Palestinians: What do you want Israelis to know about Palestinians?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 май 2024
- Filmed before October 2023 war
HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
![NOSFERATU - Official Teaser Trailer [HD] - Only In Theaters December 25](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/b59rxDB_JRg/mqdefault.jpg)
Summary:
1. We are a peaceful people.
2. This is our land. All of it.
gideon is a palestinian family name
gideon is a palestinian family name
"it has always been our land" except ignore the muslin conquest, arabization, and building a mosque on top of a historical temple.
They dont know it, they never learned it in school, they are never heard it on the Arab tv channels or read it on Arabic websites, they never been told about those things so they dont know anything, Its sad but this islam
From the river to the sea 🇵🇸🇵🇸
Saladin brought the Jews back to Jerusalem . Muslims helped the Jews against the Romans. Read a book. Jews are the ones who backstabbed the Muslims by going to the British instead of going to negotiate with Turkey or Arabs /the Muslims for land.
That's 14 centuries ago , same scenario happened to France in 480, same scenario happened to America in the 14th centuries .
Most countries were established like that ...but you want to focus only about Muslims !
@@tamimsalem6471 "Its happened many times in history...most countries were established like that" so why youu keep crying about Israel and what happened 75 years ago you hypocrite???
It seems like most of them are saying what they think of Israelis, not what they want Israelis to know about them. They don't seem to understand the question.
Because education and culture do not allow different thinking or debate.
this fat arab - the last one spoke English well and understand what he asked him and still answer the same, you simply cannot believe how stupid and brainwash they are
Because they aren’t interested in mutual understanding, they are interested in taking what they perceive as their land back.
just the regular parrot festival of alternative history...
They understand, they just want everything and they want the Jews to know it
The common answer, "i want them to know that we are peacefull pepole, and i want them to know that this is our land,all of that land, we will never give up on all of that, and israelis dont have any right here". Haahaha 😂. Realy peacefull ......
Muslims are not peaceful. They want to exterminate all Jews.
Yes Lol they clearly live in an echo chamber of delusion
Maybe you only heard what you want to. You didnt listen that they are treated as second class cirizens in their own country, they cant travel freely, that they were living in peace with jews and christians before the jews started to take over the whole land.
Funny is the selective hearing of israelis😂
@@eden3685Its called Islam
standing your ground that this is your homeland, while simultaneously saying you dont want to fight is not exceptional. I would say its normal. Dont israelis say this is our land and we dont want to fight? They are also saying we just want to have more rights than you and frankly we really just want you guys to go away. correct me if i am wrong.
"Our religion does not allow us to be violent" 😂😂😂
butthurt much?
Yes that's a fact. But of course if you oppress people there will be revenge. Judaism also doesn't preach violence but there's a lot of violence from the Israeli settlers..
@@6eeykwr2no
@@6eeykwr2 Sahih Muslim 2922 calls for the specific extermination of the Dews. Now be careful sitting down...
Tell me how did the ww1 and 2..just for example 🤔
You should really put in notation that this was BEFORE the current conflict
During
How do you know it was before?
@seuntimilehin3381 description
He writes it in the description
Which they all knew will come and celebrated
Well, they certainly were clear about it. Depressingly clear.
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
At least they are honest, not like the European invaders who claim to be the descendants of the old ancient Israelites 😂😂😂😂
These delusions are what is killing their children and still they keep sacrificing them
Absolutely agree with this. It’s mostly poor education
@@LinoynooyYou mean, how European settlers came were given an ethno-state without democratic say from the Palestinians and then cleansed from their land? They should accept it is what you’re saying
The same delusions that are killing israeli children.
@@apzzpademocratic say from plaestinian ? I ll ans that after you point out the capital of gaza
@@Devrajsingh-vc1hq You need to retype that sorry. Doesn't make any sense
De radicalization is pretty important here id say
of israelis too
@@waafwafwafafyou don’t know Israelis
@@dBer-lu8cu We know their elected political leaders though.
Sure, but I think radicalisation is an interesting term to use in this case.
I'd say people who are in a conflict are radicalised by norm. They would consider it normal, outsiders would consider it radical.
Though, as an outsider I can understand why a poeple who feel oppressed would say such things, hold and voice such opinions.
However unrealistic and unproductive I might find them. It's a dream, an ideal, similar to how people irrationally cling onto religion in times of hardship.
In my experience, in this conflict there are valid grievances and worries on both sides and there is a lot of propaganda being echoed on both sides.
In the end they will both have to compromise to come to an agreement, significantly more so than a lot of people on both sides would deem acceptable. And thus it continues, since being in an active conflict with each other, is not a firtile breeding ground for compromise.
My two cents.
@@dBer-lu8cuI know Israelis. Unfortunately. The only people that made problems at my med university even though we had more Arabs compared to them. Arabs were Wery helpful and peaceful (most of them Palestinians but not only), but Israeli Jews were making small groups only with each other and always made problems for others to make it harder to pass exams (sneaking to the head of the departments and lying about that we have answear for next credits so they changed it so it wasn’t even based on our books or lectures). Thankfully I’ve passed everything at first terms so I didn’t suffer later because of their jealousy as people who were struggeling a lot due to them. All I knew about them: jealous, fake superiority complex but inside deep inferiority complex, think that everybody hates them and if you don’t agree- bum antisemitic card 😂
Both Corey and Monamie are so great for doing this. Corey is travelling to places where he is clearly unwelcome, while Monamie has to say things to her people that they clearly would prefer not to hear. Both are doing amazing work to educate us. These videos should be displayed all over the land.
Thank you for the support and recognition.
Please share the videos as much as you can.
Also sick of seeing the Arab propaganda. People have been in the Middle East since they first left Eastern Africa. These were not Arabs. In fact there are many non-Arabic Afro-Asiatic languages which existed before "Arabs" as a population.
You want to talk about watered down atheist ”jewish” people with one grandparent jewish who now claim that they are jews just to fill up Israel?😂
Embarassing today to see who claimed to be jewish in Israel.
Russians who dont even know their religion, quickly learning some judaism to be able to move to israel. Come on now…you are all watered down😂
In what kind of hololululu school did you learn that kind of bs? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
UNRWA's message to the Palestinians? You can choose war over peace and still expect to get everything you want.*
Some humanitarian groups seem to be backing global terrorism because they're too keen on showing the world how tolerant they are. They've got this long list of people to blame, all because they want to look good. This leads them to value the wrong things, like how much aid they can give out, instead of aiming for true fairness and helping people become self-sufficient
They should be all about fairness and neutrality, helping people to a point where they can stand on their own, and then moving on to help others in need elsewhere.
Take the situation with the Palestinians and UNRWA after the 1948 War of Independence.
The real issue started when the choice was made to go to war instead of living in peace with Israel. That war led to Palestinian defeat and the creation of UNRWA to help the resulting 750,000 refugees. Fast forward to today, three generations later, and UNRWA says there are 5.9 million Palestinian refugees eligible for their services. (Remember that these humanitarian groups measure themselves by the size of aid provided.)
UNRWA has a unique definition for Palestinian refugees that includes not only the original refugees from the 1948 and 1967 conflicts but also their descendants. This definition is broader than the one that the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) typically uses, which does not include descendants in refugee status. Effectively, the agency increased its responsibilities by a factor of 8 with its new definition.
The fact that Palestinians are still considered refugees is due to their bad reputation.
Everyone in the Middle East knows how they have earned this reputation by starting conflict in Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Kuwait and Tunisia. Many of these countries still have not recovered. No one wants Palestinians to integrate into their societies. But this also reflects a failure by UNRWA to get the people self-sufficient and prioritize civic responsibilities over the priority of conflict and the destruction of Israel.
Over 74 years, UNRWA's become huge, with 13,000 people working there, still handling all basic services for Palestinians.
UNRWA keeps focusing on Palestinian victimhood and doing jobs that a government should be doing.
This overlooks the big picture: the refusal to accept Israel and the decision to wage war. Choices were made and priorities were set-not to work towards coexistence or economic partnership but to risk everything for war. Decisions have consequences.
But if you ask UNRWA, there shouldn't be a fallout from these decisions. Seventy-five years on, and we still have Palestinians in camps, hoping to reverse their defeat.
UNRWA's stance that Palestinians are merely victims without pushing for real societal and behavioral change has led to a cycle of dependency. They turn a blind eye to military efforts and validate historical grievances, ignoring the lack of accountability. While Hamas builds tunnels and missiles and the PA rewards violence, UNRWA remains silent.
UNRWA's message to the Palestinians? You can choose war over peace and still expect to get everything you want.
That's a dangerous mindset
In 1948 about 700,000 Arabs became refugees and were put in refugee Camps, and they still live there hand folded and with no hope, and UNRWA encourage them to stay refugees for ages.
In 1948 till 1950, about 900,000 Jews from Arab countries were expelled and went to Israel. Israel absorded these refugees and gave them housings and jobs even Israel had not enough money for itself at that time.
Excellent summary. Thanks for posting.
@@simko8665 And Israel suffered greatly for it. The implications of accepting so many refugees and actually helping them make a life for themselves are felt in Israel to this day. It's definitely been a net positive, but only after decades of hard work for everyone involved.
Hit the nail on the here man
I’m tired of commenting this, but here we go again. It’s quite simple and we saw from this video (as in others): Palestinians don’t want Israel to exist even in the 1947 UN approved borders. It’s not that they want to have their country only, but it’s also that they want to erase Israel from the map, in many cases altogether with its people. They don’t want a two state solution, they want something similar to what was once called the final solution
Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us.”
― Golda Meir
“Let us not ignore the truth among ourselves … politically we are the aggressors and they defend themselves… The country is theirs, because they inhabit it, whereas we want to come here and settle down, and in their view we want to take away from them their country" - Ben Gurion, first Prime Minister of Israel
These people are delusional
@stopmotionprime13 no I'm pretty sure you are the delusional one here lol
Do you want to mess with nucler power? U are delusional @@edihayat
I always thought the Israelis are delusional
you would have said the same thing when the Algerians were fighting for their independence...
@@JeanValjean587No
@8:00 "Our religion does not allow us to be violent."
Looks like some of them forgot to ask their religion for permission...
They do have a sense of humor 😂😂🎉
The joke's on them I'm afraid. Quite soon, there will be nothing left of "Palestine" in Gaza.
Apparently they saw some comments from people "one more time those Swedes". And then they believe it - "it's the Swedes, it's not us".
The term "Taqiyya" comes to mind
Palestine was a British territory not an Arab country. Israelis fought and won to keep the land they belonged to, time for the Arabs to understand that.
I don’t support both parties for me you’re both just completely stupid full of violence nations
A dutchmen is not a german while both european
You mean Britain occupied it and then you swallowed it
The thing about being a peaceful neighbor is that one doesn't have to declare that for the neighbor to know it, it's obvious on it's face. They will be known by their fruits.
and Israel showed their "peaceful" fruits by continously building settlements into palestinian lands to prevent a palestinian state. this goes both ways.
@@grasswarlock palestinians did a way more to prevent a palestinian state unfortunately..
@grasswarlock israel investing millions to build schools hospitals roads businesses and so on....that Arabs Christians and Jews could work and live side by side... but you call it settlements... 😅
@@Ayalatara "we can take your country from you if we build schools"
@@grasswarlock Do you know when the "illegal" settlements started? After the Intifadas, the government started approving them since they increased the security of Israel. We have been invaded too many times and too many attacks came from the West Bank.
They are not preventing a Palestinian State or preventing peace. This is just a lie Abbas keeps repeating. Why do I say that? Because the peace offers included removing almost all of them. Look up the offer made by Olmert to Abbas (2006~2008).
They want the land, they need to come back to the negotiation table with a more serious intent to peace, not as a Khudibayya Agreement.
We get everything and you get nothing, a tale as old as Islam.
💯
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
Islam is to submit your well to the lord of Abraham
So it's the religion of Adam
@@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zz Wrong.
Hateful and racist comment! Take a look at the mirror!
They will never get ahead until they realize it’s not Israel who is oppressing them.
you have no clue
@@nomylearnspalestine I actually do have one, do you?
dumb take
Quite a contrast to the Israeli responses in another video. Wow.
what do you mean?
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
@nomos6508 The Israelis said they wanted to live in peace with the Palestinians
@@Lily-sy5gz It has always been this way: Israelis want to live in peace side by side with Arabs, while Arabs want to live in Israel instead of the Israelis.
@@Lily-sy5gz there's no peace with occupation
End the occupation and apartheid with the border of 1967 and let the refugees come back
Wow, these ppl have absolutely no concept of historical perspective. Either they are collectively lied to or this was just really bad sample.
Collectively lied to…
No they' re right, at the end of the day it's their land. You can't come to a country and expel people like to Gaza and tink that there won't be any revenge or whatsoever..
Maybe they should be thankful that they were forced to live their villages...irony off
do you think thousands of years ago trumps 50 or 100 years ago?
Why do you say they have no concept of historical perspective? What falsehoods do you think they made?
Zionism is a collective lie. Falsely claiming Europeans have a genetic connection to land in the middle east. The zionists are so afraid of the truth they banned DNA testing in Israel hmmm I wonder why?
Been watching these videos for a while. The weaker their position is, the more they demand. Before they were saying 1967.
I just read the 18 demands by the Muslim Voters in the UK and so this comment adds to the ridiculousness
they don't take responsibility for their own actions for years. Teaching the kids for violence and blaming the Israeli government for their own terror, whether inside or outside the Palestinian authority.
When they accepted the borders of 67 Israel didn't accept "Land for Peace" Israelis brought a radical political leaders who want to trade them "Peace for Peace" and obviously they are not willing to accept that.
It took Europe hundreds of years to find peace between nations. England and France used to be bitter enemies, fighting the Hundred Years' War. Catholics and Protestants clashed violently during the Thirty Years' War. Germany and France fought each other in two World Wars. But now, they've learned to live together and even work together in the European Union.
Peace doesn't happen overnight; it's a long, tough process. But there's hope for Israel and Palestine too. Even though there’s a lot of pain and ongoing conflict, people are still working towards understanding and cooperation. Peace agreements like the Abraham Accords between Israel and some Gulf nations show what's possible.
If old enemies in Europe can become friends, there's hope for the Middle East too. It will take time and effort, but with patience and goodwill, Israel, Palestine, and the whole region can find a way to live together peacefully.
Take time and patience? You do realize that this fight between the people of the Islamic faith and the Jewish faith date back centuries. The Palestinian argument is recent b/c Palestinians are a made up people.
Are you aware that this conflict has been around for way longer than a few hundred years?
I do wish both sides will have the Will to have peace, or at least have 2 countries living next to each other quietly without war.
I say this as an Israeli born and raised.
Sometimes we forget the recent past.
One successful country, Israel, next to another poor arab country
@@brandonlefton1346 yes because there have been a lot of investments from the US and western countries in Israel also in the Startup area. And there's no Arab Country, only oppressed people....
14:38 this is why the war never ends
this is a really interesting question. And I'm glad Monami is back
Thanks! It was nerve wrecking to be honest...it's very tense..
Result of UNRWA education
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
That old meme.
Great question! It really reveals alot about their thinking without sounding political.
They believe Mohamed flew to heaven on a donkey and god told him to conquer the world. It’s not a far leap for them to think they’re native to Judea.
butthurt much?
Too much. Fun fact - Even the face of donkey is of human @@6eeykwr2🤠
Yes because Israel is also not a religious country either is it?...
@@6eeykwr2 no. you?
@@aykutlondon4784 no it’s not. It’s the home of the Judaen people. Jews are from Judea. Comprende?
"We're a peaceful people...who have nothing left but a rock." wtf
يلا لا تزعل هي الحقيقة مو انتوا المظلومين الفلسطينية المظلومين .
@@S_s_nI mean violent is not the answer neither with Israel
صح ليس حلاً ، ولكن إذا عدنا إلى التاريخ سنجد من كان يهاجم اولاً @@Linoynooy
the translation is not accurate 100% but anyhow it is very interesting that you ignore that she said the there is a way to live in peace!!
@@Saf-gu4ep It's hard to take someone seriously when they say they want peace from the other side but violence from their own
If their lives were all that awful they'd be more receptive to compromise. Apparently, they're fine with the status quo, indefinitely.
They are the Owners of the Land, they dont need to Compromise with a Colonizer..
@@FactsChecker007 No they are not. They have been owned by various empires throughout history. Also comparing Colonizing to Jews in that land is a bit different since Jews were in that land before Islam even became a thing.
@@FactsChecker007 lol no they are not.
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
@@FactsChecker007 thats kinda the grand lie at the hard of the israeli palestinian conflict. Not only does it not make sense but let's say it were true - they are the only rightful owners of this land. The conclusion is by no means that there should be no conpromise and def not solutions like october 7th, riots that harm innocent diaspora jews and acts like the man who raped a jewish woman "for palestine" in france.
They are faced with a problem, and the way its being treated is utterly irrational, immoral and wrong.
Your channel is precious my friend! Thank you for your work!
Products of an UNRWA education....
Palestinians are better Educated than israeli's per capita .. you are just ignorant
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
@@FactsChecker007
Really? Didn’t know Palestine won over 13 Nobel prizes like Israel did, pretty amazing…
Oh wait they only have 1… about peace… which didn’t last…
Israelis are equally brainwashed and superstitious. Mixing religion with politics is totally wrong for Israel's people and its government.
@@FactsChecker007 Source?Trust me ,lol neverland pepole are so dumb,0 brain,
"our religion does not allow us to be violent" - yeah right
does judaism allow violence?
@@sarahgirard1405sure does
@@fuuz642 hm
It’s like they all read from the same depressing script.
"depressing script" you mean asserting their right to their home which is being stolen from them?
any human being would respond the same way to occupation
@@Undoublethinkful no they wouldn't. where are the native american suicide bombers? the Tibetan baby beheaders? the Maori mass rapists? the Uighurs launching rockets at Han chinese? Just because your so racist as to believe Palestinians are too dumb or barbaric to find an alternative to violence doesn't mean the rest of us have to be bigots too.
as if israelis are different
@@Undoublethinkful no they wouldn’t. Your obfuscating religious extremism for a land conflict
@@mda990 in these videos they are
That they are mentioned nowhere in the Torah, Bible and Quran.
The 1st person is exactly the mentality that scares me, I mean understandably but if we constantly do to each other what the "other side" did to us that's just literally exchanging torches.
They are completely delusional. It's scary.
I read your comment before listening to his response. I strongly disagree with his opening statement. But you didn't criticize his opening statement; you criticized his follow-up about "trading places": "if we occupied them, what would they think of the situation?"
If the answer to that question scares you, well, what does that really say about the situation?
@@silentiumestaureum1 I would ask, why didn't they "resist" Jordan and Egypt as well? Their violence is selective only against Jews
If they traded places...
If the arabs and the Palestinians won the 1948 war, the Israeli's would be dead.
If the arabs and the Palestinians won the 1967 war, the Israeli's would be dead.
If the Palestinians traded places with the Israeli's, the Israeli's would be dead.
@@dani-ks9cg No… it's because they weren't asked for their opinion before the UK decided to sell out the land they were on (talking about british mandate).
How about asking them "how long can one be considered as a refugee, how many generations"? Their religion doesn't allow violence??😂ABSOLUTELY HOPELESS. I am astonished, however, how brave you are going to these places...
simp
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
Israel has been the occupier since 1948, look at the UN resolution if you don't believe me.
Maybe 3000 years ish?
@@Ahmed-oq3ugdamn correct bro😂😂
Thanks!
There will come a generation of peace one day, but not soon. All the rest of us better start buckling up for a lifetime of this nonsense.
I mean isn't 76 years the lifetime of many, already (also I do hope many still are granted an even longer & healthier life in every heaven right)? I feel we here who are in their Teens to 40s just may "woke up to this nonsense even (still) existing?" (And egoistically sometimes I wish I didn't because my partially hippy heart breaks apart when I see children paying for (alleged) sins of their x-time (great-)(grand-)parents.
unless a future israeli goverment would finally start acting according to the international rules and lift the opressive barior andgive the palestinians the freedom that they deserve and eventually the resistance would be no longer needed and would fade away
@@dzart8460 They already did it in August 2005 when Israel gave them Gaza. We all saw how the "peaceful palestinians" thanked them on October 7th
@@dzart8460but you saw some say they would never stop "resisting" until there is no Israel.
@@dzart8460
Totally true.
The jews are stealing land in the West Bank.
Burning their houses , killing them.
This is completely ignored by the pro "Israel", read jew supporters.
There is a story on both sides. And Israel is not doing peace a favor, and that's already for a long time the case.
And the Hamas bunch , same.
3:24
"We are peaceful people. We are an Arab Islamic people country"...
De facto, something wrong with that sentence....
That person is 100% correct. Palestinians welcomed homeless jews who were running from hitler and later jews started slaugthering the people who welcomed them in their houses.
Several things are wrong. They're not peaceful, they're not a country and they're definitely definitely not a peaceful country
We peacefully came and conquered Jerusalem ancient Jewish land and planted a mosque on top of Jewish holy sites and claim it for themselves like they did in Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, northern Africa everywhere they went the pushed out the indigenous people.
@@hannahanderson4305 why are you trying to link modern day Palestinians to what happened in the Arab conquests, over 1,000 years ago?
@@kingcobra8840 Because it's the same malarkey, the same set of ideas and ideology that is non-conducive to peace.
That peaceful lady saying she is peaceful, while saying that Jerusalem is Muslims' land. lol
It was Jews thousands of years before Islam even existed
Simply it boils down to one's values. If you love dictatorship, islam, Sharia law, martyrdom, jihadis, oppression and persecution of women, apostates, and gays - you side with Palestinian jihadis. If you love democracy and human rights (however imperfect), life, pursuit of happiness, progress - you side with Israel. People try to sympathise with those who give out candies when Jewish children are stabbed or those who celebrated 9/11 attacks and so on...
I was not surprised.
For me is very clear what can happen if these people will have the same power as Israel. In one day they will start the war and try to make 7th October again.
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
What claim do they have on Jerusalem?
Al Asqa mosque. Try to educate yourself.
@@The_Voice_of_Reason748 oh that thing that was built on top of the temple mount? So you build on top and suddenly it's a claim? Strange
@@diannafeliciano5208 It was used as a dumping ground before the mosque was built.
@@The_Voice_of_Reason748 actually you are the one who should try to educate yourself
The Romans were as**oles like that@@The_Voice_of_Reason748
Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad speaking on Al-Hekma TV said in March 2012:
“Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians…”
What are Israelis ? Aren’t they Polish and Russian and Moroccan and everything else?
@@Zahra-lc3mj Did they murder us and forced out in Poland because we are Polish? In Russia because we are Russians or in Marroc because we are Maroccan? No, because we are Jews, wherever we were forced to live in exile.
@@Zahra-lc3mj Not genetically. Jews may have lives in various countries throughout history after the Roman expulsion but are still ethically different from the majority population of whatever country they were living in.
@@lioness_of_Judah
Even if our genetics not related to the grandchildren of Israel, Being Jews gives us the right to own this land
There is not one "pure" race, everyone has mixed heritage and DNA. Palestinians as well as Israelis. Palestinians have jewish heritage., like the Israelis., mixed with other heritage.. The problem is that the state of Israel are taking their human rights.
The facts are: before Zionism, "Palestine" was a backwater. Yes, the Jews had help learning how to cultivate the land, but the Jews are who made Israel a thriving successful country. The arabs and Turks did not do that.
So when Arabs say Jews come from all over the world, they're unintentionally making the case that even though the Arabs were already there for so many years, they did not make anything out of the land. It was a backwater plagued by malaria.
The Jews built it up from nothing!
עם ישראל חי!
Mate....Before Zionism there was peace for the most part. Before zionism all religions living in relative harmony.
Talking about thriving as in riches, but we're not talking about the billions in aid Isreal gets just for the fuck of it.
But a colonial state is a colonial state. The Brits did the Indians no good and they thrived in India, no?
Neither did the Dutch and Swedes in Western Africa, The brits almost anywhere they set foot, the french and Algeria....It only brought misery to the natives. And that sorry of an excuse you just said was LITERALLY what every white supermicist in Europe since the 1800s said to justify taking other people's shit.
Justifying theft, land grapping, genocide, kidnapping (even kidnapping Mizrahi Jewish kids when Israel was created cause Ashkanazi Jews saw them as Inferior), rape....Countless crimes they commited against humanity but hey.....They are making money!
We would rather be in a malaria backwater than have you invade us and build the land thank you
Both sides MUST learn to co-exist. That's the only viable solution.
@@Han-es8qu one side knew the other side didn't. The more the one side tried to co exist the more terror the other side chose . Extreme breads extreme more and more israelis are smarter today and don't believe in peace in forcing peace on people who don't know peace in their heart
Does not matter. There were ppl living in that land, then came millions of Jews, created a mass immigration crisis and a foreing institution (UN) gave that land to Jews in spite of palestinians. Anyone here would be pissed.
For example, I am from Brazil. Imagine if a bunch of brazilians indigenous Guarani ppl started migrating to my city and the UN said that the city is now Guarani and that I should leave, what would you have me do? Pack up and leave? Leave my relationships, the structure, the oportunities... to start from scratch anywhere else because some outsider decided that I should? Hell no!
they look so oppresed oh my god the horrors 🤣.stupid people led by hate
بصراحة انتوا شكلكم عبيط ومقرفف🙂
Terrible crowd
You are actually. You know how this will end. Back to where you came from.
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
weather one agrees with them or not - this is such an important project, thank you so much gil and all your helpers!!
Powerful and scary 😬😳
The painful truth, together with the videos of October 7th it's crystal clear what the "palestinians" would do if they were the strong side
@@dani-ks9cg So does that justify what idf are doing?
Who the Israeli State?
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
@@stefansollberger5658 the obvious fact palsetinians don't want no peace, never had.
His religion does not allow them to be violent, except for history.
Which civilization has not committed genocide?
@@maxx_thedragondominator every civilization has. Especially muslims in the name of their religion. India, armenians, coptics etc.....
If his religion prohibits violence, imagine if it didn’t 😅
@@laurenzb.1919 especially the white Western people committed massacres, you have to say! Not Muslims! Almost every country in the world is a colonisation of the West, bigot
@@maxx_thedragondominatorwell Muslims a long time ago were… COLONIZERS
Israelis were in israel before the arabs.
If you want peace you must know truth
Thanks
“Our religion doesn’t allow us to be violent” LMAOOOOO
the jews say the same LMAOOOOO 🤣But they act even worse despite that they say they are angels ! Funny isn't it 🤣
Islam:
Al-Bayhaqī. Al-Sunan Al-Kubrá #15896: "Written on the Prophet ﷺ’s sword as a reminder to all, 'Verily, the worst of people in insolence are those who strike at whoever did not strike them, a man who kills those who did not fight him.'
Sahih al-Bukhari 3015: "Narrated Ibn `Umar: During some of the Ghazawat of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) a woman was found killed, so Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) forbade the killing of women and children."
Christianity/Judaism:
Deuteronomy 13: 6-9 "If your very own brother, or your son or daughter, or the wife you love, or your closest friend secretly entices you, saying, “Let us go and worship other gods” (gods that neither you nor your ancestors have known, gods of the peoples around you, whether near or far, from one end of the land to the other), do not yield to them or listen to them. Show them no pity. Do not spare them or shield them. You must certainly put them to death. Your hand must be the first in putting them to death, and then the hands of all the people."
Ezekial 9: 5-6 "As I listened, he said to the others, “Follow him through the city and kill, without showing pity or compassion. Slaughter the old men, the young men and women, the mothers and children, but do not touch anyone who has the mark. Begin at my sanctuary.” So they began with the old men who were in front of the temple."
1 Samuel 15:3: "Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass."
The person is correct. Palestinians didn't move to Eastern Europe and start fighting jews, it's the jews that moved to Palestine and started killing and expelling Palestinians from Palestine.
Well we don't have amalikites in our religion
These attacks are individuals
Excellent work
If they were to say that they originally came from Egypt and Saudi Arabia. We all know that they came to a land that was literally empty of people after the massacres performed by the Byzantines and the Romans against the original Jewish and Samaritan inhabitants.
I really enjoyed listening to the perspectives of the man at the end
What are Palestinians? What is their historical claim to the land? Who was their king or their leaders? What was their currency? How come there is no letter “P” in Arabic and they named the land with a word that they cannot pronounce? How can they explain that everywhere in Israel there are historical and archeological proof that Israel and the a Jewish people been living on the land of Israel for 3,500 years and the a Jewish people are the indigenous from the land. There are 40 references in their Quran about Israel and 0 zero about Palestine.
" I m a Palestinian.from 1921-48 I carried a Palestinian passport"- Golda meir
We found a map of Palestine of 1897,1905,1947
We found a coin of 1928 where Palestine is written
Palestine is mentioned in Balfour declaration official letter which was written before fall of Ottomans
We found a driving licence of an Palestinian Arab of 1942 where government of Palestine is written
We found a flag of Palestine with a picture of Al Aqsa mosque
We found the passport of Shimon Peres
" Granted Permission as a immigrant in Palestine by the government of Palestine "waz written
In a Speach
Hitler once said
" We won't attack the following counties:
Iraq Syria Palestine Arabia Poland Russia Britain "
We found a passport of a Palestinian man of 1947 where Palestine is mentioned
" Every Israeli town were built on top of
Palestinian Arab villages"- Moshe Dyan
Very funny the letter P story ,,, what about Egypt ?? Can you claim that Egyptians have no history?? Egypt is older than your god
the level of brainwashing in this comment, you're literally listing the talking points you are taught. this letter "P" thing is so silly. that's like saying how come the Chinese don't have the letter C in their alphabet. It's a different language for god's sake. Palestinians speak Arabic, it is called Falasteen in Arabic. and what do you mean historical claim? You mean like in the bible? Not everyone in this world believes religion is a nationality
@@AbrarJahin-vs8yz The word for Egypt in Arabic is pronounced "misr," likely coming from the ancient Hebrew name for the area, "Mizraim"
@@AbrarJahin-vs8yz not palestinians - ARABS, simple brainwashed ARABS!!!
I really think both the audience and the interviewees would benefit from you framing questions within a certain set of parameters. Prefacing the video by framing each topic and defining the question under those parameters would actually make this channel amazing.
Why?
No, the point is that the questions come directly from viewers, and the answers come directly (unedited) from the interviewees.
@@thewkovacs316 because both the way the questions are delivered and how they are answer very often seem muddled
@@benb6527 I get the point. I have been watching the channel for years . I really enjoy it but I am saying that if the question were framed better and given context the answer given would be better . Still all the same people with unedited answer … just better given framing and context
How can I send in a question?
:23 “ They should know that they have no rights here.” - Thank you for showing us non stop how there is no two state solution/delusion.”
Haven’t heard a single thing that someone can understand that could help anything.
Like Israelis have their ears open right now. You have you eyes closed. Of course you dont want to hear or see that you are breaking international law and unlawfully occypying and settling multiple areas and not giving equal rights to another people.
“This has always been our land” Jews lived there thousands of years before, and they built a mosque over our Temple Mount. Most can’t even pronunce Palestina correctly because it’s a Roman Latin word.
“We welcomed them” literally tried everything to fuck with the Jews who lived in the region, way before they started calling themselves Palestinian, there was a tradition of slaughtering Jews during the month of Ramadan. It’s documented as the rabbis used to send letters to the Ottoman authorities to provide more security in Jerusalem during Ramadan because of this.
Unbelievable lol
simp
Bollox
😂
@The_Voice_of_Reason748
Quote from Zuheir Mohsen a senior member of the Palestine Liberation Organization,
"There's no such thing as a separate Palestinian people, there's no difference between Jordanians Palestinians Syrians... the Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons. The creation of a Palestinian state is a new instrument in our ongoing war against the state of Israel and for the purpose of our Arab unity.
"Mohsen himself stated that there were "no differences between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians, and Lebanese", though Palestinian identity would be emphasised for political reasons. In a March 1977 interview with the Dutch newspaper Trouw he stated that "between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese there are no differences. We are all part of one people, the Arab nation [...] Just for political reasons we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity. Because it is of national interest for the Arabs to advocate the existence of Palestinians to balance Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons", representing the Ba'athist perceptive regarding the question of Palestine"
Jews lived there but not the Jews of Poland, Ukraine, Russia and America 😂😂
Yeah, sure, big guy! ALL the Arab Nations are SO happy to help their Palestinian brothers and sisters.....
For a question that was meant to promote reconciliation, these answers were highly revealing (as was the inability of most to understand the purpose of the question).
“The Palestinian nation is struggling…. Not to kill”. The struggle is REAL!
I laughed out loud at that
"We have nothing left but a rock" said the Palestinian girl standing in front of 2024 model cars and a bustling market,,,, The amount of self awareness can only match her second sentence of "we are muslims...peacfull people"
same exact woman said that there is a way to live in peace... and it is interesting that you ignored everything she said but this sentence!!!
RE, I'd like the question to be asked: were you ever taught about sharing in childhood, in school?
Ask the Palestinian people about their Jewish ancestors and how they needed to convert to Islam
They look prosperous, nice clothes, cars, shopping. They are a peaceful people and only want peace for Israelis - rest in peace!
Israel is historically Jewish. They should go back to Egypt and Saudi Arabia while they can.
nobody cares about your history! We are in 2024 A.D.
Depressing people:(
dehumanised and opressed people
They used to live in Palestine and Jews came to steal their land to occupy and steal their home leading to 8 milion refugees and replace them with Jews from Poland, Ukraine, Russia, British....etc
That piece of land was Ottomans and before that it was Jews, at least they can go study history
I dont need to watch the video to know their answers
These people.... I have no words. Not ready for peace.
U guys killed their kids
Still U expect them to do peace with U !
Whith who exactly to speak about peace? They belive in what they want to belive and what their leaders teaches them, the hate.
@@AbrarJahin-vs8yz But this is exactly the reason why their kids are dying...
The moment you don't see peace and negotiations as a viable option but only war and resistance, then your kids will die in that war which you keep on promoting and pushing for. Wars only bring more death.
@@AbrarJahin-vs8yz they killed their own kids by using them as human shields and supporting their genocidal government
@@AbrarJahin-vs8yz do u see jews blowing themselves up because of Germany? or Natives doing this to Americans? except Palestinians actually are not from there.
Biggest victim card I've ever seen. 🍉
So are you a rapist or just a regular terrorist? Your mother wants to know.
Is that an israeli flag designed imprinted on the ground at 2:00?
The imprinted designe is of the Star of Lakshmi(made of 2 squares) and the israeli flag have the star of david(made of 2 triangle). So no, it's not related to the israeli flag in any way.
The last man was so correct. He even sighted a UN resolution in response to being asked “why would Israel accept the Palestinian refugees returning?” Maybe because it’s part of the rules of war? Maybe cuz it’s part of international law under the “right of return”. If the goal is peace, then surely governments following international law need to be at the heart of it. You know why many Israelis wouldn’t accept it? Because it wouldn’t be a Jewish state anymore if they did. They don’t want open democracy, they don’t want diversity, in their true, pure forms. They want a gerrymandered, discriminatory, illegal form of “democracy”, that always has a Jewish majority. If you’re an Israeli or if you’re sympathetic to the Zionist cause and you’re reading this, please ask yourself, would it be ok, even with a two state solution, to have an Arab as your president or prime minister? Because in an open democracy that is a realistic possibility. And don’t tell me that you already have Arabs in the Knesset, they hold basically no power. I’m talking about top positions in government. The ruling party. I am in favour of a one state solution with open democracy but I’ve heard Israelis who are in favour of a one state solution say that they would want the Arabs who live in the hypothetical one state, presumably named Israel, to vote in Jordanian elections! People say that is an extreme view, and I would agree, but I haven’t heard a single moderate Israeli view that follows international law, and allows for an open democracy. That’s all the majority of Palestinians are asking for, but I don’t think you can say the same for the majority of Israelis, as it would mean the democratic erasure of their manufactured Jewish state, and a RETURN to what was before. A religiously, culturally, ethnically, diverse nation named PALESTINE 🇵🇸
A Blessed Chodesh Tov Iyar To All Am Yisroel And Friends Of Zion 💙🕊💙
Really peaceful people😐…
probably more peaceful than the Israelis
@stefansollberger5658
You are delulu
@@stefansollberger5658 🥴
@@user-vm6qx2mx5z The thing is i used to work in a Kibbutz in 1996 for 3 months called Revivim. Now, i since i saw what happened to the Palestinian people, i regret this very much. I am feeling like a fool.
Angels in fact! Completely peaceful, innocent and lovely people. Excuse me, I must be sick now...🚽
So much anti-Palestinian hate in the comments, sad.
I personally think the Israelis (and the world) already know everything they need to about them.
that line of thinking is reductive and honestly kind of discriminatory. How would you feel if someone said the same of israelis?
@@nuklearboysymbiote oh sure. I guess “from the river to the sea” isn’t 🙄 hypocrites everywhere
@@QueenQaffir dodged the question very well i'd say
@@nuklearboysymbiote I didn’t dodge anything. The obvious went over ur head, per the usual.
@@QueenQaffir still didn't answer the question did ya. You're not honest with yourself
Zero accountability the Palestinians have
Victimhood is a hell of a drug
Only group of humans i know that are allowed to be defeated by war for 70+ years yet continue to be a refugee and seek vengeance
well the Israelis started the whole conflict
@@stefansollberger5658 you sound like my three year old niece blaming her two year old sister “she starrttteeddd”
@@stefansollberger5658lies
Is there any Arabic saying for putting oneself in anothers shoes? Are there an Arabic words for empathy and perspective-taking?
Is that a serious question or just showing the brainwashing Israel has been doing about arabs?
Is there a hebrew word for self-awareness
god the irony in this stupid comment. how about israeli occupiers put themselves in the shoes of the native palestinians who have had their land stolen from them?
Thats a good question. Eskimos have 200 words for types of snow.
I think in ar abic there are many words for terms that are important to their culture.....
And you can guess what these are
I'm gonna take your questions literally and answer them.
"Is there any Arabic saying for putting oneself in another shoes?"
Yes, there is. It is "Put yourself in my place" or "حط حالك محلي"
"Are there an Arabic words for empathy and perspective-taking?"
I guess with this question you meant taking the perspective of the person you're discussing with.
The answer would be yes. The saying from the first question also works in this situation. And in Arabic there are many words for empathy such as "شفقة" "أناة" "عطف" "مرحمة" ......etc
I am trying to wrap my head around the question and the answers given. Either I am not understanding the question, or the question isn't being answered. Maybe an Arabic speaker can help out here.
the girl on 10:00 is confused because the translation monami was giving her "... to know about US" so she didn't understand, if the question is coming from abroad and it says "what would you like for israelis to know about us" of course it doesn't make sense. The arabic translation of the questions asked should also be written, corey, as are the english ones, so that they are asked also in the same way.
Thank you for that.
The interviewees know I am Palestinian, so when I say "us" they know we are one and the same.
Your advice is really good and I will write all questions and the translations so they are more unified
❤
Honestly I don't think anyone there understands the conflict. They all seem either brainwashed or uninformed or both.
How would you feel if someone commented that towards your people?
@@nuklearboysymbiote who are my people?
@@laurenzb.1919 idk. I meant it in an abstract way. Whoever you think your people are. Imagine that.
They don’t have free speech and school/media only teach the narrative. They believe wholeheartedly that they are right.
There’s a very interesting video on this channel where he asks them about the history of Palestine. They all stuck with no answer.
right because you as a foreignor know better
Even the Jordanian and Egyptians "peace" is no more than Hudaybya "peace".
Now they are crying for a cease-fire, completely ignoring that Ham-a$$ broke a cease fire on the 7th of October.
This guy should be in charge of negotiating the peace deal
What amazing about them is how ignorant are they about their own history.
That’s amazing!!!
Sadly they already know what they want them to know
“Jerusalem belongs to us” they say a lot of things but this proves they probs don’t have proper education about history, Jerusalem spiritually & ancestry are a holy place for Jews, Muslim and Christian’s do have a history conquering Jerusalem but that doesn’t deny it’s the holiest city in Judaism. I mean holy place for Muslims in Mecca but for some reason nobody fights over that!
being a holy city for a religion doesn't take it away from its local people.
a Muslim from Nigeria isn't more entitled to Mecca than an Atheist from Arabia.
The Arabian Atheist is still at home in Mecca, the Nigerian Muslim is a foreigner.
@@user-jt8vj1vm6y Remind you that before 1900 Jerusalem had jewish majority, and the arabs expelled all the jews from the east, and destroyed a lot of cultural places.
Palestinians: What do you know about Palestine? Can you answer this:
1. When most of the Palestinians arrived in that region?
2. When the local Arabs started to call themselves Palestinians, by whom and why?
3. When did the Jews started to arrive in that region in the new era?
🤣here we go again with the silly history questions 😄move on! We are in 2024! Good Morning 🤪
@@sy-ys5094 Sorry, but we are still in 1948 with the rights of the Palestinians and the Jews.
Most of those who express their opinions here and also argue do not know what the correct facts are. It seems even yourself as well.
That's the reason why put here those questions.
You told here to move to 2024. What do you suggest to do which was not done in the lasr 76 years?
Still, can I have your answers for these three questions?
@@simko8665 is a history lesson enough to stop the conflict? That's what I'm saying. If it could have stopped it, it should have been stopped until now.
@@sy-ys5094 No, it won't stop it but at least they will know what's all about. Hearing only one side make people brainwashed and no effort will put sens into their heads.
I asked you what you suggest, what was not done till now that can stop the violence?
"Filmed before October 2023 war" is deceiving. The woman from 06:05 was filmed answering a post Oct 7 question in this video: ruclips.net/video/M_AR71W6l3M/видео.htmlsi=VcG0DqDfFN2WlSE6&t=344.
Faces filled with hatred
Ziopigs
@@HamadAl-zb2pu how your mumamed pig? fu** a ship today alrerdy?look at my picture,that your future rat :) we here for ever!
"We are peaceful and don't make troubles. We just want your land, your capital and your lives"
You must be joking. Ask you grandparents where they lived before 1947 before you say my country!
@@naturesound8660 since 1948 there are born as Israeli, wherever their grandparents were used to be born, in Europe, Iran, Yemen or British mandatory.
@@beatrixvanhonk6542
Born by the British on the Palestinian's land. So the British give you a land that is not theirs. Can you please tell me what was your borders were when Israel “born”?
@@naturesound8660 you don't have much clue about history? And why and how Britain came to "this job"? And how you can found a State and get it recognised internationally = by majority of world countries? And there are rules of wars? Did you ever hear Germany claims back its territory lost after WW2 ? Or of "indigenous" Germans who invented the "palestinian" way to get them back ?
Then you have to reconsider India in its borders of 1947 as well, similar circumstances. Bye bye Pakistan (and inform yourself, there was not a people of "paks"), bye Bangladesh.
This is Their capital,their land
Zionist theives stolen those lands
I know so many Arab Christians who resent phrases like 'Arab Islamic people'. Arabs seriously need to stop assuming they are one, giant monolith. They are not and should stop using phrases like this. Even among Palestinians (a tiny proportion of worldwide Arabs) there are different groups and tribes and religions.
I like ur channel but im sorry man the clear difference in how you treat / talk to Palestinians vs Israelis is clear as day. Bro let the Arabs talk and explain themselves instead of getting weird and intense . It’s like you make them answer the way you want bro take a breath wtf
The big difference between Israelis (Jewish people mainly, even though non Jews live in Israel) and Palestinians (which is completely people of the Islam faith) is that the ppl in Israel are okay with a two state solution and want peace. They don't wish death on other people, only those who are evil terrorist, while the Palestinians hate the Jews and want us dead. I wish there were Palestinians that wanted peace and to truly live in harmony. One day...I pray.
Please check your facts, After October 7th, more than 80% of Israeli citizens, Arabs included do not want a Palestinian state of any kind.
NO, not any more. I think that even the hardest leftists understand that a two-state solution is not on the agenda.
Palestinians are not all muslims… your way of framing things is not helpful
@@nuklearboysymbiote Less than 2% of Palestinians in the West Bank are Christians, less than 800 Palestinians in Gaza, less than 0.1% are Christians. Stop the nonsense
@@shainazion4073 why is it nonsense? I pointed out a technicality
"its our land" , its not your land because you stole it through conquest. Palestinians have been decolonized.
The most of the so-called Palestinians started to arrive in that region at the end of the 19th Century as migrant workers from all over the M.E.
Now they claim living there for ages.