+MissEzzati omg this comment. i don't know if i need to compliment MBC or hating them. argghhh. i just wth did they do when they turned on the audience camera at the favorite dance part and the stick dance. arghh.
I don't think people realize that it's not the camera man's fault that MBC chose to show the audience. It's the editing staff. They have camera men everywhere and each have their own job of what to shoot and focus on. I'm sure they have the shot of the dance break with the rulers from the camera man in front of the stage, but instead, whoever edited the video chose the shot from the camera man all the way in the back of the venue. It's nice to see everyone ignorantly bashing on someone just doing their job instead of thinking logically. #themoreyouknow
IS NO ONE GONNA TALK ABOUT HOW YERI VOICE WAS SO CLEAR HERE? GOOD JOB YERI SHOW EM' WHAT YOU GOT! Yeri is not my bias, seulgi is, but i hate how people say she contributes nothing to the group. Yeri is slowly proving herself, her voice is just naturally soft but she's gaining confidence. NICE
+SHINeeGeneration redvelvexo I was thinking the same thing! When she sings anyone say anything but if she had not sung half of these comments would be talking bad about her..
***** ikr.. its like what do they want from her? She obviously improved a lot. It takes time, talent isnt supposed to be shown all at once, you are suppose to show it little by little
Ikr.. There are people who can show the talent since the early and there are people who need time to emerge. This is the second comeback she participates and she is already showing improved.
***** yep, i agree. What I'm wondering is why they are judging her based off of Ice cream cake, its like its only her first song together with them, give her time she only had a tiny amount of camera time to show her talent and in this song she definitely improved and seems more confident. She was only a rookie, it only has been 1 year since she joined and its obvious she improved now but they were judging her and bashing her when it was only within 1 day of her first stage, they need to realize that her voice isnt the loud and powerful type its more soft, it reminds me of yoonas voice from snsd (it beautiful yet fragile, a nice combination) Im sure it takes time, cause it took time for people to realize that yoona is a good singer, like yoona who improved a lot Yeri improved a lot too
I totally agree. They require it to be a main singer, but her position in the group is only vocalist and rapper .. The truth is that they just want to hate her and arrange stupid excuse for it.I believe it will only improve the course of career ,the same for the other members.
Seriously this group is just too perfect. I am a Joy bias, but I can't deny that Irene is really a goddess. Gosh! She's just so pretty. Of course, Wendy and Seulgi's vocals are slaying. And I never realize that Yeri is pretty. This video made me realize that she has that charisma and sex appeal. *____* But, I will still stick to my Sooyoungie :D And btw, thanks MBC for letting us see the crowd. I was very touched! #Sarcasm -______-
Since no one else will say it. FINALLY YERI SINGS LOUDER THAN THE MR! It felt nice finally being able to ACTUALLY hear Yeri over the back track for once. Goodness gracious. I knew she could sing. Everyone who kept saying her age was the reason why she couldn't sing please watch this and eat your words. I always knew she could sing. She just didn't want to sing louder than the back track. But this performance she sang louder than the back track crystal clear and she has a good sounding voice. Thank you Yeri for proving my point.
+Daniel Soares ummmm why don't you look at their pre debut pictures. And also I think every group do plastic surgery why SM idols is still has prettiest people.
+Daniel Soares r u kidding? YG does too. Every company. There are beautiful naturals in SM too but why does it matter if they do PS? It's their own choice to make them feel better about themselves. And either way, how are you gonna deny them of that? They were all still pretty predebut too. Newsflash: every company, including ur precious YG (YGstan -.- I don't Stan companies. I like YG groups but SM groups I love) has people with plastic surgery.
***** Bom did it, Minzy did it, CL probably did it. Daesung did it, Seungri probably did it, GD did it, Taeyang unsure...T.O.P. and Dara are naturals but a lot are not. Just like Siwon and Onew and Yunho from SM are all natural. But a lot of SM is too. EVERY company. And it doesn't even matter!!! Plastic surgery doesn't made a company good or bad -.-
wow, Red Velvet look so nice here! Their performance was so good here and wooooooow I didn't know they had that many members wow good job, cameraman :O 😒
+zelos wifeu It is not the camera man's fault. If you had common sense you would realize that one guy could not change angles to quick. It is the editors fault.
+Kaylena Rose +Kaylena Rose "if you had common sense" wow sorry for the overly misleading typo. Im more than aware that there are multiple cameraMEN operating many cameras at once and that I'm more than aware of the editing. Thanks :^)
2019 and still watching this vid. Dumb dumb is such a great song and is one of my favorites. Their choreography here is hard yet they are still singing live with clear voices and Wendy and Seulgi are so stable. I really love these girls
To the people who are blaming the cameramen: Are you freaking stupid? It's the director/producer who decides whether to show the audience or idols. The cameramen are just doing their job either only focusing on the girls or maybe only a few of them who focus on the audience. If you're so angry, why don't you go to S.Korea yourselves and got to MBC Music Core's PD room and make some argument? It's not like MBC would even care to read the comments here. Gosh.
+Muthia Farina there are many cameraman. those who film audience and those who film the idols. and it's actually the director/pd who decides whether to show the scene of audience or idols. so don't blame on cameraman, they just did their jobs anyway
wah😍 i've never pay attention to RV & this is the first time i watch them live and.. you know, in a girlband there is often one person stay in the back or dont get attention as much as the other members got but i think in RV , each of them is bright ! each of them perform and slay thought. its awesomeeeee. i got confused who is the brightest among them. theyre star.
*crowd:* dead af *me in my room alone:* YASSSSS OHMYGOD YASSSS SLAY ME OHMYGOD RED VELVET FIGHTING! ASDFGHJKL UGHHH PLEASE BE MY WIFE, ALL OF YOU YASSS AHHHHHH
Dear, MBC Music Core, we do not care about the audience neither how the stage looks like from afar. We want to look at our girls' performance and faces clearly, thank you.
I don't care and know why people bash Yeri but all I can say is she is soo pretty! I'm glad the editor or cameraman or whatever focus on her more. She need that confirmation to believe that she is good enough. She is unbelievably cute
Actually , I really like Seulgi ! She fits the dance like in 1:05 - 1:10 and also her outfit fits on her ! I also like Irene , my 2nd bias in Red Velvet ! And the girl group I only know is Snsd , 2nei1 , Red Velvet , Miss A and F(x) and my bias list in all 1 Yoona 2 Seulgi 3 Yuri 4 Irene 5 Taeyeon 6 Bom 7 Krystal 8 Jessica 9 Seohyun 10 Suzy 11 Sandara 12 Yeri
Music Core's really smart making the face/visual of each group the thumbnail of their videos. 😏 (Bora & hyorin - sistar, irene - red velvet, hyungwon - monsta x, minggyu - seventeen, taemin - shinee)
Omg every member of Red Velvet slays a lot!! Their live performances are always great, I think RV is going to become the best girlband ever in the future :)
Stop blaming the cameramen guys.... it's not them, it's the director in the editing room which decide what will show. Red Velvet are so talented, great live girls
Damn, they showed the audience at my favorite dance part. The robot dance. Since they put it on the audience I need to look at the screens to see their dance. Nice job MBC.
As much as how bad the camera work was, the acoustics and the sound system including the live singing we can here from the girls is actually amazing espeically at 2:25 , if you open 2 youtube videos and put another live show on and mute it but listen to this one, amazing experience
Everything was so on point this performance vocals, rap, visuals, AUDIENCE 😡 and people try to say they aren't talented Yeri has improved so much I'm so glad they are singing live
![[HOT] Red Velvet - Dumb Dumb, 레드벨벳 - 덤덤, Show Music core 20150919](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ITL9LjIG8Vw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HOT] Red Velvet - Dumb Dumb, 레드벨벳 - 덤덤, Show Music core 20150919](/img/tr.png)
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #12 ПРЕДАТЕЛЬ [Большой Заговор] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mbu21mCSWj4/mqdefault.jpg)
me: omg omg i dont know where to look at the members are too pretty!!
mbc: here look at the audience instead
Ikr. Your comment was on point 😂😂😂
I love your comment!
Exactly how we feel!! 👍 they missed the point of the dance man.. 😔
+MissEzzati omg this comment. i don't know if i need to compliment MBC or hating them. argghhh. i just wth did they do when they turned on the audience camera at the favorite dance part and the stick dance. arghh.
i love your comments....lol
I don't think people realize that it's not the camera man's fault that MBC chose to show the audience. It's the editing staff. They have camera men everywhere and each have their own job of what to shoot and focus on. I'm sure they have the shot of the dance break with the rulers from the camera man in front of the stage, but instead, whoever edited the video chose the shot from the camera man all the way in the back of the venue.
It's nice to see everyone ignorantly bashing on someone just doing their job instead of thinking logically.
#themoreyouknow
yeah that senseless PD do not realize that audience can watch live while video viewers watch their edited videos.
ikr!! There's no way one camera man could change angles so quickly. There's several of them. It's just common sense! :)
watch the producers
so u can see how it works
ikr u people blaming the camera man should watch the producers
so u can see how it works
that's not how it works for live show. there's no time for editing
This video should be called "Audience - Dumb Dumb"
LOOOOLLLL
true story
+love68274 For real, though!
LMAOOOO
IS NO ONE GONNA TALK ABOUT HOW YERI VOICE WAS SO CLEAR HERE? GOOD JOB YERI SHOW EM' WHAT YOU GOT! Yeri is not my bias, seulgi is, but i hate how people say she contributes nothing to the group. Yeri is slowly proving herself, her voice is just naturally soft but she's gaining confidence. NICE
+SHINeeGeneration redvelvexo I was thinking the same thing! When she sings anyone say anything but if she had not sung half of these comments would be talking bad about her..
***** ikr.. its like what do they want from her? She obviously improved a lot. It takes time, talent isnt supposed to be shown all at once, you are suppose to show it little by little
Ikr.. There are people who can show the talent since the early and there are people who need time to emerge. This is the second comeback she participates and she is already showing improved.
***** yep, i agree. What I'm wondering is why they are judging her based off of Ice cream cake, its like its only her first song together with them, give her time she only had a tiny amount of camera time to show her talent and in this song she definitely improved and seems more confident. She was only a rookie, it only has been 1 year since she joined and its obvious she improved now but they were judging her and bashing her when it was only within 1 day of her first stage, they need to realize that her voice isnt the loud and powerful type its more soft, it reminds me of yoonas voice from snsd (it beautiful yet fragile, a nice combination) Im sure it takes time, cause it took time for people to realize that yoona is a good singer, like yoona who improved a lot Yeri improved a lot too
I totally agree. They require it to be a main singer, but her position in the group is only vocalist and rapper .. The truth is that they just want to hate her and arrange stupid excuse for it.I believe it will only improve the course of career ,the same for the other members.
The last part with them dancing with the sticks/bracelets is what I've been waiting for. But the camera had to show the audience -_-
me too!!!!!
me too -____-
same here!!! annoyingggggggg, zoomed to audience for what, too much alrdy
Ley S arghhh Same!
This is not the only stage thay happened. Most of Dumb Dumb stages camerawork skipped robot dance. Korea does not have good movie editing classes.
I just realized joy's stage name is the only one that doesn't have an E in it
HAHAHAHAH. Even her birth name doesn't have an E
Doubt it was supposed to be funny, just a realization
OMG I NOTICED THAT TOO!
That's because Irene has two e. So it's all balanced out. :P
SoshiSone Fan OMG same😂
I bet the camera mans girlfriend is out there in the crowd. He's looking for her.
ur comment got me rip
lmao.all these comments crack me up.hahaha
omg best comment
daebak 😂
This actually made me laugh out loud 😂
joy is so prety
Joy looks really pretty in here, their stylish is getting better on choosing their costume!! And wtffff we dont need the audiences look -,-
Holy... 2:43 Joy's adlibs are life
Seriously this group is just too perfect. I am a Joy bias, but I can't deny that Irene is really a goddess. Gosh! She's just so pretty. Of course, Wendy and Seulgi's vocals are slaying. And I never realize that Yeri is pretty. This video made me realize that she has that charisma and sex appeal. *____* But, I will still stick to my Sooyoungie :D
And btw, thanks MBC for letting us see the crowd. I was very touched! #Sarcasm -______-
Since no one else will say it. FINALLY YERI SINGS LOUDER THAN THE MR! It felt nice finally being able to ACTUALLY hear Yeri over the back track for once. Goodness gracious. I knew she could sing. Everyone who kept saying her age was the reason why she couldn't sing please watch this and eat your words. I always knew she could sing. She just didn't want to sing louder than the back track. But this performance she sang louder than the back track crystal clear and she has a good sounding voice. Thank you Yeri for proving my point.
Joyちゃん可愛すぎる😍😍
joy is soo talented,,......love her,....
Wendy looks like she has a ballet performance at 12 and then gym class at 12'30
SM really has the most prettiest female idols haha :) and every group in SM really success!
even rookies group bigger than many group...
+Daniel Soares ummmm why don't you look at their pre debut pictures. And also I think every group do plastic surgery why SM idols is still has prettiest people.
+Daniel Soares r u kidding? YG does too. Every company. There are beautiful naturals in SM too but why does it matter if they do PS? It's their own choice to make them feel better about themselves. And either way, how are you gonna deny them of that? They were all still pretty predebut too. Newsflash: every company, including ur precious YG (YGstan -.- I don't Stan companies. I like YG groups but SM groups I love) has people with plastic surgery.
***** Bom did it, Minzy did it, CL probably did it. Daesung did it, Seungri probably did it, GD did it, Taeyang unsure...T.O.P. and Dara are naturals but a lot are not. Just like Siwon and Onew and Yunho from SM are all natural. But a lot of SM is too. EVERY company. And it doesn't even matter!!! Plastic surgery doesn't made a company good or bad -.-
***** ?????? aren't u the hater here?
웬디 언니랑 조이언니 음이 너무 좋아요/// 다시 듣고 싶은 목소리에요
just love joy's real name SOOYOUNG
I'm going DUMB DUMB for Joy-yaaaaaaaa!!!!!!!!!! Saranghae!!!!!!!
Vocals say what !!!! And haters try a act like they can't sing ! Outta here they are killing it!
you're everywhere lol
taylor nina Let's just say I have lots of opinions haha!
+Maria Gomez hhhhhhhhhh
This was live tho
+Lol Lol It's not, there's still backtrack being played.
wow, Red Velvet look so nice here! Their performance was so good here and wooooooow I didn't know they had that many members wow good job, cameraman :O 😒
hahahaaha.
+Sophia lami يي
+Sophia lami يي
+zelos wifeu It is not the camera man's fault. If you had common sense you would realize that one guy could not change angles to quick. It is the editors fault.
+Kaylena Rose +Kaylena Rose "if you had common sense" wow sorry for the overly misleading typo. Im more than aware that there are multiple cameraMEN operating many cameras at once and that I'm more than aware of the editing. Thanks :^)
joy's smile daebak 😍😍
2019 and still watching this vid. Dumb dumb is such a great song and is one of my favorites. Their choreography here is hard yet they are still singing live with clear voices and Wendy and Seulgi are so stable. I really love these girls
WoW! They really singing it live. I had to admit Irene's rap live is very impressive, she doesn't sound like out of breath or something..
To the people who are blaming the cameramen: Are you freaking stupid? It's the director/producer who decides whether to show the audience or idols. The cameramen are just doing their job either only focusing on the girls or maybe only a few of them who focus on the audience. If you're so angry, why don't you go to S.Korea yourselves and got to MBC Music Core's PD room and make some argument? It's not like MBC would even care to read the comments here. Gosh.
go to*
but the cameramen show audience when important part
+Muthia Farina there are many cameraman. those who film audience and those who film the idols. and it's actually the director/pd who decides whether to show the scene of audience or idols. so don't blame on cameraman, they just did their jobs anyway
+Muthia Farina chances are theyve been recording the audience since the very beginning anyway too so
i really love joy and irene's out fit here
Red Velvet song always amazing and catchy!!
Joy can good sing, rap, dance........perfect
i hope more line for Joy and Joy'll visual group
5명 모두 춤 잘 춘다
얼굴도 예쁘고 몸매도좋음
Despite the dumb dumb camera, Joy looks really cute and adorable.
Irene is stunning!!!!!!!! They look so fresh, the make up was really soft and made them even more beautiful. They're look like dolls, so flawless...
the crowd should realize they are watching SM's pretty princesses
joy hip thrusting i died bye world
Their vocals here are so clear!!!
JOY IS SO PRETTY!!! ^^
Joy is so cute
Sungjae: hot joy 😍😍
wah😍 i've never pay attention to RV & this is the first time i watch them live and.. you know, in a girlband there is often one person stay in the back or dont get attention as much as the other members got but i think in RV , each of them is bright ! each of them perform and slay thought. its awesomeeeee. i got confused who is the brightest among them. theyre star.
No doubt red velvet is the best girl group in visuals.
I want more Joy!!!
Omgggg yeri has improved she's very pretty tooo i can't leave this video without complimenting her
joy so beautiful
*crowd:* dead af
*me in my room alone:* YASSSSS OHMYGOD YASSSS SLAY ME OHMYGOD RED VELVET FIGHTING! ASDFGHJKL UGHHH PLEASE BE MY WIFE, ALL OF YOU YASSS AHHHHHH
Dear, MBC Music Core, we do not care about the audience neither how the stage looks like from afar. We want to look at our girls' performance and faces clearly, thank you.
Love Irene and love red velvet so much 😍❤
I see JOY, I click~!!! 💜💜💜
WOOW!....The crowd though!...RV is really getting popular by the day.
Joy ❤️
I can't stop watching them their are so pretty!!
I don't care and know why people bash Yeri but all I can say is she is soo pretty! I'm glad the editor or cameraman or whatever focus on her more. She need that confirmation to believe that she is good enough. She is unbelievably cute
Actually , I really like Seulgi ! She fits the dance like in 1:05 - 1:10 and also her outfit fits on her ! I also like Irene , my 2nd bias in Red Velvet ! And the girl group I only know is Snsd , 2nei1 , Red Velvet , Miss A and F(x) and my bias list in all
1 Yoona
2 Seulgi
3 Yuri
4 Irene
5 Taeyeon
6 Bom
7 Krystal
8 Jessica
9 Seohyun
10 Suzy
11 Sandara
12 Yeri
joy can sing can rap can dance..well rounded clap clap
Joy looks so cute 💚💚💚
Irene has improved so much! I'm so proud yay
Joy slayed as usual.
Music Core's really smart making the face/visual of each group the thumbnail of their videos. 😏
(Bora & hyorin - sistar, irene - red velvet, hyungwon - monsta x, minggyu - seventeen, taemin - shinee)
Omg I just saw seulgis skirt on the opening ceremony website :O I was pondering over it but now I must get it!!
Omg every member of Red Velvet slays a lot!! Their live performances are always great, I think RV is going to become the best girlband ever in the future :)
Stop blaming the cameramen guys.... it's not them, it's the director in the editing room which decide what will show.
Red Velvet are so talented, great live girls
Ooohh I love Yeri's hair !!
i see joy, i click
I WANT TO SEE MY GIRLS PLEASE
+♢ Diamond Choa ♢ "Nope, the crowds."
OMG SLAY SLAY SLAy
The audience too they slay
+Alliah Corpuz ur comment basically made my day
they just had to zoom out at my fav part of the choreography at 3:04 =.= meanwhile seulgi bear wearing a bear pullover! cute!
RV Have so many fans now. The fan chants are amazing
omo omo omo I can see my bias at the crowd. she's at the 25th row 18th column. waaahhhh I Love You Jooooyyyy
The audience is not dead
The audience is mesmerized
Know the difference
I LOVE YERIM'S SHIRT!
joy and yeri saranghae
Daebak I Love Music
after watching snsd performance with their glorious beauty, now i see the fresh youth beauty. i love both, irene please accept my hearteu!
Yeri looks the prettiest here! love her hair and that sweater looks good on her ♥
joy look beautiful than other
so CUTE ! love the song !!
Seulgi gorgeous as always !!
Compare Joy in the MV with her in the performance. How does she switch from hot to cute just like that?
plot twist : THE CAMERAMAN IS ACTUALLY SHOOTING THE AUDIENCE
WENDY'S SKIRT THOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO TTTTTT
Damn, they showed the audience at my favorite dance part. The robot dance. Since they put it on the audience I need to look at the screens to see their dance. Nice job MBC.
this is the first time I like every member of the group. they all look so pretty and talented!
joyyyyy ❤
As much as how bad the camera work was, the acoustics and the sound system including the live singing we can here from the girls is actually amazing espeically at 2:25 , if you open 2 youtube videos and put another live show on and mute it but listen to this one, amazing experience
1:06 Cool !
The visual game is strong in red velvet tbh they are all gorgeous, but damn irene is a goddess!❤
how can wendy hit those high notes while dancing this complicated moves? RV slays.
FINALLY!!!! I have found my performance. Thank you music core!!!!
does the stylist hate wendy or-
+unknown anonymous ifkr omg
am i the only one who love her outfit? its unique and chic
+Nur Diana me too.. i love her outfit.
That tutu tho lol
every girls' outfit is a disaster compared to Irene's :/
I love their outfits here! And the dance is still slaying me
JOY 😍💚💚💚
Irene😍
Wow! It's live! Love this performance, especially Irene's parts ♥ Their sunbaes should learn from them. lol
joy is the original maknae
ASKGHKJFDHJ i'm pulling my hair out bc of this camera man ._.
I like Irene's pink outfit💖
JOY SO BEAUTIFUL
Wow actually.. this is a very good live performance of RC! Love It...
Red velvet is so talented and their so good and performing! Also one of the best dancing girl groups!
love. joyyyy
they slayyeddddd...but the camera man needs to realize that the choreo is dope AS F, SO FOCUS ON IT.
The performance is great
Everything was so on point this performance vocals, rap, visuals, AUDIENCE 😡 and people try to say they aren't talented Yeri has improved so much I'm so glad they are singing live
my favorite girl group❤