With due regards to Talal Sahab , ye hamari khush kismati hai ki Rafi Sahab ne ye gaana gaaya. aankhon ko barasne pe majboor kar de aisi aawaz sirf Rafi Sahab k paas hi thi. ❤
पालकी का ये गाना बहुत मुश्किल गाना है, अंतरो मे बहुत उतार चढ़ाव है, उर्दु की पकड़ बहुत ज़बरदस्त हैं, इस गाने के साथ रफी साहब ही इंसाफ कर सकते थे! तलत साहब भी गा सकते थे पर इनता गंभीर पन ना दे पाते!
Comment from London. If ever the song recorded in Talat Mahmood can be released it would clear lots of doubts as to who sang it better Talat or Rafi. My guess is Rafi's released & pictured version would be a winner by a huge verdict. I am so convinced Talat version would not have any justice to the superb gazal/nazm composed by Maestro Naushad.
Comment from London... As a music lover, the Talat version must be found and released. Can Naushad's son Raju help and release Talat's version for us all.??? We ALL would be most grateful to Raju Naushad.
What is this? There is another version. Rajendra Kumar went to Naushad to get it re- recorded in Rafi Sahib voice. Rafi Sahib initially refused, but then spoke to Talat Mehmoodji and he did not object. Then it was re-recorded.
Talat sahab had his points but the film was somehow to be completed. Without the blessings of Production team Naushad sahab was not able to complete. Further, K.Asif sahab intervened and he was in favour of getting the song to be sung by Rafisaab who suited most for Rajendrakumar.
नौशाद ने ऐसा फिल्म "आदमी" में भी किया था। "ऐसी हसीन आज बहारों की रात है" गाने में फिल्म के हीरो मनोज कुमार के दबाव में आकर तलत मेहमुद वाला पार्ट महेन्द्र कपूर की आवाज में डब करवाया गया था। ये अन्यायपूर्ण था।
Talat sab ke pas se Naushab ne 1949 aayi Babul film ke bad koi bhi gana nahi gawaya tha.Aadmi me Rafi ke sath 1967 ya 1968 me gawaya tha. karib 18 saal ke baad.Matlab pahele se hi Nausad ko Talat sab pasand nahi the. Babul ke gane super hit hone ke baad bhi!
With due regards to Talal Sahab , ye hamari khush kismati hai ki Rafi Sahab ne ye gaana gaaya. aankhon ko barasne pe majboor kar de aisi aawaz sirf Rafi Sahab k paas hi thi. ❤
बोहत अच्छी जानकारी दी भाई आपने
Wahh 💐🌹🥀🌺🎶😊
काश ये ग़ज़ल Talat Mahmood जी के आवाज़ में रही होती
पालकी का ये गाना बहुत मुश्किल गाना है, अंतरो मे बहुत उतार चढ़ाव है, उर्दु की पकड़ बहुत ज़बरदस्त हैं, इस गाने के साथ रफी साहब ही इंसाफ कर सकते थे! तलत साहब भी गा सकते थे पर इनता गंभीर पन ना दे पाते!
There is no need to agitate the past.Let us enjoy the works of the legends.
Rafi saab the zinius 👍
Comment from London.
If ever the song recorded in Talat Mahmood can be released it would clear lots of doubts as to who sang it better Talat or Rafi.
My guess is Rafi's released & pictured version would be a winner by a huge verdict.
I am so convinced Talat version would not have any justice to the superb gazal/nazm composed by Maestro Naushad.
Good USEFUL KNOWLEDGE. THANKS MAHESHWARI SIR🏆🌹🏆.
Ye rafi sahib hi ka gana tha beshaq
महेश जी आपका तहे दिल से धन्यवाद करता हूं मैं बहुत हैरान हूं क्या आप ऐसी डिटेल अंदरूनी बातें कहां से लाते हो यू आर द ग्रेट🙏🌷
Jai Mohammed Rafi Sahab.
J talat mahmoodd
Amazing
THANKS FOR SHARING SUCH A GREAT KNOWLEDGE
Very nice inf thanks
Tell about movie vishwas song aap ko hum se bichhude hue by manhar udhas
Thank u sir 💐💐for your all Running videos
रफी साहब जी लाजवाब लाजवाब लाजवाब
Not only Talat Meehmood any singer cannot sing like Rafisaheb Rafisaheb is a rare cutpiece
Comment from London...
As a music lover, the Talat version must be found and released.
Can Naushad's son Raju help and release Talat's version for us all.??? We ALL would be most grateful to Raju Naushad.
You Should Show Us Talat Recorded Song Also. We Know Both Are Great Singers. Tnx. From Navi Mumbai.
Naushad had donw one more time such act when he got Talat Mehmood song rerecorded in film admi." Kaisi haseen aaj baharon ki raat hai......".
Fantastic indeed
TALAT SAHIB KA YE GEET AGAR KISI KE PASS HAY TU PLZ MUJHE SEND KAR DAIN ...TALAT MAHMOOD KING OF GHAZALS
What is this? There is another version. Rajendra Kumar went to Naushad to get it re- recorded in Rafi Sahib voice. Rafi Sahib initially refused, but then spoke to Talat Mehmoodji and he did not object.
Then it was re-recorded.
I wish to listen to Talat's version. Hope someone has this recording.
Talat sahab had his points but the film was somehow to be completed. Without the blessings of Production team Naushad sahab was not able to complete. Further, K.Asif sahab intervened and he was in favour of getting the song to be sung by Rafisaab who suited most for Rajendrakumar.
Talat ji k saath nainsaafi hui bhale hi is gaane k saath Rafi sb ki awaz zyda achi thi fir bhi baat baat hoti hai wada wada hota hai
Thainks😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Thank u sir...but kissa thoda alag hai..jaisa aapne kaha waisa nahi..kal raat 8 baje sunaunga is gaane ka pura qissa sadabahar fankar mein ..zarur suniyega..🙏🙂
Ye gaana Talat sb ke liye Thora mushkil raha hoga chunki high scale per tha jo Rafi sb ke liye hi fit tha.
नौशाद ने ऐसा फिल्म "आदमी" में भी किया था। "ऐसी हसीन आज बहारों की रात है" गाने में फिल्म के हीरो मनोज कुमार के दबाव में आकर तलत मेहमुद वाला पार्ट महेन्द्र कपूर की आवाज में डब करवाया गया था। ये अन्यायपूर्ण था।
It is not a fault of Naushad but of Rajendra Kumar who insisted Rafi instead of Talat Mahmood.
Jab talat sahab ka version nahi sunwa sakte toh video kyon banai. Adhoori hai ye video.
Talat sab ke pas se Naushab ne 1949 aayi Babul film ke bad koi bhi gana nahi gawaya tha.Aadmi me Rafi ke sath 1967 ya 1968 me gawaya tha. karib 18 saal ke baad.Matlab pahele se hi Nausad ko Talat sab pasand nahi the. Babul ke gane super hit hone ke baad bhi!
Previously I heard a slightly different story.
Bhai thoda respect bhi de diya karo...Naushad sahab ya ji bolo...
Bina gana sunaye video Ekdam bakwaas lagtaa hai
Bad decision of Naushad Ali
Absolutly right sir
Noushad mia ne hamesha talat sahab ko neecha dikkhane ki koshish ki
बकवास