Indonesia: The Balance of Power in Asia
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
- Indonesia is at the heart of global geopolitical competition, being Southeast Asia's largest economy and most populous state. Their rapid development is putting them on track to hold the balance of power in the Indo-Pacific, yet the United States has focused very little on improving bilateral relations, increasing trade, or expanding military ties. Ireland, with its 5 million people, trades more with the US than Indonesia, with its 270 million.
We analyse the challenges Indonesia must overcome to fulfil its potential, and the importance it holds for the region and wider geopolitical interests in the Indo-Pacific.
To watch the full discussion: • The Geopolitics of Ind...
On the panel for this episode was:
Kyle Springer (US Asia Centre)
Natalie Sambhi (Verve Research)
Gordon Flake (US Asia Centre)
Animated by Marisa Rafter
Voiced by Michael Hilliard
Written by Michael Hilliard and Owen Swift
Concept Art by Marisa Rafter
For more information please visit - www.theredlinepodcast.com
Follow the show on Twitter - / theredlinepod
Follow Michael on Twitter on - / mikehilliardaus
My Germany buddy, as a telecom consultant said that Indonesia is very challenging, is not easy doing build the telecom, electrical, road, etc infrastructure in Indonesia. Not like India, Brazil or South Africa as the subcontinent country, Indonesia has 17.000 more islands, and 6.000 more are habitant. It's not easy connecting whole of islands, nature challange, earth quake, eruption, roughest sea, volcanic mountains, with thousand ethnic and local languages. with a million complex problems. Big country with big problems. How Indonesia become in one nation. He was still amaze.
Because we have the "Bhineka Tunggal Ika"
Local language is not even a problem, almost every Indonesian could speak national language
And that's the reason why internet in Indonesia is so slow.
Nice point. Country of Challenge.
Indonesia became one because lots of island considered themself a Muslim brotherhood
Don't worry, now youth Indonesia slowly but sure to be smarter than previous generation. We create more intelligent power day by day. Last time we are underestimated, but we are fast learning to moving toward. I am Indonesian and I have studied to another country to transfer technology and I was teaching in my country. I teach computers programmer, and so on. So my target I can create more people smarter than me. You will see so many youth people very smart and good skill such as electronics, they can make own electric motor, they can manufacturing etc. All can we make it in near future. Now Indonesia the biggest netizen in the world, internet just come one decade to my country. You will see the biggest technology growing in Indonesia. Because we have different gen than others country such as China, Korea, etc. We have hyper creative gen and this is our unique talent. I love my country Indonesia
aku cuma berharap sih, kalau orang indonesia itu yang harus dirubah dari segi perilaku dulu, ketaatan peraturannya juga harus diperhatikan sih. Percuma dong kalau negaranya udah jadi super power tapi orangnya belum :(
Not really i see that the genereations are smarter than before but gadgets,sosial media and racism are slowing the growth
@@Somebodythatiusedtoknoww uU from country giveaway 999🤣🤣🤣
@@zull914 wdym?
@@Somebodythatiusedtoknoww use human language, not animals!!! upzzz forgot 🤭 your country doesn't have language 🤣
2:21 give me goosebumps 😱... Thank you for discovering country that I love so much 🇮🇩 greeting from 🇷🇺 spasibo, let's go indonesia
😞😞
Uraaaa ... 🔥, Russian Brother ... 🇮🇩🤝🇷🇺
@@itsmebuddynkri4964 😏😏
@@Wagnerboyan -> What's your nationality Bro ... ?
@@itsmebuddynkri4964 apa kau 😶
Funny thing is that while in some military superpower like South Korea have something like a forced military service, in Indonesia some problem arise because too many people want to join the army
Edit: alright, my definition of superpower is wrong but imma keep it there
Lmao
fascinating to know
True.
@@asianman8712 even some people give money ... because they really want to be soldier
At heart, every Indonesian is born a soldier
As a Malaysian, would love to read more on this as the growing political and economic power of Indonesia will surely effects its neighbours
You guys should be ready if we Indonesia be attacked by east or west power, should Malaysia become non-alliance member with us.
I always dream of Nusantara Federation, once Indonesia is much more richer than today, we can keep our current political system in place just a united army and united foreign policy.. This way Indonesia and Malaysia can make join and stronger control of Mallaca Strait. I know a union is not a popular option right now as we both have different needs. But I see it as a future possibility with foreign threats..
@@bomba7197 are you Indonesian or Malaysian? Well if we just look our root race, we are one family (plus Brunei and Philippine). And the history of Ganyang Malaysia its because we are Indonesian try help Malaysian for escape and not ruling by western colonialist and imperialist, nah the effect if Malaysia still under west influence till now is joined west military pact. 🤐
@@YouOnUsPath Indonesian Student in Malaysia. Living in Malaysia just makes me more certain a federation is possible someday, tho not today.
@@bomba7197 what if we make an EU version of SE asia? Like a more advanced and upgraded ASEAN...
I think after reading The Jakarta's Method books, this country has been soft with the west since Soekarno's defeat in 1965. All their foreign policy might be soft-controlled by west too. On my notes, Indonesia once out from UN in 1964 that's bold and brave moves for new country. But, yeah agreed this country is a global trading crossroad. Indonesia can easily influence or maybe controlled global trading route.
Before 1965, we hate western bloc and love china and USSR. After 1965, we hate China and USSR, but love Western bloc. After 1998 anti Soeharto protest, we are NEUTRAL and pragmatic.
1965 was actually a bloody year for Indonesia, even some years after. at that time, especially september 30th, indonesian communist party launched a coup, but then succesfully wiped out by the official military. after that, as you say, Soekarno retired(?), replaced with Soeharto as the next president. from the day he became the president, till the day he retired, Indonesia sided with the west, the government even freeze the Indonesian embassy in China at the first era of his presidency. After Soeharto retired, some people said that we became neutral once more, but i don't think so.
@@arihs1729 Soekarno was a PKI friend. How come PKI launched a coup to him? It was not PKI that launched a coup. It was actually Soeharto.
@@nurnur-qo5sx it was against the government, meaning that they wanted to overthrow him too. it wasn't about friendship, it was about Indonesia's ideology. if PKI were to overthrow them, they would also change the national ideology. PKI also didn't want to get wiped out of the politics after Soekarno's era, that was also one of the reason why they launched a coup against Soekarno's government. they wanted to take control asap before his era ended. as for why he retired, he was kinda forced to. the people kinda felt betrayed by PKI actions back then. as Soekarno also had some friendship with PKI, they began to think that they had to replace him with a more-pro-Pancasila president. tho in fact, it was actually the provisional People's Consultative Assembly who revoked his position as the president.
as for Soeharto, i also have some suspicions towards him too. like just how did he get into power even tho he got a "mandate" from Soekarno himsel? he didn't even give an answer till death. so that was really suspicious.
@@arihs1729 PKI was predicted to win the indonesian election some years later. They didnt need a coup. And if they really launched a coup, they would kill Soekarno, not some TNI generals.
Indonesia is the key for both China and Australia. China will be foolish if they ever antagonized or even attack Indonesia knowing really well that Indonesia is emphasing neutrality policy which is rarity for a country as big as them, in the same time Indonesia is acting like "shield" protecting Australia from China's hard invasion coz the Chinese are gonna need to occupy the archipelago first before mounting the attack on Australia's soil.
China and Indonesia is actually BFF rather than to The West. In fact Australia will pay the price soon coz Nowdays Timor Leste already under control by China (Economic etc). And yes soon China will build up their military base there.
can u image how close Timor to Darwin is.. oh well good luck for Australia.
@@envoguecalifornia yes it works
@@envoguecalifornia yeah but theres will be a lot of resistance. I for one don't agree with the relations between Indonesia and the CCP (the ccp, NOT china.) Not because of the fact that theyre comunist based, but because of the unfair treatment and imprisonment of its own people a long with many foreigners that has been sent to camps, accused of something they havent done. The CCP is puppeting their people just like how we were puppeted before the revolt of 1998. I really fucking wish what Im saying is all bullshit, exagerated and unreal but its unfortunetly proving me right. And Im sure Im not the only one who knows about these information.
@@envoguecalifornia nope, if china really want to build military base in timor leste, they will make jakarta really angry, not just australia. and china really know about it. thats why china change their plan and try to make military base in solomon. and now, US and australia try so hard to stop this china's plan.
before solomon, china have plan to build a base in PNG in the first place, but it didn't going well, and this is because of indonesia too. PNG share border with west papua's indonesia. there is separatist group there and if china build a military base in PNG it will make jakarta really suspicious with their intention. the same reason why australia didn't have military base anymore in PNG
indonesia is a big country, we didn't want any fight with other nation. but if you disturbing us, we will make you pay the price really bad
@@envoguecalifornia nah... that's one among many reasons we invaded TL back in the 70s. If China want to do that, Jakarta will be happy to play it all over again, that ehm.... what's the name of the game recently? special military operation?
Doctrine among 255 milion Indonesia people : "Better to die than surrender to the enemy" .
This shows how much Indonesian people love their country.
They always says : "Freedom Or Death"
Its Yeagerist country
CRINGE overproud type
We SURRENDERED to the Dutch twice, and we will surrender to the CCP if we keep being weak like we are now
In Balinese we call puputan
279 million*
it an absolutely stupid nationalist attitude. Indonesians are being taught to defend their country.
1. From whom? Nobody wants to invade that place ever.
2. Indonesia doesn't even have enough weapons to defend itself and their over supply of population.
3. You are being taught to love your own people and YET you are the first ones to be corrupt for your own gains and corrupt against your fellow Indonesians. It is to the point where you steal, scam and take away the screws from your own bridges! Is that how you show love to one another?
All of the Indonesians are religious and must believe into one of the 6 religions? I see nothing but hypocrisy.
Indonesia has a very long way to go if it truly wants to live up to the bhinneka tunggal ika.
although in Indonesia there is no war but every army registration there are always many young people who want to join, being a soldier is pride in Indonesia, Because the army is more respected and trusted by Indonesians than the police, There are many military tasks that make people happy, such as building roads in villages, building bridges, help when there is a natural disaster, teaching in rural areas
@@nisc.a at least they're not the "tigers" if you know what i mean
@@thepinkwither138 no I dont know what you mean, kenapa tiger?
Because there is no job outside working in government salary like army
@@nisc.a pp pemuda pancasila is like the civilian organisation for idk originaly they only serve new order goverment bu after the suharto fall they rebrand themself as defender of pancasila in reality they just stealing peoplr money
@@thepinkwither138 careful cus you don't want to get your house raided by the Tigers themselves
I hope asean countries grow more solid. It's one of the most important thing in order for our region to grow in power.
This. 100% agree. We're not just neighbours. We're family
@@ditawihandoko3918 As a person from India, which influenced some nations in the ASEAN region, I tend to see India as a father/mother to the ASEAN. If the ASEAN does grow more solid then the whole world will benefit.
@@PasscodeAdvanceindia did have strong influence in the past (precolonialism period). but nowadays not really.
US: We are going to be the WESTERN superpower !
China: We are going to be the EASTERN superpower !
Indonesia: We are going to just sip the coconut water and relax on the beach. Now, who's coming?
Rofl XD best comment ever
LMAO...
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Count me in 😍😍😂😂
LOL Kita mah Santuuuy....selama ga diganggu
Amazing
The problem with Indonesia is, that it is too comfortable living here so the people are lazy and less ambitious, even when you mention poor citizen, poor citizen in Indonesia still eats 3 meals a day and owns a cellphone. There are no wars, the crime rate is low, and life is so mundane that a small celebrity mishap becomes a huge problem to us lol.
1000% TRUE! 😂 we are so lazy and quite content with our life. 😂
yeah lol, too good environment made us evolved into 270 million human that only use their mind to create a new shorcut toward the progress, but yeah, we rarely use our mind 😭
" Yaudah lah ya"
Nikmati hidup apa adanya, Tenang, aman damai, dan hidup bahagia✌️😁
Hahaha betul😂
As an Indian Would always support Indonesia... We share the same rich cultural heritage of the past.. we believe in our ancestors ... And even though Indonesia has become a Muslim country they still respect and preserve their ancestral heritage .. which i love and admire..
yeah, you'll easily find muslim guy named wishnu, krisna, bima, gatot, brahmana and etc 😂
I think is No wkwk
Indonesia mean Indian Archipelagos..
We are same, we are children of Noah
@@prasetyawirahartono8626 This doesnt happen in india.. though.. here muslims are moving away from thier cultural heritage and kind of arabising themselves.. :(
5:04 as the former Minister of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries of Indonesia, Susi Pudjiastuti, said, "sink 'em all!"
The only minister brave enough to have explosive traits
Too bad it was replaced....
@@icbm5389 the great lord luhut not like her.
Hey you got Princess Viktoria Luise of Prussia as your Profile Pict. What a man of culture.
Very informative video. I'd like to reiterate one thing though, that they are doing a good job in poverty. The poverty or villages in Indonesia (kampungs) are very different than that of China or India. They might be poor, but they have 3 meals a day, a cell phone, and internet avaliable. It's a fertile land with plenty of food for all. They are doing good with the electricity problem, I've seen power outlets in the literal JUNGLE at some little hut. How? Beats me..but progress is being made here
Yes, we can give 1/6 world food if we focus and work seriously about world civilization. But, again, we are still sleeping giant 😂
That right, i live in Desa/Kampung. Main problem is no spirit to do hard. It called " santai"
yep,we can eat directly from natural resources,thank god
Couldn't agree more 🤧🤧
some grandparents who live in the kampungs are richer than the average worker here, they own hectares of land but live very humbly 😂
I surprised you talked about Indonesia geopolitics without telling about non-alignment. Every time you ask an Indonesian which side Indonesian government is, they will almost always say non-alignment. Indonesia was even the one that create non-alignment movement during cold war through Asia-Africa Conference in Bandung (which probably piss America a lot because some of the country joining is strategically important and also a lot of countries that joined were kinda communist, even Indonesia itself). Every school thought that Indonesia foreign policy is free (non-alignment) and active (at mantaining peace). China is the largest Indonesia trade partner, but Indonesia also increase trade partner with US to counter-balance. Indonesian jet fighter come from Russia, US, and France. "the benefits of non-alignment is if the US blocks their arms trade, just buy from Soviet " - my legendary history teacher.
Example of recent non-alignment action, Australia is Indonesia's friend but when they joined AUKUS and talked about nuclear sub, Indonesia opposed, Indonesia opposed and responded by buying ship, submarine, and jet fighter from France (which also oppose AUKUS) because the government anticipate arms race in Southeast Asia. This was ironically restrain China control in South China Sea even more which was probably what Australia wants (of course Australia control was also restricted although I haven't heard news about that).
If you want to now the people's view, well, it's very random. The people don't like France, don't like US, like US, don't like Malaysia, love Australia (a lot), no opinion on China, no opinion on East Timor, like Bangladesh, love Saudi Arabia, like Turkey, hate Israel a lot, love Palestine. Keep in mind, this is just my lazy observation. The people's opinion varies a lot and can changes so much, you could almost say they hates all countries and overpo... actually you know what, I'm too lazy to write the rest, like a lot of this probably wrong already. Ignore 3rd paragraph. Time to get back to depression
Non alignment, no military alliance, zero loyalty.
I love my country...
I always said, kalau mau Indonesian maju, sebaiknya embargo diri sendiri drpd diembargo negeri luar
Ur a smart Guy, thanks for the information.
@@Si_nengatcha Presiden kita udh ngestop ekspor beberapa SDA ke luar negeri.
Non alignment only usefull if the strategic interest of the country are met... currently... the way i see it... it back-fired massively for indonesia...
@@hendrasutrisno4191 Why? We can get stuffs from all sides.
Indonesia had always been that slippery land that people sometimes avoid to talk about. That one point in history Indonesia was slightly tilted to the eastern block with its friendship with USSR, the local Communist Party staged a rebel that would later on recalled as a national tragedy which turned Indonesia's neutrality towards Communism into extreme hatred, now why would that happen so suddenly and at a critical stage of Cold War too, hm? Afterwards, a new president was installed and the new president for some reason leaned heavily to western block. When all of that had ended, none dared to have an open talk with Indonesia again. Russia kept the warm friendship but didn't overtly display affection like in the past with USSR and USA also maintained a pretty much indifferent and subtle approach. Why is this? It's not because the natural resource has run out, nope. In fact, it didn't really change much from the past, but no one dared to be as close as they used to be in the past.
Why? IMO, they're keeping the lukewarm status quo to keep in check the other side. They also mostly kept Indonesia out of the heavy talk because the least they need is more attention to Indonesia. Indonesia is like the forbidden land that everyone wanted but dared not to touch because it will, IT WILL, alarm your enemies who will do everything they could to destroy any budding affection you carved with it.
Don't forget the fact that the new president are a dictator in favor of the west and he got overthrown... Yes, because of that Indonesia become neutral again.
whenever big boys fighting for world dominance we are the one suffering from it. For them we are just a tools to further their agenda.
The communist lobby triggered Indonesia-Malaysia confrontation in 1963, the US lobby triggered the invasion of east timor in 1975.
The communist wanted to subvert the nation from the inside (madiun 1948), while the US literally funded, trained, and armed rebels in our territory (Permesta 1957).
Indonesia is a wildcard, a card you want to be in your hand when you're running out of options, not a card you want your opponent knows it's on your hand
The moment that card is revealed, the opponent would do anything they can to destroy its value.
That is why for Indonesia non-alignment is not a matter of political stance in the global stage, but it is also a matter of our survival.
We do not choose to be non-aligned, it is the only way we could continue to exists.
taek..
I'm Indonesian, finally.. somebody get the point that we're learned from the past. Once we betrayed the aim of our bloody freedom which had built by our founding fathers, we'll gonna fell apart. Our constitution mandate that we have to active to keep the world peace. So.. the world will always try to keep it that way..
💯 ✌️
I would say Indonesia is an impossible country to manage, since the lands and people are scattered into thousands of islands. Not to mention the country is huge, like.. HUGE. It makes the process of managing country is harder compared to a country in a single land.
But somehow, Indonesia 'magically' able to hold it's identity as a country so strong 👍
because here we have a slogan "unity in diversity"no matter what race,religion,or ethnic you are... you're indonesia
i know it's not easy because we went through so many war with seperatists and civil war but at this point nothing is impossible...these are the possibilities for indonesia's future :
either indonesia became the next yugoslavia
or indonesia will become a new global superpower
Sebenarnya alasannya gampang, kita melalui peristiwa berdarah yang mungkin tidak banyak diungkapkan. Namun hal itu memang diperlukan untuk membuat suatu identitas bangsa, karena bangsa Indonesia sendiri adalah bangsa yang baru tercipta sesaat sebelum merdeka tidak seperti kebanyakan negara lain yang memiliki akar yang sama
Kami mempunyai ideologi pancasila yang mampu mentukan semua perbedaan yang ada
Creating a single identity was crucial. And a single identity was created indeed. First by having the same enemy, the Dutch. For example, in early and late 19th century respectively, we had Cut Nyak Dhien in Aceh, and Pattimura in Maluku. Both were seperated so far away, almost 4000 km, with different cultures, different religions, different languages, but they were fighting the same enemy. That created a bond, and eventually an identity.
This was then strengthened by Sumpah Pemuda in 1928, which included Bahasa Indonesia as a language that unites all. Using a relatively new language as the national language, instead of choosing one of the local languages was also very important to the country's survival. This single identity, "Indonesia", has been engraved in our mind and heart our whole lives. That's what keeping this country as one nation, even though it seems impossible.
Yea we used to be divided into tribes and kingdoms before, until the white Europeans came and managed to unite the entire archipelago by being European.
Since then our founding fathers kinda indoctrinate many tribes into supporting the independence movement and managed to do exactly that, creating an identity as a nation based on unity and further indoctrinate the people into believing that they are part of Republic of Indonesia (and it works).
Our founding fathers managed to fool everyone, the Malays, Sundanese, Javanese, Papuans. Into becoming part of Indonesia without any cultural or historical basis at all, they all simply becoming Indonesians because apparently the founding fathers say so and he also say that colonization and imperialism is bad, which is something everyone agreed on.
So how did the Indonesian regime continued to survive and even developing despite the odds?
Indonesia is like that kid on school that very quite never talk or bother anyone but had some few friends. But once they got bullied he's ready to pull out his guns
Indonesia: Perfectly balance as all things should be
yes...
its our culture to made all thing balance..
we have biter experience century ago, and we learned from that case..
yeah, unlike in other countries where many of their people are identified as both their nationalism, their regional etnichity, and their religions, many Indonesian people are only identified themself as Indonesian
We have been testing the water..
When china fishing boats sailed around North Natuna...guarded by their guard boat... And then suddenly Indonesia carried out coal export ban... Only one month.
And China as a country that import 65 % of its domestic demand from Indonesia was Stunning...
And then
After Japan, Korea complained about the Indonesia coal export Policy.. followed by Jin Ping that phoned on Jokowi by direct call ,
Indonesia's Coal Export policy to China started to deliver it again.
BUT Amazingly.....and..
finally, There were no China Fishing boats anymore within Indonesia North Natuna sea.
Thats the Indonesian way...
Not too many talks..
just showing it's unpleasant gesture...
You knew it.. didn't you.
Yeah right ... that is Indonesian way
krn tiongkok yg sedang gambeg dg aussie, jadi utk urusan batubara ya hrs beli dr tempat lain
mau beli dr india? nggak bisa juga
Saya sepat bangga juga terhadap preden cina beliau berbicara terhadap tentaranya dan mengatakan indonesia bukan musuh indonesia bukan orang lain😊kami harus diam karna kami takut ada pihak ke 3 yang ikut campur dengan tujuan perdamaian palsu
Indonesia is a strong country.. they are able to face colonialism from the Portuguese, Spanish, Dutch, Japanese, British and even Americans in eastern Indonesia
Well, you will know Indonesian is so big when you must flight 6 hours(if direct) across 2 times zone and must pay same as ticket jakarta to haneda Japan for meet up with your GF. For flight from most East province to most West Province is around 8-10 hours direct.
really? that's so far
@@silverkun2141 yups, my current city is 4 hour flight (direct) from my hometown. My hometown is in the middle side of west time zone and my current city is In the west side of east time zone.
@@silverkun2141 yes, i think it's like a flight from london to new york
REAL FACT 🇲🇨 : Indonesia has a strong unity and a very strong country, Indonesia has many allies, and if Indonesia is attacked, it is difficult to control all the islands in Indonesia, and the attackers will not only fight the army but will also fight the peoples, all men and young people in Indonesia,, the people will be willing to die for the country, the Indonesian people have a history of fighting dutch, as a country with the most Muslims they believe defending the country means protecting religion and they consider it and called it "jihad", or death for religion, Indonesia has a saying "freedom or death"
And are your the one of the Suicide? yeah I know that why people does tell it's jihad don't say I don't know what is that. Bro it's sick thought u kill ur self?!! For the stupid stuff?! Why? Wheres the army so?! u get terrible for ur self u are a innocent people just a gimmick dumb toy, please don't do it! if ur all still have an army u will be safe this is for ur prices.
Noo!, No! No! SMH, so that's why people were coming be Islamophobic and call most of Muslims was The Terrorist 'cuz SORRY TO SAY* But this to overly insane, don't u thought u get fighting like tht and kill for strangers and make u dangerous for all the most of innocent peoples and don't know whose the people u will be face up.. u will be killing the innocents people of the most..
Doctrine among 255 milion Indonesia people : "Better to die than surrender to the enemy" .
This shows how much Indonesian people love their country
@@youngalfa8684 aku pun sebagai wanita dan warga indonesia kalau negaraku di usik jiwaku terus meronta ronta darahku mendidih dan marah sangatt...
🇲🇨fact. Real 🇮🇩 indonesia
Merdeka atau mati 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
3:35 as an eastern Indonesian, i can say this is not really..
Yes It's common to see a house with the solar system built in. Especially at some places which the national electricity company does not reach yet. But by the time, they slowly penetrate as the infrastructure growth by the present gov.
in jokowi era we can significantly see the increase of infrastructure in rural areas
building infrastructure in an archipelagic country is very difficult but Indonesia has started to do it
"House with the solar system built in".........
The "nearby" K2 civilization would like to know your location.
@@death_parade "The power of the sun in the palm of my hand"
Siapapun pemenangnya (US/China), Indonesia haruslah menjadi Basis Manufacturing dari global chain perusahaan-perusahaan global karena selama ini Indonesia hanya di jadikan Pasar oleh Thailand dan Vietnam ( otomotif dan elektronik/ponsel), keputusan yang paling tepat adalah jangan sampai Indonesia terlalu menunjukkan kemampuannya dalam berpolitik internasional sebelum Indonesia dijadikan Base oleh Manufacturing Dunia...( ASEAN telah mengambil keuntungan yang terlalu besar dari yang seharusnya mereka peroleh dari Indonesia)
semua tergantung dari para tokoh dan pemimpin Indonesia ke depannya. jika masih mementingkan kelompok dan kroninya, masih mudah tergiur dgn "fee atau komisi" dari para oligarki pengimpor dan distributor, maka selamanya hanya akan jadi "pasar".
@@bambang9897Dan juga pedagang² Indonesia. Semoga Indonesia ada perusahan yang terkenal di dunia luar selain Indofood
@@Mr_Schizo seperti Jerman di Europa union, mengambil profit terlalu banyak dan lebih besar dari negara EU yg lain
@@afdalridwan3813Hmmm. Kira² german akan membuat sebuah dinasti baru lagi gak karena kekayaan mereka?
Benar
Terima kasih sir for explain about my country 🇮🇩 and its potential in current era (from geopolitic until economy)
Indonesia love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤️❤️❤️
Indonesia need to solve their socioeconomic problem very quickly. We from the neighbors believe it will bring more good than harm to the region in general. 🤝
@Wangseng Gaming mesti ke plosok pulau lu, biar tau semiskin apa penerima blt yg nyatanya ga dapet blt krn saking terisolirnya
Singaporean here, we invest alot in Indonesia and have seen its economy skyrocket in recent years while Malaysia's economy stagnate. But recently Islamic fundamentalism is creeping back and it might really dampen decades of economic progress but luckily its people and leaders are choosing to keep extremist ideologies at bay and follow what makes a economy tick
Yep, even Indonesian realized that Extremists are big problems. It's even an open secret that Armed force officers are dominated by either Christian or moderate muslim.
@@Kevin-fj5oe You know shits hits the fan when even the largest Muslim majority country in the world starts to recruit non Muslims and less fanatical muslims
@@worlds3061 well, Indonesia aren't Islamic state, but secular state that recognize few religions. And where else you have chinese new year as official holiday's in muslim majority countries.
@@Kevin-fj5oe Like i said "Muslim majority country" mas
@@worlds3061 yes
considering indonesia has 7000 islands it is very impresive they have stayed united and become a sleeping giant
17000
+ 10.000
@@nisscharostislav4951 most of them are tiny islands with like 8 people on them
@@izumikonomi3320 the majority is not interested, for what? Lmao its just minor issue (framed as big in msm).
@@izumikonomi3320 Data please, how big? Statistically? Or only in your spread mouth propaganda?
Great brief explanation but I wish you would mentioned a little bit more about Indonesia's "Free-Active" foreign policy and its relevancy today and decades to come.
Indonesia is a democratic country, which means a country led by the people... if Indonesia goes to war it can be estimated that the number of Indonesian soldiers will be at least 10 million depending on the availability of weapons.
lucky Indonesia can make rifles, missiles, tanks, panzers, submarines, battleships, airplanes, radars, drones and many more..
*warships
Iyah tau gk usah norak
the good old bambu runcing.
sudah kuduga bahwa masyarakat Indonesia itu rata rata tentara 😂 emang sih...bila wilayah aku disini di serang orang ya tak tembak orang tersebut 😂
Indonesia berpotensi menjadi negara besar di masa mendatang. Negara berpengaruh di dunia.
Di negara lain orang-orang lari dari militer .. di indonesia orang-orang berebut masuk militer. Sampai ada orang-orang yang ikut berkali-kali tes untuk masuk menjadi bagian dari militer.
tbh demand masuk militer di indonesia nggak lebih dari dorongan narsistik,nggak heran banyak yang pake jalur "belakang",kan yang penting berseragam.
The thing about Indonesia is that they seems to have little to no ambitions to dominate SEA, they don’t really meddle with other people’s issues and they’re very preoccupied with internal issues. Could be a dangerous thing because everyone’s friend usually ended up being friendless in conflict, and looking at their past confrontation with Malaysia, no one seems to side with them in any issue whatsoever.
Indonesia just has too many problems at home and forget the problems outside. and mostly, it is because of free and active (bebas aktif) foreign policy. we are really welcome cooperation in economy, but not in military
because of free and active (bebas aktif) foreign policy
no one sided with Indonesia then because Indonesia had crossed the line. After Britain gave sovereignty to Malaysia there was a faction that wanted to join Indonesian republic and Indonesia reaction was to send military support to that faction in other word to annex Malaysia. That's just wrong. UK couldn't just let that happened. So UK sent their military support to Malaysia. Thx for UK, if not Indonesia could have just swallowed that region.
@Crazy Airman It is the lobby from PKI and the comintern to support the sarawak communist organization in their fight for independence, Soekarno just paying back to the communist after their help in the Trikora, where Indonesia gain massive military aid especially the air force. At the peak of the conflict Indonesia is among the strongest airforce in Asia, sporting the latest soviet technology like Mig 21 even the first time (and only one of two nations) non-communist nation ever received the long range strategic bomber Tupolev Tu-16, sending a huge red flag for the US.
@Crazy Airman if you can read Indonesian you can try reading the book "Sukarno, tentara, PKI: segitiga kekuasaan sebelum prahara politik, 1961-1965" by Rosihan Anwar.
He is a well respected journalist and historian from the era, this book is his memoir of early days of Indonesia with all of its bad and ugly side
I as an indonesian would love to see the day where ASEAN become one.. internally trading with one another, rather than try to please the giant overlords like the U.S. or China.. there is just something beautiful where small nation united and grow TOGETHER..
but alas.. only in dreams and unicorn land where that can be achieved..
LOVE TO ALL ASEAN MEMBERS~
Hebatnya adalah para bapak pendiri bangsa kita, Indonesia, berpesan "Janganlah kebarat-baratan juga ketimur-timuran." Kultur dan sistem kerajaan masih terasa, dari undang-undang dan juga ideologi Pancasila serta semboyannya yang diambil dari kitab Sutasoma yang isinya kurang-lebih mengandung toleransi.
Balik lagi ke dalam ideologi Pancasila, ideologi Pancasila singkatnya menunjukkan wajah bangsa Indonesia. Berketuhanan dan sosialis. Adab dan demokrasi. HAM dan persatuan. Jadi tak heran jika Indonesia sejatinya adalah negara yang berbeda dengan negara lainnya. Hampir tiap baris kita punya perbedaan tapi persatuan harus ditegakkan.
Jika sekali saja negara kita mengalami revolusi mungkin kita akan maju lebih dari selangkah ke depan menyongsong hari yang lebih baik. Saat ini kebanyakan dari kita masih tertidur nyenyak dengan keadaan yang diberikan oleh kemajuan zaman. Singkat saja, jika kita bisa merubah sistem pemerintahan kita ke arah yang lebih baik maka tidak dipungkiri kita bisa lebih maju dari negara lainnya tapi untuk itu kita harus memperkuat nilai hukum dan membubarkan lembaga negara yang tidak penting.
Indonesia is so independent, even their worst enemy is themselves.
Indonesia is INFJ confirmed
Is irony but that the fact…
this video is insanely well made, i can't believe you don't have more subscribers
With the current geopolitical state that Indonesia is currently in, I don't think Indonesia will be able to tie themselves as an ally with the US because of how reliant we are as a country to China. Non-alignment is definitely the best move, for now.
wel, it is US's fault for being ignorant on the SEA region for a long time.
@@clockworkschannel4691 waktu obama jadi presiden sebenarnya sdh punya grup di pasific yaitu tpp
tapi tdk semua anggota asean ikut, sop nya sedikit rumit
tapi waktu trump jadi presiden langsung keluar tpp dan bikin tiongkok kena sop yg lebih ketat
krn tiongkok menerapkan sop yg ketat utk brg usa jadilah asean adalah mitra yg paling diandalkan
perdagangan asean-tiongkok naik drastis ketimbang usa-asean
trump mungkin senang ketika datang di acara wto
tapi nyatanya produk usa kurang kompetitif
tiongkok stop import kedelai usa, beli dr brasil dan argentina
petani kedelai usa yg merana
cmiiw
even US itself is dependent on china.. all of their stuffs are made in china.
The US could've been a close ally for Indonesia since a long time ago if only JFK wasn't assassinated. JFK actually had similar ideals to Soekarno and according to Kurschev, the 2 presidents were pretty close.
But sadly, JFK died early, and Soekarno went on a really dark path since then. Things keeps getting worse for us until reformation era finally ends with Jokowi becoming the 1st Indonesian president with no ties to Soekarno's old order or Soeharto's new order, Indonesia was able to focus more on economy and military since then. Let's hope we can continue to be better in 2024
Interesting comments and accounts to be read here. Indonesia tries very much to become a world balancing power, through various leaders and governments it has not without its challenges as monetary, social, and cultural developments especially since the latter half of the 20th century has been so rapid. As the initiator of the Non-Alligned Movement during the Asia-Africa Conference in 1955 in Bandung, West Java, Indonesia’s foreign policy has always been “free and active”. This, Indonesia believes, will keep the balance of world powers in South East Asia. Despite the fact that Singapore and the Philipines have alligned themselves more to the USA, and Malaysia and Brunei also being a member of the British Commonwealth, I believe they are not puppet countries of the West. Indonesia and ASEAN must be neutral to maintain peace in South East Asia and not become entangled the politics of the US, China, Taiwan etc.
👍
Thanks, it's an great honor for us 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩
As a Bangladeshi, i find this so intriguing.
Such interesting geopolitical scenarios.
This is making me restless.
ill not big at talk...
just remind..: we have many books about future prediction ... and there is 85% acurate..
1. this country is the true UN , Indonesia has experience to handle diversity
2. Our basic culture is enchance beautifull world more and more.
3. we avoided war as much as we can, but if it comes, we will never surender.. ( its our culture )
4. about economic, we have guranted about it.. we always balancing ourself among civilian.
5. our goverment is not realy used, they can sleep anyway.. but our comunity will start growing even slow.. but for sure.
where is the fact??? come here, and you will understand, why we always confidence about Peace and Happines, also unity this world under Balance of Peace
On paper we Indonesia will never aligned ourselves to either one becouse our constitution told us not to do so
In reality we might be, but because nothing is formal we pretty much flexible. I believe the superpower know that
The strategic need no longer support neutrality... it is more of hinderance in my opinion
@@hendrasutrisno4191 nope.. neutrality is tested when critical moment come.. if goverment cannt handle the neutralize,,, the civilian will spoke with their own way
@@lazirmodernwarung1315 when critical moment come... it is too late to change anything
@@hendrasutrisno4191 nope.. fakta membuktikan indonesia selalu bertahan dari krisis apapun, dan terus berbahagia..
sudah jadi tabiat orang indonesia untuk terus menjaga keseimbangan dalam dirinya..
masalah akan selalu ada, tapi bangsa kita bangsa yang survive di segala kondisi..
saya bisa memberikan ribuan halaman penjelasan beserta bukti kongkrit kenapa Indonesia akan menjadi negara penyeimbang dunia di masa depan.. dan mampu melewati segala masalah sampai titik minus sekalipun ( critical moment )
@@lazirmodernwarung1315 bertahan itu ada harga nya juga lhooo gan...
Krisis 65,98 itu ada harga nya...
Kalau kita bicara kolektif ya bertahan tapi ada harga yng dibayar...nyawa,harta, waktu
Permasalahan kondisi sekarang dak seperti dulu seperti komen saya dibagian... bukan Soviet-US yng terjadi jauh disana sehingga sini maen imbang2an... Indonesia sendiri ZEE nya senggolan sama China...bisa flexible? See flexible menyerahkan zee natuna ke china?
anda jangan cuma melihat jumlah Militer tentara INDONESIA 400.000 , lihat lah kedalam negara INDONESIA bangsa yang mempunyai 150 ORGANISASI MASYARAKAT lebih, mereka semua mempunyai Paramiliter, salah SATU ORGANISASI TERBESAR DI INDONESIA bahkan DUNIA tahun 2023 mempunyai paramiliter 7 juta lebih, yang siap MENJAGA NEGARA KESATUAN REPUBLIK INDONESIA. NKRI HARGA MATI. 😊
U know what
If we look carefully, Indonesia exactly look's like Europe, has the same empire that qonquer the surrounding kingdom
But Europe never unite and always in war, while in musantara it's kingdom has less war and more trade, Europe has desert that full of more kingdom to do war with them in South and Viking in the nort that always sack and attack them, while musantara don't, only a desert continents that has so many deadly animal like emu and normal tribe in the South and more normal kingdom that always kill each other in the nort
But both safe from mongol invasion, but Europe fight the mongol directly and musantara use talk no jutsu to trick them so one guy can create an empire and unite the musantara (majapahit empire)
And that's why Europe qonquer the world and musantara not
Mainland SEA : war
Maritime SEA : Trade ?
@@Kevin-fj5oe trade is love trade is life
- some asian economist
Less war but more trade? What kind of hstory book do you read? The most important is that indonesia is not an imperialist, but west does
@@rumighazali8984 thats why nusantara never qonquer the world just like what europe do
If only nusantara spend their whole history in war, I bet nusantara will focus their life in inventing the best weapon possible, just like other European country
If only many nusantara king didn't spend their fking life in peaceful everyday life, nusantara might be full of imperialism country
Don't u know why Netherlands took 3 Fking hundred years to qonquer nusantara? That's because when they come, nusantara already had cannon and gunpowder gun
Nusantara not Musantara
South East Asia in general is an important area that will play a key role in the future O.O
Yeah, Because their sea is a global tool road, if South East Asia sea in war like middle east or Ukraine, There would highly raised price for many comodities, Trust me, This World owe Indonesia so much to keep South East Asia sea keep in peace
Most parts of the Maritime Southeast Asia are predominantly parts of the continental Nusantara Archipelago.
Kuncinya koruptor dihukum mati itu yang akan membawa Indonesia menjadi negara maju
I think the issue with America in Southeast Asia goes beyond only Indonesia. There should be very heavy work being done both diplomatically and economically with all of ASEAN and, in particular, the 5 tiger cub economies and Singapore. Even if it’s just to guarantee neutrality which Southeast Asia tends to favour anyways. Being between India, China, and America has incredible economic potential that Singapore took full advantage of. Indonesia, Thailand, Vietnam, Malaysia, and the Philippines are probably the most important countries on the planet to gain the favour of going forward. America hasn’t seemed to fully grasp how important this is yet. Luckily, Japan and Australia have with both pouring tons of FDI into the 5 and Australia cooperating a lot with Indonesia in counter insurgency operations training.
What? America grasp over South East Asia is so apparent. Philippines literally just colony of US. Malaysia always favored America, they let US operated on their sea to spy over South China Sea. Indonesia once had pro western and America regime, banned Chinese culture and oppressed Chinese.
INDONESIA bisa bangkit berdaulat ketika pemerintah berhasil lepas dari para investor dengan mewujudkan industri dalam negeri melalui BUMN tanpa campur tangan asing
as the largest archipelagic country in the world with a vast sea area, Indonesia has great potential to become a superpower and leader of Asia and a balance between the two great powers, needs a lot of improvement and improvement in performance as well as production and economic productivity, improving the quality of human resources, and needs leaders. big visionary to make Indonesia a developed country superpower in the future
Jika sukarno tidak dikudeta suharto mungkin dari dulu indonesia sudah mempunyai rudal nuklir😂
Really great video. So nicely explained.
Siapapun dan dimanapun, kita adalah saudara, budaya dan bangsa adalah perbedaan yang bisa di satukan lewat cinta dan toleransi
FYI, the constructionof the New Capital City, which named Nusantara, has begun, and when the government finally move from Jakarta to Nusantara I believe the state of Indonesian geopolitics landscape will drastically change. Or maybe it won't, idk.
emang ibukota jadi pindah?
@@silverkun2141 2024 bos siap gk siap akan di pindah
Gak setuju saya dibikin namanya jadi Nusantara. Gak kreatif dan terkesan mengabaikan orang-orang lokal.
@@hanggaraaryagunarencagutuh7072 ya kan mewakili seluruh indonesia gmn sii
Cold War make Indonesia as Domino for western and eastern bloc. If USSR can still make Ir. Soekarno believe at them, that was a victory for eastern bloc in SEA region, but the reality is western bloc succesfully erased Ir. Soekarno from Indonesia's politic with an coup d'etat by the Military with the justified to purge the communist party and they supporter. But, in the end the military also killed some intellectual person (like university college students) also many Soekarnoism or Soekarno is supporter.
But why Soekarno must be removed from Indonesia's politic? Because Soekarno main projects is make Indonesia to independence from all means, like in foreign policy the president want to Free and Active policy that make Indonesia can 'befriend' all country and all nation.
Another reason is, Soekarno was a socialist and want to make NASAKOM (Nasionalism, Religious, Communist) he want to make like United Front for 3 parties, PNI or Indonesian Nasionalist Party, all Religious parties, and the Indonesian Communist Party or PKI.
Some faction seen this as threat for them, one of those is the Military faction from I like say old guard who are trained under the colonial.
In the end, CIA and the Military successfully removed Soekarno from Indonesia's politic and make a new regime under military restrictions for 32 years and fall in 1998.
And now, Indonesia is under the Oligarchy is control. Just look at the cabinet and how many oligrachs are on the Senate and National Assembly.
BETTER OLIGARCHS THAN THE USELESS BUREAUCRATS! How many projects went from zero to zero because our bureaucrats are so corrupt and slow?? you lot so proud of indomie yet it is own by oligarch. lol the fact is oligarch is the engine of economy growth of every country from US, to Japan, and China. why? because they have expertise/capability, and will power to make something out of nothing.
Trade alone is not a good enough indicator of strategic influence. You need to look at history, geography, demographics, supply lines etc. This is an extremely narrow view of geopolitics. To imply that the USA has no interest because of trade deficits between countries is a useless artifact.
Exactly. Historically speaking, Chola empire of india even launched naval raids to their rival Srivijiaya empire of Indonesia, similarly to Yuan of china who did the same centuries later to the Singashari of Indonesia, within their each respective era.
even portugese, british, and netherland were fighting one another to estabilish colonial supremacy in the archipelago. need no more explaination in this aspect I believe
even more so in other aspects. demographic for example. 4th most populous country, largest muslims population too.
This video is simply lacking in depth
For sure, US influence is historically and deeply entrenched in Indonesia Military (TNI). This US reach in Indonesia defence and security sphere has sometimes offseted China’s enormous economy influence in Indonesia like in recent case of Natuna’s EEZ breached by Chinese Fishermans and Coast Guard. The EU also has strong influence in TNI which solidify the notion that in terms of defence and security, Indonesia is leaning towards the West
@@camovault true, for economy we go to China, for military we go to the west. Though for military we're still going for the west hardware but also detaching away from US dependency.
ill not big at talk...
just remind..: we have many books about future prediction ... and there is 85% acurate..
1. this country is the true UN , Indonesia has experience to handle diversity
2. Our basic culture is enchance beautifull world more and more.
3. we avoided war as much as we can, but if it comes, we will never surender.. ( its our culture )
4. about economic, we have guranted about it.. we always balancing ourself among civilian.
5. our goverment is not realy used, they can sleep anyway.. but our comunity will start growing even slow.. but for sure.
where is the fact??? come here, and you will understand, why we always confidence about Peace and Happines, also unity this world under Balance of Peace
Kekuatan nyata di Indonesia🇮🇩 ada di rakyatnya yang cerdas, terdidik oleh sejarah yang panjang,
Sehingga mampu menempatkan diri di atas pergaulan dunia yang netral.......
Sampai jumpa di pertemuan G20 sebagai bukti kematangan Indonesia🇮🇩 dalam pergaulan dunia🌏
Uraaaa........
As an indonesian, i can't agree more with Kissinger. It is fatal to be a friend of the US. My view is reinforced after seeing how the US treats it's close ally Germany with the Nordstream ops. We do have problem with China, but we would be in crisis if we invite the US. The last thing we need is a foreign hegemon. Either we make peace through strength with China, or... there is no ''Or' for us this time. I support an indonesian nuclear program, 100%. ASEAN needs a powerhouse of it's own, it's time we take care of our own house. Build up of defence industry will kick up high tech sector boom. It will be a high tech sector that produces real tech like hypersonics and space-related products, not just a lame app for payment or chatting.
Indonesia IS THE POWER ;
Not just a balance of power.
Thank You.
relationships made during cold war were really important
just look at Russia and India
Indonesia🇲🇨 luck is with you because you don't have an immediate threat from your neighboring countries that's why your country only spend 0.8% of your gdp on defence i.e. 7 to 8 billion dollars, keep up the hard work. Unlike us Indian🇮🇳 us we got neighbors like pakistan and china, that's why we have to spend 2% of our gdp in defense i.e. 60 to 70 billion dollars. If we had good neighbors we need not had to spend that much amount on defence rather we would have spent it on building schools, education and new businesses.
Just make friends, use soft power with both countries, treat them like friends and they will treat you the same
@@imgoodboy123 geopolitics doesn't work that way bro.
Not really most indonesian peoples see both Australia and china as a threat
@@widodoakrom3938 bro it's not treat it's threat.
@@Trilok_world sorry my grammar
4:08 If Indonesia has a large military power at sea, equivalent to a super power country, then international sea lanes can be used as a profitable source of income. other schemes involve big countries such as the USA, PRC, Russia, to participate in 'getting' part of the international seaborne "security insurance" in the Indonesian Archipelagic Sea Lanes (ALKI 1, 2, and 3).
Equivalent? Indonesia dosen't even have aircraft carriers nuclear submarines destroyers that can match big powers.
There are 3 major straits that happen to be the toll gate for international sea lane.. Somehow its remind me of silk road, but now rebuild as Sea Road..🤔🤔
Ini sarkas luar biasa
@@riderchallenge4250tunggu waktunya brow tetap indonesia akan mempunyai nuklir untung mengimbangi autralia
@@motengfreeTV1990 bukannya asean ada kebijakan jangan bangun senjata nuklir ya? Jadi gamungkin indi bakalan bangun senjata nuklir
Unlike Europe in the past. Indonesia as a power would like to stay away from the blue or red. The nation would like to be an intermediary nation, because it bodes well with them geopolitcaly.
The nation is currently on the way of achieving such goal, slowly stabilizing it's territory and developing their eastern region. And in current time, should an outside power try to disturb via planned 'subterfuge', it will possibly tilt the country's alignment dramatically.
Country's relationship toward any outside power is simple; be nice and they will be nice in return, be hostile and they will retaliate.
In layman term, the fuck around and find out diplomacy
Interesting video! Also liked how you edited it.
Glad you enjoyed it, you can thank the amazing Marisa Rafter for that one.
I can't believe this video got recommended to me
I hope you will get more subscribers
the united states didn't care until finally china started investing then they started to care🙃🙃
Average us move
To be honest, I also think the majority of the Indonesian Muslim majority (at least 85% of the population) tend to have bad views about the West, and our govt probably knows this. This negative view probably emerged since the US' Iraq stuff, but rest assured Indonesia has fought against the Western influence (not the West itself) in SEA region since many of the CIA's blackmailing & intelligent efforts on Soekarno & the nation in general happening in the 1960's.
(During Soekarno's Old Order era, Soekarno made Indonesia non-aligned (not East, not West), but he has a political(ly personal?) attachment to Beijing & Moscow and left wing ideologies at that time)
India is not a US ally typically...
Its more of a strategic partner...
We have relationships with Russia and the US at the same time so its in the middle...
But yea, China is India's greatest foe so no doubt...
India is it's own power. We're not in the camp of anyone. If today we talk about Washington and Beijing. I strongly feel that in 20 years from now, we will say Washington, Beijing and New Delhi. That's how it should be and that's how it will be and we can already see the birth of this tripolar world in today's asia. India had 25% of the world's money and if history really does repeat itself, it sure af will with India.
@@RS-ko9fx if that happens, I would be happy...
We really never want a conflict with the Chinese or basically anyone...
@@chrismathewjoseph1283I have a question. Why Indian ppl like to shiting on the public area like beach
@@Mr_Schizo that r4c1st
We still have many many fixing our country stop disrespecting everyone 🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@Mr_SchizoI like Indonesia but not a trash talker like you. If there was no India then your whole island nation would have been colonised by Europeans and it still would remain their part.
i love the new video style .
Officially , India never sided with any block as it was the founder of Non Alignment movement.
Indonesian 🇮🇩 strength comes from the roots of their civilisation, namely Bhineka Tunggal Ika mean united in diversity by upholding humanity, tolerance, democracy, and the noble ideals of social justice.
Indonesia, the most blessed people in the world, that's why we have very complex problems...Masya Allah 🤲🏼
Great content. Especially about the importance of Indonesia. A few small corrections though. Thailand, Vietnam, and the Philippines are US allies. Myanmar is not quite in the China camp. And India is too large to side with anyone.
Nope, Thailand & Vietnam play in the middle, especially Thailand as they always been. Only The Philippines belong to US interest, opening their legs allowing US military based but not much in return
@@paranoya733 as a filipino myself i dont know where all the hatred and sentiments and anti-american feeling from Filipino-American War (the philippine insurgency) have went on those almost 3 decades of american occupation.
@@paranoya733 and philippines was semi neutral only holding favourable views on america... and a little bit of china that almost all US base are gone. Only until Xi got the leadership and all those claims (and Duterte almost bowing to Xi but went unconcluded) that the philippines openly went back to US military dependency.
They wanted neutral only adaptation according to the threat, when the Americans sided with the Dutch at the beginning of the war irian Indonesia asked for Soviet help, if china threatened then approached the west, and vice versa
@@paranoya733 that's old news. the ph government's focus is independent foreign policy without US interests blocking it's priorities. that's why duterte does what he did to US relations. there are no more US military bases in the philippines since the 90s and for the past decades, the joint military exercises are repeatedly threatened to be removed.
Indonesia is growing so fast and now become the member of G20... They are hard working people...
But not as good as Chinese peoples
nope, they are lazy people with good habit that act like hard working people, they got many bless and still didn't use it fully, i'm not even sure if they already use 10% of it
Awesome, informative short video. Will be revisiting the episode!
Glad you enjoyed it!
This channel’s quality deserves millions of subs
Aku bangga menjadi rakyat Indonesia ✊✊✊
Indonesia is a non block country..
which means all we wanted is peace for everycountry on this earth
Its hard to take this seriously when you think Philippines is a neutral country with US military bases on it and India is siding with the US while having no American military bases on it.
INDONESI🇮🇩 is a sleeping giant, rich nature, ethnic and cultural diversity, if Indonesia is able to process its natural resources properly and end corruption, one of the superpowers
And might be China's rival.
I totally agree, it is very possible that Indonesia will compete with China
They are more concerned about Australia getting the nuclear sub.
No. We're not
Red Chinese propaganda has worked then..
@@kaptenhiu5623 Yes, in the name of non-alignment. In response, Indonesia buy more ship and fighter jet from France, something that China (and maybe Australia but not sure) doesn't want
we hate them both when it comes to prpxy war
@@kaptenhiu5623 Yes we are
Sayangnya indonesia tidak sehebat itu. Bayangkan, produsen sawit terbesar, tapi minyak mahal. Banyak tambang emas, batubara, tapi rakyat sekitar tambang miskin. Garis pantai terpanjang, tapi garam impor. Negara agaria, tapi beras impor. Daging impor. Bayangkan.
Saya harap, anda perlu belajar lagi, dan perlu menggali informasi yang lebih dalam lagi.....sekali-kali ngopi yang agak jauhan dikit.
@@ipunksoboparan7577 itu fakta apa bukan?
SDA hampir semua ada, eh pendapatan per kapita terendah kedua di antara negara2 G20, klo Indonesia lbh sdkt penduduk udh pasti nggak masuk G20
@@ardi08 berarti juga terbalik dong kalo indonesia lebih kecil pendapatan rata2 nya juga lebih besar? Kritik mulu ah dek
@@ardi08 ASBUN HAHAHA. India bahkan gpd perkapita nya cuma setengahnya Indonesia
Our bebas-aktif/free-active policy doesn't mean we wouldn't choose a side, but we choose what side benefits/align with our policy and needs. At the moment, the trade situation is balanced but the armed force is definitely leaning toward the west.
Imagine if countries like India , Indonesia , Philippines, Sri Lanka , Oman and Egypt form their own bloc
Indonesian people very brave strong together and strong army
Indonesia is a country with a population of more than 270 million, with 718 regional languages, tolerance here is very high🙏💕🇮🇩
Sekarang 279 million jiwa🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
*Indonesia 🇮🇩 and for that matter every TROPICAL country should know that the structure of everything in this world, is determined by uv ir...high energy to low energy... there's highest energy in the tropics... everything else is just the low energy arrangment and nothing else*
3:47 It is very true, I ordered stuff from Japan which came exactly one month and only took me around $23 to ship to Java while my parent once have to wait 6 whole months for a package from Papua to arrive. Only cost them $3 tho.
This video deserve more views.
Kami Bangsa Indonesia bangsa yg besar dan bermental baja... Kita welcome jika negara lain ingin bergandeng tangan mewujudkan perdamaian dunia dan kami bangsa yg rela mati demi kedaulatan Negara Indonesia... perlu di ingat nenek moyang kami orang yg ramah tamah dan orang-orang yg rela mati demi memerangi penjajahan
What weird about Indonesia is that for some reasons they are very close to Russia. Even if the government didn't act like that, but there are plenty of Indonesians out there that actually support Russia on this war.
😂😂😂😂uraaaaaaaaaa
Saya ingin sekali di rekrut debagai tentara bayaran tapi pemerintah meminta kita netral
well, i think it's because past indonesia - uni soviet relationships, but indonesia still keep their neutrality, and threat both ukraine & russia like 'normal' countries
Great video!
Well hello there. Found this video under your indonesia video. Keep up the great work!
Greetings from Philippines mabuhay
Good analysis and perspective. Now Indonesia order hundreds fighters like Rafale and F 15, submarines to strengthen their navy and air force. Indonesia want to take more role in Asia Pacific.
Mana buktinya udah order? Sudah teken kontrak?
@@kang_sapar udah deal bro makanya lihat berita Jangan kartun terus yang ditonton
@@nasrullahilham4171 sudah teken kontrak dan sudah efektif kontraknya? Ada link beritanya efektifnya kontrak itu? Dan juga DSCA tentang F15 sudah apa sudah rilis? Kalau kau taunya deal berarti 100% jadi dan ga ada link berita kontrak efektif atau rilis DCSA mending ikutan nonton kartun aja..
@@kang_sapar bnyak2 lihat berita dari orang dalam bang. info2 seperti ini sulit didapat dari luar
@@martiskun8221 komen safruddin yg aku balas komennya itu karena dia bilang kita sudah order rafale sama f15, sedangkan kalau bicara bahasa "sudah order" berarti kontraknya sudah deal semua (spek dan cara pembayarannya) kita tinggal tunggu barang dibuat.
Aku ga pungkiri pembicaraan selama dalam proses pengadaan ga akan diumbar ke publik, dan aku ga tertarik bahas masalah spek maupun harga barang tersebut karena itu bukan konsumsi publik, namun setelah pembicaraan dan terjadi deal akan dokumen resmi, seperti misal amerika memperbolehkan kita membeli f16 atau rudal air to air, maka akan muncul di DCSA dan itu menurutku diatas 90% akan terealisasi.
Sekali lagi safrudin diatas bilang kita sudah order, arti sudah order berarti masalah harga dan spek sudah deal, kapan barang akan dikirim sudah deal, kapan pembayaran dilakukan sudah deal dan kita hanya tinggal tunggu barang datang, cuma di DCSA aku belum nemu amerika sudah ngeluarin pemberitahuan bahwa kita beli f15 dari mereka.
Jangan sampai gembar gembor media kita akan beli su35 dan beli kasel kilo akhirnya cuma jadi berita, keburu youtuber di indonesia udah koar koar bikin berita bombastis didukung komen komen netizen kita yg ga nglakuin search and research dulu sebelum komen, sekarang akhirnya jadi serangan balik dan jadi memalukan kita sendiri.
Ingat ! Aku tidak mempermasalahkan proses ordernya (spek dan harga) karena itu bukan konsumsi publik. namun aku hanya mempermasalahkan safrudin ngomong bahwa kita sudah order (pesan) rafale dan f15. Pembelian beberapa macam alutsista mungkin tidak akan di tampilkan di publik, namun pembelian jet tempur macam f15 dengan jumlah lumayan akan berpengaruh di kawasan regional dan pasti tetap muncul di DCSA sebelum barang mulai di buat
Salam
Its good country with lots of good potential natural resources, unfortunately the government is terrible and the education level of some indonesian is below average.
Yeah that's why i heard from my indonesian friends.. they would be independent like many gen z who wanna be entrepreneur to make economy country better and cause the government is useless.
As a Malaysian this is interesting
Thank you so much.
Greetings from Indonesia. 🇮🇩🙏
A support a asian union when asian countries are developed
Once people talked about China 🇨🇳 like this. But now it's Indonesia. It's a country like India... Not so much interesting Politically, but economically
great powers never follow alliances but make alliances and Indonesia is a great power