Noam Chomsky interview on his Life and Career (2003)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 сен 2017
- In this in depth interview with Noam Chomsky, he talked about his life and career as a political activist and critic of U.S. foreign policy. He also responded to questions from viewers on the telephone and submitted by fax and e-mail.
Check out these Noam Chomsky books on Amazon!
Noam Chomsky: A Life of Dissent: amzn.to/315GxSX
Manufacturing Consent: amzn.to/2N3CF1f
Requiem for the American Dream: amzn.to/2ZJYQ3w
On Language: Chomsky's Classic Works: amzn.to/2UF9NgV
Understanding Power: The Indispensible Chomsky: amzn.to/2ZSSMRv
Join us on Patreon! / manufacturingintellect
Donate Crypto! commerce.coinbase.com/checkou...
Share this video!
Get Two Books FREE with a Free Audible Trial: amzn.to/313yfLe
Checking out the affiliate links above helps me bring even more high quality videos by earning me a small commission! And if you have any suggestions for future content, make sure to subscribe on the Patreon page. Thank you for your support! 
Развлечения
Check out Chomsky's "Requiem for the American Dream" on Amazon: amzn.to/2ZJYQ3w
Join us on Patreon! www.patreon.com/ManufacturingIntellect
Donate Crypto! commerce.coinbase.com/checkout/868d67d2-1628-44a8-b8dc-8f9616d62259
Share this video!
Get Two Books FREE with a Free Audible Trial: amzn.to/313yfLe
Checking out the affiliate links above helps me bring even more high quality videos by earning me a small commission! And if you have any suggestions for future content, make sure to subscribe on the Patreon page. Thank you for your support!
Yes because who better to judge the, " Requiem for the American Dream ", than a man who himself became a multi-millionaire writing books bashing the country where he himself has enjoyed a successful & comfortable life! smh
M CK Is what he writes wrong?
@@John_21601 ,
IF Chomsky accurately recites last season's pro football stats, then Chomsky is not, ' wrong ', per se. But does that make him qualified to play or coach for an NFL team? 😀
Chomsky merely cherry-picks data in order to support his own biased preconceived conclusions about fields that he has never actually worked in himself-Which is everything outside Linguistics!
M CK As I understand it, he didn’t cherry pick anything. RFTAD was a recap of speeches he’d made over his career up to when the film was made. Most of it was excerpts from speeches and such.
I’m no expert but it seems pretty apparent what he “predicted” has come to pass.
@@John_21601 ,
Please provide a specific example where Chomsky ever accurately predicted a particular future event, and I will look at it.
Love this man. Especially that he tells viewers to research for themselves and not take his word as gospel. Such integrity. And what a brain - even at 95!
Thats what im saying ,he fuccin aged well ... Joe Biden cant even remember his scripted lines ,but Chomsky is a Rembrandt...I wish i could age like him in mind ...
Brilliant. Sharp here at 75. Still sharper than most at 93!!
Yes, he could still remember the bullshit that he was talking all his life. :-)
@@schmetterling4477I find, as a rule, it's best to completely discount the in(s)ane ramblings of coo fash trumpet-skis. Just saying
@@celestecanyon Of course. That's just one of the reasons why I am not listening to you. ;-)
True.
The man is unbelievable to exist!
He's always respectful and brings out an insight in his answers. Thanks for posting this.
What i love about Noam is how he answers people. His tone is the same no matter what. You expect to hear at least some sort of defensive or impatient tonality in response to the especially the more challenging people, but it never happens. I find it helps me recognize how reactionary I can be and to pause and think a bit.
Quite so. Always clear, precise, and level-headed - with no rhetoric or points scoring. What Noam Chomsky seeks is Understanding and it's Transmission.
I heard him talk about how trying to persuade people of things is a waste of time, or worse. I can't quite figure out how to stop doing that. He just says what he knows and that's that. Like it, don't like it, doesn't matter, he just keeps it moving.
L LLP
A thousand times YES!! His manner of speech&presentation actually precluded me from liking/understanding him the 1st times I encountered his content, surely because (on some level/subconsciously) because I'd simply presumed he had some schtick I wasn't able to readily detect!
After finally seeing that he was just 100.0% honest & genuine, I just considered myself lucky to have finally 'found' all his material. And wow, what a LOT of material (I've even gotten into learning his linguistic/universal-language work which is incredibly fascinating & makes you realize the 'political'/social-observation stuff is genuinely not "his specialty" but is simply what's easier to grasp & has broader appeal.
Also I agree Re realizing how reactionary/emotional/biased/etc I can/could be (and I'd *thought* I was objective!), just being exposed to his stuff for long enough has profound impact upon "typical rhetoric" you'd use at *any* time (not just "if/when talking politics", but literally any time, ie talking to family about emotions, ordering fast food from a clerk etc etc just any&every form of communication) It also leaves you astounded at how "loaded" 99% of people's communications really are.
Professor Noam Chomsky is a very warm and incredibly respectful man and an amazing and interesting intellectual. I just love listening to him. I would love to have been one of his students. God bless. Xx 😊
I can listen this man for hours. Bring his more videos on board
Very few idols in life this gentleman in my eyes is one......respect fascinating intelligence
I'd bet you know nothing of his intelligence. You value the aesthetic that he can provide you.
@@michaelcrabtree1647 I mean, you can listen to what Chomsky has to say. Everything he says about what's going on in the world is a fact. You can disagree with what should be done about it, but he's not saying anything that can't be verified.
@@michaelcrabtree1647 I don't even know what that's supposed to mean. Obviously the original comment was meant to express a relief that there is one person (Noam) who does seem to deserve some of the accolades he receives. We don't have many good examples let us be happy for this one. That's my view of it. If Prof. Chomsky ever were to say something I disagree with, I would immediately withdraw a relative amount of support. That just hasn't happened yet and I've listened to literally weeks worth of lectures and books. Would you rather be disappointed?
I wouldn't describe him as an "idol" for me but he definetily inspires and makes me feel less lonely in a world where too many intellectuals put their talents at the service of nefariuos or at best dubious purposes.
@@michaelcrabtree1647 I know about his genius. I studied his ideas about parsing. It's why his shameless self-serving Left fascist shilling is so inexcusable.
imagine having a father you can ask about most of the pressing issues of life plus linguistic expertise... I miss my father....
I miss my father too.
Excellent interview from the past.
Noam Chomsky is a gem of information, This country since the beginning has always used narrative's to control the thoughts and actions of it's people. Noam Chomsky debunks all that misinformation. I thank you Noam Chomsky.
narratives; its
Sounds like an interrogation! Interviewer is about as warm and friendly as a weekend in Guantanamo
Yeah I thought a panel of personalities were interviewing him.
true i think hes the boss of cspan tho and the final boss too i guess
That's Brian Lamb. Founder of cspan
It is an interrogation
Gets the job done, though! I wonder what they said to eachither during the breaks.
This interviewer is asking Noam Chomsky "when he went to MIT and why" like he was interrogating a suspect of homicide
Guilty as charged, went to school.
Hey ease off Brian Lamb, he’s like that with everyone, it’s just his style.
Absolutely! Since Chomsky is not a staunch right winger the inflection of Lamb’s voice and his line of question ing are not very “nice”
Great questions.
I feel like I'm a kid in the 2000s again watching this. The graphics and music are still rooted in the 90s but the video quality feels more modern, and the remorse around 9/11 and the war in iraq
wow. Especially on Iran it is as if Professor Chomsky spoke today. All he said are correct. This man is a seer I think.
Love it….hey 2021 still going 💪🏽!!!!
Was the Professor advised of his rights by the Detective there? lol
"What were you doing there at the Pentagon?" That tone of voice, lol
He knows them better than the "Detective", as you capitalized it.
Who the fuck do you think you're talking about, moron?
Haha yes, I thought the same - "Why did you go to MIT and why!"
This man was doing podcasts even before they were a thing
How could someone do podcasts before they were a thing?
@@michaelcrabtree1647
You’re an intelligent man - how about antedating a present day podcast to a date in the past preferred/chosen by the interrogators/podcast crew to cover up a brutal crime they purposely committed, filmed and released on RUclips as proof of their sick bravado & twisted beliefs in their unquestioned hold/control on social media and to other people they victimise because they perceive them as dangerous threats to their reckless uncontrolled evil deeds!
EDIT: 31 Jan 2021
The criminals had since pulled out the incriminating video/podcast I mentioned above from the date I originally made this comment and replaced it with several, not just one, cover up videos, in their desperate hope that they can get away Scot free.
About the Media: " The choice of topics, the shaping of information, the basic assumptions, and so on fall within a fairly narrow spectrum which tends to be highly supportive of state and corporate power." -Noam Chomsky
I love this show. Not being from the states i didn't grow up with it but have been watching some fantastic interviews. Is it still going?
no
Yes it does: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Depth
Very good professor Naom Chomsky...
Can anyone tell me which song is playing at 1:11:00?
Thank you in advance!
I think this is just something made by C-Span to fill the air waves. I don't get any artist/name when using an app that identifies music by sound.
1:48:41 I found it amusing he pointed at the books behind him, *the legal literature* 😆
Beautiful Life.
Good memory Noam
At 2:32:11, the rising tide raises all boats analogy from a caller made Noam crack a smile. The voice of the caller sounded to me a lot like the comedian Al Franken, but I am probably wrong about that.
Im an Irish catholic and felt bad when Chomsky stated he had a, albeit "irrational", fear of the Catholics in his neighborhood but could also see why also and I think practicing or "practicing" Catholics need to be more understanding and , and this is very important, be able to reasonably debate their beliefs. Furthermore, I've always loved the Jewish culture(not out of pity but actual real admiration, some only respect Jews post ww2 but not for their intellectual thought) and sorry that the irish Catholics in his neighborhood did not respect him,or other minorities. For me, I see my history as a colonial experience that informs me. Many Irish separate that history from other post English colonial states but I don't. I think it's consistent to have an idea of identifying myself as a Catholic Irish with an anti colonial sentiment with a sympathy for the other post colonial states(India,Pakistan etc). Many irish today separate their history from India for example. This is inconsistent with the real experience, rights struggles and beliefs. Have the Irish become anglophiled? I think so, but O haven't! Can only speak for myself. Love chomsky
fuck christianity
blicky2blacky n in i i. gotta i oí i was i io
blicky2blacky iohas io i i i. iyeah ihas has to a day o o o o o o o o i. i.
nooyeah yeah i
blicky2blacky nohas ihas in
i. i noyeah i nlike ilike o. yeah o
n i
i no
omni
o
n o. no. noi n onninini i
you should o. you should or in nmmmonm
no
io innin ono no o
o
no n oniooijnnjiji
nnmmmmn i. i i i
blicky2blacky ojo
in no io in i niin ini.
n
n
yeah oyeah non
o. n
n i o o
n
no
i
no i iniion i noninterventionist
i
in
ionnn inininini ii
iononon
o o o i
jn
jn
98 books 👍
It's amazing you knew how to count
Thank you! Stay tuned.
This guy sounds like he’s interrogating Noam
I just wish we had leaders like him in power. We'd have a different world, and one I would like to see happen one day.
This man is now 94 or 95. Quite a remarkable man, Insightful with great intellectual, political and cultural acuity.
According to “Noam Chomsky” by John Lyons, he was born on December 7, 1928. So he is 94.
Requiem for a dream
It's easy to forger that this is 2003, when callers like the guy at (approx.) an hour and thirty-seven minutes really believed that a missile hit the Pentagon and the towers collapsed because of an internal controlled explosion. Chomsky is very kind in his polite dismissal of that stuff.
Interesting how great men like Professor Chomsky generally come from good loving close families, while horrible authoritarians narcissistic monsters often come from broken families where they never received important parental love and care…
Brian Lamb Interrogates Noam Chomsky!
State the interviewer's name in the description
Noblesse Oblige. Our most visible scholar is not infallible, but we need more of him.
Weird comment.
Not at all. Noam himself states that human beings are fallible.
1:22:43
2:04 he said so many words about so much, and I kept thinking, ‘If he’s still alive, he has Qanon now!’
based
I've watched this interview several times and I STILL cringe at 2:23 because of the lady calling to ask if he's read an Ann Coulter's book. Good grief !!!!
2:35:30
سؤال هل المعانات التي واجهها اليهو هي سبب تفوقه في معظم العلوم
I don't want bruise your ears
Or hurt you again
But I got back-stabbed by a black cab
When I needed a friend
[Verse 1]
Now I'm in town, break it down, thinkin' of making a new sound
Playing a different show every night in front of a new crowd
That's you now, ciao, seems that life is great now
See me lose focus as I sing to you loud
And I can't, no, I won't hush
I'll say the words that make you blush
I'm gonna sing this now (Oh, oh)
See, I'm true, my songs are where my heart is
I'm like glue, I stick to other artists
I'm not you, now, that would be disastrous
Let me sing and do my thing and move to greener pastures
See, I'm real, I do it all, it's all me
I'm not fake, don't ever call me lazy
I won't stay put, give me the chance to be free
Suffolk sadly seems to sort of suffocate me
[Chorus]
'Cause you need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you at all
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you at all
You need me
See Ed Sheeran Live
Get tickets as low as $84
You might also like
Suburban Legends (Taylor’s Version) [From The Vault]
Taylor Swift
Saturn
SZA
Electric Touch (Taylor’s Version) [From The Vault]
Taylor Swift
[Verse 2]
I sing and write my own tune and I write my own verse, hell
Don't need another wordsmith to make my tunes sell
Call yourself a singer-writer, you're just bluffin'
Name's on the credits and you didn't write nothin'
I sing fast, I know that all my shit's cool
I will blast and I didn't go to BRIT School
I came fast with the way I act, right
I can't last if I'm smokin' on a crack pipe
And I won't be a product of my genre
My mind will always be stronger than my songs are
Never believe the bullshit that fake guys feed to ya
Always read the stories that you hear in Wikipedia
And musically, I'm demonstratin'
When I perform live, feels like I am meditating
Times at the enterprise when some fella filmed me
A young singer-writer like a Gabriella Cilmi
[Chorus]
'Cause you need me, man, I don’t need you
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you at all
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you at all
You need me
[Verse 3]
'Cause with the lyrics, I'll be aimin' it right
I won't stop till my name's in lights at stadium heights with Damien Rice
On red carpets, now, I'm on Arabian Nights
Because I'm young, I know my brother's gonna give me advice
Long nighter, short height and I'd gone hyper
Never be anything but a singer-songwriter, yeah
The game's over, but now, I'm on a new level
Watch how I step on the track without a loop pedal
People think that I'm bound to blow up
I've done around about a thousand shows, but
I haven't got a house, plus, I live on a couch
So you believe the lyrics when I'm singin' them out
Wow, from day one, I've been prepared
With V05 wax for my ginger hair
So now, I'm back to the sofa
Givin' a dose of what the future holds 'cause it's another day
Plus, I'll keep my last name forever, keep this genre pretty basic
Gonna be breakin' into other people's tunes when I chase it
And replace it with the elephant in the room with a facelift
Slipping into another rapper's shoes usin' new laces
I'm sellin' CDs from my rucksack aimin' for the papers
Sellin' CDs from my rucksack aimin' for the majors
Nationwide tour with Just Jack, still had to get the bus back
Clean cut kid without a razor for the moustache
I hit back when the pen hurts me
I'm still a choir boy in a Fenchurch tee
I'm still the same as a year ago, but more people hear me, though
According to the MySpace and RUclips videos
I'm always doin' shows, if I'm not, I'm in the studio
Truly broke, never growin' up, call me Rufio
Melody music maker, readin' all the papers
They say I'm up and comin' like I'm fucking in an elevator
[Chorus]
'Cause you need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you at all
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you
You need me, man, I don't need you at all
You need me, man, I don't need you
About
Genius Annotation
35:00 34:00 33:00 32:00 31:00 30:00 29:00 28:00 27:00 26:00 25:00
When did u meet Carol “we’ll I was 4 and she was 2” I’m cackling
CSPAN is Great!
in 1:36:00, CSPAN bombards Chomsky with 4 questions. Seriously?
1:42:46 gold
Piers Morgan is everything I hate about mainstream politics. Anything against the grain of HIS ideology means he takes his stab at calling someone out for being an apologist. It’s ridiculous. What’s more ridiculous, is his fidgeting while Chomsky is talking, interrupting him and totally changing the topic to his personal life… Loved how Chomsky had to remind him with every answer, to paraphrase, “first, let’s start with the facts.”
2:03:00 JFK Conspiracy Theorist caller and Chomsky's response.
24:50
And now having the benefit of being 19 years in the future from when this interview was conducted, we know that the lack of WMDs meant absolutely nothing and had absolutely ZERO consequences. I'm surprised Chomsky did not predict this.
1:24:00
Much as I respect him, can´t agree with him in labelling Operation Northwood as a contingency plan. It was not a "what if" plan seeking oportunism. It was an actual proposal to by active action shape the global geopolitical ground. His concious dismissal displays his willingness to avoid an honest openminded debate about 9/11. Even his bodylanguage changes each time the topic is brought up. Even if in this instance and subject he acts as sort of a gatekeeper, I still agree with him in 99% of his thought regarding other topics.
Chomsky shoud debat more religious problems and the role of the US via others poors countries
What Barack is he referring to in relation to bill clinton if this was in 2003?
He's referring to Ehud Barak, then-PM of Israel
In another interview, Chomsky talks of the Ehud-Clinton proposal, which is more or less about their discussions with Yasser Arafat at Camp David
Might sound bizzare but this is the first video for me where Chomsky ‘ sounds’ like an American :) for an outsider like me
Just curious, what do you mean "sounds like an American"
On Dec. 8th, 1941, the survival of Britain was not in doubt; 90% of the world's people and resources were allied against the Axis, it was now only a matter of time" - Winston Churchill's "History of WWII".
Came here for ASMR, ended up listening to all 3 hours.
Less than 1000 total comments/rankings on this 3 hour whirlwind tour, while the most base pop music video might have millions of views... is it any wonder political change, social change, and progress for the entire human race seems so far away?
These callers just ramble on and on Jesus cspan do a little moderation one time.
Chomsky is the greatest intellectual and dissident speaking truth to power in our times. Whatever happens to this poor planet, and us, we can't say Chomsky didn't warn us.
4:04 that's insane the conditions noam grew up under
58:06 haha never believe anything that's put on a cover by a publisher; well said.
Shouldnt it be "personufacturing" now?
destroy the market forces and there is order without power
Does twirling them feel good? ;-)
1:10:55 Stats
1:26:10 For me Zionism meant opposition to a Jewish state
Ever notice or get the impression the world is ruled with a whip and people are so used to it
Not just used to it. They prefer it. Most people are inclined to believe what they are told since they're not intelligent enough to imagine something better.
No. It's ruled by people without a whip, and you follow willingly.
@@michaelcrabtree1647
Not physical whip but mind - frequent mind control. Beware of what you’re listening to or what interests you - it will be weaponised against you. That’s how people, no matter how highly educated/successful in their life may be, it matters not to the neoliberals because to them - they are the privileged and nothing/no one will ever be their equal; they are the “creme de la creme” of society - this is how the so called ZOMBIES are treated/shown to know where they belong in society by the crazed group!
@@mindabobis7601 Does what you tell me also apply to you? Of course, you know what the word "neoliberal" means and you're highly educated, yes? That means you have to be careful, too.
@@michaelcrabtree1647
What do you mean, I have to be careful too? - I’m just verbalising a truth which is tolerated or accepted by the victims blindly due to their lack of knowledge on how to free themselves from their unending subjugation by the ruling elite. What would you do or feel if you are one of them or they are your family/related to you or close family friends; will you just be content to turn a blind eye to such injustice for the rest of your life? We no longer live in the feudal ages; every citizen have constitutional rights and maybe, bringing awareness of the unnecessary plight enforced on people might draw attention from the true libertarians/freedom minded members of govt/society who can seriously take action to ease the pervasive sadness/hopelessness you can smell/detect from these silent victims.
It would be great if we all, regardless of colour/status in society, or whatever, will voluntarily acknowledge our responsibility to engage intellectually with the constitutionally elected government leaders to look at the prevailing norms of living in their respective communities and conscientiously enforce the proper constitutional law for any situation.
goddess energy? nothing to say about it tbh
That was wack. Not coz the caller bieve it but coz she thought Nomaky would entertain this silliness .
Noam was streets 😊
Who is the most intelligent person in the world? You are watching him.
I think wise and learned would more aptly describe him. We all have our blind spots
This video seems little bit strange as his lips are not supporting his words
ctet or uptet vale like kre
I am the academic who has voluntarily ruining the remainder of his intellect by going about summarizing RUclips videos. Remember almost every RUclips video is" just too long".
I didn't watch this one, sorry
So, we too can live in a Democratische Arbiter's paradise...
First step is to put up a wall to keep our people in.
What will the cognoscenti do when Noam is gone? Will the mouth breathers finally succeed in self destruction, by truculently supporting their Owners, who, do not believe they actually have the right to even live?
Michael parenti should of got the same amount of time he is much more interesting, I THOUGHT HE WAS MORE BIAS AGAINS PARENTI
What?
Chomsky says about Iran applies universally : if a country is threatened from a foreign adversary, as Iran is threatened by the US, it will take a defensive attitude toward that country and tend to be authoritarian domestically.
So, it makes sense, then, that the threatening country, like the US, will propagandize its aggressive stance to its own population about lack of democracy in the country it threatens. This can apply to US current relations with Russia, China and other countries the US threatens.
Then why does almost every middle east nation fear Iran and want it's nuclear program stopped.
Why is it that Iranian leaders and many citizens routinely scream "death to America"?
This Chomsky
Head nutcase speaks again.
NONSENSE! TAKING AMERICAN DIPLOMATS HOSTAGE IS AN ACT OF WAR LIBTARD!
It’s convenient that all authoritarian regimes have that excuse 🙄
Long live democratic socialism and freedom
SOCIALISM/COMMUNISM IS AN UTTER AND COMPLETE FAILURE AND HAS NEVER WORKED! IT IS THE ANTI-THESIS OF FREEDOM, LIBERTY AND INDEPEDENCE! SOCIALISM/COMMUNISM HAS MURDERED 500,000,000+ PEOPLE SINCE IT WAS IMPOSED UPON THE WORLD BY THE CRONY CRIMINAL COMMUNIST DEVIL vladimir ulianov IN 1917 AND ENSLAVED BILLIONS WORLDWIDE UNDER OPPRESSIVE DICTATORSHIPS AND POLICE STATES! LIBERALISM IS A MENTAL DISEASE AND LIBTARDS LIKE YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY INSANE!
It's called social democracy, kid. At least try to remember the correct word order. ;-)
@@schmetterling4477 WRONG LIBTARD! IT DOES NOT MATTER WHICH ORDER BECAUSE IT MEANS EXACTLY THE SAME THING! ANTI-FREEDOM, ANTI-LIBERTY, ANTI-INDEPENDENCE AND ANTI-AMERICAN! SOCIALISM/COMMUNISM IS AN UTTER FAILURE EVERYWHERE IT HAS BEEN IMPOSED BECAUSE IT DOES NOT WORK!
@@drumqid Socialism is the control of the means of production by the government. That is, by definition, incompatible with democracy. Dude, seriously. This is not rocket science, you guys simply didn't pay attention in school. ;-)
@@drumqid I am talking about your failed education. ;-)
There is no such thing as democratic socialism. In socialism the state takes all economic power away from its citizens. If you don't get to make choices, then you don't have democracy. :-)
Once you start the drawing board lies
they're not lies anymore, just a language
Michel is familiar to em , maybe details locked in the baggage
i plant so hard, you'll never deny convention's language could be a jack russell recalled
come here tho, even your bridge is murdered, i make conventions in your cerebral to see the object like im mohammed , ur necked
so they don't ever last aroud here, cos, when its my turn to howl at Nas, I wait for Godot to help me concrete that for the suns reflection off her face, I will do 4 others what Mobb Deep does for me, they're real bro
disagreeable ISFJ with developed Fe
I agree with Noam Chomsky on a lot of topics. However, his opinion on 9/11 is completely off-touch. The amount of evidence is simply too much for all of it to have been a coincidental.
Perhaps it is his lack of an engineering background what holds him back from seeing the evidence.
The perfect, symmetric freefall speeds of tower 1 and 2. The collapse of building 7, which wasn't hit by a plane of any kind. The lack of photographic and physical evidence at the Pentagon. 40 to 100 tons of Aluminium, composites, fabric, titanium, you name it. It all vaporized upon hitting the Pentagon on one side and exiting out of the other, apart from a few mismatched aircraft parts before the first impact wall.
In regards to the argument that leaks would've happened. Countries have been able, throughout history, to cover-up a lot of plots for a very long time. Yes, this plot was of unprecedented grandeur, but, nevertheless, there are countless precedents.
Countries such as Britain still have WW2 archives locked away. I am not talking about technological papers. Those have a reason to be inaccessible.
Russia has countless documents still locked away from its Soviet days.
We still argue about who set fire to the Reichstag in Germany.
I could go on and on...
Nothing happens by accident
Your lack of an engineering background + your inability to trust the experts in their respective engineering fields causes you not to see the evidence.
Keep that same energy the next time your toilet or sink is leaking or electrical wiring is wrong in your house. Go with the least trusted contrarian in the market to tackle those problems 🍿
@@t33nyplaysp0p I have listen to experts.
Gatekeeper
Thank you, that was very helpful. I was going to pay attention. Your single word has helped me to realize how stupid it would be to ever listen to anything or try to understand anything.
@@stevenhines5550 Tell us about how the evil muslims did 9/11 - lol
Sounds like an FBI interrogation, disrespectful and stupid considering that this is the most brilliant mind alive
stop crying
So why don't you dispute Pakistan? 1947.....or Tibet? And then you cannot agree to a Palestinian state ( there is no such people, ever) because that would contradict what you just said about "privileged people" in Israel. I once respected thus guy but like the rest who cannot see the supernatural work of God in the reformation of Israel after thousands of years scattered abroad, I now see him as another "professing to be wise but becoming fools" who's pride in there great God gives intellects, has blinded them to the spiritually obvious. The hatred of the Jews is demonically led because Jesus was a Jew and will return as the Lion of the Tribe of JUDAH. Through the Jews salvation and the Bible came to all mankind who will believe. No other explanation for such hatred of a tiny people group can ever make sense. They are God's chosen, they strayed away, God will soon show the world his grace and mercy towards them and will destroy all evil countries that gather against Israel in the soon Russian led alliance against them. This is the real reason for the current Ukraine war. To prepare for the great Gog and Magog war of Ezekiel ch37, 38.
Then the whole world will know at last, what the "Almighty" God can do in the blink of an eye.
you sound like a psycopath
Constrantly decries the USA and capitalist economies lives in the US and benefits financially from the capitalist enterprises of the sale of his books and lectures.
You should read
@@borninvincible I read but I don't swallow everything I read and when I hear or read what Chomsky say what he does I realise the inconsistency in what he says that make his statements so wrong. He picks and chooses parts of historical situations or present situations to support what he says rather than taking a wider view. His inconsistencies in economic matters proves he is so far off target. An example is his support of Chavez where he openly made a statement that praised him but when the situation went sour he claims he didn't support Chavez's policies. He said what he said but he doesn't stand up and support capitalism in the same way he did Chavez. That is an example of his inconsistency.
@@Rob-fx2dw I don't believe Chomsky ever endorsed Chavez personally, he was just praising Venezuela for creating a democratic movement and electing a popular leader.
@@tastemaker_87 That is Not what he said. it may be what you hoped he said. Just look at his imbalanced criticism of Capitalist countries as opposed to otehrs.
If it’s his selling books that pisses you off, you can email him, free of charge.
So right away, he avoids giving ANY real examples of anti-semitism he actually experienced? Why is that Noam? He just makes some general reference to "reading about it" lol. That's really odd. Why would he dodge that question? And he DID dodge it.
This interviewer is awful, he really shouldn't interview again...
Isn't it great that his name is nowhere to be found in the description?
@@michaelcrabtree1647
Yeah, great for the cover up concocted by evil minds at the same time flaunt their conscienceless practice of violence and leaving evidence behind to gloat and proclaim/boast to their cohorts/gang members their unchecked criminal behaviours. To bad, this time discerning minds caught these madmen with their pants down!!!
He is the founder of cspan according to other comments. Pretty crazy.
I disagree. I like his short, concise questioning style. This is a segment about Chomsky, we don't need the interviewer's personality.
whats awful about him exactly?
Let me summarize:
I grew up in a Kibbutz
Then I shilled for as a gatekeeper for the establishment
Then I retired
And let me guess:
You are intellectual young and where exposed to alot of propaganda..
Im only from smalltown in germany but i wouldnt call Philadelphia of the 1930s a "Kibbuz" (settlement, commune)
If you want to be funny atleast be 50% correct.
And how is a 'shill' if hes went for jail for his critic of the esteblishment his government?
You also dont seem to know many teachers or professors, they usually arent that wellpayed/ lazy or pro government/establishment you make them sound..
Spoken like a real idiot
Zaz chaudhary be careful (yunus
@@NewPipeFTW His government is in the Middle East
@@yingyang1008
Who are you refering to.
And how is that relevant?
He may be a renowned linguist and darling of computer scientists, but his politics show him to be a stereotypical pacifist fop.
In your narrow view, yes
I agree .he always makes excuses to not elaborate on what really happened on 911, even though he is smarter than most.
Hey i wanna feel insulted too..
Whats a 'fop'?
Also - he answered most of those questions regarding 9/11..
He didnt see any evidence yet confirming the government planned or assisted in the attacks.
Tho he acknowledges they could have known in advance and that the government was using those attacks to justify there crimes/lies/failures
Dont think he changed his few alot since this interview.
But he seems annoyed by all those questions indicating a bigger conspiracy without any proof.
I get that this topic was still 'fresh' for the callers but i guess he knows (to this day) alot more true, proofable and currently still happening crimes against innocent/the public - that dont get the attention they deserve.
"this guy doesnt want to bomb countries for no reason i hate him"
He is arrogant and boring!
OOOOOOOOOH!
Back to the pump house.