You may notice that the editing is a little bit different in some places. That's because I have been helped with the editing process by two members of my production team, BillyBob and Nannynomnoms. Thank you to both of them for helping me out so much and for taking some of the weight off my shoulders. 😊 Here's the Discord link: discord.com/invite/AfyKTtPprq And yes, apologies I pitch jumped quite a bit in this video. It just helps me to maintain a good rhythm when narrating. But I am working on doing it less 🙂
I like the idea where 13 regenerates into 10 again following almost the same timeline and reuniting with Donna. As time goes on, the Doctor realizes that with the forced regeneration into the Master Doctor and back messed with the regeneration cycle where he keeps bridging between different Doctors, leaning in 10 followed by short arching to 13 and landing on other Doctors. This could mix up the adventure at the end of the universe confusing the intelligence that couldn't mimic perfectly their forms anyway. Ending with the Toymaker being defeated and as a prize using his gun to create the bigeneration to stop the constant back and forth between Doctors. 10 will still stay with Donna and Rose for a while and 15 will still continue on his way.
@@BillWhovian i feel that as a 60th Anniversary year, it should go with a bang. If RTD wanted to, he could even use some other as he exclaimed as cannon Doctors as well, similarly to Dimensions Of Time miniepisode.
That’s my favorite too. What makes the three specials interesting is that David Tennant as the 14th Doctor doesn’t feel like a new incarnation, it’s more like the 10th Doctor is given a chance to live a normal life with Donna and spare himself from traveling the universe. But I do support the idea of Jodie staying as 13 for these specials with Yaz and Donna joining her. Lastly, this timeline has a better ending where Ncuti as 14 takes off on his TARDIS while 13 finally settles down with Yaz and Donna’s families as she has her first kiss with the former.
David Tennant still could appear with Catherine Tate in 2023 in this scenario but in a minisode leading into the 60th anniversary special. The minisode could be a “missing adventure” type story with the Tenth Doctor and Donna.
I really enjoyed this video i do like all 3 timelines but i think timelines 2 and 3 are the best because if Jodie whittaker were to have stayed on it would be right for Mandip Gill to have stayed on with her.
Power of the Doctor was a strong swan song for Jodie but your third scenario with Donna and Yaz would have been amazing. It really was pointless bringing Tennant back for the sake of nostalgia, they could have revisited the edge and had him cameo with the other modern era Doctors in the mix this time before she bi-generates.
To be completely honest I vastly prefer the Specials we did got over these but I would’ve definitely preferred the Chess game ending for the Giggle instead.
This is very cool. I like the chess game and I would have had the game in timeline 3 swell. I have an idea for another what if. what if Jodie had regenerated into Matt Smith
If i was Russell id have Tennant for Special 1, McGann for Special 2, and maybe Colin for Special 3. That way we get a doctor from each era instead of just Tennant
Im not sure if you take requests/ideas for what if’s but I had this one for a while. What if Lungbarrow was made in Season 26? It would’ve taken Ghost Lights original place as the original season finale and maybe even series finale. It being the last classic series story would’ve been interesting too.
@leebiggs7755 Hey. Yes, it will be out soon. It's just being edited right now. It took a bit longer for me to make due to it being longer in length than I thought it would be 🙂
@@filmunion8194 i think matt smith should still be in the what if, it may not be accurate as to what actually would of happened but its more interesting that way
3:35 so she gives birth to the timeless child anddies in child birth, I would love to see everyone's reaction to this, the master and the doctor having a baby timeless child, WTF NO! Edit: thankfully my guess was way off, this concept is just horrifying to me, what's wrong with my brain!
You may notice that the editing is a little bit different in some places. That's because I have been helped with the editing process by two members of my production team, BillyBob and Nannynomnoms. Thank you to both of them for helping me out so much and for taking some of the weight off my shoulders. 😊
Here's the Discord link: discord.com/invite/AfyKTtPprq
And yes, apologies I pitch jumped quite a bit in this video. It just helps me to maintain a good rhythm when narrating. But I am working on doing it less 🙂
yaz & donna would be ABSOLUTELY chaotic
18:00 this is how the ending of the giggle should of been, a chess game would of felt more enjoyable
An idea I've always had since I heard Donna's theory of why Fourteen looks like Ten; what if Thirteen regenerated back to One's face?
I like the idea where 13 regenerates into 10 again following almost the same timeline and reuniting with Donna. As time goes on, the Doctor realizes that with the forced regeneration into the Master Doctor and back messed with the regeneration cycle where he keeps bridging between different Doctors, leaning in 10 followed by short arching to 13 and landing on other Doctors. This could mix up the adventure at the end of the universe confusing the intelligence that couldn't mimic perfectly their forms anyway. Ending with the Toymaker being defeated and as a prize using his gun to create the bigeneration to stop the constant back and forth between Doctors. 10 will still stay with Donna and Rose for a while and 15 will still continue on his way.
@timothyweers8054 Hmmmm very interesting 🤔
@@BillWhovian i feel that as a 60th Anniversary year, it should go with a bang. If RTD wanted to, he could even use some other as he exclaimed as cannon Doctors as well, similarly to Dimensions Of Time miniepisode.
Thank you for making this what if video it is brilliantly done well done to you type 40 for this fantastic video 😊👍
If Russel was writing for Jodie i do think she would end on a little bit of a high note
I wish Jodie had stayed a bit longer i would have loved it ❤
I wouldve really liked the relationship drama between Yaz and 13 in your second scenario. Love the chess idea too. Wouldve been very cool.
Timeline 3 is my favorite among all of these!
That’s my favorite too. What makes the three specials interesting is that David Tennant as the 14th Doctor doesn’t feel like a new incarnation, it’s more like the 10th Doctor is given a chance to live a normal life with Donna and spare himself from traveling the universe. But I do support the idea of Jodie staying as 13 for these specials with Yaz and Donna joining her. Lastly, this timeline has a better ending where Ncuti as 14 takes off on his TARDIS while 13 finally settles down with Yaz and Donna’s families as she has her first kiss with the former.
@@ivanjuarez7731 Same!
David Tennant still could appear with Catherine Tate in 2023 in this scenario but in a minisode leading into the 60th anniversary special. The minisode could be a “missing adventure” type story with the Tenth Doctor and Donna.
I am really looking forward to your next what if video😊
I really enjoyed this video i do like all 3 timelines but i think timelines 2 and 3 are the best because if Jodie whittaker were to have stayed on it would be right for Mandip Gill to have stayed on with her.
I do find it funny that even with this theirs still a tennant connection since 10 regenerated once and kept his face lol
1:46 Thank you!
@@griffinlaw9367 No problem 🙂
Power of the Doctor was a strong swan song for Jodie but your third scenario with Donna and Yaz would have been amazing. It really was pointless bringing Tennant back for the sake of nostalgia, they could have revisited the edge and had him cameo with the other modern era Doctors in the mix this time before she bi-generates.
What if the doctor/ John Smith stayed human in the family of blood, and maybe gave the fob watch to the family? 😮
New subscriber here man you earned it
@@thelukeofficial9626 Thank you very much 😊
To be completely honest I vastly prefer the Specials we did got over these but I would’ve definitely preferred the Chess game ending for the Giggle instead.
This is very cool. I like the chess game and I would have had the game in timeline 3 swell. I have an idea for another what if. what if Jodie had regenerated into Matt Smith
Timeline 3 is my fav
If i was Russell id have Tennant for Special 1, McGann for Special 2, and maybe Colin for Special 3. That way we get a doctor from each era instead of just Tennant
Im not sure if you take requests/ideas for what if’s but I had this one for a while. What if Lungbarrow was made in Season 26? It would’ve taken Ghost Lights original place as the original season finale and maybe even series finale. It being the last classic series story would’ve been interesting too.
I do indeed take requests. And good idea 🙂👍
Hello I don't been to sound impatient be will your next what if video be out soon I'm only asking because it is after the weekend now.
@leebiggs7755 Hey. Yes, it will be out soon. It's just being edited right now. It took a bit longer for me to make due to it being longer in length than I thought it would be 🙂
What if Donna died in The Star Beast and they had Clara for special 2 and Martha for special 3
Do a Doctor Who what if David Tennant stayed with series one
what if the doctor regenerated in the stolen earth?
@@filmunion8194 Watch until the end for the next What If teaser. Your wish will come true 🙂
@@BillWhovian would not cast smith as the 11th doctor more Robert Caryle or David morrisry.
@@filmunion8194 i think matt smith should still be in the what if, it may not be accurate as to what actually would of happened but its more interesting that way
I apologise for my error
@@garyparson8927 Thank you for apologising
No problem it was another video I was commenting on and it flicked over to yours and I enjoyed your what if tbf
3:35 so she gives birth to the timeless child anddies in child birth, I would love to see everyone's reaction to this, the master and the doctor having a baby timeless child, WTF NO!
Edit: thankfully my guess was way off, this concept is just horrifying to me, what's wrong with my brain!
@@robbycooper6787 😬
You need a lobotomy.
Timeline two is better.