I'm not a fan of EXO but D.O's voice is soooo freaking sweet like ohmygosh I can't get enough of it and Luna, I've always loved her voice. I'd love to hear a duet between just D.O and Luna *o*
+paradis3ra i wasn't exo fan .and truly i hated them a lot ...without no reason but recently when i was watching (i remember you ...D.O was so attractive and woowww very good in acting and when i started searching about him and i discover that he is from EXO i was like OOOH PLZZ whyyy Exo (T_T) but when i heard them music and watched them in shows they were verry cutte and lovely i am now EXO-L ..........they re verry good and D.O voice verrrry soft yap he is good he is my bias ^^ PS:i am girl i am just using Ali laptop ^^
+Ali Laftouh it's so funny cuz i kind of liked EXO at first i gived them a chance and ive watched a lot of their shows and suddently my biases kept leaving and now i hate them without any reason (but i like reading fanfics about them dunno why!!)
lol if it wasn't Anna Kendricks for doing that video with f(x) and me getting addicted to 'Electric Shock', I wouldn't have gotten into kpop. and if it wasn't for f(x) I probably wouldn't be an exotic. It was thanks to DO's amazing vocals and harmonizing here that I decided to check them out. amazing how youtube has influenced my life so much haha
That's...wow :D I'm not exactly an f(x) fan but they have plenty of songs I like. I'm actually more of a VIXX and BTS fan. You'll find a lot of groups to love in k-pop ;D so this is just the beginning.
cocoalakin haha yea ive slowly been introduced to other groups through watching the music shows or just going through the performances and I actually just got into UKiss besides the other SM artists along with some of the newer groups like JJCC and HIGH4. For some I'm more of a casual fan like Got7 and VIXX. f(x) was just the beginning haha
I usually hate slow/romantic Asian pop songs, really corny, too bubbly idk just don't care from them at all. But this one has a lot of depth to it, both with vocals and instrumental - first one I've liked ever :)
Try listen to more f(x) songs. Pink Tape (the album this song is from) and the most recent Red Light are amazing. I also really like 9Muses and I don't think their songs are as bubbly as other groups. Brown Eyed Girls are also amazing - Abracadabra, Sixth Sense, Candy Man, Cleansing Cream, After Club are some of my faves.
You should listen to SECRET - "My Boy" (not Ma Boy, but MY Boy). It's a good slow-sad-pop song with piano and their vocals express emotion well in it. ^^
aster tanguilig yes the co-writer is Ambers friend...actually the co-writer is Henry's good friend back in the states..,he was henry's classmate who also became close with Amber!!! Amber's really awesome!
This is making me cry rivers. I'm on my last high school year and i feel so touched by the meaning of this song. I used to have a friend and he loved me but i never knew. Last year i got hospitalized because i suffered anorexia. I didn't went to school for a month. When i came back, my friend confessed his feelings to me. I was scared and i didn't do anything. We never spoke again.. He lives in another city now. If i could only go back in time...
Love this song! I wish F(x) would sing more songs like this! They all have beautiful voices, but wish Luna and Amber could sing more, even though I do love Krystal, sometimes it's a bit high pitched (squeally*)
Holly Nguyen YEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!! omg yessssssssss!!! kyungstal, let's ship. maybe SM will do them like troublemaker? like... krystal half naked, touching the kyungsoo half naked...
Amber's voice is so beautiful,it's a shame that all she could do here was rap in her own song.I'm happy she could record the original version the way she wanted.This lyrics are beautiful but I prefer the original.Plus it seems like a D.O feat F(x)
My sister introduced this song to me, and I love it! Such a cute and sweet song, major props to Amber for writing this. >< D.O.'s warm and beautiful vocals are killin' me, hahaha.
You know, what started out as a 5 minute break has ended up in listening to all the songs in Pink Tape. Shoots. But it's worth it! Love this song, and love almost all the other songs as well xD probably this one's going to be a favorite song forever too
Over the years Krystal has improved vocally. I personally feel like if she practices more with vocal her and Luna could both bust out some serious ad-libs together. Like in their song milk of their most recent album the ad-libs from Krystal and Luna at the end give me the feels. They're so simple and not even high notes but their chemistry and voices go very well together.
OOOOOKKKAAAAYYYYY I love EXO and I love DO, but it seriously frustrates me that Amber's part is so short and DO is singing throughout the whole thing. I do realize he's a singer, and that's what he does in EXO but, I learned Amber's part in a span of 5 minutes. Even the little parts that she sings with them. She is such a great singer and has an immense amount of talent that they don't use. I hate when this happens. I dearly love f(x) and this song and all of the members, but it's starting to aggravate me. I didn't realize that she was used so little in f(x) until now. She's my favorite f(x) member next to Krystal. I see her talent. I know she's a great singer. SHE GOT INTO SM JUST BY HER VOICE. She rapped and sang for them and they let her in as a trainee and trained her to become this amazing person. Not to mention she did all that while still learning Korean. She wasn't even all that good and he still did it. I hate when there's a member with a lot of talent and end up with the shit end of the deal.
The lyrics are way too real! It would be hard to find somebody this doens't speak to. This is a really beautiful song, well done Amber! :) (Like the others, I'm just disappointed of the lack of Luna and Amber in it. I don't hate Krystal but Luna (or Amber's amazing voice that I discovered with "Beautiful") would have been a much better choice fot this song).
ok this song actually reminds me and a "friend" i had back in school well i didnt felt anything for him because we were friends but he did felt something for me for about 3 years and the last day on the graduation ceremony he told me he liked me but he never contacted me again because he knew i didn't felt the same and now i regret it because until now he was the only one that loved me the way i was because i didnt hide anything from him and he knew all the stupid things i did and he still liked me so.... :( im sad
D.O and Krystal blending their voices, D.O actually dominates. D.O and Luna blending their voices, it sounds perfect. I don't hate Krystal, it's just that I think Luna deserves more lines here. :)
This song is very nice^^ It is really amazing, and this is one of my favorite songs^^ The english version (which is the original version) is also good too^^ Those lyrics came from our lovely rapper Amber^^
so proud that Amber herself composed this and it's such an awesome song
Amber composed that song?Wow...i really liked the song and its meaning:)
the friendzone has never been sadder...
Omg Ike I fucking balled my eyes when I first heard the song and read the lyrics
I'm not a fan of EXO but D.O's voice is soooo freaking sweet like ohmygosh I can't get enough of it and Luna, I've always loved her voice. I'd love to hear a duet between just D.O and Luna *o*
+paradis3ra u should check them out because they're really talented and their songs are amazing :)
+paradis3ra i wasn't exo fan .and truly i hated them a lot ...without no reason but recently when i was watching (i remember you ...D.O was so attractive and woowww very good in acting and when i started searching about him and i discover that he is from EXO i was like OOOH PLZZ whyyy Exo (T_T) but when i heard them music and watched them in shows they were verry cutte and lovely i am now EXO-L ..........they re verry good and D.O voice verrrry soft yap he is good he is my bias ^^
PS:i am girl i am just using Ali laptop ^^
+Ali Laftouh it's so funny cuz i kind of liked EXO at first i gived them a chance and ive watched a lot of their shows and suddently my biases kept leaving and now i hate them without any reason (but i like reading fanfics about them dunno why!!)
+Hajar Jalili reaalllllllly who is your bias.....??? ...... kris..luhan..tao ??
Ali Laftouh at first it was kris then i switched to luhan when he left i realised that my bad luck effected the fandom so i left peacefully
I swear Luna and D.O NEED to have a solo song together! It would sound perfect 💖❤️
Love it when Krystal and Amber sings the english lines.
Luna's high note towards the note is everything. D.O and Krystal harmony is everything. Amber's voice is everything. I just really love this song.
Amber wrote this song!!! nice lyrics......love them...f(x)!!!!
did she write the whole song? even the melody part? wooww
Camille Afurong yes she did!!! she's studying on how to compose songs....so I really hope she'll make another good song in the future...!!!amazing...
J Salgado I'm pretty sure there was a co-writer too oh and she also
helped with the music (instrumentals too) :)
i though she only composed the song. she had written the song originally in english and then SM kept the melody but changed the lyrics.
OMO MY UNNIE AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!
one of the type of songs i can keep listening to without getting bored of it^^
i've literally been so obsessed with this song so much i can't stop listening to it
Love d.o voice
Fits the song perfectly♥
Luna voice so good ~~~~~
DO's voice never fails I swear
lol if it wasn't Anna Kendricks for doing that video with f(x) and me getting addicted to 'Electric Shock', I wouldn't have gotten into kpop. and if it wasn't for f(x) I probably wouldn't be an exotic. It was thanks to DO's amazing vocals and harmonizing here that I decided to check them out. amazing how youtube has influenced my life so much haha
haha once you are in, there is no way out /evil laugh
haha you can say that again
YOU CAN NEVA ESCAPE DONT EVEN TRY!!!!! *EVIL LAUGH IN THE BACKGROUND*
That's...wow :D I'm not exactly an f(x) fan but they have plenty of songs I like. I'm actually more of a VIXX and BTS fan. You'll find a lot of groups to love in k-pop ;D so this is just the beginning.
cocoalakin haha yea ive slowly been introduced to other groups through watching the music shows or just going through the performances and I actually just got into UKiss besides the other SM artists along with some of the newer groups like JJCC and HIGH4. For some I'm more of a casual fan like Got7 and VIXX. f(x) was just the beginning haha
Luna and D.O singing together... omg
I usually hate slow/romantic Asian pop songs, really corny, too bubbly idk just don't care from them at all. But this one has a lot of depth to it, both with vocals and instrumental - first one I've liked ever :)
I'm the same way. Maybe try listening to Hyolyn's album Love & Hate. It's more R&B slow songs but still AMAZING :)
thanks ill try that
Try listen to more f(x) songs. Pink Tape (the album this song is from) and the most recent Red Light are amazing. I also really like 9Muses and I don't think their songs are as bubbly as other groups. Brown Eyed Girls are also amazing - Abracadabra, Sixth Sense, Candy Man, Cleansing Cream, After Club are some of my faves.
Try All for you by Eunji and Seo in guk
You should listen to SECRET - "My Boy" (not Ma Boy, but MY Boy). It's a good slow-sad-pop song with piano and their vocals express emotion well in it. ^^
20번 넘게 플레이..진짜 좋다!
곡 자체도 좋지만 가사 진짜 좋다
가사때문에 고등학생의 풋풋한 사랑을 잘 느낄 수 있는 듯
Omg D.O's voice is so amazing
Wish Amber would make the English version of this... Her voice is a gift
She did!
+Beth L Just wanna is better ^_^
디오 음색 엄청 좋다. 그리고 크리스탈이랑 루나랑 같이 화음 넣으면서 하는 거 되게 잘 한다 bb
This is Goodbye Summer, but soon it will be Hello Summer for me...
For me now it's "goodbye summer" and 'hello winter"
I finished reading a manhwa today and it is proud to say that the author said that the characters and story are inspired by this song
can you tell me the tittle?
Oh my God! This was actually really really good! Their voices blend so well together! Loved it!
aster tanguilig yes the co-writer is Ambers friend...actually the co-writer is Henry's good friend back in the states..,he was henry's classmate who also became close with Amber!!! Amber's really awesome!
D.O has a A LOT of parts considering he is featured in another group's song. This should more be like "Goodbye - D.O ft. f(x)"
Yes
Sneha Nair but Ber wrote it.
omg i totally forgot this song until today.
it's such a good. it feels like listening to an oldie. that counts, kinda?
man i miss 2013 though.
This is making me cry rivers. I'm on my last high school year and i feel so touched by the meaning of this song. I used to have a friend and he loved me but i never knew. Last year i got hospitalized because i suffered anorexia. I didn't went to school for a month. When i came back, my friend confessed his feelings to me. I was scared and i didn't do anything. We never spoke again.. He lives in another city now.
If i could only go back in time...
You probably don't use this account anymore but damn you made me cry at 4am
i always wanted to hear amber sing more in this song, but now im happy bc she will have her solo debut in 2015 AND I JUST CAN'T WAIT!
Combination Of D.O's Voice Krystal Is.. Ugh!!😍
2022, anyone?
Whenever I hear this song it never fails to make butterflies inside my stomach. I miss F(x) by the way.❣️
I like the summer songs has because Hot summer , for the beginning of Summer and Goodbye Summer for the end :3 FX Girls are amazing !
and Summer Lover of Red Light
Love this song! I wish F(x) would sing more songs like this! They all have beautiful voices, but wish Luna and Amber could sing more, even though I do love Krystal, sometimes it's a bit high pitched (squeally*)
would've liked it more if amber sang too. :/
Me too. She sounds amazing when she sings!
J Ve i agree!
I agree!
She also wrote the song so I think it's kinda unfair the D.O sang more than her...
yana smiley omg she did?? that just makes it even more unfair then!! oh SM peeps, that is not cool...
Yes she said it herself ~
I felt really bad for her
D.O.'s Voice I CAN'T BREATHEEEE
i think D.O's voice and Krystal's voice sounds DAEBAK!!(no offense)
after this............. i kinda............... ship................ DON'T JUDGE
Holly Nguyen
YEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!
omg yessssssssss!!!
kyungstal, let's ship.
maybe SM will do them like troublemaker? like... krystal half naked, touching the kyungsoo half naked...
marie SHINee omg YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAASSS hahahahaha omg yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaassss ur a genius!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Amber's voice is so beautiful,it's a shame that all she could do here was rap in her own song.I'm happy she could record the original version the way she wanted.This lyrics are beautiful but I prefer the original.Plus it seems like a D.O feat F(x)
My sister introduced this song to me, and I love it! Such a cute and sweet song, major props to Amber for writing this. >< D.O.'s warm and beautiful vocals are killin' me, hahaha.
chiidawg Also, this must be said: D.O. looks amazing in that photo!!! lol, good job, editor. B-D
You know, what started out as a 5 minute break has ended up in listening to all the songs in Pink Tape. Shoots.
But it's worth it! Love this song, and love almost all the other songs as well xD probably this one's going to be a favorite song forever too
I'M SOOOOO IN LOVE WITH D.O's VOICE!!!!
BEAUTIFUL IT ALWAYS MAKES ME CRY...
This song is perfection ^^
Over the years Krystal has improved vocally. I personally feel like if she practices more with vocal her and Luna could both bust out some serious ad-libs together. Like in their song milk of their most recent album the ad-libs from Krystal and Luna at the end give me the feels. They're so simple and not even high notes but their chemistry and voices go very well together.
i Love D.O vOice it makes me felL Like i am in heaven
After reading/understanding the English sub of this song, it made me fall in love with it even more! I love the sweet & cold melody of this song!
I feel so giddy when I hear this! This is way too good!
luna
The lyrics to this is definitely romance comedy film material
It definetly feels like a romcom manga
this song will never get old it reminds me so much of summer
احساس الاغنيه جميل اصواتهم ناعمه تدخل القلب بسرعه والكلمات شي ثاني تعبر عن الاحساس اللي جو القلب الاغنيه تجنن😢💜💜
this song is never getting old
Feeling so emo these days and I'm missing f(x). Btw, this is my fave song in Pink Tape album.
2019, anyone?
you know after listening to these kpop songs, i began to wonder if my love life will be like the ones described in these songs. ^.^
Same here.Sometimes i daydream about it.
D.O and Luna highnote was so lit
Im in love with their voices OMG ;;;
I love the song.. i love their voices..n most importantly i totally like the lyrics...
One of my favourite male artist's voice !!!
the photos that can't define our relationship , is a heartbreaking story .
i'm sorry , summer , now goodbye .
#fx #exo #goodbyesummer #kpop
Omgod when Luna and D.O sang the high note one their voice really blend. Omgash omgash kyaaah sorry im bad at english
Who is still watching it(2015)??????!!!!!!
I have another thing to ask. Is Amber a boy or a girl:-? º-º
***** I thought that she was a boy %80
Meeeee !!! I really like this song ,especially D.O. , because of him I discover this song. OMG his voice make me melt
me. I'm really like kyungsoo voice+Krystal voice
+sahe soso me and a looooot D.O voice just waaaw so soft and beautifulll ^^
kyungsoo's voice is so perfect in this song ♥ I love this is a perfect match C:
all the harmonies are very pretty.... d.os voice goes very nicely with lunas
omg this song was just so beautiful and yet sad because i can relate to it omg i was close to crying...
OOOOOKKKAAAAYYYYY I love EXO and I love DO, but it seriously frustrates me that Amber's part is so short and DO is singing throughout the whole thing. I do realize he's a singer, and that's what he does in EXO but, I learned Amber's part in a span of 5 minutes. Even the little parts that she sings with them. She is such a great singer and has an immense amount of talent that they don't use. I hate when this happens. I dearly love f(x) and this song and all of the members, but it's starting to aggravate me. I didn't realize that she was used so little in f(x) until now. She's my favorite f(x) member next to Krystal. I see her talent. I know she's a great singer. SHE GOT INTO SM JUST BY HER VOICE. She rapped and sang for them and they let her in as a trainee and trained her to become this amazing person. Not to mention she did all that while still learning Korean. She wasn't even all that good and he still did it. I hate when there's a member with a lot of talent and end up with the shit end of the deal.
Don't worry, Amber's solo debut is on its way VERY soon. This month actually.
She's doing an english version of this song with Eric Nam on her mini-album!!!
Thanks for uploading
listening to this on the last day of summer... :(
RIP
Thanks for the subs! You're awesome!
I love d.o and krystal voice duet its almost thousand i hear good bye summer songs. ❤️
Luna's and D.O's voice make a good match.
Soojung and D.O's voice really fit together. They both have soft voices.
Love this! hope they make an MV for this~ Btw I love Luna and D.O's voice
i dunno why i always cry listening to this song. remines me of my old high school days...
The lyrics are way too real! It would be hard to find somebody this doens't speak to.
This is a really beautiful song, well done Amber! :)
(Like the others, I'm just disappointed of the lack of Luna and Amber in it. I don't hate Krystal but Luna (or Amber's amazing voice that I discovered with "Beautiful") would have been a much better choice fot this song).
This is such a very nice song. D.O'ss voice is very nice!
one of the best song in 2013
ok this song actually reminds me and a "friend" i had back in school well i didnt felt anything for him because we were friends but he did felt something for me for about 3 years and the last day on the graduation ceremony he told me he liked me but he never contacted me again because he knew i didn't felt the same and now i regret it because until now he was the only one that loved me the way i was because i didnt hide anything from him and he knew all the stupid things i did and he still liked me so.... :( im sad
D.O and Krystal blending their voices, D.O actually dominates.
D.O and Luna blending their voices, it sounds perfect.
I don't hate Krystal, it's just that I think Luna deserves more lines here. :)
the song and the lyrics makes me cry :
환상의 콤비
AMBER SİNGS THİS SONG İN ENGLİSH İN HER NEW ALBUM WİTH ERİC NAM!
IT'S CALLED " I JUST WANNA"
I really wish RUclips would make a Love button.
Amber 's voice is very good !! I like it
God D.O. stahp playing with my heart and being perf with your singing
I am in love with this song.
노래정말좋네요..
i love D.O and krystal match couple
but she's with kai now hohohohohoho
"You cried so much on the day before graduation
"You held it in firmly since you're a guy.
Pfft.
its 2022 and i come for this lovely song....i miss you guys...
amber wrote this song that's why its so good
I really loved this song~
D.O's voice ❤_❤ I love this song, it's perfection!~
I really really love this song.....
Amber's song!!!!
this song felt me in love ♥
Omo krystal so sweet..aww
luna is so pretty i really love her :)
Hi, MeU! Luna's new song "After This Night Is Over" released. You can find by writting "LUNA&UL feat Danny Jung" on RUclips's search button.
Love luna she is so talented and attractive
♥ I really like this song , D.O. and f(x) sing well ,their voice sound good♥
i love this song so much
i swear krystal and d.o NEED to have a solo song together! it would soung perfect
i hope that would happen soon
D.O sang lot of lines..and i like it the most
This song is very nice^^ It is really amazing, and this is one of my favorite songs^^ The english version (which is the original version) is also good too^^ Those lyrics came from our lovely rapper Amber^^