@@willsaint7469 Doesn't matter if he dove or not. While he exaggerated the contact, you can't tell me that there weren't two hands in the back and an extension of the arms.
The holding the ball rule needs some serious clarification, players, coaches and fans have no idea which way any decision is going to go, dissent should be decided by the MRP or tribunal, losing a game because a player expressed his emotions on the field should never happen.
Holding the ball could be so simple I mean count to 2 and if the possession player is tackled after 2 seconds then it's holding the ball no matter what. Same thing goes for dropping the ball the player has 2 seconds to dispose of the ball if they drop the ball or its knocked out of their hands after 2 seconds it's dropping the ball. No ands, ifs or buts. And the dissent rule should not exist at all it should be scrapped completely.
He’s in the top 3 most suspended players in the League….he’s the only player ever to be suspended for a jumper punch. Literally the exact opposite of what you’re saying lol
You've missed the two biggest howlers of not only 2022 but possibly ever. Darcy Moore featured in both. The ridiculous contact below the knees against Hawthorn when he was first to the ball, a hawks player fell on top of him and they got the free in the square. Second one the deliberate rushed behind in the wet against the GWS, even though he touched the ball inside the goal square. Edit: we can add the preliminary final "no call" to the list.
I remember that game very bad call but I think it was the umpires giving 1 back to hawthorn after hawthorn were crucified in the first half Also no holding the ball call to miochek and holding the ball to Breust a second later in the dying moments of the game
@@dylanleigh9920 when they are incompetent Also need to scrap this no criticism to umpires What other job in the world do you not get criticised for farking up
I'm a Collingwood fan and my fav player is ginni but I gotta say that was a flop I was laughing about it during the game I was happy they didn't pay it.
Selwood and Hawkins get everything given their way but literally never get anything called against them. Selwood ducks and Hawkins dives but hey let’s just make an example of Ginnivan because he was open about it. Selwood literally has the world record for free kicks for literally the same action that Ginnivan gets nothing for 🤷♂️🤷♂️
I agree, players should be allowed to show emotion. If it is vulgar then go for it but if a players is frustrated and show emotion the umps will see it as insult to them. We watch footy for the players not for the umpires.
0:51 the fact that all the players started running st kildas way after the tackle shows everyone on that field knew that was incorrect disposal. Unreal
I fucking love that this happened, I go for freo, and I like st Kilda, but for us to be at the long end of the stick + the 50m with 10 seconds left, it just feels nice for once
actually, the player did kick it. the ball wouldn't of dribbled that way unless he kicked it. besides, the umpire was right in front of it when it happened.
How is the duncan one at 2:26 supposed to be holding the ball. He juggled the ball the whole time and never had enough control of it to get rid of it and was tackled immediately.
The Warner one is an insane double error. He didn't run too far, and his "dissent" (over a howler) wasn't even enough to meet the insanely strict threshold at that time.
Have been for 15 years 5 years in a row selwood was awarded double the frees to the person who finished with the 2nd most amount of frees for the year In the top 10 there were always 3 or 4 Geelong players
Hawkins has been allowed to shove people in the back for literally his entire career and the commentators always talk it up as his strength. Like how the Melbourne defensive unit involves May/Lever holding onto their opponents arms while the other tall takes an intercept mark.
He does it a lot in throw ins and ball ups as well Barely ever gets done for it and then is handed the softest frees Geelong have been very well looked after by umpires the past 15 years
@@islandsofgreece1586 Might explain why Geelong are so dominant. GMHBA is still a VFL oval plus the umpires essentially umpiring for Geelong. Selwood used to get away with a lot and Hawkins gets away with a lot.
@@ryankingsbury779 Mate, Kardinia Park was used during the VFL era. There’s a reason why ovals like Waverley Park and Whitten Oval aren’t used for the AFL. GMHBA is the same, but apparently chucking in a few lights and grandstands makes it a “world class stadium.”
Got footy day at school next Friday, there’s gonna be a teachers vs year 6’s game on the oval all my friends aren’t gonna play but I’m craving another game of footy since my season ended. Go tiges 🖤💛🖤
Not a Geelong supporter but the Selwood throw looked from the umpires angle as a handball have to admit so don’t blame that one. The one right after not deemed holding the ball is right cause he never had full control before the tackle therefore didn’t have possession, right call. Same with Bolton against lions, never had possession, right call. Blues high against trelor is disgusting from the blue player. Great vid. Lots of shocking calls and non calls from the umps this year
@@robdouglas698 So you're just gonna ignore the fact that he also threw the ball? lol solid argument 🙌 He also finally gets control right before he attempts the fend off if you watch closely. I wouldn't expect you to pick up on that though 🤷♀
Not a good video, a lot of these decisions were correct 1:20 correct decision, push in the back 2:08 advantage, umpiring preoccupied looking at Mason Cox taking selwoods head off 2:28 play on, never took possession kept fumbling 2:47 correct decision, Ginnivan dove onto the ball and failed to get it out 3:14 correct decision again, massive dive 4:51 correct decision, wasn't close enough to the contest to take the player out 6:02 correct decision, ducked into it
1:20 agreed 2:08 true, but still probably should have been called. 2:28 sure 2:47 I don't know, I guess it's true 3:14 agreed 4:51 whatever you say I guess 6:02 agreed I half agree, but I also feel like the umpires COULD have called these the other way.
That Dan Butler tackle was so frustrating I was at the game and the crowd was with me so frustrated it cost us the game that night the umps and it ended up being our season
The ginnivan one isn't called cause of how he acts for his frees. Was there a push? Probably yeah, but he dived so hard you can't pay it. same with his shrugging the shoulder. It's against the spirits of the game
The first one of Ginnivan here wasn't even a push, it was clearly a flop. The guy barely touched him. In the second one, you can see Ginnivan raise his arm (something Selwood is also known for doing) in order to draw a high tackle. Umpires should never be giving frees to players to play for them.
I hate when people say Steve Hocking made football great again ... footy was making that transition anyway..all he did was create controversy and anxiety all the way down to junior level..The new 50 m penalties and the stand rule are hideous and are deciding game outcomes 😡😡😡😖
Hocking and Co part gillies island ceo stuffed the game will not last long I'm sure people will have enough captain must say all together which rules they don't want
Thanks for putting this together! Great video! If degoey got 3 weeks then Pickett should have got 6. Just because one person has a strong neck, hard head should determine weeks. I guess those were 2023 though. And there were easily 6 Ginavin high tackles in 2022 you could have featured.
must be a pies fan if u think ginnivan didnt flop And the 1st holding the ball against him WAS reasonable as he dragged it in first while being tackled then left the contest the 2nd one was because it was an obvious flop and he made no attempt to get rid of it
Hey man you need ta do this every week if your not already....well done about time some real attention was brought to these bloody umpires....I understand mistakes can be made but not this often and this bad surely
It appears standing on the mark awards 50m now as well (Magpies vs Swans). Umpiring appears to be getting "worse" with BS calls, gambling companies all over the footy, coincidence?
2 things: 1)THe abuse rule has to be the worst new rule the AFL has ever brought in. Players would look the wrong way and a 50m was paid because the umps were too soft and precious to have any form of disagreement. 2) Ginnivan is the epitome of the boy who cried wolf; he made a name for himself as a ducker and a flopper so now when he deserves a free he is much less likely to get it. That being said, the two you put here are 100% not frees for him, he literally dives when Guthrie touches his back and against NM you can clearly see him drop his knees into the tackle and immediately look to the ump. He has talent, if he just focuses on playing the game he'll be a star, until then he's gonna be hated for being a sook/flop.
I hardly think Umpires are too soft and precious. Its about time people stopped arguing with their decisions. Umpires are people too, they make mistakes. Its time they get consistent respect. I would like to see you umpiring in front of a million people.
it was correcting umpiring on the Ginnevan push (guy did a massive swan dive) and the Carlton touched ball against Richmond (hand/fingers wiggled after contact with the ball).
Not Daicos' fault the dude decided to juggle it to the forward 50. He also clearly put his right arm out to fend off the tackle which he was unsuccessful at. Holding the ball any day of the week.
@@tastyj111 ur right it’s not daicos fault hence why it was play on. Never had the ball in control and was never balanced and steady. Play on any day. I go for pies
Does any one think that maybe the afl dictates to the umpires how to officiate each game depending on who’s playing, when and where? This happens quite regularly in the NBA. Referees have been instructed how to call a game for the sake of a players and or a teams status to encourage fan numbers and revenue.
I think you're onto something here Lee. I'm convinced the umps favour the team that is losing to even up the game for the sake of numbers (of eyeballs on TV screens that is) and the $$$$. Ad money, etc..
The Ginnivan ones you've included are really bad selections. They're actually great calls, especially the one at 6:00. You're clearly on that "GiNnIvaN iS UmPiReD DifFeRenTly" bandwagon. The way he plays is a cancer on the game, such a cancer that the AFL (who are so protective of the head) and now paying less high tackles because the spectacle of the game is being ruined by certain players. The one at 6:00 is an excellent, 10/10 call that most spectators of the game absolutely loved. In keeping with the rules, the umpire correctly deems that Ginnivan lowered his bodyheight for no reason other than to draw high contact, which forfeits his right to a high free kick and forfeits his prior opportunity. Look at how Ginnivan looks at the umpire instantly after the tackle. That's all he cares about.
I appreciate the umps have a tough gig, with the one eyed fans, the abuse on and off the field, the constant scrutiny, but this video could have been 40 hours long with the clangers I have seen this year.
So many times this season players have just been allowed to drop the ball while being tackled. It doesn't feel like umpires are actually looking to reward good tackles anymore.
Some people clearly don’t understand the rules of the game. Mitch McGovern bumped vandermeer off the ball and front on as he was running not in the play. As well as the Shai Bolton being tackled by Neale, great tackle and would deserve holding the ball of Shai ever had prior. His attempted to dispose of the ball as soon as he got it and if he can’t dispose of it he never had prior.
You're right Mate, people don't know the rules...... that's cos' every frigging year they[AFL] add, tweak or change the rules! In 50+ years of following AFL, i can't recall a single year without some sort of BS rule being applied. As you can see from this vid the shambles & inconsistency that are at play now & effecting the outcomes of the results of the game! AFL football is a fiasco, a joke...... a cluster f**k of rules! This is NOT the sort of footy i want to be watching! ET
Reckon it was Port's last game of the season, Byrne-Jones I'm pretty sure, makes a twenty metre chase down beautifully, opponent drops the footy, "play on"
Richmond get a free kick, ball spills out to Baker and he stops to motion not to take advantage. Umpire ignores common sense and calls play on. Baker who is standing still is tackled. Instead of common sense balling it up the umpire calls holding the ball. Naturally the Richmond players are in disbelief and after one argues the point the umpire gives a 50M penalty against, easy shot on goal.
Tom Hawkins is the prime example of forwards can push in the back, but backmen can’t.
unless the backman is pushing Jack Ginnivan
Papley in the prelim
@@Punkologist dive
@@willsaint7469 Doesn't matter if he dove or not. While he exaggerated the contact, you can't tell me that there weren't two hands in the back and an extension of the arms.
@@Punkologist best comment 😂
This season has been a shocker for umpires, inconsistent the whole season.
Maybe it’s harsh, but I have had moments where I said that they should sack the lot of the umpires and replace them all
Ikr it’s such a shocker
I totally agree with you
Totally agree. One of the worst years for the umpires.
100%
The holding the ball rule needs some serious clarification, players, coaches and fans have no idea which way any decision is going to go, dissent should be decided by the MRP or tribunal, losing a game because a player expressed his emotions on the field should never happen.
100% dissent should be a fine but not affect the game itself
the only thing the dissent rule does is make the umpire calling it look like a dibby dobber kid from kinder
I think the deliberate out of bounds rule is broken
Holding the ball could be so simple I mean count to 2 and if the possession player is tackled after 2 seconds then it's holding the ball no matter what.
Same thing goes for dropping the ball the player has 2 seconds to dispose of the ball if they drop the ball or its knocked out of their hands after 2 seconds it's dropping the ball.
No ands, ifs or buts.
And the dissent rule should not exist at all it should be scrapped completely.
Screw dissent, let the players do whatever thay want
Hawkins is a protected species in the AFL
Geelong is a protected species in the afl
@@drasticturnip358 yet we’re the only team that doesn’t ever get home finals.
He’s in the top 3 most suspended players in the League….he’s the only player ever to be suspended for a jumper punch.
Literally the exact opposite of what you’re saying lol
wait til you hear about harley reid
You've missed the two biggest howlers of not only 2022 but possibly ever.
Darcy Moore featured in both.
The ridiculous contact below the knees against Hawthorn when he was first to the ball, a hawks player fell on top of him and they got the free in the square.
Second one the deliberate rushed behind in the wet against the GWS, even though he touched the ball inside the goal square.
Edit: we can add the preliminary final "no call" to the list.
Deliberate rushed behind was the right call. Contact below the knees was the wrong call and imo was the biggest howler of the year
the contact below knees was a bad decision. But the deliberate was a textbook free.
What about that deliberate rushed behind in the Coll V GWS game?, worst decision in history, that shit happens 50 times a week for no penalty
@Archie Sinfield it wasn't right. I was at the game and he got pushed through the line.
I remember that game very bad call but I think it was the umpires giving 1 back to hawthorn after hawthorn were crucified in the first half
Also no holding the ball call to miochek and holding the ball to Breust a second later in the dying moments of the game
Mate I hate to say it but Ginivan dived like a swimmer in the Geelong game. They said earlier that week no dives or ducks would be paid.
That goes against the majority’s agenda
Sure he exaggerated, but clear hands in the back with straight arms. That's a free kick according to the current rules
That’s a free kick mate he was jumping for the ball and got pushed really hard mate how’s that not a free kick
@@Catalyst_ his hands were on his back, but he didn't push him. If players wanna take dives the free will not be payed.
@@Catalyst_ You're allowed to put hands in the back as long as it's not a push
Umpires can absolutely spoil a good game of Footy.
Especially finals or close games
@Harper they’re*
How can umpires ruin ALF if you can’t have footy without umpires?
@@dylanleigh9920 Alf?
@@dylanleigh9920 when they are incompetent
Also need to scrap this no criticism to umpires
What other job in the world do you not get criticised for farking up
Ginivan's push in the back was a massive flop, play on
as a mad ginnivan and collingwood fan, couldnt agree more
ginnivan IS a massive flop.He's not the first actor to not get frees
@Justin Kassis fr he has ruined the game
I'm a Collingwood fan and my fav player is ginni but I gotta say that was a flop I was laughing about it during the game I was happy they didn't pay it.
it was but hawkins does it quite frequently too
Selwood and Hawkins get everything given their way but literally never get anything called against them. Selwood ducks and Hawkins dives but hey let’s just make an example of Ginnivan because he was open about it. Selwood literally has the world record for free kicks for literally the same action that Ginnivan gets nothing for 🤷♂️🤷♂️
You couldn't be more wrong buddy
@@aussie9489 explain how he's wrong
🧂
🧂
Saltttttyyyyy brutha. Stop complaining about umpires. Umpires aren’t the reason teams are losing
The McGovern mark where Petracca walked into the protected zone and tackled him.
Tom Hawkins always pushes his opponent in the back and never gets a free kick against him for push in the back
🧂
@@Kevv-d8f good rebuttal
jeez youre good at nothing aye
That whole abuse rule almost killed the game.
I agree, players should be allowed to show emotion. If it is vulgar then go for it but if a players is frustrated and show emotion the umps will see it as insult to them. We watch footy for the players not for the umpires.
@@Bineash92 But do you watch a game without umpires?
do you just want them to abuse the umps or something?
@@stewie420k4 Strawman anyone?
your mum and dad prolly abuse you
0:51 the fact that all the players started running st kildas way after the tackle shows everyone on that field knew that was incorrect disposal. Unreal
I fucking love that this happened, I go for freo, and I like st Kilda, but for us to be at the long end of the stick + the 50m with 10 seconds left, it just feels nice for once
actually, the player did kick it. the ball wouldn't of dribbled that way unless he kicked it. besides, the umpire was right in front of it when it happened.
correct decision by the ump
@@gwilkes5325 what about when freo got 30 more free kicks than the giants? what do u mean "for once"
@@MitchyPlayzz The ball went with the player's momentum? If he kicked it, the ball would have deviated due to him being tackled in the action.
How is the duncan one at 2:26 supposed to be holding the ball. He juggled the ball the whole time and never had enough control of it to get rid of it and was tackled immediately.
Exactly
2:15 It was a high bump so it doesn’t matter if it is a legal disposal or not. It has to be a fair tackle for htb which it wasn’t. Right call
It was a throw plus he talked him
@@brodstar23_94 he got hit high first before the throw
Nah, it's Selwood being Selwood, he disguises the fact he drops pretty well.
@@brodstar23_94 thanks brodstar23_94
Banging vid like always. Always so happy to watch a umpiring video
cheers worked hadr orn it
the Newnes goal was the biggest bullshit ever, that was not touched
Richmond players have a disability, its called wiggly fingers syndrome. This is often brought upon by too much assimilation with the coaches.
💯
agreed, yiure slow
this season with umpires has been a shocker
The Warner one is an insane double error. He didn't run too far, and his "dissent" (over a howler) wasn't even enough to meet the insanely strict threshold at that time.
I hate dissent and agree with you even though I clinicly despise Sydney. Stuff the dissent bull shit
He took sixteen steps after the bounce, count them.
@@nathrogers7 I don't know where you've got 16 from, I've got at MOST 14
@@patrickheyen I'm a really good counter.
@@nathrogers7 i got 14 as well
If this video says anything, Geelong are really looked after.
Probably most looked after team in the league, besides maybe West Coast at home.
100% I wonder if that flog Steve has something to do with that
Yeah so looked after we don’t get home finals at GMHBA. Idiot.
Have been for 15 years
5 years in a row selwood was awarded double the frees to the person who finished with the 2nd most amount of frees for the year
In the top 10 there were always 3 or 4 Geelong players
you are joking clearly lmao
Hawkins has been allowed to shove people in the back for literally his entire career and the commentators always talk it up as his strength. Like how the Melbourne defensive unit involves May/Lever holding onto their opponents arms while the other tall takes an intercept mark.
🧂
He does it a lot in throw ins and ball ups as well
Barely ever gets done for it and then is handed the softest frees
Geelong have been very well looked after by umpires the past 15 years
@@islandsofgreece1586 Might explain why Geelong are so dominant. GMHBA is still a VFL oval plus the umpires essentially umpiring for Geelong. Selwood used to get away with a lot and Hawkins gets away with a lot.
@@Rob-lv3fc GMHBA is listed as a world class stadium champ. i get you dont like it but cry some more.
@@ryankingsbury779 Mate, Kardinia Park was used during the VFL era. There’s a reason why ovals like Waverley Park and Whitten Oval aren’t used for the AFL. GMHBA is the same, but apparently chucking in a few lights and grandstands makes it a “world class stadium.”
Thought this was gonna be a replay of the whole season.
spot on u didn't miss any great video
Thanks 👍
Tom Hawkins deserves a award for “flop of the year”
Got footy day at school next Friday, there’s gonna be a teachers vs year 6’s game on the oval all my friends aren’t gonna play but I’m craving another game of footy since my season ended. Go tiges 🖤💛🖤
Not a Geelong supporter but the Selwood throw looked from the umpires angle as a handball have to admit so don’t blame that one.
The one right after not deemed holding the ball is right cause he never had full control before the tackle therefore didn’t have possession, right call. Same with Bolton against lions, never had possession, right call.
Blues high against trelor is disgusting from the blue player.
Great vid. Lots of shocking calls and non calls from the umps this year
That hawthorn Geelong one was absolute crap anyway nice vid mate
Sometimes i think that when their team are playing a match and they are the umpire they give free kicks to their team
I love how the commentators said ginnovan has a separate set of rules for him, it had me crackin up. Another great video too mate love the content
2:40 had no prior. clear collingwood supporter here.
He puts his right arm out to fend off you spud. That's his prior. He also threw the ball a second later.
@@tastyj111 He doesn't have possession you "spud". Can't be holding the ball if he doesn't have control of the ball
@@robdouglas698 So you're just gonna ignore the fact that he also threw the ball? lol solid argument 🙌 He also finally gets control right before he attempts the fend off if you watch closely. I wouldn't expect you to pick up on that though 🤷♀
@@tastyj111 he has no prior, doesn't take full possession and makes a genuine attempt to dispose. Play on
Some of these calls want to make me throw up
been looking forward to this
Not a good video, a lot of these decisions were correct
1:20 correct decision, push in the back
2:08 advantage, umpiring preoccupied looking at Mason Cox taking selwoods head off
2:28 play on, never took possession kept fumbling
2:47 correct decision, Ginnivan dove onto the ball and failed to get it out
3:14 correct decision again, massive dive
4:51 correct decision, wasn't close enough to the contest to take the player out
6:02 correct decision, ducked into it
1:20 agreed
2:08 true, but still probably should have been called.
2:28 sure
2:47 I don't know, I guess it's true
3:14 agreed
4:51 whatever you say I guess
6:02 agreed
I half agree, but I also feel like the umpires COULD have called these the other way.
look at how protected geelong are 😆
Always have been
If Geelong are so protected, how come they don’t get finals at GMHBA?
I’ll never understand why everyone thinks thinks Dunkley didn’t deserve a free kick. Degoey clearly lands on his back.
because collingwood can do no wrong in collingwood fan eyes
It’s not about the free it’s about the 50, De Goey was frustrated at himself as anyone would be and got pinged for it cause of the dissent rule
Dehoey?
The one that was touched by Broad against Carlton was obviously touched? You can see his hand snap back 😂
The ball didn’t go anywhere near his hand, don’t know what u were looking at
@@AR_Sports8 well it did, so you’re wrong. You can see the ball impact his fingers. Sorry to make you look like an idiot kiddo.
@@AR_Sports8 aye mr blind, shaddup
You can literally see a shadow on his hand
@@razorracer3472 you’re actually cooked 😂 quit living in denial
That Dan Butler tackle was so frustrating I was at the game and the crowd was with me so frustrated it cost us the game that night the umps and it ended up being our season
💯
You can’t totally blame the umps because you guys just sometimes weren’t good enough
@@jammy23 bro so true plus look at round 2 same thing but other way around
It didn’t cost you tho, you were completely outclassed by the dockers
U were 18 points down 😂
6:00 the right call was made
You could have a 20 minute video like this just n the deliberate out of bounds
The ginnivan one isn't called cause of how he acts for his frees. Was there a push? Probably yeah, but he dived so hard you can't pay it. same with his shrugging the shoulder. It's against the spirits of the game
Looking from another angle I don’t think he was pushed
The first one of Ginnivan here wasn't even a push, it was clearly a flop. The guy barely touched him. In the second one, you can see Ginnivan raise his arm (something Selwood is also known for doing) in order to draw a high tackle. Umpires should never be giving frees to players to play for them.
Yea I don't know why the collingwood fans are angry with that
as a Richmond fan I am happy that they finally outlawed the swan dive and elbow shrug that Rance and Grimes used to get away with.
watching this to make me feel better about the crows being robbed yesterday, thank you for posting this
RIGTH INFRONT OF ME
I hate when people say Steve Hocking made football great again ... footy was making that transition anyway..all he did was create controversy and anxiety all the way down to junior level..The new 50 m penalties and the stand rule are hideous and are deciding game outcomes 😡😡😡😖
Hocking and Co part gillies island ceo stuffed the game will not last long I'm sure people will have enough captain must say all together which rules they don't want
@@stevesalkas9128make the afl great again - more like make afl fans angry again
who?
Umpire dissent is the biggest joke call in the game
I feel like there were lots of Jack ginnivan calls that were missed but I get why. You don't just want a video of him
@@rainbowcharlesbear he ould be a good bollywod acter
Thanks for putting this together! Great video!
If degoey got 3 weeks then Pickett should have got 6. Just because one person has a strong neck, hard head should determine weeks. I guess those were 2023 though.
And there were easily 6 Ginavin high tackles in 2022 you could have featured.
Holy shit I’m glad I’ve been missing the past few weeks this shit doesn’t even look like footy anymore
Need another 8 min vid for shocking umpire decisions, you can use the SYD VS COLL preliminary final for an easy 8 min of shocking calls.
must be a pies fan if u think ginnivan didnt flop
And the 1st holding the ball against him WAS reasonable as he dragged it in first while being tackled then left the contest
the 2nd one was because it was an obvious flop and he made no attempt to get rid of it
Ginnivan bias
The pies free kicks only 1 was controversial (the Duncan throw) their fans are just a bunch of Whingers
@@thegunn6732 same with every afl team's fans mate lol
Hey man you need ta do this every week if your not already....well done about time some real attention was brought to these bloody umpires....I understand mistakes can be made but not this often and this bad surely
He better quit his full time job because that's going to keep him very busy
yure yapping to none hoosh
The nick daicos tackle on Duncan is mind blowing to think it wasn’t paid as ball absolute joke and things like that lose a close game
That’s karma for having the game played at the MCG.
maybe cause he never had it
Never had control of the ball at any time in having learn the game Collingwood lost that game cos they were worse be quiet
glazing harder than krispykreme
Nearly all of these have Matthew Stevic how is he not fired
The umpiring is a disgrace sometimes. I think umpires let their "personal" preferences get in the way of the actual rules sometimes.
However good Tom Hawkins is you literally can't accept him just flying in the air !
the bloke who made this video either hates Geelong or goes for Collingwood
No, he's just showing how much Geelong cheats
@@gryjss9167 wanker alert 🚨
Don't see the problem with the Selwood/Cox one. Throw or not it was going to be high contact. Play on.
Love the vid mate
you havent even watched the video yet??
It appears standing on the mark awards 50m now as well (Magpies vs Swans). Umpiring appears to be getting "worse" with BS calls, gambling companies all over the footy, coincidence?
nick dacos tackle no hold on the ball was insane collingwood may have won and be in the premirlary final
2 things:
1)THe abuse rule has to be the worst new rule the AFL has ever brought in. Players would look the wrong way and a 50m was paid because the umps were too soft and precious to have any form of disagreement.
2) Ginnivan is the epitome of the boy who cried wolf; he made a name for himself as a ducker and a flopper so now when he deserves a free he is much less likely to get it. That being said, the two you put here are 100% not frees for him, he literally dives when Guthrie touches his back and against NM you can clearly see him drop his knees into the tackle and immediately look to the ump. He has talent, if he just focuses on playing the game he'll be a star, until then he's gonna be hated for being a sook/flop.
I hardly think Umpires are too soft and precious. Its about time people stopped arguing with their decisions. Umpires are people too, they make mistakes. Its time they get consistent respect. I would like to see you umpiring in front of a million people.
@@dylanleigh9920👍
luv the vids!
Umps look after geelong that’s for sure
it was correcting umpiring on the Ginnevan push (guy did a massive swan dive) and the Carlton touched ball against Richmond (hand/fingers wiggled after contact with the ball).
Just proves the Geelong are the umpires favourite by far how many did they not give anyone playing against Geelong and get anything for Geelong
2:05 how is that not a touch?
The hands were already wiggling before the ball got anywhere near it
2:10 Selwood got paid the free, it was advantage tho
Umpires are like the parole board, not being held accountable for their bad decisions.
Funny how Geelong is on the end of four strange free kicks which resulted in goals for them. I wonder why.
And they're only the ones we've seen here. Goodness knows how many more that weren't featured here.
The tackle on Duncan at 2:30 isn't actually holding the ball. Duncan never had full control of the ball when getting tackled. Play on!
Not Daicos' fault the dude decided to juggle it to the forward 50. He also clearly put his right arm out to fend off the tackle which he was unsuccessful at. Holding the ball any day of the week.
@@tastyj111 ur right it’s not daicos fault hence why it was play on. Never had the ball in control and was never balanced and steady. Play on any day. I go for pies
You missed the whole game of geelong vs collingwood🤣
hahahahahahhahahahahahhahahahahahaha
The saints/freo one is so bad its actually hilarious 😂
Petracca tackling McGovern in the protected zone
Just Geelong being looked after as usual
No
@@chazcow9868 yes
Does any one think that maybe the afl dictates to the umpires how to officiate each game depending on who’s playing, when and where?
This happens quite regularly in the NBA. Referees have been instructed how to call a game for the sake of a players and or a teams status to encourage fan numbers and revenue.
100%
I think you're onto something here Lee. I'm convinced the umps favour the team that is losing to even up the game for the sake of numbers (of eyeballs on TV screens that is) and the $$$$. Ad money, etc..
those fucking umps especially that geelong v pies ones like pay the frees to the pies
The Ginnivan ones you've included are really bad selections. They're actually great calls, especially the one at 6:00. You're clearly on that "GiNnIvaN iS UmPiReD DifFeRenTly" bandwagon. The way he plays is a cancer on the game, such a cancer that the AFL (who are so protective of the head) and now paying less high tackles because the spectacle of the game is being ruined by certain players.
The one at 6:00 is an excellent, 10/10 call that most spectators of the game absolutely loved. In keeping with the rules, the umpire correctly deems that Ginnivan lowered his bodyheight for no reason other than to draw high contact, which forfeits his right to a high free kick and forfeits his prior opportunity. Look at how Ginnivan looks at the umpire instantly after the tackle. That's all he cares about.
I’m a bomber fan myself but even I was a bit confused about no call from the umpire not complaining tho pies reaction was hilarious
I cannot wait for the 2023 version 😂
You could make a 6 hour compilation of all the crap Geelong get away with
How does this man only have 30k
Chad Warner took 16 steps after the bounce. Good call.
How is the touched one shocking
Cause it wasn’t touched their was another angle that he nerve showed it was a clear gap between his hand and the ball
@@Mythsandstorys bro how the finger bent back
@@Wbix240 was clearly black magic bro. Broad sold his soul so that the tiges could get Tarranto and Hopper in. This is just a side affect
@@Wbix240 it didn't but ok
U could put Errol Gulden tackle against Bulldogs that was called a push in the back when it should’ve been ball!
I appreciate the umps have a tough gig, with the one eyed fans, the abuse on and off the field, the constant scrutiny, but this video could have been 40 hours long with the clangers I have seen this year.
1. Missed PIB
2. Unwarranted ran too far
Correct dissent
3. Correct non - HTB, snicked his boot
Correct HTB - Balanced and Steady
Correct dissent
4. Correct PIB
Correct dissent
5. Cannot tell
6. Correct HC (takes precedent over throw)
Correct advantage
7. Correct non - htb (no prior opp, did not have control)
8. Unwarranted HTB - dive/drag (left ginnivan's possesion)
9. Correct non PIB (no extension of arms) ginni dived
10. Unwarranted HC
11. Unwarranted bloke (hawkins dived)
12. Missed HTB - balanced and steady
13. Correct prohibited contact, ball outside 5m
14. Unwarranted insufficient intent
15. Correct non HTB no prior
16. Correct play on
Correct HTB - duck
17. Correct abuse
Love hearing the pies fans upset 😂
BT the sook joining in
best commentatorer to grace the game
The umpiring the Collingwood Geelong final is some of the worst I've ever seen. Umps have their members in the rectories of Geelong for sure
Still haven't seen an actual bad call from that game yet
the whole umpire team photo 🤣
It seems to me some umpires have a love affair with the Cats which started when Ablett was playing. Some also have a down on Ginnivan.
So many times this season players have just been allowed to drop the ball while being tackled. It doesn't feel like umpires are actually looking to reward good tackles anymore.
Mason Redman on Jack Ginnivan
The league and other fans don’t like it when Collingwood win. Gotta say I’m loving this tho 😂
Quite a few of these aren't even bad, but overall this season has been a shocker
This video could never possibly be controversial 🫣😂
You missed every other call that was made.
Some people clearly don’t understand the rules of the game. Mitch McGovern bumped vandermeer off the ball and front on as he was running not in the play. As well as the Shai Bolton being tackled by Neale, great tackle and would deserve holding the ball of Shai ever had prior. His attempted to dispose of the ball as soon as he got it and if he can’t dispose of it he never had prior.
You're right Mate, people don't know the rules...... that's cos' every frigging year they[AFL] add, tweak or change the rules! In 50+ years of following AFL, i can't recall a single year without some sort of BS rule being applied. As you can see from this vid the shambles & inconsistency that are at play now & effecting the outcomes of the results of the game! AFL football is a fiasco, a joke...... a cluster f**k of rules! This is NOT the sort of footy i want to be watching! ET
A lot of Geelong free kicks for no reason. Especially from that final vs Collingwood.
Reckon it was Port's last game of the season, Byrne-Jones I'm pretty sure, makes a twenty metre chase down beautifully, opponent drops the footy, "play on"
Video idea: AFL ‘Put The Finger Up’ Moments
Richmond get a free kick, ball spills out to Baker and he stops to motion not to take advantage. Umpire ignores common sense and calls play on. Baker who is standing still is tackled. Instead of common sense balling it up the umpire calls holding the ball. Naturally the Richmond players are in disbelief and after one argues the point the umpire gives a 50M penalty against, easy shot on goal.
THE AFL NEEDS TO DO "SOMETHING" ABOUT THIS