As someone who lives in the himalayan hills, Hindu rashtra and Muslim Caliphate has zero meaning for me, and in their forms, shapes and characters are alien ideas. Meanwhile, secular democratic constitution with a flag, common currency and Republican nature of government is much more meaningful and useful. 😊
@@rashmirajsonal8971 Without Right there would have been no need for Left. Now if you want to debate's nuances go ahead & i shall answer you though my positions are a mix of various sides not of ideological Left or Right.
The idea that India has two nations, Hindu nation and Muslim nation, originally comes from the book written by British administrator James Mill in 1817. So yeah Hindu Rashtra is a colonial construct, in that way.
The james mill, father of John stuart mill, John stuart Mill, is the most influential contributor to modern liberalism. What james mill wrote was correct and right.
India is a land of multiple minorities. Their culture, language and customs need to be protected.They are slowly united under the idea of hinduism. This is essential to resist the conquer of foreign origin sematic religions.
@@imaginedragons257 There is no such umbrella and no such protection is needed or provided by Hindutva. Don't confuse religion and culture. Hindutva is a 100 year old political movement. Nothing more nothing less.
I really dont know why this lady is not in jail, isnt she not the one who made those comments on Kashmir and which also featured in Kashmir files movie? if arundhati roy is prosecuted, then niveditha menon is even more responsible for her explosive comments.
Fantastic conversation. Such “interviews” are so captivating to watch/ listen. Dr Menon with her lucid thoughts, responses; and Jahnavi Sen who actually read the book and asked probing questions, and listened without interruption. More of these please.
Till The Conscience Of South India Is Alive & Babasaheb Ambedkar Is Read & Understood, The Hinduvita Dream Shall Always Remain An Impossibility & Self Defeating Project. Jai Bhim!!
Why is Prof Menon opposed to the protection of Muslim women from the oppressive & deeply patriarchal customs and traditions of Islam ? If Sati was abolished and all are happy abt it, why should Halala continue and be justified by coining this mischievous term ‘legal plurality’. I can clearly see the Prof is no friend of Muslim women. If she thinks that BJP can be fought and defeated on the backs of oppressed Muslim women she only shows herself as sick & cunning.
If I were a true hindu... I would bring back sati.. Its been a tradition for ages before even christ was born.. Its a ritual of union and devotion which is a pathway to swarg shared by the husband and wife... Such as your statement prove that hinduvta is a western modern ideology... It wants to establish feminism and other western angikar rather than sanatana dharma.Sanatana dharma has been a victim of epistemicide,butchered by godless, spiritless brits and their students, who now boasts about hinduvta,a secular nationalist ideology
What a conversation!👏🏻 What eloquence!🤌🏻 The host does a commendable job by not at all cutting off the Professor even once. Hope to watch more such enlightening content.
They will not cut off someone of their own tribe who speaks stuff which they want to promote. They will only try to cut off those with whose views they don’t agree with. That is the harsh truth!
What does secularism means in India ???? Treating a particular community as first class citizens through Haz Subsidy, Madrasa Education, Wakf Bord, Sariya Law, Unlawful Reservation for them along with treat all other communities as second class citizens !!!!!
Secularism means India will be ruled by practical rational and religion will not dictate politics. Religion is best left for people to freely practice in their personal life.
@@Vhshjvbjbcch3457 Pakistan and countries that have made religion rule over politics have given a good example of self-destruction. India has done better because we let science and rational lead us not priests, mullas, or Sadhus. If we want to face China and be No1 we need Science, Rationale and Unity.
That is such a 'hit on the head,' statement, that nobody realises the underpinning intent as it is meant to be, and here we have the populace embrace the idea without a care. Very important to have these nuanced conversations thrown in for ppl to think about...
With a limited mindsets and didn't want to understand what is secularism and what is religion and its practices, all are talking on it. Every one thinks he/she is on righteous path and practicing their religion. Secularism means to understand and find the best solution to stop all evils. For this every individual should be enough matured to understand and accept the truth and live the bluffs created for personal benefits.
Though India remained Secular everything and everywhere had been dominated by chaturvarnas who were and are opposed to the very idea of ' Secularism ' ?. Without ' Pluralism ' India has no existance ?.
@@NaughtySaint-kz8co India was never a Secular country and never will be. We mix religion in almost every aspect of our life whether one likes it or not.
@@kirchunetwork1986 secularism doesn't mean atheistic ..... Almost all empires here ere secular abt their policies..... Even most mughals.....muriyan Ashoka empire...and on..., our people like Ghandi and like to practice religion in their personal and social lives......but most not policy making and politics
@@areebanaveed9485 the very concept of Secularism evolved in the West to oppose interference of Church in the government.In India every ruler irrespective of their religion consulted the religious head when it came to policies. Nehru was the first head of the Nation who was truly Secular.
There is a lot of dishonesty here. I’m sure one can derive convoluted arguments for what the puranas say.. but other religions often quite explicitly state that other religions are wrong, and that they must be done away with. And they say so without needing spurious derivation. But that never figures in the discussion?
@@shubhambakshi2320then they are cowards and so is pro bjp channels. No use of comment makers Just satisfaction of egos. Mine also same but the fun thing is i comment rarely and doesn't use bs words like others do . No use of these talks. Ground realities are entirely different what these various channels video present. People want good governance and all political parties who are in power offers substandard governance. India Bharat disappointed that political parties n its leaders let our country down
POLITICS BY BJP RSS......furst it is hindu vs muslim....then it is OBC vs OBC...then it OBC vs SC ST....THEN it sc st vs scst.....that is structure OF CASTEISM and division......who BENEFITS..BRAMINS ...AND ONLY BRAMINS......PPL REALIZE
Stop spreading your lies. It is Congress and other opposition parties, of whom you are an agent, who are making all efforts to divide Hindus on the basis of caste. That is why they are asking for a caste census. The intent of your masters is to divide Hindus and create chaos across the country.
Interesting discussion, but her (critical) interpretation of the 2005 amendment that gave women right to ancestral property remains elusive. Also, interviewer should follow up with some good poking follow up questions
Madams,india has nothing indigenous except perhaps poverty. Whatever india is today is all the legacy of Mughals,British and West. A well researched thesis indeed.
If Sati practice being considered as cultural, religious right of a woman, would it be allowed? How could one read Ambedkar's view on Hindus but completely ignore his views on Hijab and Islam. Read Pakistan and Partition of India by Dr Ambedkar for his views on Islam and Indian muslims, one would surely baffled by his views on Hijab, Muslims regarding religion over nation, Non muslim rights etc
Dont call yourself independent media you are sold out.not just this video even for WB case where all are calling out mamta benerjee u are attacking centre by restricting it to a men-women issue
There are two perspectives,one is that everyone and everything is homogeneous and another is everything is unique,one can give his entire life understanding yet wonder,respect and revere.The weak will always choose the former as his ego is the only shelter.
I couldn't determine whether the Puranic quest to integrate, assimilate, and overwhelm all marginalized communities with puritanical and hegemonic Brahminical values and norms has failed, or if the attempt to define Hinduness through the Hindu Code Bill-essentially based on modern, and of course, Western values such as gender equality, individual rights, and social justice-has faltered.
As long as there are traitors within the Hindu community that work, for their own petty self-interest, on the behalf of those outsiders who want to divide Hindus, the unity of Hindus will remain a tough task to complete.
Securalism is a modern, western project. It has its roots to catholic protestants demanding reformations. Bharat has always been a Hindu rashtra . All the people belonging to other religions are all converts. Bharat has been a safe haven for Jews and Parsis since millenias. If they never felt threatened, why would the 2nd largest majority feel any other way? There are 56 muslim countries. Bharat has every right to declarr herself a Hindu rashtra. Btw: Hinduism is the only religion which preaches inclusivity and allows diversity. But, mutual respect from other religions has to be there for coexistence. Secularism doesnt mean hiding Hindu sentiments
She herself seems to be confused. If uniform civil code is a western concept or approach towards secularism then she should also understand that democracy itself is a western concept of forming a government. She is very selectively taking the ideas to justify pluralistic approach.
That's her hypothesis. Other Professors are free to refute it. This is what academics do. I'm a big Modi fan. I'm here to listen to what she has to say. What you said is correct. But we need a proper academic takedown of this. Only then it is valid. What you and I say on RUclips Comments section; nobody cares. Especially, the Left Liberals. They just cancel us.
She is arguing for decolonization through Ambedkarite framing. If I understood her correctly, she also argued for it in her reading of gender By challenging binary imagination Concerning womanhood. Cognising India is having multiple minorities is probably a good way to to bring the politics of disability to the forefront.
Arayans,Braminical is not hinduism Mahesvara puja is not demonical Sages doing yogna why did they go to Assuras land and create problem polyandry is there not myth vilans against matriachal society This country is a multiple minority University is under attack by religious majority
Remember, as a Brahmin, you are in Minority in India, and Brahminvad is not Hindu religion or Hindutva. It's about time the Brahmins were punished for keeping India uneducated and using all the charity given for their personal well-being and not the Public good as other religions do.
@@pardeeptandonin that case no one is the majority in this country. Should minority rights be applied to Brhamins? Is Deoband a minority, or Bairalvi a minority, Shia, Ahl-e-haddis, Khoja, Ahmadiyyas part of small groups... Who is the majority then?
@@FreddieMurphy746@FreddieMurphy746: All Communities in India are minorities. That is why the founders of our constitution gave us a secular constitution, as they were aware that the Hindu religion was artificially created by the Britishers for their Administrative ease. We are all Indians first and then anything else. The government can give special rights to backward communities. These rights can not be given to Brahmina as they today enjoy hegemony on country resources.
@@pardeeptandon Then Articles that give Minority privileges should be taken off. Minority educational institutions should adhere to normal policies. Temples that are mostly in govt's control should be freed just like Mosques and Churches
Who cares when BJP supports such ppl in states where they are in majority role West Bengal CM should resign what about cases in Delhi, UP, Bihar and now Maharashtra- Reason BJP Ruling states Ram Rahim on back to back parole- Haryana CM- BJP Why they are not ensuring women security at India Level- Women are also part of India
Such a wonderful discussion.. kudos to learned professor 🎉🎉🎉 and very impressive and intelligent journalist whose done her homework well 👏 👍 👌 Sitting in Vienna 😂😂❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
What is true secularism ??? According to Wire promoting a particular majhab which teach good and humanitarian teaching as jihad, jizya tax, maal-e-ganimat, gazwa-e-hind is only secularism !!!!!
Secularism word hmare savidhan mein nhi tha baba sahab ambedkar ji ne savidhan mein secular word nhi likha tha ye congress thi jisne Muslims kk khush karne k liye bharat k anpadh Hinduo ke sath dhoka kiya jabki muslims ko 2 Islamic desh de diye
@@MkpSingh21 bt secularim to nhi h or savidhan mein minorities ka samrakchan likha hai unka haq hi hai bharat m ek samaan ye baba sahab ne nhi likha tha ye kaam ghatia congress n kiya muslims ko 2 desh bhi de diye yha bhi bhar liya barabar se jyada ka haq diya lekin hinduo ko kya mila
Jawaharlal Nehru and Mohandas Gandhi allowed them, who demanded and achieved separate homeland for themselves, to stay in India with not only with equal rights but also with special rights as religious minorities only for providing them sufficient opportunity to create a few more Pakistan and even make India a bigger Pakistan.
@@user-rg7jt4xp9y Modi is bania, Yogi Is Rajput, Gadkari is Brahmin, Nadda is Brahmin, Nirmala Tai is Brahmin. BJP 👉 ब्राह्मण बनिया राजपूत जनता पार्टी 🙏 Ram & Krishna Mythological Characters jo brahmin ko aage jhuke ke rahate hai🙏
@@errahulmali7486 What about Kovind? What about Murmu? Well, what about Rahul Gandhi? And what about CPM Sitaram Yechury? Especially, what about Ambedkar's wife? You gonna hate on all of them?
No groundswell of support for Hindu rastra? Are you sure?If it is true that all most all political changes in any country are driven by the urban middle class,then Hindurastra has big support by the Hindu urban middle class.A survay would be the right thing to ascertain. Elections are different things,There are hundred other considerations other than Hindutwa or secularism for the ppl to vote.Even then 30-35% vote share for BJP is a given thing. *India is dangerously close to the Hindutwa project* (Kerala,TN may miss that beat)
Kashmir files movie showed her real character.
As someone who lives in the himalayan hills, Hindu rashtra and Muslim Caliphate has zero meaning for me, and in their forms, shapes and characters are alien ideas.
Meanwhile, secular democratic constitution with a flag, common currency and Republican nature of government is much more meaningful and useful. 😊
Unfortunately hindi belt(~40%population) has been almost brain washed by the right wing
@@rashmirajsonal8971 Without Right there would have been no need for Left. Now if you want to debate's nuances go ahead & i shall answer you though my positions are a mix of various sides not of ideological Left or Right.
Nationalism & the nation state is an European 18th century ideology and political arrangement... So,basically what you want is foreign too
@@user-mn2gt4ct3l The language you typed the comment is also western. Oh noes! 😅
The idea that India has two nations, Hindu nation and Muslim nation, originally comes from the book written by British administrator James Mill in 1817. So yeah Hindu Rashtra is a colonial construct, in that way.
India itself is a colonial construct 😂
spot on
@@sandyj342dude every country on this damm planet is a colonial construct.even European colonial powers also.
The james mill, father of John stuart mill, John stuart Mill, is the most influential contributor to modern liberalism. What james mill wrote was correct and right.
@@swapnilshivhare31 haha...so you agree thag Hindu Rashtra is a colonial construct, Mr. Succesor of Colonial Bootlickers?
India is a land of multiple minorities. Their culture, language and customs need to be protected.They are slowly united under the idea of hinduism. This is essential to resist the conquer of foreign origin sematic religions.
@@haridas.kkavanat888 Dont confuse culture and religion. They are not inter changeable terms. Lot of Indians do that.
The Sanatana Hindutva is an umbrella which protects all the indigenous culture
@@imaginedragons257 There is no such umbrella and no such protection is needed or provided by Hindutva. Don't confuse religion and culture. Hindutva is a 100 year old political movement. Nothing more nothing less.
I really dont know why this lady is not in jail, isnt she not the one who made those comments on Kashmir and which also featured in Kashmir files movie?
if arundhati roy is prosecuted, then niveditha menon is even more responsible for her explosive comments.
Because of this shit thing called Democracy
Why are you not in jail for making dumb statements that are so anti-national, anti-India, anti-history?
At around 7 minutes the scholar so comfortably switches the position on ucc just because it’s a project of so called Hindu right. Some scholar, huh!
Fantastic conversation. Such “interviews” are so captivating to watch/ listen. Dr Menon with her lucid thoughts, responses; and Jahnavi Sen who actually read the book and asked probing questions, and listened without interruption. More of these please.
This is a fantastic discussion. Thank you !
I'm glad someones even watching this stuff to this detail !
Hindutva a masculinist approach to Hinduism.
Till The Conscience Of South India Is Alive & Babasaheb Ambedkar Is Read & Understood, The Hinduvita Dream Shall Always Remain An Impossibility & Self Defeating Project.
Jai Bhim!!
What is your take on Muslim obcuranticism?
@@bharatpandit4796 yours on hindu obcurantism 😂?
@@bharatpandit4796Sir, It Would Have Been Far Better If Ad Hominem Tactics Were Avoided Instead Levying Flak To My Point. Alas!
@@EshfaqWani4u deflected the point as always u fascist
@@EshfaqWani4 Meem tu Bhim chhu kathujode, beyi na kenh!
lutyens delhi discussing wild wild west lol
Yes Savarkar devotees would like to discuss Adolf Hitler and his solutions..
@@mg.f.9023so everyone who criticises the leftist Marxist lobby is a Savarkar devotee now ?
Why is Prof Menon opposed to the protection of Muslim women from the oppressive & deeply patriarchal customs and traditions of Islam ?
If Sati was abolished and all are happy abt it, why should Halala continue and be justified by coining this mischievous term ‘legal plurality’.
I can clearly see the Prof is no friend of Muslim women.
If she thinks that BJP can be fought and defeated on the backs of oppressed Muslim women she only shows herself as sick & cunning.
@@nissarguru-xg1wx as an Ex-muslim u stated something that hits hard.... without saying anything hateful
If I were a true hindu... I would bring back sati.. Its been a tradition for ages before even christ was born.. Its a ritual of union and devotion which is a pathway to swarg shared by the husband and wife... Such as your statement prove that hinduvta is a western modern ideology... It wants to establish feminism and other western angikar rather than sanatana dharma.Sanatana dharma has been a victim of epistemicide,butchered by godless, spiritless brits and their students, who now boasts about hinduvta,a secular nationalist ideology
What a conversation!👏🏻
What eloquence!🤌🏻
The host does a commendable job by not at all cutting off the Professor even once.
Hope to watch more such enlightening content.
They will not cut off someone of their own tribe who speaks stuff which they want to promote. They will only try to cut off those with whose views they don’t agree with. That is the harsh truth!
ये भरे जवानी में बाल को सफेद करने का चलन बहुत बढ़ गया, लोग गहरे थिंकर समझते है😂😅
The Sanatana Hindutva is an umbrella which protects all the indigenous culture
What does secularism means in India ????
Treating a particular community as first class citizens through Haz Subsidy, Madrasa Education, Wakf Bord, Sariya Law, Unlawful Reservation for them along with treat all other communities as second class citizens !!!!!
Correct this is all done by congress but hindu still vote for congress
Secularism means India will be ruled by practical rational and religion will not dictate politics. Religion is best left for people to freely practice in their personal life.
@@mg.f.9023 then why give pakistan an Islamic countries to muslims and why we hindu didn't have our own hindu country???
@@Vhshjvbjbcch3457
Pakistan and countries that have made religion rule over politics have given a good example of self-destruction.
India has done better because we let science and rational lead us not priests, mullas, or Sadhus.
If we want to face China and be No1 we need Science, Rationale and Unity.
That is such a 'hit on the head,' statement, that nobody realises the underpinning intent as it is meant to be, and here we have the populace embrace the idea without a care. Very important to have these nuanced conversations thrown in for ppl to think about...
Why the Professor is critical of Parliament passing the amendment in 2005 that gave women right to ancestral property!?
Slave morality h apke m .......
She is another Arundhati Roy and Rpmila Thaper put together. She should go and live in Pakistan or Bangladesh.
Prof Dr.Menon🎉🎉🎉🎉
It’s truly refreshing to listen to Prof Menon ,such a thoughtful discussion .
this clown is still in the market 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
With a limited mindsets and didn't want to understand what is secularism and what is religion and its practices, all are talking on it.
Every one thinks he/she is on righteous path and practicing their religion.
Secularism means to understand and find the best solution to stop all evils. For this every individual should be enough matured to understand and accept the truth and live the bluffs created for personal benefits.
If this is true then why congress amend constitution nd made shariya a part of a constitution why
Where do I get this book
Though India remained Secular everything and everywhere had been dominated by chaturvarnas who were and are opposed to the very idea of ' Secularism ' ?.
Without ' Pluralism ' India has no existance ?.
@@NaughtySaint-kz8co India was never a Secular country and never will be. We mix religion in almost every aspect of our life whether one likes it or not.
@@kirchunetwork1986 secularism doesn't mean atheistic ..... Almost all empires here ere secular abt their policies..... Even most mughals.....muriyan Ashoka empire...and on..., our people like Ghandi and like to practice religion in their personal and social lives......but most not policy making and politics
@@areebanaveed9485 the very concept of Secularism evolved in the West to oppose interference of Church in the government.In India every ruler irrespective of their religion consulted the religious head when it came to policies. Nehru was the first head of the Nation who was truly Secular.
Wire The Liar, busy spreading anti-Hindu propaganda 😂
There is a lot of dishonesty here. I’m sure one can derive convoluted arguments for what the puranas say.. but other religions often quite explicitly state that other religions are wrong, and that they must be done away with. And they say so without needing spurious derivation. But that never figures in the discussion?
Hindu rastra is concept of bjp,when india is devide in pak and india,pak one nation is secular other relageous,it was heterogenic
Ye channel comment delete karta hai.
@@shubhambakshi2320then they are cowards and so is pro bjp channels.
No use of comment makers
Just satisfaction of egos.
Mine also same but the fun thing is i comment rarely and doesn't use bs words like others do .
No use of these talks.
Ground realities are entirely different what these various channels video present.
People want good governance and all political parties who are in power offers substandard governance.
India Bharat disappointed that political parties n its leaders let our country down
Its Mrs Menon 's Political Hypothesis ,,, Not political theory or practice
💯
POLITICS BY BJP RSS......furst it is hindu vs muslim....then it is OBC vs OBC...then it OBC vs SC ST....THEN it sc st vs scst.....that is structure OF CASTEISM and division......who BENEFITS..BRAMINS ...AND ONLY BRAMINS......PPL REALIZE
Metal people are hear to. .. .. .bjp poltics is only hindu. . . .. ..you people are who want to divid hindu. . .. ..and incaurage jihad
Stop spreading your lies. It is Congress and other opposition parties, of whom you are an agent, who are making all efforts to divide Hindus on the basis of caste. That is why they are asking for a caste census. The intent of your masters is to divide Hindus and create chaos across the country.
Interesting discussion, but her (critical) interpretation of the 2005 amendment that gave women right to ancestral property remains elusive. Also, interviewer should follow up with some good poking follow up questions
Then why don't u guys talk about too much illegal immigrants from Bangladesh now they live in india nd they spread all over in india 😢😢
When Akhand Bharat happens, you can have all the Bangladeshis inside India. Don't worry! 😅
Madams,india has nothing indigenous except perhaps poverty. Whatever india is today is
all the legacy of Mughals,British and West. A well researched thesis indeed.
Would legal pluralism justify Manusmriti?
Who has written Manusmriti? Do you know the author?
@@keyurpatel1982 that doesn’t matter? Who wrote Bible or Quran, no one can be certain. You surely must have heard of the phenomenon of ‘Shruti’.
Exceptionally enlightening and showing a new approach to the way we understand things around us and our past!
India was never Secular and never will be. Secularism which evolved in the West is the Practice of keeping religion out of Politics and public life.
One more assumption is there: that all religions don't say how to run a country on their holy scriptural practices.
Left mind set ladies😂😂😂
Hindu rashtra was a dream of famous Hindu King jaichand who invited Muhammad Ghori to India.
When will the Hindi version of Nivedita Menon's new book be available
If Sati practice being considered as cultural, religious right of a woman, would it be allowed? How could one read Ambedkar's view on Hindus but completely ignore his views on Hijab and Islam. Read Pakistan and Partition of India by Dr Ambedkar for his views on Islam and Indian muslims, one would surely baffled by his views on Hijab, Muslims regarding religion over nation, Non muslim rights etc
Thanks!
Dont call yourself independent media you are sold out.not just this video even for WB case where all are calling out mamta benerjee u are attacking centre by restricting it to a men-women issue
Yes, All media need to worship the PM.
Amazing discussion! Eye opener.
Land right of women is the need of the hour
There are two perspectives,one is that everyone and everything is homogeneous and another is everything is unique,one can give his entire life understanding yet wonder,respect and revere.The weak will always choose the former as his ego is the only shelter.
Love ,truth is bitter
Christianism +islamism +communism = pure sanatani grinha(Hindumisia)
Imperialism and colonialism through back door. and digitally remote controlled.
I couldn't determine whether the Puranic quest to integrate, assimilate, and overwhelm all marginalized communities with puritanical and hegemonic Brahminical values and norms has failed, or if the attempt to define Hinduness through the Hindu Code Bill-essentially based on modern, and of course, Western values such as gender equality, individual rights, and social justice-has faltered.
As long as there are traitors within the Hindu community that work, for their own petty self-interest, on the behalf of those outsiders who want to divide Hindus, the unity of Hindus will remain a tough task to complete.
Securalism is a modern, western project. It has its roots to catholic protestants demanding reformations. Bharat has always been a Hindu rashtra . All the people belonging to other religions are all converts. Bharat has been a safe haven for Jews and Parsis since millenias. If they never felt threatened, why would the 2nd largest majority feel any other way?
There are 56 muslim countries. Bharat has every right to declarr herself a Hindu rashtra. Btw: Hinduism is the only religion which preaches inclusivity and allows diversity. But, mutual respect from other religions has to be there for coexistence. Secularism doesnt mean hiding Hindu sentiments
Yes, Sanskari people like Brij Bushan, Prajwal Revanna will need to lead this Nation.
😂😂😂😂@@mg.f.9023
what is the deal for Adani in Malaysia?
❤❤❤👌✌✊✊✊✊✊
She herself seems to be confused.
If uniform civil code is a western concept or approach towards secularism then she should also understand that democracy itself is a western concept of forming a government.
She is very selectively taking the ideas to justify pluralistic approach.
That's her hypothesis. Other Professors are free to refute it.
This is what academics do.
I'm a big Modi fan.
I'm here to listen to what she has to say.
What you said is correct.
But we need a proper academic takedown of this.
Only then it is valid.
What you and I say on RUclips Comments section; nobody cares.
Especially, the Left Liberals.
They just cancel us.
Tell this to j sai depak
j sai deepak will cry for 3 days
So much misinformed argument due to not proper revision of scriptures, itihaas and puranas... Amazed by the heights of ignorance
She is arguing for decolonization through Ambedkarite framing. If I understood her correctly, she also argued for it in her reading of gender By challenging binary imagination Concerning womanhood. Cognising India is having multiple minorities is probably a good way to to bring the politics of disability to the forefront.
Could it be that the aim of the capitalist project goes beyond promotion of individual property rights to the very idea of individual rights itself?
What can be expected from the Wire .........do you have any same or not?.
Jahnavi is a competent anchor.
There should be open debate with her and Vivek agnihotri.
No, I prefer J Sai Deepak.
Vivek can't think and talk.
J sai deepak can't talk and stop.
This is your third class thinking
Yes First class thinking only by BJP people like Sanskari Brij Bushan, Prajwal Revanna and likes
@@mg.f.9023 mulayam singh jisne r*@pe ko bachcho se galti ho jaati hai bola , Moin Khan r@pist sp leader
Whether the constitution is a book of rules or a philosophical treatise?
Arayans,Braminical is not hinduism
Mahesvara puja is not demonical
Sages doing yogna why did they go to Assuras land and create problem
polyandry is there not myth
vilans against matriachal society
This country is a multiple minority
University is under attack by religious majority
Kitni badssurat he ye dono
When she will be arrested...?I will have a party 😂😂
Remember, as a Brahmin, you are in Minority in India, and Brahminvad is not Hindu religion or Hindutva. It's about time the Brahmins were punished for keeping India uneducated and using all the charity given for their personal well-being and not the Public good as other religions do.
Party Karlo , Pata chala ye mauka kabhi nahi milega.
@@pardeeptandonin that case no one is the majority in this country. Should minority rights be applied to Brhamins? Is Deoband a minority, or Bairalvi a minority, Shia, Ahl-e-haddis, Khoja, Ahmadiyyas part of small groups... Who is the majority then?
@@FreddieMurphy746@FreddieMurphy746: All Communities in India are minorities. That is why the founders of our constitution gave us a secular constitution, as they were aware that the Hindu religion was artificially created by the Britishers for their Administrative ease.
We are all Indians first and then anything else. The government can give special rights to backward communities. These rights can not be given to Brahmina as they today enjoy hegemony on country resources.
@@pardeeptandon Then Articles that give Minority privileges should be taken off. Minority educational institutions should adhere to normal policies. Temples that are mostly in govt's control should be freed just like Mosques and Churches
Is she still teaching at jnu ?
It's a fascist project.
Hindu Rashtra matalab Brahmin Rashtra ✅
@@errahulmali7486 wrong!
@@bharatpandit4796 yes, you're
ചിന്ത യാകന്നു വിജ്ഞാനം അതുകൊണ്ട് ഹിന്ദു രാഷ്ട്രം അതിലൂടെ ഓരോരുത്തരും ഇവിടെ വന്നു ചിന്ദനം ചെയ്തു മനസ്സ് ശുദ്ധി കൊണ്ട് മടങ്ങുക അതു തന്നെ അല്ലെ ജീവിതം
Correct. I'm also of the same opinion. I quit Hindu thanks to sangparivar after learning what is a hindu
Good for u....U suit well to be a Chapraasi of Periyaar😅
@@kishandubey7882correctly said Hindi people are the best
these people look very evil
A technical but insightful and enlightening interview. Thanks a ton 👍🙏
Who cares when BJP supports such ppl in states where they are in majority role
West Bengal CM should resign
what about cases in Delhi, UP, Bihar and now Maharashtra- Reason BJP Ruling states
Ram Rahim on back to back parole- Haryana CM- BJP
Why they are not ensuring women security at India Level- Women are also part of India
Such a wonderful discussion.. kudos to learned professor 🎉🎉🎉 and very impressive and intelligent journalist whose done her homework well 👏 👍 👌
Sitting in Vienna 😂😂❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Would like to know what is her opinion on consanguine marriage
Sorry...don't understand your language. Please use simple language so that common man can understand and relate to.
What is true secularism ???
According to Wire promoting a particular majhab which teach good and humanitarian teaching as jihad, jizya tax, maal-e-ganimat, gazwa-e-hind is only secularism !!!!!
baap or bhai dejej v dega or property v dega jang hojayega,isi lia the father must have right to decide to whome it want to transfer thats capitalism
Hun right man
Yes secular Uniform civil code is hindu right wing ideology
Four varnas is the agenda
Musalman already took separate homeland for themselves and so India should be only for non-musalman communities.
Nationalism ko haraya nhi jaa sakta ....apko history accept karna hi padega ..... koi upay nhi h
Nationalism led by Sanskari Brij Bushan, Prjwal Revanna and likes
Nivedita Menon is absolutely correct.
As opposed to the leftists?
An extensive discussion on the book. Enjoyed.Thanks both to the author and interviewer,
Secularism word hmare savidhan mein nhi tha baba sahab ambedkar ji ne savidhan mein secular word nhi likha tha ye congress thi jisne Muslims kk khush karne k liye bharat k anpadh Hinduo ke sath dhoka kiya jabki muslims ko 2 Islamic desh de diye
Word Equality toh hai constitution mein..??
@@MkpSingh21 bt secularim to nhi h or savidhan mein minorities ka samrakchan likha hai unka haq hi hai bharat m ek samaan ye baba sahab ne nhi likha tha ye kaam ghatia congress n kiya muslims ko 2 desh bhi de diye yha bhi bhar liya barabar se jyada ka haq diya lekin hinduo ko kya mila
@@MkpSingh21You are not equal to yourself on two different days so what equality you expect in the society at large?
Nice interview 😊
Jawaharlal Nehru and Mohandas Gandhi allowed them, who demanded and achieved separate homeland for themselves, to stay in India with not only with equal rights but also with special rights as religious minorities only for providing them sufficient opportunity to create a few more Pakistan and even make India a bigger Pakistan.
100% correct currently Assam Kerala Bengal half pakistan ban gye h
Hindu khatre mein modi ke aanesey since 2014 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
7:52
It's diluting critical thought of global south by again looking at global south from Western or global North context context.
Dear Wire, don't u have any other topic than communal conflict.
Hindu rashtra is a need of hour in india
so says Sanskari Brij Bushan, Prajwal Revanna...
Hindu Rashtra ❎ Brahmin Rashtra✅
Modi is a Brahmin
Yogi is a Brahmin
Rama is a Brahmin
Krishna is a Brahmin 😂
@@user-rg7jt4xp9y Modi is bania, Yogi Is Rajput, Gadkari is Brahmin, Nadda is Brahmin, Nirmala Tai is Brahmin. BJP 👉 ब्राह्मण बनिया राजपूत जनता पार्टी 🙏 Ram & Krishna Mythological Characters jo brahmin ko aage jhuke ke rahate hai🙏
@@errahulmali7486 What about Kovind? What about Murmu?
Well, what about Rahul Gandhi?
And what about CPM Sitaram Yechury? Especially, what about Ambedkar's wife?
You gonna hate on all of them?
Rahul is also a Brahmin will this make the congress Brahmin party? @@errahulmali7486
Adivasi oil lagao baal kale karo
Excellent video. Please make more of these!!
Go to hel g🎉🎉- haddis
No groundswell of support for Hindu rastra? Are you sure?If it is true that all most all political changes in any country are driven by the urban middle class,then Hindurastra has big support by the Hindu urban middle class.A survay would be the right thing to ascertain.
Elections are different things,There are hundred other considerations other than Hindutwa or secularism for the ppl to vote.Even then 30-35% vote share for BJP is a given thing.
*India is dangerously close to the Hindutwa project*
(Kerala,TN may miss that beat)
lol 😂
Very interesting, explained in a very simple way.