The fact that in the credits, Cutie had been repaired implies that the toys don't really die, if she was actually alive. But that would mean that she spent hours without an leg and one of her ears torn off, and also got to hear the people who killed her celebrate and dance in the tears of the one person she loved dearly. this shit is fucked up
@@debbiewong6539 I think that make sense because they didn't even care that their daughter is crying and her favorite toy is ripped they just wanted to go back to normal
They thought that since her tears where what caused them to be stuck in this predicament in the first place, it would get them back to their bodies. But of course it didn’t work, and thus Hakim has to step in and remind them the only way to get back to reality is to fix what’s broken, their relationship.
@@christophersudbrink4946 yeah yeah we all know the context, what I'm saying is despite the weird things happening, it would take MASSIVE mental gymnastics to conclude all that needs to happen to break the cursed is for her to cry on them again, no strings attached? Also doesn't it say a lot about them that they don't even flinch at the idea of making their daughter cry, or like ever second guess themselves about the morality of things, not even a comment about how maybe what they're doing is wrong, whether it helps them or not. My point is, I don't care what they thought they're shitty parents for basically bullying their daughter to help themselves out of a situation they stuck themselves in in the first place.
The voice actress for Cutie nailed it, you really need to be good at acting to make everyone feel THIS bad. The begging and crying really sounds innocent, desperate and scared, it’s just so good
@@mydogghostIt really wasn’t supposed to be funny, they just threw humor in there to lighten the blow. Even the music goes weird once the murder starts.
This wouldn't be so bad if Cody and May came to a realization that they made Rose cry for no reason and start having some self relfection on what their daughter's feeling, especially after seeing the toy that's comforting her through the divorce is all ripped up, but they don't.
@@ImALombax because they wanted to turn back to normal and they believed that what turned them to dolls would be the same thing that would turn the, back (aka their daughters tears)
The fact that the elephant was just trying to have a tea, to just escape; then to plead for her life and finally get ripped apart before falling to her death. Was just...to graphic that I would be surprised if someone doesn't feel horrible just to watch it.
Playing with my girlfriend, after both eating an edible, I literally broke down crying half way through. I had to pause the game because of how horrible I felt. Literally the only thing that pushed me to finish this part is the idea that the game would force me to start the whole scene over later, if I had just turned it off.
@@19reaperassassn85 1. Was it a weed edible or a LSD edible 2. Don't go blind on movies, shows, games or other forms of media while high, any emotions created by a scene will be multiply from the drug
I really applaud the devs for putting this into the game. The fact that the characters willingly killed an innocent and then tried to bathe in the tears of their own child to break their curse really shows what Narcissism is like.
Well. in interviews they express intent that it was supposed to be this monty pthon moment andi nstead it just kinda... showcased hwo blindly selfish they both were.
As gruesome as this was, this scene was really important at showing they didn't understand how their actions affected their daughter. Going as far to make her cry without realizing the consequences. I was legitimately upset with the parents as I played through this section
Cutie's death is gruesome, but i believe this all links to rose's psyche: her childlike innocence has beem stripped away from her directly by her parents actions. While they never fought in front of her, they still hurt her to a depressed degree: to a point where rose blames herself for her parents disagreements.
That's exactly what I thought. Everyone thinks this scene was just a random act of sadism, but the symbolism is very apparent for the emotional ordeal of divorce. However, it is still a very sad scene.
The writers probably didn’t expect people to identify with a toy elephant so much. There are a lot of clues that this was meant to be just a dark joke (with obvious implications about the parents). The whole buildup. „I know how we become humans again... we make her cry!“
After this scene I failed to empathize with the two main characters for the rest of the game. I really never got over it and it honestly kind of ruined the rest of the story for me. I think that's just a testament to how well crafted this scene is.
@Cronotriggered Not me, I empathized with them the whole way. They were forced to become clay figures by a book some guy wrote & there kid has no one to look after her when they were clay.
they were shit (obvious) before this scene, how anyone even can empathize with them, but this is the main idea of the game. how bad people may become better
6:58 *May:* "Oh no... Oh gosh..." *Me:* Oh shit, she's starting to realize what they've just done. Time for character development! *May:* "We're stuck like this!" *Me:* ...I hate these characters.
They could have asked the elephant what else makes her cry instead of killing her. Then explain the situation to the elephant, she'd actually be happy to help.
@@badoe7138 Exactly. Up to this point, instead of talking out their problems, they see a divorce as the only solution to the problem. This scene reflects that.
I know right!!!!!!?????? She was such a cute and kind hearted spirit that wanted to make friends and people happy, and they killed her!!!!!!! that's why I don't like this game!!!!!!!!! If they brought back to life in the end that would've been nice.
@@ketanmay8469 She's fixed in the end credits. Honestly I think this scene is important as it shows how the May and Rose were looking at their own problems and being so wrapped up in how to solve them the easy way (divorcing, murdering Cutie to force tears from Rose) that they didn't see just how much they were hurting the poor girl, or look for other solutions that would require more effort.
I am not lying when I say I was full on SOBBING during this scene. I loved Cutie so much. She was one of my favorite characters. To hear her cry, and scream, and beg for her life just broke my heart. And to make it worse, Cutie was the one thing comforting Rose during all of this, yet the parents just killed her, watched their daughter cry, felt absolutely no remorse, and were angry instead of upset when they realized that their daughter's tears did nothing. This was one of the most gory and brutal scenes I've ever seen in a game, and there wasn't even any blood.
Outside the uncomfortable murder of an cute elephant. I like how they destroy their daughters favourite toy then literally bathe in her tears, then read a note from her blaming herself for the divorce, and there's no self-reflection at all.
@@jaxendale7864 same. Literally had to brush mats out of my hair which hurt so bad I cried, found a dying dog and called the owner who said throw the collar in the garbage and leave the body there which made me sob, and then this scene sent me into a crying fit
The part that makes it disturbing is when may says “kill her” the music distorts And the closer you get to the edge the music distortion gets more intense
She apologized to cutie for getting hurt just like she apologizes for the bad relationship her parents have and she wants to fix both Basically she thinks everything bad happening is her fault
It's not fair! Cutie is such a sweet, kind, and lovable character and she had to be killed, and the fact that Cody and May killed her for, basically, nothing makes her demise even more upsetting.😭
Cutie needs a damn hug. I absolutely hate that someone so sweet and undeserving of death, had to die a brutal, fruitless death. Nothing was gained here.
@Nolan Connolly it's 2 characters... if i you want to know more i will say the first word of their name or their entire name(which i don't recommend) because your gonna hate the other character.
Me: goes to therapist Therapist: what's wrong? Me: i saw two dolls brutaly kill a toy eleplant Therapist: now I need therapy Edit: My grammar was bad so I fixed it.
“You don’t have to do this.. I love Rose.” Falls to death. *hears loud shattering* What the hell did someone throw a rock through my window!? Oh god it’s my heart shattered 💔
Cutie: * Screaming in pain due to the fact her ear was literally stabbed * The dad: she’s tricking us! Tug on her leg harder so she can feel even more pain!
I wish I had a Cutie the Elephant now. Just so I could take care of her and wash this memory away. Please, this is actually the worst thing I've ever done. Worst part is that she's either fixed but dead or fixed but traumatised. She deserved so much better.
The interesting thing about this scene, what makes this so disturbing, is the confrontation between the identity of the player characters (the parents) and the real point of view the game leads you to have: the childhood's vision of suffering. From the beggining of the game to this point, you try to immerse yourself as one of the parents. You get attached to the characters, with their personalities and flaws, and get involved into THEIR situation, THEIR relationship, THEIR marriage. Until that point in the game, Rose is not the subject of the story. She rather seems to be a TOOL they need to solve THEIR problems. At no point they really thought of Rose's suffering as if it was the cause of the problem they were trying to solve. There is a time for the characters to learn something. They are clearly not ready to understand how selfish they are at this point of the game. They have much more work to do on that! But there is also a time for the players to learn a message or a morale, and here, what we all learned is that the suffering of a child is not less important than anyone else's just because they are children. From their point of view, they could live irremediable experiences, as their innocence is constantly threatened of being butchered by the cruelty of life, especially if their parents aren't helping them but contributing to ruin their childhood. Cutie the Elephant was Rose's innocence. And her parents mercilessly killed it, believing it was "not that important", because obviously, their grown-up problems were "so much more important"! And just to make it clear, I am not defending the parents' actions! I almost cried playing this and am still in shock. Maybe I'm overanalyzing the scene, but it is my way to release the pressure. Overall, I believe this is brilliant writing. Risky and bold, but brilliant. The developers took the bet of giving us all trauma to make us feel what it is like for a child to suffer of being ripped of his innocence, and I believe it worked... Maybe too much!
@@gantz22ify I'd say they massively succeded. The sharp contrast in the scene's action and the parents' reaction is exactly that dark comedic tone you describe. Idk a lot about Monty Python, so I can't compare it to that, though.
@@christophersudbrink4946 Yeah, and after that? They're just disappointed, not horrified at what they had to do to accomplish nothing. Then they move on to the next clue without showing remorse for what they did to both Rose and Cutie. No wonder Hakim said they hadn't earned it.
Too bad this scene is completely pointless. No, really; I'm wracking my brain trying to see any reason as to why this was even remotely necessary, and I got nothing.
I was playing this because a friend invited me to play. I was slow to drag the elephant to the edge and I felt absolutely shitty doing everything to get to the edge. I felt sadness and hatred for the characters. When they felt no remorse after noticing the tears didn't break the curse, I quit. "These are shit parents and they are undeserving of anything good in their lives. Fuck this game." was my response before I left the Discord voice chat and went to bed absolutely angry.
So they murder a poor, innocent loving stuffed animal who was completely undeserving of such cruelty and then _happily_ bathe in the tears of the daughter whose heart they willingly break? If the game allowed it, I’d probably have these terrible excuses for parents thrown in a furnace instead.
@@Savageboy726 the parents are destroying something their daughter loves to make her cry and having their daughters tears rain on the dolls to turn back into their real bodies, unfortunately that didn't help
If I had my way, I’d give these two horrible parents to Sid in Toy Story before Woody scared him just so he’d turn them into abominations while feeling extreme pain in the process. I think that they deserve to be tortured and ripped apart and then reassembled into monsterous forms.
I cried my eyes out while I watched my boyfriend play this part, she was just wanting to be friends and play but instead they did all this to her, I understand they were trying to break the spell but to see cutie call for rose and to seeing her cry and be torn a part broke my heart.
This scene made my fiance and I stop playing. We thought the parents were already really unlikeable characters, but it became impossible to root for them after that. Felt very unnecessary and just pissed us off really.
Love how even after they see it didn’t work They are like “meh” You just tortured someone and make them plead for mercy and bathed on the tears of you crying daughter The fuk Sorry but at that moment I wish I didn’t played those characters
@PRchris13 They were forced to become clay figures by a book some guy wrote & there kid has no one to look after her when they were clay. Plus none of the stuffed animals are alive, the book was just using magic.
@@kijanajenkins2546 a parent cares for their kid Yes they became toys and are forced to find a way out But that doesn’t justify that they should abandon the idea of caring for their child or if the child gets hurt (mentally, emotional or physically) irl they shouldn’t care Like they broke the favorite toy of the daughter and it made her cry It failed and yes it was a bad thing it didn’t worked But damn they didn’t even showed a emotion of “oh shit we forced our innocent daughter to cry out of sadness and she is all alone now without nobody to support her” Like I would also get wha you say if they weren’t alone or didn’t involved their daughter But they did involve her and after what they did to her they hardly cared Like at this point they could hurt her and I bet they would be like “god damn it we didn’t turn normal”
I just played this section of the game and I cried the entire time. Im a stuffed animal lover, Cutie just hit home for me because shes the kind of toy I would have definitely loved to have as a child :(
@@theotheseaeagle Agreed, watching her get slowly eviscerated was heartbreaking to watch. But at least she’s alive, likely still in pain, but alive. She’s with Rose, so she’ll be loved till Rose gets older and matures away from her toys.
My brother and I just played this part and couldn't stop freaking out! Half way through my brother said "WHERE'S THE BOOK!?!? WHY ISN'T HE STOPPING US!?!? WHAT THE FU-" and you know the rest. We just thought it would be a shove off the top and it would shift to Rose's perspective as she hit the ground but NOOOOOOOO AMPUTATION AND THEN YOU SHOVE HER OFF WITH YOUR FOOT!!!
@@voidwalker5784 Background music was even more unsettling than anything else. U can hear the childhood being stripped away in it. And I absolutely HATE the book even more now, he could've done something.
I think this whole scene with Queen Cutie tells how parents think that one solution would fix their problems w/ their children, only to make the situation even worse. This is especially true since Dr. Hakim (the book) tried to coerce the two to make Rose cry by killing Queen Cutie. Not thinking of any other way of making Rose cry, they just went with Dr. Hakim's suggestion because it was EASIER for the weight of responsibility to fall on Dr. Hakim and take less blame themselves.
@@PrimalDragon1740 I thinks it totally intentional of him. He didn't encourage them, they only thought up the tear idea themselves, but I think he only allowed it to show that their problems can't be resolved that simply. Its the harshest lesson for them to learn. Like you said. The book is a real bro, and I'm disappointed people thought he was annoying when he was just doing his job honestly
Cody & may when murdering cutie: WE SORRY WE HAVE TO DO THIS rose crying when they killed a innocent child: WOOOOOO WE DID IT- HEY WHY ISNT SOME MOURNING WORKING DAMNIT THAT SUCKSSS
This is literally the most horrific thing I’ve ever done in a video game, far surpassing the GTAV torture scene and the No Russian level of MW2. To force the players to enact this torture to a sweet helpless character as they literally beg you to stop is the most vile and traumatic experience I’ve ever faced in a video game. Playing with my girlfriend, we have refused to play the game further, simply because the characters have quickly become the most unlikable characters I’ve ever been forced to play as. Not only did they torture murder a helpless elephant as she begged them to stop, all in an effort to make their daughter cry, but they then feel no remorse for making their daughter cry and instead LITERALLY. DANCE. IN. HER. TEARS.
i felt so bad. me and my sister almost cried, we felt genuinely so bad. she didnt even call guards or anything. i feel so bad- thank god she got fixed.. but its depressing. especially how rose reacted.
Breaks a part of the former child of me. I have a Teddy Bear that i got on the day of my birth, some 30+ years ago. I know very well how important it was to me as a child and it frankly still is. The thought of it coming alive and being murdered just turns my stomach. It´s like innocence and love incarnate got curb stomped.
This was just terrible. I could not believe that they would do it. Now I have a deep feeling of guilt for this. Just curious on who wrote this part of scenario.
It seems there should have been some dedicated cutscenes and/or gameplay to make up for this one: 1. Parents realizing they're being awful selfish people at their daughter's expense 2. Parents redeeming themselves through several acts of kindness and selflessness 3. Repair the elephant, and profusely apologize to Rose while starting to fix the damage they've inflicted on her. Through proper parenting and therapy.
I think alot of people are missing the point of this scene. Yes what they did was wrong and THAT'S THE POINT. Hakim has stated many MANY times, the only way to turn back is to rekindle their relationship, not once did he ever hint that Cutie was the solution. The fact that Cody and May refuse to take his advice shows how stubborn they are at first and how they slowly start to understand Hakim's actions.
I thought that at least I wouldn't die in vain ... but seeing that Rose's tears didn't break the spell and that we killed cutie for nothing ... made my sister and I feel like cruel monsters. :(
This is very creative in a way that yet, feels so dark. You don't need effects to make it horrific and tragic, just the emotion that is like jeepers crust.
What makes me upset is that they barely even thought twice about killing Cutie. In the process of literally trying to murder her, they say they feel bad and will need therapy and whatnot, yet they never hesitate or stop. They were only sad when they realized that the tears didn't turn them back to normal, and not about torturing and murdering a cute lil elephant. Or the fact that they made their daughter cry for no reason, and that they were joyful when she did. The game just kinda makes the characters go "well, shit. That didn't work" and never truly reflect on the severity and horror of what they just did. They just brought out the funny-looking book guy and said "oh well time to move on to the next puzzle." Knowing this happens has been one of the biggest turn-offs I've ever had towards a video game. I will *never* touch this game, nor will I watch anyone play it.
I ended up playing through the game with my little nephew who is in 2nd grade. I felt so bad cuz he started tearing up when we started dragging her towards the edge. He closed his eyes when we let her go. I felt so bad.
This is incredible. How could they make such a game, one filled with cuteness and love, while including in it a scene such as this, one filled with horror and torture?
because the people who are behind the creation of this game have certain goals and one of them is to kill humanity and simply everything good in people and also make them suffer. This is possible if a person again and again does something that his conscience makes him suffer because of the actions he has committed (as for example in this scene). Thus, each time the figurative heart or conscience becomes coarser and over time a person stops feeling (I think now it has become more clear why some call themselves Dead Inside because they stop feeling anything, in other words they become depressed) and also perceive cruelty as such and in to please his own desires, he is ready to do the most cruel acts that he could not even imagine. That's why almost all of today's entertainment contains the "poison" of violence and cruelty everywhere you look. But the good news is that anyone can recover.
And they even consider Cutie as a Boss Level? the atmosphere just change so fast. Tbh i was tearing up what they did to Cutie.i mean who the hell told them killing Cutie was the Cure anyway. This is frustrating😡😠
The fact that in the credits, Cutie had been repaired implies that the toys don't really die, if she was actually alive. But that would mean that she spent hours without an leg and one of her ears torn off, and also got to hear the people who killed her celebrate and dance in the tears of the one person she loved dearly.
this shit is fucked up
I actually have a theory maybe the parents ripping her up was symbolic of the parents divorce hurting the girl
@@debbiewong6539 makes sense
@@debbiewong6539 I think that make sense because they didn't even care that their daughter is crying and her favorite toy is ripped they just wanted to go back to normal
Facts
Pointless game.
Killed their daughter's favorite toy and then literally bathed in her tears
Parents of the year ladies and gentleman
That was the joke
@@kidcoma1340 a joke that most people didn't find funny
They thought that since her tears where what caused them to be stuck in this predicament in the first place, it would get them back to their bodies. But of course it didn’t work, and thus Hakim has to step in and remind them the only way to get back to reality is to fix what’s broken, their relationship.
Disgusting
@@christophersudbrink4946 yeah yeah we all know the context, what I'm saying is despite the weird things happening, it would take MASSIVE mental gymnastics to conclude all that needs to happen to break the cursed is for her to cry on them again, no strings attached? Also doesn't it say a lot about them that they don't even flinch at the idea of making their daughter cry, or like ever second guess themselves about the morality of things, not even a comment about how maybe what they're doing is wrong, whether it helps them or not. My point is, I don't care what they thought they're shitty parents for basically bullying their daughter to help themselves out of a situation they stuck themselves in in the first place.
The fact she still tried to be their friends even though they ripped off her leg and ear poor cutie she didn’t deserve that
the jump rope line makes me so sad
@@cheri8832 I KNOW ITS SO SAD EVEN THOUGH SHE IS BEING MURDERED SHE STILL WANTS TO PLAY JUMP ROPE
This is so fk up
Yep really fucked up
stupid god dam elephant i wish you could had messed up her more
The voice actress for Cutie nailed it, you really need to be good at acting to make everyone feel THIS bad.
The begging and crying really sounds innocent, desperate and scared, it’s just so good
Not really the scene was supposed to be a funny
@@mydogghost Well it wasn't
Fun fact: It’s the same actress who voices Horrid Henry (Lizzie Waterworth-Santo)
@@mydogghostIt really wasn’t supposed to be funny, they just threw humor in there to lighten the blow. Even the music goes weird once the murder starts.
@@TomLegend101the fact that I can hear it 😭 Idk if you’ve ruined this for me or made it better
"I dont want to die!"
"I know, but the writers couldn't think of anything a sane person would do to make a child cry."
The whole point is that the parents are that selfish with each other and they don't want to find other alternatives to get out of their predicament
hard to be sane when you're a doll lol
So true, they could’ve tried cutting onions or something, would’ve been way more practical and less…sad
@@viliamsmigel821 oh yes, a knive in a childrens room
This wouldn't be so bad if Cody and May came to a realization that they made Rose cry for no reason and start having some self relfection on what their daughter's feeling, especially after seeing the toy that's comforting her through the divorce is all ripped up, but they don't.
Dr Hakim is truly the villain
Agreed
Can I get an explanation on WHY they are supposed to kill her though?
@@ImALombax because they wanted to turn back to normal and they believed that what turned them to dolls would be the same thing that would turn the, back (aka their daughters tears)
iirc they realize how much their shit affects their kid and apologize to her
The fact that the elephant was just trying to have a tea, to just escape; then to plead for her life and finally get ripped apart before falling to her death. Was just...to graphic that I would be surprised if someone doesn't feel horrible just to watch it.
Playing with my girlfriend, after both eating an edible, I literally broke down crying half way through. I had to pause the game because of how horrible I felt. Literally the only thing that pushed me to finish this part is the idea that the game would force me to start the whole scene over later, if I had just turned it off.
@@19reaperassassn85 1. Was it a weed edible or a LSD edible
2. Don't go blind on movies, shows, games or other forms of media while high, any emotions created by a scene will be multiply from the drug
It's didn't help that she sounds like she is young either
I did
@@19reaperassassn85 is this what men have become? LMFAO
If it makes you feel any better the Elephant is fixed at the end credits
It does a little, but it's still sad. And she didn't even fight back the poor thing
She just wants to play and have some tea.
It really dosnt because
It still remembers😞
Thank God
She's traumatized
I really applaud the devs for putting this into the game. The fact that the characters willingly killed an innocent and then tried to bathe in the tears of their own child to break their curse really shows what Narcissism is like.
Well. in interviews they express intent that it was supposed to be this monty pthon moment andi nstead it just kinda... showcased hwo blindly selfish they both were.
As gruesome as this was, this scene was really important at showing they didn't understand how their actions affected their daughter. Going as far to make her cry without realizing the consequences. I was legitimately upset with the parents as I played through this section
Can't believe we all witnessed one of the most goriest death scene in video history without any blood or mutilation.
The beauty of a creative mind.
The sick imagination of the mind of man, to create pleasure in the suffering of others, or to do it just because
Like Pooh said:”Oh Bother.”
@@gregoriocosino9852 cry about it, among us player
@@billybobthelandlord2790 ok and? 1. It's ok to cry and 2. Among Us is a great game.
This was the most depressing thing I ever had to do in a video game. Almost cried. Felt like killing a child or something.
pretty much
i felt like it was like that when I witnessed it
yeah but at least enemy children are jerks in video games
Yeah I get that feeling when I’m sad, always cheers me up afterwards though.
Weak and effeminated
Cutie's death is gruesome, but i believe this all links to rose's psyche: her childlike innocence has beem stripped away from her directly by her parents actions. While they never fought in front of her, they still hurt her to a depressed degree: to a point where rose blames herself for her parents disagreements.
Woah....thats deep.
That's exactly what I thought. Everyone thinks this scene was just a random act of sadism, but the symbolism is very apparent for the emotional ordeal of divorce. However, it is still a very sad scene.
The music on top of this too
The writers probably didn’t expect people to identify with a toy elephant so much. There are a lot of clues that this was meant to be just a dark joke (with obvious implications about the parents).
The whole buildup. „I know how we become humans again... we make her cry!“
Huh, I never thought of it that way, but it's still terrible, and I hate it
After this scene I failed to empathize with the two main characters for the rest of the game. I really never got over it and it honestly kind of ruined the rest of the story for me. I think that's just a testament to how well crafted this scene is.
Me too
Perfectly explained how I feel
by "well" you mean horrible? Yeah, this game is shit now
@Cronotriggered Not me, I empathized with them the whole way. They were forced to become clay figures by a book some guy wrote & there kid has no one to look after her when they were clay.
they were shit (obvious) before this scene, how anyone even can empathize with them, but this is the main idea of the game. how bad people may become better
"I feel so evil"
I think the world is telling you to stop what you're doing at that point
6:58
*May:* "Oh no... Oh gosh..."
*Me:* Oh shit, she's starting to realize what they've just done. Time for character development!
*May:* "We're stuck like this!"
*Me:* ...I hate these characters.
same, in special may
Didn't the development came later in the game? Besides it's they fixed her in the ending
Adults taking tears not seriously and hurting their children.. I think the devs did this in purpose.
Yep, horrible
@@gregoriocosino9852 hey at least they fixed her
They could have asked the elephant what else makes her cry instead of killing her. Then explain the situation to the elephant, she'd actually be happy to help.
Yes! That could have been better!!!
I think that's the point as well, the parents never even try to talk things out rationally, they just act on whatever suits their selfish interest.
@@badoe7138 Exactly. Up to this point, instead of talking out their problems, they see a divorce as the only solution to the problem. This scene reflects that.
@@badoe7138 parents of the year
And if Cutie asked “Why do you want to make her cry?” They could respond with something like how they want to prevent the things that make her cry
She wasn't hurting anyone, she just wanted to play
This is may and Cody mistakes that they thought rose’s tear will give they back to real body but not
Haha elephant body parts go brrrrr
I know right!!!!!!?????? She was such a cute and kind hearted spirit that wanted to make friends and people happy, and they killed her!!!!!!! that's why I don't like this game!!!!!!!!! If they brought back to life in the end that would've been nice.
@@ketanmay8469 She's fixed in the end credits. Honestly I think this scene is important as it shows how the May and Rose were looking at their own problems and being so wrapped up in how to solve them the easy way (divorcing, murdering Cutie to force tears from Rose) that they didn't see just how much they were hurting the poor girl, or look for other solutions that would require more effort.
@@ketanmay8469 lol i make a camp fire out of her remains ez
I am not lying when I say I was full on SOBBING during this scene. I loved Cutie so much. She was one of my favorite characters. To hear her cry, and scream, and beg for her life just broke my heart. And to make it worse, Cutie was the one thing comforting Rose during all of this, yet the parents just killed her, watched their daughter cry, felt absolutely no remorse, and were angry instead of upset when they realized that their daughter's tears did nothing. This was one of the most gory and brutal scenes I've ever seen in a game, and there wasn't even any blood.
Outside the uncomfortable murder of an cute elephant. I like how they destroy their daughters favourite toy then literally bathe in her tears, then read a note from her blaming herself for the divorce, and there's no self-reflection at all.
I have watched many Death Scenes, but this is just psychological evil.
Worst than the villains in the games I know.
Exsctly like I usually feel nothing but now im sad and have a lingering feeling of guilt
THEY SHOULD BE RIPPED APART AND BURNED ALIVE
Ik right like this is on par with some of the most horrible deaths, the music doesn't help either
It will be fixed it is a toy even tho it is kinda sad
its so weird how the parents are just like YES YES OUR DAUGHTER IS CRYING YESSSSSSS
The parents were so focused in their divorce that they ignored the fact that their daughter's taking the hit too.
And they were selfish.
That's how adults were, sometimes so selfish... sooooo selfish
@New Blue I feel you haha
Parenting 100
If that the case then
There not ready to child parenting get that kid to CPS right now
At least in the end credits cutie is repaired but that doesn’t excuse the fact that they showed no remorse for any of there actions.
Same peter i feel the same.
not gonna lie, had a really bad day, watched this video, felt way worse. thankfully your comment fixed that worse part, thanks!
@@jaxendale7864 when I said cutie is repaired you see stitches and duck tape on cutie so when I saw that I was relieved to see cutie fixed
@@noahgonzalez5705 thanks, I went ahead and found the shot itself, again ty for the comment.
@@jaxendale7864 same. Literally had to brush mats out of my hair which hurt so bad I cried, found a dying dog and called the owner who said throw the collar in the garbage and leave the body there which made me sob, and then this scene sent me into a crying fit
"Everything is fuzzy."
That hit me. Poor thing doesn't know the feeling of dying because it never had to.
Parents thinking of themselves instead of what a child thinks.
The part that makes it disturbing is when may says “kill her” the music distorts
And the closer you get to the edge the music distortion gets more intense
She apologized to cutie for getting hurt just like she apologizes for the bad relationship her parents have and she wants to fix both
Basically she thinks everything bad happening is her fault
We need therapy, but Rose needs it even more
and her parents are so self-absorbed that they just ignore that they hurt their daughter so much
The fact that her parents are so ignorant nd ignored how much emotional damage they’ve influcted to their daughter 🙁
Tell me about it.
Just like any kid in its early life.
Omg they killed cutie because they thought it will break the spell.
That is very DARK, so much very Dark
Without context, this is really evil
VERY fucking dark
This is darker than my soul
And it's creepy how the music changed when she landed in the claw machine
😭😭😭😭😭
@@jacksoninc.4062 We did this last night ...with context is was bloody dark!....I felt awful after it haha
It's not fair! Cutie is such a sweet, kind, and lovable character and she had to be killed, and the fact that Cody and May killed her for, basically, nothing makes her demise even more upsetting.😭
To quote Dave Lister after witnessing the execution of Winnie the Pooh.
"That's something no one should ever have to see..."
He's refusing the blindfold.
Cutie needs a damn hug. I absolutely hate that someone so sweet and undeserving of death, had to die a brutal, fruitless death. Nothing was gained here.
I'm having flashbacks to another game.
@Nolan Connolly it's 2 characters... if i you want to know more i will say the first word of their name or their entire name(which i don't recommend) because your gonna hate the other character.
@@Iamnotaspy. just say it
@@123newjersey3 fine! M- m- mo- Mon- Mono and Six from little nightmares! 2!
@@Iamnotaspy. oh frick yup I remember that sad ending
Me: goes to therapist
Therapist: what's wrong?
Me: i saw two dolls brutaly kill a toy eleplant
Therapist: now I need therapy
Edit: My grammar was bad so I fixed it.
Why is this underated
THE CIRCLE OF LIFE 🎶🎶
The Therapist will get another Therapist to fix their problems just to have their Therapist need another Therapist. The cycle continues..
@@chypethechilean OMG HOW
Therapy for ALL 💅✨
“You don’t have to do this.. I love Rose.” Falls to death.
*hears loud shattering*
What the hell did someone throw a rock through my window!? Oh god it’s my heart shattered 💔
The dark side of Toy Story
Me,too...😢.
And when when she pleads for rose to help rose can’t hear her
It felt like she was a poor, innocent, kind child
...I'm a terrible person but the first thing that came to mind is "Long Live the King"
Cutie: * Screaming in pain due to the fact her ear was literally stabbed *
The dad: she’s tricking us! Tug on her leg harder so she can feel even more pain!
I wish I had a Cutie the Elephant now. Just so I could take care of her and wash this memory away. Please, this is actually the worst thing I've ever done.
Worst part is that she's either fixed but dead or fixed but traumatised. She deserved so much better.
She's fixed but traumatized
The interesting thing about this scene, what makes this so disturbing, is the confrontation between the identity of the player characters (the parents) and the real point of view the game leads you to have: the childhood's vision of suffering. From the beggining of the game to this point, you try to immerse yourself as one of the parents. You get attached to the characters, with their personalities and flaws, and get involved into THEIR situation, THEIR relationship, THEIR marriage. Until that point in the game, Rose is not the subject of the story. She rather seems to be a TOOL they need to solve THEIR problems. At no point they really thought of Rose's suffering as if it was the cause of the problem they were trying to solve.
There is a time for the characters to learn something. They are clearly not ready to understand how selfish they are at this point of the game. They have much more work to do on that! But there is also a time for the players to learn a message or a morale, and here, what we all learned is that the suffering of a child is not less important than anyone else's just because they are children. From their point of view, they could live irremediable experiences, as their innocence is constantly threatened of being butchered by the cruelty of life, especially if their parents aren't helping them but contributing to ruin their childhood.
Cutie the Elephant was Rose's innocence. And her parents mercilessly killed it, believing it was "not that important", because obviously, their grown-up problems were "so much more important"!
And just to make it clear, I am not defending the parents' actions! I almost cried playing this and am still in shock. Maybe I'm overanalyzing the scene, but it is my way to release the pressure. Overall, I believe this is brilliant writing. Risky and bold, but brilliant. The developers took the bet of giving us all trauma to make us feel what it is like for a child to suffer of being ripped of his innocence, and I believe it worked... Maybe too much!
I would say this enters in the territory of "gone horribly right"
@@julianmartinez4719 agreed
According to the head writer, it was supposed to be darkly comedic, like something out of Monty Python. They failed miserably in that regard.
@@gantz22ify I'd say they massively succeded. The sharp contrast in the scene's action and the parents' reaction is exactly that dark comedic tone you describe.
Idk a lot about Monty Python, so I can't compare it to that, though.
@@JustAnthon nah man, dark comedy makes you laugh, not feel bad and drop down to cry :'(
it get sadder when she hides in her ears after her leg got ripped off I've never seen a mom and dad so happy to make there daughter cry
Their*
They thought they were going back to their real bodies by having Rose cry on them, but it didn’t work.
@@christophersudbrink4946 Yeah, and after that? They're just disappointed, not horrified at what they had to do to accomplish nothing. Then they move on to the next clue without showing remorse for what they did to both Rose and Cutie. No wonder Hakim said they hadn't earned it.
@@korsekil yes. And it’s then that they finally realize that they need to work out and fix their relationship.
@@christophersudbrink4946 Yeah they have a LOT to work out, not just for their sake but Rose, considering how selfish they were in this scene.
Just seeing her desperately grab at any and everything she passed REALLY drove home how truly dark this scene was...
It was rad af
@@comedy6631 you mean sad?
@@Barondelculo RAD
Too bad this scene is completely pointless. No, really; I'm wracking my brain trying to see any reason as to why this was even remotely necessary, and I got nothing.
@@Jaceblue04 except that it's absolutely RAAAAADDDD!!!
I was playing this because a friend invited me to play. I was slow to drag the elephant to the edge and I felt absolutely shitty doing everything to get to the edge. I felt sadness and hatred for the characters. When they felt no remorse after noticing the tears didn't break the curse, I quit. "These are shit parents and they are undeserving of anything good in their lives. Fuck this game." was my response before I left the Discord voice chat and went to bed absolutely angry.
lmao i don't imagine that friend asks you to do anything with them anymore
That would be my reaction too ngl.
“We’re stuck like this!” Good: i hope you stay that way FOREVER! It’s what you deserve!
Jesus, the parents are the real villains in this game!
They did feel bad about doing it though.
No may say “This is horrible I feel so evil”
And the real villain (in my opinion) is da stupid talking book because he want may and cody kill cutie
@@hayrahdeptrai29 true
@@hayrahdeptrai29 I mean, not really, it was cody who thought crying would save em, not hakim
So they murder a poor, innocent loving stuffed animal who was completely undeserving of such cruelty and then _happily_ bathe in the tears of the daughter whose heart they willingly break?
If the game allowed it, I’d probably have these terrible excuses for parents thrown in a furnace instead.
Do you know why they did it?
@@lossantoscustoms4664 why
@@Savageboy726 the parents are destroying something their daughter loves to make her cry and having their daughters tears rain on the dolls to turn back into their real bodies, unfortunately that didn't help
Lol they’d just respawn 😂
If I had my way, I’d give these two horrible parents to Sid in Toy Story before Woody scared him just so he’d turn them into abominations while feeling extreme pain in the process. I think that they deserve to be tortured and ripped apart and then reassembled into monsterous forms.
I thought this was supposed to be a cutesy type of game, not Spec Ops: The Line.
Spec Ops: PG version
Im dead😂😂😂
“Do you feel like a hero yet?”
Do You feel like a parent yet?
Do you feel like a good game developer now?
I sobbed for a whole hour after playing this scene. And it got worse after finding out they didnt even have to kill her
4:54 that little noise is heartbreaking
Yeah, she really reminded me of trump when she did that.
@@monkeyheist lol
I'll need therapy after this
same
Me too
Yes
Get it from that magic book
WE ALL NEED THERAPY!!!!!
I feel so sorry for that poor elephant... :(
I really do.
Good thing all of that was a dream so she never died
So am i
@@randomplushiesigues52 that's spoiler?
@@kandade4563 SHIT NOOOOOO IM A MONSTER
@@randomplushiesigues52 Wait is it true? Please I need to know that Cutie is ok she’s so precious 🥺
I cried my eyes out while I watched my boyfriend play this part, she was just wanting to be friends and play but instead they did all this to her, I understand they were trying to break the spell but to see cutie call for rose and to seeing her cry and be torn a part broke my heart.
a very effective way of depicting how divorce tears apart the family/child
This scene made my fiance and I stop playing. We thought the parents were already really unlikeable characters, but it became impossible to root for them after that. Felt very unnecessary and just pissed us off really.
Love how even after they see it didn’t work
They are like “meh”
You just tortured someone and make them plead for mercy and bathed on the tears of you crying daughter
The fuk
Sorry but at that moment I wish I didn’t played those characters
@PRchris13 They were forced to become clay figures by a book some guy wrote & there kid has no one to look after her when they were clay.
Plus none of the stuffed animals are alive, the book was just using magic.
@@kijanajenkins2546 a parent cares for their kid
Yes they became toys and are forced to find a way out
But that doesn’t justify that they should abandon the idea of caring for their child or if the child gets hurt (mentally, emotional or physically) irl they shouldn’t care
Like they broke the favorite toy of the daughter and it made her cry
It failed and yes it was a bad thing it didn’t worked
But damn they didn’t even showed a emotion of “oh shit we forced our innocent daughter to cry out of sadness and she is all alone now without nobody to support her”
Like I would also get wha you say if they weren’t alone or didn’t involved their daughter
But they did involve her and after what they did to her they hardly cared
Like at this point they could hurt her and I bet they would be like “god damn it we didn’t turn normal”
@@PRchris13 I can agree to that.
I think what is more messed up about this is that the parents broke their promise to the astronaut monkey and made the daughter cry
It’s okay guys she’s not dead forever. They fixed her
It doesn’t forgive her suffering tho.
This was fucked up in a way that Jigsaw, the Human Centipede and other far more bloody franchises cannot comprehend
I just played this section of the game and I cried the entire time. Im a stuffed animal lover, Cutie just hit home for me because shes the kind of toy I would have definitely loved to have as a child :(
Yooo, when I got to this part of the game, my heart just dropped. It made it even worse knowing that Cutie actually died for nothing
At the end in the vredits they out her back togethee but shes still dead😭😰😢😔
At least Cutie was repaired
Edit: Ok, but Cutie's suffering is still horrible
@@Cinnamonrollsvr Cutie isn’t dead, she was repaired.
@@RobGordonJC that doesn’t mean what happened to her was any better. She literally suffered (most likely mentally as well as physically) for no reason
@@theotheseaeagle Agreed, watching her get slowly eviscerated was heartbreaking to watch.
But at least she’s alive, likely still in pain, but alive.
She’s with Rose, so she’ll be loved till Rose gets older and matures away from her toys.
When she said everything is fuzzy my heart dropped 😩😭
Sounded like she was getting weaker by the second
Press F to pay respect towards Queen Cutie
F
F
F
F
F
My brother and I just played this part and couldn't stop freaking out! Half way through my brother said "WHERE'S THE BOOK!?!? WHY ISN'T HE STOPPING US!?!? WHAT THE FU-"
and you know the rest.
We just thought it would be a shove off the top and it would shift to Rose's perspective as she hit the ground but NOOOOOOOO AMPUTATION AND THEN YOU SHOVE HER OFF WITH YOUR FOOT!!!
Also I swear if the world had background music like in this scene there'd be way less crime worldwide
@@voidwalker5784 Background music was even more unsettling than anything else. U can hear the childhood being stripped away in it.
And I absolutely HATE the book even more now, he could've done something.
4:32 more like your child is going to need therapy after this
I think this whole scene with Queen Cutie tells how parents think that one solution would fix their problems w/ their children, only to make the situation even worse. This is especially true since Dr. Hakim (the book) tried to coerce the two to make Rose cry by killing Queen Cutie. Not thinking of any other way of making Rose cry, they just went with Dr. Hakim's suggestion because it was EASIER for the weight of responsibility to fall on Dr. Hakim and take less blame themselves.
What?! They thought of it themselves. The good doctor didn't do anything except sell them out to her guards trying to stop them.
@@PrimalDragon1740 The book is the best character in the game I tell you
@@ringkunmori And I don't disagree
@@ringkunmori I was just saying that he really had no real part in helping the parents kill the elephant
@@PrimalDragon1740 I thinks it totally intentional of him. He didn't encourage them, they only thought up the tear idea themselves, but I think he only allowed it to show that their problems can't be resolved that simply. Its the harshest lesson for them to learn. Like you said.
The book is a real bro, and I'm disappointed people thought he was annoying when he was just doing his job honestly
1:57 that song pitch change was scary and sad at the same time
Ikr
Cody & may when murdering cutie: WE SORRY WE HAVE TO DO THIS
rose crying when they killed a innocent child: WOOOOOO WE DID IT- HEY WHY ISNT SOME MOURNING WORKING DAMNIT THAT SUCKSSS
4:27 that’s because you two *are* evil
The fact that at the beginning she told them you dont need to bow
This is literally the most horrific thing I’ve ever done in a video game, far surpassing the GTAV torture scene and the No Russian level of MW2. To force the players to enact this torture to a sweet helpless character as they literally beg you to stop is the most vile and traumatic experience I’ve ever faced in a video game. Playing with my girlfriend, we have refused to play the game further, simply because the characters have quickly become the most unlikable characters I’ve ever been forced to play as. Not only did they torture murder a helpless elephant as she begged them to stop, all in an effort to make their daughter cry, but they then feel no remorse for making their daughter cry and instead LITERALLY. DANCE. IN. HER. TEARS.
Even I was like what the fuck type of parents are you even before they were at the castle they promised the moon baboon not to make her cry
Kkkkkkk
Agree with every your word
*wheeze* AND THEY NEVER FIXED HER
@@waterlily7075 the cutie is fixed in the credits
I was watching a streamer when this part came on. The entire chat started calling them a murderer and screamed stop.
i felt so bad. me and my sister almost cried, we felt genuinely so bad.
she didnt even call guards or anything. i feel so bad-
thank god she got fixed.. but its depressing.
especially how rose reacted.
Cody: I 'll need therapy after this.
I think you need amnesia after doing something like that
More like a lethal injection
When your stuff toys love you more than your parents.
Can we talk about 1:45, how precious the elephant is to the husband
Breaks a part of the former child of me. I have a Teddy Bear that i got on the day of my birth, some 30+ years ago.
I know very well how important it was to me as a child and it frankly still is.
The thought of it coming alive and being murdered just turns my stomach.
It´s like innocence and love incarnate got curb stomped.
This is just a master thesis to prove that you don't need blood, gore, or swearing to make a horrifying scene
So they just tortured, mutilated and killed a little innocent elephant; and they bathed in her daughter's tears afterwards? What the fuck.
LOL
So May and Cody entered Cutie's castle to asassinate her.
Assassins creed plush
In a brutal way
This was just terrible. I could not believe that they would do it. Now I have a deep feeling of guilt for this. Just curious on who wrote this part of scenario.
Josef Fares, who else? Its clearly his sadistic style :)
@@namjoonsgf41 we know but it still hit on the heart. Don't u have a heart or feelings?
@@namjoonsgf41 That makes you sound really heartless-
@@namjoonsgf41 no shit Sherlock, I thought it was a Shakespeare show. Thanks for opening my eyes
(I could not believe that they would do it)
1. FIXING THE CURE
2. THIS FEELS LIKE LIKE A TEEN GAME
3. THE CURSE WASN’T THE TEARS
“Do you feel like a hero yet?”
Spec ops is a great game
Your no savior your talents lay elsewhere
It seems there should have been some dedicated cutscenes and/or gameplay to make up for this one:
1. Parents realizing they're being awful selfish people at their daughter's expense
2. Parents redeeming themselves through several acts of kindness and selflessness
3. Repair the elephant, and profusely apologize to Rose while starting to fix the damage they've inflicted on her.
Through proper parenting and therapy.
This scene had no gore, no creepy atmosphere but it already makes my day really uncomfortable. ps Cutie is the best elephant doll
Fact: this part was more likely to make you cry than the end of the game.
not really I'm just seething with rage
The end is disgusting, this pair of fools don’t deserve no marriage and no family, they deserve to have their ears and legs torn off
I have seen many things in this cursed realm called the internet but rarely has something torn my soul to pieces like watching this.
kids game, sure. Is there a bad ending for the parents? Where they get teared to pieces by pet cat or dog?
I think alot of people are missing the point of this scene.
Yes what they did was wrong and THAT'S THE POINT.
Hakim has stated many MANY times, the only way to turn back is to rekindle their relationship, not once did he ever hint that Cutie was the solution.
The fact that Cody and May refuse to take his advice shows how stubborn they are at first and how they slowly start to understand Hakim's actions.
I thought that at least I wouldn't die in vain ... but seeing that Rose's tears didn't break the spell and that we killed cutie for nothing ... made my sister and I feel like cruel monsters.
:(
This is very creative in a way that yet, feels so dark. You don't need effects to make it horrific and tragic, just the emotion that is like jeepers crust.
I legit teard up of how cutie was killed like that Jesus Christ i didn't know i could cry for a fictional cute elephant but here we are...
It's not sad. It's plain sadistic.
What makes me upset is that they barely even thought twice about killing Cutie. In the process of literally trying to murder her, they say they feel bad and will need therapy and whatnot, yet they never hesitate or stop. They were only sad when they realized that the tears didn't turn them back to normal, and not about torturing and murdering a cute lil elephant. Or the fact that they made their daughter cry for no reason, and that they were joyful when she did.
The game just kinda makes the characters go "well, shit. That didn't work" and never truly reflect on the severity and horror of what they just did. They just brought out the funny-looking book guy and said "oh well time to move on to the next puzzle."
Knowing this happens has been one of the biggest turn-offs I've ever had towards a video game. I will *never* touch this game, nor will I watch anyone play it.
I ended up playing through the game with my little nephew who is in 2nd grade. I felt so bad cuz he started tearing up when we started dragging her towards the edge. He closed his eyes when we let her go. I felt so bad.
she literally said “that’s what friends are for”
I mean at least the main characters admitted that they needed therapy from a professional.
You know, it’s funny how happy the parents were to shower in the tears of her own daughter! YOUR OWN DAUGHTER!!!!!!!!
And they only care about them being stuck like that instead of felling bad about making rose cry
And yet this game won the family game award, and the GOTY 2021 award.
Yea because it's a good game.
3:47 the Sif limp has competition for the most "now I feel like an absolute irredeemable monster" moment in gaming.
i need so much therapy. this is so sad.
"I've lived too long to see myself to become the villain"
This is incredible. How could they make such a game, one filled with cuteness and love, while including in it a scene such as this, one filled with horror and torture?
How tf does this one scene make me more miserable than my years of dealing with depression
because the people who are behind the creation of this game have certain goals and one of them is to kill humanity and simply everything good in people and also make them suffer. This is possible if a person again and again does something that his conscience makes him suffer because of the actions he has committed (as for example in this scene). Thus, each time the figurative heart or conscience becomes coarser and over time a person stops feeling (I think now it has become more clear why some call themselves Dead Inside because they stop feeling anything, in other words they become depressed) and also perceive cruelty as such and in to please his own desires, he is ready to do the most cruel acts that he could not even imagine. That's why almost all of today's entertainment contains the "poison" of violence and cruelty everywhere you look. But the good news is that anyone can recover.
(5:22) "Long live the king"
*Dies*
And they even consider Cutie as a Boss Level? the atmosphere just change so fast. Tbh i was tearing up what they did to Cutie.i mean who the hell told them killing Cutie was the Cure anyway. This is frustrating😡😠
BLAME THE “LOVE” BOOK