I lie, I wait I stop, I hesitate I am, I breathe I meant, I think of me Is it any wonder, I can't sleep? All I have is all you gave to me Is it any wonder, I found peace Through you? Turn to the gates of heaven, to myself be damned Turn away from light It's not enough, just a touch It's not enough I taste, I love I come, I bleed enough I hate, I'm not I was, I want too much Is it any wonder I can't sleep? All I have is all you gave to me Is it any wonder I found peace Through you? Turn to the gates of heaven, to myself be damned Turn away from light It's not enough, just a touch It's not enough, just a touch It's not enough, just a touch It's not enough, just a touch It's not enough, just a touch It's not enough, just a touch
97' ...I was 17 in love with both bands. Also when the movie Lost Highway came out with one of the best soundtracks to ever come out... with both these guys...and Rammstein. I miss the 90s too..
Same. I'm 40, and never saw it before. I was obsessed with both acts as a teen. And still love them now, so I'm glad to have found it! I mean I knew that BC and MM were good friends, so it makes sense. And I like their voices together too! ❤️ (I'm guessing it was a one time collab at that concert only. 🤷♀️)
Probably my favorite song right now. Been listening to Manson since 98 and I love how he reinvents himself with every new album. This song is a rare gem.
I started with Manson when I was 13 and when Holywood was released. To this day this album is in my Top Ten of the best Albums ever existed. Greetings from Germany and keep on listening to all MAnsons Albums 🙂
@@angelashinnerI suspect that he constantly quotes Andy Warhol to himself “I just do art because I’m ugly and there’s nothing else for me to do.” Unfortunate he's nowhere near as talented.
i come back to this video every week... i am addicted. i want to go back in the 90s and i wasn't even alive then lol. if any one of you attended any manson concerts during that era feel free to comment the experience or any stories about it, i'd love to hear them:)
Saw MM 3 times between 99 and 2001. Still the best shows I've ever seen, hands down. The effort that went into his sets was incredible; each song was its own play with its own characters. I have also never seen a crowd respond to an artist like they did at his shows. He owned them. People don't realize what a showman he was. So glad I got to experience it.
Saw Manson at a venue in Alabama called Sloss Furnace in 2001 during the Guns God and Government tour. It’s an old “haunted” steel mill. It was one of the best shows I’ve been to. He put on an amazing performance using a variety of costumes, prosthetics, even stilts. He wrote about the place in his book, “The Long Hard Road Out Of Hell” about an incident that happened backstage, if I recall correctly. In the book he mistakenly stated that Sloss was in Mississippi. I’ve seen him several other times. During The Antichrist tour was also amazing. It was in Alabama too, so I am surprised he even got to play because this was when many of his shows were being canceled due to his “controversial” lyrics and performances. There were church groups outside protesting and screaming at us as we walked in. During the show, he stood behind a podium and ripped up a bible. He also dressed in his German WWII costume and also a large black coat covered with feathers and had wings. One of the best experiences of my life.
I relate to these lyrics immensely. My best friend took his own life a few months ago. I realize I loved him more than I thought. Every word from this song is him. It's me. Never again will I see him, or feel his touch..
Around 1999ish, I remember waiting hours at a time for several days to download this entire video with dial up. 5 percent here, 10 percent there. I eventually had the whole video.
I have to admit I wasn't sure if I'd really enjoy this but was pleasantly surprised and glad I checked this out seeing it posted in a Facebook group dedicated to punk, metal and rock
THank you so much for sharing this!! I knew that Billy and Marilyn hung out and performed together-never got to see any footage of it though. Magnificent!
It’s real. With the *almost* mistakes by Iha, the *giggling* by Corgan, and the *powerful* vocals by Manson. The drummer *almost?* dropping the sticks at the end. This is such a great feat of songwriting, it takes me to another place. I’m not necessarily trading this version for the studio version, but this is what I love about music, with all its lovely imperfections. Had I known this existed around ‘97 or ‘98, I would have shit my pants.
Que dejame decirte que el "boom" o el mejor momento de Manson fue hasta 1999, que estúpidas acusaciones sin fundamentos reales lo hayan logrado hundir , no desmerita que el mejor año de Míster Manson fue en 1999'.
Cool. I've always found that post-Antichrist Superstar, pre-Mechanical Animals era of MM to be very intriguing, but they didn't produce much at that time. Long Hard Road Out of Hell was a great song with a different sound; seems they mutated too fast for a proper expression of that time to be documented. At least there's this.
@The GRlggsTER Mechanical Animals was for sure a great concept album. I did get really into it years later around 2005; I'd get loaded and lay in the dark and listen to it every other night for weeks or even months. I have heard quite a bit that came after and never could get into it.
This is a great concept you guys!! I never contemplated this...Long Hard Road is probably my fave music video & song...Though they have many incredible vids! Shame there wasn't one more album at that time. Wish I could relive those concerts, they are so foggy in my mind...MM on giant stilts etc. Wow, just wow!
![The Smashing Pumpkins [Cherub Rock - Live on MTV Most Wanted with Ray Cokes 1993]](/img/1.gif)
I lie, I wait
I stop, I hesitate
I am, I breathe
I meant, I think of me
Is it any wonder, I can't sleep?
All I have is all you gave to me
Is it any wonder, I found peace
Through you?
Turn to the gates of heaven, to myself be damned
Turn away from light
It's not enough, just a touch
It's not enough
I taste, I love
I come, I bleed enough
I hate, I'm not
I was, I want too much
Is it any wonder I can't sleep?
All I have is all you gave to me
Is it any wonder I found peace
Through you?
Turn to the gates of heaven, to myself be damned
Turn away from light
It's not enough, just a touch
It's not enough, just a touch
It's not enough, just a touch
It's not enough, just a touch
It's not enough, just a touch
It's not enough, just a touch
It sounds like they’re saying turn away from eye.
I thought so too
Yes
I have NEVER seen, nor knew this performance existed until just this moment. My happiness cannot be contained over this.
Happiness ever after resides here
Nor did I
It's awesome.
They're ruling it!¡! Biss
🤣🤣😭😭
Me too, and I'm a huge pumpkin fan! 🤯
Fuck! D'arcy's there too! 😍
Awes
I miss the 90’s so much...The last greatest times of rock (mainstream) such as this awesome collaboration.
The best era of both bands.
@ODIN Force both my sons say the same thing. Lol
For Smashing Pumpkins yes it was their best era.. but Manson is hitting his stride NOW, although his older stuff is obviously very good.
@@sercastamere9853 I def agree.. But stuff like lunchbox, tourniquet, etc was all pretty amazing
Agreed
@@jennyhazzel31 ok
97' ...I was 17 in love with both bands. Also when the movie Lost Highway came out with one of the best soundtracks to ever come out... with both these guys...and Rammstein. I miss the 90s too..
Whats lost highway about. Dont know Rammstein. I'll listen to them
@@jgrignard1 Rammstein is a fantastic band. I would highly recommend listening to Mein Hertz Brent. The music video is also very nice!
I always tell people how much I still miss the 90's. I really do. Wonderful time to be alive.
Apple of Sodom is my favorite Manson song. Such a great soundtrack!
These guys were so big then and still are superstar musicians!
I had no idea this existed. Both Billy and MM doing Eye together acoustically is beautiful.
Same I'm 42 and I've never seen this
I am 57 and have been an MM fan since the beginning and I had no idea✌🥰
Im 47 and just seeing this
Yep, 40 here and never seen this 🤔
Same. I'm 40, and never saw it before. I was obsessed with both acts as a teen. And still love them now, so I'm glad to have found it! I mean I knew that BC and MM were good friends, so it makes sense. And I like their voices together too! ❤️
(I'm guessing it was a one time collab at that concert only. 🤷♀️)
Probably my favorite song right now. Been listening to Manson since 98 and I love how he reinvents himself with every new album. This song is a rare gem.
How he USED to reinvent himself in the 90s
I started with Manson when I was 13 and when Holywood was released. To this day this album is in my Top Ten of the best Albums ever existed. Greetings from Germany and keep on listening to all MAnsons Albums 🙂
This is a Smashing Pumpkins song actually.
@@GerardoCaruso I know. I have got all their CD's as well next to my Manson Albums :-) Just keep on listening to their great music!
I love this live, I love Marilyn Manson ❤️❤️❤️♠️♠️♠️♠️
After so much years they still send fucking shivers down my spine
I love how Twiggy always looks COMPLETELY blasted out of his mind but he's always fully functional lol. He's a goddamn modern wonder
Who's twiggy
@@jgrignard1 as far as I remember, a guitarist of nine inch nails, I guess, he plays here too
@@jgrignard1 At the time, was Marilyn Manson's bassist. In this clip he is directly behind Manson playing the guitar.
Agreed
@@jgrignard1 red wig
He looks sooo beautiful 😻😭✨
@Angela Shinner He really is a very good looking man there's no doubt about that 🤩💖💖even in his later years he's 🤩💖💖
Satire is not dead
@@iconoclast5278 denial either.
@@angelashinnerI suspect that he constantly quotes Andy Warhol to himself “I just do art because I’m ugly and there’s nothing else for me to do.” Unfortunate he's nowhere near as talented.
@@iconoclast5278 y’all are just a bunch of stupid bullies huh? Guess what I never asked for ur opinion
Best of both worlds of my teenage goth years 🤘🤘🤘
Oh 90's so lucky to live in this era
i come back to this video every week... i am addicted. i want to go back in the 90s and i wasn't even alive then lol. if any one of you attended any manson concerts during that era feel free to comment the experience or any stories about it, i'd love to hear them:)
Saw MM 3 times between 99 and 2001. Still the best shows I've ever seen, hands down. The effort that went into his sets was incredible; each song was its own play with its own characters. I have also never seen a crowd respond to an artist like they did at his shows. He owned them. People don't realize what a showman he was. So glad I got to experience it.
Saw Manson at a venue in Alabama called Sloss Furnace in 2001 during the Guns God and Government tour. It’s an old “haunted” steel mill. It was one of the best shows I’ve been to. He put on an amazing performance using a variety of costumes, prosthetics, even stilts. He wrote about the place in his book, “The Long Hard Road Out Of Hell” about an incident that happened backstage, if I recall correctly. In the book he mistakenly stated that Sloss was in Mississippi. I’ve seen him several other times. During The Antichrist tour was also amazing. It was in Alabama too, so I am surprised he even got to play because this was when many of his shows were being canceled due to his “controversial” lyrics and performances. There were church groups outside protesting and screaming at us as we walked in. During the show, he stood behind a podium and ripped up a bible. He also dressed in his German WWII costume and also a large black coat covered with feathers and had wings. One of the best experiences of my life.
@@samantha8666Wow. I envy you. I would do ANYTHING to be able to experience a MM concert in the 90s. You're so lucky
Marilyn Manson Great voice
Damn Marilyn looked sooo pretty, my god✨🐞
Perfect, love it. Miss the good music years.
Billy Corgan on vocals
James Lha on guitar
Matt Walker on drums
Marilyn Manson on drugs
😀
I cant believe i have never seen this before! Beautiful!
This is really beautiful!
I had no idea this existed are you serious? Marilyn sounds great on this song!
I relate to these lyrics immensely. My best friend took his own life a few months ago. I realize I loved him more than I thought. Every word from this song is him. It's me. Never again will I see him, or feel his touch..
I wish they had done a studio version of this.
Why?! This is perfect. I mean,...I could listen to these monsters in ANY Medium
This is fxcking beautiful
I love his dirty voice and look since I hear him the first time!
Around 1999ish, I remember waiting hours at a time for several days to download this entire video with dial up. 5 percent here, 10 percent there. I eventually had the whole video.
The beautiful Manson 🖤
I have to admit I wasn't sure if I'd really enjoy this but was pleasantly surprised and glad I checked this out seeing it posted in a Facebook group dedicated to punk, metal and rock
I can't believe my eye...This is so amazing. Where I have been all this years without knowing this exists?
I am completely in love with this song🖤
F****** amazing guys!! This is pure ART !!
Yeah they have a real talent making terrible music 😂😂
@@vonclohk507 👍
This is why we “miss” this era!!!! Manson could still sing, Darcy & James on stage wit Billy
I honestly have chills right now! What a beautiful piece 🖤🖤🖤🖤
One of the greatest songs ever love 💕 MM
Ти. Очень. Круче. Все х
Love song? sounds like death 😂
Я патресен очень сильно
Я патресен очень сильно я очень рад за вас
Excellent collaboration. Love seeing Twiggy on that guitar.
Wow they sound amazing together..it's crazy how good they mesh..would love to hear a colab
You are hearing a collab 🤣
Daaamn. Beautiful. And Twiggy 🔥👌🏼
Who's twiggy
Back when music was not all the same
Why do u say that
@@jgrignard1 all the pop songs now days can be played with the same chords
This song stuck in my head for to long
Always one of my fav pumpkins tunes and feat MM sick
Tan bonito que estaba Marilyn Manson en ese tiempo.❤
Seeeee lastima que engordó :(
@@fototero6019 es que ahora si come, antes pura droga
Aún sigue.
And now
@@fototero6019 who? Is he obese
Corgan tiene una voz felina que es ûnica y Manson encaja perfectamente con un toque más grave, gran dupla, cracks!
eso si mira el año, marilyn manson estaba en su mejor momento y billy corgan ya había alcanzando la madurez artística
voz felina, hermosa metáfora, muy de acuerdo!
I miss you and you know this already and you know your awesome too.
20 años, aún se me eriza la piel ❤
Me too !
this is perfect
Ahhh I watched this many years ago and couldn't remember how it's called and I finally found it again 🥺❤
THank you so much for sharing this!! I knew that Billy and Marilyn hung out and performed together-never got to see any footage of it though. Magnificent!
I fucking Loved this. My 2 favourite musicians, especially Marilyn Manson and Twiggy. I'm in LOVE!!!!
Nice to see things as they were…
?
It's a whole different song with his vocals on. I dig it.
It’s real. With the *almost* mistakes by Iha, the *giggling* by Corgan, and the *powerful* vocals by Manson. The drummer *almost?* dropping the sticks at the end. This is such a great feat of songwriting, it takes me to another place. I’m not necessarily trading this version for the studio version, but this is what I love about music, with all its lovely imperfections. Had I known this existed around ‘97 or ‘98, I would have shit my pants.
Красавец Менсон, обожаю его.
✨️✨️Marilyn✨️✨️ = glamorous*Beautiful*magical*hypnotic!💫🌟🤗👌❤😍❤🙏😻👀✨️✨️
Marilyn, du fehlst uns!!!!!!❤️
Why did he overdose
Thanks for the post! Lost highway ost is perfect, like the movie.
I love those times. Great memories.
Two of my faves
That little kiss on the head at the end ❤
They both sound so good live wow
ahh my favs 😭😭😭❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
AMAZING 👍👍💖💖💋💋💋💋🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
this is the best thing that i ever seen all
i love you manson.
Manson was so great, in his prime!
Haha u don't like older people
I really enjoy the hell out of that!🤘❤Thanks you guys! How I miss those days...before, well ya know. Heres to love slaughter an metal baybee💋💜💥
Wow this just made my night
Потрясающе!!!!Великий и Ужасный Мэнсон и Пампы.25 лет назад.25!!!!!!!Красавцы!
Блеск!.. Мэнсон может быть и таким, очень романтично и проникновенно. Браво!!
How have I never seen this
Asking myself this very question lol
Manson y los Pumpkins en su mejor momento. Emocionante.
Que dejame decirte que el "boom" o el mejor momento de Manson fue hasta 1999, que estúpidas acusaciones sin fundamentos reales lo hayan logrado hundir , no desmerita que el mejor año de Míster Manson fue en 1999'.
@@pedrosantiago3519 2000
Неповторимый Мерилин Мэнсон!!! 💪💪💪
This was worth my internet bill this month.
Love it!!! Both great artists
my beautiful manson
Omg 😱 this is an iconic collaboration!!!! Thank you for sharing ❤️🔥🖤
Saw Pumping live in London around 2010 , featuring Marilyn. Amazing gig got goosebumps all the way
I miss the 90's...
that was beautiful, man
I think it would be awesome to be able to be on that stage with all the talent and be able to jam with them.
What a great song!! OMG!
Awesome! Thanks for sharing this. I've only heard the audio, never knew there was a video. LOVE it! \m/
AWESOME THEM TOGETHER. LOVE THEM ALL.
Marilyn manson en esta canción es una obra de arte, me encanta ese toque tranquilo que tiene 😌
Gold
We need this collaboration album yesterday
Masterpiece
This is love.
Pure love ❤️
I was born in 1977 😱🔥🥰
Dreams come true
Beeeeauuutifuuuul
Cool. I've always found that post-Antichrist Superstar, pre-Mechanical Animals era of MM to be very intriguing, but they didn't produce much at that time. Long Hard Road Out of Hell was a great song with a different sound; seems they mutated too fast for a proper expression of that time to be documented. At least there's this.
@The GRlggsTER I was kinda bummed when Mechanical Animals came out. But it did grow on me later on. That really was the end of an era.
@The GRlggsTER Mechanical Animals was for sure a great concept album. I did get really into it years later around 2005; I'd get loaded and lay in the dark and listen to it every other night for weeks or even months. I have heard quite a bit that came after and never could get into it.
@The GRlggsTER Yeah! That's my favorite one. Used to do mushrooms and listen to it a lot.
What do you mean
This is a great concept you guys!! I never contemplated this...Long Hard Road is probably my fave music video & song...Though they have many incredible vids! Shame there wasn't one more album at that time. Wish I could relive those concerts, they are so foggy in my mind...MM on giant stilts etc. Wow, just wow!
Thanks for this masterpiece, happy new year 🙏
Wow I love that song
Nunca había visto este video. So in love 💞💕
So I was there. On the grass. Marlyn was NOT on the bill. He came out of nowhere!! It was at the Shoreline Amphitheater 1997
Haven't heard this in very long. Haven't heard this version at all. Wow.
Such a cool man who stood out
Damn so great 🥰💥💥
Brilliant
Really love that both groups cool
Billy Corgan
17/03/1967
54 años (55)
Excellent version !!!