of all time, no one was as disgustingly evil as him, and if you ask me, anyone who thinks like him should be killed on the spot
Eternal respect to Ataturk from me-a Nigerian and a Christian-for having vision, resolve and determination to build his nation into a strong, nationalist and modern entity that cherished it's heritage but would not be stifled and hindered by it. Really amazing how such a leader like him accomplished so much despite the real threat of hard-line islamic fundamentalism and foreign interference potentially ending his life and undermining everything he worked for. It is undeniable that modern Turkey owes him and his cohorts a great debt. He is like Seretse Khama.
He had eternal respect for greek Christ mians eho he genocided
He has Eternal respect of the muslims he supressed.
@@ibro8855 like Communist did in europe. He may have supressed religion for a while but religion never dies and certianly not Islam. It will always existed. It just keeps getting stronger. When you supress Islam it will only come back stronger and even more hardcore. Afghanistan and Iran are one example.
@@Beyonder1987 He did not supress religion in a way you think he did. He just toned down Religion's influence over society, which should be done in every country.
@@Agentblue009 Tone down? i think he did go far as replacing Written language from Arabic to Latin which is really insane to come think of it as the Turks have always known Arabic script. Added to that he brought into laws where Muslims cannot call to prey in Arabic which is the basis of all islamic teaching. He wanted it in turkish which is not acceptable in Islam. There are better ways to modernise a nation that be very aggressive. You take small steps, not a 100 steps. Others muslim leaders such as in Afghanistan and Sha of Iran tried to do what Kemal did but with a more aggressive tone which caused its downfall.
He was a great man, if the Turkish youth follow his ideas, their country can come to good places. btw nice video
😂
@user-ef1zm2pd2h Smartest moslem.
His cult of personality is one reason as to why Turks are so fascist on both sides wether it’s islamists or Kemalist
We can die for Ataturk's revulation. He did hard works at his time. Turkiye is secular country. One day will go away someones but he never... There is something that those who live in Turkey and hate it do not know. They will not be able to show the same hatred in Afghanistan...
Don't forget the little-known conflict between one Kurdish tribe who mostly traded in dairy and another tribe who mostly traded in citrus fruits. So it was basically cheese Kurds vs. lemon Kurds 🥁
Good one lol
😂😂😂
Mustafa Kemal Atatürk was one of the greatest leaders in history and Greatest Turkish Leader in Tukish History
Great for who? The West who supported and influenced him?
Sultan Mehmet was better
@@hamzsportsgaming676 not even close
@A Real Man; 100% Masculine; Hate BTS God would forgive him even if he judged for hell. He saved many lives and let people live their religions freely
Kemal was an accursed child who grew into a shaitan.
The Ottoman Empire always had a secular branch of government so secularism in Turkey isn’t entirely a new thing but ataturk pushed secularism even further
Atatürk was one of the greatest men of the 20th century. Sure, he had his weaknesses, but he was great.
None Muslim, working for the enemy's of Turkey and Islam, ex jew
Are you a muslim??
i love tjis man for eradicating conservative radicalism from Anatolia
Your review is so much flawed and miss so many points. Why did you not talk about his reforms in laicism section? He ordered translating muslim's holy book Kur-an. He dissolved cults, he cut privileges of sheiks and zealots, he gave women equal rights. Other sections are so shallow as well.
Ataturk was the Ulysses S. Grant and Robert E. Lee of Modern day Turkey who helped shape the country into what it is today!
Ataturk had great Commanding and Charismatic leadership skills like Ulysses S. Grant, while also possessing the brilliant tactical and strategical mindset skills like Robert E. Lee! Combined, Ataturk and his soldiers beat the odds that were stacked against them, fighting a multi-front war. Winning not just the battle, but the War itself And the Turks deserve my commendmoration,admiration, and my utmost respect!!!
Greetings and Respect from U.S. :)
Why do you block the Turkish symbol on the thumbnail, crescent and star have nothing to do with islam since it's a paganic symbol. Look at any arab country's flag (except north africa) nobody uses that symbol lol
I'd love to see one on Jinnah and his change of heart from Indian Muslim integration to separatism.
I think the entire Independence movement can be termed as seperatist. Jinnah's movement seems like a seperatist movement within a seperatist movement
@@johnxina5126 I have yet to come across any independence movement from a European imperial power regarded as a "separation" from the said empire.
Would love to do a video on Jinnah in the future!
@@HikmaHistory Jinnah and Ataturk had so many similarities. Both were certainly paradoxical. At least Ataturk made no attempts to hide his disdain of the Islamists and tried to mould the state accordingly while Jinnah was hobnobbing with the very folks he despised the most. He ate pork, drank like a sailor and yet he made a state in the name of Islam. Would love to see your video on Jinnah and would be happy to help in any way I can. I’ve read a lot about Jinnah and his metamorphosis.
@@HikmaHistory You could make one about Bangabandhu too. He separated East pakistan from West or modern day pakistan and created a new country called Bangladesh
He never claimed to be the Leader of Islam, he refused to be a Sultan when Kazim Karabekir and Ismet Inönü asked him to be the next Sultan... All his words are against all religions not exclusively against Islam.
Great Hero.
father of me and all Turks
Not all Turks
@@chto962 I know he didn't have kids 👎
@@chto962 I know idts:)
Thanks for making videos about Turkey 😊
Türk milleti ( Anadolu + Trakya ) hiçbir zaman sömürge ( dominyon ) olmamıştır , Emperyalist ülkeler ( Büyük Britanya, Fransa , İtalya ) Araplar ve diğer uluslar gibi sömürmemiştir; daima bağımsız olmuştur , Arap Sermayesinin sömürgesi olmayacaktır .
Long live Attatürk! The Muslim World need more men (or women) like him. He's among the few dictators (or authoritarian leaders) I respect. The others are: Gadaffi, Tito, Nasser, Lee Kwang Yeh and Rojas Pinilla from Colombia.
Kid mind your own business we all need Allah in this life if any atajew wannabe comes to other country they will be destroyed
Bro respects gaddifi 😂😂😂 what a lunatic
الله لا يوفقك 😂
Ataturk was evil. He oppressed conservatives greatly and disrespected islam by turning mosques into animal farms and night clubs and many other evil things.
don't forget assad of syria, he is secular too
Based on the comments written here, and in response to some points the narrator didn't understand, I will provide a brief summary: Although Atatürk may seem like a leader with complex and inconsistent thoughts, the key to understanding lies in the political rhetoric prevailing worldwide during his time, such as fascism and ethnic nationalism. What makes Atatürk great is not only his planned reforms and military background but also his pragmatic success in implementing these reforms. Also, in comments section I saw some unrealistic stances (muslim out-siders), saying that "let's not abolish the caliphate, but rather establish a softer form of secularism". Well, this would have had disastrous consequences in the uneducated and susceptible society inherited from the Ottoman era(less than 10% literacy) turning Turkey into a mere cesspool in the Middle East. Last but not least: I can talk with you about this topic until morning. I have read more than 10 books about Atatürk, and currently, I am studying political science :)
Başbuğ Kemal 💙
Uygur ağlar, Kerkük ağlar
Ankara'ya umut bağlar
Özgürlüğün düşündeyiz
Canavarın dişindeyiz
You are with Kılıçdaroğlu?
Who kicked earthquake effected people out of thier homes and who is standing with pkk and the one who is trying to seperate turkish people by saying he's an alawait
@@kenanshora bıdı bıdı yapma arap
@@kenanshora Kemal Atatürk not Kılıçdaroğlu
Kerkük ağlıyor??? Biz sana ne yaptık da darıldın???
being modern does not mean stopping piety or disregarding Islam, it means to move ahead and have progress and piety at the same time this is very much possible your nation can be a religious and modern nation at the same time #SaynotoSecularism
A hero
Mustafa Kemal Atatürk ❤️
Great warrior . A real hero with big balls. He has lots of shitty haters around.
@@RusselKabirTR These examples will not change the size of his balls you know. And our brothers should have stayed vigilant and strong. Always possible to see a new stalin, mao or kuteybe around.
@@RusselKabirTR Atatürk is a person who fought for his nation's independence, even If u don't agree with his reforms u have to accept that he is not like those.
It's sad that some people learn about Atatürk from erdogan sponsored sources.
@@RusselKabirTR U aren't worth talking.
Most of the haters are Arabs. Idk why they think their opinion matters.
@@RusselKabirTR Are you referring to the ethnic minorities that committed treason by supporting the invading troops of hostile countries during wartime ?
Well, made it secular...for a while.
Doesn't seem like his successors are doing so good at that lately.
What with the undermining of the democracy, secularism and gender equality parts
Literally, like two days ago the Turkish government censored the opposition on twitter ahead of an election.
@@RusselKabirTR Actually, you’ll often find a lot of people in the US objecting to what they perceive as Christians imposing their views in others, like what happened after Roe v. Wade was overturned.
Although Atatürk is a flawed person with questionable action he still lead the Turk to independence and modernity. May he rest in Peace.
One of my favourite quotes of him is: "Peace at home, Peace in the world"
Such a remarkable person.
How is he gonna rest in peace? Lol
@@mastermokond2633what kind of question is that? What answer do you want me to give?
lol
@jackbirdie😅 single minded sheep
@jackbirdie you got proof hes in hell?
Hero.. Respect
I respect Turkish history and somewhat had some admiration for Atatürk
اتاتورك شخصية غريبة وجميلة
لقد غير شكل دولته للأبد
لولاه لا أصبحت تركيا الآن مثل افغانستان
Next video idea "How Erdogan destroyed Ataturks legacy by destroying the secular state."
Erdogan en cok Islama zarar verdi...Ataturke zarar veremeyecek..
Long live the great Atatürk and the secular and democratic Republic of Turkey.
Y bro 😢
The Ottoman Empire is the best
They are muslims
Y u love that kuffar?
He didn't completely succeed, unfortunately:/
All his deeds will be reversed by erodgan
yep, dog died , many in india will follow him.
Soon all he did will be reversed
@Momana Sideka get rid of secularism, get rid of some liberalism, and republicanism. Sure he will be remembered, but getting rid of those thingsnhe implemented is reversing the most important things he did.
@@azmolhossain9244 don't call him in bad name. Turk will hate you and your country.
1:50 Er musste erstmal die Reformen umsetzen und das System gestalten, es war ein Prozess, sein Ziel war es dort hinzukommen, in einem Prozess bist du nicht sofort von A nach B
Kemalizm + Tengrism ❤
brain dead
@@Metehan-hm7bm 😭😭☠️
100K👍👍 it's about time 🎉
Took some time but we got there in the end!
At 2:10, bro has no information about how anatolian people was ignorant an the time, in additional he used to try to open new parties like 'free republic party' and 'progressive republic party'. Both of the these parties indirectly caused to Menemen Incident and expansion Sheik Said rebellion (we lost the chance of retake mosul from British). As you see, Ataturk wanted to establish a democratic govenrment but he always encountered with ignorance and slavish believe to islamic rumors. This thing still exist with a party called AKP (justice and development party). They did everything except justice and development.
That's why I love Kemal Ataturk! Stop force feeding your religious practices, I don't care about religion that much!
Turkey's flag doesnt represent islam it represents blood of the martyrs at the night , legend here , you can search on the internet :
According to legend, the red on the flag is blood red and represents the shed blood of the martyrs. At midnight, the image of the Turkish flag is formed with the crescent moon and a star reflected on these bloods. It is said that this legend took place in the First Battle of Kosovo, which took place in 1389.
Respect Ataturk from Pakistan
🇵🇰🩷🇹🇷
As a Turk my nationality comes first and I believe in Tengrizm not Islam.We strictly believe Government and (ANY)Religion should be separated due to historical facts about the outcome which ended up mostly crumbling the Uygurs Selcuks and so many examples.
Well i have huge respect to the turkish people, but Look what nationality did to Balkan
The problem with nationality is that lead ultranationalist which is basically racism
You will feel your nationality crumble when you reside in high economic country
I telling this because i experienced it
I really sorry i did come out negative and pushing
I am so sorry
🇲🇷❤️🇹🇷
allah sanada dogru yolu gosterir bir gun hak ediyorsan, hak etmediysen, gecmis olsun diyelim o vakit.
@@ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273 Turkey is to blame for the balkans. They are the reasons why the balkans was a warzone in the first place...500+ years of ottoman slavery in the balkans...
@@ibrahimmohammedibrahim9273 identity is all we have my brother as a Turk.We have Christians Jews as well besides islam..You understand?
@@alperenbaytimur Isa dese inanirim birader...Sizin Allahiniz size olsun..Ben Arap degilim Turkum..
We miss you soooo much Ataturk ❤ Rest in peace ❤
He had the option of becoming a Caliph, and having all the privileges associated with such a position. He rejected it because it did not align with his vision of the future of the country he was trying to build.
Even if he had preserved it- what good would such a position be in the political context of the middle east in the 20th century? The Gulf Arabs wouldn't listen and would have used their wealth to overthrow and destabilise the country. In that sense, he did what had to be done and that is history, and the consequences are felt today.
The Turks have good reason to thank him for the decision he made and the state of Turkey today.
What has alcohol and sex out side of marriage got to do with building new roads, bridges, hospitals and factories? Liberals make no sense.
He seens a lot like Getúlio Vargas of the middle East. A very dificult figure to study … Thanks for sharing the vídeo !!
Thank you for the reference - I'm a big fan of post-1800 Latin American history; admittedly it's mainly the Hispanic countries. Will be researching Vargas more!
Turkey is not a middle eastern country
by trying to destroy the Islamic faith by humiliating it he is truly the enemy of Islam
That's not a bad thing though.
@@willgibbons1733 imagine you had to be forced into a religion and forced to discard your values.
@@mgigachad3170 He didn’t ban islam he just said go practice it in mosques and stop using a religion to further your political and social agendas. So if you want a enemy of Islam blame the individuals who aims to use Islam’s followers for political power and praise Atatürk for keeping Islam what it is a religion, that everybody has a right to belive or not to believe in their private life.(I believe Islam also endorses in peoples freedom to believe or not to believe)
@@egetansk4170 I didn't say ban islam did I his policy against it is what I am referring to for example he turned some mosques into pubs and casino,stables for pigs and horses and banned the hijab forced the Muslims to pray salah in turkish which in our religion is not right.
@@willgibbons1733 Yeah it's not a bad thing to bastardize your folk, it's not a bad thing to make them suffer such stupidly needless complexes, it's not a bad thing to break up your society by screwing up your youths.
Very well told!
Thanks man! Decided to go with a funky structure (6 Arrows) but I think it came out decent in the end.
@@HikmaHistory ja I think so too!
Ataturk was a great leader. Can you show a single country that developed with Islam? Today, children are being abused in the institutions you praise. Those who say they want to be governed by Sharia immediately move to the West, where Islam is not common. If Ataturk had been against Islam, there would not be a single believer left in Turkey. Almost all of the Islamic organizations are supported by either Europe, England or America. Those are the first places they go. Do you know where those who tried to spread Sharia ideas under the name of Islam in Turkey in the 1950s came from?
Wearing a Fez is a vibe, though
Couldn’t agree more
when II. Mahmud bringed fez some idiots were angry at him than Atatürk bringed hat and some idiots were angry at him too they are just typical idiots
I am a turkiey and I love ata turk
This guy said ataturk basically was the reason to buy into his sponsor I'm done bro 03:00 💀
The steel-colored brightness of [his] eyes shines out of the warrior-like, sunburned brown of [his] face with an uncanny, captivating power. Eyes, within which the supple power and the ruthless will of self-assertion of the Turanian grey wolf twin- kles." Be it Aryan, Turanian, or even Mongolian, or, again perhaps obviously, Prussian-when, in the narratives, Atatürk meets the Kai- ser, Hindenburg, and Ludendorff in 1917-what his appearance and actions reaffirmed was the awakening and the "triumph of race." Schopen concluded:
He is nothing less than the incarnation of all warrior-like na- tions. The Turk is, in his moral qualities, one of the best sol- diers of the world. For him the victorious military Führer stands above everything else. And Mustafa Kemal, mathematician and carrier of soldier blood from his father's line, was a genius of the strategic idea."7
For most of these texts, Atatürk was the ultimate warrior-"battle was his nature."+ Froembgen described him as "a thunderstorm turned man." Melzig said in his Atatürk biography: "In him a he- roic spirit rose to the light from the depth of thousands of years." Froembgen also stressed, "He is a soldier the like of which seldom comes along." Atatürk's prowess in battle was stressed time and again: "The soldiers hesitated to throw themselves into the rain of death. Mustafa Kemal knows, here no order will be enough, here one needs to be a role model, to be a Führer."52 The Führer as a role model for everybody-in battle, for the Turkish farmer with his model farm, but also for the ordinary Turk, when it comes to demeanor, dress, and indeed everything-was a constant theme of these texts.53
Descriptions of Atatürk's aura elevated him to messianistic levels. With his deeds at Gallipoli during World War I, Atatürk emerges in these narratives not only as the imminent savior of Constantino- ple but as a transcendental "savior." Indeed, the formula "savior and Führer" was frequently put forward by some texts. Some stressed that one could feel a special aura, "a magic circle," in his presence he was "the chosen one."
VİVA OUR DEAR FATHER ATATURK!!!!!!!!!!!!
genuine question to any secular turks, how do you like enver pasha? do you think he is similar to atatürk in some ways?
Turkıye Not Arabıa !!!! Turkıye Democratıc, secular, Modern .And Ataturk is our ancestor, our ancestor
Very Very Very Thanks Atatürk 🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷
Mustafa Kemal Atatürk is one of the best Turkish leaders.
He wasn't Turk he was greek
@@Mizar4😂 todays Greece and lots of other countries were ottoman lands and everywhere Turkish people was living. His patents and ancestors are Turkish nomads in Anatolia.
Yaşasın Türkiye Cumhuriyeti 1923 - 202oo, Yaşatılsın Ulu Önder Gazi Mustafa Kemal Atatürk. 1881 - 193oo.🇹🇷💐🙏
Long Live the Republic of Turkey 1923 - 202oo, Long Live the Great Leader Gazi Mustafa Kemal Atatürk. 1881 - 193oo.🇹🇷💐🙏
"The heart does not derive pure pleasure from what is impermanent"
- Said Bediüzzaman Nursi
sounds like Plato ^.^
I was a student of Bediüzzaman or talabun nur for 4 or 5 years. And the most disturbing thing about him is his view towards Theory of Evolution or people who holds the theory to be true.
@@beepboop204most sufis sound like Plato
@Hikma History, Congrats with your 100K brother. Are we going to get a 100K sub video?
Atam benim ❤️ Thank you for everything
Long Live Ataturk❤️
If state adopt any religion, people quit. If State quit, people adopt. its a cat and mouse game.
I find surprising that in Turkey no conservatory Islamist fringe of society tried to make the government fall because of all that sudden secularism ( apart from the Kurds , but they were a minority that were against their turkification). In Iran the attempts of the Shah to secularize the country rapidly lead to the 1979 Revolution ( although I know that in Iran there was also the problem that the Shah was seen as a puppet of the Western countries) .
*On one hand* I hate his views on history, religion, culture and nationalism. He didn't only abmiar the west, according to him western civilisation is literally the only civilisation and anything that is not considered western is barbaric. To me that's mental sickness
*On the other hand* without him turkey wouldn't exist today, he literally defeated 5 armies at the same time by himself!! And his reformers to econmy army and infrastructure can't be denied, I understand why turks love him he literally created their country
As an arab muslim I don't know how to feel about him , he's a very complex person. I'm very interested in reading and learning more about him. His ideas for the better or worse shaped and influenced a lot of leaders throughout the islamic world to this very day
@@oktaythegreat
Selamun aleyküm ، i'm from iraq, do you have any books you recommend about atatürk, or the establishment of the Turkish republic? It would be much appreciated
@@oktaythegreat thank you for your recommendations and your time👍
It's been a while since your comment, but can u elaborate on the first paragraph you wrote? What do you hate about his views on history, religion, culture and nationalism? I think you Arabs are really looking at the situation one-sidedly, I say this because I have not come across any Arab who could understand Ataturk's vision.
You look positive from one side that he defeated 5 armies same time by himself as u said. You know these 5 armies are western imperial powers that want to divide our lands, right? Do u think a nationalist man who fought against the West itself admired the West because it was the West, or did he turn his face to the West because development and prosperity were in the West? Isn't it your prophet who says seek knowledge even if you have to go to as far as China?
@@hussienbintalal91 When your people understand his vision you start to free yourselves from the yoke of Israelis Americans or Russians.
Love from Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️
What war of independence? The Ottoman Empire was defeated in WWI and had to bear the consequences. Its territory was divided among the winners -Britain, France, Italy and Greece, just as Germany was divided in 4 parts after WWII. If a German general had organized a resistance movement aiming at kicking out the Americans, the British, the French and the Soviets would you talk about a "war of independence"? 😃
What were we supposed to do ? You came to our home tried to kick us and we resisted
@@loseyourself5023 Ironic. A turk talking about invading homes and kicking out people...The ottomans did that for 500+ years in the balkans,middle east and africa...
How are they comparable. Zones of occupations faced by the germans after ww2 is not the same as having your lands being sliced off by invaders
"If a German general had organized a resistance movement aiming at kicking out the Americans, the British, the French and the Soviets would you talk about a "war of independence"?"
Of course lol
Kurdish people have their own culture n language, it should be respected n they in return should love n respect the countries they live in ,at the end of the day we are brothers in Humanity who have Islamic affinity with non kurdish Muslims,so let us have mutual respect for all .
in nutuk (ataturks otobiography) he accepted he done some things he dont like about ethnic groups , but u have to understand why he make such things. Look at the history when ever turks lost an area or a war there is always another ethnic group lives under turkic goverments the closest trought the history is şeyh said rebellion. in 1925 turkey and england is going to war for the city mosul ,ataturk give eastern army to 12.500 man to take the city while brits make some agreements with şeyh said . İn that time şeyh said never said ' he was gonna freed kurds' but he said ' ı am mehdi ' to gain power after that turks lost the city mosul şeyh said dead and the army find british golds inside his house . this is why atatürk does such things even do he not proud of these things.
@@efeaydinli25Yes Ataturk admitted that he wasn't proud or happy about some of his methods but felt that it was necessary to protect the mother land from potential traitors. It was mere political strategy.
Long live islam and muslims from ever🎉
You Sunni or Shia 😂😂
@@lou6749 sunni😊
@@muslime9515 I'm Shia 🤣 to bad..
@@lou6749 i respect😊
@@muslime9515 I respect everyone doesn't matter the believe religion is a cult nothing else.
14:34 in my opinion, every country should do this.
We’re in the modern era. Gale the population shouldn’t be ignored due to outdated views
Islam is not outdated. Islam allows for religious freedom. Kemal just went too hard on secularism and actually banned the Arabic Adhan and the Wearing of hijab.
We dont care about your modernity just don’t interfere with us
I am from Pakistan and in recent years our best leader I ran Khan also seems to be the most religious while the other leaders only care about getting as much of people taxpayer money to buy there luxury apartments on the other side of the world
The Turkish state could have been saved without abandoning Islam
He killed the opposition and got support from the europeans and russia.
Based Atatürk
I admire Ataturk but I think he went a bit too far in adopting a harshly secular model for his republic (incidentally, the Turkish word "laiklik" is taken from the French "laicite"), even going as far as forcing mosques to call prayers in Turkish instead of Arabic, which is why a conservative-populist party AKP still popular among many Turks. Would he instead adopt the US model of separation between the church and state which is a softer approach when dealing with religion and politics, religious conservatives of Turkey wouldn't have much to complain about. Still, he did far more good for his country than bad cause he managed to save his country from partition by the Entente powers, developed the economy and introduced much-needed societal reforms, especially when it comes to women's rights.
Azan should be Turkish in Turkey...
@kızgın tosbağa I am Turkish and I dont want non Turkish backwardness in my country.
Akp is not popular. There ara no democtaric and fair elections in Turkey.
Adnan can only be on Arabic no other language
@@hamzsportsgaming676 No it can. It is not written in quran.
This was quite difficult to watch. To summarize, he saw weakness in the technology, economy, education, and unity of the country. Ataturk's solution to the education problem of the religious people was to hinder the education of religious people by requiring them to abandon their clothing, their day of rest, and their system of morality if they wished to get an education. He also changed the writing style rather than educating the people in how to read it, so that they would be cut off from centuries of philosophy, religion, and political thought. Basically, he severely limited the ability for people to hold different ideas from him. He sought to remove the connecting idea of brotherhood across the Muslim world, and instead focus back on a form of tribalism called "nationalism", where he forced anyone currently in the country to pretend they were part of his tribe. We had modernists in Pakistan, as well, and Quaid-e-Azam, the founder of our country, was a modernist. However, Ataturk would be considered extreme. His actions as described in this video are far closer to the fascism which was sweeping Europe at the time, and I believe since he tied his goals to imitating Europe, he would be easily swayed by those philosophies. After all, fascism did abandon much in favor of "nationalism", technological development, and extreme unity. Germany and Italy both greatly advanced their technological capabilities. Thank God that Turkiye never fully followed in those footsteps. I truly hope Turkiye elevates itself from this petty Kemalism.
Great comment. Regarding the change of the alphabet I thought the motive behind it was just the same as it was when he changed the call to prayer from Arabic to Turkish: hatred of Arabs and everything that's associated with them.
But your conclusion that he wanted to limit the sources of information that didn't allign with his ideology, appealed to my common sense right after I read it.
It is genius but diabolical at the same time.
And he succeeded, overall Turkish Muslims are one of the least religious Muslims out there only surpassed by Muslims from ex communist countries.
@@drt-tv7ct It makes me laugh, I see Turks in the UK with tattoos, eating pork, drinking alcohol. I ask them are you Muslim they say yes, I say to them your not Muslim and they get angry. Nothing about them is Muslim but they insist they are Muslims. Even when I go to the Turkish mosque it is so different how they pray and behave.
Arabic traditions&living culture is not religion itself. Atatürk tried to create a Turkish Nation from the wreckages of ummah ideology which is strongly embedded with Arabic traditions.
Today, existing goverment is trying to change the course but the youth overwelmingly chosed Atatürk 's ideology despite all the efforts to create medresah education again. I think, consequences can be visible within a decade.
Pakistan and Iran should follow the same route, otherwise they feel pain when they recognise how much behind they are in all fields.
@@freemillenniumideas if it was just culture he wouldn't be so controversial. Secularism and Islam exclude each other. If you have ever read the Quran you know that it's full of commands and punishments for this world. And that it has nothing to do with todays feminism and things like that. The Hadith have even more of that. And a caliph is also part of a Muslim country.
But he removed all of it. Even European countries like Belgium, Spain and England didn't go so far and kept their King. He was a hardcore reformist and not only allowed haram things but even prohibited halal things like marrying more than 1 woman or changed the day people don't work from Friday to Sunday i. e. things that you can't justify with logic
There was no "brotherhood of ummah" back then. You are romanticising post ww1 era islamic world.
Watching all these videos made me realize why the Arabic nations cannot move forward, every time a revolutionary leader wanted to modernize their country, Islamist will deter it from happening. Maybe the islamic world need a renaissance?
Ataturk was a visionary and saw that a conservative or Islam based society can't thrive in this day and age. For example Saudi's wouldn't be rich if they were no oil. He is a dictator but a democratic one at that. He ruled by popular rule also the said parties were filled with Islamists this lead to the speculation that they will undo the changes that was made to modernise the republic. Said Sufi orders and other sects that were active in Ottoman Empire was pretty cooperative with the occupation forces and they were a nuisance that always bugged the Ottoman Empire. They were the cause of many Janissary revolts. They also tried to form a nation in a nation. They were not some great organisation that helped Islam no. They were opportunistic institutions that just took the power away from the state and caused public unrest. Ataturk aimed at destroying one thing that held the people among lines that they did not wish to be a part of. Alevi's and Sunni's Shia's and Yezidi's. These lines established by the local religious influences divided Anatolia and its people. Change was needed so Ataturk greatly isolated religion from politics. Turks are not like the Arabs. The were nationalistic even before Ataturk and they were proud of it. I am a person who descended from Alevis living in Anatolia. Because of that I know the dangers of a divided society. Cultural nationalism was needed and one culture society lead us to prosperity that we've didn't saw in Anatolia for a very long time. Germans wrote about our backwardness and so did the other powers. We were seen as backwards as the Turks and as the Ummah. Ataturk's reforms were needed and those who've resisted these reforms were stopped. I have many Kurdish friends not just or two. I lived in a ethnically diverse place that had many ethnicities living together. We were united with one cultural identity but our values were not lost. We had our own cultures as branches of this countries dominant culture. Our cultures didn't went extinct but were integrated into the Turkish identity as a whole. A mix of Arabic and Persian alphabets were not suitable for the Turkish language so a more suitable alphabet was chosen. During the Great Depression many liberal economies suffered while Turkish economy based on domestic production survived. Dersim Rebellion and other rebellions before that was needed to be destroyed because rebellions as we know is not something that has place in a nation. They were crushed and the regions were pacified. I am saying this as person who is of Alevi descent you people that love the idea of Caliphate that much suppressed us for many years. We've suffered under the caliphate rule and you know what? Ataturk gave our rights we've praised our lord in the ways we wanted. We were not killed like in the old times we were given religious freedom like many other Islamic groups in Anatolia. Though i still have a good laugh when seeing people who think all of these are Ataturk's ideas. These things we talk about is not even originated from Ataturk mostly. These are of a long standing tradition that started with II. Mahmud. After that reforms continued and Ittihadists took control. Ataturk had his own party before the formation of ITF but he choose a more popular option and over time his views were influenced by Ittihadism. Kemalism is a continuation of reforms that started in 1800's and the ideology of Ittihadism. I am a Turkmen Alevi in ethnicity but i don't call my self "Alevi" i call myself "Turk" even though its not encouraged in schools anymore. Arabs and Berbers at that times were under colonies created by their French and British overlords while Turks were prospering under a new system. Thats the duality of these kind of video when it comes to information regarding 6 pillars of Kemalism and Mustafa Kemal Ataturk himself. Tengri Biz Menen!
Are joking turkey was shithold no body knows about before Erdoğan. A friend was traveling through turkey in 90. He told it was dirty shithole. But look at turkey now days
@@jaqafle yeah we cant eat anything erdogan is one of the worst leaders people vote him because he is using religion as a tool
So basically you claim Erdoğan is kind of a savior that saved this country while you know nothing? Its still the same place that your place saw plus he is not a native like me. So his opinion would be more biased and he would of course not like the state of this country because after all he came to this country easily and ate and drank what he/she wanted for a pretty low price. You guys really need to think about it.
@@Atabey381 could baised but I don't what motivation he had to lie for me, but it pretty well stableshed that time Istanbul had problems with electricity, water and pretty much all public infrastructure. Also side note inflation in turkey was much higher before remember you had very high currency nomination up to millions also unemployment was much higher. I get everyone will sick of same guy in power 20 years but you have give the guy at least some credit. I my self live in Kocaeli but moving to Africa. But a decade ago no one could point Türkiye on the map it was i unrelevant place and least known places. You would differ but ask around. My friend didn't came to eate and drink, he come here unvulentry and by change and left as soon as he had the chance for Syria just to finish his business from and also said Syria was much of better place, 20 years later he visited again and said this can rival Europe and I agree very much. We are both Norwegian citizens.
@@jaqafle See my point here? Norwegians citizens can't really understand the general being of Turkey. I am a native who lives in these lands and let me tell you the inflation that me and my family experienced was not worse than the current thing we are experiencing. We had a job a steady income and Americans just ruined everything by embargos but we weren't hungry. Now i live on a diet based of pasta and if i am luck some vegetables. My body needs protein but i can't get much of it unless my roommates get us some food from their parents or great parents. Today I "Poğaça" a pastry that has nothing inside for me to consume. No cheese no chocolate or anything that you can think of. I ate something that has near to the things i need to upkeep my body. This evening as we speak of i am eating a instant noodle because with the money i had in my pockets that the highest thing i can get. Our electricity gets cut every 3 months and sometimes its lowered to 2 months. Eating from the cafeteria is impossible and we use a place we know to wash our clothes. We use public showers to get cleaned and we use communal bathrooms with no privacy and with little time. Look friend because you have money in a country that has a crippling economy doesn't mean that the country you are talking about is in great condition. Well there is more i want to say but it would go into more "private" matters so i am not willing to tell more