A fantastic initiative Dr Taimur and Ammar. We need progressive discourse in the country. Although, personally I do not agree with the thought process of the “left” yet this is the happiest thing I have seen on the internet today. I extend my complete and unconditional support for this platform. Above everything else, two learned, progressive and intelligent people discussing issues is something Pakistani society needs badly. My best wishes your way.
Same discourse by the informed duo as such would be termed simply as rational, progressive, logical in the West. In our Third World it appears on the "Left"!
Shahrukh sir god bless you. I would be an agnostic if you didn't make the reconstruction series of islam. Salute to you sir and another thing that i have learned from you is "optimism". You are a blessing in disguise for me thank you sir once again.
"The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point is to change it. One of the most difficult tasks confronting philosophers is to descend from the world of thought to the actual world. Karl Marx.
Dr. Taimur Rahman sb and Dr. Ammar Ali Jan sb, this is going to be a great opportunity for us to learn. We are very grateful. We expect it to be continued with new and new topics . Enlighten the public.
پاکستان اور ہندوستان ہی کیا بلکہ یہ سارا خطہ استعماری قوتوں کا ستایا ہوا ہے اور اج بھی ان کے ہاتھوں کا کھلونا ہے سو ہم سب کو ہی اس طرح کی گفتگو کو سننا ہے اور اس سے سیکھنا ہے
@latestnews6967 yahi aap wali soch badlengay tau duniya badly gee. Insaan ki qadar karna seekhay. Jub allah mian yahoodi musalman sub pay bila tafreeq apni rehmatay Barsata hay tau aap kiyu insano mein tafreeq kartay hay? Allah aap ko hidayat de aur Tamam insano fitnay say nijaat de
hi, watched the Entire episode from India I am also a leftist I can suggest a few topics for next episodes 1. How neoliberalism fuels neo fascism, I learned this from Marxist Prabhat Patnaik lecture 2. techno feudalism A book by Greek Communist and former finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis on How tech giants like Whatsapp, facebook & X use data as a currency and profit from it 3. Where do you see BRICS going in the next decade and what it might mean for the Global South 4. On how to better India & Pakistan relations and if u feel USA would be against it or not 5. How do u think India should balance its relation between USA and China, now that China is our biggest trading partner surpassing USA 6. Situation in Balochistan, Kashmir 7. About upcoming US elections & who could be worse for global south Harris or Trump 8. How to make general people more aware of realities around because consumer culture spreading like wildfire in India, most don't even want to talk about the realities of the world which makes me very concerned 9. About what Macron is doing in France despite the Left winning the elections
Were you at JNU ever? I'm a non-communist but open to learning from all sources and was on campus during 1986-1992. Periyar, Sutlej very briefly and eventually Brahmaputra.
ڈاکٹر تیمور کے بارے میں سب سے اچھی بات، آپ انگریزی بہت کم استعمال کرتے ہیں اور یہی وجہ ہے کہ آپ کو سن کر ہمیشہ خوشی ہوتی ہے اور آپ کو سمجھنے میں آسانی ہوتی ہے۔
I highly appreciate such an incredible initiative. Because, awareness is the first and foremost thing for the establishing and beginning of any movement. ❤❤❤
Incredible podcast. Keep it up. The point of placing Pakistan in the context of global politics and trends is what i like the most about this podcast. As discussed in this podcast, we often try to understand our national issues without bringing into considerations the global dynamics, which lead us to a sort of skewed understanding of our national issues. They must be seen in light of the global political dynamics in order to make somewhat intelligible sense of it, and, at the same time, chart out ways in keeping the same dynamics in observation.
I fully endorsed and agreed on the views and thoughts of Dr Ammar and also appreciate on the bold step of Dr Taimour for starting of such debate in pakistan where it is even difficult to talk and live fearless. I hope the people of Pakistan especially young generation now think that the way they are ruled by military generals with the help of corrupt politicians should now be ended for ever for which every one has to be stand up.
You have discussed very important topic of economic and cultural colonialism. How west has exploited resources from different regions and portray their success as utopia for the people of south. Pakistan is not yet independent as U.S economically support generals and bureaucrats. It’s a great initiative to talk specifically on these issue and pervade awareness among people who doesn’t have analytical skills.
Amazing, i had been feeling the need for this for quite some time, in fact from the point when i got to know the left politics in general and politics of the left in Paksitan, there is so much thirst and space for the discourse that the left indulges in, that i hope this Podcast, the Red Room, will tilt the discourse from short term to long term and from extreme right to center atleast or left by good chance. Thank you so much for putting every bit of effort that you dr Taimoor Rehman put in your teaching and general videos and Dr Ammar Jan for starting an urban leftist party. Thank you all for listemning as well
Truely blessed to having you sir really u are the epitome of knowledge.one thing I want to mention here sir the thing is most of the students are not aware fully aware from the basics of the political philosophy so I vehmently Suggest you plz avoid the jargon and make ur conversation easy that every students comprehend the ideas that u people are delivering.
❤آپ نے بہت ضروری بحثیں شروع کی ہیں۔ جاری اور باقاعدہ ٹیم ہو جو ان کو سوشل میڈیا پر عام کرے۔ دائیں اور بائیں دونوں کو بلائیں۔ اور اپ نے مذہب کے قریب نہ جائیں۔
اللہ تعالٰی آپ لوگوں کو اپنی حفظ وامان میں رکھے! ماشاءاللہ آپ کے اس علمی تجزئے سے کافی لوگ مستفید ہوئے ہونگے! کاش یہ تمام باتیں کسی طرح قاسم کے ابا تک بھی پہنچا دی جائیں، تاکہ وہ اپنی سمت درست کریں۔ چونکہ جب تک طاقت کے استعمال شٹر بے مہار کو لگام نہ ڈالی گئی تو بخدا کسی عمل کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں ہونے والا!! چاہیے پدر قاسم دس بار منتخب ہو کر آ جائیں 🤔
Zabardast sir ❤ Please carry on these discussions Pakistan badly needs such revolutionary discussions.. We are curious to know. In fact, such discussions should prevail in Pakistan.
Dr. Taimur n Ammar together has provided an intellectual feast, repercussions of global historical facts and objective analysis! ✨✨✨ U r such a kind listener..dr Taimur! Thanks 4 introducing Ammar. This duo hs demonstrated tht how mentally liberated thinkers see n analyze post colonial (Neo Colonial )world. Looking forward to learning from next podcasts of the red room.
This is an excellent discussion Dr. Taimur and Dr. Ammar. We hear too little from the left in our limited political space, so this was much needed. Perhaps some aspects can be kept simpler and related directly to Pakistan so people remain engaged and see it as useful but it is super overall and your discussion with Junaid Akram was also quite educational for new recruits to the left.
دونوں کامریڈز نوں ڈھیر مبارکاں ۔ بوہت ای ودھیا پروگرام اے، سواد آ گیا۔ لیفٹ دے ساتھیاں دا سوشل میڈیا اتے کونٹینٹ لبن تے وی نئیں لبدا، تہانوں دوناں نوں ویکھ بہت خوشی ہوئی۔ پلیز کم کھچ کے رکھو۔ اگلے پروگرام دا انتظار رہے گا
میں اپنے معاشرے میں ہر سو پھیلے انتشار کو دیکھ کر جب اس کی بنیادی وجہ کو سمجھنے کی کوشش کرتا تو مجھے کوئی تسلی بخش جواب نہیں ملتا. لیکن آپ کی اس گفتگو کے آخر میں آپ نے جو مغربی دنیا کی اجاراداری کا ذكر کیا وہ کافی معقول بات معلوم ہوتی ہے ۔ آپ سے گزارش ہے کہ اپنی آئنده نشست میں اس کے حل پر بھی روشنی ڈالیے ۔ شكریہ ۔
آپ دونوں کی بہت اچھی کاوش ہے ۔پاکستان میں شدید ضرورت تھی لیفٹ کی سوچ کو اجاگر کرنے کے لیے کوئی چینل موجود ہو۔کیونکہ یہاں مسلط کردہ سطحی سیاسی بحثوں کے سوا کچھ نہیں ملتا ۔
Thank you so much Dr. Taimur Rehman and Dr. Ammar. Being a junior student of Politics, it was treat to watch this episode in particular... I would like you to have a discussion some day about the real history of Communist movements in general and taht of USSR in particular. Because, I feel that we are presented Western narrative here. The writers and authors of Eastern Europe and those who served in USSR are somewhat missing or I did not come across them so far... Lastly, More power to your team!!!
Very Good step...one day I want to be on this podcast in order to talk about the education crisis for lower classes Education for mazdoor kissan's kids.. Laal salam
Excellent, meaningful effort to disseminate knowledge awareness and understanding of a very complex problem, and subsequently will lead towards solution. 1. My advice would be to keep the episodes shorter as the average length of concentration span wears off after 20 min. Also a lot of people may not even start listening once they see the time of 1.21:46 2. You must not make the same mistake of being dogmatic about the “other side” opinion, and after a while you need to open up the debate by including other people for a diversification of options and solutions.
It will be very helpful for students if you would recommend some books about the topic u are discussing.so that the students can study and would increase there knowledge about the discussed topic....
A fantastic initiative Dr Taimur and Ammar. We need progressive discourse in the country. Although, personally I do not agree with the thought process of the “left” yet this is the happiest thing I have seen on the internet today. I extend my complete and unconditional support for this platform. Above everything else, two learned, progressive and intelligent people discussing issues is something Pakistani society needs badly. My best wishes your way.
Same discourse by the informed duo as such would be termed simply as rational, progressive, logical in the West. In our Third World it appears on the "Left"!
Shahrukh sir god bless you. I would be an agnostic if you didn't make the reconstruction series of islam. Salute to you sir and another thing that i have learned from you is "optimism". You are a blessing in disguise for me thank you sir once again.
@@Engr.OsamaMahmoodkitne ghatya insan ho tum 😂😂
Bs kr agree na kr ja k summary prh k video bna your fragile opinion doesn’t matter
"The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways;
the point is to change it.
One of the most difficult tasks confronting philosophers is
to descend from the world of thought
to the actual world.
Karl Marx.
Ufff. What an initiative. I dont know if red room makes impact or not but the idea of having Dr Taimoor and Dr Amar together is a treat for me❤
Exactlyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
Dr. Taimur Rahman sb and Dr. Ammar Ali Jan sb, this is going to be a great opportunity for us to learn. We are very grateful. We expect it to be continued with new and new topics . Enlighten the public.
सर आपने जो काम शुरू किया है उसकी हिंदोस्तान में बहुत जरूरत है अब हम भी आपकी बात जीत से फैजयाब हो सकेंगे ।आपको इसके लिए बहुत बहुत मुबारकबाद ।
پاکستان اور ہندوستان ہی کیا بلکہ یہ سارا خطہ استعماری قوتوں کا ستایا ہوا ہے اور اج بھی ان کے ہاتھوں کا کھلونا ہے سو ہم سب کو ہی اس طرح کی گفتگو کو سننا ہے اور اس سے سیکھنا ہے
@@Seemasungpahle aap muslman bne
@latestnews6967 yahi aap wali soch badlengay tau duniya badly gee. Insaan ki qadar karna seekhay. Jub allah mian yahoodi musalman sub pay bila tafreeq apni rehmatay Barsata hay tau aap kiyu insano mein tafreeq kartay hay? Allah aap ko hidayat de aur Tamam insano fitnay say nijaat de
hi, watched the Entire episode from India I am also a leftist I can suggest a few topics for next episodes
1. How neoliberalism fuels neo fascism, I learned this from Marxist Prabhat Patnaik lecture
2. techno feudalism A book by Greek Communist and former finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis on How tech giants like Whatsapp, facebook & X use data as a currency and profit from it
3. Where do you see BRICS going in the next decade and what it might mean for the Global South
4. On how to better India & Pakistan relations and if u feel USA would be against it or not
5. How do u think India should balance its relation between USA and China, now that China is our biggest trading partner surpassing USA
6. Situation in Balochistan, Kashmir
7. About upcoming US elections & who could be worse for global south Harris or Trump
8. How to make general people more aware of realities around because consumer culture spreading like wildfire in India, most don't even want to talk about the realities of the world which makes me very concerned
9. About what Macron is doing in France despite the Left winning the elections
Well very Specific Questions, they must Debate on it, fully Supporting it.
Were you at JNU ever? I'm a non-communist but open to learning from all sources and was on campus during 1986-1992. Periyar, Sutlej very briefly and eventually Brahmaputra.
شکر ھے آپ دونوں نے صراط مستقیم پر چلتے ہوئے اس پروگرام کو شروع کیا ھے ۔
سر میں نے پوری ویڈیو دیکھی ہے جس طرح آپ نے نیو کلونیل اور پوسٹ کلونیل آرڈر ورلڈ پراسپیکٹو ۔۔۔ روول بائے فیئیرکیا آسانی سے سمجھایا ہے بہت خوب ❤❤❤❤
ڈاکٹر تیمور کے بارے میں سب سے اچھی بات، آپ انگریزی بہت کم استعمال کرتے ہیں اور یہی وجہ ہے کہ آپ کو سن کر ہمیشہ خوشی ہوتی ہے اور آپ کو سمجھنے میں آسانی ہوتی ہے۔
I highly appreciate such an incredible initiative. Because, awareness is the first and foremost thing for the establishing and beginning of any movement. ❤❤❤
ایک شان دار پروگرام جوکئی لحاظ سے ذہن کھولنے میں مدد دیتا ہے۔ آپ دونوں نے گراں قدر گفتگو کی ہے۔
Fantastic conversation between both of you… I also recommend Dr. Noaman G. Ali on this room
Incredible podcast. Keep it up. The point of placing Pakistan in the context of global politics and trends is what i like the most about this podcast. As discussed in this podcast, we often try to understand our national issues without bringing into considerations the global dynamics, which lead us to a sort of skewed understanding of our national issues. They must be seen in light of the global political dynamics in order to make somewhat intelligible sense of it, and, at the same time, chart out ways in keeping the same dynamics in observation.
Only heard stories about Ammar bin Yasir. Now listening to the living Ammar-he's truly justifying his name.
A very welcome web-based initiative. Thank you for doing this. All the best, comrades.
Surkh Salam for both of you Comrades ❤...
I fully endorsed and agreed on the views and thoughts of Dr Ammar and also appreciate on the bold step of Dr Taimour for starting of such debate in pakistan where it is even difficult to talk and live fearless. I hope the people of Pakistan especially young generation now think that the way they are ruled by military generals with the help of corrupt politicians should now be ended for ever for which every one has to be stand up.
A much needed initiative! Looking forward to the program! ❤
This is the podcast we want
You have discussed very important topic of economic and cultural colonialism. How west has exploited resources from different regions and portray their success as utopia for the people of south. Pakistan is not yet independent as U.S economically support generals and bureaucrats. It’s a great initiative to talk specifically on these issue and pervade awareness among people who doesn’t have analytical skills.
thanks for a very informative discussion sir.
Amazing, i had been feeling the need for this for quite some time, in fact from the point when i got to know the left politics in general and politics of the left in Paksitan, there is so much thirst and space for the discourse that the left indulges in, that i hope this Podcast, the Red Room, will tilt the discourse from short term to long term and from extreme right to center atleast or left by good chance. Thank you so much for putting every bit of effort that you dr Taimoor Rehman put in your teaching and general videos and Dr Ammar Jan for starting an urban leftist party. Thank you all for listemning as well
Truely blessed to having you sir really u are the epitome of knowledge.one thing I want to mention here sir the thing is most of the students are not aware fully aware from the basics of the political philosophy so I vehmently Suggest you plz avoid the jargon and make ur conversation easy that every students comprehend the ideas that u people are delivering.
Amazing discussion! Thank you Taimur bhai and Ammar bhai. God bless you both
❤آپ نے بہت ضروری بحثیں شروع کی ہیں۔ جاری اور باقاعدہ ٹیم ہو جو ان کو سوشل میڈیا پر عام کرے۔
دائیں اور بائیں دونوں کو بلائیں۔ اور اپ نے مذہب کے قریب نہ جائیں۔
اللہ تعالٰی آپ لوگوں کو اپنی حفظ وامان میں رکھے! ماشاءاللہ آپ کے اس علمی تجزئے سے کافی لوگ مستفید ہوئے ہونگے! کاش یہ تمام باتیں کسی طرح قاسم کے ابا تک بھی پہنچا دی جائیں، تاکہ وہ اپنی سمت درست کریں۔ چونکہ جب تک طاقت کے استعمال شٹر بے مہار کو لگام نہ ڈالی گئی تو بخدا کسی عمل کا کوئی فائدہ نہیں ہونے والا!! چاہیے پدر قاسم دس بار منتخب ہو کر آ جائیں 🤔
Zabardast sir ❤
Please carry on these discussions
Pakistan badly needs such revolutionary discussions..
We are curious to know.
In fact, such discussions should prevail in Pakistan.
Such talks should be very frequent. It is very enlightening.
You both continue to gather and make a series of actual issues.
Dr. Taimur n Ammar together has provided an intellectual feast, repercussions of global historical facts and objective analysis! ✨✨✨
U r such a kind listener..dr Taimur!
Thanks 4 introducing Ammar.
This duo hs demonstrated tht how mentally liberated thinkers see n analyze post colonial (Neo Colonial )world.
Looking forward to learning from next podcasts of the red room.
Excellent... Excellent... Excellent.
Congratulations Sir.. 🎉🎉🎉❤
Very well articulated, thoughtful and timely initiative
Thank you so much!
More like this!✊✊
More power to Dr. Ammar Ali Jan✌
More power to Prof. Taimur Rehman✌
This is an excellent discussion Dr. Taimur and Dr. Ammar. We hear too little from the left in our limited political space, so this was much needed. Perhaps some aspects can be kept simpler and related directly to Pakistan so people remain engaged and see it as useful but it is super overall and your discussion with Junaid Akram was also quite educational for new recruits to the left.
What a wonderful and realistic analysis ❤️🌹❤️
This is going to be an amazing journey, best of luck Dr sahiban ❤
Best conversation
Fantastic 👍Dr. Taimor and Ammar. This is real service of humanity.
دونوں کامریڈز نوں ڈھیر مبارکاں ۔ بوہت ای ودھیا پروگرام اے، سواد آ گیا۔ لیفٹ دے ساتھیاں دا سوشل میڈیا اتے کونٹینٹ لبن تے وی نئیں لبدا، تہانوں دوناں نوں ویکھ بہت خوشی ہوئی۔ پلیز کم کھچ کے رکھو۔ اگلے پروگرام دا انتظار رہے گا
Wow Sir Amazing debate. I literally do not have words to appreciate this debate. Keep it up
Dr ammar great positive personality pakistan needs such enthusiastic person
میں اپنے معاشرے میں ہر سو پھیلے انتشار کو دیکھ کر جب اس کی بنیادی وجہ کو سمجھنے کی کوشش کرتا تو مجھے کوئی تسلی بخش جواب نہیں ملتا. لیکن آپ کی اس گفتگو کے آخر میں آپ نے جو مغربی دنیا کی اجاراداری کا ذكر کیا وہ کافی معقول بات معلوم ہوتی ہے ۔
آپ سے گزارش ہے کہ اپنی آئنده نشست میں اس کے حل پر بھی روشنی ڈالیے ۔ شكریہ ۔
Good to see you coming together. It's time left create a narrative at national level
Left is garbage
YOUR CONTRIBUTION IS HIGHLY APPRECIATED
Very informative discussion ha. We really appriciat it.
Great discussion of great minds
Very glad to hear you sir ❤
Both comrades 🌹🥀
So excited for this.
Well done
آپ دونوں کی بہت اچھی کاوش ہے ۔پاکستان میں شدید ضرورت تھی لیفٹ کی سوچ کو اجاگر کرنے کے لیے کوئی چینل موجود ہو۔کیونکہ یہاں مسلط کردہ سطحی سیاسی بحثوں کے سوا کچھ نہیں ملتا ۔
I am watching Dr. Ammar Ali Jan first time with you and I am so amazed.
Great and meaningful discussion.Goal achievement way.
Thoroughly entertaining and educational. Looking forward to the next episode!
Thank you so much Dr. Taimur Rehman and Dr. Ammar. Being a junior student of Politics, it was treat to watch this episode in particular... I would like you to have a discussion some day about the real history of Communist movements in general and taht of USSR in particular. Because, I feel that we are presented Western narrative here. The writers and authors of Eastern Europe and those who served in USSR are somewhat missing or I did not come across them so far...
Lastly, More power to your team!!!
What a knowledgeable discussion,
After consuming the matrix of the right dominant narrative my algorithm is finally getting a sigh of relief .. Amazing initiative!
A great initiative by Dr Taimur & Dr Ammar. I hope we'll get more insights regarding global left & left in Pakistan through the The Red Room.
What an initiative !!! So much love and support ❤❤ for you two; laal & curly
wah g, what an initiative,
Very Good step...one day I want to be on this podcast in order to talk about the education crisis for lower classes
Education for mazdoor kissan's kids..
Laal salam
Thanks for such an interactive enlightening session.
Waiting for next episode.
Wonderfull initiative.Really enlightening and thoughtful.
thank you lal. fntastic initiative
Love from India ❤ .you both are doing fantastic work. Conversation was very interesting and informative 🎉
I love it. Cannot wait for more episodes. This truly a great initiative to educate masses.
Thank you Professor a fantastic initiative.
2 legends in one frame 💯
My favorite political teachers.
Thank you , sir.Please continue to educate.I feel enlightened
Great intellectuals both of you
Outstanding and worthy
Great sir please continue it
Dr. Taimur Rahman sb and Dr. Ammar Ali Jan
really fantastic initiative, great job learn a lot of new idias appreciated
Excellent, meaningful effort to disseminate knowledge awareness and understanding of a very complex problem, and subsequently will lead towards solution.
1. My advice would be to keep the episodes shorter as the average length of concentration span wears off after 20 min. Also a lot of people may not even start listening once they see the time of 1.21:46
2. You must not make the same mistake of being dogmatic about the “other side” opinion, and after a while you need to open up the debate by including other people for a diversification of options and solutions.
Great initiative sir. Much needed discussion
Dr amaar di gal baat ty faiz ahmed faiz di gazal ik brabar❤❤ kia baat hy. toba toba toba .kaanon main say dhuaan nikal gea mairy to
Pure education ❤❤
Great. Well done.
Nice discussion
Great initiative ❤
Please invite more comrades across the country
Best wishes
Your every video deserves a like ❤❤❤
Great initiative!!
Gurus aa hi gaye!!! Kudos.
This is going to be an amazing journey ❤😊
Now we got real shit!!! This is what we needed…. Keep philosophising and dropping new episodes; laal & curly
Thank u so much, this is much needed
Fully informative discussion
Well wishes for both intellectuals❤
Well insightful debate
Breath of fresh air 🎉
Thanks for the podcast and especially mentioning, the Hero of the subcontinent Bhagat Singh! 🎉❤
Love love and love itttttttt . Plz dont stop keep doing sir g
It will be very helpful for students if you would recommend some books about the topic u are discussing.so that the students can study and would increase there knowledge about the discussed topic....
Nice analysis by both Ammar Ali Jan and the Red room ✌️❤️
Keep up the good work.
Love and respect from
SaudI Arabia
Very well initiated indeed. Students need these shows for sure
Awesome initiative by both professors. Looking forward to more of such discussions.
Zabardast, bht informative video Dr Taimur and Ammar.
Congratulations sir on your first ever podcast
This podcast is engaging. Congratulations for upgradation
Excellent Conversation.