Tired feminist tropes | Rosaline
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- I've been wanting to watch Rosaline ever since I saw the trailer, it intrigued me with the whole modern manners in a 16 century scenery, but it also had me very doubtful that they could actually pull it off. Because in order for this concept to work it has to be exceptionally well done or it could turn out terrible. Well Rosaline is finally out and here's my review of it.
Let me know your thoughts down in the comments
Copyright Disclaimer
Under Section 107 of the copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
I actually loved that ending for Romeo and Juliet, and thought it was really clever, as even when they lived, they were still always meant to be a tragedy 💔 😂
lol yeah,,,tragedy 😂 I am happy I found someone with same opinion as mine
the ending reminded me of The Graduate ending
Her actions have NOTHING to do with Feminism. If you are a Feminist, then you treat everyone fairly: You want everyone treated the same, legally, and treated fairly culturally. If you are anti-male, or anti- any race, religion, or cultural group, then you are not a Feminist. Rosaline's character is portrayed a certain way, and that is what makes the WHOLE movie. She acts more like a superhero, and less like a typical female. If her character was male, you wouldn't have any complaints, I don't believe.
Talk to This creator who has The weirdest takes
You make some really good points, I think is sad how in media some aspects of Feminity, motherhood or cool things as dresses are portrayed as something bad, when in reality is not as simple as that. And in a movie setting it just becomes more of the same speech :'v
God gave us Free Will. Women, as well as men, have a God-given right to choose what they want. If you try and take someone's Free Will away, then you are doing the opposite of what God wants...God created Our Universe with Love and Free Will. Use your Free Will to Love!
If you don't like it, just don't watch it. Just watch the Zeffirelli movie. This film isn't even about feminism, it just depicts a modern woman trying to find her place. And tada in the end she finds true love in the very masculine Dario, a quite conservative message if you ask me.
As a guy, I'm not sure about the feminist agenda. Probably my radar is off. It's just enjoyable enough for me and Rosaline reminds me of my sister.
I'm also seeing historical fictional stories in movies/tvshows where they tried to "modernise" it very annoyingly, I understand this is the modern day world we're living in but not every story has to appeal to everyone. God I miss certain traditional movies
Yes me too! I just end up re-watching them instead of watching new movies because they're often a disappointment
I loved this take on the story. It reminded me a lot of what they did when they updated both, Shakespeare's Taming of the Shrew with "10 things I hate about you," and Jane Austin's period piece comedy, Emma, with the movie "Clueless" back in the 90's
This is THE BEST, partly because it is unique. If you want a traditional film, watch one of the 247 versions of Rome And Juliet.
@@dancingdragonfly1667 I found out only a few months ago why I liked Clueless SO much! Because it was the Jane Austen Classic!!!
@@ivillu What do you mean? TV shows and movies always try to modernize literature by using the standard 'modern' of the time. It's nothing new. Even Disney's Little Mermaid, The Hunchback of Notre Dame, and Aladdin change the original story.
What's annoying is they literally could have set this in modern times because in addition to being based on Romeo and Juliet, it's also supposed to be an adaptation of the modern set YA book "When You Were Mine". Which is why it goes so majorly intense on the whole Rosaline isn't over Romeo thing. In the actual play she didn't want him, told him no thanks, and he mopped and cried until he met Juliet. That's all. I like the idea of putting it back in ye old times for the adaptation because the book wasn't well received and had a lot of Juliet-blaming people didn't like when they saw her as being as much a victim as Rosaline. But, i wish they hadn't kept the forced feminist message and just let the story be the story.
Taking classics into modern setting is very 2000s. Nowadays, it's modern writing applied to costume drama. Although UK has done this from very long time ago.
She doesn't act like a Feminist. A Feminist believes everyone she be treated equally and fairly...that is all. Trying to take someone's Free Will away is THE WORST sin...God created Our Universe with Love and Free Will. Use your Free Will to Love!
I really appreciate your content and the tolerant people calling you a racist for critiquing the fact that Disney keeps changing original characters don't seem to tolerant like they claim.
As we should be
@LaReinaDePompis y???
people have already given so much valid facts on why tiana shouldn't be white lol. It's not our fault you only seem to look at things one sided
This is NOT the original story. The authors are free to change whatever they want. If you don't want to see changes, you can watch one of the 247 film versions of Romeo And Juliet. And, Our Universe changes a MASSIVE amount, every day. We HAVE to keep up with the changes, or Our Civilization is doomed. God created Our Universe with Love and Free Will. Use your Free Will to Love!
Tiana was never whyte 🤦🏻
This is the 2nd review I’ve seen you give... I think your take is as fantastic as your editing!!! I’m two reviews in, so far, so good...
Recent fan of your vids. Your review on Roseline really help open my eyes on elements in the movie that flew over my head when I was watching it lol.
Keep it up!
Thank you! I appreciate it
@@ivillu racist, reply to my comments?
I’m happy people are talking about this finally.
So many shows lately try to inject 4th wave tiktok “girl boss” energy into 15th-18th century type vibes. This, that cringy Jane Austin thing, The Great, Catherine Called Birdy, Gentleman Jack, etc.
Feels like they wanna make everyone bi; you just have to figure it out if it’s -sexual, or -polar 😅
Yeah I don't get it, the "girl boss" trope is so overused. You already know the obligatory "I'm a woman and I can be more" line is coming, it's just annoying at this point
@@ivillu I can be more in reality means I can fight traffic, work long hours, be too tired to go out and drown your sorrows in Netflux and box wine. Kids at least love you back and appreciate what you do (unlike your boss).
@@tiffanyl4829I don't think people go drown themselves in box wine because They work jobs. Which world do you live in? Fantasy or you have never worked. Kids and work aren't comparable buddy. Also kids are hard labor too, ask any mum including me. Wtf
@@tiffanyl4829all of us Don't have the luxury to go home and drink Box wine or not work ...
And why would you want your boss to love you back 😮...He's not in that kinda relationship wth
the funny thing is her dad was right.
My girlfriend and I just watched this due to both loving the cast. She doesn’t know much about movies and loved this while I’m a cinema connoisseur and I have to say I very much agreed with your take. It was an alright movie while being very predictable (like who didn’t realize Dario and Rosaline were going to end up together from the start). My biggest grievance isn’t even the “girl boss” thing because that’s a given in modern cinema; it’s the modern mannerisms in a period piece. The movie could have been so much more if it was just an adaptation of Romeo & Juliet but focusing from Rosaline’s perspective.
This is a good change of pace. If you want the original, you can watch one of the 247 film versions of Romeo And Juliet, and you can watch it in Shakespearean English, most people can't understand, because most people are TERRIBLE at trying to learn foreign languages.
@@atpcliff it was a basic movie not really a change of pace for anything. I don’t want the original I wanted a comedic Romeo & Juliet story from the perspective of Rosaline but not set in a modern reimagining of Shakespearean times as I previously stated
I'm pretty done with feminism and I used to be so rabid. It ruined Galadriel. And now you can't get any romance in movies. Blah.
I don't think you were a feminist if you found feminism in THIS BAD movie 😂
I like the movie, but the couple should have more screen time😕, everything was so fast to me.
A LOT of viewers, like me, want this made into a series, or at least have a follow-on film...God created Our Universe with Love and Free Will. Use your Free Will to Love!
Thank you. I lasted 20 minutes and just said nope.
Yeah, too bad cause it was an interesting concept, they didn't quite manage to pull it off
I really love your content, it just says everything I've always been thinking but never had the right words to say myself.
Thank you! I'm glad someone out there is enjoying it
Reviewer complains about women having personalities instead of grovelling at a man's feet for 9 minutes and 15 seconds
If that's what you got from it then I don't know what to tell you
@@ivillu where do u edit ur video?
@@ivillu you be like "oh no she talks about wanting more than a man. 2022 feminist agenda strikes again"
Oh yes that's exactly what she was saying! She wants women to grovel at men's feet. Now that's a smart comment. If you're sick of the girl boss trope you hate your sex and want to be subservient to men. You are really boring and ridiculous. Someone ought to tell you.
Feels like this is the reason why they won't do anything original because they put no effort, it likely gets little to no word of mouth traction and then they will just go back to making more disney princess live action remakes.
Sorry, but apart from the "gay friend" trope, everything else sounds like opinions with weak examples. And the line "feminism ruins a good movie" is quite the statement, that I did not find in this review. This movie did not negate motherhood. Just like it's okay to be a mother, it's also okay not to be one. I'm not sure why you are looking for these things in a movie, that clearly has a different theme.
I'm looking for a fun movie that doesn't fall into this typical script pattern, the modern day "girl boss" "I can do anything a man can do and more!" lines. You don't have to insert that every 10min in order to get the point across if anything it cheapens the message. It gets tiring and it takes away from how fun the movie could be. That's my opinion at least, it's overdone and it's a wasted opportunity for better script writing as I think they actually had an interesting concept here.
Because it's overused now? You can't find any positive portrayals of women who want to get married and have kids. The reality of modern life is something some if us want to escape from: hours of commuting, bosses who steal your work and keep you down as not to compete with you, your check half gone from taxes, no time for friends and family because you're exhausted from work. A little escapism is necessary from reality to mentally survive the endless boring routines of being a girl boss.
@@tiffanyl4829 yes, totally! Being a stay at home mom/wife is so stomped on nowadays it's ridiculous!
@@tiffanyl4829why do you people call anyone who works for a living "girl boss". 😒 I am an employee, not a damn boss as you think. Lol I need money for my family. Stop trying to shame women doing jobs. Geez
My point exactly. This is a teen movie. Fan fiction and bad at it.
feminism ruins a good movie ????????????? wow a women is the one who is saying that too feminism might be something old and boring where you come from it might be and old topic for you but there is still a lot of women struggling where i'm from over the idea of women rights you think she's a teen brat because she's defending a right to be heard and to marry who she wants that says a lot about you as a women so instead of hating on a good movie that supports women go find some real reasons to hate a movie and those movies that represent feminism like this movie enola holmes and an with an e that you're saying are boring and repeated are actually a very good representation for us so please stop being an antifeminist or homophobic cause it isn't a joke where i'm from no offense (sorry if there's spelling mistakes english isn't my first language)
While I agree that feminism is needed in certain areas in the world (not sure where you're from), this movie that is produced by an American company is not it. In western media there's way too much emphasis on things like "omg changing diapers, that's so degrading" etc. Like she said in the video, it's such an overly used trope that it gets old quick, especially when you're trying to tell a story. Feminism doesn't necessarily ruin the whole movie, but when there's too much emphasis on pushing some sort of message or agenda it does.
Also saying "no offense" and then calling her antifeminist and homophobic don't really contradict each other.
Have you even read the source material? It's this a joke?
Please make more reviews like this in future. Very interesting and enjoyable to watch.
Thanks, I will :)
Honestly I’d be grateful for the hateful comments if I was you. Just showing you their whiny true side and when they eventually back pedal you have a shit ton of ammo to fuck them up. You keep doing you and I’m loving these vids.
Thank you, I really appreciate the encouragement. As for the hate, they're just showing any sane person that stumbles upon my videos their true colors so..
@@ivillu Not our fault you're racist lol. And they say that you have a shit ton of ammo yet you don't reply to comments that had easily beaten your 'argument' it's almost like you're wrong and don't know how to respond
they most defint do not have a "shit ton of ammo to fuck them up" over 40 people has already made valid arguments against them and yet they do not reply... it's almost like they are wrong and don't know how to respond! Hilarious! (and i my self has already made over 8 comments countering their stupid argument, only one response... and it was to my weakest one... LOL!)
@@ivilluI don't think valid criticism is hate 😅
@randomlyswatching9481 we agree then, but I did get plenty of genuine hate void of any criticism. It's the internet though, it was expected, and people can say what they want
Nice video. 👍👍
Thank you :)
I agree with this all but it seems like you believe women belong in their specific gender roles, and they don’t. you seem like you don’t think we should be allowed to do what men can.
Not at all. I think women can do whatever they want, and in the west they can, so do it and shut up about it. That's all
I'm probably too blind to see feminist part here😂😂😂
It's the "speech" part
Same
how do i block you? just wondering cause idk how to block you
How do I block you?
No no she should block you
@@Small_Siren okay cool
I'm not saying I don't like her oppiones I just wanna block them cause I watched one of there videos and now they are all over and it's kinda getting annoying
@@Mir-kat girl if you don't want to watch it then just look up on how to do it instead of being rude and say "oh how do I block you " that sounds like you don't like her opinion which I will get mad at but still really?
Love the videos. Keep up the good work.
Thank you so much, I will :)
langue its released in depends on the area it is being played in. i can bet ya over in its original home country, the langue is the one ya want to hear it in. just got to do some... digging. faily this happens in anime were we have a english setting but japanies langue unless they are making a point its another world entirely. its something i can over look easy cuz anime is great. as for the dresses... people really think all of them were painfull? just watched another youtuber who makes such historical clothing and all her clothes look lovely, old style and not painfull.
Ahh nevermind, just saw all of your content- racism, sexism, homophobia and get this - Nord stream pipeline conspiracy. A russian propaganda account if I ever seen one.
right...
literally
Without even watching another video of hers I can tell that you are not a critical thinker. Racism, sexism, and homophobia today has lost meaning and has become simply "anything and anyone I don't like" along with "RUSSSIAAAAA REEEEEE". Can you people PLEASE go back underground with the other goblins and allow normal humans to go back to having nuanced dialogue with civil disagreement? Seriously. It's people like you that are driving the rest of us away from the Democratic party because the nonstop labeling and whining and insult hurling is boring, tired, and hard on the ears and eyes.
@@tiffanyl4829 honestly you ate.
@@tiffanyl4829 🤓
Perfect review it worth a watch, but expect some eye rolls.
She has a big nose
Finally. RUclips's shitty algorithm showed me a good channel and it's just starting too. Early 3k subscriber here!
Thank you, I appreciate it :)
you influenced some one a little to hard that they are having hallucinations that i deleted a comment and they now think that 'me deleteing a comment' gives them a point... LIKE BYE ( i didn't even delete a comment...)
Whaat
Idk who this lady is with this channel but will you marry me? Lolol jk but i appreciate your content 😌 thank you
i was so put off by all the little 'feminist' moments which were really so performative and annoying more than anything, especially that 'yes you all have big swords' like she's destroying toxic masculinity by saying that