Aristotle's Metaphysics

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 сен 2012
  • Chapter Nineteen from Book One, Part Two of Bertrand Russell's "The History Of Western Philosophy" (1945).

Комментарии • 50

  • @michaelaureliusrose3064
    @michaelaureliusrose3064 3 года назад +4

    The essence. Those qualities about yourself , which if lost you would cease being yourself . Aristotle called your “ Essence” ✨💖✨🌹✨

  • @S2Cents
    @S2Cents 11 лет назад +19

    workingklass, thanks for uploading this. I'd buy you a beer.

    • @emersonwilson872
      @emersonwilson872 3 года назад

      dunno if you guys gives a damn but if you're bored like me during the covid times then you can watch pretty much all of the latest movies and series on InstaFlixxer. Have been watching with my brother for the last weeks xD

    • @leandrotristian8229
      @leandrotristian8229 3 года назад

      @Emerson Wilson yea, I have been using InstaFlixxer for since december myself :D

  • @shelleyharris2850
    @shelleyharris2850 2 года назад +2

    Love your voice on these videos. Thank you 🙏😊😎🌍🖋💛🕊💪

  • @alwaysgreatusa223
    @alwaysgreatusa223 11 месяцев назад +1

    The invention of an ideal language to analyze natural language only begs the question of the metaphysical status of what language means.

  • @alwaysgreatusa223
    @alwaysgreatusa223 11 месяцев назад

    When the question is different from what you supposed it to be at the outset, you have done nothing more than simply begged the question by changing the subject.

  • @eniopasalic
    @eniopasalic 6 месяцев назад

    There is some background noise in these videos, such as inaudible speech.

  • @donjohnny6462
    @donjohnny6462 7 лет назад +5

    I prefer Aristotle to Plato by a large margin.

  • @HoovyTube
    @HoovyTube Год назад

    23:49 *The 4 causes* 🔆

  • @michaelaureliusrose3064
    @michaelaureliusrose3064 3 года назад

    I have never studied Aristotle quite as much as I should. Have I missed very much ?? I did not know that Aristotle was a student to Plato. I didn’t know that. I send my love. “”M’””✨💖✨🌹✨💖

  • @jodeg205
    @jodeg205 4 года назад +1

    That is true Alexander and Aristotle seems like they never met! Alexander seems to have not nurtured a reasoning mind but nurtured a warrior body and mind for strategy

  • @michaelaureliusrose3064
    @michaelaureliusrose3064 3 года назад +2

    ✨🌹✨ I wish to be more of the “ ideal animal” trapped in my own divine nature, that I really am. The Animal

  • @naztubez
    @naztubez 9 лет назад +10

    The true meaning of Aristotle's philosophy is sometimes confusing because he was an enlightened mind, he was an awakened being who had deeper knowledge of ultimate reality than most people will ever get close to in their lifetime. To approach his work from a purely intellectual perspective is to miss a lot of the spiritual profundity.

  • @Israel2.3.2
    @Israel2.3.2 3 года назад +4

    25:35 "Plato was mathematical, Aristotle was biological."

    • @peterwelsh1932
      @peterwelsh1932 3 года назад +2

      Aristotle believed in logic. Math, reason, computers (logic = computer language), science..
      Plato believed in essence, thing-ness (tree-ness, cat-ness! Dog-ness, person-ness) idealized metaphysical forms, “souls”
      Plato RATIONALIZED what he already thought, what he wanted to argue . Power, class, elitism, slavery. Opposite of pure math and logic. Aristotelian Logic doesn’t care what you want the answer 2B

    • @Israel2.3.2
      @Israel2.3.2 3 года назад +4

      @@peterwelsh1932 Aristotle argues for slavery in his Politics, he criticizes the system of slavery but doesn't seek to abolish it, arguing that some men are slaves by their very nature and that these men should be slaves.
      Plato was a mathematician at heart, proving that integer solutions to the equation aa + bb = cc must take the form a = nn - mm, b = 2nm, c = nn + mm, he taught Eudoxus the most original mathematician of antiquity, and his philosophy relies on the visual side of geometric diagrams much more so than Aristotle.
      Better to say
      "Plato was a geometer, Aristotle was a logician."

    • @tetraneutron9350
      @tetraneutron9350 2 года назад +1

      @@peterwelsh1932 Plato is over-rated, Aristotle is the man.

    • @alwaysgreatusa223
      @alwaysgreatusa223 11 месяцев назад

      @@peterwelsh1932 Aristotle was actually pro-slavery and believed in the supremacy of the Aristocracy. It is true that Plato was against democracy and believed in classes of society, but his Utopian society was conceived as being open to promotion of class-status for the individual based on intellectual merit as its foundation. I personally don't agree with politics of either man, but to think Aristotle was more democratic than Plato is absurd !

    • @alwaysgreatusa223
      @alwaysgreatusa223 11 месяцев назад

      @@peterwelsh1932 Plato's philosophy is largely a rational explication of what he believed to be the innate philosophy of Socrates and its metaphysical, epistemological, political, and moral implications. Aristotle's philosophy is based largely on Plato's philosophy, although Aristotle attempts to correct Platonism by modifying it with a critique based on a more exact logical analysis and ordinary commonsense.

  • @musabalalawi3554
    @musabalalawi3554 9 лет назад +3

    i respect scientists

  • @michaelaureliusrose3064
    @michaelaureliusrose3064 3 года назад

    Does Aristotle have any originating thought or is all of his work derivative from Plato ? ✨💖✨💖

    • @peterwelsh1932
      @peterwelsh1932 3 года назад

      I have heard your rhetorical statement before😹 The answer is “ If you have to ask... 🎶

    • @smkxodnwbwkdns8369
      @smkxodnwbwkdns8369 2 года назад +1

      Aristotle is very original, not derivative at all

  • @shelleyharris2850
    @shelleyharris2850 2 года назад

    Oh, my goodness, the history is like somewhat of a confirmation, hmm.🙏🙌💛🖋🔎😎💪🕊Blessed beyond.

  • @rgaleny
    @rgaleny 10 лет назад +1

    Quality is a better word for both a universal and a particular.

  • @shelleyharris2850
    @shelleyharris2850 2 года назад

    His hand

  • @michaelaureliusrose3064
    @michaelaureliusrose3064 3 года назад

    ✨🌹✨ To what extent is “ a person” merely the sum total of their actions and effects in the universe ? Can a “ being” who does not actually contribute, create, effect or actually do anything actually be called a “ person” ??

  • @michaelaureliusrose3064
    @michaelaureliusrose3064 3 года назад

    Am I defined only by the boundaries set around me. The rules and laws of others and my own personal limitations ? Do these things define who I am, and further who I am to become ? The will and whim of other Men ?? I think it not !! I think it not !!. The Prince of Persia ✨💖✨🌹✨

  • @caseofkobi9525
    @caseofkobi9525 9 лет назад +3

    This seems too personal to be free from bias.

    • @JCVET18
      @JCVET18 4 года назад +1

      I agree

  • @GaudioWind
    @GaudioWind 5 лет назад +1

    The more I hear about these ancient philosophers the more I think the king is naked. It seems that everyone is afraid to say that all this stuff is ridiculous and incoherent.

    • @lordmozart3087
      @lordmozart3087 5 лет назад +1

      Gaudio Wind How

    • @Oners82
      @Oners82 4 года назад +1

      Gaudio Wind
      Missing the point entirely.

    • @GaudioWind
      @GaudioWind 4 года назад

      @1jnkz The problem is that no one seems to have understood it. Every one has his own interpretation and no one is coherent.

    • @jackdarby2168
      @jackdarby2168 3 года назад

      The more i hear from "analytical"( as if they alone engage in analysis) "philosopher"( as if they qualify as philosopher) the more i realise that they are actually the same people we call journalists and microbiologists

    • @jackdarby2168
      @jackdarby2168 3 года назад +2

      @@lordmozart3087 because the commenter is low in the Virtue intelligence but high in the sin of pride

  • @michaelaureliusrose3064
    @michaelaureliusrose3064 3 года назад

    A form cannot be identical to its essence. Aristotle was mistaken. Ugly children grow up to be very beautiful people . Aristotle must accede to his error in this regard., Essence is not always expressed in form. Form is not always expressive of the essence in its completion and fullness. The uniform is not expressive of the person
    . The person is not the uniform that they happen to wear. This is a nonsense syllogism. I am very suprised at Aristotle. Very suprised

  • @shyamlalbharti3153
    @shyamlalbharti3153 5 лет назад

    #Knowledge and Perception in PLATO:Good Morning,Have very-2 nice & beautiful Thursday to all Our,"Vashudhevkutumbkam"......"GOD"bless us all...I miss you always....#Mere Ati Priyon,"Mujhhe Duniyan waalon,Sharaabi na sumjhho main Peetaa nahin hun;Na pilaai gai hai.....(2)Kahun Kyaa main kishko,sabhi be khabar hain Jamaane mein Apnaa Gujaaraa nahin hai...(2)#Mere Ati Priyon,"Aaj Esh tunhaai bhare Aalum mein,Central Church Ministries se;Yah jaannaa chaahtaa hun ki,"PAVITRA BIBLE" ka Mukhya PAATR/NAAYAK koun hai...?? Aap sub ki najron mein Maatr,"ISHU JI" hain,Binaa PITAA ki Aasheesh mein(0) Kripyaa,Buraa na maanein;Kyonki,Param PITAA nein Apnaa Ekloute bête ke Mooh mein;Apne Aashtitav ko Paridharshit kar Maan badhaayaa;Aur Samajiktaa ki Sohrat se Magan MUN ISHU JI,Swaim PARMESHWAR ban baithhe!"Mere Priyon,"PITAA--PITAA hi Rahtaa hai,Yadi ISHU JI ke Kar Kamlon dwaaraa;Aashcharya chaqit kaarya hoote Rahe;Too Kyaa kabhi PITAA ki bhi Yaad Aai....??NAHIN....KABHI NAHIN...?Mere Priyon," PITAA" ki Vednaa,Pahaadiyon se Baatein kar kahaa,"Mujhhe MANUSHYA ke PUTR par Purn Yaqeen Va Bharoshaa hai ;Aur meraa Vaachaa ke Anushaar PURN UDDHAAR bhi hai!!Mere Priyon,"Yah Vednaa Kyaa Sanket deti hai.....?? Abhi Gut VARSH mein DAASH-PUTR nein ISHU JI,Se VARSHAA KARWAANE ki Vinamr Apeel par JUG Hanshaai hui;Sabhi ko Galat saabit karne ki Raah se Magan Huye....."ISHU JI",nein bhi Apnaa haanthh Uthhayaa...??Magar,"DAYAA KE SAAGAR"Pyaare PITAA nein DAASH-PUTR ka Maan badhaane ke liye VARSHAA KARWAANE!Amen! #Mere Priyon,"Sachchaai too Yah hai ki,"Church Ministries" nein Purv Year se hi;"PAVITRA BIBLE"ke Addhyan/Massages par Rook lagaa diye hain;Mujhhe koi GUM nahin,Aadhyaatm ki Raah par chalkar PITAA se SUMAARG praapt kar lungaa;Meri kaamnaa hai ki,"PARMESHWAR" ki Mahtee Aasheeshon mein,Aap sub sadaa Khushhaal Rahein!Amen! #Aapka:Shyam Lal Bharti/"WISDOM OF KING"BHARAT.