Karen Read Says Jury Voted Not Guilty in Killer or Cover-Up Murder Trial
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 июл 2024
- BREAKING: A new motion filed by Karen Read's attorneys says the jury was ready to deliver unanimous verdicts on two charges when a mistrial was declared. The attorneys are now asking a judge to dismiss those charges, including murder.
#CourtTV What do YOU think?
Catch up on MA v. #KarenRead here: www.courttv.com/tag/karen-read/
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.com/email/
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.com/podcast/
Join the Court TV Community to get access to perks:
/ @courttv
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv
Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
RUclips / courttv
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE
www.courttv.com/trials/
HOW TO FIND COURT TV
www.courttv.com/where-to-watch/
![Chk Chk Boom - Stray Kids ストレイキッズ 스트레이 키즈 [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 240719](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/63QPwqCRGcw/mqdefault.jpg)
#CourtTV What do YOU think?
Catch up on MA v. #KarenRead here: www.courttv.com/tag/karen-read/?
Emmkay. So the jury whose foreman wrote that eloquent explanation to the Judge that they were deadlocked is the same foreman who didn’t understand you have to check the boxes on the jury slip???? Yeah, right. How insulting of you.
The Judge assigned to the Read case was AWFUL
I think you all are absolutely horrifically biased.
I also think that bev being inept was kinda expected going by every other person in the judicial system there.
Karen Read is a nasty liar and KILLER.
@@jtjones4081 Such rubbish, can you believe Alan Jackson ? The man that came up with all the conspiracy theories !!
misquote in this video...the jurors DID NOT pick the foreperson...the JUDGE did.
And THATS wrong!!
@jbkidsco juror number 4? And excused someone else correct?
love court tv hate when they get facts wrong and when their contributors clearly havent followed the case theyre speaking on Ive even caught them stating facts from another case and attributing, it to the one they were questioned about😡
One needs to make a short silent film featuring the smirks, confident, "Here I am, cam" expressions of KR and AJ.
@@shazzasees reason?
The judge dismissed the court without allowing the jury to say a word. The judge almost immediately just dismissed the court. Her bias is clear to me.
@@kateshane8277 she told the jury she will meet them in the jury room.
I always heard the judge give the jury their closing instructions. You don't have to speak etc. before anyone ever leaves the court room.
Its possible she wanted to poll the jury out of the eye of the public. Thats not uncommon. You dont want the jury being exposed to more criticism than necessary. But it looks like she didnt poll them at all.
She didn't even poll the jury asked the jury if this is their vote.
@@supernova743 can you imagine if she did and she knew the split.
@@supernova743Massachusetts is a non-jury polling state
This case is now complete.
The investigation was a joke, the DA is a clown, the prosecution was laughable, and now the judge has added more embarrassment. An absolute disgrace.
EXACTLY!!
You haven't heard even the half of it yet. Watch what happens there....
@@ThisCharminManc there will be a conviction in trial 2 guaranteed. let’s bet.
this case is not complete at all and you saying it is doesn’t make it true lol
Wait a minute,I thought the mob expected a not guilty on all charges
This judge wanted a guilty verdict. She wouldn’t accept anything less. She made that CLEAR
Clearly through that jury form. That was bizarre. No box for not guilty for lesser charges. Even when she went back on her decision and changed the form it was still very confusing! And not standard in MA.
@@Miaholmes4952 I agree 💯
Clear as water. Almost to juror's intimidation. Awful usage of the law!!! KR will ⚖️⚖️⚖️ PREVAIL🌺
Yeah the judge was in on the big cover up 😂😂😂😂
Absolutely right and it jurors that came forward not one
What a poorly ran trial and investigation. Massachusetts needs to do better.
Massachusetts needs to do better? MA. has always been a craphole because it is a top to bottom BLUE state entrenched in chaos and corruption.
You got it!!@@user-nn8ki8tg5u
If they did any worse they would be North Korea
Needs to do better and convict this criminal once and for all,, murderer out in public!
@@user-nn8ki8tg5uWell said!
Either the judge is awful at her job or she did this purposely to give the state another chance. This is absurd and a waste of taxpayer dollars!
And completely manipulating a case
Corrupt judge just the same as the corrupt cops that committed this despicable crime
No evidence! Jeez! Water for brains.
Yeah, who cares about John and his family and kids. KR is the only victim 🤮
@@colleenmiller7429 the greatest expense of all is the expense to Karen on so many levels in so many ways... ❤️
Does this surprise anyone? Not me! The judge openly showed the whole world how bias and corrupt she was for the entire trial.
Not true! Lie!
What a kangaroo court. I think it's time for the judge to retire.
Agreed. But I think it's time for this judge to face consequences.
Maybe she can go for a long Cape swim & meet a friendly shark. ❤❤❤
@@pebbles377 Because of THE TERRIBLE & CONFUSING VERDICT FORM, the jury falsely believed they had to AGREE ON ALL 3 CHARGES to render any verdict. IE: THEY MISTAKENLY BELIEVED THEY COULDN’T HAVE A VERDICT ON EACH CHARGE INDIVIDUALLY. This is a big reason our “JUSTICE SYSTEM” is extremely flawed: Lawyers & Judges use CONFUSING LAWYER-SPEAK because they’re basically FORCED TO by Legal Mumbo-Jumbo.
THERE SHOULD HAVE BEEN 3 BOXES NEXT TO EACH CHARGE:
Box 1 --- Not Guilty
Box 2 --- Guilty
Box 3 --- We Cannot Agree On A Verdict
This is such a tainted court case. This judge wanted a guilty verdict period.
Absolutely
😢😢😢
@@marymedler6702It’s almost like somebody just said that
She did want the guilty verdict. Period, nuff said 🙅♂️
😂😂😂 You are reaching!!! That's putting it.nicely
Horrible Judge !!!!!!!!!!
💯
@@Neraa777 corrupt judge
This is on the jury, not the judge.
The judge met with them after so she Definitely knew about it!
@@Haarschmuckfachgeschafttadpolethe judge gave them a hard time
We've seen judges ask, did you come to a verdict on any of the counts, when the jury is unable to agree. And if they have, that verdict stands! On record, before the jury is dismissed. It's insane to me to think the judge didn't even find out what the split was over. Insanity.
Exactly! She botched this whole case. She never should have been on it. If the motion is denied i gurantee the state doesnt retry after this. They will know they cant win next one
Nah., she knew exactly what she was doing.
She misled the public if there were 12-0 aquital votes on ANY of the charges. She declared mistrial as if they couldn't agree on all 3. She should be arrested.
Blame the judge. She was the worst judge I’ve ever witnessed.
I actually felt she let the defence get away with far too much. Allowing Hollywood into the courtroom and Cushing things because Jackson was having a fit.
@@mariannerogers8003 liberal judge
@@debrapeluso2233Nope CURRUPT!
@@debrapeluso2233people like you have only one retort for literally everything. It is so silly. Grow up.
How could she not have made sure or viewed The Forum how did she not tell the jury clearly, how did she get away with not viewing their jury form before declaring a mistrial how did the jury miss it if it was told
Its not a mistake from thenjury. It was a mistake of Judge!!!
She knew what she was doing.
Yes!
They blame everyone but the CRIMINAL Karen Reed!
You’ll believe anything won’t you?
@@PEBBLEZ21Shut up.
It’s infuriating that they didn’t know they could share they were unanimously in agreement with a few of the counts. How did they not know this??
The judge told them they have to agree on everything, without clear instructions that everything is for each count. The judge didn’t make this clear. I can easily see where people not working with law might not understand this. It’s Bev’s fault, but also attorneys for not asking her to make that clear.
Exactly
Unfortunately the judge is not going to do the correct thing here
It would have been on the jury paperwork, judge saw it and knows . Judge meets with jury after
Foreman was not voted for by jury , judge picked him damn court tv get ppl on that know what they are even saying
The entire case needs thrown out, judge retired and prosecute that police force!!
Colin Albert and Jen McCabre
The judge should not be retired she should be kicked off the bench with no pension.
Why would you want someone who definetly had something to do with your brother, or son’s murder to just walk free ? Read is not innocent in this , she was the last person with him. In her car, and knew exactly where she left him . There relationship was at its end , they both knew that, but just by Reads personality and actions , it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to see or hear more of her nasty words to know that Read was obsessed and jealous of O’Keefe being with anyone else but her .
“Tell them the guy never came in the house.”
@@Sherry-hk2vsoof given you don’t understand the clear facts of science in this case and that science proved JO was NOT hit by a car and a car did NOT cause those injuries, I’m guessing you are definitely not a rocket scientist or understand things that “you don’t need to be a rocket scientist to figure it out.”
The math don’t lie. Science proved she did not do it.
The judge announced I'm going to poll the jury in private and she told the court room she was meeting with the jurors privately
Then she knew and is dead wrong
It was 12-0 not guilty on top 2 counts. The jury had a group text going. I'd love to see that
Counts one & three.
I doubt the CW will bring the top charge in the second trial. Manslaughter is more fitting.
@@jtjones4081they CAN’T bring the top charge to retrial if the jury in fact acquitted her of that
@@gwp4eva Even though I believe she is not guilty 100%, you are incorrect. She was not acquitted. The jury was hung, hence couldn't come to ANY verdict using the form they were given. The state has already declared that they intend to retry her on all charges.
@jtjones4081 it would be if she actually hit him and double jeopardy which I heard the term being thrown around does not apply to a hung verdict. Only if she's Acquitted for those charges which is why I'm assuming here, the defense wants them dropped. Then hopefully go back to trial and have her acquitted on manslaughter. I mean if indeed 12 jurors voted not quilty on those two charges why was she denied those verdicts
I could not believe the behavior of this " so called" judge .........
Maybe if the court paid attention to what attorneys are saying about a confusing misleading form instead of saying we have always done it this way like it’s 1782 you wouldn’t have these problems.
Shady instructions from judge. She is in on coverup imo.
Wow! You are dumber than I thought. The judge cover up?
Definitely, I said that from the start, she should be wearing an Orange jumpsuit!
@@Shashie24 Because of THE TERRIBLE & CONFUSING VERDICT FORM, the jury falsely believed they had to AGREE ON ALL 3 CHARGES to render any verdict. IE: THEY MISTAKENLY BELIEVED THEY COULDN’T HAVE A VERDICT ON EACH CHARGE INDIVIDUALLY. This is a big reason our “JUSTICE SYSTEM” is extremely flawed: Lawyers & Judges use CONFUSING LAWYER-SPEAK because they’re basically FORCED TO by Legal Mumbo-Jumbo.
THERE SHOULD HAVE BEEN 3 BOXES NEXT TO EACH CHARGE:
Box 1 --- Not Guilty
Box 2 --- Guilty
Box 3 --- We Cannot Agree On A Verdict
Judge appointed the Forman.......... the jurors didn't elect the Forman...
Because the judge made instructions CLEAR AS MUD
Wow! Aunty Bev needs to be removed now! The state police are the one who investigates the jury issues
Ummm...no you are wrong. The jurors did not elect one person as a foreman, that was done by the judge. Get your facts straight.
Most other states the jury selects a for person auntie Bev selected the one in this trial
@@danielbernier9115it is different for each state, not just Mass
Thats totally irrelevant
I can’t believe these lawyers go on Court tv having never read Mass law. Embarrassing.
@@chhansen9813what is irrelevant? The woman said the judge selected the foreman which is not true. Are you saying facts are irrelevant?
Makes u wonder what other cases this little town has had like this..
Well, you asked...so right now there is the case of Sandra Birchmore. This place is rotten to the core.
No way the judge didn’t know this. She’s a corrupt PoS and has no business being in the position she’s in. I truly hope she’s disbarred after all of this.
Just in…. Trooper Proctor suspended no pay! Does this also mean he was fired indefinitely? He should also be charged!
Woohoo amazing
It’s about time!!! I hope he gets fired!!! W/O his pension AND CHARGED!!! Setting up an innocent person planting evidence witness intimidation he is guilty of all of this!!!
Proctor destroyed video evidence.
For what ? Swearing. Is that against the law ? Serious question ?
According ti legal bites, its a process. Hopefully next step he is fired.
This judge, really F@cked it up. She is either in on it or she's incompetent. It's a shame,.
Yea she is.. they call her Auntie Bev for a reason
She protects the townies with her corruption and position
Both things can be true.
The judge is ABSOLUTELY in on it, she knows the Alberts and McCabe, he brother IS THEIR FREAKING ATTORNEY.
It's not a shame... IT'S A DISGRACE!!!
Karen Read did not suggest anything. Counsel on her behalf submitted evidence. Important difference.
LMMFAO! Thats the same thing, CLOWN!
They always do that. The brother of O’Keefe was doing it in his interview. It’s very dishonest
It's a manipulative act by CourtTV to phrase their title falsely this way.
REALLY? Karen Read was VERY INVOLVED with her case.
@@claudiamontano519 the statement was made by her counsel to the court, it's not a press statement by Karen Read.
This judge is a disgrace
With corrupt cops and many lying witnesses, this should not even be going back to court!
It won’t. I’m pretty sure they have their own problems now lol
I cannot believe this, again. What a circus.
You got that RIGHT !!!!
You’re defiantly right about that CIRCUS!!
Welcome to America 🤦♂️
Created by the CW and the shady police investigation
I believe the judge was biased fir the prosecution
Auntie Bev needs to be investigated
I’ll allow it🤪
What you see from the media IS THE INVESTIGATION,.... and you are a very important part of it.
Now she needs to be removed from the bench.
She’s your aunt?
The people who actually killed John know the judge well and call her Aunty Bev.
@@s.z.6200 ALL THOSE PEOPLE ARE LYING but the one who admitted it and had motive and means is not? They DO NOT call her that. That’s from your stupid cult crap.
What a complete scam of a trial if this proves to be true. UNBELIEVABLE. No wonder they took forever on these charges. They were confused af
Judge Bev went to talk to them, so she is AWARE. How corrupt of her not to bring the jury right back in and clarify the record.
This case should have never been brought forth to begin with.
Exactly
It should have been brought to court , only they have the wrong defendant, it should be Higgins and Brian Albert
And people got mad that Alan Jackson didn’t like the verdict form!
Point!
Exactly 100%
He said it was very confusing. The verdict form did not have (not guilty) the judge stated it was obvious if you believed she wasn’t guilty you left it blank. It seemed particularly confusing on the day.
@@mariaskinnider115and now it seems purposely confusing.
@@anonymoususer4866 it does !!!!
Wish the FBI swiftly talks with all the jurors bc Canton is fishy AF. I said shady from the judge down right from the get go
Why wasn’t each jurist polled for their verdict after the verdict was read ?
The judge stated that she was meeting with the jury privately immediately after she declared a mistrial. I don’t know if that happened
Auntie Bev wanted Karen guiltily. Shes such a disgrace to the bench! Allan Jackson told her her forms were confusing the jury! She should have looked at the forms then and after, and she never polled them on any of their counts! She needs to be disbbared!
💯
The Judge should have asked if they reached a verdict on any counts
Yes!
Yes, I just watched a case out of TN, where it was a hung jury, judge asked if they agreed on anything, they said yes, first two charges acquitted, third charge hung
like the judge did in the David Swift trial...
The judge tried to pull a fast one.And the jury put her out there for not doing her job.
💯💯💯
You’ll believe anything won’t you?
@billyb5847 I bet I’ve watched and rewatched WAY more than you and paid attention, she’s guilty. I’m still rewatching. Go put your head back up her behind. A killer either way a cult/fan club. If she were a man it would be so different.
👏🏼
The judge needs to be admonished and probably forced to retire or be fired. She changed the form to offer guilty for each charge OR innocent on ALL charges option, that was it…no innocent on each charge- this is 1000% the judges fault. Also, she is friends with the decedents family and bailed out John’s brother from jail when he got his DUI leaving someone in a wheelchair from a drunk driving accident last year. She should’ve recused herself- she made many more mistakes than this in the trial. This entire city is filled with half ass professionals or full blown criminal city workers. No one in this town did anything about all the corruption for decades…now that they’re being called out, and only now, they’re FINALLY standing up for change. What a mess.
Also, Chris Albert’s 1994 Hit And Run Homicide Shows He Hired Judge Beverly Cannone’s Expensive Attorney Brother, Police Never Questioned Him About Drunk Driving. Beverly Cannone’s Brother Was Chris Albert’s Attorney When He Killed a Man In a 1995 Crash, He Worked With Jill Daniels’ Father At Quincy Courthouse. Chris Albert fled the scene and then turned himself in. This family has done many wrongdoings with none or hardly any consequences.
Karen Reed bailed John's brother Paul O'Keefe out of jail, not the judge. Agree with all the corruption going on, I also want to add that it looks like the police, the state police, and possibly the DA's office hydrate with beer instead of water. Unfortunately, many dead brain cells from all that drinking are in the brains of people whose decision affects people's lives...like accusing an innocent woman of hitting a person with a 6000lbs car which was proven to be factually impossible.
The judge is friends with the actual murderers.
One correction. Karen bailed Paul Okeefe out of jail from his 24 mph dui car accident he caused in which an elderly man was paralyzed. He blames Karen, who never hit John with her car, yet he actually DID cause a serious accident while drunk. And you can google the photo from his accident which shows how much damage a 24 mph accident actually does. You can't make this stuff up.
@@jills9373 Thank you so much for the correction. Yes, I’m way too tired today to get all my criminal conspirators in order and remember all the details of this insane case 🙃 I was getting my felons confused- was thinking of the Chris Albert DUI where he murdered someone and fled the scene and Judge Bev’s brother represented him (RIP Peter Berger) Definitely can’t make this stuff up. It’s wild and sad. John didn’t deserve any of this and neither does Karen. Yikes 😳
This is the court's screw up. Unbelievable
@conradsieber7883 NOT A SCREW UP. EVERY BIT AS DELIBERATE & INTENTIONAL, WITH MALICE & AFORETHOUGHT, AS THE ENTIRE INVESTIGATION WAS.
NOT INCOMPETENCY, NOT BOTCHED;
THIS WAS CALCULATED & DONE PURPOSEFULLY.
@@evelynmahoney3569the Jury and Judge colluded with the prosecution and LE… ok😂
I don't believe the defense opted to not poll the jurors. I think Bev opted to rush them out of the courtroom quickly.
@@B_Bodziak Good Gawd, The defense DOES have that option in EVERY court in the land.
@@RebeccaSmith-gj5scdefinitely not the jury🤣🤣🤣🤣🤷🏼♀️ it was 12-0 on 2 charges allegedly
The Foreman in this Case was Chosen by Judge Bev...NOT elected by the Jury
Even worse
That s how it s done here in Mass..fireman was totally solid❤
And he is a retired corrupt cop!
WOW!!!
She picked him BEFORE picking the alternates, which tells me she knew who the alternates were going to be. This entire trial has been sus from the start
Poor jury instructions. This is 100% on the judge. A large part of her obligation is to ensure they understand instructions. I mean, didn’t she poll the jury??
Why wouldn’t the Judge asked if it was on all counts ?? That judge is just as bad as the police department.
That form was ridiculous!
Standard Mass form. Out of an abundance of caution the Judge gave the defense exactly what they asked for in a revised form yet now you say that wasn’t good enough??😂😂😂
Sounds like you need a whaaaaambulance.
It was and this is exactly why the defense protested.
But weirdly enough, you can google for a verdict slip template for mass and find that that form is actually a standard form.
There was no option to vote not guilty on some and not guilty on others, unless they voted guilty on at least one. The verdict from is so biased toward guilt.
@@jtjones4081 You're laughing because you know that the form was confusing. And apparently - it was.
@@jtjones4081 so you are happy that a form that awful exists? Just because it's been around for awhile doesn't mean it's good.
Judge needs to be disbarred
For following Mass. law? Yeah. Not going to happen.
@@Haarschmuckfachgeschafttadpole Ikr! Ppl just talk out of turn and speak crap. These Karen fans have NO CLUE about the law. The judge doesnt make the law, but interpret them.
@@Haarschmuckfachgeschafttadpole we’ll see on appeal. How many rulings stand. Standby. Jury form, NOT STANDARD IN Massachusetts, as stated yesterday 30 lawyers. Jury caused confusion with jury by there recent statements to defense attorneys.
This judge belongs in jail PERIOD.
She is not qualified to handle anything more complicated than traffic tickets. Obvious bias.
The judge said she was going to poll the jury in private....to which I commented "WHAT?"
Absolute power, corrupts absolutely.
Impeach this Judge!!
The instructions were completely confusing.
That's what the state intended. They know what they are doing. Anything to grease the verdict away from not guilty.
This is actual bullshit. No reason it shouldn’t have been asked in the first place. That judge is gross!
Was the defenses job to poll., not the judge.
@@Haarschmuckfachgeschafttadpolewrong. It is the judges responsibility to poll the jury. The defense can request it.
Exactly. Judge falsely made it seem the jurors couldn’t agree on anything which is a lie.
Not in every state. Each jurisdiction is different when it comes to pulling the jury. @@Haarschmuckfachgeschafttadpole
@@MADNESS084. She moved on it soooo fast and when she is reading the note from the Foreperson it said they were deadlocked on counts (plural)
The note from the Foreperson to Judge did not say clearly that they were only deadlocked on 1 of the 3 counts.
But is the Foreperson job to run a court …I don’t think so it is the Judges job I live in Massachusetts how much did this cost us?
This Judge is not above board.
I think Lally and the Judge should pay for this trial and not the taxpayers of Mass.
The foreperson’s grammar was impeccable…. And obviously knowledgeable about the law. Why couldn’t he have asked questions about the form?
How could the judge not have polled the jurors before declaring a mistrial? Is there something in the water in that city?
Some shady sh@t going down in Canton town!
For reals. I don’t even care that I believe she’s guilty; LE was so SO corrupt in the investigation. Let them ALL see her walk free and know their corruption caused the mess.
She needs to be investigated! Definitely a state I’d never care to visit !
Please stay away from any state you’re not already afflicting with your Dumbness.
@deneenstrickler6032 I agree nothing to write home about. I visited the state 2 times in my life Chicopee was interesting . The city for Boston was cool to see but the people just seemed pissed off
judge was sighing when the defence spoke she should never put the tail light in evidence they didnt collect it probly it was after wards wi hey just drive by see what u can find in the yard eh what wheres the report sighn in sheet as to who was there at the search wheres the photos ect wheres the photo of johns body as to where he was lying no where then u got the family wi the alberts blaming karen ignoring the science evidence lack of investigation.
I here ya, and I live here...for 60 yrs!. But my part of the state not only has corrupt state cops but idiot small town cops! (but you should visit, most of MA is beautiful, ocean on one side and mountains on the other and my grand kids in the middle!!
Judge should be investigated. She's a disgrace.
Who can we contact about this judge? She needs to be off the bench and investigated!!!!!!
If I was a juror that sat there that long I would want the truth to be told too!!!
Boston. This Bev Cannone judge is terrible. The law community is laughing at you. Do better. Throw this biased woman off the bench.
Embarrassing living here
@@RobynHurley-zp9sh dont be too hard on yourselves. this is how problems get corrected. It takes a bunch of people getting angry to get anything done.
I'm so glad I don't live in Massachusetts anymore
Shame on the Judge ......
The defense questioned the clarity of the verdict form! There was only 1 not guilty space for the 3 charges! This is all on the judge
The lawyers claims are so frivolous that they could be sanctioned. They claim that a NON juror contacted them with alleged screenshots from another NON juror. The only juror they claim contacted them was an alternate who never deliberated. The lawyers state plainly in their motion what they really want , access to the jurors. The judge should sanction this ridiculous attempt to violate the law
And Alan Jackson is now barred from representating Karen Read because of his misconduct caught on video while the jury was deliberating. His inappropriate contact with his client is an unwaivable conflict of interest
@@bethpatriots7290he is not 😂
@@bethpatriots7290your ATTORNEY can have a “conflict of interest” if the conflict involves another one of their clients, not for knowing the client, agreeing with the client, etc
@@bethpatriots7290well I can see you learned to lie at the mcalbert school of lying! What a ridiculous lie. Clearly you believe every single unhinged piece of propaganda put out there to attack Karen. How sad you don’t have an independent brain cell. Just sad.
The form was faulty , the defence team attempted to argue that n the Judge shut down that argument
Yes, but later came back and changed it. LOL
Judge conceded to defense request about the form? Really? I did not hear that.
@@jh-is8nq Yes, she came back later and amended it.
@@jh-is8nq Look up this video.'
"Karen Read trial judge agrees to adjust verdict slip."
The foreman was NOT elected by the jury, but appointed by the JUDGE!!!
This is how many jurisdictions do it.... juror 1 is the foreman by default.
@Haarschmuckfachgeschafttadpole it looked like she picked a foreman before choosing the alternates. It brought up the question what if the foreman was an alternate.
🎯💯
@@Haarschmuckfachgeschafttadpole yes but that is not what was said in this interview.
@suzannerodio1744 in Massachusetts the Judge appoints the foreperson of the jury. Always been like that here
This whole case should be thrown out. HoW EMBARRASSING from beginning to end. All of it!
Karen has major medical issues she doesn’t need this crap. She’s a victim too as well as Officer John O’Keefe! The person or people who are responsible for this are shaking in their boots cuz if it’s not Karen, then investigations will begin! Last thing they wanted.
This is, at best, mixed news for Read. I think that most people who think that Read did it, didn't think that she did it intentionally. The murder 2 charge was an overreach. But if the information is correct, the jury was split 8-4 to convict on the dui/manslaughter charge.
Stop feeling sorry for a bar fly shes not the victim. She did it u blind people make me sick. If it was your son or father or brother please just shut up
This case was tainted from day one... By the judge. This is more of a corruption trial than a murder trial. I agree with others, this judge would not accept a "not guilty" verdict.
Aunt Bev is having a nervous breakdown now.
She's not. 😂
What do you mean? I have not followed it since the end of trial. Had no idea there was new info released.
Jackson just filed the motion to dismiss this morning@@Dontknowwhatmynickshouldbe
@@melistasy "She's not. "
No, she's most definitely not - she drinks as much as the 15 witnesses who couldn't even manage to bury a 220 pound cop in 3 inches of snow with him already expired.
@@danielbernier9115 o wow! Then definitely she must be having a breakdown now🤣
One of the most "educated" parts of the country and none of the players, prosecution, defense, or jury can figure out the verdict form.
Leads one to believe corruption is involved. And Auntie Bev is part of it. What a mess! The results of the federal investigation should be very interesting. I'm guessing charges will be filed.
Poor Karen, mowed down and killed JO'Keefe, now messing with jackson , Are you living in different universe......?
@@TheLydia1011 My comment was about the freaking verdict form not the verdict you moron.
@@TheLydia1011 pot kettle black? 😂😂😂😂😂
@@TheLydia1011 thelydia or crazyLydia. Lol
This is so representative of the judge not giving clear instructions, because she wanted a guilty verdict. She needs to be disbarred immediately. Her conduct was an absolute disgrace to this country.
The truth hurts: When J.O. drinks with K.R, he makes her drive. When he's not with K.R. and he's drunk, he drives.
His brother (Paul) paralyzed a guy when he was drunk driving.
J.O's ex girfriend Marybeth took a motorcyclists leg when she was drunk driving. You'd think he'd learn that drunk driving is hurting people.
Nope, didn't care.
J.O. parties and bar hops like hes a irresponsible kid, not a 46yr old man.
And hes a cop. A cop who breaks the law.
J.O.'s friends are crooked cops.
Birds of a feather...
You think crooked cops wanna hang out with a straight laced good cop ?
Yeah, right.
All these people are loosahs.
This was never about justice for J.O.
Its about justice for K.R.
Top Comment award
If this is true , its a failure on the courts part.
Correct !
If true ? If what’s true ???
@@stevenprice6957 Can you decipher words ?
more corruption
the lead investigator is suspended without pay, perhaps the judge should also be suspended without pay
When I was on a jury with multiple counts the judge specifically told us if we can ALL agree on at least one count, that we need to provide that verdict, even if we couldn’t agree on ALL counts.
The judge did not do that here . She basically told them it had to be all or nothing
Sounds like Aunt Bev didn't do her job as a judge.
What didn't she do exactly? There is no law requiring her to poll the jury.
@@melistasy Let's say it a different way.....What is her job? To seek Justice?
Who saw this coming ..l I hope she faces repercussions
@@melistasyunclear jury instructions
@@melistasy "What didn't she do exactly? There is no law requiring her to poll the jury."
Now you're just looking desperate. Enough already - we get it - you get prickly when someone takes a crap down the throat of the judge.
Let the investigation into Aunt Bev begin. 😂😂🎉🎉
The defense brought up the issue with the lesser charges. Why did Bev insist on making things complicated for the jury?
she’s guilty of vehicular homicide by intoxicated use of a vehicle !! disgusting how ppl are supporting someone who’s obviously guilty of this
Physics gravity and the principals of force says otherwise. If a 7k lb car hit John’s forearm going 24mph his arm would break. He was allegedly hit so hard it blew him out of his shoes. He was hit so hard he shattered a tail light but didn’t have any injuries below the neck? He wasn’t made of titanium sweetie. The Karen is guilty crowd all seem to be science deniers. Those Marks on Johns arms came from a dog. That’s why the Alberts quickly rehomed their family pet. This case never should have come to trial.
@@karinaz8756Don’t forget it hit him so hard it made him slam into the ground and hit his head then bounce him, with glass in hand, pirouetting 30’ into the yard. The force of which sent pieces of tail light into their own time travel over a period of days and weeks days. Truely a feat of magical “science” the likes of which troopah Paul could not determine the velocity, distance, gravity, molecular adhesion, atmospheric pressure and temperature and even time itself and literally any other qualifying factor. Oh yes, it was obviously totes true 😂. He sure showed those aarca guys 😂😂😂
Judge Bev gave very misleading jury instructions. She needs to be held accountable for judicial impropriety.
She did exactly what the defense wanted. And they were happy. Until the mistrial.
She's right. The verdict form did not accomodate a separate "not guilty" verdict on each charge.
Court TV, the jury DID NOT elect the foreperson.., the judge DID. 🤔
To begin with the verdict form is not only complicated but also confusing. The judge is incompetent.
They brought jurors back in Murdaugh trial
Not guilty
SO ALL HIS FRIENDS KILLED JOHN, WHY???? CANYOU ANSWER THAT? THE DEFENSE CAN"T!!
@@pennicochrane8886doesn't make a bit of difference. There's no evidence that he was hit by a motor vehicle. Not guilty on all counts.
Well@@pennicochrane8886they're obviously not his friends, and it's also obvious that it was just one or two that were involved in the actual murder, but they all took part in convering it up!
@@pennicochrane8886are you a science denier? Do the laws of physics not apply in Massachusetts?
@@ThisCharminManc Have you ever heard of the Dunning Kruger effect?
This is, at best, mixed news for Read. I think that most people who think that Read did it, didn't think that she did it intentionally. The murder 2 charge was an overreach. But if the information is correct, the jury was split 8-4 to convict on the dui/manslaughter charge.
Are these 8 people science deniers? Are they in on the conspiracy as well?
The Karen Read cultists have a screw loose.
How could there even be a hung jury if the re-enactment expert said he was NOT run over by a car!?! For heaven's sake, this case is going nowhere. Dismiss the case and disbar the judge for not polling the jury. That seems just plain unethical. And yet - why didn't the defense demand this?
Anything the defense requested was shot down anyway. They tried to resolve this ahead of time by questioning the verdict slip the jury was required to fill out
Don’t believe this for one second. The jurors were asked to go back 3 times? And they couldn’t ask the judge why they were being asked to go back when they have reached a verdict? Some jurors are just good at causing confusion!
The judge picked the foreman.
NOT GUILTY!!
Guilty. She’s a killer.
@@stevenprice6957how did you come up with that conclusion?
@@OGMatty420 very simple. I followed the evidence lined up all data and looked at every one of Karen ls actions before and after. I’m an old man. I’ve had my share of crazy women in my life. 2 restraining orders long ago. I know the type but they all don’t lead to killers. Many women kill though. She snaps like a biscuit. Narcissistic sociopath.
The evidence is huge. I was a dog breeder of hunting dogs. Pig hunting dogs. They are definitely not even close to dog bites or dog scratches. DNA would be over loaded. Dogs mouths soak. He didn’t go in no house. The days doesn’t lie. GPS has him on the lawn straight after her reversal at speed. His DNA is inside the housing of a tail light. It’s a brand new car. The tail light was sealed before it broke as we saw in footage 2 days earlier. Not a mark on the car.
So he didn’t work at Lexus did he. Microscopic pieces are mixed in with blood and vomit in his clothes. The reconstruction guys although highly rated looked at 1/3 of all evidence. It’s not near enough for w full evaluation. But let’s go back to the night in question. She texted him and calls him all day. You are setting me up to fail John. She also is cheating. She blames others as it’s never herself. It’s all John’s fault. He doesn’t want to fight argue whatever. Males or most Steve into that. I know I’m not.
So the data lines right up but at 12:31 when he never moves again, Karen is scooting to his place. 12:37. I f--g hate you John. Keys go forward 2 days after the crime for a sec, yanetti , it was an accident. She didn’t think she hit him that hard. My client loves that man your honour. People like her don’t love. As she said, they were dating. But they still want to possess. So let’s go back. 12:37. Pure hate. That was her 5th call to John after 12:31. She rang and rang. Victim blaming is Karen with the 12:37 i effin hate you. . She failed and it’s his fault. 12:42 you can hear her psychopath footsteps. 12:46 where are you ? Nobody knows where you are ? Karen you just dropped him off 14 mins ago? There’s a blizzard ? Where else would he go. ? Nobody knows where you are ? More like please pick up
That phone because my nightmare is a growing. Rings daddy all night as every 40 year old does. Calls 53 times. Panicking. 4;40 speaks to her father. 4;45 wakes Kaylee and says something really bad has happened then storms off ranting. Comes back I think John could have been hit by a plough. Calls Jen McCabe with Kaylee’s phone. Mentioned her tail light busted and this is another key. So she knows it’s busted. Ksykee bscks up Jen McCabes story. Says she had a big fight with John and she left him at the water fall. Then calls many people. Has a different story for each person. Kaylee said she’s never seen Karen like this before. Rings Jen McCabe again. This time she says broken tailight and left him at the water fall but Jen’s husband says what is she talking about? They were out front of your sisters ? Jen remembers and says Karen we saw you at my sisters place out front ? What are you talking about? Karen replies I can’t remember I was too drink I don’t remember going there. Umm ok Karen. Gets in her car and as we know the tail light busted as been mentioned twice by Karen. She pulls out then love taps johns car bumper to bumper if anyone knows cars. And then takes off. Right there. I’ve zoomed in. And it’s a gaping hole. Clear as day. So the conspiracy is shot. It’s a fairly story. The whole works. Calls Kerry at 5am that’s before she’s headed out. He’s dead Kerry. Click. Calls 5;01. Kerry it’s a plough that got him. Or might have done it ? lol. I could go on with har X-ray vision eyes seeing a body in that darkness under snow in a car in a blizzard. I’ve actually hardly ever seen a person as guilty. It’s very logical. She’s a Nutter. She’s a killer. What’s worse is she’s blamed people that were only trying to help her that night. Imagine helping someone or thinking you are and having your world and your family’s world thrown upside down. All because a woman didn’t take responsibility and thought and planned cunningly before grabbing witnesses and acting confused etc. Then days later. We are all in on the same joke right? That’s when actor story teller Jackson came on board. For 300 grand he will say and do anything. All in on the joke right? What joke Karen ? The Alberts killed John. The bashed him then pulverised my tail light haha. Ok where ? At the scene after your reverse ? Did they hold you down ? Or did they break into johns garage at 3am and take a bag to carry tail light pieces in. Lol.
It’s baffling that many believe inn her innocence. Humans are strange. Blaming innocent people is not on. No searches were done at 2:27 of how long to die. We all know that. Even a silly turtle would. It was done when Karen demanded it. 10 mins later she’s in an ambulance saying she’s gunna jill herself. Or daddy did. They saved her from early questioning. Then she says I’m fine and walks out of hospital a few hours later. Guilty. 100%. It ain’t even close.
@@OGMatty420he can’t tell you, he just reiterates the same arguments the prosecution got absolutely crushed with on cross and expert testimony. The same arguments that believe the mcalberts are all innocent 😂 and the same arguments that think canton LE isn’t as corrupt AF 😂. In other words he’s a flat earther and as bright as a broken bulb.
What a toxic case about a toxic defendant.
our entire justice system is crooked. you don't think this is the only crooked court in America do you? of course not.
Old Canone will try to stop them. She's crooked as hell.
And all the evidence? Too many crooked cops. Take off your blinkers.
Overruled.
Type this comment the right way, Counselor.
Where is aunt bev to say sustained
I’ll allow it
@@missylynns8966😂😂 She better allow a hearing!
I'm sick of the whole thing!!😮😮
AMEN !!!
Me too
I think if I was a judge I would not want this case.
The most corrupt trial ever!!! 😡
As Clint Eastwood would say *what a clusterf*ck!*
The judge wouldn’t let them have a not guilty box on each charge.
So now this news person is blaming jury for what? The judge has control of her court room and verdict forms. No she was tooooo tired to do it straight. At least the jury is coming forward and trying to fix it correctly.
This case is the most corrupt case ever