Bank station is a nightmare. Sadly, there is a growing tribe of underground dwelling people stuck in Bank station, for they can never figure out how to exit that labryinth of a station.
@@litetakeri remember once when I loved to London and was meeting a friend near bank coming from Canary Wharf, the way in was so packed they had closed the entrance gates and people where literally suck standing still unable to move forward.
I like the way that London's transport system is a messy memorial to past enthusiasms, like an archetypal teenager's bedroom - a distressing muddle that somehow kind of works, most of the time.
As a member of the original team that built the DLR, one of the benefits of Tower Gateway (TOG ) was to provide tourists with an easy way to get between The Tower of London / Tower Bridge and Greenwich, two historically important areas for tourism. Originally, TOG trains went to Island Gardens, at which a person would walk through the Thames Tunnel to Greenwich. Back in the late 1980s, I and many others did just that ... as tourists. To do that today, a person would need to change trains (since TOG trains only go to Beckton), and exit the DLR on the south side of the river at Greenwich.
Your Rolling Stones reference reminded me of a Limerick that goes thus: There was a young man from Japan Whose verses would never quite scan. When asked why this was, He said it's because I always like to try and get as many words into the last line as I possibly can.
The version I learnt at school has 19 words in the last line to your 18: There was a young man from Japan Whose limericks never would scan When told this was so He replied yes I know But I always try to get as many worlds into to the last line as I ever possibly can.
2:14I love those 'next train' indicators that say 'Check front of train'. "We've no idea how far it may be going, it's entirely up to the driver" 🤷♂️, it seems to be saying
Love the Towie G casually slipped in at 6:57. Made a special trip last year to finally travel from the station. If they had enough capacity at Bank it would probably have gone by now. Also lucky there was space fory the viaduct. But it's a classic example of half a loaf is better than none; Towie G got the DLR started, it built up success, demand rose and it could then be expanded. Like Crossrail was originally projected to stop at Maidenhead and maybe not run to Heathrow, which seemed nonsense but got the project authorised. Of course by the time it was complete it could run to Reading. The flipside was the Kings Cross-Cambridge electrification in 1978 which stopped at Royston for fiscal reasons, it being "only a formality" to add on the extra few miles to Cambridge. It got turned down and took several more years, during which time there was a 2 coach dmu shuttle.
The Royston situation is similar to what currently happens with GWR at Didcot Parkway, there still being a 2 car DMU shuttle in place of the London - Oxford stopper that used to run with the same DMUs. So I’m expecting that service to return with the “new” EMUs and longer carriages once the Oxford station rebuild is eventually done and wires go up in the year 3871
I was staying in the Tower Hill area for a few days, visiting different parts of the city. One day I decided to go to Canary Wharf for a look round, as I'd never been. I knew I'd have to get the DLR but couldn't figure where the nearest DLR station to Tower Hill would be. After looking into it, I realised that the unwashed, slightly dystopian looking covered steps I'd walked past every day was it. Called Tower Gateway it hadn't occurred to me it might be a railway station, and instead had thought it was some kind of development proposal exhibition on the area or business enterprise centre. Once inside it was very desolate, and it did seem an oddly understated access to the quite wonderful DLR.
I've always had a soft spot for Tower Gateway. The funny thing is until about 2010 I thought the DLR was some sort of special service that wasn't open to everyone, so I didn't use it until then. (For instance, I sometimes thought it was maybe just for people working in the Canary Wharf area). I felt really stupid when I realised it had always been open to the public from the start.
@@ugiswrong who said free? You have to tap in and out or else one of these days, that guy with a fare validator will come on the train and you'll be in big trouble, buddy!
One of the best remaining examples of the original DLR postmodernist-ish architecture. If it does get demolished, I hope they manage to preserve or relocate some of it
Interesting, I didn't realise it had such history. when I last did a London bash in 2019 I stayed in the docklands Travelodge, and due to works on the line on the weekend they were terminating at Tower Gateway, thought it was a decent enough wee station...even if the escalators were broke on both days!
Excellent report! Since Fenchurch Street is the only London terminus without a tube station, a new underground station on the DLR Bank line with that same name having passages to Tower Hill station might be a good way to eliminate the existing Tower Gateway station.
Hmm I thought City Thameslink counted as a terminus, it is certainly listed as such on the London and South East rail map... Although I think it has an interchange with St Paul's UG... A mystery of its time
@@thatcommentaccount69 for Thameslink's ticketing purposes yes, they count it (makes it a lot simpler for buyers and staff) but trains terminating at City is rare - i think just 2 trains terminate there every night to run into the snow hill carriage sidings and likewise those same 2 start from city every morning
Hi Jago from Spain. Because of the intensity of the Fenchurch St to Barking and beyond sevices, four tracks are needed in the approach to Fenchurch St. to provide holding space for when a platform was occupied. The handing over of two tracks west from the then Stepney East to the DLR created the need for a new junction at Christian St. and thus four tracks were restored outside Fenchurch St. Initially this caused a number of problems with regard to train describers at Barking. I had to stand at the signal at the London end of East Ham, identify each train as it approached, and tell Barking box whether it was for East Ham depot, Tilbury or Upminster. Fortunately the weather was kind.
ive heard that a station anywhere along that entire route was both unfeasible due to cost and disruption and impossible due to the steep grade of the track as it descends - afaik its a constant climb from bank up to the surface
@@whyamiwhat I wonder if a couple of loop lines could be installed, one either side of the existing tunnels, made level, where the current tunnels run under Tower Bridge Piazza. Some trains could pull into the loop platforms to serve the area currently served by the existing Tower Gateway station whilst the rest of the trains could take the existing tunnel, bypassing Tower Gateway station.
Amazing! I always enjoy your history lessons of appearing and disappearing train/tube stations and now I am a little bit part of such kind of history: remember my school trip from Hamburg in 1987, where we were very first users of the DLR, ridding through the to be developed docklands towards Island Gardens, to proceed on by foot through the tunnel to Greenwich. 30 years later travelling with my father to London, having our base in a no-thrills hotel around Tower Hill, we often used the station in question a lot, to go to Greenwich on Sunday mornings. Proud to be one of the 10%...😁
I hate the way that the 1987 pic was in black and white - we had colour in the 1980s! I remember vividly travelling on the DLR in the early days and there was definitely colour!
If the train operators have any sense at all, Tower Gateway will remain open. If there is an incident of some kind at Bank, or if the Bank Station is closed, or Strike and so on - TG is ideal as a diversion. It also allows DLR to keep running if the Tube is inaccessible. The turnarounds on automatic computer trains are practically instant so that is no problem.
77 million quid...there are Premiership footballers who cost more than that! I never really realised just how much of a shoestring budget that the DLR was built on! I am visiting London in September, and I will see if T.Gateway underwhelms me or not! Nice video, Jago, keep em coming!
According to the Bank of England's inflation calculator, it equates to ~£208,000,000 in modern money. So only £20mil more than what PSG paid for Neymar. Or about 5x as much as Star Wars: A New Hope's tiny budget ($11m), or about £100m less than Star Wars: The Force Awakens' budget. Also, it cost less to build the DLR than it does to buy even the cheapest MLS club, which is CF Montréal, valued at $390,000,000...
I guess it says a lot that I've lived in London my entire life (33 years) and i used TG for the first time ever two weeks ago to get to Custom House and that was only due to the Elizabeth Line having severe delays due to a signal failure at Liverpool Street.
Bank is an obvious terminus for DLR but the interchange to the tube lines is a real pain. I wouldn't have thought it rocket science to build a more pedestrian friendly interchange at tower gateway to tower hill.
Has that changed since the modifications at Bank? Agree that it was a right royal pain in the backside to get to the DLR from the entrance at Bank previously - hopefully the refurb has made it easier.
@QuincyMD the central/northern interchange is much better, but it still seems a bit of a trek to the dlr. I think the basic problem is that they've to push the dlr deep to avoid everything else.
As someone who hasn't used my local railway station here in the Midlands since 1980, I always enjoy the alternative universe on a mode of transport called 'the train' provided by Jago's brilliant, informative and tongue-in-cheek videos. On one of my rare visits to the Big Smoke in about 2017, I set myself the task of ticking off all the places on the London version of the Monopoly board and was amazed how small Fenchurch Street station was inside (but it has a great frontage), even though it doesn't connect to any major cities. Having tramped around the area - admittedly at the weekend - I couldn't believe how many stations there were in that area within a short walk of each other. Therefore, as a precaution against technical failures, would it not be a good idea to keep all the current stations open? P.S. Re the Monopoly trail, when I got home, I realised I had gone to the wrong Vine Street!
An excellent video as always Jago. Brought back memories of travelling from Waterloo to Poplar in the early 90s to work on the DLR expansion project and having to trudge daily from Tower Hill to Tower Gateway before the Bank tunnel opened
I clicked on the like button at the "It was to cost no more than £77m or about the price of a round of drinks in the West End" line. While that alone earned the like, thanks for putting this togther. There was a period of a few months in 2000 when I used Tower Gateway daily and, although it is some time since I last used it, I will be sorry to see it go. Incidentally, I'm baffled that Tower Gateway doesn't count as an official interchange with Fenchurch Street and Tower Gateway when it is nearer to both than, for instance, the distance between Euston Station and Euston Square.
I remember first going to Tower Gateway in 1988 to check out the new DLR as a 6 year old kid. It seemed like some space age thing out of the future. I recently went there and found it frustrating how you could literally see the end of the Fenchurch Street platforms, but had to take a very circuitous route to actually get to the station. Something definitely needs to change to make it a useful station in 2023.
Dear Mr Duke, there was a great story many years ago concerning the DLR and Chase Manhattan bank. Top executives had flown in from the US and were looking for new premises and Canary Wharf was just getting going. An appointment was made and the executives asked the best way to get there. The DLR was the best and quickest solution. So they went and bought tickets from Gateway. On the journey to the Wharf, the train captain asked to see their tickets. They had in error all bought child tickets and despite protests, were all fined. Fuming, they got off at the Wharf, said the deals off and promptly went back to the City again!
I don't think i've ever seen it mentioned anywhere including any well known London blogs or specific Tower Gateway videos/posts like this but Tower Gateway is supposedly getting a new entrance soon actually so it has some positive outlook ahead, a big but understandable ommision. I only know this stuff because I go through planning application submitions for certain areas so i saw the plans for the new entrance. It's going to be next to the currecnt secondary entrance on the Royal Mind St devellopment. Basically look at 3:27 on the video and the construction site opposite, there. Not sure why but I guess its quite a simple thing to do if a building is being built there anyway. I suppose it allows them to add a gateline there so they can close off the current secondary entrance. It'll also have a lift. It's been a year since i've seen the plans but i assume they've been approved by now. I can give you where to find out but you probably know where and how to find out already, it'll be on the Tower Hamlets planning site, not CoL. Also if it gets 10% of passengers but 25% of trains then I suppose adding a few more trains to the Bank branch will level it off a bit without touching Tower Gateway. Either way it's not proposed to close until 2050 or so and by then i'm sure the frequency to Bank will be improved anyway and the population will increase enough that the current few trains an hour to Tower Gateway will be justified. Imo it won't get closed unless Fenchurch Street station wants to expand into the space.
"...tiiiiiiime, is on my side." . Sometimes I think its the ideas that are wrong, or the implementations, and then its the economic situations. Its still fascinating to see how the ideas change for good or bad as time goes on. Nothing ever seems to end up how it started or quite what people had in mind. "Change is inevitable - except from vending machines"
Marvellous, thank you. I love that whole area, but, again, never bothered to find out its history, reasons for changes, or its rolling stones - sorry, stock. Thank you. As always, a great treat to watch 🎉
1:23 Sailing barge Xylonite. I think we might have seen her before so if so, thanks again. We go back 40-odd years sailing out of Maldon up to Harwich.
Always pleased to hear more about the Minories. Maybe if 'they' [insert relevant transport authority/group/cartel here] develop a proper connecting station, the base of the of 13th century abbey will be dug up, thus stopping construction for the foreseeable future
At your most excellent advice Jago, I got on the DLR the morning of Oct 14th at Tower Gateway (after arriving at Heathrow and taking the tube to Tower Hill) A great ride through familiar areas of London I no longer recognize on a fantastic railway. One change and I was at Stratford. Tower Gateway was a joy, I must had taken 20 photos. The DLR I go on and on about to this day. Great railway, it is how it should be done.
Thanks Jago The Docklands Light Rail is a textbook example of Treasury penny pinching that ended up costing the taxpayers huge amounts later on in upgrading the infrastructure to meet demand later on. Likewise was the decision not to fully rebuild Victoria Underground Station when the Victoria Line was constructed in the 1960s.
I just came back a few weeks ago from London for a week vacation, such a cool city. I recognize that area at 1:24, it's Limehouse. I walked around that very area from where this was filmed. I was there to visit a friend who was in the 4 tall buildings to the right (not seen) I walked over that metal bridge to get to the home she lived in. I used Tower Gateway to get back and forth from Tower Hill (where i stayed at Citizen M) to Limehouse and used Fenchurch St. once, I love this channel and London (from USA)
what a wonderful video, insightful both statistically and realistically great look into te current sysem and what could be, i really enjoyed this and think i will spend my sunday binging on the rest of your videos
I remember when the DLR first opened. I lived on the Isle of Dogs and it was absolutely brilliant to have a train. Before then you had to either walk under the river through the Greenwich foot tunnel to get a mainline train, or get a bus up to Mile End tube station and get on the central line. Although it was always breaking down for the first year, the train captain had to take over and drive it to the next station and then reset it.
My most vivid memory of Tower Gateway is when I had to use it during the summer of rail strikes in 1989. SO busy then, there were queues down the staircase-escalator, and you'd miss 4 or 5 trains before you could cram on one. I now use Fenchurch Street regularly and just assumed Tower Gateway was still a pretty useful station, though now I think about it, Limehouse seems the logical place for people to swap over to the DLR.
Hi there great video's thank you,now i am not Religious but when you go and see these places it blows your mind like it has clearly blown yours ! Another great city to visit when you are here is York which has Roman,Viking and Saxon remains and a great Cathedral known as York Minister and also a medieval wall to walk around. Cheers
Sorry to confuse you Jago I love your videos and am a great fan that reply I sent you should have gone to a chap in the US who was doing a vid on Canterbury Cathedral, sorry about how that happened I do not know,Cheers
I do have to wonder if TfL had the money whether we would actually see the total reorganisation of the three stations at Fenchurch Street, Tower Hill and Gateway into one more centrally (for the 3) located place. In my mind the underground platforms for the District and Circle lines can stay where they are, but the block bounded by Crosswall to the North and Coopers Row to the Wesr, that seem to be occupied by America Square and the various hotels would retain much of the rail approaches and would give relatively easy access to both the Underground and DLR could be expanded too. It would allow for the current station to be redeveloped and newer hotel/buildings to be built. One does have to wonder how much more Bank/Monument can actually take before the whole thing collapses, then they will need somewhere like a renovated and expanded DLR base, especially if the proposed westward extension plans ever happen
The black New World phone box outside was once two blue greenhouse Mercury phone kiosks. I thought they looked well with the design of the DLR stations
Tower Gateway originally had two tracks and a platform serving each. It was a lot busier at first than it is now, as the Bank line didn't exist for the first 3 years. It was originally the only DLR station with escalators. All trains used to run to Island Gardens, then reverse and go up to Stratford, things were a lot simpler then, but full credit to them for building all the extensions. Croydon Tramlink (or whatever they like to call it now) by contrast, has only the lines opened at the outset.
So i first got the DLR from here to Island gardens on a school trip in the early 90's. Two strange things, sitting at the front, i'm sure there was a national rail platform/NSE trains and a sign for Liverpool St which with what i know now couldn't have been. However catching the DLR years later, i expected to see the Fenchurch Street platform/trains alongside the DLR station. Perhaps it changed when they made modifications but seems unlikely, however i vividly remember seeing the station like that 😮
Having used the DLR extensively in the early to mid 2000’s I was quite familiar with the old style Tower Gateway station. However, it was the image of the carriage at the station @ 4:47 that triggered a memory, having first used the DLR from the original Island Gardens in 1989 I had the recollection of the doors opening inwards. A quick search confirmed this. Knowing how busy transport in London can get; how did they think that this would be a good idea and when was it changed?
I think those original trains with the inwards folding doors were found to be unsuitable for the underground extension at Bank. They were not fire-safety compliant for underground journeys, so were flogged in the early 90s to one of the German transportation authorities, if i am not mistaken.
@@cjayos7654 I believe the P86 stock (Poplar depot) went off to the Stadtbahn in Essen for use on it's new U18 line. But some have undergone a retrofitting programme to run on the systems other lines
Originally the plans for the Docklands was light industry and residential at a relatively low density. Little of this remains. Then another plan came along for a medium density development around the original canary wharf estate.....buildings like 112-114 Marsh Wall. Then we got to the point of what there is now high rises springing up everywhere outside the original cluster of supertalls of Canary Wharf. The DLR first gen trains the P86s were built and ordered with the first plan in mind. The extension to bank didnt work with that model so we got new trains, and more.of them....and the jubilee line to go with the fancy new developments...
Before DLR opened at Bank, I had to follow directions at street level to Tower Hill Gateway. They could at least have built an underground walkway from (say) Tower Hill so that it was weather proof.
The problem with that would be having somewhere to put it as the pedestrian route between the two crosses over the District Line tunnel, and being a cut and cover line that doesn't leave a lot of space between the tops of the trains and the road.
Did the £77m include the tip? And did they say “What can I get for you guys?” in the initial process? 🤔 Seems insane to still-in-age-denial me that the picture of the ‘new’ station was taken thirty six years ago. Even more astonishing is the change in that view which is considerable. I drive out of Fen St daily and so much has changed even since the mid 80s. Much of the old infrastructure that had clung on for decades suddenly stared disappearing like the Royal Mint buildings, the old signal box and the long-disused approach tacks to the goods yards. I can even remember when ‘Stepney East’/Limehouse was physically a junction. But hey, progress 🤷🏻♂️ Shame that ‘T-Gates’ (did make me chuckle) seemed set to close but in truth it did seem to be in a hiding to nothing even when I used it in the mid 90s. I lived by the old Island Gardens station (on the viaduct…really miss that) and this was a great way for me and my then girlfriend to go straight into town for a walk along the river and a bevvy or two. But we were never pushed for getting a seat on the way back and the train was almost empty by the time we left Shadwell 💁♂️ I did think the upgrade to ‘TG2’ made sense along with the emergency siding for stock movements, but I fear you may be right. As the Beatles once sang, “When I was young and so much younger than today, I never need anybody’s help in any way, but now those days are gone I’m not so self assured, now I find, they change their mind, alight at Shadwell and take the more direct route to Bank for its far more convenient interchange possibilities.” 🤔 The 60s eh? Crazy times, crazy lyrics…I mean what were they smoking? 👍🍀🫖☕️
When I started work in Canary Wharf I had to use Tower Gateway. Once the Bank platforms opened, a short walk from Cannon Street was a lot easier. Not been back to TG since!
It's a real shame the pedways scheme never really happened. It would be great to be able to connect on and walk above-ground from Tower Gateway to Fechurch St or directly to workplaces
Brings back many memories. I was living on the Isle of Dogs when the DLR was in its infancy. I remember the first big malfunction when 2 trains collided at West India Quay. In those early days not a day went by without at least 1 breakdown, meaning that the trains had to be driven manually. Also I remember they didn’t run late at night or at weekends so if you lived there it was back on the bus. Seems like a lifetime ago, One Canada Sq tower was newly built and bankrupt, then the time the trains didn’t stop at South Quay due to the IRA bombing. How times have changed
That brought back painful memories of daily commutes from Kent into Victoria, down the District Line and round the corner to the DLR station (if my memory seves there was no cover over the staris back then) to go a few stops to Limehouse when the whole of that area down to Canary Wharf was no more than one huge building site. The early mornings on the station were awful, the service was awful and the trains were overcrowded and spent more time stopped than going. I, for one, would not be sad to see the DLR being scrapped and a decent transport system put in place.
On of the interesting aspects of the DLR is the integration with the buildings….going through them or under the eaves. ‘Quite fascinating from a modeler’s perspective!
I used to get a train from Shadwell to Tower Gateway as my office was on Bevis Marks. I loved the station and would be sad to see it close. Let's hope not 🙂
Lovely writing as always Jago. Had I got my Time Machine working I’d have an alternate history with rail tracks running across tower bridge. Maybe the district/ circle line could have branched and sneaked through the bridge deck and swapped the bascules to a vertical lift, or link into bricklayers arms or cut and cover toward elephant and beyond. Also those ambitious 1946 plans to build tower bridge station would have an interchange. Or even now now curve the dlr to squeeze through those huge arches and cross the lud to interchange with what maybe the bakerloo extension. Maybe a lot to get through running but I’d love to get railed across tower bridge.
“…77 million pounds or a round of drinks on the West End.”
Hahaha I love this 😂
@The Bad Lieutenant 😆 classy
That was 1987 prices 😳
Accounting for inflation.....
I think that it's the "Jago-Gems" why I actually tune in. The railway stuff I can take or leave.
@The Bad Lieutenant yes even I forgot that
@The Bad Lieutenant I've never tipped in a pub. Is that a thing?
Tower Gateway serves an extremely important function for those of us who despise Bank station.
Bank station is a nightmare. Sadly, there is a growing tribe of underground dwelling people stuck in Bank station, for they can never figure out how to exit that labryinth of a station.
To be fair it's much improved since the new Northern Line platform and connections to the Central Line were opened.
Great for PSAs. I can usually get 4 mins dwell at TOG to sit and relax before another rounder! Bank? Not a hope in hell.
I love Tower Gateway
@@litetakeri remember once when I loved to London and was meeting a friend near bank coming from Canary Wharf, the way in was so packed they had closed the entrance gates and people where literally suck standing still unable to move forward.
I like the way that London's transport system is a messy memorial to past enthusiasms, like an archetypal teenager's bedroom - a distressing muddle that somehow kind of works, most of the time.
*some of the time lmao
@@Justanotherperson_01 some of the time allll the time 😎
Architecturally, Lemon squeezer combined with Crystal Palace revival style.
time to rename the station Perspex Palace
Think of it as The Tower of London's tomato house.
Lemonsqueezer...part of NZ Army dress uniform.
As a member of the original team that built the DLR, one of the benefits of Tower Gateway (TOG ) was to provide tourists with an easy way to get between The Tower of London / Tower Bridge and Greenwich, two historically important areas for tourism. Originally, TOG trains went to Island Gardens, at which a person would walk through the Thames Tunnel to Greenwich. Back in the late 1980s, I and many others did just that ... as tourists. To do that today, a person would need to change trains (since TOG trains only go to Beckton), and exit the DLR on the south side of the river at Greenwich.
Your Rolling Stones reference reminded me of a Limerick that goes thus:
There was a young man from Japan
Whose verses would never quite scan.
When asked why this was,
He said it's because
I always like to try and get as many words into the last line as I possibly can.
The version I learnt at school has 19 words in the last line to your 18:
There was a young man from Japan
Whose limericks never would scan
When told this was so
He replied yes I know
But I always try to get as many worlds into to the last line as I ever possibly can.
Towie G & T Gates are little flashes of the brilliance of J Hazz. Chapeau sir! 👏
2:14I love those 'next train' indicators that say 'Check front of train'. "We've no idea how far it may be going, it's entirely up to the driver" 🤷♂️, it seems to be saying
Love the Towie G casually slipped in at 6:57. Made a special trip last year to finally travel from the station. If they had enough capacity at Bank it would probably have gone by now. Also lucky there was space fory the viaduct. But it's a classic example of half a loaf is better than none; Towie G got the DLR started, it built up success, demand rose and it could then be expanded. Like Crossrail was originally projected to stop at Maidenhead and maybe not run to Heathrow, which seemed nonsense but got the project authorised. Of course by the time it was complete it could run to Reading. The flipside was the Kings Cross-Cambridge electrification in 1978 which stopped at Royston for fiscal reasons, it being "only a formality" to add on the extra few miles to Cambridge. It got turned down and took several more years, during which time there was a 2 coach dmu shuttle.
T Gates is nice too
The Royston situation is similar to what currently happens with GWR at Didcot Parkway, there still being a 2 car DMU shuttle in place of the London - Oxford stopper that used to run with the same DMUs. So I’m expecting that service to return with the “new” EMUs and longer carriages once the Oxford station rebuild is eventually done and wires go up in the year 3871
Checked the album sleeve notes - yes that's the original lyrics. Was cut down for the single release of course - a bit like the DLR plans.
The fact that Mick was able to sing all that in one breathe is something very few talk about but it was certainly an achievement.
Well Mick Jagger did attend the LSE, so it is understandable that he would write lyrics like that.
I was staying in the Tower Hill area for a few days, visiting different parts of the city. One day I decided to go to Canary Wharf for a look round, as I'd never been. I knew I'd have to get the DLR but couldn't figure where the nearest DLR station to Tower Hill would be. After looking into it, I realised that the unwashed, slightly dystopian looking covered steps I'd walked past every day was it. Called Tower Gateway it hadn't occurred to me it might be a railway station, and instead had thought it was some kind of development proposal exhibition on the area or business enterprise centre. Once inside it was very desolate, and it did seem an oddly understated access to the quite wonderful DLR.
I've always had a soft spot for Tower Gateway. The funny thing is until about 2010 I thought the DLR was some sort of special service that wasn't open to everyone, so I didn't use it until then. (For instance, I sometimes thought it was maybe just for people working in the Canary Wharf area). I felt really stupid when I realised it had always been open to the public from the start.
What? The DLR is free for all the public??! No way!
@@ugiswrong who said free? You have to tap in and out or else one of these days, that guy with a fare validator will come on the train and you'll be in big trouble, buddy!
@@litetaker tell him you're the driver
0_o
One of the best remaining examples of the original DLR postmodernist-ish architecture. If it does get demolished, I hope they manage to preserve or relocate some of it
Interesting, I didn't realise it had such history. when I last did a London bash in 2019 I stayed in the docklands Travelodge, and due to works on the line on the weekend they were terminating at Tower Gateway, thought it was a decent enough wee station...even if the escalators were broke on both days!
Excellent report! Since Fenchurch Street is the only London terminus without a tube station, a new underground station on the DLR Bank line with that same name having passages to Tower Hill station might be a good way to eliminate the existing Tower Gateway station.
the line is too steep for a platform sadly
Hmm I thought City Thameslink counted as a terminus, it is certainly listed as such on the London and South East rail map... Although I think it has an interchange with St Paul's UG... A mystery of its time
@@thatcommentaccount69 for Thameslink's ticketing purposes yes, they count it (makes it a lot simpler for buyers and staff) but trains terminating at City is rare - i think just 2 trains terminate there every night to run into the snow hill carriage sidings and likewise those same 2 start from city every morning
I've always had a soft spot for Tower Gateway and I forever wish they'd clean the roof of the entrance.
I always thought that Tower Gateway was a important station now I have found out it wasn't
Hi Jago from Spain. Because of the intensity of the Fenchurch St to Barking and beyond sevices, four tracks are needed in the approach to Fenchurch St. to provide holding space for when a platform was occupied. The handing over of two tracks west from the then Stepney East to the DLR created the need for a new junction at Christian St. and thus four tracks were restored outside Fenchurch St. Initially this caused a number of problems with regard to train describers at Barking. I had to stand at the signal at the London end of East Ham, identify each train as it approached, and tell Barking box whether it was for East Ham depot, Tilbury or Upminster. Fortunately the weather was kind.
So glad I had those Fenchurch street bridges painted RAL 5003 Blue and white lined, they look great.
I’ve heard there is actually a bit of straight and level DLR tunnel near Tower Hill as passive provision for an interchange station
Where ya hear that?
ive heard that a station anywhere along that entire route was both unfeasible due to cost and disruption and impossible due to the steep grade of the track as it descends - afaik its a constant climb from bank up to the surface
@@whyamiwhat I wonder if a couple of loop lines could be installed, one either side of the existing tunnels, made level, where the current tunnels run under Tower Bridge Piazza. Some trains could pull into the loop platforms to serve the area currently served by the existing Tower Gateway station whilst the rest of the trains could take the existing tunnel, bypassing Tower Gateway station.
Tower gateway provides a step free interchange with the district line where bank does not!
“By closing Towie G…” and “T-Gates.”
Jago bringing the cool lingo that’s on fleek, fellow YOUTHZ.
Jago definitely brings the rizz
Towie G? T-Gates?
Love it!
Amazing! I always enjoy your history lessons of appearing and disappearing train/tube stations and now I am a little bit part of such kind of history: remember my school trip from Hamburg in 1987, where we were very first users of the DLR, ridding through the to be developed docklands towards Island Gardens, to proceed on by foot through the tunnel to Greenwich.
30 years later travelling with my father to London, having our base in a no-thrills hotel around Tower Hill, we often used the station in question a lot, to go to Greenwich on Sunday mornings.
Proud to be one of the 10%...😁
Only in London would 'across the road from the most important historic building in the city' equate to 'in the back streets'.
Great video. I was an early user of the DLR and remembered the old station format well.
I hate the way that the 1987 pic was in black and white - we had colour in the 1980s! I remember vividly travelling on the DLR in the early days and there was definitely colour!
No-one expected the Spanish Solution.
If the train operators have any sense at all, Tower Gateway will remain open. If there is an incident of some kind at Bank, or if the Bank Station is closed, or Strike and so on - TG is ideal as a diversion. It also allows DLR to keep running if the Tube is inaccessible. The turnarounds on automatic computer trains are practically instant so that is no problem.
77 million quid...there are Premiership footballers who cost more than that! I never really realised just how much of a shoestring budget that the DLR was built on! I am visiting London in September, and I will see if T.Gateway underwhelms me or not! Nice video, Jago, keep em coming!
To be fair, that was 80s money. Even so, I think it comes out today at less than the cost of, say, a Star Wars film.
According to the Bank of England's inflation calculator, it equates to ~£208,000,000 in modern money. So only £20mil more than what PSG paid for Neymar. Or about 5x as much as Star Wars: A New Hope's tiny budget ($11m), or about £100m less than Star Wars: The Force Awakens' budget.
Also, it cost less to build the DLR than it does to buy even the cheapest MLS club, which is CF Montréal, valued at $390,000,000...
Ahhh, the front seat on a DLR train. The joy I got from doing that! Takes me back, almost as much as Jago's dulcet tones.
I guess it says a lot that I've lived in London my entire life (33 years) and i used TG for the first time ever two weeks ago to get to Custom House and that was only due to the Elizabeth Line having severe delays due to a signal failure at Liverpool Street.
You always scare a laugh or two out of me! 😂
Haha. Those Stones' lyrics proper made us chuckle Jago!!
Bank is an obvious terminus for DLR but the interchange to the tube lines is a real pain. I wouldn't have thought it rocket science to build a more pedestrian friendly interchange at tower gateway to tower hill.
Has that changed since the modifications at Bank? Agree that it was a right royal pain in the backside to get to the DLR from the entrance at Bank previously - hopefully the refurb has made it easier.
@QuincyMD the central/northern interchange is much better, but it still seems a bit of a trek to the dlr. I think the basic problem is that they've to push the dlr deep to avoid everything else.
As someone who hasn't used my local railway station here in the Midlands since 1980, I always enjoy the alternative universe on a mode of transport called 'the train' provided by Jago's brilliant, informative and tongue-in-cheek videos. On one of my rare visits to the Big Smoke in about 2017, I set myself the task of ticking off all the places on the London version of the Monopoly board and was amazed how small Fenchurch Street station was inside (but it has a great frontage), even though it doesn't connect to any major cities. Having tramped around the area - admittedly at the weekend - I couldn't believe how many stations there were in that area within a short walk of each other. Therefore, as a precaution against technical failures, would it not be a good idea to keep all the current stations open? P.S. Re the Monopoly trail, when I got home, I realised I had gone to the wrong Vine Street!
An excellent video as always Jago. Brought back memories of travelling from Waterloo to Poplar in the early 90s to work on the DLR expansion project and having to trudge daily from Tower Hill to Tower Gateway before the Bank tunnel opened
I clicked on the like button at the "It was to cost no more than £77m or about the price of a round of drinks in the West End" line. While that alone earned the like, thanks for putting this togther. There was a period of a few months in 2000 when I used Tower Gateway daily and, although it is some time since I last used it, I will be sorry to see it go. Incidentally, I'm baffled that Tower Gateway doesn't count as an official interchange with Fenchurch Street and Tower Gateway when it is nearer to both than, for instance, the distance between Euston Station and Euston Square.
I remember first going to Tower Gateway in 1988 to check out the new DLR as a 6 year old kid. It seemed like some space age thing out of the future. I recently went there and found it frustrating how you could literally see the end of the Fenchurch Street platforms, but had to take a very circuitous route to actually get to the station. Something definitely needs to change to make it a useful station in 2023.
80s/90s Docklands were so cool and slick.
If you’re interested in that era you might like 1987 film Empire State. Shows SQP and Skylines Village etc being built in 86.
Dear Mr Duke, there was a great story many years ago concerning the DLR and Chase Manhattan bank.
Top executives had flown in from the US and were looking for new premises and Canary Wharf was just getting going.
An appointment was made and the executives asked the best way to get there. The DLR was the best and quickest solution.
So they went and bought tickets from Gateway.
On the journey to the Wharf, the train captain asked to see their tickets.
They had in error all bought child tickets and despite protests, were all fined.
Fuming, they got off at the Wharf, said the deals off and promptly went back to the City again!
Tower Gateway was where I first experienced the DLR back in 1989 or so. Thanks to you, now I shall ever think of it as Towie G or T-Gatez.
I don't think i've ever seen it mentioned anywhere including any well known London blogs or specific Tower Gateway videos/posts like this but Tower Gateway is supposedly getting a new entrance soon actually so it has some positive outlook ahead, a big but understandable ommision. I only know this stuff because I go through planning application submitions for certain areas so i saw the plans for the new entrance. It's going to be next to the currecnt secondary entrance on the Royal Mind St devellopment. Basically look at 3:27 on the video and the construction site opposite, there. Not sure why but I guess its quite a simple thing to do if a building is being built there anyway. I suppose it allows them to add a gateline there so they can close off the current secondary entrance. It'll also have a lift. It's been a year since i've seen the plans but i assume they've been approved by now. I can give you where to find out but you probably know where and how to find out already, it'll be on the Tower Hamlets planning site, not CoL.
Also if it gets 10% of passengers but 25% of trains then I suppose adding a few more trains to the Bank branch will level it off a bit without touching Tower Gateway. Either way it's not proposed to close until 2050 or so and by then i'm sure the frequency to Bank will be improved anyway and the population will increase enough that the current few trains an hour to Tower Gateway will be justified. Imo it won't get closed unless Fenchurch Street station wants to expand into the space.
Another absolutely top-notch presentation from you Jago. Thanks.
"...tiiiiiiime, is on my side." .
Sometimes I think its the ideas that are wrong, or the implementations, and then its the economic situations. Its still fascinating to see how the ideas change for good or bad as time goes on. Nothing ever seems to end up how it started or quite what people had in mind.
"Change is inevitable - except from vending machines"
"Unless it's a circa 1981 Nestle railway station chocolate vending machine. Then you get more change than you bargained for."
Marvellous, thank you. I love that whole area, but, again, never bothered to find out its history, reasons for changes, or its rolling stones - sorry, stock. Thank you. As always, a great treat to watch 🎉
1:46
Haha, I've just remembered the Spitting Image puppet of Norman Fowler.
1:23 Sailing barge Xylonite. I think we might have seen her before so if so, thanks again. We go back 40-odd years sailing out of Maldon up to Harwich.
Always pleased to hear more about the Minories. Maybe if 'they' [insert relevant transport authority/group/cartel here] develop a proper connecting station, the base of the of 13th century abbey will be dug up, thus stopping construction for the foreseeable future
You killed me with the comment "77 million pounds, or around the cost of a round of drinks in the West End." 🤣🤣🤣
At your most excellent advice Jago, I got on the DLR the morning of Oct 14th at Tower Gateway (after arriving at Heathrow and taking the tube to Tower Hill) A great ride through familiar areas of London I no longer recognize on a fantastic railway. One change and I was at Stratford.
Tower Gateway was a joy, I must had taken 20 photos. The DLR I go on and on about to this day.
Great railway, it is how it should be done.
Thanks Jago The Docklands Light Rail is a textbook example of Treasury penny pinching that ended up costing the taxpayers huge amounts later on in upgrading the infrastructure to meet demand later on. Likewise was the decision not to fully rebuild Victoria Underground Station when the Victoria Line was constructed in the 1960s.
I just came back a few weeks ago from London for a week vacation, such a cool city. I recognize that area at 1:24, it's Limehouse. I walked around that very area from where this was filmed. I was there to visit a friend who was in the 4 tall buildings to the right (not seen) I walked over that metal bridge to get to the home she lived in. I used Tower Gateway to get back and forth from Tower Hill (where i stayed at Citizen M) to Limehouse and used Fenchurch St. once, I love this channel and London (from USA)
what a wonderful video, insightful both statistically and realistically great look into te current sysem and what could be, i really enjoyed this and think i will spend my sunday binging on the rest of your videos
I enjoy your clever humour. Just a compliment. Not trying to “1 up” you as usual
I remember when the DLR first opened. I lived on the Isle of Dogs and it was absolutely brilliant to have a train. Before then you had to either walk under the river through the Greenwich foot tunnel to get a mainline train, or get a bus up to Mile End tube station and get on the central line. Although it was always breaking down for the first year, the train captain had to take over and drive it to the next station and then reset it.
Minories. The most famous model railway plan for restricted space. Cheers Cyril.
My most vivid memory of Tower Gateway is when I had to use it during the summer of rail strikes in 1989. SO busy then, there were queues down the staircase-escalator, and you'd miss 4 or 5 trains before you could cram on one. I now use Fenchurch Street regularly and just assumed Tower Gateway was still a pretty useful station, though now I think about it, Limehouse seems the logical place for people to swap over to the DLR.
Excellently researched as always Jago - and I say that as someone who worked for the LDDC at the time.
T-Gates and Towie G oh my
Hi there great video's thank you,now i am not Religious but when you go and see these places it blows your mind like it has clearly blown yours ! Another great city to visit when you are here is York which has Roman,Viking and Saxon remains and a great Cathedral known as York Minister and also a medieval wall to walk around.
Cheers
Sorry to confuse you Jago I love your videos and am a great fan that reply I sent you should have gone to a chap in the US who was doing a vid on Canterbury Cathedral, sorry about how that happened I do not know,Cheers
Jago keep up the great work, love your videos
I do have to wonder if TfL had the money whether we would actually see the total reorganisation of the three stations at Fenchurch Street, Tower Hill and Gateway into one more centrally (for the 3) located place.
In my mind the underground platforms for the District and Circle lines can stay where they are, but the block bounded by Crosswall to the North and Coopers Row to the Wesr, that seem to be occupied by America Square and the various hotels would retain much of the rail approaches and would give relatively easy access to both the Underground and DLR could be expanded too. It would allow for the current station to be redeveloped and newer hotel/buildings to be built.
One does have to wonder how much more Bank/Monument can actually take before the whole thing collapses, then they will need somewhere like a renovated and expanded DLR base, especially if the proposed westward extension plans ever happen
Algorithm Ultras unite!
How many of us have ultra clearance at this point?
You should definitely be engaged as a lyric writer for antique rock bands!
Nice video. At this point Tower Gateway migth aswell close bc Bank really needs the trains.
stones have no appreciation for pure genius.
Tower gateway is always my go to for anything at the excel, with good access to nearby hotels
The black New World phone box outside was once two blue greenhouse Mercury phone kiosks. I thought they looked well with the design of the DLR stations
Never disappointing! I ❤ London one of the greatest cities in the world, what a place!
It sure was amazing how Jagger made it rhyme so well back when they recorded it.
Lovely
Tower Gateway originally had two tracks and a platform serving each. It was a lot busier at first than it is now, as the Bank line didn't exist for the first 3 years. It was originally the only DLR station with escalators. All trains used to run to Island Gardens, then reverse and go up to Stratford, things were a lot simpler then, but full credit to them for building all the extensions. Croydon Tramlink (or whatever they like to call it now) by contrast, has only the lines opened at the outset.
So i first got the DLR from here to Island gardens on a school trip in the early 90's. Two strange things, sitting at the front, i'm sure there was a national rail platform/NSE trains and a sign for Liverpool St which with what i know now couldn't have been. However catching the DLR years later, i expected to see the Fenchurch Street platform/trains alongside the DLR station. Perhaps it changed when they made modifications but seems unlikely, however i vividly remember seeing the station like that 😮
Having used the DLR extensively in the early to mid 2000’s I was quite familiar with the old style Tower Gateway station. However, it was the image of the carriage at the station @ 4:47 that triggered a memory, having first used the DLR from the original Island Gardens in 1989 I had the recollection of the doors opening inwards. A quick search confirmed this. Knowing how busy transport in London can get; how did they think that this would be a good idea and when was it changed?
I think those original trains with the inwards folding doors were found to be unsuitable for the underground extension at Bank. They were not fire-safety compliant for underground journeys, so were flogged in the early 90s to one of the German transportation authorities, if i am not mistaken.
@@cjayos7654 I believe the P86 stock (Poplar depot) went off to the Stadtbahn in Essen for use on it's new U18 line. But some have undergone a retrofitting programme to run on the systems other lines
Originally the plans for the Docklands was light industry and residential at a relatively low density. Little of this remains.
Then another plan came along for a medium density development around the original canary wharf estate.....buildings like 112-114 Marsh Wall.
Then we got to the point of what there is now high rises springing up everywhere outside the original cluster of supertalls of Canary Wharf.
The DLR first gen trains the P86s were built and ordered with the first plan in mind. The extension to bank didnt work with that model so we got new trains, and more.of them....and the jubilee line to go with the fancy new developments...
I think that was the original lyric but Mick couldn't get his lips around it so they shortened it.😂
Before DLR opened at Bank, I had to follow directions at street level to Tower Hill Gateway. They could at least have built an underground walkway from (say) Tower Hill so that it was weather proof.
The problem with that would be having somewhere to put it as the pedestrian route between the two crosses over the District Line tunnel, and being a cut and cover line that doesn't leave a lot of space between the tops of the trains and the road.
A whole station for the price of two Babychams, a Bacardi and Coke, and a pint of lager top. Incredible really.
I now find myself wondering if I can draw up future extension plans like I did a little while ago with my "DLR tube" to Thamesmead.
Did the £77m include the tip? And did they say “What can I get for you guys?” in the initial process? 🤔 Seems insane to still-in-age-denial me that the picture of the ‘new’ station was taken thirty six years ago. Even more astonishing is the change in that view which is considerable. I drive out of Fen St daily and so much has changed even since the mid 80s. Much of the old infrastructure that had clung on for decades suddenly stared disappearing like the Royal Mint buildings, the old signal box and the long-disused approach tacks to the goods yards. I can even remember when ‘Stepney East’/Limehouse was physically a junction. But hey, progress 🤷🏻♂️
Shame that ‘T-Gates’ (did make me chuckle) seemed set to close but in truth it did seem to be in a hiding to nothing even when I used it in the mid 90s. I lived by the old Island Gardens station (on the viaduct…really miss that) and this was a great way for me and my then girlfriend to go straight into town for a walk along the river and a bevvy or two. But we were never pushed for getting a seat on the way back and the train was almost empty by the time we left Shadwell 💁♂️
I did think the upgrade to ‘TG2’ made sense along with the emergency siding for stock movements, but I fear you may be right. As the Beatles once sang, “When I was young and so much younger than today, I never need anybody’s help in any way, but now those days are gone I’m not so self assured, now I find, they change their mind, alight at Shadwell and take the more direct route to Bank for its far more convenient interchange possibilities.” 🤔
The 60s eh? Crazy times, crazy lyrics…I mean what were they smoking? 👍🍀🫖☕️
Brilliant stuff as usual ❤
I remember visiting this station when I visited London during my school trip to England.
When I started work in Canary Wharf I had to use Tower Gateway. Once the Bank platforms opened, a short walk from Cannon Street was a lot easier. Not been back to TG since!
It's a real shame the pedways scheme never really happened. It would be great to be able to connect on and walk above-ground from Tower Gateway to Fechurch St or directly to workplaces
Brings back many memories. I was living on the Isle of Dogs when the DLR was in its infancy. I remember the first big malfunction when 2 trains collided at West India Quay. In those early days not a day went by without at least 1 breakdown, meaning that the trains had to be driven manually. Also I remember they didn’t run late at night or at weekends so if you lived there it was back on the bus. Seems like a lifetime ago, One Canada Sq tower was newly built and bankrupt, then the time the trains didn’t stop at South Quay due to the IRA bombing. How times have changed
That brought back painful memories of daily commutes from Kent into Victoria, down the District Line and round the corner to the DLR station (if my memory seves there was no cover over the staris back then) to go a few stops to Limehouse when the whole of that area down to Canary Wharf was no more than one huge building site. The early mornings on the station were awful, the service was awful and the trains were overcrowded and spent more time stopped than going. I, for one, would not be sad to see the DLR being scrapped and a decent transport system put in place.
On of the interesting aspects of the DLR is the integration with the buildings….going through them or under the eaves. ‘Quite fascinating from a modeler’s perspective!
I would love to build a model of the DLR.
Happy father's day......great Jago
Mick Jago.
…..and you are the concrete extension to my RUclips and to all of RUclips, Sir Jago Hazzard.
I used to get a train from Shadwell to Tower Gateway as my office was on Bevis Marks. I loved the station and would be sad to see it close. Let's hope not 🙂
Lovely writing as always Jago. Had I got my Time Machine working I’d have an alternate history with rail tracks running across tower bridge. Maybe the district/ circle line could have branched and sneaked through the bridge deck and swapped the bascules to a vertical lift, or link into bricklayers arms or cut and cover toward elephant and beyond. Also those ambitious 1946 plans to build tower bridge station would have an interchange. Or even now now curve the dlr to squeeze through those huge arches and cross the lud to interchange with what maybe the bakerloo extension. Maybe a lot to get through running but I’d love to get railed across tower bridge.
Running tracks across a bridge that still has to open occasionally would be ......interesting
Thanks for another interesting video
I've never been to Tower Gateway since the DLR Bank station opened. These days, I mostly get on the DLR at Heron Quays or Canning Town.
I’m looking forward to the Paul McCartney album ‘Give My Regards To Tower Gateway’ next year
I love this station.
Why am I enjoying the name 'Minories' so much😊. This is the first time I've heard of it.
Paul and John went back and forth for months trying to get that line just right
I always sing it that way at karaoke
Cracking video sir.
Love the Rolling Stones reference. As i recall, i think you have the lyrics spot on 👌
The station I most remember from DLR opening back in the 80s as a boy.