Ahsoka Tano vs. The Magistrate
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- Most Asked Questions:
Why did the lightsaber stuck up with the staff? Shouldn't it break it?
- The staff was made by Pure Beskar, a material that can survive many blaster shots, or lightsaber strikes and won't break.
Watch this video. www.youtube.co....
When her lightsaber sank in the river, has she ever gotten it back?
- In the end of Chapter 13 she had both lightsabers on her belt so, yes.
Could this mean Thrawn, Ezra maybe even Sabine will appear in Mandalorian?
- I kinda don't think so, however it is only speculation. This might be a tease for some Rebels Sequel coming in.
It's impossible that Ahsoka would have such a problem beating non-force staff user. - Ahsoka was not trying to kill nor hurt the lady. She was aiming for disarming her and getting information, she needed her alive.
Have you heard about modification for Jedi Academy that adds it's own playable gamemodes, skins from all across Star Wars no matter what timeline? Legends aswell, many skinpacks that add new models to the game also exist. Very realistic hard-to-learn lightsaber combat.
You should try MovieBattles II, a well supported mod for Jedi Academy. www.moviebattl...
You can check my own Dueling Guide for MovieBattles 2 here: steamcommunity... here you can find a Steam Link for the guide. Very well explained, clear and with videos for better understanding.
I own all rights to this video.
Everybody gangsta till ahsoka goes backhand grip
You can tell she shat herself when ahsoka unlocked the backhand grip move
Everybody gangsta till ahsoka name drops Grand admiral thrawn
I know, that's legends but there's only one king in backhand Shien form - STARKILLER
@@KamilKapala That dude was broken, way too overpowered so they had to make him non-canon.
Completely useless in real life.
The level 187 character vs the level 22 character who thought she was some hot shit because she joined a clan.
who ever trained this woman was no joke, sure ahsoka needed her alive but she clearly wasn't expecting someone to hold their own as well as she did.
Ahsoka preference in Lightsaber Combat is using Form 4: Ataru, her natural acrobatic, stamina and speed is proof during the clone wars when she dueling Darth Maul. She also preferred to use her reverse Shien grip method but was asked by Anakin to keep the standard grip. She may has skills in Form 3: Soresu if Obi Wan showed and teaches her. She prefers speed rather than strength unlike Anakin Skywalker who prefer Form V: Djem So, a lightsaber form that focuses on strength and overcome the enemy. Since Shien is meant to be used as a blaster deflection back to the owner, Ahsoka is good at blaster deflection too. She also decided to take Jar’Kai which make her more lethal in combat, but there’s certain weaknesses that she will be too reliant to second blades
The only thing that intrigates me about the name drop at the end is: Thrawn and Ezra are so well hidden that FOUR YEARS have passed since Ahsoka and Sabine went looking and they still haven't found them.
The fact that Sabine isn’t with her could be indicative if they already found Ezra. The reason there after Thrawn could be because he is true leader of the imperial remanent not the one that became the first order or sith eternal but sorta like an imperial remanent that operates in the galactic frontier.
@@Phantom19913 That’s something I didn’t think about before
The difference between this episode, and the quality and writing of season 3, is staggering.
Everything that can be said has been said so i just add .... pure Gold ^^
Man I can't wait to see Ashoka in Clerks III this Fall!
hahaha the moment she switches to her classic reverse Grip she just wins in seconds.
Lmaoo
She waited until that bitch gave up
Edit. My parents asked me why i call everyone a bitch but that is the truth
I loved that! And the just "Oh shit!" look on the chick's face lol
She was basically toying around at first
In reality, holding a sword in reverse gives you less leverage to block attacks. It's like sitting backwards in a chair. It serves no purpose, make you look like a poser, and is just a bad idea.
She's fought Vader, Ventress, Maul, Grievous and multiple Inquisitors... this lady had no chance
Ahsoka had to be slow to get info and not hurt her
She also ding dong ditched Palpatine in the time travel maze
@@anonymousaccount4483 LOL almost forgot about that
@@LeonsSW yep, my thoughts
and resisted the senate himself haha
Honestly imagine the legend of Ahsoka Tano at this point. She is one of the very last living Jedi who were not only trained by the Order, but was a commander in some of the thickest action, and trained under the legendary General Anakin Skywalker.
And Don't forget was also fo trained by the Sassy Obi Wan Kenobi
Though she definitely deserves it, I don’t think there is any legend around her. She stayed hidden throughout the Galactic Civil war and her past was wiped out alongside all the Jedi orders archives
@@shawnjones7295 true But no doubt there is a few tall tales of a Torguta in grey with saber of white slicing past blasters like nothing.
At this point, Ahsoka is the last remmant of the old Jedi Order.
@@varric she left the order so, no longer a jedi
Ahsoka: Reverse grips her light saber
The Magistrate: My time has come... 👀
xddddd
very Princess bride
"i know something you don't know"
"which is?"
"i am not left handed"
MAMAAAA!!!
Execute order die
Honestly one of my favorite moments in Star Wars.
So basically everything Ashoka did up to the point when she flipped her saber , was her playing around 😂 this why we love her .
Yup 😂
Yep
I think she was a little surprised by how much of a fight she put up
I didn't realise that, I thought the people who made mandolrian forgot to include that which is why I was concerned when her saber was disarmed when not even darth vader did that
@@rosesweetcharlotte She was just toying with her because she wanted not to kill her and get info
Lady... she’s had Darth Maul... I don’t think you’re THAT good with a staff 😂
Hahaha fact
AND Darth Vader lol
Got to give her credit, a non-force user lasting as long as she did even on the off-chance Ahsoka was playing around.
I think lady did pretty good, she even take one of her lightsabers down, not mentioning the fact that lady is a non-force user
@@consumerjtc5835 actually why ahsoka didnt use force on her? in episode she only uses force once (to hit a guys with tree)
I love how the Magistrate thought she was toying around with Ahsoka at first, when in reality it was Ahsoka that was humoring her
All she had to say is I've fought Darth Vader and lived to tell the tale. That would've made her run away real fast.
Not unlike Vader vs Luke
Yeah cuz Ashoka had like 5 opportunities to kill her throughout the whole thing
@@shawnthompson2303 Completely different situations and contexts
Is anyone else in love with the sound that a lightsaber colliding with pure beskar makes
Yes
Yup. Especially the volley at 1:51
Not just that. The way the clashes come right after the peaceful water sounds and build on the sound of footsteps and the occasional grunt of effort is amazing.
It’s awesome, but I think the folly sound when the staff strikes the ground in the initial fight was off a bit. But I still enjoyed the scene very much.
What one must take into account, is that in a Time Long Past, it was quite the common sight
_Ahsoka uses her reverse grip._
Magistrate: “I’d like to apologize.”
Underrated comment.
I believe she knows form 1 and 3 as well due to being trained by annakin and obi won
@@donnellebarfield3964 Anakin uses form 5 though.
@@donnellebarfield3964 Plo Koon uses form 1 though.
@@christophermueller9764 No he uses Form V as well. Kit Fisto is the one who uses Form I
love how when she had her sabers up the hum sounded low, but when she changed it to the back hand, the hum got higher
That's good detail
Indeed nice touch on the sound crews part.
This scene has good sound design in general, I feel.
Reverse Grip Mode: On
Love how the magistrate visibly panicked when she changed to her reverse grip 😭
She realized Ahsoka was just fooling around with her the whole time. This lady couldn't handle a serious Jedi Master that fought Sith Lords. Yes, I call her a master because she pretty much is at this point in time.
Reverse grip is really just playing around or bad choreography. And it's overused in the last couple of years. Waaay overused.
@@thedokkodoka4349 You might not realize this, but Ahsoka used the reverse grip a lot in Clone Wars. Kinda her 'thing' iirc. So when the lady saw the reverse grip come out, its like saying "Yeah I'm about to somewhat try now."
It was THAT unusual to her because fighting against unconventional stances are rare AND combatants who fight with reversed grips are even rarer.
@@thedokkodoka4349 You do realize that the Ahsoka character has been shown using this grip since she was introduced back in the Clone Wars movie? So with her character it's not a new gimmick but an established part of her character's technique.
Ahsoka wasn't trying lol no way she was legit she won the second she switched the blade the way she usually holds it
No she definitely was trying they just made her weak
@@drewpeterson9236 Or maybe we underestimated the Magistrate too much. Being an actual martial artist and Bruce Lee's Goddaughter in real-life, I'd expect her character not being a push-over.
@@mstr293 Ahsoka did clearly say don’t underestimate the magistrate. And I agree with OP comment, Ahsoka got serious when she got disarmed and then took the Magistrate down with just one lightsaber.
initially I was like "phah normally grip, they did it to pander to people not getting reverse grip", then two minutes in was more "ah there it is"
@@mstr293 I think Ashoka was holding back. Ashoka was able to fight darth Vader! U can’t tell me that someone with a fucking spear can be that good. Hell, Ashoka didn’t use force abilites, high jumps, and she didn’t use her usual lightsaber form.
I like how Ahsoka doesn't use the force here, it's like Maul vs Vizla, the goal was to humiliate them
Even though she wanted more the information :D But yeah also a honorable duel
The real goal behind everything is to do a samurai style fight 👌🏻 like they said in the making of, they want to do what George Lucas would do
She could have force pulled the staff out of her hands in a blink of an eye and had that sabre at her throat in seconds and got the same response out of her
@@Token528 without a cool fighting sequence? Boriiing
Yeah a cool fighting scene is better than how the fight should be. Ahsoka probably could manipulate the Magistrate of mess her mentally with the force. Ahsoka have done it before.
Ahsoka:"where is grand admiral thrawn"
Me:" oh it's happening!! Everybody calm down!!! Everybody calm fcking down!!!!!"
Exactly such hype
Same dude
Man I freaked out and screamed when I first saw it
@Kryptoskillet but then wheres sabine they were supposed to do it together also how does she know the person works for thrawn
I maintained calm by understanding they only dropped a name. I'm definitely stoked, but I'll believe it when we see him.
2:08 when you saw Rosario as Ahsoka switch her grip on the saber to a reverse one, you know the writers were paying attention to Clone Wars.
The writer paying attention? Wasn’t this episode written by the guy who created her?
@@NTWoo95 yes, and he also directed the episode lol
Except this is Filoni's show...so ofc he knows
Ahsoka: *flips her lightsaber*
The Magistrate: Say sike right now
Its psyche
@@joshportie no, it’s sike.
@@joshportie shut the fuq up
@@joshportie thats an entirely different word with an entirely different pronounciation..do some research before trying to sound smart
@@joshportie Dumb ass
“We don’t need an army, we just need one person”
Ezra Bridger-
first one to quote Ezra
"We don't need an army, we have an Ahsoka"
“We don’t need an army, we have plot armour” Every rebels character
"I have an army
We have an Ahsoka"
@@shlongmanator9505 ik this is a late comment but fr
Rosario got Ahsokas's mannerisms and body movements down pretty good.
Agreed!
She must have studied for the role and im very confident that's cause Dave wanted this to be perfect which it was for me at least.
She said years ago she wanted to play ahsoka, she's def a fan and would never do ahsoka wrong
@User 2389 “everything is SJW” I’m so sick of you people. You’re far worse than any SJW could ever be. SJW this, oh there’s a powerful woman? SJW! Rosario Dawson is cast as Ashoka? SJW. Shits annoying frfr.
@User 2389 For you, everytime there are women it is "sjw agenda"... you are not a true sw fan and you dont deserve to call yourself a star wars fan if women disturb you that much (btw the witcher was awesome too)
I love that Ahsoka gave this woman the fight she thought she wanted. Showed her opponent that they indeed were skilled. Then when she switched to her reverse grip style she showed them why that skill isn't enough and never would be. Far more devistating than simply force shoving her or speedblitzing. Give someone what they want what they think is the thing they had envisioned.... and then yank the rug out from under them.
That is a real Alucard move right there. Give the adversaries the illusion of a chance, of hope, and then totally curb-stomp them right then and there.
Cannot express how much justice they did for Ashoka”s character
How much justice Dave Filoni did*
I actually don't even mind her voice, it fits. It sound like a older Ashoka.
@@HeavyTanker-vx4oq I don't like her that voice so much since you imagine her in Rebels and her now, it isn't that long time and impossible to change that voice so much, still liked the episode though
@@LeonsSW yeah I noticed her voice was a lot deeper. They could’ve voiced over w someone else but it might’ve seemed even weirder. One of the few cons of live action I guess
I mean its clear they are either gonna use Ray Park with Sam Witwers voice in a live action again one day like they did in Solo....or if it were me, I'd say fuck it and just bring in Sam Witwer with the makeup and all.
Ahsoka is fine. Tbh it'll be around 10 years ish since what happened in Rebels for her anyway right? So its not totally out of the oridinary for her voice to change a little.
Ahsoka: Where is Grand Admiral Thrawn?
Literally the entire fanbase: You had our attention, now it's undivided.
Right? I almost flipped our coffee table when I heard Thrawn's name.
I understood the reference
@@phoenixloop You know Thrawn was in Rebels right?
I literally jumped from my chair
@@lefishe6611 oh you sweet summer child
"Where is grand admiral Thrawn?"
A surprise, to be sure, but a welcoming one
I've been expecting this day for 2 years. In a way, it's a relief. But in another way, it's most unwelcome.
@@nikolaspapanagnou2723 why so?
@@lepage7120 because if thrawn is alive, then din djarin will have another enemy tracking him.
@@nikolaspapanagnou2723 but let's not forget a new ally Esra Bridger , is most likely coming back
Weak
Am I the only one who appreciates the sound work in this? The sound of Beskar connecting with Lightsaber's energy... God damn those hits sound good...
Facts!
Her sabers in general are some of the best sounding ones
Take the time to appreciate other sound design elements.
- No music
- Environment ambience. The water and wind sounds fades out the moment Ahsoka ignites her light sabers (though I think they could've fade out the sound smoother; but it's still good).
It's almost as if it was inspired by an Akira Kurosawa film. Hmm...
100% correct
@Riorozen Beskar existed in old canon as well, and it was stronger than Cortosis.
We all know the Magistrate stood no chance and that Ahsoka was just playing around, buy I'll still give it to the lady for lasting as long as she did
i agree
she would have been finished in 2 seconds but asoka needed information
Also as soon Ashoka switched to her natural reverse grip the fight was over. She was 100% toying with her
I like the fact that Ahsoka's only reason to fight was to disarm the magistrate and ask questions. she didnt even need to fight longer than mere seconds, she has been in full control the whole fight, and clearly pulls back in order not to do anything more than disarming her adversary. she goes full Ahsoka only when the magistrate disarms her, so she gets tired of toying around and wins in a matter of seconds
In essence, Ahsoka fights like a Jedi even if she's not a Jedi anymore. It's a great detail.
Because they were knowing each other and they had different objectives. The Magistrate wanted straight forward kill Ahsoka and prove her habilities in battle. Ahsoka on the other hand didn`t need to prove anything but to have her disarmed, tell her important intel and have her removed from the city administration. But Ahsoka needed to know the limits of her adversary.
@@alexandrelot2798 i'm not fully sure that Morgan Elsbeths objective here is to actually kill Ahsoka. I've theorised that she is one of the Ming Po, a group of people that were massacred by Death Watch during the Clone Wars (at which Bo Katan and Ahsoka were present). In this light and the fact that she works as one of Thrawns agents, her fight with Ahsoka can easily be to finally vent out the inner turmoil that she's harboured since, as well as allow Ahsoka to earn the information she seeks as a warrior (her actions on Corvus acting as a beacon fire that an empathic Jedi would be drawn to resolve, and doubly so for Ahsoka as she's looking for ezra at this time).
@@charlesburgess4511l
@@Cailus3542 Ahsoka is more of a Jedi than most actual Jedi of the order.
2:03 General Grievous: "A fine addition to my collection"!!!!
xD
He was waiting it the koi pond the whole time
lmao Grievous leaps out of the water like fucking Jason.
Someone add CGI grevious doing a headfirst dive into the pond
@@maxumus1019 except dont zoom in on it or add a voice line literally just in the background just him diving into the pond
To everyone wondering why the Magistrate had a chance: Ahsoka used the force in this fight a total of zero times AND she used a standard grip on her sabers up until right after she lost one of them. Once the reverse grip came out, she began to give 10% of her effort and the fight lasted 15 seconds. She didn't want to kill the magistrate, she needed information. She coulda force pulled the spear out of the Magistrates hand at any time, but chose not to.
Ahsoka learned from Frieza
Or used the lightsaber to just slide down the spear and take her arm off on the first block. The fight was slightly honourable, Ahsoka was just giving her a chance to show off a little, but then when the fight needed finishing. Bam. Done.
Holy shit you’re a nerd 😂😂😂😂
Newbie question: how come a light saber doesn't just slice right through an ordinary spear? No problem slicing through living flesh?
@@Ge1Ri4 The material the spear is made of is strong enough to counter lightsabers
Fun Fact: The actress who plays the Magistrate, is Diana Lee Inosanto, she's not only a legit martial artist/stuntwoman/actress but also the daughter of Grandmaster Daniel Inosanto, Bruce Lee's close friend & student who continued to teach Bruce's Jeet Kune Do fighting style after his death.
She's a veteran stuntperformer, who has worked on countless movies/tv-shows and is also teaching martial arts.
Thanks for the fact
In other words that girl is a badass
@@jeremyetremblay6663 No. She's a Certified Badass.
DVDVAMPIRE01 you got me there bud
Yes! She's Bruce Lee's godchild and was Aaron Eckhart and Melissa McCarthy's trainer for their respective action movies and fight choreographer for RE:Apocalypse. No wonder the magistrate looked so familiar - I love anything FMA and am a big fan of anything Inosanto, Jeff Imada, and Ron Balicki (Diana Lee's husband!) - so pleasantly surprised when she appeared on screen. Wielding that beskar spear near the opening, I already knew the final battle will be between spear vs dual sabers - wasn't disappointed!
She was toying with the magistrate, we've seen Ahsoka fight, when she wants to end someone she will.
yes
*laughs in sidious, yoda, or any council member*
exactly, she looked slow and the stance wasn't her signature stance so I was kinda disappointed really
Lets think it that way 👌🏻
It's because she doesn't want to kill her, she wants information, she would use her real stance if they were in a true confrontation were they were at each others throats
Not pictured: Anakin's Force Ghost nodding approvingly and mouthing "that's my girl!" offscreen
oww
Yoda's Ghost: Better than Rey, she is.
I can imagine him with Kenobi’s Force ghost eating the Star Wars equivalent of popcorn while watching this as if they’re cheering on their favorite sports team
"That's my girl... that I tried to kill... twice"
@@jennas9033 With one lightsaber, even.
anyone here after the tales of the empire?
You're lucky Anakin didn't show up, the way your fighting you wouldn't have lasted long
HAHHAA
@@LeonsSW man Anakin would’ve had alllllll these foos
It would be over in seconds
Errr anakin is currently dead chronologically
@@darthvenom305671 r/woooooosh
For those who asked why Ahsoka's fight with her was different.
1. You can't be careless and open with someone trained by Thrawn.
2. Ahsoka was trying to not kill her head-on or go too hard. She needed that information from her
And she was going a little easy to have some fun.
@@Dakarai_Knight yes
Its because its harder to choreograph a fight holding a blade backwards since this isn’t a cartoon where you can easily animate hard to perform movements
Pretty sure all she needed to do was use speed or pull to take the spear away
@@LeechUFC Thats why people say her handling of lightsabers is dumb, the only good thing she can do with backwards holding it stab people, which is only useful against Beskar Armor.
I love how the sabers give her a mysterious vibe cause the environment is so dark she is only illuminated when she fights
They play with the environment in this chapter.
Just watched Tales of the Empire, didn't even realise until now that this magistrate was the same one in Ahsoka series.
The attention to detail in the Mandolorian is astonishing. The fighting styles are on point. Ahsoka fights with emotion like her master, while Luke fought in a very calm collected manner. Like the force was guiding his every move.
I mean, his hood covered his eyes, so I’m pretty sure that’s exactly how it went. He was fighting in Jedi Ultra Instinct mode😂
In EU, there's a part where Luke actually lets the force [guide him] whereas the common Jedi/Sith use the force to [assist them] in battle. In his hallway scene, that's why he moves so much more smoothly (supposedly) rather than jumpy movements with the lightsaber.
I mean, it's not really "on point." She could have ended the fight at the very beginning during the first block just by casually sliding her saber down the length of the spear and slicing off the Magistrate's fingers. Lightsabers aren't swords. They're fucking lasers-on-a-handle. You would NOT fight like that with a lightsaber if they were real.
Nevermind the magical mass the "blades" get when they're ignited in the shows. Even the center of gravity changes when they're thrown; it's the handle that should be spinning, not the full fucking length of the weapon.
@@DocFunkenstein well don’t forget that Jedi use the force on their Sabers. A lot of what happens is because they use the force. Like ur supposed to hold the ignition button down on a saber so the only way they are able to throw it in the first place is because they are using the force to ignite it in the air. Which also explains why the momentum is at the laser not the hilt. That being said ur right about that one scene with Ahsoka.
Seems like productions nowadays have no choice but to pay attention to detail. Viewers apt to rip you a new one if there are any holes
People like to ask "Why did Ahsoka almost lose to her?" The answer is simple: she wasn't taking the fight serious.
Anyone who is a fan of Ahsoka knows that her natural fighting style is reverse grip. The majority of that duel, Ahsoka was standard grip. When she got serious and switched to reverse grip @2:10, the fight was over in 15 seconds.
Ahsoka was distinctly going for a disarm and interrogate too. With this woman potentially being trained by Thrawn, Ahsoka wasn't taking chances either, so she fought reactively, and once she had the measure of her enemy, Ahsoka beat through her defences and disarmed her
I feel like if she started off with her reverse grip style, the magistrate would have lost immediately. But she needed information out of her, so she tested her.
@@willhyde5026 I noticed that Ahsoka went for a couple of killing strokes, but luckily the magistrate was able to dodge and block those.
@@zacharygilmore1075
You can compare it to Jack Sparrow testing Will Turner (Curse of the Black Pearl).
Jack tested him with some basic attacks and when he easily counters it, he added more intensity and even asks how is his foot work. So I'm quite surprised with people saying she's weak when she isn't.
When I saw that she switched grips, I just nodded and said she's dead. She's done this before with the Inquisitors lol! She knelt offering the enemy to strike her down then she just disarmed the sister and ended her with a force push for a bitch slap.
Exactly. The instant Ahsoka went to her usual reverse grip, Elsbeth was finished.
I didn't expect her to say Thrawn's name.....
Yet it happened and it's amazing.
I didn’t think she would say it but I was gussing that’s who her master was but I thought I would have to wait awhile
This because since thrawn is with Ezra, they want to search gor them
Makes me wonder if maybe at the end of the season we're gonna get a surprise cameo from Ezra at the last minute. Technically he should still be around, likewise Luke, Leia, Cal kestis, the character from Vader immortal and I guess Cere are also all potentially still alive and Jedi/non evil force users.
Whilst I strongly doubt we'll see Luke, Leia or the Vader immortal protagonist, atleast outside of a mention or brief cameo, Cal kestis and Cere should still be alive though. So who knows.
None of us did
Reasons the magistrate lasted as long as she did:
1) Ahsoka wasn't trying to kill her, so she was taking it easy. She was only trying to disarm her opponent to get info on Thrawn.
2) it's heavily implied that the Magistrate is a survivor of Dathomir. Her makeup artist outright says this and Ahsoka herself states that her people were massacred during the Clone Wars. Morgan Elsbeth is honestly a very witchy name too if you think about it. Being a force sensitive witch would explain a lot.
3) It's only when Ahsoka was disarmed did she realize she was underestimating the Magistrate. Once Ahsoka lost her second saber and took on her usual stance, the fight was over in seconds.
As he says ^
And she is à night Sister... à witch , it makes sense now
Nah, on number 2, it is a retcon.
3) wait, didn't she only lose one saber?
Ahsoka: Where is Grand Admiral Thrawn?
Mandalorian Fans: Who is that?
Legends and Rebels Fans: *INTERNAL SCREAMING!!!! 😱😱😱*
xD
I'd say EXTERNAL SCREAMING
@@pollynesia2820 definitely external screaming. Source: Me
@@dragoninthewest1 ikr? My version of it was a loud "WHAT?!" at 1 a.m.
Absolutely true
I think Rosario Dawson did a great job as Ahsoka. The little mannerisms, the eyes, even the voice and tone all fit the character. My only issue is with the montrails. The montrails look to be the same size when she was 14 at the start of the clone wars. She is in her mid 40s ish now and should be closer to what they were like in Rebels. Other than that, Bravo!
yeah that's what I was thinking too it certainly bugged me a bit but her performance was quite good and I can't wait to see more :)
Maybe it would have been too heavy for her to wear and it would be a bit harder to even move around in them, but I see your point and I agree.
@@leonidasrising5998 I'm pretty certain that's exactly the reason. Go look at how terrible Shaak Ti looked in the prequels. Ahsoka could've looked that bad.
I get that length wise they would have been impossible for Rosario to do the stunts with if they were Ashoka's adult length, but I kina wish they had made them out of a little better material.
The "small" montrails are for functional purposes. Some things that work on print or in animation just wouldn't work in live action, and would just look goofy and off.
This is the most Kurosawa thing ive seen in live action Star Wars.
George tryed to do the same with Kenobi vs Vader
@@aspitube2515 but this was better
Was literally looking for a comment that would say that.
@@853Nynn what makes It really good for me is the overal setting of the garden and the minimal music.
@@Aizekku I know im not the only one.
For the Magistrate, Ahsoka was her final boss fight. For Ahsoka, she was just her warmup set.
This aged well.
Oooo yeaaaa this is STAR WARS
Diana Lee Inosanto.
Daughter of Dan Inosanto, a true martial arts master, and the top student and best friend of Bruce Lee.
That's some serious pedigree on screen.
I was looking for someone who mention it. So cool.
Someone whose dad had serious pedigree, that is
Wait is that the magistrate? Ngl thats super super interesting
Ahsoka handled her lightsabers like Escrima batons. I wonder if she got some tips from Diana, since her father is an Escrima master as well.
I love how rosario’s voice is more deep, like Ahsoka has actually grown
I love Ashley's preformance when voicing Ahsoka, but it always bothered me how Ahsoka in Rebels sounded almost exactly the same as she did as a teen in the Clone Wars, since she was many years older. Rosario's voice is exactly how I imagined Ahsoka's voice to sound once she properly matured.
Not everyone’s voice gets deeper though...
@@asherakatze4611 yh lol ashley ek is a prime example
She would be in her 40s now
@@samuelfawell9159 43-44 to be exact
It's funny how much Thrawns name drop completely eclipsed the entire fight scene itself. So much was opened up by that alone. The fact Thrawn survived much mean Ezra also survived.
Oh yeah, my literal response to that line was "SHE'S LOOKING FOR EZRA!"
Thrawn, cloning scientist, mandalorians and the time era it's in lead to 2 possibilities: Byss or Mount Tantiss
@@JanikLitalien Mount Tantis is shown in Bad Batch
No one’s ever really gone 💀😂 These writers are mega cringe
It didn't eclipse anything, and no need to explain what everyone here understands/knows.
Image her ending the fight before it even begins: "I was trained personally by Darth Vader."
As Setsuka from Soul Calibur would say: “The fight was decided even before I drew my blade.”
THIS NEEDS TO HAPPEN!
Ashoka: “I sliced Darth Vader’s helmet open once.”
@@rueluxprince6982 Luke: I removed my father's helmet completely and brought him back from the Dark Side, whilst believing there was still good in him, just as my mom said before she died.
i love how instead of just force pushing her or force choke her or just overwhelmed her with pure speed and strength alone, Asoka decides to just beat her in combat showing her that even while holding back she’s more stronger then her. My god we need her series NOW!!
also this is just a small nitpick for me but Ahsoka Tano is one of the most agile characters in Star Wars, i wish we would have seen more of that to be honest. Ashoka likes to jump a lot during battles, and likes to use her agility to her advantage but i mean by the end of a new hope Asoka must be in her early 30’s by now so it makes scene why she isn’t jumping around like in Clone wars haha but still a very well executed performance by Rosario Dawson who made one of my dream cameo appearances come true. much love ^^
@@Tripod9648 Ahsoka is less reckless now too, so she's less acrobatic since acrobatics open severe gaps in her guard in most cases
@@Tripod9648 well. there are logistical limits with live action. also, she's well into her 40s here, not 19 anymore, styles change i guess
@@ogmechsftw Thought she 36 at the end of ROTJ and this is 5 years after so she only 41.
@@ogmechsftw tell that to 900 year old Yoda. As for live action, nowadays, only the budget is the limit.
The magistrate: "why did you still fight me even though I never stood a chance?"
Ahsoka: "I just wanted to polish my lightsabers"
Hahha fact
Oh what a troll
@@LeonsSW some of feminist and sjw said we men doesn't like girl in star wars franchise
They typically death wrong.
69th like
If she got trained by thrawn her chances are better than you imagine
From 2:12-2:13 if you pay attention, you see the magistrate's eyes widen with fear and suprise when Ahsoka changed her grip. As the Audience, we know when this happened, Ahsoka conveyed the Message "Alright, Playtime is Over"
Right. So, to me, the beginning of the fight was a nod towards the original trilogy, and their "old man fight". THEN, they steadily amped it up, until the magistrate could no longer keep up the pace.
I agree with all of you, Ahsoka was formed by Anakin, lived through the Clone Wars, battled Darth Maul, AND Darth freaking Vader in her time. She could have ended the fight in seconds. But disarming someone without killing them is a lot harder than just dealing a killing blow I think. She had to be careful with how much she put in the fight, or she'd have killed her by mistake.
She mainly fight with reverse grip, yet didn't used it until she was disarmed. This is proof enough that she was going easy on her opponent. But the magistrate did put up a good fight for a non force user against a confirmed jedi knight. Not that strange for an old Thrawn subordonate, the grand admiral was, himself, a good fighter even against Jedis.
OR, she could disarmed her in 2 seconds flat with a smile on her face. They wanted to make it feel more serious and set up the lady as a better opponent. It was a bad idea...
A jedi disarming a non - force user should not be difficult
Disney has gotten so, so many things wrong with SW. The use of Ahsoka was perfection. They hit the jackpot with rosario dawson. Whatever she wants to be paid, pay it. Can we just pretend like the sequels never happened and rewrite the whole thing with Luke and Ahsoka in it?
I fucking agree so much, get the new trilogy out of her and make it about Luke, Leia, and ahsoka finishing the sky walker series.
Agree. Sequel trilogy horrible. Horrible.
They had so much stuff from the books sanctioned by Lucas that they could've used and instead they went off in a different direction and none of the movies really even connect to each other
Force awakens : clone of a new hope
Last jedi: Luke dies of exhaustion and is scared to do anything
Rise of sw: oh suddenly, palpatine is alive
Wdym? The only thing Disney got wrong with SW were those damn sequels, they could've been made better, even with the new characters. But the rest of star wars products so far had been from quite good to acceptable, with some few exceptions
There is actually a good third trilogy where they can take a lot of source material from. Its called heir of the empire, the original thrawn triliogy.
Yeah theyre working on decanonising sequels and solo but dont rush them...
She didn't even break a sweat. Remember her fight vs maul in mandalore? She was heavy breathing midfight. Here she was just practicing
This reminds me of Maul’s fight with Vizla. I feel like Ahsoka was just toying with the magistrate (I mean come on she isn’t even force sensitive. There’s no way she could’ve kept up with even a fully trained Jedi in a duel that actually was trying) but the moment she pulled a (debatable) dirty move disarming Ahsoka she ended the battle seconds afterward.
@@Allsoproductions The resonance of the spear, that weird wiring sound that starts after she bangs it, disrupts the connection with the force so it was more of an equal footing. However Ahsoka's power started to defeat that, hence the change in the sound.
Of course I'm going by a similar fight Luke had in Legends, so maybe they weren't putting all that in there.
@@Djarra what lol
Why not just disarm her with the Force?
@@Сайтамен She may not have respected Ashoka and maybe wouldn't have given her any info. The fact she beat her fair and square shows shows her skill as worthy.
She held back so much, it was almost painful to watch. She was really trying not to kill her so she could get info on Thrawn and I believe by extension, Ezra.
Exactly
simply beautiful, the silence before the storm... samurai and western vibes, chapeau Filoni
Yeah it alot remembered Samurai
Thrawn...
i have not heard of that name since Rebels..
I'm so hyped, this person was not teased not leaked not even speculated to appear until now
@@LeonsSW ikr
@@LeonsSW im hyped as hell
@@LeonsSW holy shit I can’t believe we’re gonna see thrawn this is Star Wars at it’s best
@@mothbum5580 probably means we could see Ezra as thrawn survived
The only reason Ahsoka lost one lightsaber was because she was just toying with her in the beginning. After that she went full beast mode with that reverse grip!
Tales of the empire episode 2 anyone?
This is always how I imagine it. Samurai style. With pause in between. The choreograph is just in right amount. No unecessarry lightsaber movement or swing.
and no unnecessary music...
You know y’all basically just disrespected obi wan and qui gon vs darth maul which is the best lightsaber duel of all time
@@mari2x474 not really. That one is one of my fave too.
A lot of people hate on Rebels (for good reason sometimes), but one thing to take away is that final, samouraï-style Kenobi vs Maul duel. Short, precise, both characters looking for the advantage before the fight even starts, and then a few streaks of light saber and the fight is over.
@@alexandrearrive6199 I prefer this too. It makes the duels feel more personal and visceral. I think back to the first duel between Luke and Vader in Empire Strikes Back in the carbonite pit.
"Where is Grand Admiral Thrawn?"
Me: NANI !??!
That moment when Ahsoka do the reverse grip........that magistrate is finished....
😂😂😂
Ya, she was sizing her up. When she got disarmed is when she was like "Ok, time to get serious"
I can't get over how beautiful her white sabers look in live-action, this whole scene is done so well!
Ahsoka: *reverse grips her lightsaber*
Morgan: guess ill die
I like how the lightsaber hums differently than regular lightsaber
Yea
@@LeonsSW The lightsabers at one point bled red, after Ahsoka purified them they turned a pure color. Hence the unstable sound.
@@Masterahsoka its not an unstable sound if its purified.
I really like this fight, reminded me a lot of the Obi-Wan vs Maul duel on Tatooine. The Magistrate clearly knew what she was doing and they spent a lot of time testing each other, which I love. Ashoka won easily yeah but it was definitely a really cool fight. Great to see her back, hopefully we are getting a show centred around her. The opening sequence with her taking out the guys in the fog was so damn good!!
it's so funny to me that a throwaway line in _a new hope_ brought us this scene. "your father fought in the clone war" or something along that line. did lucas know what that meant when the script was written? i don't know, but if it wasn't for a single line of dialogue from old crazy ben, we never would have had ahsoka, rex, hondo, ventress or this fight scene. amazing.
also: that cloak drop. kenobi would be proud.
He always knew, up till prequels at any rate. He pretty much explained that "his" Star Wars was about telling the story of Anakin Skywalker, his rise and his fall up till his redemption and death.
When he produced TCW and Ahsoka was intoduced, he definitely knew someone this close to Anakin would be long lasting... or very short lived.
2:13: that feeling when you haven’t trained to fight against reverse grip opponents 😧
Atsoh Jr to be fair reverse grip users aren’t that common, especially in this era
Her face says it all 🤣
@@frost1262 the women and children too aren’t common in this era either
the way she duels it's just so... wise and respectful, at the same time it's mortal and badass
AND THE SOUND OF HER SABER? Awesome! we need more different sounds of lightsaber in live action (kylo's saber it's kinda cool)
What I think is really interesting is that Ahsoka’s sabers make exactly the same sound as Darth Vader’s, only pitched up half an octave. Despite sounding completely different, it’s made from the same recording from before 1977.
I like that sound too
I also like different saber sounds. Vader's, Ahsoka's, Kylo Ren's, and the Darksaber.
I know right I love her sound on her sabers I had to go and buy me the light saber that had her sounds in color which is why I love her to death, she’s one of the most powerful Jedis besides Luke Aniken Obi-Wan Kenobi, supposedly mace windu was supposed to be the best with the light sabers no I disagree I think that is Ahsoka. Due to her reverse grip, yeah I bought one dueling light saber that has everybody even count Dooku then I bought the dueling light saber of Kylos I have the actual saber, that thing is heavy as hell LOL but it is awesome
For those that don't know; The reason it makes that noise is because of the crystals inside her lightsabre. A sith who uses the force on their kyber crystal will make it turn red due to the hate and rage. The reason why Ahsoka's lightsabres are white is because the crystals originally belonged to an inquisitor or sith (can't remember) who had red sabres. When Ahsoka extracted the hate and rage from the crystals they turned white leading to why her lightsabre color is a pure white.
Ahsoka to Disney, regarding the Sequel Trilogy: "You could not live with your own failure, and where did that bring you? Back to me."
HAHAHA
Ahsoka is definitely the best character. Beats Rey 1000%
Genius
Ahsoka Thano(s)
Wow
You can tell Ahsoka wasn't even putting her all into that fight. She just wanted to show how easy it is to defeat the Magistrate with little power, forcing the woman to submit and answer the question about Thrawn. Or maybe Ahsoka wanted to amuse the woman with the little duel. Who knows
Probably both, knowing her.
She had a fight with inquisitors, maul, vader, and Palpatine all in the same day no way this was "challenging"
I think it wasnt
Palpatine?
@@adityabhalekar3506 star wars rebels
@@adityabhalekar3506 when she went into the world between world's and Palpatine tried to capture Ahsoka and Ezra
@@theseeker2360 I thought you meant lightsaber duel
If Ahsoka would always say to her defeated opponents she would say "You're beaten"!
and that's a fact
Well this woman was better then the inquisitors
@@obiwankenobi7475 I think she actually was she was no match for Ahsoka but better than the inquisitors. However if the inquisitors were to fight the magistrate I think they would win because of their powers in the force.
@@gw7911 Seventh Sister I would say is still decently above the Magistrate, but the Fifth Brother is definitely below her, since his lightsaber skills actually suck.
Ashoka here just playing with her food
After all, she needs to have some warm up
@@rexlumontad5644 It's been a while
@@abelneto5762 Indeed. At least it's a cool fight
@@rexlumontad5644 Yes, very samurai Akira Kurosawa style
@@abelneto5762 How nostalgic it is
If you see Ahsoka looking at you like that, you might as well just drop whatever weapon you have, and just tell her where the evil blue dude is... She's beyond awesome.
you damn right man, she’s a boss
@@mariocar0727 It only took me a few minutes to fall in love with her after she stepped off the drop ship in the Clone Wars movie. I wasn't too sure at first, but when she called Anakin "Sky Guy" I just knew she was gonna be awesome! 😁
In the ancient Mandalorian Wars the mandoa cruzades uses meele weapons made by beskar like her armours. Is wonderful see the classical lore being adapted in this canon series.
Vibro blades
not gonna lie. Throw in the "Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood" cover by Santa Esmeralda at 0:39 and you have yourself a Tarantino fight.
Just did that, such a great idea ^^ thx
This video is already online since the episode day, in fact !
I was thinking the same thing
I love how this fight scene is suppose to be a Samurai Duel and Mando stand off is like a Wild West cowboy stand off
2:12 You can see the fear on Magistrate face when Ahsoka finally uses reverse grip and she realizes that real duel begins.
This fight was phenomenal, to me at least, seeing the progression, the control, then seeing the fear on the magistrates face. Ahsoka is NEXT LEVEL, she was always in control of this fight. Not even Darth Maul could kill her, came close though. The magistrate was good but never truly stood a chance against Ahsoka. She was just toying with her, she could have ended it rather quickly.
Reverse grip is stupid and you would only ever use it if you're a fictional character fighting a moron.
@@turrible2s She is a fictional character... She's fighting a space wizard, having a back handed grip isn't a liability in their world.
@@turrible2s Blade momentum isn't necessary with a lightsaber - the blade will blaze through anything it touches except those materials resistant to it and another lightsaber. Reverse grip, while controversial, gives Ahsoka the leverage that icepick-gripping a dagger would, and this iteration of Ahsoka mixes standard grip and reverse well. The only stupid thing about reverse grip is the danger of hitting oneself, and Ahsoka has had decades to learn not to hit herself with her own blades.
Side note, daggers and spears can be used reverse-gripped. The grip is far from stupid - it is the application that makes it unwise. Note how Ahsoka flips her grip constantly in other fights, and primarily fights standard gripped in this one. She isn't stupid, she knows the ins and out of her chosen style
@@willhyde5026 a quick addition: ashoka usually only uses one saber in a reverse grip. She learned all her forms both normal and reverse grip
Magistrate: Knocks Ahsokas saber out of her hand
Ahsoka: *D I S C O M B O B U L A T E*
You can literally see the fear on the magistrates face when Ahsoka changes to her reverse grip
2:09 this this right here is why I love reverse grip. People ever fight anyone who uses a reverse grip style ever in the time they are training so once someone breaks it out they become very hesitant because the angle of attack changes it is not an easy prediction and it shows the person is very clearly skilled to be using a super unorthodox fighting method
Definitely shows ahsoka has had enough
Indeed. Back in early high school, I used to have lightsaber duels with a friend and he would be winning a majority of them. I decided to practice using the reverse grip (thank you Force Unleashed lol) and I was able to pull more than a few victories over him.
Nowadays, we’ve been equally matched without much differences as our styles have evolved past what we used to have.
Long story short: an unorthodox style (when properly trained and practiced) can overcome typical forms of combat
Just a disclaimer to anyone reading this, reverse grip doesn’t apply to actual real life, this is just fantasy.
@@tweso1499 same, I had a group of buddies who’d all be slow duelling and they were all mirroring each other’s strikes, didn’t work against me for some reason, ends up discovering that I’m subconsciously left handed. It was pretty neat when we all figured it out and we were all surprised.
@@tweso1499 Funny story actually. So in gym class the other day, me and my friends were playing badminton and my team was losing. Mostly due to my fault cause I kept missing the birdie. We were just playing for fun and we were already losing the game so I thought "why the fuck not" and decided to switch my grip on the racket to the reversed grip like Ahsoka's. In just five minutes the score went from 5-10 to 14-10. It confused them the fuck out that they just didn't know what to do, and then of course once we were winning we were all laughing like idiots because it *actually fucking works.*
They did Ahsoka justice! She's as powerful, and as beautiful as ever!
@@jennas9033 wait Ashoka is 6'0? I thought she was at least in the 5s
@@livinglegend9709 Ahsoka in rebels is apparently 6'2
@@jennas9033 dang she kinda tall. How tall is Anakin then?
The lightsaber choreography is so much better here than in the sequels. It's almost as if there's a Jedi on screen rather than some maniac swinging a lasersword like a basebat bat
Wel Kylos fightingstyle was based on european hema fencing. And it fitted perfect to his sword and apperance. It's funny, cause a whole generation of star wars fans hated the choreography at the prequels for beeing to atrisctic and to less fencing :)
Ben and Rey weren't skilled fighters and fully trained jedi. Ben was basically a padawan and rey was self taught. it makes sense lol Luke fought like they did in the og trilogy
Right, I’m not a massive fan of the sequels but why do all of you fans have to bring them up when watching something Star Wars related😂😂
@@suddenhit3923 Kylos fighting style is stylized broadsword or greatsword. I dont know wtf Reys fighting was, but the only time Kylos fighting style was really evident was in his first duel with Rey in Snow.
That last duel they fought by the ocean was miserable. They basically just did exactly what Peterson said...they tried to Babe Ruth each other into the ocean.
@@suribuxton9079 Kylos been training for years. Hes had as much if not more training than Ahsoka had by the time she got paired with Anakin, plus he trained under Luke.
12 years after writing the character (and saving her from death by George), Dave finally got to bring her to live-action.
I hope Nicolas Cage plays Thrawn
if we actually get live action thrawn and not spoil to rebels sequel
@@LeonsSW very probably the Mandal is the rebels sequel that we're looking for
They need to save him for a later show Dude. I hate to be the one to mention this but I don’t want this show to just devolve into the type of crap the force awakens used
I believe Robert Patrick (T-1000) is a better fit for Thrawn.
No they should use the voice actor from rebels
After seeing this episode... Could we maybe discard the sequel trilogy and start regarding this as one? I mean honestly, any episode of this is AT LEAST 20 times better than the entire movie trilogy.
Stfu
yeah lets make a petition to make the sequel trilogy non canon and start from scratch with mandalorian
Truthfully im view it that way or set in a different timeline with suppose reintroduction of admiral thrawn will helpfully lead into war with the far outsiders (yuuzhan vong)
The first one was ok. The rest were trash.
@@starkiller6864 agreed. first one was ok but had potential, The Last Jedi squashed any chance it had, and I've still not taken the time to watch Rise of Skywalker, i have more respect for myself than that.
why ashoka didnt just hit the magistrate's fingers? also light saber , which is basically weightless, is 1 billion times faster than a staff made of metal. That's why I really hate lightsaber battles too many plot holes.
Anyone got Kurosawa/Kill Bill vibes from this fight? Not complaining, I thought it was amazing.
[Plays Santa Esmeralda - Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood in my head]
That’s right. Dave got inspired by them, Lucas loved those too.
I wonder if Thrawn and Moff Gideon are working together
That is actually interesting.. Would be amazing seeing those two as Main Villains against the New Republic and Moff Gideon talking about hunting down Mandalorian with those Dark troopers he had in Chapter 12!
The new "canon" sequel Trilogy would be Thrawn as the main villain. AMAZING!
Probably gideon is a subordinate of thrawn
either that or they are two separate imperial factions
I think we will prob have those answers by these last 2 episodes
THIS. This is why you SHOULD NOT miss out on Rebels or your gonna be floating in space.
Clone wars too
The only asoka stuff ive ever seen is star wars in cartoon network a long time ago....when did they make a real version of her? 🤔
@@brandonh5201 you're an idiot
@@Knookah No, he has a life outside of Star Wars. There's a difference.
@@brandonh5201 the first season of Mandalorian. Haven't seen it myself, so I don't know which episode.
And here we are in the new Ahsoka series, Morgan Elsbeth being a right pain in Ahsoka's side again