@@user-fl8eu7nl3c actually this case is not about conviction of rapist rather its about government’s lack of action and doctor students safety, that’s why these matters are being raised. CBI is still doing its investigation regarding the actual matter.
Why this guy Kapil has the habit opening his mouth every second ? Can't he listen for some time? If he is team member in a a project, i would throw him out in no time. How is that india tolerated this person so long?
He behaves like all security measures have been installed already and all hospitals are safe now, if another such case happens will the Kolkata state & police take full responsibility?
Even as you hide one thing is crystal clear. You are jealous of TMC Govt operating in Kolkata because you are andhbhakt of Modi who Pays you Rs 2 per comment. That is ultimate truth. 😂😂😂
Yes milad we are doing it already doing it I am saying it. We are following the standard operating procedure to the teeth... Poor West Bengal people wasting their huge tax money to this rich man for this three sentences, and they are suffering in the rural side without even proper water sanitization food and medicine... If you don't know how to elect your leader you don't deserve democracy.. this is 100% true
Nation should bow their head down because of the arguments present in this case. Top court of our country is talking about rest rooms, CC TV's, basic security features. Supreme court level is reduced to a mere security discussion platform. Top Supreme court judges are discussing about these issues. It's a shame on our country. Kapil sibal is charging lakhs of rupees for arguments like this.
CJI one time personally visits & meets RG Kar hospital doctors he will get to know the truth & how TMC rules how Neglected such incidents accordingly he will give judgement also.
@@sriramvenkatraman Aper having no sanity of his mind could not assess the thing otherwise he could not in a laughing approch '"it's an instance of common place." For money power he is got lost. This type of brutal crime is paramount only for this type of inhuman personalities who have no care for the society.
Rape culprits are later first of all the ones who tampered evidence and why, under whose order needs to be find out. This isn't a normal rape case but a huge plot & conspiracy from the top worked.
Such a fine CJI ... and his panel . love them . Wonder Why WB government needs to be told what to be done ? If they are genuine , their swift reaction should have installed confidence among the young doctors. it's a point to introspect for WB govt ..
Sibal needs a lot of counseling as to how he shoulf behave in the SC of India.I find his behaviour rather overbearing and objectionable!He talks like Lord Shiva!
Rightly said Brother but don't compare him with Lord Shiva, even if Sibal tries every other trick up d sleeves he & his Team incl d Lady will ALWAYS REMAIN a Devil's Advocate
Introduce bio metric access and appoint Security personnel first. Then ask them to join work. Mr. Sibal, You were waiting for a ghastly happening like this horrendous rape and ghastly murder to introduce these elementary safety requirements?
Even as you hide one thing is crystal clear. You are jealous of TMC Govt operating in Kolkata because you are andhbhakt of Modi who Pays you Rs 2 per comment. That is ultimate truth. 😂😂😂
KAPIL. SIBAL. ALWAYS. YESSS YOU ARE. RIGHT. WE. WILL. DO. IT HE IS SMART. IN SAYING. ANY DAM. THING. YA. YA. FAIR. ENOUGH. VERY. SMART IN DIVERTING. ARETHEY. REALLY. ON. GROUND. .
CJI: regular police is not doing their job, forget about good job. Cisf should train and send their trained personnel on govt records...not some private trained goons. Docs want safety, not more of corrupt police
Why is Kapil allowed to respond with "Right", "Yes" following every sentence from CJI. Who is the judge and who is arguing ? Confused... Kapil must learn to carefully listen to others with silence and then to respond in his turn. How can such a show run at the proceedings of the Apex court ?
In West Bengal there are 28 Govt. Medical College ( including one AIIMS in Kalyani) and 9 private Medical colleges ( some of which are in PPP MODE). Therefore , there are 37 Medical Colleges in West Bengal. And not 47. I think the state counsel is always saying yes as per the nos of medical colleges concerned.
The greedy scoundrel with sheer hubris behaves as if he is above the honourable CJI. The body language and swiftness with which he agrees for the important security measures ? Quite clearly indicates he is making a mockery of it. ‘Absolutely’ nothing or some jugad !!!
This guy Kapil Sibbal is smart enough to mislead the Supreme Court with different issues which are not directly related with the rape case. It looks that the court is running as per his convenience.
Yes yes absolutely we agree mi lord. I agree will do everything. What a liar For last 50 years your eyes are not open to crimes and fraud sibbal. Your are rather keeping your eyes open to look for opportunities to fight case for them. Sab idhar hi reh jayega Upar kya jawab doge my lord ko?
Why the CJI is lenient towards Kapil Sipil? Number of assistants around him. Can a normal citizen can afford such extravaganza? Can 6:59 these judges hear common men, who can afford to hire a junior lawyer's argument?
Look at the audacity of Kapil sibbal. CJI while addressing, the way he tried to put his word onto CJI is a very mischievous way and against the decorum of court. Very very wrong... Shame.
Kapil sibbal is real judge. What ever sibbal says, CJI will accept & the truth submission by other advocates will be over looked. I am sure sibbal will win the case, CJI is forced to order in his favour.
Absolutely glad the CJI can see the vital need for security for the young medical force that joined so enthusiastically to serve people and are treated so badly by the Health Ministry... Without a thought for their basic needs. The legal aide for the Govt appears to be gaslighting. almost 50 days have passed and he is asking for two more weeks to even formulate a policy... By not a thorough security policy should have been in place to assure that all doctors and patients are safe... Even the morgue seems unsafe presently
What a mockery is going on. ALL these points discussed are live data facts that state Govt is utterly failed and CJI is simply giving a Short term and Long Term solutions. Sibbal is liaison of the law at Supreme Court.
Being a senior advocate does Mr Sibbal have any manner ? not to cut off CJ while talking? CJ gives him time and space to speak & never cut -off Mr Sibbal's speech; however I see senior advocates & legal scholars have no mannerism during hearings.... they cut each other and no patience to wait till other speaker completes their speech!!!! Is it a civilized way of discussion!?
🙏🤔Their should be an audit of this swo or muto how much money did this thing cost the Indian taxpayers and the supreme courts time and money, we know that Mr Sb turned a rape and murder case into installing cctv cameras. MiLords when there is another incident like this in future for sure there will be, and no recording will be found because that’s what is going to happen then the CJI will ask why only the cctv cameras were not powered 24/7. Mark my words. Next rape case we will decide the operation of all these security cameras to be recording 24/7 And Next rape case we will discuss to power all these cameras with dual power. Next rape case we will discuss who is responsible for making sure all the cctv cameras are all recording and are powered. What about the rape and murder case?😡
What actions are completed regarding the security of youngsters? If not by what date and time they will complete. I feel ashamed when I hear that Mr Sibbal says the word - everything, all.
Sibal is speaking with half the information! Women police are under training. But doesn't know what's the training period. Cc cameras information also is this...that... horrendous!
Om Hon'ble Justice CJI is so sympathetic and study in depth the sufferings of Doctors in Governmeñt Hospitals and has pulled up the WB government to its failures to ensure safety. And securityof Doctors in GH Sich fscciliies should have been provided from day one of the opening of Hospitals Government'failuted to take care of their doctors tanamount to derelictikm of their assigned duties 😊
Besides 35 hospitals of modern medicine, there are Homoeopathic and Ayurveda medical colleges in West Bengal having lady students, doctors, their rest room and hostels. From hostel to hospital there is variable distance of about 500 meters. Besides lady students doctors there are lady nurses, attendants, safai workers mostly young or middle aged. Unless they feel safe they will not work. Patient care is a team work. Doctors alone can not do any thing.
Sir, Instalation of cameras is not sufficient. Wherever lady Doctors are working they must Post atleast more than 2 lady security personnel at each room or hall or lady toilets etc.,
Granted, medical colleges in India should be privided with enough security to protect the life of doctors, medical students, and patients.That said, which medical colleges anywhere in India have the kind of security the honorable CJ is asking for?
The case has moved away from the point of rape and murder
Exactly and behaving like they are gonna solve each issues just now than solving the rape issue
Absolutely correct. Rape and murder is.pushed under carpet and wasting time on other issues.
@@user-fl8eu7nl3c actually this case is not about conviction of rapist rather its about government’s lack of action and doctor students safety, that’s why these matters are being raised. CBI is still doing its investigation regarding the actual matter.
True...people have now forgotten who is Sanjay Roy.
I am also worried
Real culprit will never get punished
Sad states of affairs in our country 😢
CJI Chandrachud is behaving like a Lawyer and Sibal behaving like Judge😂
Yes. Fully agreed Not only that CJI makes it more technical rather than punishing police & political personnel from TMC.
Absolutely 😂😂😂
KAPIL SIBAL PROVED HIS ROGUE CHARACTER. AN ADVOCATE FOR EXTREMISTS SEPARATIST AND RAPISTS AND ILLEGITIMATE GOVT OFFICIALS AND CORRUPT POLITICIANS
I pity your understanding of legal process.
That's because CJI is an experienced lawyer too. He had practised law before becoming a Judge.
Why this guy Kapil has the habit opening his mouth every second ? Can't he listen for some time? If he is team member in a a project, i would throw him out in no time. How is that india tolerated this person so long?
CJI is Kapils friend. Both are ......
Because he thinks hes a friend and privileged..
Its similar to Pappu / Gandhian syndrome
He is great in misleading mylord.
He is doing his duty....you don't know basics in your are commenting....😮
He behaves like all security measures have been installed already and all hospitals are safe now, if another such case happens will the Kolkata state & police take full responsibility?
It's disgusting that every time,Sibal certifies CJ by saying "CORRECT"?
He thinks he has super power.
It need not be viewed as certification
Very near to GOD
This is a style of Chamchagiri , trying to nod nod and nod
Why fooling public by dragging unwanted things instead giving justice to departed young doctor....So sad.
Sibal and his vulture team
Only 21 vultures.
He is worst than crocodile
Mr Sibal showing his pose, posture , position and power to establish him above par. Practicality he is not so, having no sanity of mind !
He is just doing his job. You are focusing on the wrong guy while the culprits are free
Even as you hide one thing is crystal clear. You are jealous of TMC Govt operating in Kolkata because you are andhbhakt of Modi who Pays you Rs 2 per comment. That is ultimate truth. 😂😂😂
@@dc7916 Precisely the point. You are absolutely right ✅️
@@Maverick_Ideology 😂🤣
@@dc7916it is between Morality and proffession !!
Yes milad we are doing it already doing it I am saying it. We are following the standard operating procedure to the teeth... Poor West Bengal people wasting their huge tax money to this rich man for this three sentences, and they are suffering in the rural side without even proper water sanitization food and medicine... If you don't know how to elect your leader you don't deserve democracy.. this is 100% true
Being from Kolkata, I completely agree with you on this...
Thats why Mr Shashi Tharoor called this as Banana Republic .
we are doing it to the tee.
I hv completely lost faith in our legal system
It’s beyond hopeless
Nation should bow their head down because of the arguments present in this case. Top court of our country is talking about rest rooms, CC TV's, basic security features. Supreme court level is reduced to a mere security discussion platform. Top Supreme court judges are discussing about these issues. It's a shame on our country. Kapil sibal is charging lakhs of rupees for arguments like this.
I hope the respected CJI realises that such remedies are needed for medical colleges throughout the country.
He says'eye opener'.But even if eyes wide open,he can't see good,right things.
Just see how Sibal is cunningly manuvouring and avoiding responsibilities!
Why these standards didn't?
How mr kapil telling lie without knowing anything...
I think he is misleading the case and as the result no quick justice for the Indian daughter!!!!!!! Pl. Do justice as quick as possible 🙏🙏
It’s greatness of Kapil diverting arguments what is other side lawyers doing hope not sleeping
Isn't it duty of CJI & other SC J'S sitting on d chair to SHOW Sibal his True place & NOT GET carried away by fake, sweet statements
We agree we agree
Quality audit. Outcome will be zero other than in paper
Big blow to Kapil Sibbal arguments. Kapil Sibbal interpretation of law did not work well with CJI.
CJI one time personally visits & meets RG Kar hospital doctors he will get to know the truth & how TMC rules how Neglected such incidents accordingly he will give judgement also.
He must visit the hospital n look at what 18yr olds are going through
@@sriramvenkatraman Aper having no sanity of his mind could not assess the thing otherwise he could not in a laughing approch '"it's an instance of common place." For money power he is got lost. This type of brutal crime is paramount only for this type of inhuman personalities who have no care for the society.
If these Lady lawyers have any respect towards womanhood, they should boycott Kapil Sibal.
They can go to any extent for money , who cares fir humanism.
CJI is also set by Sibbal
Ur set by bj party
@@dogsingh7985better than Sibal
@@dogsingh7985you are set by Con party
@@dogsingh7985 where does party came in picture ? I said abot CJI and Sibbal... Whole world knows sibbal is advicating for culprit.
In this type of System ... Can we hope for justice!!!!!!!
Honorable CJI
Please look into the institutional angle of this murder.
He won’t. He is blindfolded
Where is the argument regarding the rape culprits.
Good and see in trial court..not in this court
they won't discuss that matter SCj let to drag this . murder
Rape culprits are later first of all the ones who tampered evidence and why, under whose order needs to be find out.
This isn't a normal rape case but a huge plot & conspiracy from the top worked.
Devil is everywhere!
"Yes" to everything.... And " No" at the end of day😂😂😂
Sibal, you are just impossible.
Past Retirement age sibal
Such a fine CJI ... and his panel . love them . Wonder Why WB government needs to be told what to be done ? If they are genuine , their swift reaction should have installed confidence among the young doctors. it's a point to introspect for WB govt ..
Sibal needs a lot of counseling as to how he shoulf behave in the SC of India.I find his behaviour rather overbearing and objectionable!He talks like Lord Shiva!
It is due to the weak personality of the bench that he is allowed to get away with such obnoxious behaviour
Rightly said Brother but don't compare him with Lord Shiva, even if Sibal tries every other trick up d sleeves he & his Team incl d Lady will ALWAYS REMAIN a Devil's Advocate
Sibal continuously interrupts Honarable CJI when he is speaking.
CJI is very sensitive to the problems of the medical students, has done homework dilligently and is going into minor details. We are grateful.
But what can he do if these fall into deaf ears?
Introduce bio metric access and appoint Security personnel first. Then ask them to join work. Mr. Sibal, You were waiting for a ghastly happening like this horrendous rape and ghastly murder to introduce these elementary safety requirements?
Oh what a soft spoken person but where was this soft voice when a lawyer was standing for public right?
Why is kapil sebil supporting goonda mamatha bannerjee
May be he wants to marry her 😅by impressing such things
Panam only that.
Because she is your wife's mother in law. 😂😂😂
Even as you hide one thing is crystal clear. You are jealous of TMC Govt operating in Kolkata because you are andhbhakt of Modi who Pays you Rs 2 per comment. That is ultimate truth. 😂😂😂
😅😅😅😅😅😅@@jyotijha2341
Cant we start a petition for CJI to remove sibal from this case?
We are the public.
Kapil Sibal is disgusting
But far better than your Grandpa's son who is more disgusting. 😂😂😂
No but ur mo mis
KAPIL. SIBAL. ALWAYS. YESSS YOU ARE. RIGHT. WE. WILL. DO. IT HE IS SMART. IN SAYING. ANY DAM. THING. YA. YA. FAIR. ENOUGH. VERY. SMART IN DIVERTING. ARETHEY. REALLY. ON. GROUND. .
In India "yahaan Aisa hi hota hain". If interested stay. Else shift base elsewhere. 😊😊😊
CJI: regular police is not doing their job, forget about good job. Cisf should train and send their trained personnel on govt records...not some private trained goons. Docs want safety, not more of corrupt police
Mr sibal should have asked for more personnel to install cctvs quickly. Hea doing a slow job alright
Why is Kapil allowed to respond with "Right", "Yes" following every sentence from CJI. Who is the judge and who is arguing ? Confused... Kapil must learn to carefully listen to others with silence and then to respond in his turn. How can such a show run at the proceedings of the Apex court ?
Everything for him is yes yes he is a yes guy and not listening.
Next Assignments are ready for Kapil Sibal and Singhvi combo.
Waqf case
One Nation One Poll.
On d mark. Rightly said both d Anti National Advocate elements ready to destroy India
Is it only mr who feels sibal talks like a teenager to the judge.. his attitude and tone
Useless discusstion , mockery.😢😢
Soibal unable to convince the SC that WB is ruled by angels
C bal smartly turned this into a doctor safety issue.
Where is the justice SC CJ????
NON OF THE WORK EVEN ONE IS DONE, NOT EVEN ONE CCTV CAMERA INSTALL NOT SHOWING PROOF IN SUPREME COURT SUCH A SHOCKING AFTER SUCH A LONG WEEKS..😂😂😂😂😂
This is India. Wait for another 1000 years for it to be America. What is your hurry. American Visa are anyways available. 😊😊😊
In West Bengal there are 28 Govt. Medical College ( including one AIIMS in Kalyani) and 9 private Medical colleges ( some of which are in PPP MODE). Therefore , there are 37 Medical Colleges in West Bengal.
And not 47. I think the state counsel is always saying yes as per the nos of medical colleges concerned.
The question should be why it wasnt there in the first place. Whats the point of arguing about CCTVs now? Is this how justice runs now.
The greedy scoundrel with sheer hubris behaves as if he is above the honourable CJI. The body language and swiftness with which he agrees for the important security measures ? Quite clearly indicates he is making a mockery of it. ‘Absolutely’ nothing or some jugad !!!
Sibal is an embarrassment to the law profession
What a cozy discussion betwn two friends. Was there really a heinous crime? As if an FM Company manager is guiding the installation manager. Shame
Mr. Sibal is very adept at diverting the courts attention to security of the premises from the mishandling of the case by the TMC government.
This guy Kapil Sibbal is smart enough to mislead the Supreme Court with different issues which are not directly related with the rape case.
It looks that the court is running as per his convenience.
CJI TOP MAN Sibal talking over the others is clear that he is trying to brush over many issues. He IS A lost Cause.
Haan hain. Woh apni marzi ka hai maalik. Toh???
Btw, aapka problem kya hai. Woh bataao. 😊😊😊
Looks like a two-member Sibal-CJI club decide whatever happens in important cases. And 140 crore people have to accept.
Biometrics, CCTV cameras are not there in such a large and famous hospital... Country CJI shld request for that...such a pity😢
why not order for that cctv footage from WB it's suspicious
Yes yes absolutely we agree mi lord. I agree will do everything. What a liar For last 50 years your eyes are not open to crimes and fraud sibbal. Your are rather keeping your eyes open to look for opportunities to fight case for them. Sab idhar hi reh jayega Upar kya jawab doge my lord ko?
Why the CJI is lenient towards Kapil Sipil? Number of assistants around him. Can a normal citizen can afford such extravaganza? Can 6:59 these judges hear common men, who can afford to hire a junior lawyer's argument?
Then TMC will deploy their troops as contract workers
Not sure what is being discussed .. where is the case heading towards
When????
For the welfare of honest and law abiding indians law degree of Saibal should be cancelled.He is an inhuman being
More of testing and confirming mathematical skills then judicial skills. I thought I was listening to Barrister Indrajit Chaddha from Damini movie. 🤣
Nothing better is going to happen from this worthful discussion.
They are not going to install, that's why they are slow. Once, the docter are tired, they are going to do same as earlier. They should never stop.
Look at the audacity of Kapil sibbal. CJI while addressing, the way he tried to put his word onto CJI is a very mischievous way and against the decorum of court.
Very very wrong... Shame.
Yes, talk about camera but not about the rape and justice for that lady. Pathetic court
The incident is an Eye opener - Sibal? Shame on the hospital and the state
Living Legend Sibal Sir
Admirable CJI
Yes yes we will that
Identify the place, which place like seminar
Isn't Justice to trainee Dr is the high priority?
This is where urgent justice is required instead of posting Dr.s to different places
Who are the culprits
They will say yes to everything..
Kapil sibbal is real judge. What ever sibbal says, CJI will accept & the truth submission by other advocates will be over looked. I am sure sibbal will win the case, CJI is forced to order in his favour.
Absolutely glad the CJI can see the vital need for security for the young medical force that joined so enthusiastically to serve people and are treated so badly by the Health Ministry... Without a thought for their basic needs.
The legal aide for the Govt appears to be gaslighting. almost 50 days have passed and he is asking for two more weeks to even formulate a policy... By not a thorough security policy should have been in place to assure that all doctors and patients are safe... Even the morgue seems unsafe presently
What a mockery is going on. ALL these points discussed are live data facts that state Govt is utterly failed and CJI is simply giving a Short term and Long Term solutions. Sibbal is liaison of the law at Supreme Court.
Bharath desh mein "Aisa hi hota hain". If interested yahaan raho, warna shift base elsewhere". No one is affected by your movement. 😊😊😊
Being a senior advocate does Mr Sibbal have any manner ? not to cut off CJ while talking? CJ gives him time and space to speak & never cut -off Mr Sibbal's speech; however I see senior advocates & legal scholars have no mannerism during hearings.... they cut each other and no patience to wait till other speaker completes their speech!!!! Is it a civilized way of discussion!?
🙏🤔Their should be an audit of this swo or muto how much money did this thing cost the Indian taxpayers and the supreme courts time and money, we know that Mr Sb turned a rape and murder case into installing cctv cameras. MiLords when there is another incident like this in future for sure there will be, and no recording will be found because that’s what is going to happen then the CJI will ask why only the cctv cameras were not powered 24/7. Mark my words.
Next rape case we will decide the operation of all these security cameras to be recording 24/7
And
Next rape case we will discuss to power all these cameras with dual power.
Next rape case we will discuss who is responsible for making sure all the cctv cameras are all recording and are powered.
What about the rape and murder case?😡
Why is Kapil Sibal constantly interjecting when the CJI is speaking ? Is he over the CJI ? Time to put a check on his smartness.
After listening to this conversation, what senior level lawyer does not seem to gather information and work like a messenger?
India is fortunate to have judges like Mr. Chandracudh.
What actions are completed regarding the security of youngsters? If not by what date and time they will complete. I feel ashamed when I hear that Mr Sibbal says the word - everything, all.
Sibal when entered case gone
Sibal is speaking with half the information! Women police are under training. But doesn't know what's the training period. Cc cameras information also is this...that... horrendous!
Om Hon'ble Justice CJI is so sympathetic and study in depth the sufferings of Doctors in Governmeñt Hospitals and has pulled up the WB government to its failures to ensure safety. And securityof Doctors in GH Sich fscciliies should have been provided from day one of the opening of Hospitals Government'failuted to take care of their doctors tanamount to derelictikm of their assigned duties
😊
Let the Advocate give undertaking in writing
No use of verbally give the assurances.
etiquette ?
Sibol is dodging and skipping out of responsibility!?
Why not ask directly a senior working doctor women committee to identify places for cameras
SOP to manage Supreme Court
Besides 35 hospitals of modern medicine, there are Homoeopathic and Ayurveda medical colleges in West Bengal having lady students, doctors, their rest room and hostels.
From hostel to hospital there is variable distance of about 500 meters.
Besides lady students doctors there are lady nurses, attendants, safai workers mostly young or middle aged.
Unless they feel safe they will not work. Patient care is a team work. Doctors alone can not do any thing.
Sibel should be C Justice of Supreme Court
Sibal is answering as if he is responsible of the situation on the ground . Everything has an answer and no action report.
Bharath desh mein "Aisa hi hota hain". If interested yahaan raho, warna shift base elsewhere". No one is affected by your movement. 😊😊😊
Why isnt this all India?
Sir,
Instalation of cameras is not sufficient. Wherever lady Doctors are working they must Post atleast more than 2 lady security personnel at each room or hall or lady toilets etc.,
Granted, medical colleges in India should be privided with enough security to protect the life of doctors, medical students, and patients.That said, which medical colleges anywhere in India have the kind of security the honorable CJ is asking for?
Heads off to CJI patients, managing senior lawyer interrepting every time.
Kapil Sibal can claim the honour of Devil’s Advocate officially