World War I - Eastern Front (1914-1918) - Every Day
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- Группа ВК: cherepa...
Most likely this is the most hardest for me video on my channel. Despite the title of the video is Eastern Front of the World War 1, I decided to include also Balkan front, Italian front and the part of Middle Eastern front (Caucasian front). This video will show the whole chronology of hostilities of the First World War in these regions on the map (every day, animation).
Eastern front of the WW1 (or Great War) is the second in order of importance for Germany and it was much more extended. The front in the east was much longer than that in the west. The theater of war was roughly delimited by the Baltic Sea in the west and Minsk in the east, and Saint Petersburg in the north and the Black Sea in the south, a distance of more than 1,600 kilometres (990 mi). This had a drastic effect on the nature of the warfare. While the war on the Western Front developed into trench warfare (Battle of Marne, Battle of Somme Battle of Verdun in France), the battle lines on the Eastern Front were much more fluid and trenches never truly developed. This was because the greater length of the front ensured that the density of soldiers in the line was lower so the line was easier to break. Once broken, the sparse communication networks made it difficult for the defender to rush reinforcements to the rupture in the line, mounting rapid counteroffensives to seal off any breakthrough.
Franz Ferdinand was assassinated in Sarajevo by Gavrilo Princip on 28 June 1914, a month later Austria-Hungary declared war on Serbia. German Empire at head of Wilhelm 2 declared war on Russian Empire on 1 August 1914, Austria-Hungary did it on 6 August 1914. Ottoman Empire also joined the Central Powers but 1914 was the year of victories for Russian army. Everything changed in 1915. By mid-1915, the Russians had been expelled from Poland, Lithuania, part of Latvia, Belarus and Ukraine during the Great Retreat. Battle of Osowiec became famous in this period. Brussilov offensive in 1916 was the sounding victory for Russia but it suffered very high casualties. It was the reason for February Revolution in 1917 after which discipline in the Russian army dropped dramatically, soldiers didn't want to fight. Bolsheviks at head of Vladimir Lenin took power in Russia during the October Revolution. They signed the humiliating Treaty of Brest with Central Powers in 1918 and Russia completely emerged from the war. Germany surrendered after the November Revolution eight months later, during that Russia was divided into several political camps because of civil war. Eventually Bolsheviks won and USSR was established in 1922. Treaty of Versailles between Germany and Entente was signed in 1919.
Sources:
Wikipedia
istoriya-kg.ru/
gwar.mil.ru/
www.grwar.ru/
prvisvetskirat...
www.hrono.ru/
Almanac of World War I by David F. Burg, L. Edward Purcell
bigenc.ru/
rgavmf.ru/book...
rgavmf.ru/book...
Invasion: The Conquest of Serbia, 1915: The Conquest of Serbia, 1915 by Richard L. DiNardo
Local region sites for the Russian civil war
• Finnish Civil War Ever...
• The Collapse of Austri...
• The Collapse of the Ge...
Music:
1. Soundtrack 2 from "Первая мировая" by StarMedia
2. The begin of creation by Boris Kukoba from "Soviet Storm" by StarMedia
3. Chimera by Boris Kukoba from "Soviet Storm" by StarMedia
4. Calm etude by Boris Kukoba from "Soviet Storm" by StarMedia
5. Fleeing from the War by Boris Kukoba from "Soviet Storm" by StarMedia
6. The big action by Boris Kukoba from "Soviet Storm" by StarMedia
Software for creating this video:
Pаint.net
Movavi Video Editor 2021 plus
![Tee Grizzley - Blow for Blow (feat. J. Cole) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wNLN5xsx5dc/mqdefault.jpg)
Without exaggeration, each project on my channel is the part of my soul. Videos release one time in 3-5 months but despite this fact you keep watching them. It is very-very important for me, thank you very much guys!
Thanks for your hardworking, your video help us understand history more
Your videos are amazing! Thank you so much for making them!
Your channel is amazing my man
I can tell these are part of your soul. Lots of Russian/eastern based content.
You go into the most detail and have the absolute most accuracy overall; soul put to good use!
Showing the Russian Revolution and Civil War in such detail when it isn't even the main focus of the video is honestly amazing
I also like how you included Sweden attempting to take Åland :) Haven't seen that on any other video with this topic
Honestly it's neglected so often in these kind of videos, which is a shame because it adds a lot of neccesary context to the eastern front of the war.
Надо ещё проверять эти "detail".
@@Fedorov-Alexandrov ты хочешь - ты и проверяй
@@MagicVolck Спасибо за реакцию на мой комментарий.
My man literally mapped Russian Civil War as side-conflict. Respect
Xd
@@robertoalvarado1968 Gay Spanish 🤮🇪🇸🏳️🌈🤡
It's not his work
You can clearly see the battle of osowiec fortress, aka the attack of the dead man, that actually pushed the germans back at 6 august 1915.
It's safe to say that San Marino saved the Entente
True if San marino never joined the Entente we would be living in a "The Man in the high castle" WW1-style scenario.
Can confirm
Wydm Armenia made the ottomans surrender clearly Armenia saved the entente
Once San Marino and the Armenian rebels joined the Entente the Central Powers were doomed
yes
За детализацию и сложность темы - отдельный лайк!
Внятной карты по этому периоду и уж тем более региону вообще нет в RUclips
Не ожидал увидеть здесь ИРДЧ)
@@QwertyQwerty-bf9tt историческая тематика все таки
Капеееец, даже ты здесь! Стоит сказать, что выход данного ролика на свет является частично и твоей заслугой тоже. Во многом благодаря твоей главной рубрике на канале я загорелся интересом к истории России. Очень информативно, разборчиво и с юмором. С нетерпением жду новой серии, смотрю с 2016 года!!
САМ ИРДЧ ЗДЕСЬ?!?!?!?!?
Из-за тебя мне подюбилась история, а потом я от этого и маппером стал
Love how the drop at 8:01 is perfectly timed.
I also find it insane how much action the Eastern Front saw, while the Western Front looks like it's on pause.
Eastern front needs more focus.
western front won the ww1, eastern front surrendered.
@@catloves338 Eastern front tied up millions of german troops for 3 years
@@iwillhelpdefeatjustiny.1640 Eastern front got wayyy less attention from the germans and was left largely untouched until the germans launched their operation to occupy Eastern Europe
As if German couldn't use the troops on the east to good affect
I actually had no clue how well Russia was actually doing holding down three empires in the beginning, I've always thought like yeah they did one good offensive or 2, but were utterly rekt
Agree
Even at the end they hadn't lost THAT much territory until the October revolution
Russia the ship that sank on the way to victory
The cope is real.
Чел, ты помимо основной темы детально показал октябрьскую революцию, оба ледяных похода, степной поход и поход Яссы-Дон. За это тебе нереальное уважение.
Absolutely weird and insane moments in WW1 that could literally only come from this war:
*The Ottomans bombard Russia, only for Russia to push into their territory and for them to barely even cross Russian territory (oh, I forgot, they attacked Russia.... in the winter.... in the mountains.... half of the army froze the death, hmm, great strategy)
*Austria-Hungary struggles against Serbia for an entire year, them Bulgaria joins, and Serbia falls almost immediately
*UK makes a huge deal out of the Germans invading Belgium, a neutral country, then proceeds to intervene in Greece in order for it to join the Entente (ahem, a neutral country too)
*Romania finds it a grat idea to invade the much bigger Austria-Hungary even though it is mainly surrounded by Central Powers, then really surprisingly gets obliterated from both sides
*Italy keeps attacking Austria-Hungary on the same front for two years, barely gains anything, Austria-Hungary launches a single attack, and successfully pushes into Italy
Like W H A T
Oh and the Italy point
Their army was worse than Austro Hungarian army
They had old ass guns (even Serbia had better tech), ancient battle tactics and overconfident generals
Plus no efficient industry to support the war effort
It's not that they didn't try to conquer Austria
They did
But they literally couldn't make any significant advance at all, plus the terrain was rough anyways (Alp mountains)
So when they decided to take more action they lost really bad (Tho that was the first time they made Austria Hungary to actually focus on them a bit more)
Their army almost collapsed afterwards and was basically kept alive by British and French help throughout the rest of the War
Bruh you tube censored my first comment so only I can see it wtf why
@@lilestojkovicii6618it can still be seen
1:30 Hostilities begin
1:39 Russia pushes into northeastern Austria-Hungary
1:58 Ottoman Empire shells Russian ports in the Black Sea and joins the war
2:18 Austria briefly occupies Belgrade
2:33 Russia's furthest ground gains in Austria-Hungary during the war
3:09 Russia moves into northeastern Ottoman territory
3:13 Italy joins the Entente
3:58 Austria-Hungary and Bulgaria begin offensive into Serbia, causing it to fall
4:59 Ottoman port of Trabson is captured by Russia
5:41 Romania joins the Entente and attacks Austria-Hungary
7:25 Bolsheviks briefly fight a war in Petrograd
7:42 Russia fights a brief war with Kornilov's Forces
8:01 Russia descends into a civil war with the Bolsheviks
8:33 Central powers begin a massive offensive into Bolshevik controlled territory
9:44 Entente begin an offensive into the balkans, causing Bulgaria to collapse soon after
9:54 Austria-Hungary begins falling apart, Ottoman Empire collapses
9:59 Germany collapses, marking the end of the war
There’s no real offensive there, the Bolsheviks allowed The Central Powers the land at Brest Litovsk
@@kohwenxu Operation Faustschlag
Bolsheviks allowed the Germans to take those lands it wasn't a offensive good comment tho
The German did launch a offensive between the October revolution and Brest livtosc the soviet army was basically non exsistent so the Germans occupied much territory in a short period of time.
@@kohwenxu Faustschlag operation
Одно из лучших видео по Восточному фронту ПМВ. Что важно: не просто видео, где карта из синего в красный цвет переливается, а с историческими справками и другими не менее важными деталями.
Не теряй планку, это действительно круто
Bro this is World War 1
@@GiulianoGariВосточный Фронт Первой Мировой Войны.
The effort you put into these videos is jawdropping, lots of people don’t understand how hard mapping is
Yes, absolutely, I'm in awe too!
Yes a masterpeace
8:42 that small russian army unit escaping all the way from romania to ukraine is so based
Прекрасное видео, я поражаюсь тому, насколько детально все сделано! Понравилось еще и то, что музыка использована из "Великой Войны", она очень классная и атиосферная. Спасибо огромное за работу!
Actually one of the soundtracks is also from soviet storm ww2 in the east. Its a great documentary on the eastern front in ww2
@@distinctjackal9016 each one is
I have to say this, you are one of the best mappers on RUclips and the most underrated one I know, I don't know why this platform values money more than quality as I randomly found your channel in my recommendations.
I am a big fan of yours brother and I love your mapping, it surpasses other mappers and the quality is the best, keep it up. And good luck :D
Hope you have a good day/night
Love from India
"...but no one knows about the First World War. And this is really sad..."
Boy, I'll say. Such an important conflict, important period in history, which arguably caused most of the major European problems of the next century. Yet so often forgotten.
Great job on this video! Really, one of the most detailed I've seen. We don't deserve these expert skills
@@Se5-s5b Not really. Trench warfare was certainly gruesome, but almost twice as many people died in WWII as compared to WWI.
@@dewayneblue1834
6-18 Million people died in WW1
65-85 Million people died in WW2
@@Se5-s5b I think the captured Chinese,Americans,Australians, Indonesians in the Pacific Front would disagree
Seriously good look up how brutal the Japanese were
The effects of the 1st world war were much greater (there were millions of people who died because of the economic crisis and people who died because of the russian civil war)
and all this happened after the war was over
The fact that Germany could have won by simply not sending the Zimmerman telegram is wild
Not really, with the 🇬🇧blockade, the fate was already sealed
Even after strong advances into communist Russia, by then, the German economy was already crippled.
That is true
While it's not discussed often, the Greek front single handily knocked Bulgaria out of the war, and was a significant contributing factor to the Ottomans and ESPECIALLY Austria to drop out. Greece not joining the Entente Powers may have extended the war quite a bit.
This is honestly amazing. I can’t imagine the time, effort, and work that went into this video. It is so well made and I hope it will get many more views as it deserves!
RIP all soldiers and civilians from Russia, Serbia and Montenegro that died for our freedom☦️🇷🇺🇷🇸🇲🇪
What about the central powers soldiers? Shouldn't they rest in peace, also?
@@herbertjager6409 every human life lost is bad in this conflict, idk why everyone cares only about entente
@@zer0cola359 infant it was the fault of entente in the world war 1
Because serbia killed an citizen of Austria Hungary in there territory and they even let serbia have an chance but they refused and Austria Hungary declared war at serbia and Russia ft France joins and ofc German empire would protect Austria Hungary because they were allies before world war.
And then UK joins which was a great war
@@elosnuhiu4023 Serbia were alleged to have supported the terrorist who killed Ferdinand but no evidence has ever surfaced that they partook in his killing. Frank Ferdinand wanted reform in Austria-Hungary and so would have been an odd target for the Serbian government.
Then we have the ultimatum against Serbia which was designed to be so harsh that they would definitely refuse. Germany and Austria-Hungary had planned a war using Serbian aggression as a pretext, and were damned happy when they finally got the opportunity.
>Implying Russia actually cared
All they wanted was some strong allies in the Balkans, nothing more
8:01 i love this scene, the erupt of the russian civil war plus the music which fits pretty well and sounds so good, it’s amazing.
Well done!
Not only is the mapping done really well, but I also simply love your music choice of using the soundtracks from Soviet Storm and the World War 1 series by StarMedia. Simply amazing.
7:42 that reminds me something...
Wagner
I did not see this coming.
1:38 i love how it goes from saint peterburg to petrograd
Музыка Кукобы из документалок StarMedia - классика
One of the best mapping videos I’ve seen, 1918 was just incredible to watch!
1918 was insane. The map just blows up all over the place!
This was pretty damn well-made, well done! Shame you cut off most of Finland, though knowledge on the frontlines particularly in East Karelia and Ingria is quite esoteric in nature, and mostly not available in English, so I don't blame you.
I think I know a good bit about WW1, but there are so many details here that cover things I've never even heard of... (IMRO? Russia pushing the Ottomans that far? Whatever the hell happened in Albania? Sweden?). Very well done.
Sweden occupied the Åland islands during the Finnish Civil War, but backed down when Germany joined the conflict.
Так РИ всё время Османов щемила
Сделано всё очень хорошо, пересматриваю по несколько раз, музыка тоже хороша. Профессионализм автора был показан хорошо. Хоть я и знаю всю историю ПМВ на всех фронтах, но Восточный фронт меня поразил, Россия не сдавалась и вела войну до конца, хоть и потеряла территории. Точность где проходили боевые действия, но со справкой и деталями тоже отлично. А равных тебе автор, даже нет.
Германию погубила Россия- ибо наибольшие потери она понесла на востоке
@@АмирБадрутдинов вы путаете первую мировую войну со второй мировой войной. здесь на западном фронте шли тяжелые бои, в среднем в два раза больше войск, чем на восточном фронте.
PS: Sorry for bad Russian, I just google translated this XD
Странно видеть коммуниста радующегося за победу России как чисто русского государства
@@goyda-goiNo.
A tiny mistake:
Dimetoka (in Turko-Bulgarian border, today part of Greece, it seems like ")" on the map) was given to Bulgaria by Ottomans. Bulgaria joined the war after they were given Dimetoka. This isn't shown on the map.
Ну и бред полный дарить свои территории, просто отврат,жаль что в современной России этот ужас в 10 раз хуже
Im actually surprised about how there was a much of fighting with both Russian Empire and Bulgaria and Ottoman Empire, Thanks to the addition of the maritime fighting. Congratulations on making one of the most impressive masterpieces CherepashkaShusha.
There was also a lot of fighting in caucaus my friend
@Gigachad no only 10,000
Сделай пожалуйста гражданскую войну в России 1918 1922
let's not forget about the tragic fate of the Armenians murdered by the Turks god bless them
Let's not forget about the tragic fate of the Turks murdered by the Armenians. God bless them.
R.I.P. the victims of Armenian Greek and Assyrian G3noc1d3.
@@stephmod7434 no such thing lol
Russian advanced so much thanks to the revolting Armenians that killed civilians and raided supply lines. They asked for this shit lmao
@@kasadam85 dude not recognizing a g3noc1d3 is a crime
its terrible to think about the fact this man who puts gigantic efforts and love into his videos has less subs than the average shitty short youtuber who makes cringy 'WeLcOmE To EuRoPe' videos, truly disgusting
Дам тебе идею, покажи что происходило на восточном фронте после капитуалирования германии и австро венгрии, будет интересно глянуть
Так это уже гражданка в России получается
Maybe next: Europe 1918 - 1924 with Polish-bolshevick war Turkey independence war
Congrats on 1 Million views!
Christ, I can only imagine how difficult it was to map out both the World War One aspects and the Russian Civil War aspects combined, let alone the collapse of the various empires (IE Austro-Hungaria)
Germany raided southern finland with zeppelins and warships, even clashed with russian ships during 1914-1916
обожаю твои видео, в месяц 1 раз нуэно обновлять канал😍
насчёт первой мировой, очень запутанная война, не понятно кто начал войну, кто за кого был, кто победители, кто проиграл и т.д.
this channel isn't just informational, but also even inspirational. Love your work
I love how you added the ocean borders too
This vid deserve more views... you put so much effort into it, that's really amazing!!
This is the most detailed WWI Eastern Front I've ever seen.
its been 2 years... please come back :(
He said he is passing exams
@@mineturtle2 oh, thx for letting me know
Soon...
38 mins ago? Am I lucky or what!
@@CherepashkaShusha Thank you for making something so good. My eyes love it
Here are the strategic and decisive battles in Eastern Front/Balkan Front:
1:35 Battle of Cer(Serbian Victory)
1:37 Battle of Krasnik(Austrian Hungarian Victory)
2:23 Recapture of Belgrade(Decisive Serbian Victory)
3:38 Battle of Osowiec Fortress(Russian Victory)
4:07 Battle of Nis(Bulgarian Victory)
4:16 Battle of Kosturino(Decisive Bulgarian Victory)
5:13 Battle of Jutland(Inconclusive)
5:15 Brusilov Offensive (Decisive Russian Victory)
7:42 Kornilov's coup(Russian Provisional Government remain in power for now)
8:01 The beginning of Russian Civil War
9:41 Collapse of the Macedonian Front
9:46 Armistice of Salonica
9:56 Armistice of Mudros
9:57 Armistice of Villa Giusti
9:59 Armistice of 11 November 1918
The Brusilov was hardly a decisive Russian victory. It achieved some limited results at unsustainable losses, was eventually beaten back and decively countered by the Central Powers.
9:04 battle of the piave ( italian victory )
Battle of jutland can't really be called British victory. Britain lost more ships than Germany, so both sides claimed victory. Also where the battles between Russia and Germany?
@@cqpp Battle of Osowiec, its literally up there
Edit: it's more of a pyrrhic victory for Russians
@@Tacitus-qd3ev if brusilov offensive failed, the soldiers would mutiny much earlier and Russia will probably end up in a much more horrible situation
Это война заслужила такой же памяти что и Великая Отечественная печально что мало говорят а на западе недооценивают огромный вклад Россий в победу
Чё-т не припоминаю, чтоб кто-то с запада говорил о таком.
ПМВ была бессмысленной войной для простого народа. И речь не только про Россию. Братания на всех фронтах с первых месяцев войны тому подтверждение.
И и не случайно именно в ПМВ массово распространились пацифистские идеи.
Именно поэтому про ту войну вспоминают как о трагедии. Когда миллионы людей погнали на убой ради интересов единиц.
Это и была Великая Отечественная. По крайней мере, так ее называли еще тогда. А вот тогдашние Власовы к сожалению у нас считаются героями...
лол, уж точно не такой же памяти, что и ВОВ.
@Evgeniy Silkin просто народу конечно было лучше проиграть, затем вступить в намного более кровопролитную войну развязанную большевиками и подыхать от голода
One of the best videos I’ve seen on the eastern front of ww1 period!
Definitely going to be using this map as a reference when I read Norman Stone’s book on the eastern front.
Если бы не идиотизм Керенского, то мы бы сегодня жили в лучшей стране без коммуняк(
Уже 30 лет прошло с тех пор, как ты живешь без коммуняк. Ну и какие достижения ? Бензоколонка?
"Коммуняки" предоставили в России такие свободы, о которых люди могли только мечтать. Правда не везде на 100%, но не просто так они одержали победу, не будь у них широкой поддержки населения - не победили бы. Предлагаю послушать хотя бы серию лекций историка Клима Жукова "Рождение революции". Многое становится понятным. Посмотрите - не пожалеете
@@ДмитрийКуприянов-м8ж чувак, я вашу революцию и философию наизусть знаю. Проблема в том, что социалистическая модель экономики нежизнеспособна и неэффективна
Единственный грех Керенского - мягкотелость в отношении властелюбивого-предателя Корнилова, без идиотизма которого, большевистский переворот был бы невозможен.
Не жили бы. Живем только благодаря кровавым комсунягам даже 30 лет спустя.
Boy I have to be a nerd to recognize the soundtrack just by hearing....
This channel is so underrated, how does it not have at least 500k subs?
In the meantime, millions of Armenians perished :(
Yes it's very sad😢
What a good recommendation. After 30 years , Germany has made their military budget over 100 billion
Видимо я так и не отправил коммент насчёт того, что это видео просто суперское). Учитывая все последние события как-то уже не в настроении был писать это... Но твой видос прям снёс мне крышу своей детализацией:)
Продолжай в том же духе)))
Its safe to say that he was searching about every single city and what happend in every day there
This may be the best and the most detailed in my opinion
Hope you can back to do videos
Next video: Russian-Ukrainian War
Yes
Where did you find the information to know all the battles of the Russian revolution? And the others too, it's so much at the same time! Wow.
Wikipedia, local Russian region sites, archives. Also all sources are in the description!!
Здесь даже присутствуют походы Кубанские и Дроздовского полка.
Лайк за детализацию! Вы молодец.
Желаем Черепашке много сил и терпения. Судя по всему, они ему очень нужны...
Благодарю, товарищ! Силы для ЕГЭ действительно пригодятся...
Massive respect for all this detail man, this video could be used in history courses
8:33 i didnt know sweeden tried to gain land from russia
Sweden wants Åland because Åland speaks Swedish
@@BEL10-693 thanks too bad i couldnt get this information 4 months ago when i comment
1:30 Beginning of WW1
1:58 Ottoman entry into the war
2:10 Seige of Przemysl; longest seige of the war
2:23 Ottoman offensive into the Caucasus
2:40 German offensive into East Prussia
2:57 Armenians rebel
3:13 Italian entry into the war
3:37 Germans capture Warsaw
3:59 Bulgarian entry into the war
4:15 Serbia is fully occupied
5:13 Battle of Jutland
5:15 Beginning of Brusilov Offensive
5:41 Romanian entry into the war
7:20 Official Greek entry into the war
7:24 Bolshevik uprising in Petrograd
7:41 Kornilov Affair; attempted coup in Russia
7:56 Austrian offensive into Italy
8:01 Beginning of Russian Civil War
8:33 Swedish attempt to capture Åland
8:35 German offensive into Russia
8:38 Treaty of Brest-Litovsk
9:14 Several puppets are established
9:45 Bulgaria surrenders
9:56 Ottomans surrender
9:57 Austria-Hungary surrenders
10:00 Germany surrenders
Sorry for any incorrect info
The Siege of Przemysl was the longest siege in Europe but not the longest siege in the whole WW1 that belongs to the Siege of Medina from 1916 - 1919
УИИИИИИ НОВОЕ ВИДЕО!!!
"Последнее предупреждение германия! Сан-марино вступает в войну!" У него огромная армия из 15 бравых солдат!
You even made parts of the western front and naval strikes, truly incredible. Cheers!
Great video! Im currently working on an animation on the ww1 eastern front (something like eastory) this video is pretty accurate 👍
If Lenin never started revolution, 1: war ended earlier
2: ussr never existed
3: usa would have better relations with Russia
4:
Based on the October Revolution, Lenin's existence is very important however I dont think Kerensky could stand much longer and they are in dual sharing power that means Lenin's side is easily replaceable. A one knock is enough against them, theyre just waiting who are the next ones who will taking over the ruins of Russian Empire. So the USSR thing surely would exist and the US-Russia relations nowadays are more vague if Kerensky succeed on neutralizing Lenin as it was already planned Stalin got him though if you know what I meant.
@@Markov16 I mean, yes. It would exist. But the chances would be lower. Also, with no definite leader, there won’t be any organization in the Bolshevik party
F RUclips. why they didnt gave me notification?
0:55 my eardrums burst
Big respect to heroic little Serbia!
Один из лучших маппингов, что я видел. Пересматриваю уже сотый раз. Очень понравилось то, что ты как в маппинге по Тридцатилетней войне закрасил страны по цвету коалиции, в которой они состоят вместо того, чтобы давать каждой стране свой собственный цвет. Когда много цветов, то создается путаница. Как по мне, единственный недочет - это то, что акватории Антанты и нейтральных стран закрашены одним цветом. Как бы то ни было, будешь ли ты делать видео по Западному фронту ПМВ? Если да, то там будет показана только Франция, Германия и Ла-Манш, или картинка более отдаленной будет?
Спасибо большое, каждый раз такие комментарии читать одно удовольствие! Западный фронт планирую сделать следующим видосом, и картинка вероятнее всего там будет с маленьким масштабом - от Ла-Манша до границы со Швейцарией. С помощью этого мизерные изменения фронта на Западе удастся показать более ощутимыми
@@CherepashkaShusha hello how are you feeling better hows your health.i know because theres a war going on but may Allah help you.
Отдельный респект за музыку из документалок Star Media
3:21 Was it at this moment that the Austro-Hungarian Empire tried to attack Jan Marino?💀
Could you make a video about the Russian-Ukrainian war of 2022? Once the war is over?
Every single time I'm amazed at how well Serbia defended itself in this war. It's a shame it just got overrun in the end, but damn
The amount of research required for making this video is enormous. Great job indeed 👍
Видео редкие, но они стоят того. Есть всякие иностранные аниматоры, но у них качество и детализация сильно страдает, даже более популярные в этом деле ютуберы по качеству уступают тебе.
All Russia had to do to win WW1 in the East against Germany was not lose. And it could have probably helped bring down Austria-Hungary faster as its armies were effective on that front.
It could have easily held out until the German collapse in the West - which would have come much faster if Germany had to fight on two fronts for longer and if Austria-Hungary weakened faster - if its army hadn't been so appallingly led. As in, just amazingly poorly. Nicolas' decision to go to the front and make his own military decisions - including taking advice from his wife and Rasputin! - was particularly ill-advised.
The Russian Empire would have survived, but the outrage over the losses would have probably forced Nicolas to adopt a constitutional monarchy or at least install a parliament with real power over him in 1918 or so. There would have been no Revolution and therefore no fear of commies, which is what brought Nazism to power in Germany. All in all, a better 20th Century.
1. Revolutions occur due to public dissatisfaction with the lack of social reforms. Changing a full monarchy to a constitutional one does not resolve this issue.
2. Hitler was appointed Chancellor by Hindenburg, who was pressured by German industrialists. They wanted revenge for the loss in ww1. Communism has nothing to do with this.
Ты думаешь только из-за войны распалась Российская Империя?)
I never knew the russians pushed that far into east prussia at the start of the war.
Vídeo sugestion: russian civil war every day
:)
Well done! I didn't know there were Serbian insurgencies post-Bulgarian invasion
all of this happened cause that driver took the wrong turn making the serbian guy shoot the king..
I can only imagine the amount of effort that went into this and it is sad it doesn't have more views, I leave it playing on loop when working for this
Everytime I watch it i feel like watching it more!!!
Like i am true
On the one hand, there are a few errors here and there, like Prizren not going to Bulgaria in 1916. On the other hand, these errors do not take away from the main thesis, that being the Russian perspective. Your works are not videos, they are experiences
Они добавили милодию из русского документального фильма о первой мировой войне в начале ролика уважаю.
Hey your back hooray
я нашел небольшую ошибку, показано что перемышль в 15 году не был взят русскими войсками а лишь окружен а позднее деблокирован, в реальности русские взяли перемышль
It's awesome!!! I'm interested in WW1 and I'm very impressed by this map. You illustrated really accurate changings of the frontline. You even added the operation on the river Stohod, that took it's place at the end of 1915. Guy, you great, you should know it!!!
You did an excellent work as always, hope you will do the western front soon but for now take a break you deserved it
Gona have to like for the high quality mapping, even tho Ive no idea about what your naming convention is.
Как всегда, отличный ролик. Очень актуальный на фоне происходящих событий
The amount of detail you put into your videos is astounding. I learn something new every time I watch one of them. Great work and keep it up! Thank you for covering this major part of the war!
emperortigerstar has been quiet since this dropped
lol
Как всегда отличное видео! Печально, что большевики забрали у России ее заслуженную победу. Вечная память солдатам, павшим в боях Второй Отечественной войны!
Не большевики забрали победу. Россия просто находилась на грани, 2 революции тому доказательство
Че печального то? С такими "успехами" в войнах и победами ценой развала страны, Вторая Мировая закончилась бы отсутствием наличия этой самой России. А Вы с большой вероятностью либо не значились в этой реальности, либо писали на немецком или японском.
лол, ничего они не забирали, просто нервы у российского народа сдали раньше, чем у противников, внутренний фронт такой же важный, как и передовая.
Вторая Отечественная война? А ниче, что Россия первая напала на Германию. Это для немцев была Отечественная война, поэтому они так отчаянно дрались против всего мира
@@flintheartglomgold5276 Россия напала?😂 Не кури больше это.
Russia:"Hold on guys I know the front doesn't look good right now but here lemme just"
*implodes*
Every mf in the Balkans: "oh yeah good idea lemme just"
*dies to macedonian entente counteroffensive*
Are ever planning on doing the Syrian War (2011)? I know it's technically ongoing, but it's basically been over for at least three years. Would be cool to see a visualized timeline of it
У меня отвисла челюсть на моменте октябрьской революции. Где ты наше инфу, какие уезды в губерниях какого числа переходили под власть большевиков? Я когда-то искал и ничего не нашел =(
открой любую книжку по истории или конкретно по истории гражданской войны, найди в конце источники, скорее всего будет указан адрес исторического архива, и все.
Для изучения российской гражданки я использовал довольно действенный лайфхак, вбиваешь запрос в гугле по следующему шаблону: "название города" советская власть 1917. В итоге тебе предлагают довольно много локальных интересных сайтов, где можно найти полезную инфу. Cоветую :D
@@CherepashkaShusha Ля, какая большая и муторная работа, спасибо тебе)
Это восхитительно.представляю как это сложно сделать. Это ведь надо Учитывать каждые военные проишествия 1 мировой и начала гражданской войны. А это очень тяжёлая работа. Но несмотря на это ролик получился восхитительный. Очень качественная работа. Спасибо огромное.
Extremely impressive work. Did my thesis in part on the Urmiah Crisis so got really excited when I saw you included map information from that event in this vid (though it was only a corner of the vid). Proof of extremely meticulous work, well done!