Do We Need Vegetables to be Healthy?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 84

  • @robinbeers6689
    @robinbeers6689 Год назад +5

    Dr Ede is the best. It was her video at the Ancestral Healing Symposium in 2012 called "Little Shop of Horrors" that convinced me to go carnivore.

  • @chazmo1981
    @chazmo1981 Год назад +9

    I really enjoy your content. IF I bought you a microphone, would you use it?

  • @carnicavegirl7214
    @carnicavegirl7214 Год назад +5

    I am mainly animal-based, but I make sure I eat fermented vegetables, kombucha… I was strict carnivore for a long time, I ended up in the hospital with a severe ulcerative, colitis and rheumatoid arthritis flare, they did my bloodwork, and I was extremely deficient in vitamins and minerals🤦🏼‍♀️ I really thought I was doing everything right

    • @bloodybjorn711
      @bloodybjorn711 Год назад +1

      what do you mean with strict carnivore?

    • @carnicavegirl7214
      @carnicavegirl7214 Год назад

      @@bloodybjorn711 Only animal products

    • @bloodybjorn711
      @bloodybjorn711 Год назад +1

      @@carnicavegirl7214 so also eggs and raw milk and still deficient in vitamins?

    • @Fresh_N_Fit
      @Fresh_N_Fit Год назад

      What were you deficient in and what foods resolved your deficiencies?

    • @Mantis858585
      @Mantis858585 Год назад +1

      What vitamins were you not getting eating animal products?

  • @clanzu2
    @clanzu2 7 месяцев назад +4

    Eating carnivore almost killed me - that after 5 weeks of this diet i ended up in hospital …
    all started with me having diarrhea , being tested that i have sibo .. for 6 weeks i tried low fodmap diet it did not help , then i switched to keto diet for a month , it neither did any good , i had 8-9 time diarrhea a day , last thing i did was carnivore diet , consuming mostly beef lamb and eggs with gee since i am lactose intolerant, my diarrhea increased my brain fog increased , i could not sleep even thought i added electrolytes and salt .. i started eating lean to stop diarrhea never helped .. i dropped from 81 kg to 63 with 192 cm height , i could not walk any more .. whoever says carnivore diet is ultimate remedy for gut problems is at least ignorant , there should be some better studies , now i am just trying to survive eating boiled vegetables at hospital

    • @jorgegarcia3358
      @jorgegarcia3358 4 месяца назад +1

      Dang sounds horrible. How are you doing now?

    • @amandabae2952
      @amandabae2952 3 месяца назад

      troll, ii were not carnivore that "almost k1lled you", would have happen on every diet. Do you now what they are during the ice age? Do you know its serveral populations around the world that only eat meat without cancer n heart attacks and live to be 100yo. I smell troll or vegan propaganda.

  • @ayafresh
    @ayafresh Год назад

    Things are not always as they seem. Amen.

  • @higherpath362
    @higherpath362 Год назад +1

    Yes vegetables are very good. They sre not fully dead. But quality vegetables are hard to find. Look at countries who eat vegetables from their agriculture. They are not dying of cancer like in the west. My personal recommendation is 50 percent good quality meat and 50 percent great vegetables. Western people dont know much with all due respect. Go live in Asia and try their vegetables.

    • @truthseeker3967
      @truthseeker3967 4 месяца назад

      We here (I'm in USA) are being poisoned - poison in soil, in air, in water, sprayed on the produce. Things are just out of wack here; we're painted into a corner.

  • @jstar9819
    @jstar9819 3 месяца назад

    Yea but Dr. Ede's main points are basically just warning against the demonization of red meat. She didn't suggest to go full carnivore. She advocated for 'pre-agricultural whole food diet' and not that means an omnivorous diet. There might be dark sides of vegetables, but so does meat just like everything in life if used unbalancedly

  • @davidwayne9982
    @davidwayne9982 Год назад +5

    YOu know- I am carnivore right now-- but God created veggies for a reason.... and I hate to see them going to waste-- I'm about to think all this eat this- don't eat that shit is a CROCK- and say f.. it- and start eating whatever the he.. I want.. I'm too old for doing wtihout now-- eating was about all I have left..

    • @cornstar1253
      @cornstar1253 Год назад +3

      No. Humans invented the vegetables in the grocery store. They never existed in their current form until a century or 2 ago. Some like brocolli have been around for a thousand years or so, but it still wasn't make by God.

    • @davidwayne9982
      @davidwayne9982 Год назад

      @@cornstar1253 Yeah- you're right- NOTHING is like it use to be-- there is no "pure" anything any more. ;)

    • @adelarsen9776
      @adelarsen9776 Год назад

      beef and sheep@@davidwayne9982

  • @an67481
    @an67481 Год назад +1

    How do you handle parasites?

  • @thomj623
    @thomj623 Год назад +1

    Hi! What about fruits? I've been reading Paul Salidono's animal based diet and interested what you think? I havent gone full carnivore yet...I don't really have any health issues to address but like eating grassfed meat and butter and just feel like I'm more satisfied and eat less. Thanks!

    • @mrmaxcarter2306
      @mrmaxcarter2306 Год назад +2

      You should read studies rather than books from people writing them for profit. You might actually cause yourself problems going on an animal based diet. Feeling good short term is not the same as living a healthy, cancer free, life.

    • @thomj623
      @thomj623 Год назад

      @@mrmaxcarter2306 are you saying go full carnivore or eat fruits and veggies lol

    • @mrmaxcarter2306
      @mrmaxcarter2306 Год назад +1

      @@thomj623 I'd say eat more plant based with meat or fish on occasion, honestly. If you can't give up meat. A whole foods, plant based diet is proven safe and effective at reversing disease. Prevention too. But if you insist on a mostly meat diet, absolutely eat fruits and vegetables. Your gut microbiome needs food to help you. And eating high antioxidant foods will blunt, to a degree , the negative aspects of the meat. Something might feel good to do for awhile. But sometimes things catch up on you in way's you don't expect. Fad diets come and go. Low carb has changed its name so many times, it's ridiculous. Human ancestors did not live off of meat, unless they had too. They ate tons of fiber rich foods. But for arguments sake, say they did, why would you do something someone did only because they had to? I wouldn't take nutrition advice from a caveman. Or someone on RUclips. But if you do, find someone who knows what they're talking about, gas a background in medicine and nutrition , isn't profiting off of selling supplements or books or workshops. And read studies yourself. Anyone can publish a study. I can show you studies showing the health benefits of smoking cigarettes. Paid for by tobacco companies. The preponderance of studies would show, a plant based or mostly plant based diet is healthier for you. And if something is better, stay in the safe zone and wait for real science to say a meat based diet is better. I will say a carnivore diet or Paleo diet is better than a diet high in processed foods though.

    • @zazaiwon87
      @zazaiwon87 Год назад +2

      ​@@thomj623 there are great videos about this topic by Dr. Ken Berry and Dr. Paul Mason. I highly advise you to check them out. It will at least help you to understand what fruits, veggies and grains are doing to your body and that will help you to make food choices that fit you :)

    • @renolittle4950
      @renolittle4950 Год назад +6

      @@mrmaxcarter2306 I disagree with you regarding plant, nuts as these are high in oxalates promoting inflamation. for those of us who are insulin resistant, no carb helps stabilize blood sugars. Going carnivore keeps me satiated.

  • @truthseeker3967
    @truthseeker3967 4 месяца назад +1

    I saw video short of your bacon, egg and ______ breakfast- were those plaintains?? I'm asking here bc there is no way to comment under video shorts?

  • @nancymweasel6561
    @nancymweasel6561 Год назад +10

    Vegetables, fruits, grains, legumes, nuts and seeds are nothing compared to it's original size and nutrition. Humans have modified all these to increase calories, carbohydrates, and sugars. These foods are best eaten by animals and they process them properly to make the perfect food for humans.

    • @Michelle-Eden
      @Michelle-Eden Год назад

      I agree with you except for the nuts being modified (English walnuts being a possible exception). Do you have any evidence that pistachios or hazelnuts, for example, have been bred to increase their size?

    • @AbonneAbscent
      @AbonneAbscent Год назад

      @@Michelle-Eden exceptions only confirms rules

    • @Fresh_N_Fit
      @Fresh_N_Fit Год назад +1

      I'll start eating lamb shit then.

  • @KevinAmatt
    @KevinAmatt Год назад +5

    I chipped one of my teeth. After two weeks the chip was gone. My tooth grew back. Has ever happened to you?
    Apparently it’s because of vitamin K2 in our saliva. Using mouthwash destroys our saliva and damages our teeth. And maybe toothpaste as well. I only use a small amount of toothpaste in the morning.

    • @Bigboyjingles
      @Bigboyjingles 8 месяцев назад +1

      U serious?

    • @kratomujbrno242
      @kratomujbrno242 День назад

      @@Bigboyjingles sounds weird but can be done. loads of things that "experts" told you cannot be done. Can be done, healed, changed.. and I aint no alt person haha

  • @crazyleaf257
    @crazyleaf257 6 месяцев назад

    I mean never eating vegetables again sounds amazing to me but... Is it true

  • @seidyn9439
    @seidyn9439 Год назад

    and what about tomato? i just started with carnivore. 2 weeks ago.

    • @Q1369
      @Q1369 29 дней назад +1

      I stay away from night shades - only because they can trigger my migraines.

  • @adelarsen9776
    @adelarsen9776 Год назад

    Petra, Where are you ? You ok ?

  • @crazyleaf257
    @crazyleaf257 6 месяцев назад

    U have birds!!

  • @OGAesthetics
    @OGAesthetics Год назад +1

    May i ask:
    Whats ur thoughts on prebiotics & probiotics?
    Also: many people say we need to eat carbs to feed gut bacteria.
    Thanks! Love ur channel learn alot.

    • @cornstar1253
      @cornstar1253 Год назад

      Your gut bacteria will change depending on our diet. Not bad or good. We aren't fermenters like Apes. We digest using protease and lipase because we evolved as meat eaters predominantly.

  • @lilann6120
    @lilann6120 4 месяца назад

    The Maasai are not that healthy anymore… they started eating a lot of corn in their milk now… n when I saw a new documentary about them, u find some overweight people (mostly women) there… cos women are not eating as much meat as the men… one guy explained they do eat the corn for about 50 years now… n what s very interesting in a study about them they also found coronary arteries calcified in them… so I wonder how it happened 😂 but at least the vegan community got another stupid point why u meat is bad❤

  • @that-avr-drummer
    @that-avr-drummer Год назад

    I will never eliminate coffee or tea! Otherwise, I'm onboard LOL Great vid as usual.

    • @suddha1
      @suddha1 Год назад +1

      Yeah personally I say pick your battles and joys and coffee is one of those little things that give me joy so we should be ok continuing it

  • @crazyleaf257
    @crazyleaf257 6 месяцев назад

    Where did your accent go??😅

  • @mrmaxcarter2306
    @mrmaxcarter2306 Год назад +4

    Animal fats and proteins are not necessary. Ketosis is an emergency back up. It's not an intended lifestyle.

    • @zazaiwon87
      @zazaiwon87 Год назад +8

      What are you talking about? We absolutely need animal fats

    • @zazaiwon87
      @zazaiwon87 Год назад +3

      Dude, are you trolling?

    • @mrmaxcarter2306
      @mrmaxcarter2306 Год назад +1

      @@zazaiwon87 tell that to all the vegans walking around. Or the cows you're eating. Of course you don't need animal fats.

    • @dougreed2257
      @dougreed2257 Год назад

      ​@@mrmaxcarter2306 🤡🤡🤡😫🤪😜

    • @dougreed2257
      @dougreed2257 Год назад

      ​@@mrmaxcarter2306 p s, no words were needed😊

  • @ManMountainManX
    @ManMountainManX Год назад

    TY.
    070423/