Ikr? And also she also said to Lee that she finally found a home and now they just made her abandoned that and Aj and everyone that loved and cared about her. Like seriously. They should of continued it with the caravan and hoping that Christa would be part of the caravan group and her and Clem would be reunited, that would of made the comic amazing but no. They decided to just made this happen to Clem.
Exactly, not only that too, in the comic she literally refers to AJ as "baby", like...she's never done that or has ever been close to doing that. Total shitshow of a "story".
@@alfieakastacysmomakashortb5869 yea and the arc with clementine protecting AJ was only 2 games and part of season 2, and if the setup is this bad then the future isnt looking too good
@@alfieakastacysmomakashortb5869 I don't think the graphic novels can save the damage that has been done in the comic. The story may be good as a stand-alone but since it's connected to the games it will be a big problem.
Clemetine literally tells lee she is tired of running and found a home to settle down at. Makes no sense for her to leave. AJ and Ericson IS her happiness.
This comic in a way makes clementine look like a hypocrite. In season 4 she tells AJ that they are done running, and she tells AJ that you can't break promises, so why is clementine doing the opposite in this.
@@attackontitanfollower yea I guess you can break a promise about staying where "home is" but you can't break one that involves leaving/killing someone you love who got bit. Seems right lol
They should’ve just made a story about the children finding a more permanent home.. the school is LITERALLY half burnt down and rotting.. thats not good for protection OR the inhabitants health. Make a comic about the kids finding a suitable LONG TERM home.
@@neverlackinquando3275 or have story about them rebuilding ericsons, it wouldn’t need any big conflict, just small things like ‘we need to find wood for this stable’ or something like that
This comic sneak peak is absolute dogwater.... baby?! When the hell has Clem ever called AJ that? Also, it looks that AJ is at least 10 or 11 in this comic
16:20 EXACTLY 🤣🤣🤣 its either Aj or goofball lmaoo I dont think Tillie played the games thoroughly she just got a summary of it from Robert kirkman and went with it and wrote the comic it goes against EVERYTHING clem did from season 1-4
We can always pretend Clem has just gone to help another settlement and Aj has stayed behind to help Ericson’s. It’s still flawed but i think it’s better
WTF that can’t be it I’m literally crying 😭 What did they’re mean with new love? WTF this is bullshit clem is the best character and happy with Louis/Violet and AJ is like a little Son why would she leave her son and love just behind? This isn’t Clem🙁and why would she be sad when she got an Aj and a Love this is fucking Bullshit and of course her new ,,Love’’ is an Girl we can’t even decided.This is Bullshit
the 'im not happy' as clem's reasoning is the cheapest, most un-original idea they could've used im actually so mad lol they just wanted an easy scape to just write their own 'clementine alternative story' fanfiction. save that shit for wattpad
i can tell the writer(s) weren’t attached to the games nor did they ever play them prior to this project. they got the job and just decided to write their own novel completely out of character. at this point, they should’ve just written their OWN novel in their OWN universe with their OWN original characters. anyways, don’t let this taint the games for you guys, the games and clementine are so great and this just wasn’t even in character whatsoever. screw this being labeled as “canon.”
Tillie Warden (the writer) has played all of the games multiple times, as she said in the live stream. But I agree, this doesn't seem like Clem at all. She wouldn't just abandon AJ because she wasn't "happy." I think there's more to it than her being unhappy at the school. And to think that she was originally going to leave without telling AJ or anyone (before AJ caught her) is out of character.
Clementine is literally becoming like Jane 2.0 She left AJ and she was gonna leave without saying goodbye until AJ found her and because she want to leave because she’s not happy like wtf I guess the graphics novel is our only hope but wait for it for a year 🙄
You’re so right bro.... this Jane all over again. Just up and leaving. Clem’s a bad ass. But this?? They way they got Clem right now, I’m not down with it. It’s not like her to up and leave. Worse She calls aj baby... took me off guard. again that’s not like her. She normally calls him goofball. Then she’s heading up north to be with another group somewhere in the winter. I forget. Like what fuck is this???? To be honest I can wait a whole year for this. I’m in no rush. I might just forget about it. I’m Better playing the first walking dead to get this bullshit out of my head. Jesus Christ
They need to explain this sudden sadness and why aj cant even keep clem happy 😤 Aj would NEVER leave clem even if she said so he already proved that S4.... she really is a jane 2.0 and I hate it so much
I'm so dissappointed Dom 😭😭 Clem pulled a Jane and left everyone even AJ without telling him. Clem is his adoptive mom, she would never do that! Was I the only one who felt like she was a totally different character while reading? Just sad man, they should've left her happy ending alone. Thanks for reading it tho man on a video, now I'm really happy I didn't drive an hour to buy this crap
They got Clementine's character wrong by making her leave AJ because she's "not happy". She would never voluntarily leave him. Honestly the writers should have played or watched Season 3 and 4 to see how far she would go for AJ.
Tille Warden (aka the writer) has played all of the games multiple times as she said in the live stream. She seemed to understand her character and said that she would totally "hurt" someone if they hurted Clementine. But this is really out of character, not sure what Tillie was thinking 🤔
If the actual writer wrote this comic book it was going to be wayyyyyy different than that like what the heck is this writer doing he is just trying to separate clementine from Aj and others is he out of his mind or something?
@@attackontitanfollower nah it don’t if you look up stuff they give a general plot she leaves finds another group of kids some trouble some love ect she’s basically ruining the happy ending of season 4 to write a (in my head cannon and most people I’ve spoke to) spin-off clementine comic
No hate toward the writer of "Clementine Lives" personally, but I would have preferred a collaboration between Robert Kirkman and one/some of the Telltale writers. Kirkman knows how to create a story and develop character while the Telltale writers would have assisted in bringing a faithful Clementine (or AJ or any of the Telltale cast) to the comics.
OK. I came up with a way to make it make sense. Actually, the conversation with AJ was a daydream. The real reason she tells AJ. he can't come with her is he literally can't because he's dead. Everyone is dead and Clementine, unable to deal with losing everything yet again, deluded herself into thinking everything was fine and she just felt like leaving because she, "just didn't feel happy." She's leaving behind a house filled with ghosts, not her friends. She's not happy because she's alone.
@@ero-ko2218 Man, what really gets me is that it's not even good. It's not creative or clever, it's just he same thing over, and over, and over, but this way it at least it wouldn't desecrate Clementine's character and erase her personality.
NO NO NO I REFUSE TO BELIVE THAT THIS IS CANNON CLEM WOULD NEVER LEAVE AJ AND ALL HER OTHER FRIENDS AT THE SCHOOL LIKE THE WHOLE POINT OF THE FINAL SEASON WAS TO FIND CLEM AND AJ A SAFE PLACE TO CALL HOME SO WHY WOULD SHE LEAVE DAMN I AM SO DISAPOINTED.
Such horrible writing. I think every fan out there could've wrote this better. "I'm not happy". The fack she was litterly the happiest woman alive at the games ending. Hopefully it will get better but for now it looks like I'll have to lock it away in my memory
@@mqddy8094 If you failed to safe violet during the end of episode two, she does a complete 180 and hates Celmentine wanting to leave her and stay in the Delta. Yeah she was brainwashed and she apologized at the end but my point still stands lol.
While the comic is a good setup for the upcoming graphic novel, I wasn't really expecting Clementine's answer for leaving to be so... selfish. The comic itself didn't feel like it was nessecary as it could've been a part of the novel. It was way too short & just leaves so many can of worms open. Of course, this does leave us with more questions than answers. I'm not a fan of Clementine's decision of leaving AJ & obviously, they need to fully explain why but hopefully... it expands upon that in a way we understand. My expectations are low but overall, I'm willing to give it a try.
I think we should still keep our heads up. We don’t know what has happened since Take Us Back. I know it looks bad but there has to be a reason behind Clem’s change of mindset, however I’m not saying that these Comics could just be awful and the writer just didn’t play the games. All I’m saying is we should keep and open mind and not hate on the author. Btw I personally like the art style of the book ALOT.
That is not Clementine! *THAT IS NOT CLEMENTINE!* That is not AJ either. AJ would never leave Clementine just like he didn't even listen to her in James's barn when he chopped her leg to save her. What a joke
I don’t like jumping the gun so not gonna ask about the story…but the graphics? Like maybe I’ve read too much manga and my expectations are a bit high but like come on Clem and AJ look nothing like this😂
@@jaredcunningham3667 yes but comics in general should be consistent, what I meant was manga maybe I’m expecting too much cos I’m not usually reading comics but more manga
Yeah, I agree. The draws are really inconsistent, some are actually really good, like the desing of Clem in the last page, but some others pages are straight bad like at 16:31
this is so disappointing... I mean I’m a big fan of twdg series since the first game launched and seeing clementine so out of her character felt like ?? we had a whole game of her trying to get back to AJ and for her to leave him like that just because she wasn’t “happy” enough? she would never do that :/
I don't know how she can do this, probably the worst emotional feeling you can fell is not knowing were someone you love is or how there doing or if there even alive, like if you know there dead atleast then there's some closure and the wound can heal but if you don't know if someone's ok that wound can never fully heal so now if aj or clem dies or clem never goes back they will never know if the other is ok
Clementine: *cherished an actual home for her and AJ and achieves that by the end of the last season* The new comics: I'm gonna pretend I didn't see that
WTF. Do these “writers” even know why their fan bases like their games? I mean did the director of the Last of Us 2 come and possess the people working on the Walking Dead? Two amazing series reputations being tarnished. I don’t even care about Ericsson, it makes NO sense for Clementine to leave AJ. And for her to call him baby? I really wanted to see AJ development. He was apart of THREE seasons. He saved her life. You telling me a one legged person is going off wondering off in the woods alone, leaving AJ who is sharp shooter and would do anything to protect her? Because she’s not happy? Tf. My only theory is that comfort and placement makes Clem feel stagnant and bored as she so used to being a survivor and being alone. This is totally different from the video game clementine. This is not clementine, this is Orange.
@@abbyanderson2463 no it wasn't and Joel was the only character that was treated like this Clementine. When I see this Clementine, I always remember TLOU2 Joel.
Damn this was a really cool dream that Clem had. I can't wait to see what happens when she actually wakes up from this nightmare so we can get a real follow up to the final season. Genuinely would've preferred to get a story were we just follow Clem's daily routine years after the final season so we could see she's doing fine after everything not whatever this fanfic is.
it definitely feels like the writer hasn't played the games. Probably just knows the story of the games but that gives you no emotional attachment to the characters like actually playing the game does
I figured they would do something like this. THe whole series was based around branching storylines and creating 'your' Clementine. They were damned if they did and damned if they didn't regarding all the 'determinant' issues. So best thing to do was to just move on from it and begin an entirely new story.
They could’ve just made a comic abt the Ericsson kids before Clem and AJ showed up. Explain why (or expand on) the reasons why they were all sent there, show how the school and teachers treated them, show the teachers up and abandoning them. Show how they lost Ms. Martin and their greenhouse, put more depth in the characters and actually introduce us to people like Sophie. Show us the stress Marlon was under trying to keep himself and his friends alive, show us what they did and didn’t know about the outside world. Answer some questions . Is Omar really a God? How did Tenn get burnt, and did Aasim (the local fire manic) have anything to do with it? Also, Tenn is like 12 years old when we meet him and it has been like nine years since the apocalypse started; meaning Tenn was like 3 or 4. Why was this toddler in a school for troubled youth? Were Minnie, Sophie, and Tenn orphans before the outbreak and somehow managed to stay together? Did Minnie and Sophie leave to try and find their parents, just found Tenn, and decided to take him back to the school with them? And more importantly, show me puppy Rosie damnit. Show me Mullet Boy bonding with this cute baby puppy and how tf he taught her to kill walkers.
I have a feeling that she is returning to her home, where everything Has begun. Maybe he will try to find the Train, Lee, Motel, cannibal's farm and other things that were in season one. Maybe seeing all of this will make her happy, sińce she said shes not happy.
Well, just realized what I think I already knew. I didn't need this. I have the final season. It's a satisfying, worthy ending for Clementine. Whatever happens next is irrelevant, at best should be left to our imagination, based on our choices.
I hope this comic reading will not have a real bad ending unlike Games of Thrones, The Last Jedi or TLOU II which broke my mind. If there is a final season part 2, I probably loose my goddamn mind that Clementine is heading north and if she really is, I hope it won't be like Games of Thrones...
This ain’t Clementine. She would never leave aj after going through everything she did to not only protect him but find him. If feels like the only reason they did this was to wipe the slate clean for the novel and try to avoid making one choice branch cannon.
If AJ had died and she left because of that and the emotions with it I would’ve been ok with that compared to this bullshit. At least then it makes somewhat sense why she left and doesn’t ruin her character
@@adilwrld You gotta look at the bigger picture here, my bro. Skybound has an audience of bored 13 y/o's they need to titillate and get money from. That means they need to have Clem do a few rotations on the ol' CC and having some kid hanging around is like bussy repellent, so AJ has to go. It's for the greater good.
Speculation: Aj has been part of Clem's life for so long. And all she wanted was to find him a safe home, that was her purpose in life. But now, that's been full filled, she possibly feels empty and without a purpose anymore and maybe that's why she left?
I would love for Clementine to meet Javi and his family again in the Comic and why she never returned to new Richmond, who was new Richmond at war with, was it Lily and her group. Also will we once again see Lily in the upcoming books, also will Clementine find out what happened to Christa. I’ll really love for these things to happen in the books.
I’m not mad anymore I think I understand why Clem left, knowing AJ and the others will be ok being “helped” by the other 2 communities/coalition near by, she gets to enjoy time on her own, years used to protect AJ, now some alone time, I don’t agree that this is the best reason either but it still give me hope Starting at a 6/10 for me
I would have much preffered a Javi story. Where Richmmond is beetwen Delta and ANF in this big free for all battle. But I guess I have to find an idea to fix THIS crap..... What I would have done is have Louis,Violet,Tenn and James die off screen becouse they are determinent and so first page would show graves of all of them. So we would be left with Clem,AJ,Ruby,Willy,Aasim,Omar and Rosie. Half of this comic would be focused on how their lives are stable but not perfect. Half the school was already burnt down,there are no supplies in the area to fix it and food is so scarce they go entire days without a meal. Thus they decide to leave and head to Richmmond. I would still keep this plot of Richmmond vs ANF vs Delta of mine. We would see in this 2nd comic book some walker action,pass through the fishing shack and train station to have a nod to the games and it would end with them making a small camp in the woods. Thus an introduction to the trilogy is set.
Obviously this is after the death of Rick Grimes and the coalition is another term for the Common Wealth or as in the final issue the eastern and western alliances. Not sure how long after Rick Grime's died though. As for why it is obviously PTSD. The sad fact is this writer is following the standard format of ignoring everything that came before.
Hey dom I was replaying s1 again and when I was playing ep 3 after kenny’s family dies you can see he takes the picture of the train conductors family off the wall
Well to me i would rather make my own stories about Clem after the final ss because this doesnt make any sense AJ is everything to her, she has loved him with the love of a mother since ss2 and then in ss3 she didnt even care much about being alone or being betrayed, she just wanted AJ to be with her, and throughout the final ss i always teach AJ to do the right things like not to steal, to be apologize, not to lose manners when eating, etc... And always protect him no matter what everyone says about him. More than that in the dream with Lee on the train, she told him that she was tired of running and could finally find a place called home and a group that she liked more than any other groups before. Clem deserves to rest, someone should step up to protect her and the group.
Since were not going to be able to change it we can try to hope that they can salvage it. At one point in the 1st or 2nd book she needs to realize her mistakes and try to get back to the boarding school and the rest of the series could be her fighting through major obstacles on her way back until she finally reaches it and has the happy ending from season 4 kinda. That's the only way I can see than salvaging this if they don't do that this whole thing might just be fucked.
We’ve come so far with this game and it hurts knowing that we didn’t know what to expect from when first loading up s1 ep1. None of us knew how emotionally attached we’d become with this game. The characters we sacrificed and the tough choices we made built all of this up. This game had everybody on there toes at all times and i just want to say well done skybound for creating a masterpiece
Thanks for this Dom! Some counterpoints to consider: at the end of the Final Season she tells AJ to keep the hat, right? That season represented AJ, a child born IN the apocalypse, learning how to survive. He demonstrated even more ability than Clem did, because of his upbringing. Clem has never had a chance to live her own life. This is about her now. It sounds like the coalition has provided a broader community for the Ericson kids to be a part of, so why would they stay isolated at the school? All I see is a girl who can finally go on her own journey. We don’t always get to find out what happens to characters until later (or never) in TWD universe- hell, you don’t get their backstories half the time either. The apocalypse tends to make things a little bit hectic.
Everyone after this comic dropped: *Your relationship with Clementine has changed.*
Like I Prefer an goes then a conic
The Fans noticed that.
Don't blame her. Blame the Skybound.
@@kevinabri322 Don’t blame skybound, they publish it, blame Tillie.
@@PostCrisisRH who is tilla
I’m just gonna pretend the comic doesn’t exist and the canon ending in the game is the final ending
Yes
Agreed
Exactly
After this, I don’t plan on buying the comic at all
Same
This isn’t Clem, why wouldn’t AJ make her happy if literally half of her story arc was to find Aj, her one source of HAPPINESS left?
Ikr? And also she also said to Lee that she finally found a home and now they just made her abandoned that and Aj and everyone that loved and cared about her. Like seriously. They should of continued it with the caravan and hoping that Christa would be part of the caravan group and her and Clem would be reunited, that would of made the comic amazing but no. They decided to just made this happen to Clem.
Exactly, not only that too, in the comic she literally refers to AJ as "baby", like...she's never done that or has ever been close to doing that. Total shitshow of a "story".
Yea who knew 12 pages of a comic could ruin 3 games worth of a character arc
1. There's 4 games 2. This was a setup for tillies future stories so don't be too hard
@@alfieakastacysmomakashortb5869 yea and the arc with clementine protecting AJ was only 2 games and part of season 2, and if the setup is this bad then the future isnt looking too good
@@alfieakastacysmomakashortb5869 I don't think the graphic novels can save the damage that has been done in the comic. The story may be good as a stand-alone but since it's connected to the games it will be a big problem.
Clemetine literally tells lee she is tired of running and found a home to settle down at. Makes no sense for her to leave. AJ and Ericson IS her happiness.
it ruins everything makes season 4 pointless af lol it literally went against everything
@@AllEliteSatire it makes everything since the end of s2 pointless
Lee would also be extremely disappointed as well
"We will all hopefully forget this"
Yes let’s act like this isn’t cannon
@@obi-wankenobi4742 agreed
@@obi-wankenobi4742 Way ahead of you.
Ye let's pretend that this comic book didn't exist at all it wasn't made
Next time skybound should hire actual writers and by actual writers I mean the people who created the story for the games
Should've brought back Kent Mudle. He knows Clemmy better than anyone. Plus he actually writes comics.
Agreed so disappointing where is she going
They're more interested in diversity hires. Cringe.
@@yusufmostafa4498 diversity is good, this was just incompetence
Yea, they really butchered it.
Dom seeing youre disappointment was great lmao
I knew he was gonna be disappointed lol I cant wait for his videos 🤣 you could gradually see him getting pissed as he processed it 😭
Thank you y’all could tell 😂
All of the things that we didn’t want to happen….Happened.
can you summarize wtf happened 😔
Pain
@@RoloBelly basically she decided to leave Ericsson and LEAVE AJ BEHIND TOO all because she wasn’t “happy.” Like wtf?
Have they lost their motha--minds?!(In my Lee voice)
at least clem didn't die
This comic in a way makes clementine look like a hypocrite. In season 4 she tells AJ that they are done running, and she tells AJ that you can't break promises, so why is clementine doing the opposite in this.
Sometimes there’s promises you have to break
@@attackontitanfollower yea I guess you can break a promise about staying where "home is" but you can't break one that involves leaving/killing someone you love who got bit. Seems right lol
And she said "I'll never leave you again" to AJ.
"And I'll never leave you again"
YEEEESSS, SIRRRR!
Of coooourse🤥
DON'T YOU LIE TO ME, I HATE WHEN YOU LIE TO ME - AJ
They should’ve just made a story about the children finding a more permanent home.. the school is LITERALLY half burnt down and rotting.. thats not good for protection OR the inhabitants health.
Make a comic about the kids finding a suitable LONG TERM home.
💯
@@neverlackinquando3275 or have story about them rebuilding ericsons, it wouldn’t need any big conflict, just small things like ‘we need to find wood for this stable’ or something like that
How would you account for different people alive at the ending ?
@@vuk5576 oh yeah, that’s actually smart
@@vuk5576 it could still just be a clementine solo adventure but at least it makes sense
My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined
This comic sneak peak is absolute dogwater.... baby?! When the hell has Clem ever called AJ that? Also, it looks that AJ is at least 10 or 11 in this comic
Lmao same, I had to double check to see if clementine actually said "baby" to AJ
16:20 EXACTLY 🤣🤣🤣 its either Aj or goofball lmaoo I dont think Tillie played the games thoroughly she just got a summary of it from Robert kirkman and went with it and wrote the comic it goes against EVERYTHING clem did from season 1-4
I would have rather them NOT show me this shit, then show me this and make me wait for a year.
The fact it’s gotta be a year is just PAIN
We can always pretend Clem has just gone to help another settlement and Aj has stayed behind to help Ericson’s. It’s still flawed but i think it’s better
That sounds better than what they did
Wayyy better. This is bs.
I agree 👍🏻
@@Scooterrr_ play clem? We are clem and clem is us
WTF that can’t be it I’m literally crying 😭 What did they’re mean with new love? WTF this is bullshit clem is the best character and happy with Louis/Violet and AJ is like a little Son why would she leave her son and love just behind? This isn’t Clem🙁and why would she be sad when she got an Aj and a Love this is fucking Bullshit and of course her new ,,Love’’ is an Girl we can’t even decided.This is Bullshit
In the flashback on McCarrol Ranch Clementine said
-And I'll never leave you again
...
And now she leaves him???? WTF???!!!
YES! 😬
Visible confusion
Complete betrayal of her character
@@DomTheBomb YEAAAAHH!!!
the 'im not happy' as clem's reasoning is the cheapest, most un-original idea they could've used im actually so mad lol they just wanted an easy scape to just write their own 'clementine alternative story' fanfiction. save that shit for wattpad
i can tell the writer(s) weren’t attached to the games nor did they ever play them prior to this project. they got the job and just decided to write their own novel completely out of character. at this point, they should’ve just written their OWN novel in their OWN universe with their OWN original characters.
anyways, don’t let this taint the games for you guys, the games and clementine are so great and this just wasn’t even in character whatsoever. screw this being labeled as “canon.”
Yeah in my books, the story ended after season 4. This is just a concept
Tillie Warden (the writer) has played all of the games multiple times, as she said in the live stream. But I agree, this doesn't seem like Clem at all. She wouldn't just abandon AJ because she wasn't "happy." I think there's more to it than her being unhappy at the school. And to think that she was originally going to leave without telling AJ or anyone (before AJ caught her) is out of character.
Independent of the terrible story, the comic book art looks fucking weird.
@@aldas11 there’s no way she played them multiple times and produced this dung heap of a comic
@@SparaticSpartan She said she did though.
Clementine is literally becoming like Jane 2.0
She left AJ and she was gonna leave without saying goodbye until AJ found her and because she want to leave because she’s not happy like wtf
I guess the graphics novel is our only hope but wait for it for a year 🙄
@Clementine i read that in clems voice when she sees her parents and gets stuck in the jewelry store with lee lol
You’re so right bro.... this Jane all over again. Just up and leaving. Clem’s a bad ass. But this?? They way they got Clem right now, I’m not down with it. It’s not like her to up and leave. Worse She calls aj baby... took me off guard. again that’s not like her. She normally calls him goofball. Then she’s heading up north to be with another group somewhere in the winter. I forget. Like what fuck is this???? To be honest I can wait a whole year for this. I’m in no rush. I might just forget about it. I’m Better playing the first walking dead to get this bullshit out of my head. Jesus Christ
The main reason why I hate Jane in the first place lol
They need to explain this sudden sadness and why aj cant even keep clem happy 😤 Aj would NEVER leave clem even if she said so he already proved that S4.... she really is a jane 2.0 and I hate it so much
@Clementine ikr
Aj: You made it so we don’t have to run
Clem: ✌️*runs*
I'm so dissappointed Dom 😭😭 Clem pulled a Jane and left everyone even AJ without telling him. Clem is his adoptive mom, she would never do that! Was I the only one who felt like she was a totally different character while reading? Just sad man, they should've left her happy ending alone.
Thanks for reading it tho man on a video, now I'm really happy I didn't drive an hour to buy this crap
They got Clementine's character wrong by making her leave AJ because she's "not happy". She would never voluntarily leave him. Honestly the writers should have played or watched Season 3 and 4 to see how far she would go for AJ.
Tille Warden (aka the writer) has played all of the games multiple times as she said in the live stream. She seemed to understand her character and said that she would totally "hurt" someone if they hurted Clementine. But this is really out of character, not sure what Tillie was thinking 🤔
If the actual writer wrote this comic book it was going to be wayyyyyy different than that like what the heck is this writer doing he is just trying to separate clementine from Aj and others is he out of his mind or something?
@@amrmettwally3858 The writer is a she
What is this... I guess i'll finally end up drawing my own canon at this point. I'm just upset...
When you dry it can I see it lol?
Me too
Ok but wth she tried so hard to find AJ and now she’s just leaving Him wtf
Remember when she started a FUCKING WAR
Imagine being Aj his only parental figure telling him he’s not good enough to make her happy and being abandoned after he saves her damn life.
Maybe the next comic will explain
@@attackontitanfollower nah it don’t if you look up stuff they give a general plot she leaves finds another group of kids some trouble some love ect she’s basically ruining the happy ending of season 4 to write a (in my head cannon and most people I’ve spoke to) spin-off clementine comic
No hate toward the writer of "Clementine Lives" personally, but I would have preferred a collaboration between Robert Kirkman and one/some of the Telltale writers.
Kirkman knows how to create a story and develop character while the Telltale writers would have assisted in bringing a faithful Clementine (or AJ or any of the Telltale cast) to the comics.
Full hate towards the writers. They didn’t even fucking try.
@@kyan7708 they didn’t even try getting a decent art design
@@kaylafairnbain8163 Right? Like it’s cute, But it looks like something someone on the walking dead sub made.
@@kyan7708 I blame the fans who kept asking for a season 5. They wanted more Clementine and they got what they asked for.
@@kaylafairnbain8163 Also i can't even take the art seriously.
It looks like some 2000s and little comedic art
OK. I came up with a way to make it make sense. Actually, the conversation with AJ was a daydream. The real reason she tells AJ. he can't come with her is he literally can't because he's dead. Everyone is dead and Clementine, unable to deal with losing everything yet again, deluded herself into thinking everything was fine and she just felt like leaving because she, "just didn't feel happy." She's leaving behind a house filled with ghosts, not her friends. She's not happy because she's alone.
That's the best interpretation I have ever seen, even if that implys that everyone is dead, at least it's still in character with clem
God I wish this was their take on it from this garbage, but it probably won’t be 😕
Your interpretation is dark af, and yet better than what it seems to be...
This better be what happens istg
@@ero-ko2218 Man, what really gets me is that it's not even good. It's not creative or clever, it's just he same thing over, and over, and over, but this way it at least it wouldn't desecrate Clementine's character and erase her personality.
NO NO NO I REFUSE TO BELIVE THAT THIS IS CANNON CLEM WOULD NEVER LEAVE AJ AND ALL HER OTHER FRIENDS AT THE SCHOOL LIKE THE WHOLE POINT OF THE FINAL SEASON WAS TO FIND CLEM AND AJ A SAFE PLACE TO CALL HOME SO WHY WOULD SHE LEAVE DAMN I AM SO DISAPOINTED.
+ clem said that shes done running and now in the comic shes doing the opposite did the writer even play the games ??!!!
Lol, as the other Dom says, “You can’t turn your back on family…”
🤣🤣🤣
"No, baby. It's not for me."' LMAO. WTF is this ishnit?
Love your commentary.
Thank you
"Baby"
Yeah, that doesn't sound like her.
Such horrible writing. I think every fan out there could've wrote this better.
"I'm not happy". The fack she was litterly the happiest woman alive at the games ending. Hopefully it will get better but for now it looks like I'll have to lock it away in my memory
Ikr I thought it would be better than this garbage
Clem just pull a Jane and Violet move all in one. Wow!
i agreed until the violet part lol
@@mqddy8094 But it's true tho.
@@Player-jh4ko elaborate💀
@@mqddy8094 If you failed to safe violet during the end of episode two, she does a complete 180 and hates Celmentine wanting to leave her and stay in the Delta. Yeah she was brainwashed and she apologized at the end but my point still stands lol.
Damn I can’t believe I paid money for a teaser trailer :(
And it’s ass
@@hamhock7036 Damn straight
LOL Scammer get Scammed HAAAA
GG you played yourself
wtf did I just read? clem leaving AJ???? without even saying goodbye??? I love the fact that clem is back but seriously?? this aint it fam
It ain’t it at all
Excellent video domthebomb and congratulations on getting a video from Melissa Hutchinson
Yeah good job as well 👍👍
Thanks
•”The walking dead community will remember that”•
While the comic is a good setup for the upcoming graphic novel, I wasn't really expecting Clementine's answer for leaving to be so... selfish.
The comic itself didn't feel like it was nessecary as it could've been a part of the novel. It was way too short & just leaves so many can of worms open.
Of course, this does leave us with more questions than answers. I'm not a fan of Clementine's decision of leaving AJ & obviously, they need to fully explain why but hopefully... it expands upon that in a way we understand.
My expectations are low but overall, I'm willing to give it a try.
I'm Sad, that was a Freak Show, thanks Skybound🥲
Don’t blame skybound, blame Tilla for not understanding her character.
@@PostCrisisRH Hmm, your Right...
@@HasAlwaysTheHighground Of course im right, Im goddamn Carl.
Hello @@HasAlwaysTheHighground, How was my son (AJ)?
@@williamcarver121 You don't understand it, right🙄?
Why they gotta make Clementine leave her “goofball” behind?! Why she gotta leave?
I guess she was made for the road and she cannot settle down.
shes not 'happy' ????????????????
Well their reason for her to leave AJ because
The plot armour says so.
@@maxcanonstunner6532 Screw that plot armor crap!! This makes no sense!
No offense
No human language can describe the disappointment I’m feeling right now
Weww
I think we should still keep our heads up. We don’t know what has happened since Take Us Back. I know it looks bad but there has to be a reason behind Clem’s change of mindset, however I’m not saying that these Comics could just be awful and the writer just didn’t play the games. All I’m saying is we should keep and open mind and not hate on the author.
Btw I personally like the art style of the book ALOT.
Was really looking forward to this comic, only got it today and avoided spoilers. Glad to see I am not alone with the disappointment tbh.
Welcome to the club
#Notmyclementine ✋
👍
FACTS!!
Definitly not my Clementine
nope not the girl i fell in love with
I would like to think that that is just a one shot and not the actual plot of the story...
That is not Clementine! *THAT IS NOT CLEMENTINE!*
That is not AJ either. AJ would never leave Clementine just like he didn't even listen to her in James's barn when he chopped her leg to save her.
What a joke
I don’t like jumping the gun so not gonna ask about the story…but the graphics? Like maybe I’ve read too much manga and my expectations are a bit high but like come on Clem and AJ look nothing like this😂
Aot's manga art is better than this even tho AOT's art is bad in comparison to other Mangas 😂
This isn’t manga, this is comic. Manga is Japanese made. While comic is American.
@@jaredcunningham3667 yes but comics in general should be consistent, what I meant was manga maybe I’m expecting too much cos I’m not usually reading comics but more manga
Yeah, I agree. The draws are really inconsistent, some are actually really good, like the desing of Clem in the last page, but some others pages are straight bad like at 16:31
You could see the moment he lost all hope.
I honestly never noticed but it progressively got worse 💀
Great, we're getting The Last Jedi version of TTG Walking Dead.
that cabin is the fishing shack you can tell by the fireplace
this is so disappointing... I mean I’m a big fan of twdg series since the first game launched and seeing clementine so out of her character felt like ?? we had a whole game of her trying to get back to AJ and for her to leave him like that just because she wasn’t “happy” enough? she would never do that :/
Boi if they kill me off Imma become VIOLENT
That's the Spirit Vi, me too😂
Btw: if you see that Vi, can we Stay Conected on YT?
yikes kinda threw the final season away huh?
Threw the whole series away.
Sometimes you encounter something so absurd you can’t help but find it hilarious. This comic is a prime example imo 😂
the walking dead fans will remember that
(?)The Walking Dead Fans will remember this
''I will remember that''
They will be left heartbroken
Hello@@DomTheBomb , Would you like to join my camp(Howe Hardware).
I don't know how she can do this, probably the worst emotional feeling you can fell is not knowing were someone you love is or how there doing or if there even alive, like if you know there dead atleast then there's some closure and the wound can heal but if you don't know if someone's ok that wound can never fully heal so now if aj or clem dies or clem never goes back they will never know if the other is ok
“Father son of all spirit this better not be trash” bruh I can’t stop laughing on that 😂
Thank you 😂
Wow. This comic really ruins the ending of s4 😔
Clementine: *cherished an actual home for her and AJ and achieves that by the end of the last season*
The new comics: I'm gonna pretend I didn't see that
💀
The comic next year better be out of this world for Clem to do some shit like this
WTF. Do these “writers” even know why their fan bases like their games? I mean did the director of the Last of Us 2 come and possess the people working on the Walking Dead? Two amazing series reputations being tarnished. I don’t even care about Ericsson, it makes NO sense for Clementine to leave AJ. And for her to call him baby? I really wanted to see AJ development. He was apart of THREE seasons. He saved her life. You telling me a one legged person is going off wondering off in the woods alone, leaving AJ who is sharp shooter and would do anything to protect her? Because she’s not happy? Tf. My only theory is that comfort and placement makes Clem feel stagnant and bored as she so used to being a survivor and being alone. This is totally different from the video game clementine. This is not clementine, this is Orange.
Wdym new director of the last of us 2? They had the same director, and he did fucking amazing with the second game. This comic is complete dogshit tho
@@kingpny9314 the second game is trash as well.
@@kingpny9314 Second game is good but they did do some shit that not a lot of us liked, First game is immensely better it’s not even close.
Hey, the last of us 2 was amazing, and none of the characters were treated like Clementine has been.
@@abbyanderson2463 no it wasn't and Joel was the only character that was treated like this Clementine. When I see this Clementine, I always remember TLOU2 Joel.
It definitely feels more like a trailer for the novel then an actual comic
Good point
Damn this was a really cool dream that Clem had. I can't wait to see what happens when she actually wakes up from this nightmare so we can get a real follow up to the final season.
Genuinely would've preferred to get a story were we just follow Clem's daily routine years after the final season so we could see she's doing fine after everything not whatever this fanfic is.
They ruined Clementine.... Time to riot.
The only one Clementine had was Aj and she decided to leave him to.. yea that ain't our Clem 🤣
it definitely feels like the writer hasn't played the games. Probably just knows the story of the games but that gives you no emotional attachment to the characters like actually playing the game does
I figured they would do something like this. THe whole series was based around branching storylines and creating 'your' Clementine. They were damned if they did and damned if they didn't regarding all the 'determinant' issues. So best thing to do was to just move on from it and begin an entirely new story.
They could’ve just made a comic abt the Ericsson kids before Clem and AJ showed up. Explain why (or expand on) the reasons why they were all sent there, show how the school and teachers treated them, show the teachers up and abandoning them. Show how they lost Ms. Martin and their greenhouse, put more depth in the characters and actually introduce us to people like Sophie. Show us the stress Marlon was under trying to keep himself and his friends alive, show us what they did and didn’t know about the outside world.
Answer some questions . Is Omar really a God? How did Tenn get burnt, and did Aasim (the local fire manic) have anything to do with it?
Also, Tenn is like 12 years old when we meet him and it has been like nine years since the apocalypse started; meaning Tenn was like 3 or 4. Why was this toddler in a school for troubled youth? Were Minnie, Sophie, and Tenn orphans before the outbreak and somehow managed to stay together? Did Minnie and Sophie leave to try and find their parents, just found Tenn, and decided to take him back to the school with them?
And more importantly, show me puppy Rosie damnit. Show me Mullet Boy bonding with this cute baby puppy and how tf he taught her to kill walkers.
Maybe Tillie Walden didn't even know who Clementine was.
That’s a problem
I have a feeling that she is returning to her home, where everything Has begun. Maybe he will try to find the Train, Lee, Motel, cannibal's farm and other things that were in season one. Maybe seeing all of this will make her happy, sińce she said shes not happy.
The fact that she said that AJ doesn’t make her happy tells you this was made by some bs writer that has probably never even played the games
She looked very fucking happy at the end of the last game!
What could have happened
What could have happened
Well, just realized what I think I already knew. I didn't need this. I have the final season. It's a satisfying, worthy ending for Clementine. Whatever happens next is irrelevant, at best should be left to our imagination, based on our choices.
I hope this comic reading will not have a real bad ending unlike Games of Thrones, The Last Jedi or TLOU II which broke my mind. If there is a final season part 2, I probably loose my goddamn mind that Clementine is heading north and if she really is, I hope it won't be like Games of Thrones...
This ain’t Clementine. She would never leave aj after going through everything she did to not only protect him but find him. If feels like the only reason they did this was to wipe the slate clean for the novel and try to avoid making one choice branch cannon.
If AJ had died and she left because of that and the emotions with it I would’ve been ok with that compared to this bullshit. At least then it makes somewhat sense why she left and doesn’t ruin her character
So... The story is that Clementine's sexually frustrated, needs some strange and don't want the kid around to salt her game.
Bro what😭😭
@@adilwrld You gotta look at the bigger picture here, my bro. Skybound has an audience of bored 13 y/o's they need to titillate and get money from. That means they need to have Clem do a few rotations on the ol' CC and having some kid hanging around is like bussy repellent, so AJ has to go. It's for the greater good.
Bro they got my man lee rolling in his grave rn
Speculation:
Aj has been part of Clem's life for so long. And all she wanted was to find him a safe home, that was her purpose in life. But now, that's been full filled, she possibly feels empty and without a purpose anymore and maybe that's why she left?
if clem is gonna friendzone/leave gabe, louis, violet and choose some random graphic novel character i swear there's gonna be blood spilled
Only way I see this ending good is if we get a video game playing as AJ finding Clem.
*Dom will remember that.
Well hopefilly season 5
You know. The walking dead the telltale series was a great quadrilogy of games. Shame nothing came out afterwards.
😂
I would love for Clementine to meet Javi and his family again in the Comic and why she never returned to new Richmond, who was new Richmond at war with, was it Lily and her group.
Also will we once again see Lily in the upcoming books, also will Clementine find out what happened to Christa.
I’ll really love for these things to happen in the books.
I would love to see them meet again
I’m not mad anymore I think I understand why Clem left, knowing AJ and the others will be ok being “helped” by the other 2 communities/coalition near by, she gets to enjoy time on her own, years used to protect AJ, now some alone time, I don’t agree that this is the best reason either but it still give me hope
Starting at a 6/10 for me
I would have much preffered a Javi story. Where Richmmond is beetwen Delta and ANF in this big free for all battle. But I guess I have to find an idea to fix THIS crap.....
What I would have done is have Louis,Violet,Tenn and James die off screen becouse they are determinent and so first page would show graves of all of them. So we would be left with Clem,AJ,Ruby,Willy,Aasim,Omar and Rosie. Half of this comic would be focused on how their lives are stable but not perfect. Half the school was already burnt down,there are no supplies in the area to fix it and food is so scarce they go entire days without a meal. Thus they decide to leave and head to Richmmond. I would still keep this plot of Richmmond vs ANF vs Delta of mine. We would see in this 2nd comic book some walker action,pass through the fishing shack and train station to have a nod to the games and it would end with them making a small camp in the woods. Thus an introduction to the trilogy is set.
Obviously this is after the death of Rick Grimes and the coalition is another term for the Common Wealth or as in the final issue the eastern and western alliances. Not sure how long after Rick Grime's died though. As for why it is obviously PTSD. The sad fact is this writer is following the standard format of ignoring everything that came before.
Hey dom I was replaying s1 again and when I was playing ep 3 after kenny’s family dies you can see he takes the picture of the train conductors family off the wall
"How in twelve pages could you possibly f*ck it up worse" Idk I wonder the same, I guess they've magic powers for doing this to 6 years of my life
Well to me i would rather make my own stories about Clem after the final ss because this doesnt make any sense
AJ is everything to her, she has loved him with the love of a mother since ss2 and then in ss3 she didnt even care much about being alone or being betrayed, she just wanted AJ to be with her, and throughout the final ss i always teach AJ to do the right things like not to steal, to be apologize, not to lose manners when eating, etc... And always protect him no matter what everyone says about him.
More than that in the dream with Lee on the train, she told him that she was tired of running and could finally find a place called home and a group that she liked more than any other groups before.
Clem deserves to rest, someone should step up to protect her and the group.
Since were not going to be able to change it we can try to hope that they can salvage it. At one point in the 1st or 2nd book she needs to realize her mistakes and try to get back to the boarding school and the rest of the series could be her fighting through major obstacles on her way back until she finally reaches it and has the happy ending from season 4 kinda. That's the only way I can see than salvaging this if they don't do that this whole thing might just be fucked.
Welp, guess that’s why fanfiction is a thing.
For now I’m just gonna pretend the games are the only thing cannon :)
Yup
The book: Clementine- I'm not happy and you can't make me happy so I'm leaving
Insert look how they massacred my boy clip
Damn I’m too used to reading manga right to left that I keep messing up reading this.
We’ve come so far with this game and it hurts knowing that we didn’t know what to expect from when first loading up s1 ep1. None of us knew how emotionally attached we’d become with this game. The characters we sacrificed and the tough choices we made built all of this up. This game had everybody on there toes at all times and i just want to say well done skybound for creating a masterpiece
Thanks for this Dom! Some counterpoints to consider: at the end of the Final Season she tells AJ to keep the hat, right? That season represented AJ, a child born IN the apocalypse, learning how to survive. He demonstrated even more ability than Clem did, because of his upbringing. Clem has never had a chance to live her own life. This is about her now. It sounds like the coalition has provided a broader community for the Ericson kids to be a part of, so why would they stay isolated at the school? All I see is a girl who can finally go on her own journey. We don’t always get to find out what happens to characters until later (or never) in TWD universe- hell, you don’t get their backstories half the time either. The apocalypse tends to make things a little bit hectic.
So much for player choice!
):