"She deserved better". No. No she didn't. She 100% deserved what she got. She lied to her still grieving clanmates, Frecklewish, her leader and let them believe that Birchface aka a recently deceased was the father of her kits. she indirectly lied but she still LIED. Furthermore SHE was the one responsible for her kits, clearly telling Appledusk that she would raise their kits alone. She is the one who got her and Appledusk's kits killed. She was the one responsible for them and she was the one who carelessly took her kits across a flooded river that even little Petalkit could see wasn't safe when she had other, safer options. Also i think Mapleshade was the other woman. She refused to take blame for her own actions and she lied to her leader, frecklewish and the rest of her clanmates , took her kits across a flooded river, she killed 3 cats and tried to kill a pregnant Reedshine. All in all she 100% deserved what she got.
@@Ab5tract._on.paw5just cuz someone betrays you doesn’t give you the right to… kill them?? that’s a pretty messed up point of view. also, duh, the novella was from mapleshades pov,p. ofc its going to make her seem in the right, but do me a favor and take a second to think of it from a 3rd person pov.
@@xx1derqueeniexxSo it's fine for Bluestar and others to have half clan kits? Everyone in Mapleshades book was wrong, but her treatment was still obviously bad
Раньше я никогда не задумывалась как эта песня подходит Кленовнице, это просто чудесно. Я так люблю спец.издание про Метеора (Crookedstar, yes) и всё связанное с ним. Надеюсь эту карту увидят больше людей
I'm so thankfull I could participate to this amazing project ! Everyone did their best and it's soooo wholesome :D Congrats to all the talented artists here !!
This map is amazing, it shows mapleshades story well! i remember spectating the server and being excited for this to be completed! good job to all the participants however i still stand with my opinion, mapleshade caused everything she went through
@@mightyleafster actually though- ive had so many people tell me im wrong when i say that people legit make me cry sometimes- they always say “apple and raven need to rot in the dark forest! maple needs starclan!” and im just dying like guys chill she killed cats for no reason
@@Raven15- I only say Appledusk, like I actually like Raven a bit and Freekle well.. But Freekle actually broke the rule. Because she didn't saved the kids from drowning
I love maple shades design! She really looks normal, like any other character, and she doesn’t feel like- an exaggerated transformed-villain! Beautiful design concept! Really, lovely work by everyone!
This is awesome - couldn’t think of a better song if I tried! And the animation is smooth and gives chills. Great job everyone who participated in this!
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!! I had an idea similar to this years ago, but I never ended up hosting the map. I'm so glad someone else brought this idea to life, all of you made such a beautiful masterpiece!
Does this have spoilers for mapleshade's vengeance? Sorry i really want to watch it but i only read crookedstar's promise (and up to most of omen of the stars) and hate spoilers "XD
hi I created a French version of this video and I credited it, I forgot to ask you first so should I delete it or not? In any case I'm sorry I will delete it if you ask me
I'm sorry, but please delete it. I have explicitly stated in the opening slogan that reposting this MAP without authorization is not allowed. Additionally, you have removed the opening slogan and the credits at the end, which is something I do not permit.
OMG! Everyone did great! Thank you for allowing me to be in this MAP! ✨
I still feel so bad for her. She deserved better. But that's just what it takes to make villains.
"She deserved better". No. No she didn't. She 100% deserved what she got. She lied to her still grieving clanmates, Frecklewish, her leader and let them believe that Birchface aka a recently deceased was the father of her kits. she indirectly lied but she still LIED. Furthermore SHE was the one responsible for her kits, clearly telling Appledusk that she would raise their kits alone. She is the one who got her and Appledusk's kits killed. She was the one responsible for them and she was the one who carelessly took her kits across a flooded river that even little Petalkit could see wasn't safe when she had other, safer options. Also i think Mapleshade was the other woman. She refused to take blame for her own actions and she lied to her leader, frecklewish and the rest of her clanmates , took her kits across a flooded river, she killed 3 cats and tried to kill a pregnant Reedshine. All in all she 100% deserved what she got.
@@xx1derqueeniexxhave you read mapleshades book?? If u did you wouldn’t be so harsh :/ plus a lot of those cats had betrayed her as well
@@Ab5tract._on.paw5just cuz someone betrays you doesn’t give you the right to… kill them?? that’s a pretty messed up point of view. also, duh, the novella was from mapleshades pov,p. ofc its going to make her seem in the right, but do me a favor and take a second to think of it from a 3rd person pov.
@@xx1derqueeniexxSo it's fine for Bluestar and others to have half clan kits? Everyone in Mapleshades book was wrong, but her treatment was still obviously bad
@@xx1derqueeniexxshe also gr00med crookedkit
恭喜冷霜第一個MAP完成！！
謝謝芽糖💖
this Map is incredible, well done to the artists
OHH THIS TURNED OUT BEAUTIFULLY! I’m so happy to have taken part of this map and everyone else did such a lovely job!
So happy I was a have to participate in this map! Thanks for having me!
Раньше я никогда не задумывалась как эта песня подходит Кленовнице, это просто чудесно. Я так люблю спец.издание про Метеора (Crookedstar, yes) и всё связанное с ним. Надеюсь эту карту увидят больше людей
Open up your eyes! очень понравилось испольнение
I'm so thankfull I could participate to this amazing project ! Everyone did their best and it's soooo wholesome :D
Congrats to all the talented artists here !!
Why does the voice fits do good with her (and the characters too)
This is amazing! I loved it and everyone did so well
I remember this song.
Edit: this is amazing, why are there not very many comments??
Hi
This map is amazing, it shows mapleshades story well! i remember spectating the server and being excited for this to be completed! good job to all the participants
however i still stand with my opinion, mapleshade caused everything she went through
For real if she just hadn’t lied and said birchface was the father and just went with “oh I’ll be raising them alone” then sm could’ve been avoided 😭
@@mightyleafster actually though- ive had so many people tell me im wrong when i say that
people legit make me cry sometimes- they always say “apple and raven need to rot in the dark forest! maple needs starclan!” and im just dying like guys chill she killed cats for no reason
omg finally a reply section where no one is arguing or whining
@@mightyleafster She didn't! It was spreeklewish (idk if I wrote the name right, I don't like her) who said it
@@Raven15- I only say Appledusk, like I actually like Raven a bit and Freekle well.. But Freekle actually broke the rule. Because she didn't saved the kids from drowning
I love maple shades design! She really looks normal, like any other character, and she doesn’t feel like- an exaggerated transformed-villain! Beautiful design concept! Really, lovely work by everyone!
This was awesome !! Good job to everyone who participated. :D
Wow this is super cool
YES! I can’t believe a M.A.P with this song of these two is just now coming out! Very excited
So glad I could participate!!
all the artists did their best
THE ANIMATORS ARE SO GOOD
Beautifully done!
Wow. Very. Cool and my favorite song❤
Soooo good!!!
辛苦了!
Woohooo
I just watched the mlp movie so this is amazing timing! AMAZING!
Я обожаю этот мап и Кленовницу! ❤❤
期待喔～
This is amazing! I love crookedstar as promise and this fits them so well!
EVERYONE DID SUCH GOOD JOB AAAA ❤❤❤
This is amazing, I love the detail of mapleshade and Tempest’s voice fits her so well ♥️
OMG THIS MAP IS SO GOOD,FROM THE STORYTELLING TO THEIR EXPRESSIONS.THERE ARE NO WORDS GOOD ENOUGH TO EXPLAIN HOW GOOD THIS MAP IS
Listening to the lyrics, I don’t think of the My Little Pony Movie anymore, this really fits, and it was touching.❤
炸毛畫的耶~（看fb進來的😂
- Все прекрасно постарались! А вообще я пришла сюда только ради части сестры. ❤
Love it! I was one of the spectators!
超讚我都看哭了😭😭😭冷霜辛苦了！！！
不會!參與的大家也都辛苦了!
Everyone did so well!! This map turned out amazing!
This is awesome - couldn’t think of a better song if I tried! And the animation is smooth and gives chills. Great job everyone who participated in this!
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!! I had an idea similar to this years ago, but I never ended up hosting the map. I'm so glad someone else brought this idea to life, all of you made such a beautiful masterpiece!
Epic!!
Amazing❤
This is a great song for them
This fits them perfectly 😭
this MAP is amazing
OH MY GOD ITS AMAZING !!!!
You have no idea how many times I watched this 😅
This is so underrated 😭
Yes.
Hello! Sorry im late, ive watch before but may i record this for a edit?
Does this have spoilers for mapleshade's vengeance? Sorry i really want to watch it but i only read crookedstar's promise (and up to most of omen of the stars) and hate spoilers "XD
it does
Mapleshades crimes arent good but she had visions of her dead kits telling her to get revenge and kill them
This is amazing! Everyone did great!
hi I created a French version of this video and I credited it, I forgot to ask you first so should I delete it or not? In any case I'm sorry I will delete it if you ask me
I'm sorry, but please delete it. I have explicitly stated in the opening slogan that reposting this MAP without authorization is not allowed. Additionally, you have removed the opening slogan and the credits at the end, which is something I do not permit.
yes of course, once again sorry.... I want to say that your MAP is incredible ^^ Have a good day :)
Thanks^^