Ukrainian prisoners of war say they were tortured at Russian prison - BBC News
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 авг 2023
- Ukrainian prisoners of war have said they were subjected to torture, including frequent beatings and electric shocks, while held in Russia, a BBC investigation has heard.
A dozen former captives described extreme violence and ill-treatment, apparent violations of international humanitarian law. Many of them surrendered in the city of Mariupol last year.
They were taken to a detention facility in the southern Russian city of Taganrog - before being released in exchanges.
Russia's defence ministry did not respond to several requests to comment on the allegations. It has previously denied torturing or mistreating captives.
Please subscribe here: bit.ly/1rbfUog
#Ukraine #Russia #BBCNews
Russia must be dismantled
Or what? The world will fall apart? Lol
So sad an sorry for this beautiful Ukraini people suffered ,Be the GLORY to UKRAINE 🇺🇦🙏🤞😘❤
Hail to the victims for being so brave, get on with it, and share their story..Words cannot express the compassion one feels when hearing this🤍
Yes how awful watching this video whilst I eat takeaway and drink beer.
Calling the BBC an honest and objective channel is like calling Azov a sister of mercy, and not neo-fascists, rapists and sadists.
@@Vitamin_71 to think I pay £100+ a year for this biased propoganda
support Ukraine 🇺🇦💔
This is why it's so important that Russia isn't allowed even the smallest victory in Ukraine, and is kicked out of Crimea. The oldest Ukrainians will tell you that dealing with Russians is far worse than dealing with Hitler's Nazis. This will also make Ukrainian soldiers fight so much harder, rather than surrender, because dying on the battlefield is vastly less painful than what Russians will do to anyone who becomes their prisoner.
You should read your history books again. Nazi Germany was much worse by all accounts.
You’ll believe anything the BBC prints huh?!
@@kasondaleigh in the short term yes, but the soviet union was fileting their own civilians alive and force feeding themselves their own entrails
for being a dissident who went against the governments strict rule
"Do what russia says and you wont get hurt" - the russian dictator, who is willing to wipe your entire family from the earth, with acid baths or lifelong enslavement in uranium mines, if you say anything not allowed by the government.
USSR civilians killed by russia between 1945 and 1988 over 50,000,000. Russia killed more of their own, than they killed nazis.
But of course when you went to the market in rustov on dawn in the 70s and said to your parents "look we could grow extra food and give it to people", the government deemed that as capitalism and you were sent to re-education as your parents were sent to the gulag
Because if you weren't being only self sufficient and nothing more, you were thinking like an enemy of the state, and the KGB/FSB would be swift to talk to you and give your children a new home while you were given a new 20 hour a day job mining uranium
@@terransunited In fact, the post-war USSR was less violent than the pre-war one, especially after Stalin's death in 1953. There were no 50 million anomalous civilian deaths (not to mention intentional killings) in the period from 1945 to 1991 in the USSR. The deadliest periods in the history of the USSR are the revolution and civil war in 1917-1921 (military losses of the parties are about 2 million, about 2 million emigrated, the total losses of the country are difficult to calculate, perhaps 10-15 million), the famine in the Volga region in 1921 (the number victims are difficult to calculate, perhaps about 5 million), a great famine in 1932-1933 (in Ukraine and in the West it is called the Holodomor) (total losses are difficult to calculate, perhaps about 8 million), Stalin's great terror in 1937-1938 (the number of victims about a million) and the Second World War (in the USSR the Great Patriotic War 1941-1945) (the total number of losses is about 26 million, of which about 12 million military and about 14 million civilian). There were no such great tragedies in the post-war USSR. Actually it was not the worst time. For example, the population of Ukraine within the USSR in 1955-1985 grew from about 40 million to about 51 million. After the collapse of the USSR, the population in free democratic Ukraine in 1991-2013 decreased from 51 to 45 million people.
History experts everywhere who all seem to know the truth....lol
they were shown bbc every day
Listening to the BBC is torture for us poor folk in the UK.
and so what
Infuriating
Guantanamo Bay, where individuals were held indefinitely, without charge, while simultaneously being tortured by the CIA.
Stalins gulag archipelago, where millions of Soviet citizens from a dozen countries were worked to death.
WAAH MOMMY! Somebody else somewhere else some other time was bad, so torturing Ukrainians is OK for us RuZZians! WAAAH!
And I remember this "girl". She was shown on TV with a sniper partner, caught on the way out of Mariupol with crying children in the car. They said that these uncle and aunt stopped the car, shot mom and dad and drove to the checkpoint.
i request you..
Help us my mother is heart patient i have one small sister and brother.
we are in trouble. Our house is broken because of the flood We have become homeless. my father is died please help us with a little help from you my mother will have great time. please help us God will also help you please
Fake.
The Russians doesn't valued themselves talk less of other people. Slava Ukrainian
yes. It's been similar with the Nazi Germany. They were cruel to others, but the normal soldiers were also very tough on other soldiers and on themselves. They sometimes didn't care of their own lives, why should they care of the lives or sufferings of others.
You believe everything you hear? I feel sad for you 😢
@@rmggallo5331 see, takes a bit of knowledge and brain to decide what to believe what not to believe. Some people believe all the wrong things for one reason or another. The Russian disregard for human life is something you should believe, unless you are completely ignorant on the matter.
Putin and Lvova-Belova to the Hague.
The Pentagon has blocked cooperation with the ICC over alleged war crimes in Ukraine due to “reciprocity” against US troops in the future….Secretary of Defense Austin
And Russian prisoners say they were tortured in Ukraine, so what's your point BBC?
The point is that the Russian torture of POW and civilians is institutionalized while torture by Ukrainians is rare and punished.
"Rare and punished" where did you get your source from, the Ukraine military ? Pffft
@@theprinceofpieLook what Ukraine allies did in guantanamo. They got off lightly.
Source: Amnesty International, United Nations Human Rights Council, and Human Rights Watch. Where did you get your source? Putin's ass?@@retarded573
BBC investigations😂😂😂 oh my
Like CNN a lot of fake news
The Putin's regime has no humanity . We are very sorry for the atrocious tortures of the Ukrainian prisoners.God save all of you .🙏🙏🙏🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦💙💛💙💛
More humanity than Ukrainians getting children out of war zones instead of usin them as politicians using them as meat shield to cling to power and vilify the enemy
Treating Ukrainian POW’s like this doesn’t help Russia’s war efforts… Because it will make Ukrainians choose fighting to the death over surrender.
And that’s why this news report is pure propaganda and lies.
Yes,they will seek revenge on the battlefield.
God bless Ukrainian ❤
and what happened in Odessa on May 2, 2014?
Пнх
Exactly the same horror stories you'd expect to hear from somewhere like Bosnia, its such a pity that this still happens in the now 21st century Europe, because we thought atrocities like the Holocaust experiments and death camps in Bosnia would be consigned to human history, its just such a shame that after all of these outrageous and most horrendous of atrocities, that autocratic leaders still do not learn from history, it makes me feel sick
Ever heard of the Guantanamo Bay or Abu Ghraib , m0r0n?
Those are just recorded traits of human armies the holocaust wasn’t unique or most recent
@@amaruandujarwhat makes the Holocaust unique is that a gargantuan amount of people were killed in it - nearly an entire group of people
@@pigpentaboo
BS
PR and monetization makes it fashionable. That's all.
Calling the BBC an honest and objective channel is like calling Azov a sister of mercy, and not neo-fascists, rapists and sadists.
I'll be 😷 of this nightmare of torcher of those 🇺🇦 soldiers, this must end! #SupportUkraine
This is why they're called orcs.
Who?
@@baruchgoldberg1941 Orcskies
He looks afresh
Won't we England doing the same in Iraq and Afghanistan just 2years ago
if you would condemn it then, why won't you condemn it now?
Why would they be told to surrender?
Sadly, this type of treatment is typical of war and should be no surprise.
I guess they don't recognise "The Geneva Convention" in Russia unfortunately
We can see this every day on civilians bombarding …God bless Ukraine! ❤️🇺🇦
God bless Ukraine 🇺🇦 🇺🇦🇺🇦❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏
Does God bless the killers?
@@Abel_Araviпнх
North Korea's Comrade Kim grants political and human rights asylum to American soldier who fled racism in the US.
They are lucky there are still alive they are fighting there brothers because of America
The horror
Russian prisoners of war were killed Infront of the camera,but that seems didn't bother you
Wagner films themselves killing their own with a sledgehammer, but that seems to not bother you 🤡
OGR=DR
Sure the same thing happens on both sides.
These soldiers are sick. What kind of monsters treat people like this? Hearing what these people went through is horrible and yet I'm glad they lived to tell the world of what they went through to show how monstrous these "people" are.
and Russian soldiers are simply shot in captivity. there is a video on the net.
Guantanamo anybody.
Saakashvili should be released immediately
Have you asked russian prisoner of war ?
Calling the BBC an honest and objective channel is like calling Azov a sister of mercy, and not neo-fascists, rapists and sadists.
Chinese defense minister arrives in Belarus as tensions with NATO rise
China's defense chief arrived in Belarus for a three-day visit aimed at strengthening ties with Russia's staunch ally, as NATO member states beef up border security with the country.
Defense Minister Li Shangfu - who aims to step up military ties with nations around the world - flew from Russia and was received in Minsk by his counterpart, Viktor Khrenin, according to Bloomberg.
In Moscow, China's defense chief pledged to step up cooperation with peers in Europe, Africa and Latin America - notably excluding the US, with which high-level military dialogue has been suspended. He called China's ties with Russia a "good model of cooperation".
i believe him glad your here to tell the world god bless
The world doesn't give a flying fak!
Friendship with Russia is essential for the world peace...Iran, China and N. Korea are becoming more powerful with the support of Russia...
Friendship with Nazi Germany was essential to prevent WWII.
i request you..
Help us my mother is heart patient i have one small sister and brother.
we are in trouble. Our house is broken because of the flood We have become homeless. my father is died please help us with a little help from you my mother will have great time. please help us God will also help you please
Imagine if we are dstill here in a few years time and there is youtube videos of a title "the fallen of the Ukraine War"!
Wow the Russian troll farm is hard at work on this comment section.
okay bot
@@winterrising8738 not a bot at all, nor am I paid for my comments. A real person with a real opinion at no one else’s direction.
i see a buss full in tamworth so should fill the empty property
Humanity deserves to see Putins horrible final
Any photographic evidence? plus he has the wolfsangle Azov symbol on his computer,a known far right symbol.
Ok commie get your roubles
People are so brainwashed the beeb doesnt even have to hide it anymore
Commie? 🤣😂 I’m English and despise communism,Hitler was a socialist,I’m an anti nazi follower of YAH.Trump 2024 🥳
I bet he was told that Bandera is a gay and that hurt his feelings big ways 😆
@@delta_glider4362Bandera was a Nazi collaborator thus I have zero interest in his bedroom activities,personally I’m very happy to be straight,as it produces the fruit of life 😊
SLAVA UKRAINI
Corrupted ukronazis ruined all the world.
🤡
They telling the truth
Propaganda !
Everyone commit atrocities..
it can't be, I was convinced that they give them cakes and pretzels there.....I'm in shock,they should have applied for guantanamo, that's the right place to have fun
Oh were shocked & stunned… Russians torture. Who would’ve thought..
山水相依，藍天白雲，綠樹青山。清新的空氣，美麗的風景，悠閒的散步，讓人心情舒暢。#美台军事援助
stop cannibal putin!
Glory to Ukraine!
why did Ukrainian aviation bomb Donbass in 2014?
International law?!! Isn't that wishful thinking at its worst?!! Whose gonna enforce these laws? Can't defeat negative human nature!
The mutants and subversives at the BBC gnawing away at the fabric of reality it's self. Without the extant power of the state machine, their diaphanous social and moral constructs would vanish like morning mist. 🤔🤔
Ok bot go give our a side quest or something
@@dancoy09 🤨🤨The BBC propaganda Yentah continues to fight against logic & the fabric of reality it's self.... 🤨🤨
At a value of only a penny do you have a wheelbarrow for the Rubles your handler gives you? 🤡
@@brianedwards7142 Russia is taking in 3,000 South African Farmers amidst the recent calls for their genocide. God Bless Russia.
Troll
Foolishness,, pray for that he is still alive,, they didint eliminate as ukrainian did
KEEP GOING UKRAINIANS DONT LET RUSSIANS GET THE BETTER OF YOU!!!!!!
My dear British countrymen cant you see whats happening ? While we struggle to pay our mortgages, rent, food and energy bills , our Tax money is being sent to Ukraine where it is disappearing. Do you know the war in Afghanistan we just fought and lost, cost £1 Trillion from our Taxes we paid. Now as soon as that war is over we now have the Ukraine war costing us umpteen Billion already . Pensioners cant retire till theres hardly any years left to live. Half the NHS beds have closed. No money to build new houses unless theyre for foreigners . How much will you stand ? Labour and Conversative have the exact same policies. No work for your children, nowhere available to rent, unemployment benefit for them £70 a week. Please shout it out . These 2 political parties are destroying Britain.
Propaganda
Hahahaha they don't look injured at all . AND OSCAR GOES TO
I mean people look worse when they don't get enough sleep. Of course injures should affect more than that
moscowiya (the so called rosiyskaya federation) war criminals must be sentenced for everything they've done
Don't worry, we believe you
New western propaganda 🍿🍿🍿
Can we be provided with some evidence of torture ? I trust those people but still want to see proofs.
Multiple human rights organizations have investigated and found the widespread and systematic use of torture by Russia. If you were actually curious, you can start by opening the Wikipedia article "War crimes in the Russian invasion of Ukraine" and clicking the links. You won't because every "free-thinker" just believes exactly what they are told, just by the other side.
Nice little Nazi rune for the Azov Battalion on his laptop there. Must be a nice guy.
NATO has told ukraine to give it up as you cant win
3 times a day eat a good meal, sleept - a nightmare. Ukraine were shooting down Russian soldiers thats a nightmare.
what those russian soldiers were doing on Ukrainian soil?
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🇺🇦
The Russians….??
I’m not having that 😂
I really believe ALL of this. Not
Cmon Russia.. end it and win it .. I'm tired of zelensky begging for money
Horrible Russian
Russian troops also have same story but BBC cant show it being an independent media 😅😅
🤡 bot
@@fortunecookie3765 truth hurts hypocrite
Why doesn't Russia allow 3rd party human rights organizations like the Red Cross inspect the POW camps like Ukraine then? But go on, tell me how they are all the same but every single organization on earth is lying but Russia.🤡 🤡
Nobody can show it because it is a lie. The BBC does not fake reports like Patrick Lancaster and RT.
I wonder why everything BBC reports is negative about Russia 🇷🇺
It's because russia acting like nazis? You think? 🤔
It doesn't, often their correspondents report on the day to day life of ordinary Russians.
Baised BBC
Until Russia kneels down and bows head like a slave
What provisions does our government make for asylum seekers claiming to have been tortured overseas?
Why are there rumours that immigration lawyers are telling immigrants to claim torture in order to expedite their asylum?
Correlation or coincidence??
Because Britain’s the new Islamic caliphate
Barges...
It widespread, its the same with African "refugees" being told to say they are LGBT even when married and leaving their kids in the place they supposedly had to flee...
What has this got to do with this news story?! Is someone forcing you to pick between the welfare of Ukrainian soldiers and asylum seekers? If other people follow your example of trying to expand the scope of stories without limits, then how on earth are we ever going to get to the bottom of anything? there are plenty of news stories on asylum seekers, why not limit your comments to there rather than wasting everyone's time including your own
This is the most prime example of whataboutisum I have ever seen
Zelensky's nazis killed all the prisoners.
I guess the term prisoner exchange was a bit much for you.
Zelensky killed them all in cold blood.
🤡
Try watching hundreds of Zolkin Volodomyr interviews ...
As if the Americans in Afghanistan didn't do anything differently...lol
And Iraq. And Guantánamo Bay.
And this justifies what Russia is doing?
I'd deflect too if I were caught behaving like a sociopath
@@nealc.6927those who committed those crime where put to justice. Google is a friend who can help you know the truth.
So Russian and american where the same? But American convicted soldiers who committing crimes
Say it isn't so. No cuddles from the Russians?
Very unlikely ,the Ukrainians want to persuade their soldiers in the field not to surrender to the Russians as they have been doing in large numbers.
To the Ukrainian soldiers ,take your Baofeng radio tune to 149.200 call sign Volga it will save your life.
Russia attacked Ukraine, they are firing barrages of missiles at ukranian cities every night where there are civilians. These are the facts. Russia is the aggressor that is the fact. Russia jails their own people who oppose the government. Fact. Russia could end the war now by returning to their own borders pre 2014 that is a fact. The Russians have poisoned several political opponants outside of Russia such as in Salisbury U.K so nothing Russia says can be trusted.
rusbot
Ohh
Ceasefire needs to be called already.
Shut up russian bot. Ukraine already signed peace treaty with ruzzia in 2014, but pootins scum kept shellung and shooting, russians are cheaters and its useless to talk to them
This is why I protested torture by American interrogators. It isn't right and it doesn't work.
❤️🩹
Bet same thing is also being done to the Russians captured. Not like they are all treated like kings.
Says African troll account
Do you know that Ukrainians have a hotline to help russian familis find their sons? They give them information if they have It. They do much more for them than russian govermant does for its own citizens.. also keep in mind that russians dont have to be there! They are the invaders!
@@dancoy09 The ukronazis bot are everywhere.
@@antareseditions go steal some fridges terrorist
Troll
What about Guadanamo?
whatabout your mum
The great, magnanimous and victorious Russian nation must demand that more referendums be held in other regions of Ukraine.
NATO fart chief says!
After a speech by the chief of staff, NATO backs off and says it is up to Kiev to 'decide conditions for the ceasefire'
Head of the Atlantic Alliance tries to circumvent the statement of his chief of staff at a press conference today (17) in Norway. At the same time, Stoltenberg declared that he "detected no change in Russia's nuclear forces".
This Thursday (17), NATO Secretary General Jen Stoltenberg tried to "fix" the speech of his chief of staff made on Tuesday (15).
"It is the Ukrainians, and only the Ukrainians, who can decide when there are conditions for negotiations and who can decide at the negotiating table what is the acceptable solution," the head of the alliance was quoted as saying by Reuters.
They look healthy
You don't really expect BBC to report that POW were NOT tortured?!
where photographic evidence like at abu graib?
whatabout your mum?
@@MedienGulli she said you have a maggot and bad breath.
So? I'm sure that the Russian prisoners in Ukraine have been treating like the Albanians in the UK, right? Like 5 star hotels and all that, right?
Ok bot
According to Geneva conventions, little bot.
Russian soldiers should stay in their country than, because Ukrainians are in theirs.
@@dancoy09
Dimwit!
😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Humanity deserves justice, May Day come and all of see crumbling Russian empire
Russian prisoner of war will say they were tortured at Ukraine prison
Yeah but you can see photos - russians go home after ukrainian prison healthy and fat, ukrainians go home emaciated and crippled
ofc they will. else they get tortured
Boo hoo 😂
So fake.
Your account yes
just like russian equipment ,fake plastic junk
@@dancoy09 An ukronazis bot speech.
and Gheyyyyyyyyyyyyy.
Russia is taking in 3,000 South African Farmers amidst the recent calls for their genocide. God Bless Russia.@@dancoy09
The are not looks like tortures
Of course they are going to beat up pows that’s normal everywhere in every war more or less what did they expect after getting captured a bowl of soup ……
No it is not and it is counter productive as well. If you treat prisoners well you are far more likely to get useful information from them.
He would say that, wouldn't he?
What is USA done in Gvantmobey?Worst in H History!And you talk about H R.Des3 People living good nos Where?😱