I'm looking for a sub 500$ speaker set up for my small retail store. I was going to buy the Edifyers but what you said about the Klipsch's filling the room with sound made me change my mind. Thanks for the excellent review.
I just got my Kipsch R-51PMs set up in my living room. I have them in an enclosed book shelf, and since they're rear ported, I don't need the subwoofer I bought. So, that's going downstairs in the theater. :)
Tip - have a look at the Edifier S1000 MKII speakers. They’re less expensive than these Klipschs but the sound they reproduce is fantastic. They have all the inputs that this R1850DB has except the sub output, but they don’t need extra bass.
Very interesting review. I’ve actually been looking at both of these speakers so this review was great for me. Klipsch definitely outperformed the Edifier as a tv/movie speaker and music speaker with a sub added. However, if using for just music without the sub, I preferred the Edifier. So now my question is do I invest in a sub or not….hmmm.
@@sazzad_hossain.s Do u need a powered sub combined with powered speakers(if that even is a thing), or sub uses speaker's internal amps? Also if u buy klipsch do u need to buy a klipsch SUB or can u go with something cheaper like the Edifier T5 or kanto's SUB8?
@@OmgiamsotriggeredYou should be able to pair any powered subwoofer (usually home theater subs, or something like the Edifier T5) with any of these speakers. The speakers only send the sound signal, they do not amplify it
Thoughts on Klipsch R-51M Bookshelf Speakers with AT-L60X-BT turntable. Versus Klipsch R-41M Bookshelf Speakers for AT-L60X-BT? I’m afraid that are Klipsch 51m are too big! I was getting the edifier R1280DBS because of the size. It’s a Christmas gift, and she young & she is brand new to turntables, so I could always updated as she gets older. Trying to get a descent pair of speakers. Debating between with 51M and 41M. Are the klipsch’s plug and go too like the edifiers? Are they all active speakers? Thanks!
I have the R1850DB with a 200w Monoprice Sub and I turned down the Bass since I want the Bass to come from the Sub - the Sub SCREAMS and I get no distraction at high volumes (sub volume is at 12:00: no port huffs)
This Kiplish are so big. They are good for short distance or it’s better for home teather? Right now I have the edifier for a computer speaker and I don’t have any complains.
without the sub, it seems the edifier has more kick. Maybe it's the long throw woofer of the edifier. For a nearfield desk speaker, the edifier is better. Klipsch is better for a bigger space. I ran a klipsch passive 160rpm with external two channel and the kick is not as pronounced as this edifier.
i am replacing the exact edifiers with the exact klipsch speakers today. the reason, the speaker cable for the edifiers comes loose and I have to wiggle it around to get a clean connection. the speaker out from the left speaker is garbage on those edifiers!
A little advice, or at least let's say a helpful opinion, u need to check out the Edifier R2750DB's for less than 390 USD (R-51PM costs 750 USD here) and u get almost better sound quality than the Klipsch R-51PM because it has 3 way high quality drivers, a 6.5 inch woofer, 4 inch mid and a tweeter of course. Also lots of bass and has a sub-out too. The only problem (at least for me) they are huge compared to regular bookshelf or computer speakers. But if your desk is big enough, which yours is, they fit perfectly.
According to Edifier, their R2850DB’s have now been released to replace the R2750DB’s out there in the marketplace. They’ve upgraded Bluetooth to v5 and the remote control unit has been given a facelift and I think that they may have also added another input (not 100% sure about that). Otherwise I think that they’re basically remained the same. I’ve also been led to believe that overall sound reproduction from the Edifier R2000DB’s compares very favourably with the R2750DB’s/R2850DB’s for a lot less cost…
2 года назад
@@Driver2616 apparently they did, I looked out for the old version on their web page and it doesn't exist anymore. Strangely though we still have the 2750DB instead of 2850DB here in Turkey, due to the pandemic I guess...And it's now unfortunately significantly more expensive than before :/
I'm going for the 1280DB because they have Optical for my PC and cheaper than 1850DB. They are exactly the same just 100 euros less because a bit less RMS watt.
All the Edifiers are probably the same predictable high quality. One can get here on RUclips the impression that some sound better but once bought, one probably doesn't notice flaws I think.
in Australia the Edifiers are $170 the Klipsch are $1050........not really a close comparison, maybe the s2000mk3 wld had been better their $400 aud n are insanely great for the price
Great video, Im looking for bookshelf speakers for gaming and movies I havent decided which are best Klipsh R41M or Edifier R1280T any help woudl be appreciated
Hi, No, those e4.5 doesn't have rca output or a pre-sub out... If you want to use a sub parallel to ur presonus, then you need to split ur audio source into two.. one goes to ur e4.5 and the other to ur edifier sub... then set the frequency cut off on ur sub to whatever you like, I would recommend 80hz since e4.5 will play as low as 70hz and the sub can play anything below 80hz cut off 👍
So a question? I have the R51pm, and want to buy a turntable, so is it better to pair it with a pre amp turntable, bluetooth turntable, or just a turntable without the extras? Thanks in advance, aI enjoyed the video as well.
8 months later but well. Maybe someone will have the same question today. I'm about to buy these Klipsch, for what I've heard, a good external preamp will make your turntable sound better than the integrated preamp in the Klipsch. Try to get a tube preamp.
@@rael2099 Yes I have my R51PM's connected to a preamp. Not tube but the sound is excellent altho I'm itching to get a sub since the bass needs more oomph for electronic music listening
@Sunny Jake your comment just shows how eager you are to show off what you have, or only have. Never once was a comparison made with separates, and my original just corrected this vid's wrong wattage info. But hey, you thought that your measly 90wpc is good enough to go bouncing around youtube comments acting like its end all fuck all. Congrats on your ability to own 90wpc. Bravo bravo. I on the other hand wont bother mentioning what I have in my Atmos setup back home to people like you. Creatures like you cant have good things, or the whole world would know about it. And you make things sound like wattage is everything, like 90wpc will bring any musicality to your system. Lmfao!
The fives will intergrade better with you TV since it's got HDMI ARC input, you'll be able to control volume with tv remote at ease... But I feel like it's way over priced for a 2-channel speakers, for the same price or a little more you can put together a 5.1 system or 5.1 saoundbar setup with dolby atmos.... I would get the R51PM instead, cost half the price 😁
hi Sazzad, if i hook up an amp to R51PM, the amp has RCA output.. so i need to switch to phono or line? want it to be like this : pc optical out > dac > pre-amp > amp > R51PM
U can connect optical cable directly from pc to R51PM or via usb cable, no need for a dac or another amp, u use phono when ur connecting a turntable to these speakers
These are bookshelf speakers for listening to music man. A soundbar is for movies and stuff. These have better sound quality but they dont have surround or height channels
Did you change audio source to aux? Tried Bluetooth? Try ruling out if the speakers work or not, if speakers are good then it could be bad cable, if cable is good then something is wrong lol if all fails then contact klipsch and see if ur warranty allows for repair or replacement
@@bighit3352 so the speakers works, hmmm could be a faulty aux connection on the klipsch amp, best to get it replaced with ur warranty or return for a new unit
@@bighit3352 ahhh, after replying I went back to look at the connection to refresh myself, so when connecting with ur phone or pc, use AUX (3.5mm) and switch it to 'line' .. the RCA connection are for turntables, so u flip to 'phono' when using those... Even thou you are getting sound out of RCA using ur phone, it may not be ideal since phono signal is different compared to AUX based on signal strength level, AUX connection is stronger then Phono, which makes it ideal for mobile devices so you can enjoy the audio better without having to turn it up so much
Well that's because he didn't do a honest review. S2000 pros would have been a dollar to dollar fair comparison. The r1850s are not in the same price range. It's like comparing a Honda to a Lexus
Why wouldn't u compare apples to apples with the s2000 pros or s3000 pros. You are not being fair. The r1850s are a desktop speaker and the Klipsch are more a "bookshelf" speaker. This is a bogus comparison. I like both brands and use the 5s and 2000 3000 pros r1850s with the t5 and airpulse 300s. Still think this was not apples to apples
Sometimes, life doesn't give you apples.. sometime, it's apples and pears... Which are like apples but not really 🤔 Thanks for checking out the video lol
Наука
I'm looking for a sub 500$ speaker set up for my small retail store. I was going to buy the Edifyers but what you said about the Klipsch's filling the room with sound made me change my mind. Thanks for the excellent review.
I just got my Kipsch R-51PMs set up in my living room. I have them in an enclosed book shelf, and since they're rear ported, I don't need the subwoofer I bought. So, that's going downstairs in the theater. :)
Some good points of information there, thanks.
Awesome review
Tip - have a look at the Edifier S1000 MKII speakers. They’re less expensive than these Klipschs but the sound they reproduce is fantastic. They have all the inputs that this R1850DB has except the sub output, but they don’t need extra bass.
Very interesting review. I’ve actually been looking at both of these speakers so this review was great for me. Klipsch definitely outperformed the Edifier as a tv/movie speaker and music speaker with a sub added. However, if using for just music without the sub, I preferred the Edifier. So now my question is do I invest in a sub or not….hmmm.
I think a 6 or 8inch sub will pair nicely with the edifiers. Like an active sub, something that will allow you to control frequency cut off ;)
@@sazzad_hossain.s Do u need a powered sub combined with powered speakers(if that even is a thing), or sub uses speaker's internal amps? Also if u buy klipsch do u need to buy a klipsch SUB or can u go with something cheaper like the Edifier T5 or kanto's SUB8?
@@OmgiamsotriggeredYou should be able to pair any powered subwoofer (usually home theater subs, or something like the Edifier T5) with any of these speakers. The speakers only send the sound signal, they do not amplify it
Thoughts on Klipsch R-51M Bookshelf Speakers with AT-L60X-BT turntable. Versus Klipsch R-41M Bookshelf Speakers for AT-L60X-BT?
I’m afraid that are Klipsch 51m are too big! I was getting the edifier R1280DBS because of the size. It’s a Christmas gift, and she young & she is brand new to turntables, so I could always updated as she gets older. Trying to get a descent pair of speakers. Debating between with 51M and 41M. Are the klipsch’s plug and go too like the edifiers? Are they all active speakers? Thanks!
I have the R1850DB with a 200w Monoprice Sub and I turned down the Bass since I want the Bass to come from the Sub - the Sub SCREAMS and I get no distraction at high volumes (sub volume is at 12:00: no port huffs)
This Kiplish are so big. They are good for short distance or it’s better for home teather? Right now I have the edifier for a computer speaker and I don’t have any complains.
When listening to this video the Edifiers seemed more balanced, the only problem I have is that I need passive speakers
.
I thought the edifiers sounded better and for $200 less they left the Klipsch in the dust.
My r51pms are coming in a few days, very excited. Got tired of my shit tv speakers
How much did you pay? They’re going for £550 in UK
without the sub, it seems the edifier has more kick. Maybe it's the long throw woofer of the edifier. For a nearfield desk speaker, the edifier is better. Klipsch is better for a bigger space. I ran a klipsch passive 160rpm with external two channel and the kick is not as pronounced as this edifier.
Nice review 👍
i am replacing the exact edifiers with the exact klipsch speakers today. the reason, the speaker cable for the edifiers comes loose and I have to wiggle it around to get a clean connection. the speaker out from the left speaker is garbage on those edifiers!
This edifiers 1855db or the vulkkano a5 ARC, which one sounds better?
Can pls compare ! Edifier R1850 vs Jbl Nano K4 ?
A little advice, or at least let's say a helpful opinion, u need to check out the Edifier R2750DB's for less than 390 USD (R-51PM costs 750 USD here) and u get almost better sound quality than the Klipsch R-51PM because it has 3 way high quality drivers, a 6.5 inch woofer, 4 inch mid and a tweeter of course. Also lots of bass and has a sub-out too. The only problem (at least for me) they are huge compared to regular bookshelf or computer speakers. But if your desk is big enough, which yours is, they fit perfectly.
According to Edifier, their R2850DB’s have now been released to replace the R2750DB’s out there in the marketplace. They’ve upgraded Bluetooth to v5 and the remote control unit has been given a facelift and I think that they may have also added another input (not 100% sure about that). Otherwise I think that they’re basically remained the same.
I’ve also been led to believe that overall sound reproduction from the Edifier R2000DB’s compares very favourably with the R2750DB’s/R2850DB’s for a lot less cost…
@@Driver2616 apparently they did, I looked out for the old version on their web page and it doesn't exist anymore. Strangely though we still have the 2750DB instead of 2850DB here in Turkey, due to the pandemic I guess...And it's now unfortunately significantly more expensive than before :/
Thank you Sazzad! Your Speaker Comparison helped me alot to make my choice!
In the end I bought the Edifier 1850 DB and I am happy with that Speakers!
Right on! Glad you like em, I definitely enjoy mine on an everyday basis, very good speakers!
@@sazzad_hossain.s Thank you so much!
I am listening to the difference between those two on $10 Trust PC speakers... Edifier R1855DB is on order now for my PC setup.
I'm going for the 1280DB because they have Optical for my PC and cheaper than 1850DB. They are exactly the same just 100 euros less because a bit less RMS watt.
All the Edifiers are probably the same predictable high quality. One can get here on RUclips the impression that some sound better but once bought, one probably doesn't notice flaws I think.
in Australia the Edifiers are $170 the Klipsch are $1050........not really a close comparison, maybe the s2000mk3 wld had been better their $400 aud n are insanely great for the price
should i buy a subwoofer for the edifiers that i already have for 120£ or buy the Klipsch for 230£?
It should be edifier s2000 vs klipsch coz it 's almost the same price category
Really nice review. 👌🏼
Thanks!
Great video, Im looking for bookshelf speakers for gaming and movies I havent decided which are best Klipsh R41M or Edifier R1280T any help woudl be appreciated
to me 😂
just to let people know..... klipsch speakers go on sale all the time and the klipsch is on sale for 279$ right now.
HI, Can i connect my Edifier T5 subwoofer to my presonus eris 4.5BT speakers?
Hi, No, those e4.5 doesn't have rca output or a pre-sub out... If you want to use a sub parallel to ur presonus, then you need to split ur audio source into two.. one goes to ur e4.5 and the other to ur edifier sub... then set the frequency cut off on ur sub to whatever you like, I would recommend 80hz since e4.5 will play as low as 70hz and the sub can play anything below 80hz cut off 👍
On 10 min and 34 sec whats the track name ?
So a question? I have the R51pm, and want to buy a turntable, so is it better to pair it with a pre amp turntable, bluetooth turntable, or just a turntable without the extras? Thanks in advance, aI enjoyed the video as well.
8 months later but well. Maybe someone will have the same question today.
I'm about to buy these Klipsch, for what I've heard, a good external preamp will make your turntable sound better than the integrated preamp in the Klipsch.
Try to get a tube preamp.
@@rael2099 Yes I have my R51PM's connected to a preamp. Not tube but the sound is excellent altho I'm itching to get a sub since the bass needs more oomph for electronic music listening
Very nice
$200 I went with the Edifier....I just want decent sound in not tryna win a loud system contest
can i hook up my pioneer subwoofer on the edifier? dont have a 3.5 jack though, just a normal wire...
Active or passive sub? If it's active then yes, but passive no
@@sazzad_hossain.s well, too bad my subwoofer is passive, my friend told me that i can have it converted to active, just have to buy subwoofer module
@@chingmarquezagito5153 yeah, partsexpress have them, you should be able to buy a unit for a good price.. just be sure to match ohms
I just bought the r-41pm on sale for $230 on Amazon
A quick correction, the 1850 has 35w per channel with a total of 70w for a pair. :) Great comparo btw!
35w per channel? I don't think so, check out edifier official website, it's 16w RMS per channel, and 19w at peak per channel :)
@@sazzad_hossain.s 19w per woofer, 16w per tweeter... :) www.edifier.com/int/en/speakers/r1850db
@@AbsoluteFidelity well waddayaknow! Ain't that something lol thank you for pointing that out, learned something new :D
@Sunny Jake your comment just shows how eager you are to show off what you have, or only have. Never once was a comparison made with separates, and my original just corrected this vid's wrong wattage info. But hey, you thought that your measly 90wpc is good enough to go bouncing around youtube comments acting like its end all fuck all. Congrats on your ability to own 90wpc. Bravo bravo. I on the other hand wont bother mentioning what I have in my Atmos setup back home to people like you. Creatures like you cant have good things, or the whole world would know about it. And you make things sound like wattage is everything, like 90wpc will bring any musicality to your system. Lmfao!
@Sunny Jake good luck spamming all my vids with vulgar comments. :) and thanks for the views!
Do the Klipsch come with a Power Button?
My Klipsch Promedia 2.1 does not !
Klipsch the fives and klipsch r51 ???
The fives will intergrade better with you TV since it's got HDMI ARC input, you'll be able to control volume with tv remote at ease... But I feel like it's way over priced for a 2-channel speakers, for the same price or a little more you can put together a 5.1 system or 5.1 saoundbar setup with dolby atmos.... I would get the R51PM instead, cost half the price 😁
hi Sazzad,
if i hook up an amp to R51PM, the amp has RCA output.. so i need to switch to phono or line?
want it to be like this :
pc optical out > dac > pre-amp > amp > R51PM
U can connect optical cable directly from pc to R51PM or via usb cable, no need for a dac or another amp, u use phono when ur connecting a turntable to these speakers
Which subwoofer did you use in the end there?
Klipsch R120SW
Damn, Klipsh are like Cinema. But in my country they cost 500 euros.
good day with reomend for more sond for mi room no import price
Klipsch r51pm.......no compromise speakers.
Between the edifier 1850db and a Dolby atmos soundbar which should I prefer??
The 1850 will sound better than 99.9% soundbars out there. Pair it up with a sub and listen to magic.
These are bookshelf speakers for listening to music man. A soundbar is for movies and stuff. These have better sound quality but they dont have surround or height channels
hi i tried to connect my phone to RCA it doesnt work i have the Pm R51
Did you change audio source to aux? Tried Bluetooth? Try ruling out if the speakers work or not, if speakers are good then it could be bad cable, if cable is good then something is wrong lol if all fails then contact klipsch and see if ur warranty allows for repair or replacement
yes i have new cable bluetooth works and usb port but iphone to or laptop to RCA doesnt work
@@bighit3352 so the speakers works, hmmm could be a faulty aux connection on the klipsch amp, best to get it replaced with ur warranty or return for a new unit
Sazzad Hossain i figured it out you just have to use phono when using RCA port thanks
@@bighit3352 ahhh, after replying I went back to look at the connection to refresh myself, so when connecting with ur phone or pc, use AUX (3.5mm) and switch it to 'line' .. the RCA connection are for turntables, so u flip to 'phono' when using those... Even thou you are getting sound out of RCA using ur phone, it may not be ideal since phono signal is different compared to AUX based on signal strength level, AUX connection is stronger then Phono, which makes it ideal for mobile devices so you can enjoy the audio better without having to turn it up so much
Thy arent the Klipsch drivers moving much? The edifiers are FREAKING OUT in a great way!!
Edifier R2850db v/s klipsch R- 51
super i like edi 1850 db super for 100 dollars sale .............
edifier i think it has more BASS
Edifier 1850DB is VFM
Klipsch speakers seem to sound fuller.
Well that's because he didn't do a honest review. S2000 pros would have been a dollar to dollar fair comparison. The r1850s are not in the same price range. It's like comparing a Honda to a Lexus
Klipsch R-51PM doesnt sound musical its more of movie speakers
Why wouldn't u compare apples to apples with the s2000 pros or s3000 pros. You are not being fair. The r1850s are a desktop speaker and the Klipsch are more a "bookshelf" speaker. This is a bogus comparison. I like both brands and use the 5s and 2000 3000 pros r1850s with the t5 and airpulse 300s. Still think this was not apples to apples
Sometimes, life doesn't give you apples.. sometime, it's apples and pears... Which are like apples but not really 🤔 Thanks for checking out the video lol
Did you even watch the video? He explains why he does this comparison in the first minute. I think it’s an interesting comparison.
@@Brinta3 I did watch it. And your wrong. But I that's ok it happens
Edifier all day long
Нихера не понял 🤥
worst review evAr