That was absolutely fascinating! Thanks so much for sharing this interview, I'm just a humble Seiko collector but it is wonderful to hear (and see) both Mr Hands and Roger Smith talking about our shared hobby
Watch making royalty. Could listen & learn from Roger all day long. A true gentleman & perfectionist. Perhaps you should have added that he wears a Rolex Explorer as a daily to the title. Might then get the number of views this video deserves! ;-)
Oh yes, I met him (Roger Smith) at Salon QP back then... He encouraged me to keep on with the design on the watches... I have since stuck to it. Great humble man.
Very interesting to listen to Roger Smith, OBE, about his improvements on the co-axial escapement. Thank you at 47:26 for asking the question which brought forth Roger sharing his experience with the Omega movement.
Great to see Roger and how he talked about George Daniel’s. Also interesting how Roger recently purchased an Omega Speedmaster Caliber 3861 and how one of the pioneers of watchmaking appreciates the co-axial movement.
This is wonderful. Fascinating interview and heartening to see a bunch of genuinely passionate watch lovers in the crowd. The antithesis of the 'flex' culture that so many watch channels focus on these days. This one was for the grown ups.
What a brilliant video. Roger is so down to earth and so articulate with his answers to the questions. It's great to hear about the shifting or should I say expanding goals not only to make watches that are accurate but ultimately to lubrication free hence extending service intervals. Big brands will make money on servicing but I do not know how many people actually service the watches at the recommended intervals anyway and that again would depend on how the watch was worn. Given that the bigger brands should they adopt the co-axial escapement could in theory reduce the servicing effort and concentrate it on watch making. I do envy Roger a little for being able to get to know George over the years but it's brilliant the he's still developing the escapement. I had to smile when he took a 3861 speedy to bits to notice the single piece coax-axial escapement wheel. Oh and unless I'm mistaken (probably) he has the Explorer given to him by his wife that he converted to co-axial on his wrist.
He addresses an interesting issue at about 44:00. The "self-policing" nature of his oversight of his team members and the importance of trust. I learned through my experience working for a very skilled luthier, that if you have the right team members and they understand the quality standards, the students will go to the master for his approval and teaching rather than the master having to monitor every procedure. It is an interesting and important dynamic, which speaks to the commitment and sacrifice of the team, and the ability of the master to extend his/her trust.
This was an outstanding event. So fascinating to hear from Mr. Smith. I seem to recall hearing George Daniels say in a video that some lubrication was needed due to variations in air moisture. Is this right? Also, I was hoping you might ask his opinion on Grand Seiko’s new escapement in the 9SA5 movement.
If I was 40 years younger I would take my tent and pitch it close to Rogers workshop and plead with him every day to let me be his apprentice, it must be incredible being part of his team
20 years without servicing? No way the big brands of the industry will adopt a co- axial. They won't make money after the sale. Incredible content Andrew and the team. Thanks for this.
@@jamesstanley7263 lol. Exactly - for more than years now at Omega. Maybe the OP is unfamiliar with both watchmaking and Google. Here’s a ~10 hrs advert: ruclips.net/video/uC-97i-SF3Y/видео.html Oh, and there’s a 9908 based Speedy on my wrist - pretty sure it’s not my imagination.
To find out about the NY event, I signed up for the newsletter. I've received some watch ads but no event information. I'm trying to plan a trip to NY and hope to hit your event while there. Where do I find the details?
Roger Smith's approach is great, at a human scale and then so humble. I understand why but I always find it so incoherent that this kind of work gets strictly reserved for very wealthy people, and we must say, not always the most humble among us. And when he says that it is gratifying to see prices going up on the secondary market...?
Perfectionism is often considered by the mental health industry as being a sort of mental disorder. I cannot state whether they're right or wrong, but it's essential to great watchmaking because it shows up in the work and it cannot be faked. The door analogy given by Roger is excellent for understanding the difference between a lever and coaxial escapement. Mobius has gone to the trouble of creating a special lubricant just for the problem (Mobius 9415). The intention being for the lubricant to stay on the pallet fork Jewels and the teeth of the escapement wheel when applied in the proper amount which is important. It resists being 'flung off' with the impact of the Jewel on the wheel remaining in place as long as possible. All respectable watchmakers use 9415 for the task. Like everything else this will need to be repeated during the maintenance cycle of a mechanical watch where as Roger explains is not a problem for the coaxial movement not needing lubricant as he claims. I for one don't have a clue as to whether or not some kind of lubricant should be used on the coaxial but can certainly appreciation in the reduction of friction in that escapement.
To the interviewer who mention more than once that he would like to own one of Rojer's watches and that it won't be for 'lack of trying', it's easy.. Ask in a serious way, wait in line, and be willing to hand over whatever money it takes to make it happen. If you're hoping to be given one, or sold one at a discount you're delusional to the point of extreme arrogance.
George and Roger are great subjects for a film. Who would play George? I’m thinking Ray Winstone. I got the vibe that George could and had to handle himself while he grew up from the docs I’ve seen and stories from someone who messed about in old cars with him on the Isle of Man
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
That was absolutely fascinating! Thanks so much for sharing this interview, I'm just a humble Seiko collector but it is wonderful to hear (and see) both Mr Hands and Roger Smith talking about our shared hobby
I was in the audience!
Thoroughly enjoyed the entire talk and meeting other watch enthusiasts after.
More events please.
Andrew, this was a masterful interview. Thank you for bringing Roger Smith to us.
Wow that was a very special treat! Thanks for posting Andrew.
Thanks so much for sharing this it was amazing to hear about watch making from the legend Roger Smith.
So wish I could be there in person. Major Congratulations on your road show.
Such brilliant content - Roger is absolute horology royalty - I could listen to this all day
Probably the most fascinating video you guys have ever done. Fabulous.
It was such a brilliant evening, looking forward to more of these events! Thank you, Andrew and Roger!
Andrew, well done. A riveting listen. This needs to be an annual interview.
I had a pleasure to attend in person, thank you so much for this possibility.
Andrew, fantastic video, the look of reverence and awe on your face sitting next to the great man is brilliant.
Quality, class, appreciation & excellence. And that's just the interviewer! Sir Roger Smith - whole next level.
I just love the utter reverence that Roger maintains for George, despite his own achievements. Wonderful to listen to.
Very cool, also nice to put a face to the voice. Roger's ace and a pleasure to listen to as always.
Thank you Watchfinder and Andrew for sharing this interview.
Watch making royalty. Could listen & learn from Roger all day long. A true gentleman & perfectionist. Perhaps you should have added that he wears a Rolex Explorer as a daily to the title. Might then get the number of views this video deserves! ;-)
Great content!! Thank you Andrew!!
What a terrific presentation ! Thanks
Could easily listen to another hour of this.
Fantastic video. A must for all watch enthusiasts.
Roger Smith, a fellow Boltonian and a master at watchmaking. Can't wait to enjoy this talk later on with my tea. 😊
Really enjoyed this one Andrew. Thanks for sharing that with us
Thank you for posting this, I would have liked to be there.
The majority of the time I hit the like button just for watching a video….but this one I actually meant it. Thoroughly enjoyable
Oh yes, I met him (Roger Smith) at Salon QP back then... He encouraged me to keep on with the design on the watches... I have since stuck to it. Great humble man.
Fantastic…..so good to hear the greatest British watchmaker speaking 👏🏻
Very interesting to listen to Roger Smith, OBE, about his improvements on the co-axial escapement. Thank you at 47:26 for asking the question which brought forth Roger sharing his experience with the Omega movement.
You're welcome 😊
@@DanMarkland Great! Thank you again Mr Markland.
What!!
Mr hands now has a face 😎
Finally
he has even another youtube channel!! Face included!
@@davidremior what is it?
@@RR-us2kp Andrew Morgan Watches
Great to see Roger and how he talked about George Daniel’s. Also interesting how Roger recently purchased an Omega Speedmaster Caliber 3861 and how one of the pioneers of watchmaking appreciates the co-axial movement.
Excellent!
Wonderful chat. Thank you!
Many thanks for this interview!
This is wonderful. Fascinating interview and heartening to see a bunch of genuinely passionate watch lovers in the crowd. The antithesis of the 'flex' culture that so many watch channels focus on these days. This one was for the grown ups.
Oh so you are the beautiful voice in your videos, love it.
Thank you Andrew and Roger. This was fascinating. I expect that the membership rolls of the BWA have benefited, I know that I am now a member.
Ah another fantastic thing to come from Bolton!
Yes, we create gems.
@@Mr-Safology It's good to see the Bolton collective 😁
Well done Andrew. 😊
What a brilliant video. Roger is so down to earth and so articulate with his answers to the questions. It's great to hear about the shifting or should I say expanding goals not only to make watches that are accurate but ultimately to lubrication free hence extending service intervals. Big brands will make money on servicing but I do not know how many people actually service the watches at the recommended intervals anyway and that again would depend on how the watch was worn. Given that the bigger brands should they adopt the co-axial escapement could in theory reduce the servicing effort and concentrate it on watch making. I do envy Roger a little for being able to get to know George over the years but it's brilliant the he's still developing the escapement. I had to smile when he took a 3861 speedy to bits to notice the single piece coax-axial escapement wheel. Oh and unless I'm mistaken (probably) he has the Explorer given to him by his wife that he converted to co-axial on his wrist.
How did I miss this event 😞
He addresses an interesting issue at about 44:00. The "self-policing" nature of his oversight of his team members and the importance of trust. I learned through my experience working for a very skilled luthier, that if you have the right team members and they understand the quality standards, the students will go to the master for his approval and teaching rather than the master having to monitor every procedure. It is an interesting and important dynamic, which speaks to the commitment and sacrifice of the team, and the ability of the master to extend his/her trust.
I enjoyed that.
This was an outstanding event. So fascinating to hear from Mr. Smith. I seem to recall hearing George Daniels say in a video that some lubrication was needed due to variations in air moisture. Is this right? Also, I was hoping you might ask his opinion on Grand Seiko’s new escapement in the 9SA5 movement.
If I was 40 years younger I would take my tent and pitch it close to Rogers workshop and plead with him every day to let me be his apprentice, it must be incredible being part of his team
Your masterwork
20 years without servicing? No way the big brands of the industry will adopt a co- axial. They won't make money after the sale.
Incredible content Andrew and the team. Thanks for this.
Does Omega not count?
@@jamesstanley7263No…🤣
Actually when you don't need to spend on servicing you will spend on new watches.
@@jamesstanley7263 lol. Exactly - for more than years now at Omega. Maybe the OP is unfamiliar with both watchmaking and Google. Here’s a ~10 hrs advert: ruclips.net/video/uC-97i-SF3Y/видео.html Oh, and there’s a 9908 based Speedy on my wrist - pretty sure it’s not my imagination.
Glashütte Original and H. Moser & Cie also do almost everything in-house.
To find out about the NY event, I signed up for the newsletter. I've received some watch ads but no event information. I'm trying to plan a trip to NY and hope to hit your event while there. Where do I find the details?
Wonderful
Roger Smith's approach is great, at a human scale and then so humble. I understand why but I always find it so incoherent that this kind of work gets strictly reserved for very wealthy people, and we must say, not always the most humble among us. And when he says that it is gratifying to see prices going up on the secondary market...?
Perfectionism is often considered by the mental health industry as being a sort of mental disorder. I cannot state whether they're right or wrong, but it's essential to great watchmaking because it shows up in the work and it cannot be faked.
The door analogy given by Roger is excellent for understanding the difference between a lever and coaxial escapement. Mobius has gone to the trouble of creating a special lubricant just for the problem (Mobius 9415). The intention being for the lubricant to stay on the pallet fork Jewels and the teeth of the escapement wheel when applied in the proper amount which is important. It resists being 'flung off' with the impact of the Jewel on the wheel remaining in place as long as possible. All respectable watchmakers use 9415 for the task. Like everything else this will need to be repeated during the maintenance cycle of a mechanical watch where as Roger explains is not a problem for the coaxial movement not needing lubricant as he claims.
I for one don't have a clue as to whether or not some kind of lubricant should be used on the coaxial but can certainly appreciation in the reduction of friction in that escapement.
I was told by an AD that I probably wouldn't need to service a co-axial Omega for about 10 years.
Wow, simply riveting so amazingly interesting! PS one bloke needs a haircut and it’s not Roger!
👌🏽👏🏼
so this has 13 dislikes, may I ask why?
To the interviewer who mention more than once that he would like to own one of Rojer's watches and that it won't be for 'lack of trying', it's easy.. Ask in a serious way, wait in line, and be willing to hand over whatever money it takes to make it happen.
If you're hoping to be given one, or sold one at a discount you're delusional to the point of extreme arrogance.
Pity about the audio
George and Roger are great subjects for a film. Who would play George? I’m thinking Ray Winstone. I got the vibe that George could and had to handle himself while he grew up from the docs I’ve seen and stories from someone who messed about in old cars with him on the Isle of Man
Roger W. Smith is a modern legend. What i would give for one of his wrist watches. Top one. Nice one. Get sorted. 😎