Yes it was definitely very hard. You MAY give a Beyonce song justice while sitting, but let's not forget Beyonce MAINTAINS the same level of vocal stamina WHILE dancing and running around. I would love to see whoever that is you are talking about do the same with same choreography Beyonce was hitting..
Isabelli Faha They aren't trying to replace Beyoncé, they are just singing her songs with their own sound and style. In a way that Beyoncé can't even do.
10 years later i'm going to reply on this one too. This group performance was probably practiced in few days (less than a week). Waiting for another reply in few years 😂
@@horseluver51000 Beyonce has her own signature sound and style. What exactly is that something that Beyonce can't do? This gurls cannot sing Beyonce's songs at least with a good breathing ❌ If you think they did better than Beyonce, then you're very stupid!
My favorite from the girls this season 1. Pia Toscano 2. Haley Reinhart 3. Lauren Alaina 4. Thia Megia 5. Karen Rodriguez 6. Ashton Jones 7. Naima Adedapo
I think, they all nailed & killed it.. They are all amazing.. solo or even in a group performance...each possess unique & beautiful voice.. I just love this season!
Merayah Carey Pia has a very fine voice, but the only time she sang anything dynamic was in the group numbers. And she did them well. However, every time she was singing solo she went for big ballads which made her seem like a one trick act. The judges told her that they wanted to see something different from her, but she never did it though goodness knows why. Haley went to the other extreme, I'm glad to say, but Randy and JLo gave her a hard time for it.
@@gynack tho yes, pia should have stepped more out of her shell (like in motown week) but the week she got eliminated she did perform the hell out of river deep, mountain high. she listened to the judge’s advice and got eliminated?
@@nateskeans9209 I'd forgotten this performance. I thought in the early part of the song who wasna very convincing, but as she got further into the song she came through more and more strongly. Being voted off was surprise as overall it was a powerful performance and all the judges were praising her very, very highly. Haley never had such lengthy, ringing praise even when she had standing ovations. The women were no doubt up against it with thon ridiculous voting system allowing people to fire off as many hundreds of votes as they could manage during the voting window. Obviously young teenage girls would be glued to their phones sending in their hundreds of votes for the boys they were crushing on. God knows how Haley reached 3rd. Idol had narrative going presenting Lauren and Scotty almost as young lovers - sigh! so sweet and romantic! Even Haley's brilliance couldna get her past that factor.
@@nateskeans9209 He and Lauren were chosen before it started. Idol was pushing them from the start. Admittedly Haley didna have a very strong start, but when she really got going she showed herself undoubtedly the most talented and brilliant performer of them all. Still, ultimately it was a TV show for entertainment, not really to to with finding the most talented singers. A reality show with drama, romance and supense. I suspect that might have been part of the reason why at times they were so hard on Haley. et audiences riled up, maybe make Haley break down. The media did actually latch on to the fact that Haley was being singled out for the negative treatment, and wrote about it. All publicity to swell the viewing figures. The ultimate aim of the show, and to hell with how they might achieve it, or what happens to the contestants apart from anyone they hope to tie up into post-show contracts.
Haley, Thia and Karen, and even Ashton, they showed that they deserved to stay longer in the competition(: they really were amazing, Karen and Thia were eliminated waaay to soon
@RodeoLuv16 I think she sounds amazing! I love her voice, it's unique. For instance, I've heard Pia's voice a thousand times. It's good, but it's not special. Haley is one special artist with fans who absolutely adore her. She's got the world in her hands right now.
@Animatedantonio why would you compare to beyonce? Just because theses were Beyonce's songs doesn't mean you have to compare to singers with alo of experience.
@RodeoLuv16 its called a growl. im not going to say that you are "tone deaf" or "have no taste in music" like others would. i get that it relies on someones taste in music and style preference. i will say, though, that she sounded exactly the way it was intended. :)
I love the song if I where a boy, I loved it when Reba did a country version, and I wan't Haley to do her version! I Wana see her sing that whole song!!!
i know i’m 6 years late but not you insulting tori kelly like that lmfao?? she was still only 18 and making music in her bedroom when this aired in 2011 (and sounding much much better than the girl in this video)
Haley fans are so rude lol like it's just a fun competition and stop saying she's so better than everybody else.. like she didn't even win. There's nothing wrong with cheering for her but you don't have to pull the other contestants down when it wasn't their fault she got eliminated
It wasn't Haley's fault either she got eliminated. As you obviously don't like her, even though most of the people that used to not like her back then, now love her today. Meanwhile, the reason why so many people say she was so much better is that she was far more talented than everyone else on the show that season. Now she hasn't become a Kelly Clarkson or a Carrie Underwood, but that's her own damn fault cause for years she has refused to sign a record deal with a big major record label even though they have all been trying to sign her for years.
The Black Dog i don’t hate haley, i actually really love haley and i also wish she released more music and keep updateds on her from her insta. i’m just saying people that season we’re so aggressive towards anyone that even had a favorite besides haley lmao i would comment “wow they really did good in that group performance “ and someone would say “haley did the best” lmao like ok???
Damn...Haley killed "If I Were A Boy". She sings that song far more soulful than Beyonce. I wish she had did that song on the show. It would have been another standing ovation. So amazing.
Space Cowboy Oh my god. I actually read the 49 lines. You are certainly a funny person. Take a deep breath, hon. Repeat after me: it's gonna be ok. By the way, me obsessed with denigrating Haley? I didn't even know who she was until I watched this video AND read the comments. I didn't watch that season of Idol. I'm only here because I wanted to see how they handled Beyonce's songs. And it's quite sad, really. They all did a terrible job, including your dearest Haley. Sorry, hon. But don't worry, I ain't gonna insult you even though you insulted me. I have way too much class to step down to your level. See ya!
+Nahuel the lying fool Now Nahuel the lying fool is resorting to deleting her own posts to try to hide the truth, which is she is a fat ugly pig and an utterly obsessed Haley hater, and a very obvious piss poor liar.
I can't believe the difference in level between this and last season. Last season's singers kind of sucked... except for Haley and Pia. They're outstanding!
When i first watched this, i realized that i forgot that there were other girls other than Lauren and Haley cause for a while they're the only girls left. xD
This just shows you how hard Beyonce's songs are to execute properly.
+Travon Prince
It wasn't too hard for Haley Reinhart, as she sang that song way more soulful and far better than Beyonce ever did.
lord. fix it jesus
Yes it was definitely very hard. You MAY give a Beyonce song justice while sitting, but let's not forget Beyonce MAINTAINS the same level of vocal stamina WHILE dancing and running around. I would love to see whoever that is you are talking about do the same with same choreography Beyonce was hitting..
@@spacecowboy299 bitch please
@@spacecowboy299 who??
2:26 Haley starts dancing and forgets she needs the mic to sing
2:58 Haley redeems herself nailing "If I Were A Boy"
Haley rocked her parts! Keep owning them my little Reinhart! :D
Now this shows that no one can replace Beyonce
Isabelli Faha They aren't trying to replace Beyoncé, they are just singing her songs with their own sound and style. In a way that Beyoncé can't even do.
10 years later i'm going to reply on this one too. This group performance was probably practiced in few days (less than a week).
Waiting for another reply in few years 😂
@@horseluver51000 Beyonce has her own signature sound and style. What exactly is that something that Beyonce can't do? This gurls cannot sing Beyonce's songs at least with a good breathing ❌ If you think they did better than Beyonce, then you're very stupid!
Bullshit .
I never get tired watching this amazing perfomance, especially from Pia & Haley's parts!!
I think all the girls nailed it! This season is the best! Love this group!
Deja Vu sounds goood with that girls voice !!!
her name is Pia Toscano :)
which two aren't going on tour? ashton and karen??
The best performance I've ever watched :D. Love Haley and Beyonce !
My favorite from the girls this season
1. Pia Toscano
2. Haley Reinhart
3. Lauren Alaina
4. Thia Megia
5. Karen Rodriguez
6. Ashton Jones
7. Naima Adedapo
I think, they all nailed & killed it.. They are all amazing.. solo or even in a group performance...each possess unique & beautiful voice.. I just love this season!
haley solo part....killed everyones.
Pia & Haley should've made it to finale! They both are amazing
Merayah Carey
Pia has a very fine voice, but the only time she sang anything dynamic was in the group numbers. And she did them well. However, every time she was singing solo she went for big ballads which made her seem like a one trick act. The judges told her that they wanted to see something different from her, but she never did it though goodness knows why.
Haley went to the other extreme, I'm glad to say, but Randy and JLo gave her a hard time for it.
@@gynack tho yes, pia should have stepped more out of her shell (like in motown week) but the week she got eliminated she did perform the hell out of river deep, mountain high. she listened to the judge’s advice and got eliminated?
@@nateskeans9209
I'd forgotten this performance. I thought in the early part of the song who wasna very convincing, but as she got further into the song she came through more and more strongly. Being voted off was surprise as overall it was a powerful performance and all the judges were praising her very, very highly. Haley never had such lengthy, ringing praise even when she had standing ovations.
The women were no doubt up against it with thon ridiculous voting system allowing people to fire off as many hundreds of votes as they could manage during the voting window. Obviously young teenage girls would be glued to their phones sending in their hundreds of votes for the boys they were crushing on. God knows how Haley reached 3rd. Idol had narrative going presenting Lauren and Scotty almost as young lovers - sigh! so sweet and romantic! Even Haley's brilliance couldna get her past that factor.
@@gynack oh yeah scotty had it in the bag from the top 24, he was never in the bottom 3 once smh
@@nateskeans9209
He and Lauren were chosen before it started. Idol was pushing them from the start. Admittedly Haley didna have a very strong start, but when she really got going she showed herself undoubtedly the most talented and brilliant performer of them all.
Still, ultimately it was a TV show for entertainment, not really to to with finding the most talented singers. A reality show with drama, romance and supense. I suspect that might have been part of the reason why at times they were so hard on Haley. et audiences riled up, maybe make Haley break down. The media did actually latch on to the fact that Haley was being singled out for the negative treatment, and wrote about it. All publicity to swell the viewing figures. The ultimate aim of the show, and to hell with how they might achieve it, or what happens to the contestants apart from anyone they hope to tie up into post-show contracts.
Haley, Thia and Karen, and even Ashton, they showed that they deserved to stay longer in the competition(: they really were amazing, Karen and Thia were eliminated waaay to soon
YEAH HALEY!!!!!! DAMN THAT GIRL CAN SING AND LOOKS GOOD DOING IT!!!! YOU GO GIRL!!!!!!!
Best 20 seconds of the finale when Haley sings at 2:55
I wish Haley would sing the whole song. ♥
This was a mess.
Agree
I love how the crowd goes ape sh** when ever Haley opens her mouth, but not for the others. *sarcasm*
Haley, I love like song ;)
love this
its funny how beyonce sounds better than ALL of them put together
They butchered Beyoncé's songs! I'm dying! Like why?!?!??! LOL
Haley is such a rock star!!!!
I love how Haley used to be a nobody in the top13. But she reached top3 anyways
@Kjini It is Beyonce, isn't it...?
@samlovesthemiz which person
@CallieAnn111 can you send me the LINK..for that song please?
TEAM PIA!!!
HAYLEY GIVES ME SHIVERS, love herrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
@RodeoLuv16 I think she sounds amazing! I love her voice, it's unique. For instance, I've heard Pia's voice a thousand times. It's good, but it's not special. Haley is one special artist with fans who absolutely adore her. She's got the world in her hands right now.
@CallieAnn111 i can't find it....
are you talking about haley?
Our group is doing a beyonce medley at one of our gigs!
do it again and again
pia sounds like beyonce! i loved her and haley of course
Stefano and casey for the males :)
@Animatedantonio why would you compare to beyonce? Just because theses were Beyonce's songs doesn't mean you have to compare to singers with alo of experience.
2:57 the best moment of the video. Yo ucan feel the crowd getting crazy when she sings BOY.
@RodeoLuv16 its called a growl. im not going to say that you are "tone deaf" or "have no taste in music" like others would. i get that it relies on someones taste in music and style preference. i will say, though, that she sounded exactly the way it was intended. :)
Where is lauren? I didn't c her?
Thia is so cute !!
Agree
It was sort of messy
But i loved it :)
what is the song that Pia sang the last....?
sithu hein deja vu
Muito bom !
the people started to scream when Haley sings
go to 2:55 enjoy to 3:14, go back to 2:55 enjoy to 3:14, back to 2:55 enjoy to 3:14.. over and over and over and over.
Pia tascano was rocking it.
I really wish Beyonce came after This season and meet Jessica Sanchez
cause she is in the Top 2 - 2 finalists :)
This looks like a high school concert
hey they cut the part where beyonce comes in! =/
I Love You Karen ❤️
@antmlover716 I heard it was because she didnt learn the dance or something like that.
This was awesome! I remember thinking "Wait... no Beyonce? Aw man, they'll just have to do" Lol.
Haley is the only reason I make my ears stand the other crap
woooooot GOO HALEYY best part!!
queen haley!! and thia
I love the song if I where a boy, I loved it when Reba did a country version, and I wan't Haley to do her version! I Wana see her sing that whole song!!!
@RaNdOmFrEaKz4LiFe She's in the final 2 with Scotty. It's only the eliminated people who are singing.
Haley is 1 one of the best finalists beside Pia on season 10 :)
1. Single ladies
2. Irriplacable
3. ?
4. if i were a boy
5. deja vu
LMAOO 9 YEARS LATE but number 3 was Get me bodied
lawlz this makes Beyonce look even better than she already is. It wasn't terrible however. Good job Haley and Thia!
ok thanks :)
Even if they've nailed each song, the transition from one song into another was a complete mess!
GO! GIRLS!
haley is awesome!
uhh then who is than? she is the best thats why she got the best part.
@CallieAnn111 oh never mind..i found it...it is Deja Vu...:) anyway thanks
haley ate everyone else up im sawryyyyyy
was that tori kelly?
i know i’m 6 years late but not you insulting tori kelly like that lmfao?? she was still only 18 and making music in her bedroom when this aired in 2011 (and sounding much much better than the girl in this video)
i love ashthons dress and she kinda looks like beyonce right and haley idk why she didnt win the AL title
Haley fans are so rude lol like it's just a fun competition and stop saying she's so better than everybody else.. like she didn't even win. There's nothing wrong with cheering for her but you don't have to pull the other contestants down when it wasn't their fault she got eliminated
It wasn't Haley's fault either she got eliminated. As you obviously don't like her, even though most of the people that used to not like her back then, now love her today. Meanwhile, the reason why so many people say she was so much better is that she was far more talented than everyone else on the show that season. Now she hasn't become a Kelly Clarkson or a Carrie Underwood, but that's her own damn fault cause for years she has refused to sign a record deal with a big major record label even though they have all been trying to sign her for years.
The Black Dog i don’t hate haley, i actually really love haley and i also wish she released more music and keep updateds on her from her insta. i’m just saying people that season we’re so aggressive towards anyone that even had a favorite besides haley lmao i would comment “wow they really did good in that group performance “ and someone would say “haley did the best” lmao like ok???
it's being unique.
Pia and Haley....are the best...
haley and ashton killed it!
did anyone else notice that lauren wasnt in the girl medly but scotty was in the guy one??
@RP1cazzo 3 is get me bodied
I could still not get over Pia looking like a goose walking on the stage.
@RaNdOmFrEaKz4LiFe actually pia was
Damn...Haley killed "If I Were A Boy". She sings that song far more soulful than Beyonce. I wish she had did that song on the show. It would have been another standing ovation. So amazing.
Oh, so you are one of those people who think growling / grunting = soul. I'm so sorry for you... :(
Space Cowboy Oh my god. I actually read the 49 lines. You are certainly a funny person. Take a deep breath, hon. Repeat after me: it's gonna be ok. By the way, me obsessed with denigrating Haley? I didn't even know who she was until I watched this video AND read the comments. I didn't watch that season of Idol. I'm only here because I wanted to see how they handled Beyonce's songs. And it's quite sad, really. They all did a terrible job, including your dearest Haley. Sorry, hon. But don't worry, I ain't gonna insult you even though you insulted me. I have way too much class to step down to your level. See ya!
+Nahuel the lying fool
Now Nahuel the lying fool is resorting to deleting her own posts to try to hide the truth, which is she is a fat ugly pig and an utterly obsessed Haley hater, and a very obvious piss poor liar.
Space Cowboy said that you (nahuel) are a fat ugly pig. Ahahahahahahaha I like it a lot 😂😂😂
I swear I repeated 2:55 more than 100 times.
thia is cute
HALEY, OH MY GOD SO, GOOD. REALLY.
:O
I can't believe the difference in level between this and last season. Last season's singers kind of sucked... except for Haley and Pia. They're outstanding!
When i first watched this, i realized that i forgot that there were other girls other than Lauren and Haley cause for a while they're the only girls left. xD
HALEY!! :D
Go Haley :)
WHERE IS LAUREN?
paprikapepper she wasn't in this.....I wish she was though. She would've been great!! 💖💖💖
2:13 is the best ♥
is it just me or do you guys think the girls version is so much better than the guys medley?
@RodeoLuv16 thats good but i wasnt trying to be sarcastic.
OMG HALEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
HALEY
ooo Ashton looked like she gained weight. But her and Haley Killed it
i like haley on 2:56 check it out
HALEY!!!!
haley reinhart the best.! love you..! :D
if only Thia, Ashton and Karen did this kind of performances they should've been stayed longer.....
@jasonsinanan uhm listen tht is not true! lauren is one of the best girls and haley wasnt even the best in the beyonce medly it was clearly thia!!!
@lolheheheboredom Thanks:)