The layer-by-layer layout is better for someone with little to no redstone knowledge, someone who just wants to build the door with no fuss. But for someone like myself who has the knowledge to understand it, I want to see it built by circuit in parts. I want to see how it works, and the awesome work arounds you used to make it work.
Both types of tutorials have their pros and cons. - Circuit by circut helps to better understand the contraption and appreciate how it works, and in my experience it requires less editing. - Layer by layer, on the other hand, it's much easier to follow since you stop the video and you see everything. It's easier to build everything - you don't have to squeeze between the components. But you have no idea what is for what.
I prefer layer by layer. It's kinda like 3D printing the door, and I like it. Plus, you get to see more of it at a time than normal tutorials, I think.
I just wanted to say, thank you for making this exact door! I've been wanting to make a spiral 3x3 piston door for a while, but I'm bad at redstone so I couldn't design it myself. I love how it's so fast while also being a perfect spiral, it just looks so nice. Much appreciated!
lmao just returned to this channel after 3 years. I did not expect your style to change completely lol. I do enjoy this more polished, edited format tho.
Hey purple , i really like your channel , and i've been a fan for a long time . I'm doing redstone as well but i got to a point witch many people would call the soft cap . Its getting harder and harder to get better , and i think you would make a great teacher . What do you think about making tutorials on circuits , and how to connect them . My biggest issue right now is that i cant make the input , i can make every part of the contraption , but it gets really big when i connect them . I would love to see a very good redstoner like yourself explain these things . Thank you for reading this far !
Have you considered redoing this design with the new Copper Bulb? It provides a much smaller 1-tick delay, which may make this kind of delay between pistons easier.
give a man a fish and you feed him for a day [layer by layer tutorial] teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime [explanation tutorial] these explanation style vids are great, i normally never stick around for the tutorial [even though i probably should], but the editing keeps things very watchable throughout. I like to play around with slime and honey, and i find random parts of your vids to be applicable in the doors i build. imo redstone is saturated by people targetting the "newb" audience, so your vids are a breath of fresh air in a sea of 3x3 tutorials, good stuff!
2:30 Translates to redstone man 2:38 translates to purple dragon nuke starring 2:43 translates to Written by Purple Dragon Core 2:48 translates to Google translated by Purple Dragon Core
U r a hero. This will definitely work as safe door for our storage room! As the smp server that I played has a plug in where it give speed boost to mob and player who step on path glass and it happened a lot of time where creeper speedrun behind my friends to blow up in storage and have lost a lot of goods we prepared to sell to other city ;-;
the block on the bottom middle of the door blocks just wont retract when the door is opened, so I fixed the design by connecting the piston responsable for that retraction with 4 observers to the one tick repeater on the second layer that is more close to the front side of the door
Step by step tutorial: - Hard to follow for beginners - For people who understand redstone, easier to understand how it works Layered tutorial: - Easy to follow - Hard to understand how the mechanism works
2:28 random 赤い石の男 (red stone's man) oh... and it continues... 紫のドラゴン核兵器演 (purples dragon nuke(?)) 紫のドラゴン核によって書かれた (written by purples dragon core (?)) 紫のドラゴン核によって翻訳されたグーグル (translated by purples dragon core (?)) (and no, it doesn't match with the song) what am i doing at 1:07 am?
@@konnihayohare_ty ok now i understand! Its because he used google translator as he wrote in the last piece xD GoogleTranslatorを使ったから翻訳はおかしいんだ コンニの英語はすばらしいですよ
To me “best” is the combination of being not just fast, but also “small” (relative to the door/redstone). (I know this door exists because it’s faster and that’s fine I just prefer the first door because it’s good enough for me)
It does work in 1.18, but for some reason it fails the first time after converting the world from 1.16 to 1.18, really weird :/ I'll change the world download to include saves for both versions
I know that this is probably the most OCD thing to pick up on, but in the video you mention how you must use an iron pressure plate - I'm just wondering, what happens if you use a gold one instead? Don't they both output the desired ss? Sorry about the OCD I'm actually just genuinely curious and I'm also currently too frustrated with redstone to build this rn (sorry I'm a lazy ass) :P
Nope, leaves placed by a player have an NBT tag that that stops them from decaying :> Also, even if they were naturally generated leaves, I don't think it would be possible for them to decay; the log is pushed down instantly, and finishes getting pulled up after 3 game ticks. I don't know the specifics of leaf decay, but I think there's a lower limit on how quickly leaves can disappear, and so the movement speed of the log would be too quick for them to ever decay.
I like layer tutorials but i prefer circuit tutorials because i can see the repeter tics better and i can understand it better. Also, the door is broken in the latest version… (just so you know)😅
Imagine showing this wiring to a redstoner in 2014
Imagine telling a redstoner in 2014 that 8 years later people would’ve used leaves in redstone doors.
@@Brubri1234 armor stands and boats in redstone doors lol
@@Brubri1234 bruh what are the composters doing there? lol
@@matheusdardenne comparators can read them and it make kind of an upwards moving power source cus you can’t use a redstone block
@@tyronium2 the question was rhetorical but thanks for the explanation. Interesting concept.
The layer-by-layer layout is better for someone with little to no redstone knowledge, someone who just wants to build the door with no fuss.
But for someone like myself who has the knowledge to understand it, I want to see it built by circuit in parts. I want to see how it works, and the awesome work arounds you used to make it work.
Some builds also can't be done layer by layer
Same
Are you still playing on xbox ?
me too
i was almost blackout sleep deprivation and still managed to build this, layer by layer is fire 🔥
Both types of tutorials have their pros and cons.
- Circuit by circut helps to better understand the contraption and appreciate how it works, and in my experience it requires less editing.
- Layer by layer, on the other hand, it's much easier to follow since you stop the video and you see everything. It's easier to build everything - you don't have to squeeze between the components. But you have no idea what is for what.
these videos are increasing severly in quality. I love this new video format: its funny, clear and a feast for the eyes!
crafty and this guy have god tier editing
yeah i know 1440p is very nice but it needs good internet though
That's one s3x3y door
agreed
Dude only 1 response after 2 years. finaly a second one
@@WolfGubbelmans yes
Yo crafty wanna be friends I'm subbed and I joined your discord
This is so cool. First redstone video I've watched in a while - thank you for transporting me back to those days. Keep being you, Purple 👊
Ells :o
yo i remember your staircase vid back in the day
I prefer layer by layer. It's kinda like 3D printing the door, and I like it. Plus, you get to see more of it at a time than normal tutorials, I think.
also super easy in survival lol
Also way simpler, because I do NOT do redstone
dude made an anime opening for a piston door
YES I WAS LOOKING FOR A COMMENT ABOUT THAT
I just wanted to say, thank you for making this exact door! I've been wanting to make a spiral 3x3 piston door for a while, but I'm bad at redstone so I couldn't design it myself. I love how it's so fast while also being a perfect spiral, it just looks so nice. Much appreciated!
lmao just returned to this channel after 3 years. I did not expect your style to change completely lol. I do enjoy this more polished, edited format tho.
Hey purple , i really like your channel , and i've been a fan for a long time . I'm doing redstone as well but i got to a point witch many people would call the soft cap . Its getting harder and harder to get better , and i think you would make a great teacher . What do you think about making tutorials on circuits , and how to connect them . My biggest issue right now is that i cant make the input , i can make every part of the contraption , but it gets really big when i connect them . I would love to see a very good redstoner like yourself explain these things . Thank you for reading this far !
Your content is increasing in quality at a frightening rate
love the new vids!! :D
Great door
Great video
Have you considered redoing this design with the new Copper Bulb? It provides a much smaller 1-tick delay, which may make this kind of delay between pistons easier.
Obviously this isn't a comment on the design, this was released well before the Copper Bulb existed in snapshots
welp
give a man a fish and you feed him for a day [layer by layer tutorial]
teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime [explanation tutorial]
these explanation style vids are great, i normally never stick around for the tutorial [even though i probably should], but the editing keeps things very watchable throughout. I like to play around with slime and honey, and i find random parts of your vids to be applicable in the doors i build.
imo redstone is saturated by people targetting the "newb" audience, so your vids are a breath of fresh air in a sea of 3x3 tutorials, good stuff!
「赤い石の男」翻訳感あって良き
Steveee: For Me?
I think layer by layer is better for the complicated contraptions like this while the usual tutorials are better for smaller doors and such
oh my god the anime opening absolutely killed me.
2:30 Translates to redstone man
2:38 translates to purple dragon nuke starring
2:43 translates to Written by Purple Dragon Core
2:48 translates to Google translated by Purple Dragon Core
Easily best redstone tutorial ive ever seen the layer by layer layout is great
Now this is the ACTUAL perfect spiral 3x3!
Edit: Also cool "anime intro" 😆 LOL
U r a hero. This will definitely work as safe door for our storage room! As the smp server that I played has a plug in where it give speed boost to mob and player who step on path glass and it happened a lot of time where creeper speedrun behind my friends to blow up in storage and have lost a lot of goods we prepared to sell to other city ;-;
amazing door, well done
tho purple dragon isnt purple anymore :p
I like the layer tut
One of the best thing about this channel is the chapters, not many people use them but they're so good for navigation
layer-by-layer seems easier to build! Which is good.
But circuit by circuit makes it easier to understand.
This vid is great.
A litematic is fine for builds of this complexity imo.
wished it was forge though, only fabric
I Love it with the layers
loved the anime part
He: tutorial
Me who knows redstone: am quitting
*"赤い石の男"*
*"紫のドラゴン核兵器出演"*
*"紫のドラゴン核によって書かれた"*
*"紫のドラゴン核によって翻訳されたグーグル"*
Excellence in both redstone and cinematography.
Luckily there is now a one gametick delay the copper bulb
until there isn't :(
@@rabbitfish1078 yeah I know :(
the block on the bottom middle of the door blocks just wont retract when the door is opened, so I fixed the design by connecting the piston responsable for that retraction with 4 observers to the one tick repeater on the second layer that is more close to the front side of the door
Found the problem. Layer 12: The left repeater must be 2 ticks
@@jesper94782 or twelve as both have sand in the layer
I'm mad RUclips took more than a year to recommend this to me.
It's normally really good but somehow I missed this legendary vid.
Very fun video, nice tutorial, great quality. Amazing job
Step by step tutorial:
- Hard to follow for beginners
- For people who understand redstone, easier to understand how it works
Layered tutorial:
- Easy to follow
- Hard to understand how the mechanism works
The layer by layer is amazing. wish more youtubers did them.
Bro you are so underrated
these layer by layer tutorials are absolutely wonderful :D keep on doing them
I found you via Sipover's video and that japanese anime section was endlessly hilarious for me.
layer by layer is much easier for building without making a mistake that you'd need to figure out down the line
Idk if it’s broken or if I just built it incorrectly, idk im not even mad I still love it been watching you since the old name dragon 💀 much love
With the carpet mod (cactus can turn blocks) the layer by layer style is verry easy to follow.
Just Finished after 45 mins of hard work, and it freaking failed
It doesn't work for me : ( maybe it's human error but I tried 3 times already, maybe it's the version or something.
Incredible work! Just happened to come across this video! Glad some people from the old days of CK are still busy redstoning!
Best door I ever seen. Keep going Purplers.👍
I loved the way how you showed how to build the door so i subscribe
2:30 from a normal redstone video to an anime opening
I hope this video not be stolen!
doesnt work for me , i tried 4 times and made no mistakes
Nvm it was of the redstone gap 70.
The last door needed 2 stacks almost 3 stacks of cobblestone. This one needs so much more with more pistons and observers.
2:28 random 赤い石の男 (red stone's man)
oh... and it continues...
紫のドラゴン核兵器演 (purples dragon nuke(?))
紫のドラゴン核によって書かれた (written by purples dragon core (?))
紫のドラゴン核によって翻訳されたグーグル (translated by purples dragon core (?))
(and no, it doesn't match with the song)
what am i doing at 1:07 am?
@@konnihayohare_ty what parts?
@@konnihayohare_ty wait. so you are not happy with purplers translations or mine?
@@konnihayohare_ty ok now i understand!
Its because he used google translator as he wrote in the last piece xD
GoogleTranslatorを使ったから翻訳はおかしいんだ
コンニの英語はすばらしいですよ
damn, the amount of dedication this requires is insane
Me: “You should make red stone Java AND Bedrock friendly”
Purplers: “NOO”
Still genuinely confused if this is your voice or the TTS narrator man.
Lmfao that anime theme song part
Wow I just discovered the best minecraft redstone channel of all youtube today I think!
Oh my god this layer by layer thing is the best
copper bulb boutta make this way more compact
Wow, dude, that amazing
With all of the 1-tick differences, I bet the new copper lamp would make this a lot easier and smaller.
3:04 “Leavestone”
? its a real thing he said it correct
@@sawyerdadino I don’t recall Leavestone being a thing
you were missing 41 blocks, 1 target block, 1 slab, 1 comparator, 1 button, 1 armor stand, and 11 pumpkin pie
To me “best” is the combination of being not just fast, but also “small” (relative to the door/redstone). (I know this door exists because it’s faster and that’s fine I just prefer the first door because it’s good enough for me)
love your content man!
Putting subtitles in the song had the spoiler of usin leafblocks and scaffloding
I love the layer by layer pls do more layer by layer
Wow your voice has gotten deeper
I guess this only works on 1.16.5, I tried on 1.18.1 and it was a no-go. Still very impressive work.
It does work in 1.18, but for some reason it fails the first time after converting the world from 1.16 to 1.18, really weird :/
I'll change the world download to include saves for both versions
@@Purplers oh okay, weird! thanks :)
I know that this is probably the most OCD thing to pick up on, but in the video you mention how you must use an iron pressure plate - I'm just wondering, what happens if you use a gold one instead? Don't they both output the desired ss?
Sorry about the OCD I'm actually just genuinely curious and I'm also currently too frustrated with redstone to build this rn (sorry I'm a lazy ass) :P
incredible, keep it up
i want a 11 by 11 spiral door design that can be adapted to cover any door size
The anime intro was sick my guy
Nice build, you lost at your third comment about your "ocd" tho :c
This is perfect!
3:48 I don't see the top piston update the bottom one upon finishing extension after 3gt, why does that happen?
This hurt my brain and I love it!
layer-by-layer tutorial mess me around because sometimes i forget to place some redstone on the layers
Is there any possibility the leaves will decay while the log is in motion as an pushed/pulled entity?
Nope, leaves placed by a player have an NBT tag that that stops them from decaying :> Also, even if they were naturally generated leaves, I don't think it would be possible for them to decay; the log is pushed down instantly, and finishes getting pulled up after 3 game ticks. I don't know the specifics of leaf decay, but I think there's a lower limit on how quickly leaves can disappear, and so the movement speed of the log would be too quick for them to ever decay.
Purple can you to make a 3x3 spiral flush door?
I don't even care all that much about redstone doors but the video was amazing :D
most tragic anime 10/10
Block event delay separator spiral door when
This is so satisfying. 14 year old me would've lost his mind. Yet even today I probably will end up building this in survival lol
I like layer tutorials but i prefer circuit tutorials because i can see the repeter tics better and i can understand it better.
Also, the door is broken in the latest version… (just so you know)😅
My favorite part was the idek
great job!
Yep, it's really fast
But what's the point of a door having a spiral animation if you almostar can't see it? 🤔
Right bottom near the redstone door, the target block is changed to wool block??
Layer by layer is the best way
The faster the worse it looks still cool
so i've got to ask now
how much smaller can this get with the copper bulb? 👀
It doesn’t work..
c l e a n
Who sang this anime song for this video?
now 1.21 snapshot experiments have copper bulb which activate in 1 game tick
the song is fun XD