I am a nurse n I totally agree with you... you r 200% right....this is really disgusting....when I was in private hospital i advised many patients to go to government hospital...the problem is lots of private hospitals owned by politicians
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
Could relate to each and every fact stated in the video. I lost my younger brother from dengue in 2017. He was admitted in Regency a multi-speciality hospital in Kanpur, he was admitted there for near about 15 days. After being the hospital for four days, his condition started improving but all of a sudden they said he would need to go on ventilator for 2 days, there is nothing to worry about, its just the matter of two days. But after two days, they kept on saying that they would observe him for one more day on ventilator. This went on for near about 8 days and then my brother who was just 11 years old, left us forever. They only allowed us to meet him twice a day for five minutes only. He left us when no one was with him, it still breaks my heart that no one was with him when he was in pain, when he was leaving us. We were helpless, we were charged around rupees 12 lac. It wasn't just about the money, it was the false hopes that they gave us by putting him on ventilator. Whenever we said that we would take him to some other hospitals, the doctors started warning us that its risky get him somewhere else being on the ventilator. I wish we would have not listened to them, sometimes we feel like we could save him if we would have not listened to them, because they only let us meet him twice, he was just 11 years who needed his mother beside him, who could him strength to fight that battle, but they didn't allow. Its been six years since he left us, but still not a single day has passed that we don't remember him.😭
I am so sorry for your loss.. It's a heartbreaking thing which happened.. I can feel ur pain..they r monsters this medical mafia..poor kid.. I am a mother too... May God give ur family lots of strength and happiness in the future.. What happened to ur family was a nightmare.. Sending u my wishes
I could never understand the loss that you're going through. Reading about your experince...when youre brother was on the vent it is advisable to not shift him anywhere else as there a lot of things that could go wrong during the process. And im thinking youre brother was kept in isolation at the ICU so its natural that they dont allow visitors because those are sterile spaces and they need to be maintained the same. But idk the entire story so I cannot comment any further. They should've taken proper consent from you for the procedures being done. About the false hope part I didn't understand. Ventilator isn't false hope. It's a devise to assist in oxygen delivery when the body is failing to do so. And yes intubating pt. Comes with risks. But the good it does far outweighs the risks.
Billing is done by the hospitals not by the doctors. They both are separate entities. Doctors take an oath and they abide by it. Corporates don't have an oath. A doctor does everything in his power to abide by his oath. People have really got to stop blaming doctors without knowing all the facts.
@@charuvikram9786 Before the day, he left us, the doctors all of a sudden started complying with the fact that yes we could take him wherever we want and then in morning he left us.
@@charuvikram9786 things started make sense after I watched the video where Aditya mentioned that modern hospitals work like a corporate world where doctors are given targets to be achieved within the stipulated time. I understand the fact that everyone is not the same, but even the politicians take oath to carry on their duty honestly but does it ever happen, in fact they are the most corrupt officials in the country. Hence, taking an oath is no guarantee that a person is honest.
I support your work, you have done a good job in bringing this issue to limelight. Last month a private hospital charged us 3K for treating viral fever using paracetamol, the treatment lasted for 35 min 😢
As a physiotherapist I used to work in a private hospital in Ahmedabad. The management of that hospital put lot of pressure on me to generate revenue. In the end, I had to leave that hospital because that hospital belonged to a politician.
Why so apologetic, you don't over bill patients, if at all hospitals do. And at the end of the day these are for profile organizations. P.s : also a doctor
@K&R Thanks for acknowledging the fact and realising the corrupt system... I do have huge respect for doctors, but there are some doctors who encash from this corrupt system. I do understand that being in the system and not follow its norms might be difficult but encouraging corruption is not the right choice !!
Why they are greedy sir ? Reservation, high education fees and too much of pressure, tell me kya koi aur profession me nai hota ye ? Doctors ko bas blame karna hoga then why doctors won't start being inhuman if they hv to face inhuman bhv by people ?
I have a fantastic solution for this issue. In the United States, credit card owners have certain protection rights, such as the ability to initiate a chargeback. A chargeback, also referred to as a dispute, allows the bank that issued your credit card to reclaim funds from the retailer's (hospital) bank when you don't satisfied with the services you paid for. This process includes penalties imposed on the retailer's(hospital) bank.
Lost my brother yesterday, 30 days on ventilator, body weight gone to 25 kgs only for a 18 year old boy. some insiders told us that case was of only 2 days, but they stretched the treatment to 30-40 days to loot our hard earned money, they charged 20 lakhs and hand over the dead body. Please share this video so that the government get pressurized and no body in future go through this situation. This case was of RHL hospital, jaipur This is the story of every hospital. The whole hospital industry is so bad that we have only two safe options either stay healthy or die at home only.
Why you haven't shifted patient to sawai mann singh, which is goverment hospital there. So u r fool enough to get looted it means. Your loss is not replaceable but no one forced you to stay
@@drpediatrica1692after 3 days in sms he was reffered to private hospital from sms only, these both public and private institutes have cons only. We have no way to go to
Sorry for your loss brother , but aap hi socho , practicing Medicine is all about taking chance , a doctor , takes chance on the patient's diseased condition based on his knowledge of lifetime , he is there to try , and boy , sometimes your body needs time to get repaired and get rid of a disease , and if u also come to hospital in a bad situation a doctor's job is to get the disease eliminated if possible or atleast extend your life
That is why I take care of my health so much and not eat outside food which full of Cancer and tumour generating, little fever can be defeated by immunity so no need to go to hospital. Believe me I live Hyderabad City and it's totally terrible because bad people are almost everywhere
@@RebelBong ok if I start explaining it will be 10page essay but in very short it's same like what diamond manufacturers did in last century to artificial inflate the price of diamonds
Whatever the story that doesn't give anyone Right To focus on profit rather than the patient...And about background.... every Post graduate for private will support this why? Bexoz they Spend in crores....after that they will not think about patients they only think about Profit
@@srishtiarmaanianasha6253 life is not this simple, you can start living life like fundamentalist but after some time you will also agree that life is grey not white and black
I have experience of a small private hospital of Bengaluru where they charged Rs 4000 for a mere stitching of and bandage of a finger !!......no need for your explanation private hospital and schools are being run by money mafia it's already known to all .
True. I faced this issue when my 1 year old son got admitted. The hospital overcharged and even put a cannula in my baby's hand which was not needed at all. There are many greedy and immoral people in the medical community. I had to fight for my son out of there.
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer. They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
Very few people have courage to make such type of video... whatever he told is damm true... Including management, many paramedical staffs and doctors are involved in this Nexus. I visited a pvt. hospital for diarrhoea treatment. They wrote chest X-ray and Full body Sonography as diagnostic test. I denied but they did it and found nothing in report. Overall i got the bill of 8K just for 2 days in hospital. They nurses unnecessary wasted the saline. They asked us to bring 500 ml of NS but they used only 200 ml. Rest of the amount was trashed in dustbin. Same thing happen for some other medicine also. From that day i lose the respect for health care workers. It was bad experience but its true.. Apart, I respect those doctor's or staff who work honestly.
Pharma,DRS , Government all are responsible for this The way you have explained is absolute correct Every DRS attached to a private hospital has their Target minimum number of patients should be admitted Pathology , xray, sonography,MRI , everywhere commission False treatment , going for false transplant In Pune this happens very frequently all private Hospital included I am one of the victims I even worked in a Pharma company for 28 yrs Still be lotted Excellent information from you Aditya
भ्रष्ट देश के भ्रष्ट इकोसिस्टम मे भ्रष्टाचार ही बिजनेस का आधार है चाहे वो प्राइवेट स्कूल हो प्राइवेट क्लिनिक हो प्राइवेट अस्पताल हो या फिर हायर एंड फायर वाली प्राइवेट नौकरी
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer. They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
This is true. In hospital 10% discount on Antibiotic injection. In market 40% discount. When per day medicine bill greater than 10000 it's affecting lot
Me is back on time without late 👍🇮🇳 Aditya Saini back to Expose the Dark reality of hospital Industry Mafia 😡📈🧡 Me any Audience likes his content and Engage in his clear Explanations and also salute to his research ,efforts and dedication 👍❤🔥
We need to have many more hospitals so that there is competition and plenty of doctors. Need to educate people as well. If there are many doctors and hospitals, these problems can get overcome. Govt should create many more AIIMS in every state and spend more on healthcare.. But this is all just we can only think of.
No my friend, this is already going on, government already increased MBBS, and PG seats, each MLA or his relative owned Medical college. So in few yrs you will find MBBS doctor, like engineers. Yes but with poor knowledge
@@nitinkumarprajapati5257es only the good experience doc will survive , and you can check in newly construct clg there is no modern machinery nothing no technology, so it's like the btech only the top one survive and the lower one berozgar
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer. They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
I got heart surgery in Delhi gov hospital with nominal charges. same Odisa, Rajasthan is also progressing in better health care system. hope all state will work on medical and education .
I have gone through financials of some of the listed hospitals. OPM% OVER 10yrs range Aster DM Health care - 6% to 17% apollo hospitals - 10% to 16% max healthcare - 7 to 21% fortis healthcare - -26% to 19% if prices are over inflated why are the margins low. compare with IT Companies TCS - 26% TO 31% - never below 10% infosys - 24 to 32% please let us know at what OPM% should hospitals do business.
@@ragnarlothbrok918 you worked hard but you know yourself ki iit graduate package....so if you already know the reality about salary before choosing this profession you shouldn't complain naa ... and If want to earn more do super specialisation or work hard get radiology seat you will definitely earn
It's really scary that we have no option during emergencies despite knowing all this. Health care has become s scam, no more a service and there are still some self less doctors to this day who charge a minimal amount. Empathy should be taught in medical schools but what can we expect, when they count everything with money!?. I request Aditya Saini make a video on less medical colleges throughout the country, that makes medicine a dream for underprivileged students...
Kindly check recent Medical college data, you will find there is tremendously increase in medical college, but with poor quality education, mostly owned by politicians and his family. In few yrs you will find MBBS doctor like engineers, and with extremely poor knowledge.
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer. They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
Teaching empathy to doctors will provide no solutions, bcoz these scams are controlled by owners and top management people of the hospitals, out of which hardly 5-10% include doctors (mostly there are having connections or are extremely senior). Rest 90% doctors don't have any control over all these profits. Politicians and businessmen sitting at the top of hospital management are heading these scams and unfortunately no one is going to do anything against them, as they aren't soft targets 😌 So the problem is actually very deep rooted.
@@nitinkumarprajapati5257MBBS is already getting saturated in our country and with so many private colleges where people enter just by paying hefty amounts and of course extreme reservation allowing substandard candidates entry to the field, MBBS is no longer a field of only meritorious students, the quality is coming down year after year. And even among those, a good portion choose to leave the country in search of better monetary returns and a better lifestyle. And guess what who are ones who leave? The good ones, the below average ones will any way not get entry into developed countries...
Hospitals do alot of overcharging. ₹2000 for xray. ₹8000 for bed 🛏️ and 3 times medication ₹1240 per day for 2 weeks. got looted of a whopping ₹1.2 lakh 🤬🤬
@AashishTelgote-zx4wp ha Bhai tera free me illaz kar dega tum unka family sambhal dega kya bsdk hospital ka bhi kharch hota wo sab kaha se dega , license salary instruments building rent
My mother is a bp patient we had to travel 150 km for her treatment from a specified doctor who had also a lot of experience but they charged a lot of money everytime we visit their then we switched to a doctor who lived nearby and had almost 3/4th experience of the previous one he cut down the numbers of medicine and changed all medicines with new one and now she is doing well
1) Who is telling you to go to private hospital for treatment if it's expensive just go to govt hospital 2) when u enter private hospital the consultation and admission chargers are well explained to relative after that when patient and relative agree with that then only treatment is started no body forces u to do that. 3) No private hospital can force you to buy medicine or do diagnostic test in there premises the patient is free to do wherever he wants. 4) and if you think the dr has advised extra test Or medicine patient can cross check with any other dr which is known to them.
Here in Odisha the government truly provides the best healthcare facilities within minimal fees or i may say almost free and along with the HEALTHCARD for farmers, its very rare for being a victim of scams but i agree that the problem still continues (Mostly among middle class people who can neither afford such private hospitals nor avail the govt schemes)
Hello, Aditya please go through this comment carefully, speaking as a doctor practicing in corporate. Answering as in order of your points. 1. There is a lot of difference between hospitals and doctors. Doctors did not over-bill, the hospital did. These are two separate entities. 2. If the government wishes they can regulate the MRP of drugs and consumables. 3. Relatives are almost always told about the critical condition of their patients. 4. Before putting on the ventilator, consent is obtained (unless it's an emergency when there is no time to do so) 5. Doctors earn way less than their age counterparts in other fields. 6. Profit from consumables and drugs has to compensate for the entire nursing staff and supporting staff. 7. If people choose to get admitted in private hospitals, they are told beforehand about the per day cost. I feel there is a lot of bias against doctors earning which is unfair. I respect your content and have been an avid viewer but I really think you should put both sides of the story. If you want to discuss further I'm open to dialogue.
I agree people are so dumb in comment section they r hating the profession of drs they don't know how much hardwork and years it takes to be a Dr and then what u get less salary and less respect by society😢
People who can make their own openion by analysing the facts often don't comment but the one who easily get influenced by any random video of post surely comment to satisfy themself. And don't see that the subject of video or post is a particular case or hospital or a few, instead generalise the argument and write irrational things about the profession
I have seen such hate towards doctors and private hospitals and along with these kinds of ill inform videos where deliberately hospitals and doctors use interchangeably. I feel i should just leave the profession and probably just start selling liquor, cigarettes where there are high margins and not so much hate. A for-profit organization has its nature fixed in a capitalist economy. Why not question your MLA or MP why not ask them to fix government health care. Or just to hell with everything and just nationalise all private hospitals. Let's have a NHS like system and let's see how we function. Private health care is not a right it's a privilege. 😢😢
@@vic4883 I have seen such hate towards doctors and private hospitals and along with these kinds of ill inform videos where deliberately hospitals and doctors use interchangeably. I feel i should just leave the profession and probably just start selling liquor, cigarettes where there are high margins and not so much hate. A for-profit organization has its nature fixed in a capitalist economy. Why not question your MLA or MP why not ask them to fix government health care. Or just to hell with everything and just nationalise all private hospitals. Let's have a NHS like system and let's see how we function. Private health care is not a right it's a privilege. 😢😢
very imp topic ......rakshak he bhakshk ban gae hai ......gov ko bahut strict action lene chaye ....nahi to gareeb ko kcuh nahi milne wala even middle class sab luta deta hai in hospitals me .....gov ko price tag karna chaye na
These are not the only way. In private hospitals patients are treated by non modern medicine practitioners like bhms bams etc to reduce their cost. It is necessary to take initiative to make Id with proper registration numbers so that people can find who are treating them using proper identification apps to atleast verify they are not treated by quacks
@@ragnarlothbrok918 bro I'm too an mbbs doctor. When it's upto admitting a patient they risk a patient on the hands of non modern medicine practitioners. But when it comes to medico legal activities or when then sense danger they need a MBBS holder registration number and if something goes wrong then refer to closest Government medical College or hospital.
@@ragnarlothbrok918 it's the fault of the government. They are keen on increasing mbbs seats but not on taking these passouts back in the government system. They don't want to develop government facilities and want to develop private hospitals to collect more revenue. The solution are 1) increase government doctors seats 2) develop infrastructure 3) keep track records on private hospitals expenses and bills 4) impose heavy penalties or cancel licences of such private hospitals found guilty of hiring quacks, charging higher prices, taking advantage of mediclaim etc 5) ensure ima or nmc approved I'd cards with number and photo Id to ensure a quack free system
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer. They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
I LOST MY FATHER DURING COVID 19 PANDAMIC 2021 . MY FATHER ALSO ADMITED IN SHREE RAM PRIVATE HOSPITAL IN JODHPER .Private hospitals used to ask to take medicines only from their hospital, they used to charge much more money for medicines than government or other hospitals. If the money was not handed over to their medical store, they used to charge interest. Even he used to get his gloves, masks, and sanitizers with our money. He earns a lot of money by playing with the emotions of a person. Every person wants to see his loved ones healthy, that's why he gives the asked amount. The government should bring a concrete law on this foot. I MISS MY FATHER ALOT 😭😭. I AM JUST 17 WHEN MY FATHER LEFT ME. AND NOW I HAVE TO TAKE CARE OF MY FAMILY .
My condolences to you bro. But this problem cannot be solved because of politics. My suggestion for you is to be educated and apply for foreign universities and leave this system. Tell this to your siblings as well so they'll also be safe .
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer. They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
I'm laboratory technician recently joined Hospital in Karnataka Jan 2024 as I'm Fresher they said will pay you 9000/- per month and at last on 10 Feb 2024 they paid only 2000 after doing 9 hrs daily duty including Sundays, 12 hrs continuously 3 days shift They charged 3000-5000 per person for diagnosis test everyday 60-70 patients were coming I when I spoke about this to the management and doctor...................Now I'm jobless 🥺
My mother also needed a treat ment in 2021 but when she went to BLK hospital . They demanded 25000 Rs for admission fees. Now my mother is well but it takes around four months in government hospital to identify the cause of illness. After that she completed the prescribed course of treatment. I think there should be a proper health facilities provided in government sector.
In my state (Rajasthan) we have free treatment of 25lackh Rupees in every govt and private hospital….. it was a major relief for everyone … my friends father is having cancer & his entire treatment of chemotherapy is free … she’s not from a financially sound family but still her father having a good treatment in private hospital…. God bless Gehlot ji … usually I don’t comment but it’s a real case I’ve seen
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer. They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
Please make video about law mafia... And please do extra research about how corporate sector works in healthcare... Target them specifically not doctors ...Doctors are just employees.....
Government Should provide more funds for government hospitals and also increase more number of hospitals in rural and sub urban areas. unless the government hospitals improve there infrastructure and medical staff the private hospitals will run the show and rob the people which even the higher authorities cannot control.
As a pharmacist I know this brutal reality of this hospitals..and doctors are writing test and medicine by the basis of cash of Representatives..the ultimate truth of our health system 😢
My Friend's Father was admitted in "MEDANTA" Lucknow on 5 Dec 20222 due to heart attack. They Charged him 3.15 Lakhs for just a single day and couldn't save him. 10k for a single bottle of injection, that's the amount he was paying there. After his Father death they transfer his body into the basement and didn't even arranged an ambulance. And forced him to take the body from the backside of the building. I was there with him at that night 😭😭😭
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer. They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
As a doctor we are not allowed to switch off the ventilator.. There are no rules of Euthanasia.. Although I work in govt hospital where the cost of per day ICU charges is ₹200 including Medicine Ventilator All the investigation Gloves Urine bag Syringes Central line Sonography CXR In case you activate MJPJAY , everything will be free of cost including CT scan , per day ircu Charges, MRI .. Literally ₹0.. So people should start seeking Govt Hospitals.
I think one of the most effective solutions you forgot to mention is Insurance, Most of the developed countries use insurance which is a must for every citizen and which covers almost everything except a few rare diseases. With special extra insurance that can also be covered. For poor people, we have free insurance but unfortunately, our people really don't know about that so we need to make aware of them. In India we need national insurance which should be eligible in every single hospital. I know these private hospitals will try to exploit that too but once govt will realizes they will start to monitor every single medicine and all and it will be an effective system just like any other country.
But here is the catch ,in name of insurance this private hospitals will charge you more , in fact they will earn more for an insured patients compare to uninsured patients
@@dhruvpatel7969 yeah that's true.. and that's why i mention that all hospital bills should be regulated through Insurance. In developed countries most of the people have national insurance and with that they really don't have to pay huge amount. they normally pay 5-10 percent of bill and rest of the amount will be paid by insurance directly so its upto hospital and insurance how they will handle it. As insurance is most of the time national insurance so the government can handle the price of that medice which they can use and their price also govt can regulate. I think what we need is we just need to follow some develop country insurance modal, study them, and modify as per our requirements and implement them.
@@drashutoshh Yeah that's also one reason, and that's why i suggest price of these medicine should be controlled by govt. I mean its an irony that a country which is world's biggest generic medicine producer they still have to use all those expensive medicines even for lower-class people. Its really one of the worst practice which explain why we have a long long way to reach where many asian country already achieved.
@@mangalsain12 generic medicine is a different ballgame altogether, if something bad happens who will je liable in that case. And when we are looking for brands in clothes, mobile even animals are from famous breed, it makes little sense to put drugs from some unknown source whose credibility is not trusted. Those trusted brands need to be regulated, we don't want what's happening with Insulin in US
We studied that hospitals and educational institutions were considered as Non-profititable institutions however these days its opposite and they are considered as the most profitable. Its very sad that the government is least interested in the health sector. Hence common man has to pay the price for that . It's a vicious cycle that never ends.
The problem is that most of the financial schemes u listed are dictated by the hospital management which itself is made up of huge businessmen who run it as any other business(concerned with profit only), also in Punjab at least the govt hospitals r so overburdened with patients and understaffed that giving decent treatment is not possible, India progressively is becoming like all other first world countries where healthcare without having insurance will make u broke whether that’s a good or bad thing is up for debate !!!
I had criticized many of this channels video due to some relevant reasons, but this video deserves a big thumps up. Whatever you have put & described is absolutely correct out of my personal experience.
Similar incident happened with my cousin sister. She was brain dead but they played with our emotions and kept her artificially alive for 10 days and charged lakhs. How can they even think to do this with an infant. 😢
I am also from Maharashtra but I don't think so the conditions of public hospitals are good enough and due to this people move towards private and they charge extra 😢
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer. They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
Don't go to private hospitals. However still private hospitals enjoy better patient management as compared to Government hospitals. This presentation is excellent in breaking patient foctor relationship. These few cases which are still under investigations cannot be generalized for millions of admissions that take place and get cured. Quality comes with a cost. Doctors charges are professional charges and called consultation fee not lootna or looters.😢 This report is not going to fo any good to society.
I want to share something , 3 years ago my father was admitted in a leading private hospital in Delhi , where when his surgery was done he wasn't discharged even after 3 months and when we were in the hospital corridor one of the doctors came to me and asked me what the other doctors were saying on my father's health , I told him that the doctors have done almost everything and we were just waiting for them to discharge him from the hospital but then that doctor told me something shocking he said the those doctor wouldn't want to eliminate their money METER . After that I told my parents about that and then we immediately got my father discharged .
Log bolte hai Dr. Bhagwan ka roop hote hian lekin ek baar jane k baat pata chalta hia ki Sakshat yamraj baithe hain wahan. Thanks is topic pe video babane k liye.👍
Thank you for making this video it was much needed for everyone. And also need to share something which is about my mother aged 78yrs. Its a common thing at this age sometimes she forget things and after sometimes its ok so one day my brother took her to GNRC dispur guwahati where she went by car and it was parked in a lane near hospital and from the parking she walked to the hospital and met the doctor which means she was physically fit. my brother discussed the matter with the doctor who said to admit her for 2 days after that she'll be ok than take her home than my mother opposed and said she is ok and want to go home but my brother thought better admit her as the doctor said she'll be fine in two days so this is were we made a mistake by admiting my mother in hospital as we trusted the doctor they admitted her in ICU my mother opposed again and said that she's fine and wants to go home but we didn't listen to her thinking that she'll be taken good care and we'll do the check ups whats necessary and in ICU they tied her legs and hands as she was struggling to get down from the bed. And by evening doctor said she needs ventilator and we asked the reason they said she had mild stroke for which I had to sign. Till about 10 days we were there without any recovery and getting worse day by day and finally we decided to shift her in GMCH guwahati where she was kept in ventilator for about 20 days and couldn't survive. If we listen to our mother and didn't admit her in GNRC HOSPITAL than I think my mother would have survived till now .
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life. There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam, and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need. There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer. They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
All these happens in Peerless Hospital in Kolkata as well. I have paid 64000 for investigation apart from other points in the bill on a daily basis, medicines 91000 and so on. Within a week, we had to pay more than 3 lakhs. Although the patient is dead, nothing can be done to this kind of so called hospitals. The so called Admins are also on their side. This is our life saving market.
I don't know if these things are still happening or not? But there are now rules and regulations for all these stuff that were happening. I knew about all these from the age of 10 as my whole family is of doctors
![VICTOR Denmark Open 2024 | An Se Young (KOR) [1] vs. Gregoria Mariska Tunjung (INA) [5] | SF](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Y3QEyCih85s/mqdefault.jpg)
I am a nurse n I totally agree with you... you r 200% right....this is really disgusting....when I was in private hospital i advised many patients to go to government hospital...the problem is lots of private hospitals owned by politicians
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
Love your work🙏
May no one ever have to see the inside of a private hospital. May these dirty institutions turn into ruins!
😢Right
For that to happen the govt. Hospitals should be proper. But they aren't. So ppl obviously prefer to go to private hospitals🤷🏻♂️
@@charuvikram9786 Right 😓
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
@@shresharma2403 in your opinion ...what are the unnecessary tests ? Please be clear.
Goverment is not taking action because majority of private hospitals is owned by politicians 😢
Edit thanks for 110 likes 🙏🙏
True
True
Yes.
True
So true
Being a Dr from AIIMS I fully support your views these corporate hosp in reality earn from dead body also
Sir aiims acha hai but late treatment ki wjh se mere dadaji ni bch paye wha😢😢)kya kren insan
Govt. Is only for VIPs and not for am Garib Janata. Am Janata is on Ram Bharose. !
Bhai tu Aisa Mt bn jana. Be a great doctor.
Could relate to each and every fact stated in the video. I lost my younger brother from dengue in 2017. He was admitted in Regency a multi-speciality hospital in Kanpur, he was admitted there for near about 15 days. After being the hospital for four days, his condition started improving but all of a sudden they said he would need to go on ventilator for 2 days, there is nothing to worry about, its just the matter of two days. But after two days, they kept on saying that they would observe him for one more day on ventilator. This went on for near about 8 days and then my brother who was just 11 years old, left us forever. They only allowed us to meet him twice a day for five minutes only. He left us when no one was with him, it still breaks my heart that no one was with him when he was in pain, when he was leaving us. We were helpless, we were charged around rupees 12 lac. It wasn't just about the money, it was the false hopes that they gave us by putting him on ventilator. Whenever we said that we would take him to some other hospitals, the doctors started warning us that its risky get him somewhere else being on the ventilator. I wish we would have not listened to them, sometimes we feel like we could save him if we would have not listened to them, because they only let us meet him twice, he was just 11 years who needed his mother beside him, who could him strength to fight that battle, but they didn't allow.
Its been six years since he left us, but still not a single day has passed that we don't remember him.😭
I am so sorry for your loss.. It's a heartbreaking thing which happened.. I can feel ur pain..they r monsters this medical mafia..poor kid.. I am a mother too... May God give ur family lots of strength and happiness in the future.. What happened to ur family was a nightmare.. Sending u my wishes
I could never understand the loss that you're going through. Reading about your experince...when youre brother was on the vent it is advisable to not shift him anywhere else as there a lot of things that could go wrong during the process. And im thinking youre brother was kept in isolation at the ICU so its natural that they dont allow visitors because those are sterile spaces and they need to be maintained the same. But idk the entire story so I cannot comment any further. They should've taken proper consent from you for the procedures being done. About the false hope part I didn't understand. Ventilator isn't false hope. It's a devise to assist in oxygen delivery when the body is failing to do so. And yes intubating pt. Comes with risks. But the good it does far outweighs the risks.
Billing is done by the hospitals not by the doctors. They both are separate entities. Doctors take an oath and they abide by it. Corporates don't have an oath. A doctor does everything in his power to abide by his oath. People have really got to stop blaming doctors without knowing all the facts.
@@charuvikram9786 Before the day, he left us, the doctors all of a sudden started complying with the fact that yes we could take him wherever we want and then in morning he left us.
@@charuvikram9786 things started make sense after I watched the video where Aditya mentioned that modern hospitals work like a corporate world where doctors are given targets to be achieved within the stipulated time.
I understand the fact that everyone is not the same, but even the politicians take oath to carry on their duty honestly but does it ever happen, in fact they are the most corrupt officials in the country. Hence, taking an oath is no guarantee that a person is honest.
I support your work, you have done a good job in bringing this issue to limelight. Last month a private hospital charged us 3K for treating viral fever using paracetamol, the treatment lasted for 35 min 😢
An eye opening video for against medical mafia
For which we can do nothing. For these hospitals we are just barking like dogs which they don't care
Learn English
No eye opening bro all know who's own admitted in the hospital
*an eye opening video against medical mafia😉
Har chiz ke mafias milne lage hai Aaj kal 😂😂😂
As a physiotherapist I used to work in a private hospital in Ahmedabad. The management of that hospital put lot of pressure on me to generate revenue. In the end, I had to leave that hospital because that hospital belonged to a politician.
Well done. Good to see your self respect is alive.
Salute
All the industry wants to generate revenue in a wrong way...
it happens when fundamental institutions like hospitals, schools, colleges are owned by politicians. Kudos to you.
Respect for you
As doctor I am ashamed by corporates running hospital and all these management and owners. And some greedy doctors
Why so apologetic, you don't over bill patients, if at all hospitals do. And at the end of the day these are for profile organizations.
P.s : also a doctor
@K&R Thanks for acknowledging the fact and realising the corrupt system... I do have huge respect for doctors, but there are some doctors who encash from this corrupt system.
I do understand that being in the system and not follow its norms might be difficult but encouraging corruption is not the right choice !!
Doctor sahab pls guide k kahan jaye ? Govt hospital me number nahi ata private me jeb khali ho jati h
Pls add your valuable feedback
Why they are greedy sir ? Reservation, high education fees and too much of pressure, tell me kya koi aur profession me nai hota ye ? Doctors ko bas blame karna hoga then why doctors won't start being inhuman if they hv to face inhuman bhv by people ?
@@ashishpaliwal9283dude most doctors themselves are running pharmacy syndicate earning lakhs by prescribing medicines 😂🤭🤭
Being Doctor i will say Whole system everything is corrupt...Everyone connect with this plays with fear of loosing thr loved once.
I have a fantastic solution for this issue. In the United States, credit card owners have certain protection rights, such as the ability to initiate a chargeback. A chargeback, also referred to as a dispute, allows the bank that issued your credit card to reclaim funds from the retailer's (hospital) bank when you don't satisfied with the services you paid for. This process includes penalties imposed on the retailer's(hospital) bank.
This will need a lawsuit and a thorough enquiry
This is real then it is one of the best idea
such things don't work in India..Everything is mafia here
implement karne ke liye tumhe Neta banana padega ,that too a Fantastic one.
@@0Kaz101why should they not do you knpw private hospitals are charging 1 lakh per day
Great report ,but this is happening continuously in India and other countries,God bless u for opening eyes of people
Lost my brother yesterday, 30 days on ventilator, body weight gone to 25 kgs only for a 18 year old boy.
some insiders told us that case was of only 2 days, but they stretched the treatment to 30-40 days to loot our hard earned money, they charged 20 lakhs and hand over the dead body.
Please share this video so that the government get pressurized and no body in future go through this situation.
This case was of RHL hospital, jaipur
This is the story of every hospital.
The whole hospital industry is so bad that we have only two safe options either stay healthy or die at home only.
Why you haven't shifted patient to sawai mann singh, which is goverment hospital there. So u r fool enough to get looted it means. Your loss is not replaceable but no one forced you to stay
@@drpediatrica1692after 3 days in sms he was reffered to private hospital from sms only, these both public and private institutes have cons only. We have no way to go to
Sorry for your loss brother , but aap hi socho , practicing Medicine is all about taking chance , a doctor , takes chance on the patient's diseased condition based on his knowledge of lifetime , he is there to try , and boy , sometimes your body needs time to get repaired and get rid of a disease , and if u also come to hospital in a bad situation a doctor's job is to get the disease eliminated if possible or atleast extend your life
For 30-40 days may be required for necessary interventions and trials
That is why I take care of my health so much and not eat outside food which full of Cancer and tumour generating, little fever can be defeated by immunity so no need to go to hospital. Believe me I live Hyderabad City and it's totally terrible because bad people are almost everywhere
Coming from a medical background,all i can say that people who say hospital charge too much don't know the whole story
Please explain
@@RebelBong ok if I start explaining it will be 10page essay but in very short it's same like what diamond manufacturers did in last century to artificial inflate the price of diamonds
Whatever the story that doesn't give anyone Right To focus on profit rather than the patient...And about background.... every Post graduate for private will support this why? Bexoz they Spend in crores....after that they will not think about patients they only think about Profit
@@srishtiarmaanianasha6253 life is not this simple, you can start living life like fundamentalist but after some time you will also agree that life is grey not white and black
I have experience of a small private hospital of Bengaluru where they charged Rs 4000 for a mere stitching of and bandage of a finger !!......no need for your explanation private hospital and schools are being run by money mafia it's already known to all .
There should be a law for hospitals and nursing home to give proper cctv footage for all operations.
give to whom ? Layman would faint at first sight.
There should be a regulating authority in Healthcare such as RBI and IRFA...
@@darkmystic5076 there is by the name of NMC but Is corrupt to the core
True. I faced this issue when my 1 year old son got admitted. The hospital overcharged and even put a cannula in my baby's hand which was not needed at all. There are many greedy and immoral people in the medical community. I had to fight for my son out of there.
Cannula is inserted so that drugs can be directly infused into the veins leading to faster action as compared to oral route.
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
HEALTH INSURANCE is must..
Right 👍👍 Every body should be aware
hats off bro....eyes opener.... every Indian must watch
Very few people have courage to make such type of video... whatever he told is damm true...
Including management, many paramedical staffs and doctors are involved in this Nexus. I visited a pvt. hospital for diarrhoea treatment. They wrote chest X-ray and Full body Sonography as diagnostic test. I denied but they did it and found nothing in report. Overall i got the bill of 8K just for 2 days in hospital. They nurses unnecessary wasted the saline. They asked us to bring 500 ml of NS but they used only 200 ml. Rest of the amount was trashed in dustbin. Same thing happen for some other medicine also.
From that day i lose the respect for health care workers.
It was bad experience but its true..
Apart,
I respect those doctor's or staff who work honestly.
1737% overcharge wtf
This is so called humanity left in this world😢
Pharma,DRS , Government all are responsible for this
The way you have explained is absolute correct
Every DRS attached to a private hospital has their Target minimum number of patients should be admitted
Pathology , xray, sonography,MRI , everywhere commission
False treatment , going for false transplant
In Pune this happens very frequently all private Hospital included
I am one of the victims
I even worked in a Pharma company for 28 yrs
Still be lotted
Excellent information from you Aditya
भ्रष्ट देश के भ्रष्ट इकोसिस्टम मे भ्रष्टाचार ही बिजनेस का आधार है चाहे वो प्राइवेट स्कूल हो प्राइवेट क्लिनिक हो प्राइवेट अस्पताल हो या फिर हायर एंड फायर वाली प्राइवेट नौकरी
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
This is true. In hospital 10% discount on Antibiotic injection. In market 40% discount. When per day medicine bill greater than 10000 it's affecting lot
Absolutely correct, it is very common in country those days now.. 👍🏻👍🏻
Me is back on time without late 👍🇮🇳
Aditya Saini back to Expose the Dark reality of hospital Industry Mafia 😡📈🧡
Me any Audience likes his content and Engage in his clear Explanations and also salute to his research ,efforts and dedication 👍❤🔥
Good content bro, this is reality, why govt. should not be controlled bills in Private hospital 🥵🤢
We need to have many more hospitals so that there is competition and plenty of doctors. Need to educate people as well. If there are many doctors and hospitals, these problems can get overcome. Govt should create many more AIIMS in every state and spend more on healthcare.. But this is all just we can only think of.
No my friend, this is already going on, government already increased MBBS, and PG seats, each MLA or his relative owned Medical college. So in few yrs you will find MBBS doctor, like engineers.
Yes but with poor knowledge
@@nitinkumarprajapati5257es only the good experience doc will survive , and you can check in newly construct clg there is no modern machinery nothing no technology, so it's like the btech only the top one survive and the lower one berozgar
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
I got heart surgery in Delhi gov hospital with nominal charges. same Odisa, Rajasthan is also progressing in better health care system. hope all state will work on medical and education .
This problem is connected to overpriced fees of medical college. Please, make a video on this also.
I have gone through financials of some of the listed hospitals.
OPM% OVER 10yrs range
Aster DM Health care - 6% to 17%
apollo hospitals - 10% to 16%
max healthcare - 7 to 21%
fortis healthcare - -26% to 19%
if prices are over inflated why are the margins low.
compare with IT Companies
TCS - 26% TO 31% - never below 10%
infosys - 24 to 32%
please let us know at what OPM% should hospitals do business.
Jaha MBBS ki fees crore tak pauch chuki hai waha aap Doctors se insaniyat ki umeed kaise kar sakte ho?
@ragnar lothbrok thanks for valuable info doctor.
@@ragnarlothbrok918equipment is ok? But don't you think being greedy 100k for a month ....If you want money the why choose this profession?
@@ragnarlothbrok918 you worked hard but you know yourself ki iit graduate package....so if you already know the reality about salary before choosing this profession you shouldn't complain naa ... and If want to earn more do super specialisation or work hard get radiology seat you will definitely earn
@@ragnarlothbrok918 i re read your comment yes 50k for 12hr Is definitely less .. MBBS Is loosing it's charm
@@ragnarlothbrok918 and i just read news about 200graduate went to gb pant for Jr
The fact that there are many politicians who own hospitals and this mighy be the biggest reason why governments don't show any interest to regulate
It's really scary that we have no option during emergencies despite knowing all this. Health care has become s scam, no more a service and there are still some self less doctors to this day who charge a minimal amount. Empathy should be taught in medical schools but what can we expect, when they count everything with money!?. I request Aditya Saini make a video on less medical colleges throughout the country, that makes medicine a dream for underprivileged students...
Kindly check recent Medical college data, you will find there is tremendously increase in medical college, but with poor quality education, mostly owned by politicians and his family.
In few yrs you will find MBBS doctor like engineers, and with extremely poor knowledge.
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
Teaching empathy to doctors will provide no solutions, bcoz these scams are controlled by owners and top management people of the hospitals, out of which hardly 5-10% include doctors (mostly there are having connections or are extremely senior). Rest 90% doctors don't have any control over all these profits. Politicians and businessmen sitting at the top of hospital management are heading these scams and unfortunately no one is going to do anything against them, as they aren't soft targets 😌
So the problem is actually very deep rooted.
@@nitinkumarprajapati5257MBBS is already getting saturated in our country and with so many private colleges where people enter just by paying hefty amounts and of course extreme reservation allowing substandard candidates entry to the field, MBBS is no longer a field of only meritorious students, the quality is coming down year after year. And even among those, a good portion choose to leave the country in search of better monetary returns and a better lifestyle. And guess what who are ones who leave? The good ones, the below average ones will any way not get entry into developed countries...
Boht badhiya yaar, ap boht ache topics uthate ho. Jo ki normal logo se jude topic h
Hospitals do alot of overcharging. ₹2000 for xray. ₹8000 for bed 🛏️ and 3 times medication ₹1240 per day for 2 weeks.
got looted of a whopping ₹1.2 lakh 🤬🤬
All of your videos are absolutely amazing in quality and content. Kudos to the efforts
I would like to clarify that the hospitals are mainly owned by businessman or politicians so doctor’s should be kept out of this
Buy not all doctors
@AashishTelgote-zx4wp ha Bhai tera free me illaz kar dega tum unka family sambhal dega kya bsdk hospital ka bhi kharch hota wo sab kaha se dega , license salary instruments building rent
Dr cannot escape saying that
@@shyamkishoragrawal4571 haa bhaklol mtlb doctor kamaye bhi na 10 saal dene ke baad,tum uske parivaar ko paloge kya
We need to stand together..❤
My mother is a bp patient we had to travel 150 km for her treatment from a specified doctor who had also a lot of experience but they charged a lot of money everytime we visit their then we switched to a doctor who lived nearby and had almost 3/4th experience of the previous one he cut down the numbers of medicine and changed all medicines with new one and now she is doing well
1) Who is telling you to go to private hospital for treatment if it's expensive just go to govt hospital 2) when u enter private hospital the consultation and admission chargers are well explained to relative after that when patient and relative agree with that then only treatment is started no body forces u to do that. 3) No private hospital can force you to buy medicine or do diagnostic test in there premises the patient is free to do wherever he wants. 4) and if you think the dr has advised extra test Or medicine patient can cross check with any other dr which is known to them.
They dont even know what it takes to be a doctor
Abe lodu pehle pura video dekha hai
Yes, there are hosp where u hv to take meds from them, diagnostics where will one do if already admitted? Many Pvt hosp are scam. Pls admit.
Here in Odisha the government truly provides the best healthcare facilities within minimal fees or i may say almost free and along with the HEALTHCARD for farmers, its very rare for being a victim of scams
but i agree that the problem still continues (Mostly among middle class people who can neither afford such private hospitals nor avail the govt schemes)
BBSR re hi what about Western Odisha?
Worst facility 👎
We have two option either Vizag or BBSR
Patient death 🤦
Kis odisha me rehte ho bhai? Periphery me jaakr dekho. Show me atleast one chc which is functioning properly
What about SUM
😂😂😂 odisha best in healthcare nice joke 🤣
@@adithyasatish5080vhi toh yeh bjd ka karyakarta hoga
That's actually so true,sbse pehle to faaltu k test zaroor likhenge
Hello, Aditya please go through this comment carefully, speaking as a doctor practicing in corporate. Answering as in order of your points.
1. There is a lot of difference between hospitals and doctors. Doctors did not over-bill, the hospital did. These are two separate entities.
2. If the government wishes they can regulate the MRP of drugs and consumables.
3. Relatives are almost always told about the critical condition of their patients.
4. Before putting on the ventilator, consent is obtained (unless it's an emergency when there is no time to do so)
5. Doctors earn way less than their age counterparts in other fields.
6. Profit from consumables and drugs has to compensate for the entire nursing staff and supporting staff.
7. If people choose to get admitted in private hospitals, they are told beforehand about the per day cost.
I feel there is a lot of bias against doctors earning which is unfair. I respect your content and have been an avid viewer but I really think you should put both sides of the story. If you want to discuss further I'm open to dialogue.
These are for-profit organizations at the end of the day.
I agree people are so dumb in comment section they r hating the profession of drs they don't know how much hardwork and years it takes to be a Dr and then what u get less salary and less respect by society😢
People who can make their own openion by analysing the facts often don't comment but the one who easily get influenced by any random video of post surely comment to satisfy themself. And don't see that the subject of video or post is a particular case or hospital or a few, instead generalise the argument and write irrational things about the profession
I have seen such hate towards doctors and private hospitals and along with these kinds of ill inform videos where deliberately hospitals and doctors use interchangeably. I feel i should just leave the profession and probably just start selling liquor, cigarettes where there are high margins and not so much hate.
A for-profit organization has its nature fixed in a capitalist economy.
Why not question your MLA or MP why not ask them to fix government health care.
Or just to hell with everything and just nationalise all private hospitals.
Let's have a NHS like system and let's see how we function.
Private health care is not a right it's a privilege. 😢😢
@@vic4883
I have seen such hate towards doctors and private hospitals and along with these kinds of ill inform videos where deliberately hospitals and doctors use interchangeably. I feel i should just leave the profession and probably just start selling liquor, cigarettes where there are high margins and not so much hate.
A for-profit organization has its nature fixed in a capitalist economy.
Why not question your MLA or MP why not ask them to fix government health care.
Or just to hell with everything and just nationalise all private hospitals.
Let's have a NHS like system and let's see how we function.
Private health care is not a right it's a privilege. 😢😢
very imp topic ......rakshak he bhakshk ban gae hai ......gov ko bahut strict action lene chaye ....nahi to gareeb ko kcuh nahi milne wala even middle class sab luta deta hai in hospitals me .....gov ko price tag karna chaye na
This is an eye opening video... Even in Arunachal Pradesh also same medical maafia rooted so deep..
These are not the only way. In private hospitals patients are treated by non modern medicine practitioners like bhms bams etc to reduce their cost. It is necessary to take initiative to make Id with proper registration numbers so that people can find who are treating them using proper identification apps to atleast verify they are not treated by quacks
@@ragnarlothbrok918 bro I'm too an mbbs doctor. When it's upto admitting a patient they risk a patient on the hands of non modern medicine practitioners. But when it comes to medico legal activities or when then sense danger they need a MBBS holder registration number and if something goes wrong then refer to closest Government medical College or hospital.
@@ragnarlothbrok918 it's the fault of the government. They are keen on increasing mbbs seats but not on taking these passouts back in the government system. They don't want to develop government facilities and want to develop private hospitals to collect more revenue. The solution are
1) increase government doctors seats
2) develop infrastructure
3) keep track records on private hospitals expenses and bills
4) impose heavy penalties or cancel licences of such private hospitals found guilty of hiring quacks, charging higher prices, taking advantage of mediclaim etc
5) ensure ima or nmc approved I'd cards with number and photo Id to ensure a quack free system
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
I LOST MY FATHER DURING COVID 19 PANDAMIC 2021 . MY FATHER ALSO ADMITED IN SHREE RAM PRIVATE HOSPITAL IN JODHPER .Private hospitals used to ask to take medicines only from their hospital, they used to charge much more money for medicines than government or other hospitals. If the money was not handed over to their medical store, they used to charge interest. Even he used to get his gloves, masks, and sanitizers with our money. He earns a lot of money by playing with the emotions of a person. Every person wants to see his loved ones healthy, that's why he gives the asked amount. The government should bring a concrete law on this foot. I MISS MY FATHER ALOT 😭😭. I AM JUST 17 WHEN MY FATHER LEFT ME. AND NOW I HAVE TO TAKE CARE OF MY FAMILY .
My condolences to you bro.
But this problem cannot be solved because of politics.
My suggestion for you is to be educated and apply for foreign universities and leave this system. Tell this to your siblings as well so they'll also be safe .
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
@@sushil8424europe probably us is more complicated and dangerous than india
What about mbbs and pg fees…. Nd govt failure in health care….
I'm laboratory technician recently joined Hospital in Karnataka Jan 2024 as I'm Fresher they said will pay you 9000/- per month and at last on 10 Feb 2024 they paid only 2000 after doing 9 hrs daily duty including Sundays, 12 hrs continuously 3 days shift
They charged 3000-5000 per person for diagnosis test everyday 60-70 patients were coming
I when I spoke about this to the management and doctor...................Now I'm jobless 🥺
Just been through the same ordeal, leaving my father half dead and bedridden for life and my savings all taken away by the hospital.
This video contains Hard truth. Govt of india should see this video & act accordingly. Share more & more to spread awareness.
Only one solution take them under government and make government hospital more and more
The only way to make yourself strong is make the law strong...
My mother also needed a treat ment in 2021 but when she went to BLK hospital . They demanded 25000 Rs for admission fees. Now my mother is well but it takes around four months in government hospital to identify the cause of illness. After that she completed the prescribed course of treatment.
I think there should be a proper health facilities provided in government sector.
This is so true i have notice such things in private hospitals....they list unnecessary tests ....
How did you know ?? Those are unnecessary test... Tere pass madical ka knowledge he kia chutia...
In my state (Rajasthan) we have free treatment of 25lackh Rupees in every govt and private hospital….. it was a major relief for everyone … my friends father is having cancer & his entire treatment of chemotherapy is free … she’s not from a financially sound family but still her father having a good treatment in private hospital…. God bless Gehlot ji … usually I don’t comment but it’s a real case I’ve seen
Yes
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
Please make video about law mafia...
And please do extra research about how corporate sector works in healthcare...
Target them specifically not doctors ...Doctors are just employees.....
Seriously bro you and your team is so much hard working. thank u so much bro for providing a good information and create awareness among people 😊
Exactly same thing has happened with my relatives. But thank god they had railway insurance.
In India there is alot of unskilled doctor working in hospitals but due to shortage of Doctors we accept them
Working on a startup to counter the problem...... ❤
Government Should provide more funds for government hospitals and also increase more number of hospitals in rural and sub urban areas. unless the government hospitals improve there infrastructure and medical staff the private hospitals will run the show and rob the people which even the higher authorities cannot control.
Private hospital hi open karege - govt....... Kyoki Treatment karna govt ka work nhi hai. Privatization hi future hai.
As a pharmacist I know this brutal reality of this hospitals..and doctors are writing test and medicine by the basis of cash of Representatives..the ultimate truth of our health system 😢
My Friend's Father was admitted in "MEDANTA" Lucknow on 5 Dec 20222 due to heart attack. They Charged him 3.15 Lakhs for just a single day and couldn't save him. 10k for a single bottle of injection, that's the amount he was paying there. After his Father death they transfer his body into the basement and didn't even arranged an ambulance. And forced him to take the body from the backside of the building. I was there with him at that night 😭😭😭
Very sad
Bastards
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
Very very important research..
I wish your channel touches the 1 million subscribers margin soon.Your analysis is very good.🙏
As a doctor we are not allowed to switch off the ventilator.. There are no rules of Euthanasia..
Although I work in govt hospital where the cost of per day ICU charges is ₹200 including
Medicine
Ventilator
All the investigation
Gloves
Urine bag
Syringes
Central line
Sonography
CXR
In case you activate MJPJAY , everything will be free of cost including CT scan , per day ircu Charges, MRI ..
Literally ₹0..
So people should start seeking Govt Hospitals.
Hmm it's quite a dilema.. eagerly waiting for supreme court's ruling on euthanasia.
Where are d beds in govt hospitals? U hv to get recommendations of politicians to get admitted
@@GSh-pg6bhit's called VIP culture
I think one of the most effective solutions you forgot to mention is Insurance, Most of the developed countries use insurance which is a must for every citizen and which covers almost everything except a few rare diseases. With special extra insurance that can also be covered. For poor people, we have free insurance but unfortunately, our people really don't know about that so we need to make aware of them. In India we need national insurance which should be eligible in every single hospital. I know these private hospitals will try to exploit that too but once govt will realizes they will start to monitor every single medicine and all and it will be an effective system just like any other country.
But here is the catch ,in name of insurance this private hospitals will charge you more , in fact they will earn more for an insured patients compare to uninsured patients
It's not about insurance it's about rational charging. Overinflation is the key problem, wo sudhar jaye toh genuine price toh sabhi dete hain
@@dhruvpatel7969 yeah that's true.. and that's why i mention that all hospital bills should be regulated through Insurance. In developed countries most of the people have national insurance and with that they really don't have to pay huge amount. they normally pay 5-10 percent of bill and rest of the amount will be paid by insurance directly so its upto hospital and insurance how they will handle it. As insurance is most of the time national insurance so the government can handle the price of that medice which they can use and their price also govt can regulate. I think what we need is we just need to follow some develop country insurance modal, study them, and modify as per our requirements and implement them.
@@drashutoshh Yeah that's also one reason, and that's why i suggest price of these medicine should be controlled by govt. I mean its an irony that a country which is world's biggest generic medicine producer they still have to use all those expensive medicines even for lower-class people. Its really one of the worst practice which explain why we have a long long way to reach where many asian country already achieved.
@@mangalsain12 generic medicine is a different ballgame altogether, if something bad happens who will je liable in that case. And when we are looking for brands in clothes, mobile even animals are from famous breed, it makes little sense to put drugs from some unknown source whose credibility is not trusted.
Those trusted brands need to be regulated, we don't want what's happening with Insulin in US
We studied that hospitals and educational institutions were considered as Non-profititable institutions however these days its opposite and they are considered as the most profitable. Its very sad that the government is least interested in the health sector. Hence common man has to pay the price for that . It's a vicious cycle that never ends.
Thank you sir for providing us such a useful information.❤❤
Thanks to Rajasthan Government for the revolutionary amendment bill for these private hospitals
Actually
Bravest video on RUclips... Hat's off brother 🙏 keep going ❤
In the end the biggest and the ultimate problem is our education system
The problem is that most of the financial schemes u listed are dictated by the hospital management which itself is made up of huge businessmen who run it as any other business(concerned with profit only), also in Punjab at least the govt hospitals r so overburdened with patients and understaffed that giving decent treatment is not possible, India progressively is becoming like all other first world countries where healthcare without having insurance will make u broke whether that’s a good or bad thing is up for debate !!!
So true ...Hope some government officials watch this and act ..
Hai Ram
Amazing work bro, it's sad that many people have lost their integrity for money
Make a same on Education system looted by private colleges & universities.
I had criticized many of this channels video due to some relevant reasons, but this video deserves a big thumps up. Whatever you have put & described is absolutely correct out of my personal experience.
Similar incident happened with my cousin sister. She was brain dead but they played with our emotions and kept her artificially alive for 10 days and charged lakhs.
How can they even think to do this with an infant. 😢
Rajasthan had made the best move !!!! ❤
Bro I am from maharashtra govt hospitals here are million times better than private hospitals and free too I have seen with my own eyes 😘💓
Lol. Most hospitals are always full.
@@sankkhami am from Sangli
I am also from Maharashtra but I don't think so the conditions of public hospitals are good enough and due to this people move towards private and they charge extra 😢
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
Must be reported. Take action Against these private hospitals.
ICU is the most profitable segment of any hospitals. Means very high ROI.
World Bank also said that India need to spent min.4-5% their GDP to health
Don't go to private hospitals.
However still private hospitals enjoy better patient management as compared to Government hospitals.
This presentation is excellent in breaking patient foctor relationship.
These few cases which are still under investigations cannot be generalized for millions of admissions that take place and get cured.
Quality comes with a cost. Doctors charges are professional charges and called consultation fee not lootna or looters.😢
This report is not going to fo any good to society.
Your every line is 100% correct.
I want to share something , 3 years ago my father was admitted in a leading private hospital in Delhi , where when his surgery was done he wasn't discharged even after 3 months and when we were in the hospital corridor one of the doctors came to me and asked me what the other doctors were saying on my father's health , I told him that the doctors have done almost everything and we were just waiting for them to discharge him from the hospital but then that doctor told me something shocking he said the those doctor wouldn't want to eliminate their money METER . After that I told my parents about that and then we immediately got my father discharged .
This Could not be stopped unless you improve govt hospital facilities .
This is true bro , this same situation happened in Bangalore , one of my relatives had faced same problem .
Log bolte hai Dr. Bhagwan ka roop hote hian lekin ek baar jane k baat pata chalta hia ki Sakshat yamraj baithe hain wahan.
Thanks is topic pe video babane k liye.👍
This happens because Governments are also involved in this
Regulating private hospitals, schools and colleges should be top priority of government
So true..this needs to change!!
Thank you for making this video it was much needed for everyone. And also need to share something which is about my mother aged 78yrs. Its a common thing at this age sometimes she forget things and after sometimes its ok so one day my brother took her to GNRC dispur guwahati where she went by car and it was parked in a lane near hospital and from the parking she walked to the hospital and met the doctor which means she was physically fit. my brother discussed the matter with the doctor who said to admit her for 2 days after that she'll be ok than take her home than my mother opposed and said she is ok and want to go home but my brother thought better admit her as the doctor said she'll be fine in two days so this is were we made a mistake by admiting my mother in hospital as we trusted the doctor they admitted her in ICU my mother opposed again and said that she's fine and wants to go home but we didn't listen to her thinking that she'll be taken good care and we'll do the check ups whats necessary and in ICU they tied her legs and hands as she was struggling to get down from the bed. And by evening doctor said she needs ventilator and we asked the reason they said she had mild stroke for which I had to sign. Till about 10 days we were there without any recovery and getting worse day by day and finally we decided to shift her in GMCH guwahati where she was kept in ventilator for about 20 days and couldn't survive. If we listen to our mother and didn't admit her in GNRC HOSPITAL than I think my mother would have survived till now .
Is there any legal option to sue doctors for medical negligence?
Yes there is. But you have to legally prove the medical negligence
Hospital delay treatment, and unnecessary procedures for increasing patient bills and risk patients life.
There must be an overlooking body for these life threatening inhuman medical demons scam,
and keep check of what is correctly diagnosed patients condition, which must be proof on paper of tests of these condition, and what correct procedure they follow according to patients need.
There must be a government app that must be filled by doctors to with paper diagnosis an paper proofs that keeps them following strict procedure and save patient lives who are consumer.
They put pressure on doctor for unnecessary treatment and diagnosis
Excellent report, to be continue ...........
We need people like you brother
All these happens in Peerless Hospital in Kolkata as well. I have paid 64000 for investigation apart from other points in the bill on a daily basis, medicines 91000 and so on. Within a week, we had to pay more than 3 lakhs. Although the patient is dead, nothing can be done to this kind of so called hospitals. The so called Admins are also on their side. This is our life saving market.
Healthcare should be free . These hospitals should be banned.
How much you pay taxes?😂
I don't know if these things are still happening or not? But there are now rules and regulations for all these stuff that were happening. I knew about all these from the age of 10 as my whole family is of doctors