@@itachiofthesharingan67 The chosen ones are always crying wolf, but as soon as they get power, they crush everyone else, censor them, threaten them... They are the children of Satan. Me
As an arab living under a dictatorship and who have been hearing ''we shouldn't revolt, do you want what happened to syrians to happen to us?'', i'm happy that we can now say to our puppet rulers : ''you should release the political prisoners and listen to your people, do you want what happened to assad to happen to you?'' elhamdou li'Allah
The problem is Arab nations' borders have been set up by the same colonial powers that still control the puppets. This prevents homogenous reaction during upheavals. If there is sudden uprising, it may or may not have already been hijacked by intelligence agencies of those same colonizers in order to pit one against the other. Mayhem seems to be what the USrael wants, so they can "valiantly" roll in with "solutions". Iran is the only revolution without foreign influence that stuck around (not an Arab nation but, significanly, relatively homogeneous).
Wake up!... Syria is gone ,the Israelis are on a land grab and will annex much of Syria thanks to the western puppets Jolani and Erdoğan... They helped the Israelis cut off the supply lines to Hamas so now not only is Syria gone but Gaza and the West Bank are now certain to be soon in the zionists hands. Unfortunately for Muslims they always fall for the western trick of 'Divide And Conquer '
wtf you guys are giving assad support still by saying that crap! i dont care if the satan came and helped get him out the children women prisons rapes torture and the rape of lebanon and Palestine by assad regime helping israel is over alhamdulilah
@@TahsanHasan-x7q hey, isreal doing what they telling since oct 7. Is a greater notreal plan That includes Syria, Egypt, Iraq, medina or Parts of Saudi. Now Syria and Iraq don't have a government or military to protect from anything. You are telling me to study mali and Somali
I have seen this quote million times, and I don't doubt that it is true, but I don't understand at all why it matters. So what if both Al Qaida and Clinton wanted Assad to go. Does that make him automatically a good guy?
@ I can’t believe that the USA chose AQ over a secular regime; there is something fishy about that decision. You can check the quote in Hillary Clinton's e-mails on Wiki leaks
Hello Middle East eye I wanted to inform you that i watched this video and it had like 607 likes, i wanted to like but i could not then i wanted to comment it said error, I thought of going out of the video and come back in from my history but it was not recorded there, then I thought of coming back to the video by search when i did it had like 12 likes, i know you may know this but i think RUclips is trying to hid your channel, i support your channel and i really appreciate your work May Allah help us all
They deleted the video and uploaded it again with a different title. The previous video had a lot of negative comments on it so might've been the reason but no clue.
The Syrian Islamists who successfully took Damascus and overthrew the Assad regime, along with his Russian and Iranian Shia supporters, have demonstrated remarkable nobility in their treatment of their enemies. Despite the years of brutal oppression, massacres, and subjugation inflicted upon them by the regime, their actions reflect a commitment to Islamic principles of justice, mercy, and humanity. Their approach has set an example of how even in victory, one can act with dignity and restraint, focusing on reconciliation and rebuilding rather than perpetuating cycles of vengeance. This conduct not only reaffirms the values they stand for but also offers a path forward for Syria to heal and unite after decades of suffering under tyranny.
True. But governing is much harder than revolution. There isnt yet a good working example in the modern world of a democratic government that operates according to laws and principles of Islam, and can accommodate the plurality of interests and thinking in the 21st century. This is totally new territory.
Yes we can all see that. And we can all agree that Assad, like his father, a dictator. Was the rebels really fighting for the Syrian people against Assad and his Iranian and Russian supporters? The former IS right hand man now rebel leader spoke about how Assad has allowed Iran and Russia to occupy Syria and yet he remain silent about Israel’s active airstrikes in “the buffer zones.” And we also haven’t heard a single word of condemnation towards the US military’s occupation of the Syrian oil fields and wheat farms since 2014. The US wanted Assad’s regime to starve and now he’s gone and the US still haven’t left the precious oil fields. So, why haven’t the HTS condemn US and Israel? And why is the new Syrian spokesperson openly admitting about allying with Israel on tv? Iran and Russia are the only enemies he said. And a week ago, one HTS member on Israeli channel 11 news thanking Israel for pushing out Hezbollah that led to the rebel success in capturing multiple provinces in Syria. So, this new Syrian government will be an ally to Israel. Aren’t you concerned about that?
Nobility??!! Sure if abu musab al-zarqawi man is considered Noble!!! You are living in the "Euphoria" phase then shit will hit the fan and interest will collide when forming a government. then you will see the true phase of Nobility!!
How ridiculous review is that? Do you think Syrian Forces came together and won the victory ?? Türkiye had been supporting as logistics, training and leadership to Syrian Forces for years. Listen to President Erdoğan speech in TR parliament in 2018. You will find the answers...
You conveniently neglected to mention how Israel is bombarding the daylight out of Syria on a daily bases!! Also you conveniently neglected to mention netanyahu's map at the UN and how this is the very first step to achieve that map!!
@@TheMohamzthe whole Syrian “revolution” lead by 80% non Syrian fighters, installing AQ and isis leaders was orchestrated by Turkey and armed by the US/NATO. It has nothing to do with the freedoms of Syrian people. Syria is done as a country. No one is merely addressing the sanctions that made the lives of civilians horrible. Well they had a life at least, now there will be no life/no country.
Revisit this hubris one year from now. Revolutionary slumber as Israel plummeted and conquered Syria without being shot at a single bullet Shameless and shameful journalism Good bye
Israel will. Conquer nothing. It has exposed its fears. It is afraid of the Syrian people. There was no reason other than fear for the actions Israel has taken since the revolutionary forces took power.
Such simplistic and lazy analysis..there is absolutely no comparison between the situation in Egypt and Syria and no analogies to be drawn..Syria is occupied by 3 countries and everybody knows arrangements between those countries is the main reason events unfolded as they did in Syria..to even suggest that this was somehow an organic armed resistance that other opposition movements in the region should draw lessons from is laughable to say the least!..30-40% of HTS fighters are not even Syrian, they are mostly central Asian alqaeda members and that’s by Golani’s own assessment in an interview he did a few years ago.and what did Golani say about Israel occupying a portion of Syria 3 times the size of Gaza..nothing! and that’s why Israel is celebrating and Netanyahu is gloating that it was his bombardment of Iran and Hizballah that directly led to the fall of Assad and he is absolutely right..to take out all this context and to suggest that if only the Muslim brotherhood have resorted to armed struggle things could have been different is complete non sense and just simplistic...not to mention that the social composition and sectarian divisions in Syria is a major cause of grievances and foreign interventions while the social and religious context in Egypt is completely different. by the way the MB did resort to violence and Egypt fought an Islamist insurgency in Sinai for many years but they were ultimately crushed not to mention of course that there would be no popular support whatsoever for such armed struggle even if there is opposition to the current regime..
@@tosamja117 I don’t like his views because they lack nuance, context and are full of generalizations and drawing false parallels..he leaves a lot out to suit his pontifications and world view but I guess that’s difficult for you to understand..
@@TawfikElkheshenMiddle East eye is funded by Qatar, who have always supported regime change in Syria. Now the Qatar-Turkey oil pipeline running through Syria which Assad rejected in 2009 is back on the cards
They are Syrian Arab nationals , it was HizbuLLaah & Iranians that came from outside , & cia & mossad who created daesh & the kurdish rebels from outside , to destabilise & engender israHelli power
And here they come! The agents of the governments this great analyst was talking about... You must be very scared now that the people have seen how weak you are! These lies about foreign attacks don't work anymore!
I don't have a problem with that as an Arab spring enthusiast and supporter of the Syrian revolution and the victorious HTS movement and their leader Sheikh Ahmed Hussein Al-Shar'.
David, pray for all the minorities in Syria. Pray for the Christians that have been in Syria since the time of Christ. And if you are "secular", pray in any case. It is your publication that is the eye 👁️ › that is focused on all of it. Whether you believe or not, God is watching too (as Bette Midler once famously sang and it is indeed not "from a distance" but up close and personal). And so are the people of this entire world watching, Arab or not, with both 👀 eyes. Don't put this on the "Syrian people themselves". ... when those that are a part of this current situation are indeed not Syrian but historic subjugators whose only "distress" is how to re-subjugate those that freed themselves centuries ago! Say it as is, David
And for those that responded before that I do not mention the Palestinian Christians, they are the reason why I even know of this publication or our host David here
And here is what my second response was: being Eastern Orthodox Christian, I pray for the entire world. Especially the innocent children of this world, for those that harm them receive the sternest warning in my book from Christ Himself.
Is Jolani going to do anything about the Israeli invasion of southern Syria, lol? What about Turkey in the north? Say what you will about the Taliban at least they won't let anybody that wants invade them. More than you can say Al-Qaeda 2 over here.
I'm overwhelmed with joy for the Syrians I'm Lebanese 🇱🇧 and we know what the Syrians have been through Between Hafiz Alassad and his son, it's been 53 years of the unimaginable 💔 And to those who think Bashar is against Israel 🇮🇱 is completely wrong Israel has been protected by the Assad family since 1971
@@namatullahsharifi5131who says he was proisrahel? But he knew very well that he's family was put in place to protect israhel. There are rumors circulating for decades that Hafiz had sold golan heights to israhel for 100ml dollars. That's why he nor his son ever brought this topic into the attention of the international organisations as an illegal occupation of Syria's territory.
Assad family got to power propped up by the west (France) anyway. Otherwise, how can a minority Alawite group hold so much power in a sunni dominant country
Lies are what you are made off🤣🤣🤣 Then if Russia is far weaker, why don’t you march on Moscow? Why don’t you, NATO, help Zelensky get back Crimea as you helped Jhadists capture Damascus? You assume the world is stupid, that’s your most dangerous weakness😅😅😊
Very good Analysis about how fragile the Syria revolution is and how other dictators in the middle East will try to derail the democratic moment in Syria like it failed in Egypt, Tunisia...
On the contrary. I used to like some of his stuff, but this piece so delusional it is preposterous. It's a complete sell out to the various geopolitical powers at play. I'm deeply disappointed, but happy to see him show his true colours, which in turn establishes what kind of powers are the financial backers of MEE.
I am your sister in God. By God, I did not write these words except out of distress and the harshness of circumstances. I am asking God and then from you. Do not leave me disappointed. My brother. We are women. We cannot go out and work like men. My Lord, I honor you. You are men. We are women. We cannot go out and work like you. My brother, where is humanity? Where is the brotherhood of faith? in Your hearts''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''' My brother, my first words are that I swear to God on the Book of God that I will not lie to you, nor deceive, nor deceive. I am a Yemeni girl from Yemen who is displaced. My family and I. There are 20,000 Yemenis between us, Ayat Al-Shahrb, and now we owe 60,000 for 3 months, and the owner of the house is one of the people who does not have mercy. By God, my brother, everything will come. One day he would insult us and talk about us and move from the house to the street because we could not pay him the rent. The neighbors saw us. We cried and they came back to talk to the neighbors and gave us the end of the week. We made him swear an oath to God. He took us out to the street. Have mercy on us. Our country is because of this war, and we cannot find food for our day, and I, my brothers and I are living on a embassy. Our father has passed away, may God have mercy on him, and we have no one in this world who has been with us in these harsh circumstances. My younger brothers went out to the street and saw the neighbors eating and stopped at their door to give them bread, even if they broke it, and by God who has the kingdom of the heavens and the earth, they closed the door and expelled them. They came back crying, dying of hunger, and no one left Have mercy on them and give it a holiday, I have made a living, and now blame one of us for helping us with a kilo of flour. I swear to God, I am dying of hunger. My brother, I am a stranger to God and then to you, and I want your help for the sake of God. I implore you, for God’s sake, to love goodness and help me, even if it is 60,000 Yemeni riyals, by messaging me on WhatsApp on this number 00967,711013075 and asking. Name my card and send it and don't be late May God compensate you with all the best, my brothers Sagar. Look at how they are, help us and save us before they throw us out in the street. We will be lost or die of hunger. My family and I ask you in God’s name, if you are able to help us, do not be late for us, and may God reward you. Good.:,,,,,.,.;;;%%%%%,,,:::::::::,,,,,,,a,,,,.>\\]] \\]]>]>>]]>]\>⇶]%;&;&;] >]\]]\\\\\⇶>⇶>>>^,,,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,...
It was the sanctions and the kurds/us taking the oil and gas and wheat that kept the crippled country from getting back on its feet. The regime committed ruthless acts during the fighting and living conditions were getting worse not better in peace time. People had nothing to fight for.
If you knew the system of Shias survival after 1446 of oppression, then you believe they grow up stronger than before. Syria was slaughterhouse for Resistance.
Mind Begs the Question: ▪︎If Western Media Censors Anti-Semitic posts ▪︎Allows Islamophobic posts ▪︎Western Media complicit for Islamophobia ▪︎Like Nazi Media complicit for Anti-Semitism,no?
according to the prophecies in islam there is a book called "alfetan" talked about a war in syria for freedom and last between 12 to 14 yrs next will be yemen and iraq(end of non-belivers) if these countries win there wars i think palastine will be free sooner
😁 I wonder why the "Arab Spring" doesn't come to counyrys like authoritarian regimes of QATAR or UNITED ARAB EMIRATES or SAUDY ARABIA... 😮 I also wonder why MEE and Aljazzera NEVER criticize these authoritarian regimes but they delight in criticize other authoritarian regimes such Syria...🤔🤔🤔🤫🤭😅
You know well Syria loses one way or another. Support Pls cause get back to Asad regime severe sanctions. Neutral with Isr: turn to a dictator to suppress Pls cause, loses the Syrian invaded territory and receives its yearly aid to remain royal.
"Most Zionists don't believe that God exists but they do believe he promised them PALESTINE"
- Ilan Pappe
If you're willing to throw a stone at a hornet's nest, you should also be ready to face the consequences of your actions......
Some random Guy
@@itachiofthesharingan67 The chosen ones are always crying wolf, but as soon as they get power, they crush everyone else, censor them, threaten them... They are the children of Satan.
Me
Dont recall Palestine being mentioned in the Bible, nor in the Qoran.
As I recall, the people blamed for killing Jesus are the Jews, not Palestinians.
@@itachiofthesharingan67You tried to sound poetic but, what’s poetic about Isr@el? Cmon man
"If I don't steal it then someone else will"
- Yakob the settler from NY
Bv
.
Bb
Vb.
V
.b.
B
B
No oppressors will win. I hope it’s time for justice in west Asia and in Egypt
what about Sudan?
what about Marocco?
What about Algeria?
What about Lebanon?
What about any country where first cousin marriage is the preferred kind?
As an arab living under a dictatorship and who have been hearing ''we shouldn't revolt, do you want what happened to syrians to happen to us?'', i'm happy that we can now say to our puppet rulers : ''you should release the political prisoners and listen to your people, do you want what happened to assad to happen to you?'' elhamdou li'Allah
You are now controlled by Israel. You should be happy now.
Good job. I'm a Somali. I support you. What country do you live, fam?
The problem is Arab nations' borders have been set up by the same colonial powers that still control the puppets. This prevents homogenous reaction during upheavals. If there is sudden uprising, it may or may not have already been hijacked by intelligence agencies of those same colonizers in order to pit one against the other. Mayhem seems to be what the USrael wants, so they can "valiantly" roll in with "solutions".
Iran is the only revolution without foreign influence that stuck around (not an Arab nation but, significanly, relatively homogeneous).
You are deluded and will probably sell your whole family for money as most Syrians sold their homeland to western powers.
@@WarikowCafe
Probably Egyptian
"We have 250 families ready to move into Gaza once they have been cleansed"
- Daniella Weiss
They plot , you all plan & Allaah Plans
&
Allaah is The Best of Planners
"Colonialism gets a bad wrap"
- Jar of Mayonnaise from Texas
Assad regime was brutal and tyrannical.. most Syrian dislike him. He ought to be deposed long ago. Hopefully Syria can rise up again
"Assad was a tyrant." Fortunately, now you have Joulani, who is a humanist.
Syria is done
Wake up!... Syria is gone ,the Israelis are on a land grab and will annex much of Syria thanks to the western puppets Jolani and Erdoğan... They helped the Israelis cut off the supply lines to Hamas so now not only is Syria gone but Gaza and the West Bank are now certain to be soon in the zionists hands. Unfortunately for Muslims they always fall for the western trick of 'Divide And Conquer '
Revolutions don't die
It's waiting for a chance to succeed
Are you over ruling the CIA and Israeli involvement in the event?
qatar seems to be 100% owned by the british east india company
Why would Israel want Assad out? He was their tool.
He appears to under value this
He gave you the answer
wtf you guys are giving assad support still by saying that crap! i dont care if the satan came and helped get him out the children women prisons rapes torture and the rape of lebanon and Palestine by assad regime helping israel is over alhamdulilah
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If ISIS,Al-Qaida
▪︎Don't help Palestinians
▪︎Help Israel occupy Syria
▪︎Islamic Terrorists or Israeli Terrorists?
You need to study more.
Stupid
@@TahsanHasan-x7qseems like an accurate description of what is happening in middle east
@@Mhdfalah250 How will you explain upcoming Syria/Afghanistan!!!
Like Mali and Somalia. You better study before commenting.
@@TahsanHasan-x7q hey, isreal doing what they telling since oct 7. Is a greater notreal plan That includes Syria, Egypt, Iraq, medina or Parts of Saudi. Now Syria and Iraq don't have a government or military to protect from anything. You are telling me to study mali and Somali
You mean CIA Spring? 🤓
“AQ is on our side in Syria”, sent by Jake Sullivan back in 2012 to Hillary Clinton
So was ISIS...
I have seen this quote million times, and I don't doubt that it is true, but I don't understand at all why it matters. So what if both Al Qaida and Clinton wanted Assad to go. Does that make him automatically a good guy?
@ I can’t believe that the USA chose AQ over a secular regime; there is something fishy about that decision. You can check the quote in Hillary Clinton's e-mails on Wiki leaks
@ Isn’t it fishy to choose religious extremism over secularism??
And the same extreme jihadists getting support from na-zionist regime by being treated in israhell when wounded
Because Iran was fighting Israel while Al Qaeda did nothing.
Did you all hear this call for liberation? Yallah!
Jolenzgy and zelensgy are gets pay from one person
Hello Middle East eye
I wanted to inform you that i watched this video and it had like
607 likes, i wanted to like but i could not then i wanted to comment it said error, I thought of going out of the video and come back in from my history but it was not recorded there, then I thought of coming back to the video by search when i did it had like 12 likes, i know you may know this but i think RUclips is trying to hid your channel, i support your channel and i really appreciate your work
May Allah help us all
They deleted the video and uploaded it again with a different title. The previous video had a lot of negative comments on it so might've been the reason but no clue.
If you didn't know what the word "propaganda" means... This is the definition of it.
The Syrian Islamists who successfully took Damascus and overthrew the Assad regime, along with his Russian and Iranian Shia supporters, have demonstrated remarkable nobility in their treatment of their enemies. Despite the years of brutal oppression, massacres, and subjugation inflicted upon them by the regime, their actions reflect a commitment to Islamic principles of justice, mercy, and humanity.
Their approach has set an example of how even in victory, one can act with dignity and restraint, focusing on reconciliation and rebuilding rather than perpetuating cycles of vengeance. This conduct not only reaffirms the values they stand for but also offers a path forward for Syria to heal and unite after decades of suffering under tyranny.
True. But governing is much harder than revolution. There isnt yet a good working example in the modern world of a democratic government that operates according to laws and principles of Islam, and can accommodate the plurality of interests and thinking in the 21st century. This is totally new territory.
Yes we can all see that. And we can all agree that Assad, like his father, a dictator.
Was the rebels really fighting for the Syrian people against Assad and his Iranian and Russian supporters?
The former IS right hand man now rebel leader spoke about how Assad has allowed Iran and Russia to occupy Syria and yet he remain silent about Israel’s active airstrikes in “the buffer zones.” And we also haven’t heard a single word of condemnation towards the US military’s occupation of the Syrian oil fields and wheat farms since 2014.
The US wanted Assad’s regime to starve and now he’s gone and the US still haven’t left the precious oil fields. So, why haven’t the HTS condemn US and Israel? And why is the new Syrian spokesperson openly admitting about allying with Israel on tv? Iran and Russia are the only enemies he said.
And a week ago, one HTS member on Israeli channel 11 news thanking Israel for pushing out Hezbollah that led to the rebel success in capturing multiple provinces in Syria. So, this new Syrian government will be an ally to Israel. Aren’t you concerned about that?
Nobility??!! Sure if abu musab al-zarqawi man is considered Noble!!! You are living in the "Euphoria" phase then shit will hit the fan and interest will collide when forming a government. then you will see the true phase of Nobility!!
Now you believe in Hasbara?
Former head choppers, are you serious?
How ridiculous review is that? Do you think Syrian Forces came together and won the victory ?? Türkiye had been supporting as logistics, training and leadership to Syrian Forces for years. Listen to President Erdoğan speech in TR parliament in 2018. You will find the answers...
I agree 💯 this review is ridiculous.
Is Jolani using a Israeli arm uniform.without badges
Probably in his pockets.
U must be delusional
Good eye
You must be semi-blind! Full of sickening hatred! But who cares
Idlib's only border is with Türkiye. They all get their uniforms from Türkiye.
You conveniently neglected to mention how Israel is bombarding the daylight out of Syria on a daily bases!! Also you conveniently neglected to mention netanyahu's map at the UN and how this is the very first step to achieve that map!!
What a joke this propaganda piece is
Thank you.
How about you bring true arguments against what he is saying?
@@TheMohamzthe whole Syrian “revolution” lead by 80% non Syrian fighters, installing AQ and isis leaders was orchestrated by Turkey and armed by the US/NATO. It has nothing to do with the freedoms of Syrian people. Syria is done as a country. No one is merely addressing the sanctions that made the lives of civilians horrible.
Well they had a life at least, now there will be no life/no country.
Revisit this hubris one year from now. Revolutionary slumber as Israel plummeted and conquered Syria without being shot at a single bullet
Shameless and shameful journalism
Good bye
Israel will. Conquer nothing. It has exposed its fears. It is afraid of the Syrian people. There was no reason other than fear for the actions Israel has taken since the revolutionary forces took power.
Respect for you David.
Such simplistic and lazy analysis..there is absolutely no comparison between the situation in Egypt and Syria and no analogies to be drawn..Syria is occupied by 3 countries and everybody knows arrangements between those countries is the main reason events unfolded as they did in Syria..to even suggest that this was somehow an organic armed resistance that other opposition movements in the region should draw lessons from is laughable to say the least!..30-40% of HTS fighters are not even Syrian, they are mostly central Asian alqaeda members and that’s by Golani’s own assessment in an interview he did a few years ago.and what did Golani say about Israel occupying a portion of Syria 3 times the size of Gaza..nothing! and that’s why Israel is celebrating and Netanyahu is gloating that it was his bombardment of Iran and Hizballah that directly led to the fall of Assad and he is absolutely right..to take out all this context and to suggest that if only the Muslim brotherhood have resorted to armed struggle things could have been different is complete non sense and just simplistic...not to mention that the social composition and sectarian divisions in Syria is a major cause of grievances and foreign interventions while the social and religious context in Egypt is completely different. by the way the MB did resort to violence and Egypt fought an Islamist insurgency in Sinai for many years but they were ultimately crushed not to mention of course that there would be no popular support whatsoever for such armed struggle even if there is opposition to the current regime..
You don't like the outcome of the revolution? admit it! You don't accept his views because you weren't rooting for the side that won.
@@tosamja117 I don’t like his views because they lack nuance, context and are full of generalizations and drawing false parallels..he leaves a lot out to suit his pontifications and world view but I guess that’s difficult for you to understand..
@@TawfikElkheshenMiddle East eye is funded by Qatar, who have always supported regime change in Syria. Now the Qatar-Turkey oil pipeline running through Syria which Assad rejected in 2009 is back on the cards
Appreciate your counterpoints 😏 fair
Middle East Eye is British based... duh.
Always pay attention when David Hearst shares analysis 👏
People should start calling it the "Israeli Spring," because only Israel benefited from that extensive U.S. operation.
I don't see how this can be called a Syrian revolution when the 'revolutionaries' are not Syrian but come from outside.
They are Syrian Arab nationals , it was HizbuLLaah & Iranians that came from outside , & cia & mossad who created daesh & the kurdish rebels from outside , to destabilise & engender israHelli power
Exactly
Very untrue. Completely false!
MEE is Qatar propaganda
And here they come! The agents of the governments this great analyst was talking about... You must be very scared now that the people have seen how weak you are!
These lies about foreign attacks don't work anymore!
Its still a mystery how a 20 thousand militia walked over 20 times bigger army without a single bullet fired. .
Bring the Arab Spring to Qatar
CIA is already there... it's all under control.
Best comment 🤣
I don't have a problem with that as an Arab spring enthusiast and supporter of the Syrian revolution and the victorious HTS movement and their leader Sheikh Ahmed Hussein Al-Shar'.
Pure propaganda. Speaker should archive his video. Your platform is another feel good POISON IN SUGAR COATINGS 😢
David, pray for all the minorities in Syria. Pray for the Christians that have been in Syria since the time of Christ. And if you are "secular", pray in any case. It is your publication that is the eye 👁️
› that is focused
on all of it. Whether you believe or not, God is watching too (as Bette Midler once famously sang and it is indeed not "from a distance" but up close and personal). And so are the people of this entire world watching, Arab or not, with both 👀 eyes. Don't put this on the
"Syrian people themselves".
... when those that are a part of this current situation are indeed not Syrian but historic subjugators whose only "distress" is how to re-subjugate those that freed themselves centuries ago! Say it as is, David
And for those that responded before that I do not mention the Palestinian Christians, they are the reason why I even know of this publication or our host David here
And here is what my second response was: being Eastern Orthodox Christian, I pray for the entire world. Especially the innocent children of this world, for those that harm them receive the sternest warning in my book from Christ Himself.
And I pray for the entire world, especially the innocent children of the entire world.
You are a spokesperson for Qatar, David. Nothing more than that.
Erasing comments is not kosher David
Thank you for saying that. I was wondering why all comments sounded the echo of the same voice.
Syria will be the new Gaza..
Israel will be the new Gaza.
@@Sundancer09...eventually. it may take a while.
Western-bullshit-blah
Far better then the Iranian lies
Is Jolani going to do anything about the Israeli invasion of southern Syria, lol? What about Turkey in the north?
Say what you will about the Taliban at least they won't let anybody that wants invade them. More than you can say Al-Qaeda 2 over here.
Turkey is not a threat to Syria. Turkey is the one already created new Syria.
@@OttomaniaGamingso türkie will exit Syrian lands and respect Syrian lands?
@@bridge2499if they feel like it. Haha. Arabs if combined will still get smashed by the Turanians.
I'm overwhelmed with joy for the Syrians
I'm Lebanese 🇱🇧 and we know what the Syrians have been through
Between Hafiz Alassad and his son, it's been 53 years of the unimaginable 💔
And to those who think Bashar is against Israel 🇮🇱 is completely wrong
Israel has been protected by the Assad family since 1971
Could you explain plz
Liar. You are MI6.
Thats wrong. Asad never was proiseael
@@namatullahsharifi5131who says he was proisrahel? But he knew very well that he's family was put in place to protect israhel. There are rumors circulating for decades that Hafiz had sold golan heights to israhel for 100ml dollars. That's why he nor his son ever brought this topic into the attention of the international organisations as an illegal occupation of Syria's territory.
Assad family got to power propped up by the west (France) anyway. Otherwise, how can a minority Alawite group hold so much power in a sunni dominant country
Inshallah, let the citizens of Syria be successful
Citizens of the world unite against all atrocities.
Salahuddin would not have approved any of this David.
Lies are what you are made off🤣🤣🤣 Then if Russia is far weaker, why don’t you march on Moscow? Why don’t you, NATO, help Zelensky get back Crimea as you helped Jhadists capture Damascus? You assume the world is stupid, that’s your most dangerous weakness😅😅😊
No.
Syria:place of the worst genocide? Really, David??
Absolutely agree
Beautiful commentary!
If it reawakens its 13 years later maybe lets call it The Cicada Spring.
Thank you for your review
Indeed well articulated. Intellectual analysis beats all speculations
But intelligence gained on the ground beats Hearst's speculations and wishful thinking every time. Syria will very soon become a theocracy.
That was peaceful tramsfer of power, supported by iran and russia, preventing bloodshed of eachother on the behalf of US and israel.
Keep telling yourself that
Agree
Thanks very much. I agree 100% with this analysis.
whaatt!!!?? Im all for deposing despots but a 13 year civil with hundreds of thousands killed is nothing to scoff at lmaoo
Why don't you show the images of the AQ "rebels" disguised as HTS expressing their "love" for the people of Latakia?
As an Egyptian, I can say that this channel got it right, unlike the other pro-Palestinian channels.
I’m surprised by your naive analysis
No, certainly not.
The Middle East Eye 👁🗨 is simply the best coverage for reporting events in the Middle East. Many thanks for your diligence. 👏 👆 🍉 😊
Very good Analysis about how fragile the Syria revolution is and how other dictators in the middle East will try to derail the democratic moment in Syria like it failed in Egypt, Tunisia...
David Hearst never seized to amaze us, that's the most vast and summarize piece of syrian victory i have seen so far.
You are dreaming and chasing rainbows.
On the contrary. I used to like some of his stuff, but this piece so delusional it is preposterous. It's a complete sell out to the various geopolitical powers at play. I'm deeply disappointed, but happy to see him show his true colours, which in turn establishes what kind of powers are the financial backers of MEE.
@alexugur In the end most of them are supporting a narrative that serves the military industrial complex.
Lay off doobies, Zio.
Really really good analysis . Thank you
Did he just suggested that peaceful revolutions are useless, and armed revolutions are successful and should be followed?
And will become democratic. Please tell us the name of your supplier and his telephone number.
Al Joulani has already said that Israel was his ally. Like any member of AQ or IS, from which HTS comes.
This songs nice and toasty but it’s fantasy. Everyone knows this is Turkish, Jewish/american push.
Great piece
@@imaduddeen4269 Of Qatari propaganda.
Topics well crafted piece by piece.
Excellent analysis sir.
The Middle East is like WW2 except it never ends
I listen to people on both sides of this - I don’t know enough to take one side or the other but I’m eager to see what’s to come.
All false kings will fall. One true King for all Arabs and Muslims will Rise.
Egypt despots are trembling as Syria toppled.
I am your sister in God. By God, I did not write these words except out of distress and the harshness of circumstances. I am asking God and then from you. Do not leave me disappointed. My brother. We are women. We cannot go out and work like men. My Lord, I honor you. You are men. We are women. We cannot go out and work like you. My brother, where is humanity? Where is the brotherhood of faith? in Your hearts''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''' My brother, my first words are that I swear to God on the Book of God that I will not lie to you, nor deceive, nor deceive. I am a Yemeni girl from Yemen who is displaced. My family and I. There are 20,000 Yemenis between us, Ayat Al-Shahrb, and now we owe 60,000 for 3 months, and the owner of the house is one of the people who does not have mercy. By God, my brother, everything will come. One day he would insult us and talk about us and move from the house to the street because we could not pay him the rent. The neighbors saw us. We cried and they came back to talk to the neighbors and gave us the end of the week. We made him swear an oath to God. He took us out to the street. Have mercy on us. Our country is because of this war, and we cannot find food for our day, and I, my brothers and I are living on a embassy. Our father has passed away, may God have mercy on him, and we have no one in this world who has been with us in these harsh circumstances. My younger brothers went out to the street and saw the neighbors eating and stopped at their door to give them bread, even if they broke it, and by God who has the kingdom of the heavens and the earth, they closed the door and expelled them. They came back crying, dying of hunger, and no one left Have mercy on them and give it a holiday, I have made a living, and now blame one of us for helping us with a kilo of flour. I swear to God, I am dying of hunger. My brother, I am a stranger to God and then to you, and I want your help for the sake of God. I implore you, for God’s sake, to love goodness and help me, even if it is 60,000 Yemeni riyals, by messaging me on WhatsApp on this number 00967,711013075 and asking. Name my card and send it and don't be late May God compensate you with all the best, my brothers Sagar. Look at how they are, help us and save us before they throw us out in the street. We will be lost or die of hunger. My family and I ask you in God’s name, if you are able to help us, do not be late for us, and may God reward you. Good.:,,,,,.,.;;;%%%%%,,,:::::::::,,,,,,,a,,,,.>\\]] \\]]>]>>]]>]\>⇶]%;&;&;] >]\]]\\\\\⇶>⇶>>>^,,,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,...
Great analysis
It was the sanctions and the kurds/us taking the oil and gas and wheat that kept the crippled country from getting back on its feet. The regime committed ruthless acts during the fighting and living conditions were getting worse not better in peace time. People had nothing to fight for.
This guy seems to have a blind eye on real Middle East issues!
Please please no more hate and revenge build your country again 🙏
Does anyone remember a couple weeks ago, when Putin fanboys claimed Russia got al-Jolani in an airstrike in Aleppo?
If you knew the system of Shias survival after 1446 of oppression, then you believe they grow up stronger than before. Syria was slaughterhouse for Resistance.
Well said
Qatari petro-islam
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If Western Media Censors Anti-Semitic posts
▪︎Allows Islamophobic posts
▪︎Western Media complicit for Islamophobia
▪︎Like Nazi Media complicit for Anti-Semitism,no?
RUclips.@@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings
@Censored by RUclips
@RUclips
Arab spring...Islamist winter.
As.per Langley instructions...
This is the best analysis i have seen so far..
Why don't Historians findout how these borders were made and what the real boundaries off Syria were before WW1 and Sykes Pico
Ironic, considering you yourself wouldn't know, were it not for historians keeping a record of it.
@@MrSlanderer My comment was to the start of the video when he mentions Historians.
If…
… this revolution is different to all the other ones.
May Allah unite the Ummah
وَمَا كَانَ قَوْلَهُمْ اِلَّآ اَنْ قَالُوْا رَبَّنَا اغْفِرْ لَنَا ذُنُوْبَنَا وَاِسْرَافَنَا فِيْٓ اَمْرِنَا وَثَبِّتْ اَقْدَامَنَا وَانْصُرْنَا عَلَى الْقَوْمِ الْكٰفِرِيْنَ (آل عمران : ٣)
So your very good analysis of the situation confirms what chinese communist leader Mao who said " political power comes out of barrel of a gun".
Excellent
MEE, do you want more civil wars?
according to the prophecies in islam
there is a book called "alfetan"
talked about a war in syria for freedom and last between 12 to 14 yrs
next will be yemen and iraq(end of non-belivers)
if these countries win there wars
i think palastine will be free sooner
😁 I wonder why the "Arab Spring" doesn't come to counyrys like authoritarian regimes of QATAR or UNITED ARAB EMIRATES or SAUDY ARABIA... 😮 I also wonder why MEE and Aljazzera NEVER criticize these authoritarian regimes but they delight in criticize other authoritarian regimes such Syria...🤔🤔🤔🤫🤭😅
Arab's Autumn.
If anyone believes your opening statement...theyre very naive.
Syrian military assets gone 😂😂😂
As a journalist, no as a human being you should be ashamed of yourself. Must be on a good salary.
It’s a zombie now
it's rare to find such complete analysis, so rare among western analysis.
You know well Syria loses one way or another.
Support Pls cause get back to Asad regime severe sanctions.
Neutral with Isr: turn to a dictator to suppress Pls cause, loses the Syrian invaded territory and receives its yearly aid to remain royal.
Your assessments are not accurate so far
The Arab Spring? Ha ha, no!
❤
Estudio en EEUU, verdad 😂?