It makes me sad when creatures are slaughtered for us; whether in fragrances or “medicines” or luxury (fur coats). So glad the perfume industry stopped that practice years ago. One of the best videos I’ve listened to in a while! From one science “nerd” to the other! 🥰💕Of course nerd is a term of endeaarance .
The suffering is endless, today children are explored for you to buy a bottle of perfume, or to harvest many raw materials, human is complicated, dont blame yourself
Hey Claire, great video. This may have been mentioned already and I may have missed it, but the reason why some of the modern synthetic musks smell "clean" or "white", or like opening a tumble dryer or ironing a shirt, is that musks are used quite extensively in laundry detergents and fabric conditioners, often together with synthetic "fresh" white-floral aromachemicals. The human sense of smell is greatly influenced both by our cultural context and by olfactory experiences and memories built throughout our life, which is why most Europeans today associate certain molecules used in cleaning/washing products with cleanliness and freshness. In the example you mentioned, habanolide does not actually smell metallic, but simply similar to the different musks clinging to the damp laundry that are being heated and evaporated by the hot-iron. (A heated hot-iron actually does not smell of metal, as solid steel itself does not smell of anything.) Only our deep olfactory memories tell us that this is the smell of hot metal. People who have never seen a hot-iron in use before will smell habanolide as neither "hot" nor "metallic"; in fact they may not even be able to consciously smell habanolide at all if their olfactory system has never been primed to distinguish the smell from other background smells. In a similar way, vanilla does not smell "sweet" to people who have never eaten a sweetened vanilla dessert or cake in their life; and ethyl maltol smells specifically like cotton candy only to people who have experienced real cotton candy before.
Yes absolutely, associations are strong with smells and you can say similar things about people who've never smelt other things. Associations are sometimes very cultural, for example, chrysanthemums and death or lilies and death. This is part of why I find gendering of fragrances really unhelpful. Thanks for watching 🥰
Wow.. the fact that people would kill them in droves for such a selfish reason is disgusting. I am loving this video. So much info. The fact that I've always explained Musk this way without actually knowing the scientific side makes me love my nose that much more. Lol. It's so sexy to me.
Yes, it's quite strange to think now isn't it? I can't imagine deer musk selling now at all... But I guess people loved fur too back then, it was somewhat normal to exploit animals. Yes, musk is definitely up there on the sexy scale. 😊
Musks are tricky since they can smell so varied, like you said. I have a soft spot for those 80s/90s style white musks. They are pretty and clean without being full on detergent-like, and not super floral. I know they don't smell sophisticated, but the cozy nostalgia is appealing. Thanks for this primer on musks!
Yes, I love the clean ones too, it is a very fine line between clean and detergent-like! I guess because that is exactly what musks like ethylene brassylate and galaxolide have been used for, as well as for perfumes. I really have a very strong nostalgia for Body Shop white musk. I've not tried it recently but I would love it to smell like it smelt in the 90s. Thank you for watching! 🥰
Yes, I really like the 80s and 90s white musks. Do you happen to have any recommendations for the best perfumes or fragrance oils that have close to the same white musk scents of the past?
@@rellg.2607 If you can find Derek Lam 10 Crosby "Silent Street" for a decent price, it's a nice scent in the vein of Jovan White Musk, etc. I have it in a body spray and it's fleeting but pretty and nostalgic.
Oh wow! I just discovered your channel and it was very educational! I work in the flavor/fragrance industry yet I learned so much! Please continue this science of fragrances and talks about the industry! I also watched your video about why perfumes get discontinued. I was like, "finally finally! someone mentioned that IFRA has something to do with it!"
Thank you! ❤️ It must be really interesting to see this from the other side. I would love such inside knowledge 😂 IFRA has banned or restricted a lot of important fragrance components so yes, it's certainly impacted what is reformulated or discontinued. Thanks for watching 🥰
Thank you so much for explaining this . I love musk in anything and Narcisco Rodriguez is a master at musk fragrances and I love civet and castoreum in my fragrances. I am happy they are not hurting any animals anymore for fragrances.
One of THEE BEST, MORE KNOWLEDGEABLE RUclipsrs around! You always make your posts so interesting and entertaining...Great vid Clair! Oh, And those poor deer!😮. For Humans to kill so many of these beautiful animals so that we can "enjoy fragrances" more is unconscionable, but then again, WE ALL benefit in one way or another from plundering our natural recources, including the wonderful wildlife which surrounds us, I guess I'm saying "who am I to judge" lol
So sorry for the late reply (YT filters got this one for some reason 🙃🤷♀️). Thank you so much! ❤️ That's lovely of you to say! You are right, if we saw the reality of the trail of destruction that pretty much everything that we consume leaves we'd be very shocked, but musk deer needed saving. Thanks for watching 🥰
Why am I only seeing your videos now? I seriously love your videos. They are so informative and I have never subscribed a channel this fast lol. Thank you so much for these amazing information you give us!
Oh my goodness! I just did a musk video too! 😀Musk is one of my favorite perfume notes. I always say, "Musk is a Must." 😊 You gave a lot of interesting information and took a deep dive. I try to give people sufficient information too. 😊 I did that in every one of my "perfume note series" video.
Musk is such a natural odor I don’t think any perfume can recreate the natural smell ☺️ I love learning all the intricate details you share!❤️ I love a good musk!☺️🤗
Deer musk is likely a lot more dimensional than synthetic musks, but I do like the clean feeling of modern musks! Haha Sunny, this video literally took me a week! 😂
In the seventies until 1984 I have often smelt the real oily animalic musk, if you want to know EXACTLY how the real animalic deer's musk smells like, you should try Ambraliquida by L'Erbolario. Ambraliquida is a cruelty-free scent, has non-animalic ingredients, BUT it is exactly how deer musk in perfumery smells like: warm, sweet, powdery, slightly pungent, little bit dirty. Loved the video and the wonderful scientific explanations, you look fabulous and you are very intelligent, congratulations, new friend here. P.S. I do NOT work for L'Erbolario, I just live in Italy and found in this brand, that kind of musky scent I used to love in my youth.
Hello! Thank you for the advice on where to find animalic smelling musk! I honestly don't think I ever smelt it... It's great to hear comparisons from someone who knows what they are looking for. Thank you also for your lovely comment, I hope to make a few more videos in this series soon. I am afraid I don't speak Portuguese, but I subbed 😂 I am happy to do so! ❤️ Thank you so much for watching!
@@dr.claire.perfume you are welcome! Thank you very much for subbing as well 🌹🌹🌹💐 Yes, I speak Portuguese, I was born in Rio de Janeiro but live in Italy, my husband is Italian. Sending you many greetings from Italy 😊🌹🌹🌸🦋🦋
@@dr.claire.perfume woooow wonderful, happy to hear this ! Italian is a beautiful language, love it. I can speak and write in German, I lived in Berlin during 27 years, I love Berlin very much, Berlin has youthful vibes, young energy and there is so much to learn over there. Your husband is very intelligent and loves learning and teaching, congratulations!!!!!!!!
Claire! This was fantastic! I loved learning about musk! Super informative and helpful. Loved the Jon Snow cameo, too. Just top notch content. Keep the series coming! We need you!
Holy smokes really blown away by the origins of synthetic musk my word. Thank u for this video. ive always been weirded out with the implications of organic natural musk in perfumery, and for so long ive subconsciously assumed natural musk likely came from actual ppl or smthing. completely overlooked the fact that animals too were an option lol
Haha! I am happy to enlighten you! Musk has a very complicated history as it's really unclear sometimes what people mean by musk as it's often a mix of compounds now when used in fragrances, not just one! Thanks for watching 🥰 have a fab week ❤️
Love your perfume science series 👍 Musk is one of my favourite notes, in almost all nuances 😍 Musc Ravageur is great one and I also love the modern Narciso Rodriguez musk 🥰
You amaze me with your research and providing all this wealth of information. ❤ This was so interesting! Musc Ravageur smells like cat pee on my skin. I was appalled the first time I smelled it 😅
What a fantastically interesting video Claire and thankyou for taking the time to talk about Musk, I hope you do alot more of these and I love the way you talk about these subject ,Great video x
Thanks Scott! This was definitely more research than I expected it to be 😂 for sure, I want to do a few more of these. I already have one on solar notes and one on watery notes. Let me know if you have a request. Thank you for watching. ❤️
Body Shop’s White Musk was holy grail status for me in the late 90s and early 2000s. I’ve heard it’s not the same anymore. Ellis Myth reminds me ofit though.
Yes, I went to try it as I had feelings of nostalgia for it but it wasn't how I remembered it. It has lost its identity. Everything has sadly been reformulated at the body shop, I think that's been part of the problem, along with exorbitant prices now. I will look into the Ellis Brooklyn. Thanks for watching 🥰
I love vintage perfumes, so I would be really interested in smelling some old style animalistic perfumes. I also love both original alien and body shop white musk. Funny enough I've heard a very young youtuber saying that bodyshop white musk reminded her of sweaty armpits. It astonished me because to me it smells so clean.
Wow! I would never think of white musk as armpits 😂 that is so funny! The original Alien is amazing! I am hoarding my bottle 😂 thank you for watching 😘
I love the note of musk. Although I must say I never loved the original formulation of Alien. My introduction to the note occurred in the late 60’s early 70’s when the note was a little more refined in my opinion. Great information Claire. Keep them coming.
Thank you! ❤️ I thought this might be something a bit different 😊 Do you think musk was a little more subtle in the 60/70s? Was there any one fragrance in particular that you were thinking of? I guess the musk in Alien that Jon talks about is an aspect of the cashmeran... Not technically a musk but something that smells very much like a musk. I can totally understand that Alien is not for everyone! I remember thinking it was very very loud when it first came out! Thank you for watching as always, it's always lovely to see your comments 🥰
I've had the opportunity to smell actual musk deer musk (musk tonquin) tincture in the past and I do love the odor. There is a modern product called tonquitone produced by IFF that is a really good facsimile of it. Ambrettolide is also quite similar but less animalic.
I've not smelt it, but I would love to. I can imagine the more modern musks are more of a range of clean to dirty, icy to warm, fresh to nutty, powdery to creamy than ever before. Perfumers need that range to be able to make what they want to. I absolutely love ambrette, I wish it were used more! Thanks for watching ❤️
Hi Yasmin, thanks for your feedback! I will look into doing a few more. I warn you that these videos take quite a bit of reading and prep so it might not be straight away, but yes, I will do more! ❤️
This is one such video you would like to listen to minute by minute. And if you miss something you would take out the time and go back and listen to it again.
Another great video! 😍 I love your science related perfume videos and this is was so straight to the point ❤ Thank you for making such effort to create these contents, it was very informative for me. 😊😊😊
Oh thank you, that's brilliant 🥰 I am so happy to read that! It is difficult to find information on these things in one place sometimes, so it's handy to have it in a video 🙂 I will for sure make some more perfume science videos. Thank you again! ❤️
I think I have smelled animalic musk, yes. When I was a young child in the 60s-70s my relative asked if I wanted to smell her perfume but said be careful this has musk in it. Do you want to smell it anyway? I was just a toddler/kid but said yes. I remember it was a nice experience and I have had good associations with the idea of the smell of musk since. I have not worn many perfumes through the years and am just now in my 50s really getting into it. I do love Narciso Rodriguez For Her. I'm glad we can have a nice smell without killing animals for it now.
Yes animalic musk is quite different to the cleaner ones that are more common now. But there are certainly some examples of vegan musks that are closer to the animalic versions. I think Narciso Rodriguez for her is now considered a classic fragrance, one of those bookmarked examples of musk in fragrance.
Doesn't matter how many times I watch this. It's just the best Claire. You're easily the best at this type of content out there. Still sometimes I forget that bloke at the end ruins it 😜
You are really providing super detailed videos for enthusiasts. I can imagine these take a long time to write and produce. Thanks for all your effort. Is this your full time job? If it isn't than really thanks for all the effort on a side gig.
Excellent blend of educational, informative and fun facts about one of the most important smells there are: a musk! Some more parfume examples would always be most welcome! Very interesting content and highly enjoyable presentation! Great video!
@@dr.claire.perfume I do not know if it is musk or something else but I find both "Black bottle" and "White bottle" Narciso Rodriguez "for her" irresistible!
Thank you for this interesting info. I haven't yet learned to love musk-forward fragrances like Musc Ravageur or Narciso Rodriguez for Her EDT, but I know noses evolve.
Yes, I've struggled with Narciso for her EDP for sure, but more because of the patchouli and peach I think... Some of my favourite musks are the cleaner ones, I really love la nuit Tresor musc diamant for example, that is more of a white musk. For sure your taste can change, I hope you find a musk that you love eventually. Thank you for watching ❤️
@@dr.claire.perfume I bet it did take you a long time! I love hard working creators. Unfortunately, people aren't always appreciative of it. Thank you for doing your homework Claire! 🥰❤
So.... musks. You've answered some of my questions (thanks Claire!) and prompted others. Isn't that always the way, though. Wouldn't it be lovely if the musk chemicals were disclosed when fragrance shopping? I've identified a dry down scent I find repulsive, and it's a metallic, brassy note. So far, I've traced it to notes for florals and musk. I do find it most often in older perfumes from department store houses, and it does remind me of vintage clothing from the 40's-60's that I used to wear. I'd love to know which musk chemical leaves a metallic residue. Also, isn't funny that items that we'd consider as stinky, like sweaty deer testicles and glands, and roots like patchouli, were combined to make interesting scents? I like to imagine the first person who said, wow, this root smells like wet, unwashed wool socks. What can I use it for? Obv I'm making light, but these are the shower thoughts I have. And how nice to see Jon! And it looks like Summer there, too.
Yes, I always think that, I want to learn how to individually identify musks. I think galaxolide is very distinctive, but that's not used now. I think with patchouli, it's the branches that are used or maybe the leaves, I'm not sure. I think it was used because it was originally used to wrap silks to protect them from moths when they were shipped from the Far East. People noticed the smell on the silks and liked it and wanted to know what it was. That's my romanticised version of how patchouli got popular anyway. 😂
What a great informative detailed video 👏👏👏 New subscriber I'm going to watch another video of yours because of the title and thumbnail which says perfume notes that makes you attractive.
This is very informative video! I am really happy our chemist can produce the synthetic of it because it is really unfair for a deer to be killed because of its popular gland! Using an original musk is like you use a horse in this modern era on the road which is not relevant anymore and i support our chemist to keep researching and produces more exact smell like the original one.
I agree that it's no longer needed. I absolutely love ambrette but the other musks provide varied and diverse musk profiles for a variety of fragrances. Thanks for watching 🥰
I was also super curious! It's just a clean mix from what I can discern. It is a very hazy term, I think clean primarily but that special mix of different musks (either polycyclic or polycyclic and linear) is key. Thank you for watching! ❤️
What a great informative video claire ! 🙂, I learned from this i didnt know there are lots of different types of musk and how they smell like, im actually not a big fan of musk, slight muskiness is ok to me depends on what other accords it is mixed with. What a great job you put on this video 🙂❤️
Thank you so much Rin! I'm so happy that you enjoyed this! Yes mild musk is lovely isn't it? In some fragrances it can also be too much for me! Thanks for watching and I hope everything is going well! 🙂
What fragrances would Ethylene Brassylate be in? Have you tried Narcisso Rodriguez for Her EDT (Black bottle)?? Thats the only NR fragrance I've tried but THAT is the type of musk I love!! The laundry one is alright but I want to know how I can find fragrances with that NR for Her black (if possible) 😬
As far as I know, NR for her EDT was a mix of galaxolide and a bit of ambrettolide, but that's from reading not from me being able to pick out particular musks. Although galaxolide when used excessively, is something that I do think is pretty distinctive, e.g. the vintage Trésor. But I know galaxolide is in the process of being banned (or may have been banned now, I'm not sure). I am not sure which fragrances would have ethylene brassylate, but I know that that musk is used sometimes to mimic galaxolide as LVMH did stop using galaxolide quite early on. Ethylene brassylate is also known as Musk T (Takasago), it's a round soft feminine skin musk. It can smell a little ambery or vanillic, but is usually used in combinations with other musks. It may be that NR for Her EDT has been reformulated to include Ethylene brassylate as a replacement for galaxolide over its 21 year history. Sorry but I'm not a perfumer so I have just read a lot about this! Asking an actual perfumer might yield a more accurate answer. Thanks for watching 🥰
I inherited several bottles of Chanel perfumes from my mother, which she would have acquired in the early 1970s. I’m certain they contain animal musk, as the scent , while beautiful, is heavy and “oily” - very much heavier and denser than the modern renditions I own. I would not wear these vintage perfumes, and therefore prefer the modern version. Also aligns with my approach of supporting the conservation of these beautiful forest animals and sustainability of nature. Thanks so much for an interesting video, Claire!
Maybe! Yes the vintage ones can be very heavy, the scent intensifies and becomes a little overwhelming with age sometimes. I'm happy we have all these modern musks rather than deer musk, I particularly love ambrette. 🥰
Thanks Claire . Me Bob from Malaysia and seeking info on how to make synthetic musk deer oil. Anyway tqvm cause few things. I should go through your video over again cause you speak spontaneously so must be truth of honestly. Take care and thanks again
i love musk in fragrances... my Mom always bought musk fragrances for me before.. I don't know why people wanted to smell like the deer's pungent smell... 🤣 maybe they thought that they could hook a lot females as well if they wear the scent, like how male deers attract does... so it is the Ethylene Brassylate kind of musk that I really enjoy in scents.. the cheapest kind LOL, the sweeter, vanillic kind... i love the "white" musk smell too... what about Black Musk? could that be just those synthetic musks that try to mimic the classic animalic musk?
I think I like the cheap one too 😂 I only just realised that black musk existed when I was making this video. I read about what was in the body shop one and it seemed like it was musk with darker notes like liquorice. I have no idea elsewhere, but I've seen it with leather, pepper and patchouli in the montale version. So I am guessing it is any musk centred fragrance with darker notes? Not sure cos I've not tried any black musk fragrances... Let me know if you find out! 🥰
Yes Jon was so kind to record something for this! I am only sorry that we weren't more organised about it, we could have had a lot more fun with the whole thing 😂 ambrette is lovely, I only have one or two in my collection that I love with strong ambrette, but I would love to try Hera.
Kiehls Original Musk, and Skin Musk Oil by parfums de Coeur, Nemat Musk and Musk-Amber, Vanilla Musk, Cabot Labs Musk, are probably my favorites and the most wearable musks. If Coty Wild Musk still smelled like it used to, it'd be right up there with the rest. I sure miss it...Jovan Musk is still around, and popular. I never tried the Alyssa Ashley musks because they looked so white musk-cold to me, I always thought they would smell like hairspray. But they're incredibly popular, so maybe I'm missing out?
I feel like the cheaper musks of old were actually much better than the cheap musks now... I didn't try the Alyssa Ashley musks either but yes I am wary too! I would love to find a good musk oil, I'm sure there's one out there for me. Thanks for watching 🥰
@@dr.claire.perfume the Nemat musk oils are quite good, as well as Kiehls, and the skin Musk oil, it depends on which kind you like...I try a lot of different attars and musk oils from various makers, red musk oils are my favorites so far, but there's so many! Hindi musk, Mecca Musk, China musk, Jamaica musk, civet musk, patchouli musk, there's a musk for every taste.
Well it was fantastic. A great overview in my mind it was probably even older than that. I bet the Chinese were using ambroxan 10000yrs ago 🤣. Yea I always guessed women were more sensitive because many seem to struggle with musk. Our unconscious senses are quite incredible aren't they, the wonder of life. Some great look at the different types and the molecules. I wonder why it became a thing after the war and not earlier. But yes you know I loved this, ur guest, not sure what he was on about
I tried to verify that Talmud thing and I struggled to make a decision either way, it depends which scholar you agree with on the translation, anyway I kept it in. For sure it was being used by the ancient Greeks in the 5th century AD at least. I guess it all hinges on how well stuff gets recorded, like with the Vikings. I want to see the source for that with ambroxan 😂 Musk can definitely get too much for me in some contexts and this whole thing has made me wonder if I have anosmia to certain types cos it seems like it is really common! I think the 50s were a time of looking forward and wanting new things, people were fed up and ready to bin their old stuff after years of rationing and shortages, new was exciting. I think that mindset expanded into use of synthetics in all types of fragrance and luxuries like perfume were becoming more accessible and mass market, so costs and supplies were important considerations perhaps? Aww! My guest made it 👌 I read about catnip after you said that. That was another 2 hours of rabbit hole, so thank you for that 😂
@@dr.claire.perfume haha they also have a weird frisky reaction to the smell of bleach u know... Strange animals or maybe it's made with cat wee? Yea I doubt I can smell much musk and all the fragrance I wear must be why I'm single masking my muskiness 🤣 Yes that's a sad part of history isn't it, the ancients knew more than we gave them credit for and somethings are lost for us modern folk to say we discovered. It's like uranium and all that surely neolithic Estonian or wherever it is came across it, and maybe Merlin with his glowing sticks and such like
I think nowadays musk is almost always synthetic thankfully. Deer musk would be crazily expensive whereas synthetic musk is pennies. Companies normally vote with their budgets, so thankfully ethics come free with that even when brands don't appear to care in other respects. Body Shop is much better these days, ethically speaking, now that they are owned by Natura rather than L'Oréal, I trust them much more! Thanks for watching ❤️
Good video. thank you. Am I the only one on this planet who thinks the smell of musk perfume is revolting? Kind of makes me want to gag. When I smell it on other people I have to get away. No other perfume affects me like that. “I know it may sound selfish but let me breathe the air.” -Little River Band (Cool Change)
Thank you ☺️ Do you mean animalic musks? Or all musks? Musk can smell really different depending on the type. There is likely to be just one or a few types that you don't enjoy I would have thought.
I love musk. I have smelled all kinds: synthetic and natural. They all smell different to me so I understand why some folks have a preference. It’s kinda magical in how one can spray it on someone’s skin and that person might not smell it at all, while a person in the vicinity of the wearer may smell baby powder… a second person in the room may smell cat pee… a third person may be utterly intoxicated and not know why. And yes it’s sad that people would kill deer for their musk, however, there are people today who hunt the deer for meat to feed families, and the musk pods are made available that way. The process must be controlled though even for food.
Yes! Musk is so diversely perceived! It's absolutely fascinating and a truly intoxicating note. If the deer are being killed for food anyway, maximum use should be made, if possible, of all parts, although I do not know whether musk deer are used for food now. Thanks for watching ❤️
Thanks you for this so very interesting Video. I have quite a collection of older perfumes. Estee Lauder, Givenchy, Chanel of course. I like them all, but I don't wear them because of these animalic notes. I collect them for referense reasons. Civit or older musks, I don't need them.
Yes, I think it's a positive thing that musk has become more ethical and I think modern chemistry is really expanding the range of musks available to perfumers too, even animalic touches are being copied better than before. I can definitely see why people would collect older fragrances, they are social history 👌 thank you for watching ❤️
@@dr.claire.perfume I remember trying other flakers maybe 12 years ago, but I don't know if they are still around (could be), by the way a lot of people say it's a little unisex but the men's version of it is also really good
Just bought Kiehl’s original musks. I was intrigued by how people in 1920s perceived smell of musk like. Musc Ravageur smells synthetically sweet but not overly sweet. It is pleasant to smell on your skin. It is like skin scent but unfortunately not long lasting. By the way, i like the way you tell your story in the beginning by putting some historical context in it. Musk is one of Prophet Muhammad’s favourite scent apart from Rose, Oud and Camphor. I am curious about Musc Tonkin by Parfum d’Empire. It is said the smell mimics the real musk gathered from the pod in 19th century from Vietnamese deer. Musk from Tonkin (Vietnam) was the most sought after during the era. I had tried small quantity of natural deer musk from Musc Khabib by Bortnikoff. From what i can remember the smells is pleasant, but have some animalic quality in it. There is a hint of barnyard smell in it but overall it is nice. There is another one house that i know of from Russia that used real Siberian deer musk. it is call Areej Le Dore by Russian Adam. It is legal according to the Russian law since the pod is sourced from a deer killed by certain tribes in Siberia for their own livelihood/survival in a very harsh environment. It is very expensive and difficult to get. I just imagined if we could just put some testosterone precursor inside the formula. I dont know who Jon Snow is but i like the feeling of walking into the off beaten path into the woods. I can smell of damp earth, wet mossy wood with a hint of musk and amber after the rain. Do you often walk into off beaten track like Jon Snow did?
Gosh! You are very into musk! 😊 It's a few years on from this video and I do really enjoy Musc Ravageur, but yes, I agree, it is much sweeter and actually less grrr with the musk than I had imagined it to be. I have heard a lot about Tonkin musk! I am also very intrigued to smell some 😊 I can understand how Siberian deer musk is allowed, if they are taking animals for survival, it seems respectful that they should be able to use every part. I do do a bit of walking, not generally on camera though, I find it hard enough to film 😂 but Jon Snow is one of my best friends here and has his channel here @ScentedSnowdrops he loves Amouage (he's made 3/4 videos reviewing about 60 Amouage fragrances) and indie fragrances. He does a lot of storytelling with fragrance too. He's worth checking out! He always walks around when he's reviewing. Thanks for watching 🥰
I've not tried that one, my grandmother was born around the same time and wore Californian Poppy by Atkinson's. My other grandmother wore Blue Grass by Elizabeth Arden. Thanks for watching 🥰
Thank you! The ones that spring to mind are la nuit Tresor musc diamant and Narciso Poudrée but I am sure there are more! For ambrette, I like Glossier you. What about you?
It makes me sad when creatures are slaughtered for us; whether in fragrances or “medicines” or luxury (fur coats). So glad the perfume industry stopped that practice years ago. One of the best videos I’ve listened to in a while! From one science “nerd” to the other! 🥰💕Of course nerd is a term of endeaarance .
Of course! Nerd is a badge of honour ☺️ Yes I totally agree, I'm so glad there are lab alternatives now to deer musk. Thank you so much for watching!
Yeah, and in America they cry that they can’t kill babies in some states.
cornball
The suffering is endless, today children are explored for you to buy a bottle of perfume, or to harvest many raw materials, human is complicated, dont blame yourself
GO VEGAN!
Hey Claire, great video.
This may have been mentioned already and I may have missed it, but the reason why some of the modern synthetic musks smell "clean" or "white", or like opening a tumble dryer or ironing a shirt, is that musks are used quite extensively in laundry detergents and fabric conditioners, often together with synthetic "fresh" white-floral aromachemicals.
The human sense of smell is greatly influenced both by our cultural context and by olfactory experiences and memories built throughout our life, which is why most Europeans today associate certain molecules used in cleaning/washing products with cleanliness and freshness.
In the example you mentioned, habanolide does not actually smell metallic, but simply similar to the different musks clinging to the damp laundry that are being heated and evaporated by the hot-iron. (A heated hot-iron actually does not smell of metal, as solid steel itself does not smell of anything.) Only our deep olfactory memories tell us that this is the smell of hot metal.
People who have never seen a hot-iron in use before will smell habanolide as neither "hot" nor "metallic"; in fact they may not even be able to consciously smell habanolide at all if their olfactory system has never been primed to distinguish the smell from other background smells.
In a similar way, vanilla does not smell "sweet" to people who have never eaten a sweetened vanilla dessert or cake in their life; and ethyl maltol smells specifically like cotton candy only to people who have experienced real cotton candy before.
Yes absolutely, associations are strong with smells and you can say similar things about people who've never smelt other things. Associations are sometimes very cultural, for example, chrysanthemums and death or lilies and death. This is part of why I find gendering of fragrances really unhelpful. Thanks for watching 🥰
Wow.. the fact that people would kill them in droves for such a selfish reason is disgusting.
I am loving this video. So much info. The fact that I've always explained Musk this way without actually knowing the scientific side makes me love my nose that much more. Lol. It's so sexy to me.
Yes, it's quite strange to think now isn't it? I can't imagine deer musk selling now at all... But I guess people loved fur too back then, it was somewhat normal to exploit animals.
Yes, musk is definitely up there on the sexy scale. 😊
Musks are tricky since they can smell so varied, like you said. I have a soft spot for those 80s/90s style white musks. They are pretty and clean without being full on detergent-like, and not super floral. I know they don't smell sophisticated, but the cozy nostalgia is appealing. Thanks for this primer on musks!
Yes, I love the clean ones too, it is a very fine line between clean and detergent-like! I guess because that is exactly what musks like ethylene brassylate and galaxolide have been used for, as well as for perfumes. I really have a very strong nostalgia for Body Shop white musk. I've not tried it recently but I would love it to smell like it smelt in the 90s. Thank you for watching! 🥰
Yes, I really like the 80s and 90s white musks. Do you happen to have any recommendations for the best perfumes or fragrance oils that have close to the same white musk scents of the past?
@@rellg.2607 If you can find Derek Lam 10 Crosby "Silent Street" for a decent price, it's a nice scent in the vein of Jovan White Musk, etc. I have it in a body spray and it's fleeting but pretty and nostalgic.
Hello my beautiful friend! Oh wow, how awesome to know this info. I love Musk and men. Lol
Hello Tera!!! 😂 haha, me too!
Oh wow! I just discovered your channel and it was very educational! I work in the flavor/fragrance industry yet I learned so much! Please continue this science of fragrances and talks about the industry! I also watched your video about why perfumes get discontinued. I was like, "finally finally! someone mentioned that IFRA has something to do with it!"
Thank you! ❤️ It must be really interesting to see this from the other side. I would love such inside knowledge 😂 IFRA has banned or restricted a lot of important fragrance components so yes, it's certainly impacted what is reformulated or discontinued. Thanks for watching 🥰
Thank you so much for explaining this . I love musk in anything and Narcisco Rodriguez is a master at musk fragrances and I love civet and castoreum in my fragrances. I am happy they are not hurting any animals anymore for fragrances.
Aah no worries! 😊 Yes, happily synthetic civetone and replacements for natural castoreum have been about for a while now 😊 thanks for watching 🥰
This is one of the best fragrance series I've ever watched. I'm so excited to binge all these videos 😁
Thank you! I loved researching this video! Musk is an obsession! I hope you enjoy the other ones, they are perhaps less epic than this one 🤣
Musk is the smell of heaven , someone who smelled a real kasturi will not love any other perfume
Musk can indeed be very magical ✨ thanks for watching 🥰
One of THEE BEST, MORE KNOWLEDGEABLE RUclipsrs around! You always make your posts so interesting and entertaining...Great vid Clair! Oh, And those poor deer!😮. For Humans to kill so many of these beautiful animals so that we can "enjoy fragrances" more is unconscionable, but then again, WE ALL benefit in one way or another from plundering our natural recources, including the wonderful wildlife which surrounds us, I guess I'm saying "who am I to judge" lol
So sorry for the late reply (YT filters got this one for some reason 🙃🤷♀️). Thank you so much! ❤️ That's lovely of you to say! You are right, if we saw the reality of the trail of destruction that pretty much everything that we consume leaves we'd be very shocked, but musk deer needed saving. Thanks for watching 🥰
@@dr.claire.perfume my pleasure ☺️
Why am I only seeing your videos now? I seriously love your videos. They are so informative and I have never subscribed a channel this fast lol. Thank you so much for these amazing information you give us!
Thank you 🤣 I will do more perfume science videos 😉 really happy that you like them! 🥰
Oh my goodness! I just did a musk video too! 😀Musk is one of my favorite perfume notes. I always say, "Musk is a Must." 😊 You gave a lot of interesting information and took a deep dive. I try to give people sufficient information too. 😊 I did that in every one of my "perfume note series" video.
Yes I think it's good to have a bit of background on what these ingredients are and how they are used. I find it fascinating! ❤️
@@dr.claire.perfume Me too! 😊
I have been looking for a book that would cover exactly what you just covered. I will subscribe to your channel. This is a fascinating world.
Thank you ❤️ I'm happy that you enjoyed this! I think this is my favourite video 🥰
Musk is such a natural odor I don’t think any perfume can recreate the natural smell ☺️ I love learning all the intricate details you share!❤️ I love a good musk!☺️🤗
Deer musk is likely a lot more dimensional than synthetic musks, but I do like the clean feeling of modern musks! Haha Sunny, this video literally took me a week! 😂
In the seventies until 1984 I have often smelt the real oily animalic musk, if you want to know EXACTLY how the real animalic deer's musk smells like, you should try Ambraliquida by L'Erbolario. Ambraliquida is a cruelty-free scent, has non-animalic ingredients, BUT it is exactly how deer musk in perfumery smells like: warm, sweet, powdery, slightly pungent, little bit dirty.
Loved the video and the wonderful scientific explanations, you look fabulous and you are very intelligent, congratulations, new friend here.
P.S. I do NOT work for L'Erbolario,
I just live in Italy and found in this brand, that kind of musky scent I used to love in my youth.
Hello! Thank you for the advice on where to find animalic smelling musk! I honestly don't think I ever smelt it... It's great to hear comparisons from someone who knows what they are looking for. Thank you also for your lovely comment, I hope to make a few more videos in this series soon. I am afraid I don't speak Portuguese, but I subbed 😂 I am happy to do so! ❤️ Thank you so much for watching!
@@dr.claire.perfume you are welcome! Thank you very much for subbing as well 🌹🌹🌹💐 Yes, I speak Portuguese, I was born in Rio de Janeiro but live in Italy, my husband is Italian. Sending you many greetings from Italy 😊🌹🌹🌸🦋🦋
@@VeritasVincitFragrancesVeritas my husband is learning Italian at the moment, he is a languages teacher. He has French German and Spanish already.
@@dr.claire.perfume woooow wonderful, happy to hear this ! Italian is a beautiful language, love it. I can speak and write in German, I lived in Berlin during 27 years, I love Berlin very much, Berlin has youthful vibes, young energy and there is so much to learn over there.
Your husband is very intelligent and loves learning and teaching, congratulations!!!!!!!!
😂😂😂Synthetic musk discovered accidentally whilst making TNT! 😂😂😂😂😂🙌💕
Just as powerful, just in a very different way! 😂
Claire! This was fantastic! I loved learning about musk! Super informative and helpful. Loved the Jon Snow cameo, too. Just top notch content. Keep the series coming! We need you!
Thank you Julija, I like making science videos but wow do they take me a long time! 😂 it was lovely of Jon to record something for this.
So informative! No scent is worth harming an animal. Thanks for the science and the synthetic musc (and other ingredients such as ambroxan)
Thank you ❤️ I really loved researching musk for this video. It's a special note ☺️
Holy smokes really blown away by the origins of synthetic musk my word. Thank u for this video. ive always been weirded out with the implications of organic natural musk in perfumery, and for so long ive subconsciously assumed natural musk likely came from actual ppl or smthing. completely overlooked the fact that animals too were an option lol
Haha! I am happy to enlighten you! Musk has a very complicated history as it's really unclear sometimes what people mean by musk as it's often a mix of compounds now when used in fragrances, not just one! Thanks for watching 🥰 have a fab week ❤️
Fantastic video! I love all the research and how you've presented it all. Thank you so much, Claire. You're such a delight 💜
Thank you Tina! This took a lot of planning 😂 I'm so happy that you enjoyed it, thank you so much for watching. 😘
Love your perfume science series 👍
Musk is one of my favourite notes, in almost all nuances 😍 Musc Ravageur is great one and I also love the modern Narciso Rodriguez musk 🥰
Thank you! Yes musk is a winner for sure with its many different forms! Thank you for watching ❤️
Ooooh! I so enjoy your research-y and info videos. They are so unique, the internet needs them!
Thank you! I am so pleased that people enjoy them cos they take a long time to make! 😂
You amaze me with your research and providing all this wealth of information. ❤ This was so interesting! Musc Ravageur smells like cat pee on my skin. I was appalled the first time I smelled it 😅
Haha, I'm scared! I don't think that one is for me 😂 thank you so much for watching 😘
What a fantastically interesting video Claire and thankyou for taking the time to talk about Musk,
I hope you do alot more of these and I love the way you talk about these subject ,Great video x
Thanks Scott! This was definitely more research than I expected it to be 😂 for sure, I want to do a few more of these. I already have one on solar notes and one on watery notes. Let me know if you have a request. Thank you for watching. ❤️
I love musks especially from Narciso Rodriguez. The older style of extracting musk from the deer was quite wild. Thanks for sharing 👍
Yes! Musk goes way back! So good that synthetics are available and such a diversity of smell from them too 😊 I also love musk! 🥰
My favorite series🙌 Thank you for taking the time to inform us!❤
Thank you for watching! ☺️
My goodness Claire. I really appreciate all the research and time you put into this video!!!👌💗
This took so long Val, literally a few nights of research here and about a week of nights editing 🤣 This was a labour of love!
@@dr.claire.perfume 💗💗💗💗
Body Shop’s White Musk was holy grail status for me in the late 90s and early 2000s. I’ve heard it’s not the same anymore. Ellis Myth reminds me ofit though.
Yes, I went to try it as I had feelings of nostalgia for it but it wasn't how I remembered it. It has lost its identity. Everything has sadly been reformulated at the body shop, I think that's been part of the problem, along with exorbitant prices now. I will look into the Ellis Brooklyn. Thanks for watching 🥰
I love vintage perfumes, so I would be really interested in smelling some old style animalistic perfumes. I also love both original alien and body shop white musk. Funny enough I've heard a very young youtuber saying that bodyshop white musk reminded her of sweaty armpits. It astonished me because to me it smells so clean.
Wow! I would never think of white musk as armpits 😂 that is so funny! The original Alien is amazing! I am hoarding my bottle 😂 thank you for watching 😘
I love the note of musk. Although I must say I never loved the original formulation of Alien. My introduction to the note occurred in the late 60’s early 70’s when the note was a little more refined in my opinion. Great information Claire. Keep them coming.
Thank you! ❤️ I thought this might be something a bit different 😊 Do you think musk was a little more subtle in the 60/70s? Was there any one fragrance in particular that you were thinking of? I guess the musk in Alien that Jon talks about is an aspect of the cashmeran... Not technically a musk but something that smells very much like a musk. I can totally understand that Alien is not for everyone! I remember thinking it was very very loud when it first came out! Thank you for watching as always, it's always lovely to see your comments 🥰
I love these informative videos about perfume chemistry!!! ⚗️🧪
Thank you ❤️
I’ve always wondered about this note! Thank you for this very enlightening video, Claire!
Thank you for watching Brooke! ❤️
Hey 👋 Claire….. This was a great video. I love the smell of animalistic notes which is probably why I love Poudree so much.
Yes, I think musk is very special! Thank you for watching ❤️
This was such an amazing video. I have always wondered about this note. Thank you for such a thoughtful dissertation.
No worries! Thank you so much for watching 🥰
I've had the opportunity to smell actual musk deer musk (musk tonquin) tincture in the past and I do love the odor. There is a modern product called tonquitone produced by IFF that is a really good facsimile of it. Ambrettolide is also quite similar but less animalic.
I've not smelt it, but I would love to. I can imagine the more modern musks are more of a range of clean to dirty, icy to warm, fresh to nutty, powdery to creamy than ever before. Perfumers need that range to be able to make what they want to. I absolutely love ambrette, I wish it were used more! Thanks for watching ❤️
I would love to see more scientific information videos like this on different notes! 😊
Hi Yasmin, thanks for your feedback! I will look into doing a few more. I warn you that these videos take quite a bit of reading and prep so it might not be straight away, but yes, I will do more! ❤️
This is one such video you would like to listen to minute by minute. And if you miss something you would take out the time and go back and listen to it again.
@@sohinisarkar4101 thank you ❤️ I really loved making this video, I'm happy that you enjoyed it 🥰
Another great video! 😍 I love your science related perfume videos and this is was so straight to the point ❤ Thank you for making such effort to create these contents, it was very informative for me. 😊😊😊
Oh thank you, that's brilliant 🥰 I am so happy to read that! It is difficult to find information on these things in one place sometimes, so it's handy to have it in a video 🙂 I will for sure make some more perfume science videos. Thank you again! ❤️
I think I have smelled animalic musk, yes. When I was a young child in the 60s-70s my relative asked if I wanted to smell her perfume but said be careful this has musk in it. Do you want to smell it anyway? I was just a toddler/kid but said yes. I remember it was a nice experience and I have had good associations with the idea of the smell of musk since. I have not worn many perfumes through the years and am just now in my 50s really getting into it. I do love Narciso Rodriguez For Her. I'm glad we can have a nice smell without killing animals for it now.
Yes animalic musk is quite different to the cleaner ones that are more common now. But there are certainly some examples of vegan musks that are closer to the animalic versions. I think Narciso Rodriguez for her is now considered a classic fragrance, one of those bookmarked examples of musk in fragrance.
Well done, Dr. Smith!! Thorough history of musk on perfumery - very informative. Lovd the video insert from Jon Snow! 💖💖💖
Thank you! Yes it was lovely of Jon to record something for this. ❤️
Wow, so interesting Claire - thank you for sharing this!!! Also loved Jon's cameo appearance at the end!!!🥰🥰🥰
Thanks Joss, glad that you enjoyed it! ❤️
Wow, thank you, that was a BOMB full of information!
No worries! Thanks for watching 🥰
Gosh you’ve put in an enormous amount of research! Informative & fascinating content. Really enjoyed this, well done 💜
Hi Lucinda, thank you! I hope to do some more in this series soon! Thanks for watching, I'm so happy that you enjoyed it. x
Doesn't matter how many times I watch this. It's just the best Claire. You're easily the best at this type of content out there.
Still sometimes I forget that bloke at the end ruins it 😜
Thank you! And 🤣 oh the bloke at the end made it ❤️ I really loved that you wanted to do something for this. 🥰
@@dr.claire.perfume well we need to do more 😜
For sure 😊
You are really providing super detailed videos for enthusiasts. I can imagine these take a long time to write and produce. Thanks for all your effort. Is this your full time job? If it isn't than really thanks for all the effort on a side gig.
Thanks. It's just a hobby but yes researching, writing and making the more in depth ones can take a while 😂
Excellent blend of educational, informative and fun facts about one of the most important smells there are: a musk! Some more parfume examples would always be most welcome! Very interesting content and highly enjoyable presentation! Great video!
Thank you! ❤️ I really do love musk!
@@dr.claire.perfume I do not know if it is musk or something else but I find both "Black bottle" and "White bottle" Narciso Rodriguez "for her" irresistible!
@@MrVoayer those are indeed very musky! So that does makes sense! And the Narciso musk is very distinctive isn't it? I think it's a combo of a few. 🥰
I love YSL and the musky notes they have in some of the fragrances. I love how detailed you got here. Very impressive and interesting to watch!!
Thank you! Yes YSL have some lovely ones ☺️ really happy to read that you enjoyed the video! 🥰
Wow so much I didn’t know about Musk! You certainly did your research, now I know why I like the smell of male sweat lol thanks for sharing ❤💕👌🏽
Yes! Love of male sweat is definitely a thing! 😂
Binge watching your videos too 😅😅😅 thank you for your teachings and knowledge. Thank you !
Thanks for watching 🥰
WOW! I've learned so much, this video should be taught in perfumery classes 🧡🧡🧡🧡
Is that a good thing? 😂 I hope so! 🤣
@@dr.claire.perfume YES😺😺🧡🧡
@@silverliningfragrance1434 phew! 😂
Incredibly knowledgeable and to the point. Well done Ma'am. Sending love from NYC.... Thank you
Thank you ❤️ I'm glad you found this informative. Thanks for watching 🥰
You're my go to for the science behind fragrance. This is a great video ❤
Thank you Gabi ❤️
Hi beautiful Claire! It makes me sad 😔 that all those deer were killed for musk. So happy to know that it’s being produced in the lab now. ❤
Yes super sad, unfortunately they are still being hunted in some countries for certain traditional medicines, but the numbers are limited at least. ❤️
Your videos are so different, a master class I really appreciate your content.
Thank you! I loved making this video, it's one of my favourites 🥰
I learn more about perfums in all your videos 💝
Thank you, that makes me very happy ☺️
🌹
You did such an excellent job in this video. Thank you for the knowledge bomb
Thank you ❤️ no problem at all! Happy that you enjoyed it ☺️
Thank you for this interesting info. I haven't yet learned to love musk-forward fragrances like Musc Ravageur or Narciso Rodriguez for Her EDT, but I know noses evolve.
Yes, I've struggled with Narciso for her EDP for sure, but more because of the patchouli and peach I think... Some of my favourite musks are the cleaner ones, I really love la nuit Tresor musc diamant for example, that is more of a white musk. For sure your taste can change, I hope you find a musk that you love eventually. Thank you for watching ❤️
Great video Claire! ❤ You did a great job giving people all the information about musk in perfumes. 😊
Thank you! It took me a crazily long time to find all of this info 😂
@@dr.claire.perfume I bet it did take you a long time! I love hard working creators. Unfortunately, people aren't always appreciative of it. Thank you for doing your homework Claire! 🥰❤
@@CeylonCleo thank you!
I love Musk in fragrance 🥰 thank you for the information
No problem, thank you for watching ❤️
What an awesome video🤩 I absolutely loved it Claire! It was super interesting and you’re a great presenter!!!!! I’d love another on Oud!!!!!!!!!
Thank you so much! I will add oud to my list, that sound like a great one to make! ❤️
So.... musks. You've answered some of my questions (thanks Claire!) and prompted others. Isn't that always the way, though. Wouldn't it be lovely if the musk chemicals were disclosed when fragrance shopping? I've identified a dry down scent I find repulsive, and it's a metallic, brassy note. So far, I've traced it to notes for florals and musk. I do find it most often in older perfumes from department store houses, and it does remind me of vintage clothing from the 40's-60's that I used to wear. I'd love to know which musk chemical leaves a metallic residue. Also, isn't funny that items that we'd consider as stinky, like sweaty deer testicles and glands, and roots like patchouli, were combined to make interesting scents? I like to imagine the first person who said, wow, this root smells like wet, unwashed wool socks. What can I use it for? Obv I'm making light, but these are the shower thoughts I have. And how nice to see Jon! And it looks like Summer there, too.
Yes, I always think that, I want to learn how to individually identify musks. I think galaxolide is very distinctive, but that's not used now.
I think with patchouli, it's the branches that are used or maybe the leaves, I'm not sure. I think it was used because it was originally used to wrap silks to protect them from moths when they were shipped from the Far East. People noticed the smell on the silks and liked it and wanted to know what it was. That's my romanticised version of how patchouli got popular anyway. 😂
What a great informative detailed video 👏👏👏 New subscriber
I'm going to watch another video of yours because of the title and thumbnail which says perfume notes that makes you attractive.
Thank you! I'm glad that you enjoyed this! There might be other videos in my perfume science playlist that you might enjoy.
Loved this video - I really enjoy your more scientific content in particular :-)
Awwh thanks Emma! That means a lot! Hope you are enjoying your weekend! ❤️
Fantastic you are! Thanks for this video! 👌🏼👏🏼😍
No problem! ☺️ glad you enjoyed it! 🥰
This is very informative video! I am really happy our chemist can produce the synthetic of it because it is really unfair for a deer to be killed because of its popular gland! Using an original musk is like you use a horse in this modern era on the road which is not relevant anymore and i support our chemist to keep researching and produces more exact smell like the original one.
I agree that it's no longer needed. I absolutely love ambrette but the other musks provide varied and diverse musk profiles for a variety of fragrances. Thanks for watching 🥰
Another informative, well researched video from Claire. 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Thank you ❤️
This is so fascinating! Thank you, Claire!
Thank you ❤️
Thank you so much for this video! Super packed with information
No problem! Thanks for watching 🥰
Obviously an excellent video. Thank you for this
No problem, I'm happy you enjoyed it. It's probably still my favourite video that I've made 🙂
Became addicted to white musk a few months ago, I tried to find out what exactly it was but found nothing. Thank you for the video
I was also super curious! It's just a clean mix from what I can discern. It is a very hazy term, I think clean primarily but that special mix of different musks (either polycyclic or polycyclic and linear) is key. Thank you for watching! ❤️
So informative. Thank you!
Thank you 🥰
What a great informative video claire ! 🙂, I learned from this i didnt know there are lots of different types of musk and how they smell like, im actually not a big fan of musk, slight muskiness is ok to me depends on what other accords it is mixed with.
What a great job you put on this video 🙂❤️
Thank you so much Rin! I'm so happy that you enjoyed this! Yes mild musk is lovely isn't it? In some fragrances it can also be too much for me! Thanks for watching and I hope everything is going well! 🙂
So interesting! Thank you for your research!
Thank you! I'm really happy that you enjoyed this 🥰
Thank you so much for all your content. ❤
No problem 😊 I'm happy that people enjoy it 🥰
What fragrances would Ethylene Brassylate be in?
Have you tried Narcisso Rodriguez for Her EDT (Black bottle)??
Thats the only NR fragrance I've tried but THAT is the type of musk I love!!
The laundry one is alright but I want to know how I can find fragrances with that NR for Her black (if possible) 😬
As far as I know, NR for her EDT was a mix of galaxolide and a bit of ambrettolide, but that's from reading not from me being able to pick out particular musks. Although galaxolide when used excessively, is something that I do think is pretty distinctive, e.g. the vintage Trésor. But I know galaxolide is in the process of being banned (or may have been banned now, I'm not sure).
I am not sure which fragrances would have ethylene brassylate, but I know that that musk is used sometimes to mimic galaxolide as LVMH did stop using galaxolide quite early on. Ethylene brassylate is also known as Musk T (Takasago), it's a round soft feminine skin musk. It can smell a little ambery or vanillic, but is usually used in combinations with other musks. It may be that NR for Her EDT has been reformulated to include Ethylene brassylate as a replacement for galaxolide over its 21 year history. Sorry but I'm not a perfumer so I have just read a lot about this! Asking an actual perfumer might yield a more accurate answer. Thanks for watching 🥰
I inherited several bottles of Chanel perfumes from my mother, which she would have acquired in the early 1970s. I’m certain they contain animal musk, as the scent , while beautiful, is heavy and “oily” - very much heavier and denser than the modern renditions I own. I would not wear these vintage perfumes, and therefore prefer the modern version. Also aligns with my approach of supporting the conservation of these beautiful forest animals and sustainability of nature. Thanks so much for an interesting video, Claire!
Maybe! Yes the vintage ones can be very heavy, the scent intensifies and becomes a little overwhelming with age sometimes. I'm happy we have all these modern musks rather than deer musk, I particularly love ambrette. 🥰
Thanks Claire . Me Bob from Malaysia and seeking info on how to make synthetic musk deer oil. Anyway tqvm cause few things. I should go through your video over again cause you speak spontaneously so must be truth of honestly. Take care and thanks again
Thank you! I am not a chemist, just a perfume enthusiast, so I don't think I can offer much help on how to make musks, but thank you for watching.
Thank you very much for sharing my friend👍 new friend here 👍
Thank you for watching 🌟
i love musk in fragrances... my Mom always bought musk fragrances for me before..
I don't know why people wanted to smell like the deer's pungent smell... 🤣 maybe they thought that they could hook a lot females as well if they wear the scent, like how male deers attract does...
so it is the Ethylene Brassylate kind of musk that I really enjoy in scents.. the cheapest kind LOL, the sweeter, vanillic kind... i love the "white" musk smell too... what about Black Musk? could that be just those synthetic musks that try to mimic the classic animalic musk?
I think I like the cheap one too 😂 I only just realised that black musk existed when I was making this video. I read about what was in the body shop one and it seemed like it was musk with darker notes like liquorice. I have no idea elsewhere, but I've seen it with leather, pepper and patchouli in the montale version. So I am guessing it is any musk centred fragrance with darker notes? Not sure cos I've not tried any black musk fragrances... Let me know if you find out! 🥰
@@dr.claire.perfume black musk is great, have you ever tried red musk? It's probably my favorite
I loved the ollab with Jon. Watch out for Hera by papillon, the ambrette is strong here, and it really tingles ❤
Yes Jon was so kind to record something for this! I am only sorry that we weren't more organised about it, we could have had a lot more fun with the whole thing 😂 ambrette is lovely, I only have one or two in my collection that I love with strong ambrette, but I would love to try Hera.
Thank you so much for this video!!!
No problem, so happy that you enjoyed it! ❤️
Kiehls Original Musk, and Skin Musk Oil by parfums de Coeur, Nemat Musk and Musk-Amber, Vanilla Musk, Cabot Labs Musk, are probably my favorites and the most wearable musks. If Coty Wild Musk still smelled like it used to, it'd be right up there with the rest. I sure miss it...Jovan Musk is still around, and popular. I never tried the Alyssa Ashley musks because they looked so white musk-cold to me, I always thought they would smell like hairspray. But they're incredibly popular, so maybe I'm missing out?
I feel like the cheaper musks of old were actually much better than the cheap musks now... I didn't try the Alyssa Ashley musks either but yes I am wary too! I would love to find a good musk oil, I'm sure there's one out there for me. Thanks for watching 🥰
@@dr.claire.perfume the Nemat musk oils are quite good, as well as Kiehls, and the skin Musk oil, it depends on which kind you like...I try a lot of different attars and musk oils from various makers, red musk oils are my favorites so far, but there's so many! Hindi musk, Mecca Musk, China musk, Jamaica musk, civet musk, patchouli musk, there's a musk for every taste.
Wow! It's a big world of musk out there! I need to try some more! 🤣
@@dr.claire.perfume currently loving Alkemia perfumers creations ... electric fur, a kind of soft musk, and foxfire, and cherries of the night....
They sound gorgeous, what amazing names ☺️
Well it was fantastic. A great overview in my mind it was probably even older than that. I bet the Chinese were using ambroxan 10000yrs ago 🤣.
Yea I always guessed women were more sensitive because many seem to struggle with musk. Our unconscious senses are quite incredible aren't they, the wonder of life.
Some great look at the different types and the molecules. I wonder why it became a thing after the war and not earlier.
But yes you know I loved this, ur guest, not sure what he was on about
I tried to verify that Talmud thing and I struggled to make a decision either way, it depends which scholar you agree with on the translation, anyway I kept it in. For sure it was being used by the ancient Greeks in the 5th century AD at least. I guess it all hinges on how well stuff gets recorded, like with the Vikings. I want to see the source for that with ambroxan 😂
Musk can definitely get too much for me in some contexts and this whole thing has made me wonder if I have anosmia to certain types cos it seems like it is really common!
I think the 50s were a time of looking forward and wanting new things, people were fed up and ready to bin their old stuff after years of rationing and shortages, new was exciting. I think that mindset expanded into use of synthetics in all types of fragrance and luxuries like perfume were becoming more accessible and mass market, so costs and supplies were important considerations perhaps?
Aww! My guest made it 👌 I read about catnip after you said that. That was another 2 hours of rabbit hole, so thank you for that 😂
@@dr.claire.perfume haha they also have a weird frisky reaction to the smell of bleach u know... Strange animals or maybe it's made with cat wee?
Yea I doubt I can smell much musk and all the fragrance I wear must be why I'm single masking my muskiness 🤣
Yes that's a sad part of history isn't it, the ancients knew more than we gave them credit for and somethings are lost for us modern folk to say we discovered. It's like uranium and all that surely neolithic Estonian or wherever it is came across it, and maybe Merlin with his glowing sticks and such like
Omg thank you!!! 🤩
No problem 😁
When Jovan musk came out it took mainstream by storm
I've never tried it! I would love to though! I'm sure it's reformulated if it's still out there.
I could cry 💔 and the only musk perfume I’ll buy is from The Body Shop as it is vegan and no animals were used/harmed in any way, ever.
I think nowadays musk is almost always synthetic thankfully. Deer musk would be crazily expensive whereas synthetic musk is pennies. Companies normally vote with their budgets, so thankfully ethics come free with that even when brands don't appear to care in other respects.
Body Shop is much better these days, ethically speaking, now that they are owned by Natura rather than L'Oréal, I trust them much more! Thanks for watching ❤️
I’d say contrary to popular belief ,there is nothing like the true ,real musk in a perfume ,back in the day it was done well 🤷♀️
I have no idea! I would like to smell it and see how it was though. 🤷♀️
Good video. thank you.
Am I the only one on this planet who thinks the smell of musk perfume is revolting? Kind of makes me want to gag. When I smell it on other people I have to get away.
No other perfume affects me like that.
“I know it may sound selfish but let me breathe the air.” -Little River Band (Cool Change)
Thank you ☺️
Do you mean animalic musks? Or all musks? Musk can smell really different depending on the type. There is likely to be just one or a few types that you don't enjoy I would have thought.
I love musk. I have smelled all kinds: synthetic and natural. They all smell different to me so I understand why some folks have a preference. It’s kinda magical in how one can spray it on someone’s skin and that person might not smell it at all, while a person in the vicinity of the wearer may smell baby powder… a second person in the room may smell cat pee… a third person may be utterly intoxicated and not know why.
And yes it’s sad that people would kill deer for their musk, however, there are people today who hunt the deer for meat to feed families, and the musk pods are made available that way. The process must be controlled though even for food.
Yes! Musk is so diversely perceived! It's absolutely fascinating and a truly intoxicating note.
If the deer are being killed for food anyway, maximum use should be made, if possible, of all parts, although I do not know whether musk deer are used for food now. Thanks for watching ❤️
@@dr.claire.perfume I’m told they are still hunted for food in parts of Russia and Kazakhstan… but that’s just what I’ve heard.
Aah ok, I wasn't sure! 🥰
Great content. I like white musk in fragrances but after a while it can become too much.
Yes, there are definitely limits with that pure clean powdery smell. And really heavy white musks can be a little headachy.
Good morning Clare ☕️
Good morning Frances! 🥰
Thanks you for this so very interesting Video. I have quite a collection of older perfumes. Estee Lauder, Givenchy, Chanel of course. I like them all, but I don't wear them because of these animalic notes. I collect them for referense reasons. Civit or older musks, I don't need them.
Yes, I think it's a positive thing that musk has become more ethical and I think modern chemistry is really expanding the range of musks available to perfumers too, even animalic touches are being copied better than before. I can definitely see why people would collect older fragrances, they are social history 👌 thank you for watching ❤️
@@dr.claire.perfume my pleasure.
This for me it is a dangerous note. I cant handle certain musks. Im still on the hunt to find the perfect musk for me.💗
I know what you mean. There have been a few slightly dirty fragrances that I've just not been able to get on with.
Super interesting, the Emporio White is a flanker of Lei (my signature) and I never tried it
Yes, it must have been long discontinued because I'd never heard of it!
@@dr.claire.perfume I remember trying other flakers maybe 12 years ago, but I don't know if they are still around (could be), by the way a lot of people say it's a little unisex but the men's version of it is also really good
@@silverliningfragrance1434 I only tried Lei and only once, I will try it again.
@@dr.claire.perfume It's very good, but I'm biased 😸
@@silverliningfragrance1434 we're all biased when it comes to our favourites, so many scent memories associated with them! ❤️
Just bought Kiehl’s original musks. I was intrigued by how people in 1920s perceived smell of musk like. Musc Ravageur smells synthetically sweet but not overly sweet. It is pleasant to smell on your skin. It is like skin scent but unfortunately not long lasting.
By the way, i like the way you tell your story in the beginning by putting some historical context in it. Musk is one of Prophet Muhammad’s favourite scent apart from Rose, Oud and Camphor.
I am curious about Musc Tonkin by Parfum d’Empire. It is said the smell mimics the real musk gathered from the pod in 19th century from Vietnamese deer. Musk from Tonkin (Vietnam) was the most sought after during the era. I had tried small quantity of natural deer musk from Musc Khabib by Bortnikoff. From what i can remember the smells is pleasant, but have some animalic quality in it. There is a hint of barnyard smell in it but overall it is nice. There is another one house that i know of from Russia that used real Siberian deer musk. it is call Areej Le Dore by Russian Adam. It is legal according to the Russian law since the pod is sourced from a deer killed by certain tribes in Siberia for their own livelihood/survival in a very harsh environment. It is very expensive and difficult to get. I just imagined if we could just put some testosterone precursor inside the formula.
I dont know who Jon Snow is but i like the feeling of walking into the off beaten path into the woods. I can smell of damp earth, wet mossy wood with a hint of musk and amber after the rain. Do you often walk into off beaten track like Jon Snow did?
Gosh! You are very into musk! 😊 It's a few years on from this video and I do really enjoy Musc Ravageur, but yes, I agree, it is much sweeter and actually less grrr with the musk than I had imagined it to be.
I have heard a lot about Tonkin musk! I am also very intrigued to smell some 😊 I can understand how Siberian deer musk is allowed, if they are taking animals for survival, it seems respectful that they should be able to use every part.
I do do a bit of walking, not generally on camera though, I find it hard enough to film 😂 but Jon Snow is one of my best friends here and has his channel here @ScentedSnowdrops he loves Amouage (he's made 3/4 videos reviewing about 60 Amouage fragrances) and indie fragrances. He does a lot of storytelling with fragrance too. He's worth checking out! He always walks around when he's reviewing. Thanks for watching 🥰
Thank you facinating break down.
No problem, I'm really glad that you enjoyed it. I have some other videos on petrichor and indoles that you might also be interested in.
Thanks Claire now watching your Top 10 Gourmand Fragrances Grown Up, I've struck gold here love your channel thanks again.
Thank you! 🙂
Haha Jon’s video is priceless 😂
It was lovely of him to film it for me.
The oldest perfume I know is taboo which my mother had. She was born in 1918 so I will look it up.
I've not tried that one, my grandmother was born around the same time and wore Californian Poppy by Atkinson's. My other grandmother wore Blue Grass by Elizabeth Arden. Thanks for watching 🥰
Loved this. You're funny.
Thank you 🥰
Fantastic and informative video, what is your favorite musky fragrance?
Thank you! The ones that spring to mind are la nuit Tresor musc diamant and Narciso Poudrée but I am sure there are more! For ambrette, I like Glossier you. What about you?
@@dr.claire.perfume♥️’s Luciano Pavarotti, Jaipur, and Mure Et Musc current favorites
@@MaskedManReviews ooh I really want to try mure et musc!
When I saw the name "Jon Snow", I expected the Channel 4 newsreader!
Not that one 😂 nor the one from Game of Thrones 🤣