House member says Antisemitism Awareness bill protects speech, doesn't allow for hatred
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 май 2024
- The House passed a bipartisan bill Wednesday to combat antisemitism as pro-Palestinian protests roil colleges across the U.S. The measure passed 320-91. Twenty-one Republicans and 70 Democrats voted against it. Rep. Josh Gottheimer, D-NJ, joins Morning Joe to discuss.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
House member says Antisemitism Awareness bill protects speech, doesn't allow for hatred
#Antisemitism #Palestine #Israel
So you can criticize Americans not Israelis??
Bs
Worse part is he's gaslighting & not one push back on the words in the bill. This is gold for a anchor. They said nothing.
Yes
You can criticize children with cancer, just not the Jews 😂
Just white Americans.
Calling for a genocide to stop is not anti semitic.
There’s no genocide.
Exactly
Their "definitions" like their proofs change over time or are altered due to reasonable challenges or inquiry, which is why they prefer to handle them with a decisive action.
The definition of antisemitism is verrrry broad, similarly to the wide definition of what constitutes "a survivor"..
Some people are ALWAYS worried about the truth being told, because they cannot afford for that to happen
The power to define is held by Jews and the politicians they fed.
Then why’d you attack? 🤡
Wow, no one is going to mention that this is a violation of our 1st amendment. Journalism has taken a turn for the worst. They just sat there and let him spew this garbage. Do your job as a journalist and ask the questions we are all asking. Pathetic
Precisely! It also means, as a Christian, I cannot say the Jews killed Jesus - 1 Thessalonians 2:15 This principle is key to Christian faith. They just outlawed the New Testament. JESUS IS LORD AND KING
@@Kev-3006 Well to be fair it was the Pharisees who killed Jesus and there were even some cool Pharisees like Nichodemus.
@@kingkoi6542 100% true!! I should have been more specific. And yes, Nicodemus is a fascinating character.
Representative do you take money from a foreign country to make laws against citizens of this country in favor of a country we don't live in shouldn't your job be to defend us and our rights
Yes, yea they do. They even wear pins of that foreign nation inside the chamber in congress
Yes they do
@@checo8187how do you know that?
@@davidreidenberg9941 It's obvious....duh.
@@davidreidenberg9941Donors are public record. Open Secrets is a good site to look at if you’re curious. There may be better sites but this one seems unbiased.
Shame on MSNBC! SHAME
Indeed. They will never recover from this
SHAME on you for supporting antisemitism!
@@lukesimas And either will pariah Israel. An entire generation finally sees who they are. And the majority of the world supports Palestine.
@@KnucklSandwich I agree 100%
Shanda!
What you mean is house passes Anti-American Bill.
Protesting against apartheid and genocide is not antisemitic.
Not protesting against the October 7 attack is.
These people r calling for genocide from the river to the sea.
While protesting genocide.
Hilarious
The only people commiting genocide are Palestinians against the native Israeli population.
They are buzz words. They don't have a clue. They don't want to know the truth. They don't want to know. Ask them Why all the Tunnels and not one child could use them but Hamas did not one family could use the tunnels but Hamas did. And why did they have All the tunnels. Hamas sold the people out for the money for the money for the muhallh in Iran. When they come for them. They will scream You must help me. I don't see one person protesting the killing the people of Syria Sudan Ethiopia Mali China Ukraine Somalia Yeamen and the Iraian people.they are a lost generation. Looking for the wrong answer s. So your Social media had a Post and you jumped on the band wagon. Your a sad flying monkey. Wake up for you put Trump back in the White House. And the whole world is watching you due it. Then you will protest the deputation of the people that started the whole thing. You demand a better way. You just pushed US back 50 years. Words sound familiar stuff your history is dangerous.
@@sayhisnamewhickerfjb "Not protesting against the October 7 attack is."
If I invade your front lawn and build an illegal settlement with the "police" on my side what will you do? Move quietly to another state or country? If so, send me your address.
The Jewish student is rude and a bully. Not convinced.
And he's also wrong about the meaning of Intifada.
Exactly
He’s a Tiktoker who wears an IDF shirt and tries to get into the encampment…every day…
“You are an antisemite. Change my mind.” -That guy.
@@sonotdown998 Actually I’m not. I carry the dna. I just don’t like bullies. I care for Israel but NOT Netanyahu! Murdering children and aid workers solves nothing.
War is peace. Freedom is slavery. Ignorance is strength.
Grow up.
@@al-bot1094 do you know where the quote originated from? You should read the book. Also, you're ok with this but not other "hate speech"? Why is it only for one special class and not all?
@@anthonyadeyemi6056 how is this "hate speech"?
Why do you think I'm okay with hate speech?
Not everyone knows this is a quote in a book.
Morons will think it's a good idea.
There is no context to it.
Stupid and dangerous quote in these times and circumstances . smh
Educated people who read books all know the quote. Google search knows who the quote is. You have no excuse to not know where the quote is from
To my fellow Christians who have been blindly supporting Netanyahus' genocide of the Palestinian people, will you blindly support your own persecution too?
Really "Antisemitism"? Most of us are done with tis term. It has been used as a "get out jail free card" for to long.
Right?!
Yes!!!
Exactly.
Zionism is a nationalistic settler colonial apartheid movement that was founded by a group of secular Jewish people that have committed acts of terrorism.
Zionism is not a religion.
Judaism is not Zionism.
Zionism is not Judaism.
“Between the sea and the Jordan there will be only Israeli sovereignty” has been part of the Israeli Likud Party’s manifesto since 1977. Sounds familiar, doesn’t it?
He's also lying. The bill says opposite
Does anyone at MSNBC ever think to ask how much in donations these politicians are getting from AIPAC? Including the President of our dear United States? No? 😅
They can't because apparently it's against the law now.
MSNBC, FOX. All of them. Right Left and Center
They probably get donations from the same people.
Intifada means to shake off the Israeli occupation. What on earth is wrong with that?
It's call for Jihadism.
@@KingPingviiniit’s a struggle for national liberation
@@KingPingviini so?
They never stated their definition of antisemitism
Saying anything bad about Iz Rel's actions is anti-semitism...
I guess we’re no longer allowed to criticise a foreign country that we send countless billions to every year.
THATS PART...... We Need to WAKE UP.... Revelation 2:9
Over 300 000 000 000 dollars so far if adjusted by inflation.
you can curse anything thing sacred but you can't criticize the brutal acts of a government.
I'm sorry you feel this way, I myself am frustrated with the the government too but more specifically with the Legislature, I'm sure many here feel the same way, so you see we look at our problems differently, I'm sorry but it is quite frustrating when things don't go our way, but change will come as it always does here, it best to let others know what the problem is specifically so a solution could be worked out. Even if you're from outside the US, people can read your comments and be familiar with your hardships, this is a good way to talk about your problems.
@@MyHalcyonDaysAreHere Thanks for your feelings. It is important for voters to be educated on this matter and use their votes to school these corrupt politicians. Making them feel their political future is not guaranteed, is the only language they understand.
Zionism is not Judaism just like ISIS is not Islam. Criticizing the apartheid and genocidal regime of Israel is not antisemitic just like criticzing the barbaric and terrorist regime of Saudi Arabia is not Islamophobia.
YOUR HAVE NO IDEA WHAT ZIONISM IS. And furthermore, I totally reject your assertion that Israel is an apartheid and genocidal regime. YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT YOU”RE TALKING ABOUT.
@@davidreidenberg9941lol
But Isis were muz lem extremists. By that logic zogs are clearly j3.i$*h extremists. Let's see how long it takes before they delete this Fact.
@@davidreidenberg9941 who cares what you think. you're wrong.
spot on comparison
Disgusting
Mind Begs the Question:
- Protocols of Zion
- Deemed a Fabricated Document
- If Protocols can be seen being signed into Law
- Fabricated Document or Plan Document?
Brought to you by Raytheon
A 6 year old Palestinian boy and his mother were killed by their landlord. Where’s your outrage
What kind of inbreed argument is that.
Why do Israeli government supporters keep telling others that they are saying things they aren’t saying ?! People have a right to their own voice. Coverage has been outrageously one sided in this. Re-defining what others are saying as hate speech is wrong.
Including Jewish people who oppose Zionism.
There’s proof of everything. Your gaslighting doesn’t work.
Left and right are two wings of the same bird.
Coverage has been nothing but one-sided in EVERYTHING associated with this people.. the indignation would be greater, IF people knew the truth..
They're afraid of the truth, not propaganda, which they use often on the non-discerning masses..
Its a spiritual warfare because of all of these demons, devils, ba'als, and these witches. Kabbalah esotericist witches.
@@the-bob-holly-podcast No, they aren't. It's not a clever saying, it's not true and it isn't even original. You're just spouting nonsense you heard someone else say lol.
Anti. f@da - armed resistance is completely legal. According to international law Every occupied nation has the right to resist.
“Armed” isn’t even part of the definition of intifada; however, Zionists have used arms to steal land the land of others and terrorize others from the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River since at least 1946.
@@darthtechnologies553 Israel is not Jews. Zionism is not Judaism. Judaism is not Zionism. Theodor Herzl was a secular Jewish person. Zionists are no more Judaism than ISIL is Islam.
Is there a bill like this for anyone else, specifically?
How About THE USA! WE NEED IT!
Nope that bill is reserved for Israel. Lol we can protest the American founding fathers but not the Israeli ones! Ridiculous.
@@seeekerman1342 go back to school.
@@seeekerman1342 No, no we do not. It’s UN-American and it is cowardice.
Freedom is scary, deal with it.
Yes. It’s already in law actually.
So I can criticize my own government, but it's automatically antisemitic if I criticize the Apartheid regime of Israel?
Also, intifada means an uprising. According to international law, uprising and resistance against an occupier is legal.
Nope. You can’t criticize its existence without consequences. Grow up and stop lying.
To find out who rules over you, find out who you’re not allowed to criticize
If there is any silver lining at all, it’s that US foreign policy hypocrisy is more evident than ever. The illusion of Israel has also been shattered for so many people as well.
Tells you who is the big boss
Those in power today won the election by getting money support from AIPAC, go figure.
When everything is antisemitism, nothing is antisemitism.
Intifada ( انتفاضة intifāḍah) is an Arabic word for a rebellion or uprising, or a resistance movement. It can be used to refer to an uprising against oppression.
Thank you!
Antifada does not mean armed resistance in Arabic, intifada simply means resistance. And protesting is a form of intifada
Someone please explain to me, what do we owe Israel? Why should we/I give blanket approval of its actions and accept responsibility for the loss of tens of thousands of innocent lives including many thousands of children?
Because AIPAC Pays our Politician ALOT of money during elections to get them elected... thus they control them with money.... literally...
they've done decades of lobbying in our govt and in evangelical churches which are among their bigger supporters, their version of the Bible helped enable this rethoric, hope that explains a bit
A surprise to no one Gottheimer receives AIPAC money.
No country other than Israel has used these definitions to make them law. Why don’t you disclose the definitions of antisemitism in the bill which makes it illegal to criticize the State of Israel or ANY Jewish person who supports them including American politicians….even if they have taken money from AIPAC.
That’s not the bill. Don’t lie.
Don't forget, it is also illegal to boycott 1srael in 38 US states.
@@the-bob-holly-podcastdont forget in some states you have to pledge loyalty to Israel to get access to support in case of natural disasters.
As children, we were taught that words have no value and to simply ignore bullying, yet as adults and policymakers, we’re literally implementing laws to protect groups from criticism. The irony of the times we live in.
But of course anti-China speech is encouraged, cuz it's not hatred.
They want everyone to hate Chinese and tiktok 😅
*Who runs the News Media?*
_That’s the Answer!_
Rich white people
The Deep State! Which Supports The Destruction of THE USA!
FACTS!!!! Kanye was RIGHT!!!!
Who owns both parties?
Same answer.
Aaaand my Comments were deleted...
Juice... it spilled every where.. & it stained...
“Between the sea and the Jordan there will be only Israeli sovereignty.” ~ from the Israeli Likud party’s election manifesto in 1977.
Democrat Jerry Nadler stood in opposition to the bill, and AIPAC.
🤯👏👏👏
The majority of Jewish House members voted against it.
Really ? Good to know. He's our Congressman.
@@MyHalcyonDaysAreHere Trust me, he is not your friend.
Overwhelmingly outvoted.
That student which was interrupted is a tiktoker who continuously wears an |$R@3| military shirt and tries to walk into the encampment…
(•‿•). Hahaha.
Unbelievable.
This is the beginning of the end if this passes.
You cannot punish people for speech unless they're threatening.
I'm livid.
ME TOO;-) AMERICA FIRST!
I am with you here. Unfortunately it passed in the house. This is bad for our country. I can’t believe a foreign government has that much influence in our country.
@@jantonio55 I'm beyond angry. I'm sick of it, it being that country and its ppl.
@@jantonio55 Did You See The Report that a Foreign Flag Was Waved In The House After the Bill for Foreign Aid Passed? SICKENING!!!
Only anti semites would be livid about a bill trying to shut down anti semitism
Under this bill it is now illegal to say that there are Js with more loyalty to Israel than their country of residence. How insane.
That is true. American zionists are betraying us and endanger our interests and soldiers.
Which is funny cause literally this bill proves that point
You have freedoms to criticize America but Israel
@@Kmcgonigle0 it’s unreal. Next we’ll criminalize saying the sky is blue
Not the bill. lol.
They all let it go. No push back. Very fox news of them.
Intifada definition makes no mention of "armed" resistance. Merely rebellion, uprising, or a resistance movement.
My shocked face when there is turmoil in the middle East for the 3,500th year in a row. 😳
It was actually a quite successful empire before western intervention. Continuous intervention from western powers including military intervention, economic exploitation ie loans favoring the west and exploiting the oil industry both those create dependency on western powers. This intervention has been present since the 19th century and continues to destabilize the region.
They call that region armageddon for a reason
People aren't buying the media's nonsense anymore. They're terrified and it's hilarious. 🤣🤣🤣
This is normally a great moment for a anchor & they didn't say anything. Pull up the bill & confront him on the lie. Stunning
Does this mean we can't mention who murdered JFK anymore?
Or who was all over 9/11.
@@jonathandoe2316or the USS liberty
@@Michelle-rj4pj Or the Chinese advances in fighter jets. I could go on forever.
Arm resistance from occupation
Armed does not define intifada to begin with but what’s truly rich is the fact arms that have been used by people resisting Zionist occupation, apartheid, and ethnic cleansing have been minuscule compared to what Zionist Israel government and settlers have used to steal land and terrorize others from the Mediterranean Sea to the Jordan River since at least 1946.
It censors the Bible.
Nope. Not at all.
Hi want to silence everything to criticize the brutality military occupation of Palestine territory ...
Apparently, this bill makes the New Testament illegal.
Yup! Indeed, it does. The Bible could be banned and preaching.
You cannot mandate the way people FEEL and THINK. This will backfire eventually!
We need To put that BS up for Votes
Want to find out who is in charge? Who is it that you cant criticize?
But..what about MY feelings!?
Remember who they really serve next time you give away your vote.
Facism
Hamas are fascist.
"intifada" just means uprising, the same word that is used to discribe the warsaw ghetto uprising in arabic.
Stop with BS.
She's right it is dispicable, do not bring up the holocaust to shield yourself from the consequences of your wrong doings, you weren't even alive then
Where's the Racism Awareness Bill? Why isn't that passed in Congress?
We need fewer bills, not more restrictions.
Remember, before Trump burns America to the ground, Biden`s 1984 level censorship lit that match.
“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”
Congratulations you have just violated the first amendment, or you can pass a law similar for Muslims, Christian’s, Buddhist, etc.
Well, it was not peaceful assembly.
@@KingPingviini Correct
CHRIST IS KING
The internal consortia in the United States are fighting and the American people are suffering.
Intifada is not defined as “ARMED”resistance.
That young man was mistaken and was insisting upon a lie as though he knew better.
Furthermore standing against Zionism (a settler colonial apartheid movement founded by secular Jewish terrorists-e.g. they bombed the King David Hotel in Jerusalem in 1946) is not antisemitism. Zionism is not a religion. Zionism is not Judaism. Judaism is not Zionism.
Layered on top of that, Josh Gottheimer’s statement here broadly was full of gaslighting, half truths, outright false claims, misdirection and nonsense, continuing the same from Morning Joe on these issues, presented with evidence or investigative journalism.
It’s not news that they present. It’s opinion, AKA propaganda, fundamental no different than Fox and Friends programming.
Hmm? His "And everyone else sounded like an afterthought
Criticism of Israel similar to that leveled against any other country is not antisemitic. Israel doesn't get a pass to commit crimes against humanity.
"You might not know you're doing this, but you are".
They're coming for your reality.
Yes. The Jews telling the truth is the issue lol
The people have every right to protest. The only issue I see is if outsiders are fueling the fire with hate. Isn't that how Jan. 6 got out of hand.
The bill protects speech, and that's a classic double-speak.
Intifada (انتفاضة) : means “uprising”. Palestinians have a right to uprise and rebel against military occupation and apartheid that has been imposed on them by Israel for 58 years.
The House member said guess where my campaign funds come from?
"Truth fears no examination"
It's about time the history repeating itself you will end up the same way, you never learn dude
Where can I see the full interview? The one the girl interrupted.
Hatred is a human emotion, by passing a bill you can’t remove this emotion. Use common sense.
The pro Palestinian protesters need to clarify their views. I have yet to hear a single protester say that they AREN"T pro HAMAS. I have yet to hear a single protester say they aren't against Jews existing.
Selective deafness?
"What do you make of the fact that younger voters disagree with you?"
"Oh, I just pretend you asked me a completely different question and that they actually do."
To learn who rules over you, simply find out who you are not allowed to criticise.
To quote that great philosopher Homer Simpson:
"Just because I am listening doesn't mean I care".
We in our country have the first amendment of free speech which does allow freedom to exPress opinions even hate. As along as people do not use physical violence.
This what you call “double speak” for all the 1984 fans out there.
Gottheimer should ask himself if he wouldn’t be more at home in the Israeli Knesset, representing his people in his ancestral homeland, and not Americans in U.S. Congress. He appeared to be unaware that no loyal American citizen is obligated to endorse Zionism or pledge an oath of allegiance to the Jewish state
Great, now I want to know if my state rep voted in favor of this, so I can vote for someone else.
What in the flying fack is going on in this country.
🤣🤣🤣 Bringing legislation does nothing thwart the hatred spewed by corporate media!
If anything it gives credence to the dual loyalty trope of Jewish people
They literally passed a law making banning criticism of Israel
If it really protects speech then it protects hateful speech as well.
Josh Gottheimer has been gifted $1,697,263 from pro-Israeli sources. He was gifted $7,900 from AIPAC. His largest donor percentage during 2023-2024 was from pro-Israel sources, totaling $212,559. In 2019-2020 he was gifted $206,095 from pro-Israeli sources.
This comment will probably be taken down in few hours
Surprised AIPAC allowed you to post this...
Great investment.
He probably owns a vacation home in Israel
If Biden doesn't stop support for Gaza, I will not vote for him!
What support? Are you referring to humanitarian aid?
I read the bill and it gave no specific definitions of what antisemitism is. When laws are not specific, they leave too much to individual interpretation, and tend to be used as a very broad excuse to violate people's rights. This is just virtue signalling and inevitably will be struck down on first amendment grounds should it be signed into law.
I did check to make sure that my representative voted nay. 👍🏼
It will be signed into law - and no Trump judge will reject it.
@@user-pf7tf3rf1u Not gonna help you.
Is not Censorship. Its actually freespeech.
Thirty pieces of silver will buy all but a few of the members of Congress.
God doesn’t want ppl to fight with each other in campus. Please have peaceful discussions and NO fighting. If you are not camped out just walk away from fights and come back later. Chant “we come in peace”. Do not chant d3@th to ___ etc NO death threats think strategically and do not stop doing what you think is right while trying to improve on it. Most of all hear me out!
You don’t need a bill to protect Jewish students just in force your policies. It’s for after this war . That is also why they want to bring Palestinians here so there are less of them over there so they can have Gaza . That’s my best guess
Thousands of Palestinians died in the Intifada, far more than Israeli's.
Yippee!
Yawn..........
@@user-jr5mg4tf3lbest comment ever
So they f'd around and found out. Got it
Free the palestinians from Hamas
when hatred is loosely defined, oppression is loosely applied.
I got tired of waiting. Did any part of this video go into detail about what's in the bill? Did you post that clip somewheres else?
No such thing as antisemitism. No community is immune from criticism.
What about the concerns of those Christians who sincerely believe that the Jews are responsible for Jesus' murder?
Revelation 2:9
"I know about the slander of those who say they are Jews and are not, but are a synagogue of Satan". 👹👿
Foreign governments have no business dictating definitions for the purposes of US law. Israel especially has NO BUSINESS dictating what Americans can say about it.
Intifada literally means rebellion or insurrection, palestineans literally live in concentration camps, anyone living in such conditions have a right to rebel against their oppressor, and this happened since the first day the Israel state was created by the British, they took the palestineans out of their homes and sent them to concentration camps
So we know who pays the bills at MSNBC like all mainstream media
To learn who your rulers are learn who you cannot criticize
The end of America
Freedom of speech also includes our right to hate whoeever we want. This is unconstitutional