Honestly have you looked at the cast? They almost all look exactly like the character they protray in game. Just keep the cast the same and film a live action version. It wouldn't hit right without the voices we've heard for hundreds of hours.
@@chandlerbraaten847The voice actors for Arthur and John look nothing like their characters. And don't get me started on the voice actor for dutch. That dude is like 200 lbs heavier than dutch and he doesn't look like him. He just has an iconic voice. I understand you like them but please stop lying to yourself and other people. We all have eyes. Next you're gonna say the voice actor for Niko Bellic looks just like Niko.
@@TJ-fe7rr he surely should, his acting as kung fu panda was nice i can see him changing the personality into a drunk outlaw. And looks the most of any other actor for Bill Williamson
I don’t know these actors too well. But i think in my opinion we need more new movies and series with new actors instead of the ones that are popular and that everyone know
@@littlemilkjug2130no just cause they look similar to the part doesn't mean they'd be good for the role. Bradley Cooper would not be able to play Arthur well at all despite him being a good actor, Charlize Theron pretty much fucks up any character she is these days by making them be something they're not, Gerard Butler doesn't even look close to Dutch in anyway, and Bill Barnes playing John Marston ain't gonna happen since he plays charismatic characters 90% of the time and not super calm and collected serious characters like John. Plus Americans would be needed in order to do the characters voices since Europeans suck at doing southern or cowboy voices.
@@angelothompson186 you do realize no one they could cast would look exactly like the character since they don’t exist. I said good casting because they’re all great actors.
@@littlemilkjug2130 like I said in pretty much my first sentence. It doesn't matter if they look the part it's about the way they act and none of them woukd be good in acting as these characters except maybe David Harbour and Diego Luna as Bill and Javier.
@@MRSARATAKI Too white does not imply "Caucasian." He's just too white to play Javier. Javier is a brown-skinned Mexican mestizo, while Pedro Pascal is a Castizo. He would be a terrible choice for Javier.
Their voice actors could play them. They did an amazing job getting in character with their voices, so I have no doubt that they could act perfectly in line with their characters
The actors in Red Dead 2 did mocap AND the acting, and they often look like their characters, so they already have everything they need to be their characters in a movie. They already have the looks, voices, and mannerisms like walking style, bc they did all that
I liked how Arthur had a resemblance to roger Clark, Hosea looked almost exactly like his actor, Micah was literally Peter blomquist the actor but with longer hair, bill had a similar beard and face to his actor
I had a thought about a RDR movie. What I thought about was that they make Red dead 2 and name it red dead redemption i and RDR I could be named Red Dead Redemption II
I think if they ever do a live action the voice actors should be the actors. And maybe they could add some stuff they didn’t or couldn’t use in the game
*knowing Hollywood. They would cast Tom Holland as Arthur and Jack Black as John 💀*
True bro, true…
Keanu reeves as john
True💀💀
There’s no one better to play Arthur Morgan than Roger Clark himself
Fr
Honestly have you looked at the cast? They almost all look exactly like the character they protray in game. Just keep the cast the same and film a live action version. It wouldn't hit right without the voices we've heard for hundreds of hours.
Not to mention that the actual cast are all actors
But not even Roger Clark looks like Arthur Morgan 😂🤣
@@chandlerbraaten847The voice actors for Arthur and John look nothing like their characters.
And don't get me started on the voice actor for dutch. That dude is like 200 lbs heavier than dutch and he doesn't look like him. He just has an iconic voice. I understand you like them but please stop lying to yourself and other people. We all have eyes.
Next you're gonna say the voice actor for Niko Bellic looks just like Niko.
Bro Lauren as abigail is perfect
That's the only one I agree with
Yeah lauren would absolutley fit as abigail
Bill is good too. But Lauren is probably the for Abigail. No doubt about it
No its not wtf 😂
no she would not💀
Uncle should be Jack Black😂
nah he sits bill the best than any other
@@alinaobryska1684i don't think i could take Jack Black seriously enough for Bill Williamson
@@TJ-fe7rr he surely should, his acting as kung fu panda was nice i can see him changing the personality into a drunk outlaw. And looks the most of any other actor for Bill Williamson
Nahhh but he could fit the roll of Pearson tho
Pearson should be Jack Black
Nah we need the smiling stock photo guy as uncle
YES
His name is András Arató if they do use him they better do it soon he's like 77
Gerald
Hide The Pain Harold?
Hide the pain Harold?
Dutch should be played by my uncle in law I swear they are identical
Hosea by Clint Eastwood if he was like 20 or 30 years younger
oh my god yes
Genuinely one of the first fancasts for anything I’ve seen that was actually good
john’s voice actor could be john’s movie actor
just give him a bit of a shave and longer hair and boom john marston
@@yesimtheworld Robb is more bigger than john it really wouldn't work and stop replying to your own comment
i was adding extra stuff i forgot to add
@@yesimtheworld you know you can edit your own comment
@@toilet0you know you can delete your extra comment
We should just have an animated film with all the original voice actors playing there parts
Hugh Jackman's look from Logan looks like Arthur Morgan with beard too
I always thought that too, both are usually drunk tired mean but also have morals, just fits
@ArthurMorgan_5074 I think physically maybe someone else but I think he would capture his character perfectly
When I played I thought Arthur looked like Hugh
I legit thought that lady from twd was the one playing Abigail when i first played the game
For Micah they would just get some random ass rat off the street 💀
Underated comment🤣🤣
I chose Brad Pitt because he can be mean in hi characters just look at Fury 🤣
Woody Harrellson might be perfect for it
Brad Dourif would do a great job if Micah was older.
@@ootfan5 na they going to get a naked mole rat for that slot my man
Jeffrey dean morgan as Dutch
Nah he looks to old now probably hosea tho
@@Successiskey-g6fhe cannot be Hosea
Those r actually good pics hopefully they try and get them to cast in sum like that
abigail casting is on point
Bro said let’s make Javier a completely different race💀
Real
And let’s make Arthur fat
Diego Luna is Mexican
Diego Luna is Hispanic 😂
I think the voice actors are the perfect people to play the characters
You actually did a pretty great job in my opinion
David Harbour is perfect
Arthur, Dutch and bill have the perfect fan castings .
Agree!
This guy cooked so hard
Daniel Day Lewis as Dutch would be great.
Trelwany
JDM as Dutch would be perfect.
@@Gameslayer-2003 exactly
as ghost hat man
Dude! I was thinking that the other day! He does a good American accent too
I don’t know these actors too well. But i think in my opinion we need more new movies and series with new actors instead of the ones that are popular and that everyone know
Norman Reedus as John Marston would be fire imo
No, going too far
Nah but I could see him fitting in as a character like Bill or something maybe
@@thatcherdoingcoolstuff2657he's nowhere near fat or ugly enough to play bill. Far closer to john.
@@GARCATCH_ Too old to be Young Marston
Keanu Reeves? No? Am I shooting a little high?
We need to see the crazy soldier from valentine
No one let this man near a movie director
This was actually a really good casting wtf are you talking about??
@@littlemilkjug2130no just cause they look similar to the part doesn't mean they'd be good for the role. Bradley Cooper would not be able to play Arthur well at all despite him being a good actor, Charlize Theron pretty much fucks up any character she is these days by making them be something they're not, Gerard Butler doesn't even look close to Dutch in anyway, and Bill Barnes playing John Marston ain't gonna happen since he plays charismatic characters 90% of the time and not super calm and collected serious characters like John. Plus Americans would be needed in order to do the characters voices since Europeans suck at doing southern or cowboy voices.
@@angelothompson186 you do realize no one they could cast would look exactly like the character since they don’t exist. I said good casting because they’re all great actors.
@@littlemilkjug2130 like I said in pretty much my first sentence. It doesn't matter if they look the part it's about the way they act and none of them woukd be good in acting as these characters except maybe David Harbour and Diego Luna as Bill and Javier.
@@angelothompson186 your acting like these aren’t all great actors though.
I feel like Brad Pitt would be a great Arthur Morgan. Other than that, this casting is perfect
pedro pascal as javier would go hard
Nah, he's too white to play Javier. The better choices would be Jay Hernandez, Benjamin Bratt, or Michael Peña.
@@weebnibba1540 Pedro Pascal isn’t even caucasian what you mean “too white” 💀
@@MRSARATAKI Too white does not imply "Caucasian." He's just too white to play Javier. Javier is a brown-skinned Mexican mestizo, while Pedro Pascal is a Castizo. He would be a terrible choice for Javier.
@@weebnibba1540 Ok now I get it, it’s like how the casted the live action Avatar The Last Air bender all over again. my b
Pedro to ols
I really hope they make a series about Red Dead Redemption 2 and like each episode could be a mission off the game
The voice actor of Arthur would be a good author because not only do he look nearly identical but he is the voice
He’s the voice and he he did all the motion capture too so he’s not a voice actor
He needs to lose weight though. Arthur is supposed to be strong and in shape
@@elpoodoo3099ngl you can make arthur fat tho
@@elpoodoo3099 roger clark isn't even that fat
@@JRL_ he’s not like obese but I still think he would have to hit the gym
Best fan casting I have seen. Didn’t know that Sadie had a cut above her eyebrow.
Bro Norman Reedus would be perfect for John. Bro looks exactly like him 💀
He just has to not mumble like in 90% of his roles
That's ok because John mumbles and grunts alot@@NotSoOriginalKid
No.
He doesn’t have the voice though..
John is just like that lol@@NotSoOriginalKid
You don't need to point your hands like a windowlicker spotting a bee on the bus
And you’re a grown man commenting on RUclips shorts
This is perfection.
Thought it would be one of those Tom Holland ones again 💀
He will play LeNnYY
Their voice actors could play them. They did an amazing job getting in character with their voices, so I have no doubt that they could act perfectly in line with their characters
actors* they did mocap. not just voice acting
Perfect cast. Especially first 3. Who do you think can play Charles, Hosiea and Micah?
Clint Eastwood as Hosea
The voice actor for Micah has the same moustache so I think he’d be good at it
David Harbour as Bill is the perfect casting
I think Roger Clark needs to stay as Arthur . He ist just perfect
Bro i could see this happening ❤
Not gonna lie Bradley Cooper is perfect.
Bills cast was also pretty goood
I disagree, Can’t improve on a near perfect voice actor
@@Nutt-u they’ll never do that or at least it’s very unlikely
Bills was spot on and Abigail’s was decently close
@@owenleach7778 David Harbour is perfect for Bill Williamson
Bro the actors pretty much already look like the characters in the game.
I personally believe everyone should be played by Tom holland. The horse can be played by Tom holland as well.
I agree but I think that Abigail should be Chris Pratt
@@debduband Sadie should be played by The Rock.
The voice/motion capture actors would be the best option ngl
John Marston should be played by John Marston
Honeslt he kinda looks like Jon berthal
Not gonna lie, Norman Reedus would be great as John Marston
Original actors and a bit of VFX and you’ve got the whole gang together
Dutch must be Zlatan😂😂
Hhhhh yeah
Honestly, we don't need a TV show of this game, it's amazing just the way it is and those characters could never be replicated to me.
Ngl I kinda think some of the actors are too Pretty/ handsome or whatever to play some of them
Like who?
That is actually great for a cast
Or we use the voice actors??
They were whole performance capture
They’re old and don’t look much like their characters
@@zuccsucc476 fair enough reason 👍🏻
@@zuccsucc476 theyre literally modelled after them only john doesnt look similar
@@ManWitAPlanDutch doesn’t look like his actor either, other than that use original cast
Damn. Pretty solid lineup bro
Hear me out now, Christian Bale, as John would be amazing with his acting skills
THERE WE GO YOU GET IT
John Marston was the last sigma male of the west, after all.
@@noise3312 Jack...
The actors in Red Dead 2 did mocap AND the acting, and they often look like their characters, so they already have everything they need to be their characters in a movie. They already have the looks, voices, and mannerisms like walking style, bc they did all that
Tom Holland as Hosea Matthews 💀
Hes not even a good actor but hes what I imagine when I try to picture a very young ng Hosea
@TheRealMrMajestic I meant it as old Hosea, and I meant it as a joke entirely
@@Blbeditz alr
Maggie finally got out of the apocalypse 💀💀
Gerards scottish accent is so fucking previlent no way he'll play dutch
Jeffrey dean Morgan can do the dutch Van der linde voice & acting.
@@johnyosores4022 agreed
Well Dutch has some scottish ancestry, and he could change his voice for the role
@@JRL_ from what i see from gerard his scottish voice sometimes goes through in his movies which sounds weird at times
I NEED TO SEE THAT BEFORE I DIE
These are all spot on 👌👌👌
Idk abt that
Female choices were spot-on
I think jensen ackles would be an amazing arthur
Abigail one is literally the same person!
I liked how Arthur had a resemblance to roger Clark, Hosea looked almost exactly like his actor, Micah was literally Peter blomquist the actor but with longer hair, bill had a similar beard and face to his actor
honest the cast who were in rdr2 would just be my favourite
I'd pay top dollar to see that kinda cast with that Magnificent story
lauren is a great idea for Abigail
and we gotta get jack black in there somewhere 😂
He could be uncle ngl
I honestly think Arthur Morgan could be played by the guy who voice acted him in the game. I couldn’t imagine anyone else being Arthur Morgan
john marston's voice is so iconic that it would be hard to not get dissapointed if they cast another actor other than Rob
Norman reedus as John 🤯
Good casting. I feel like playing red dead redemption 2
Bro wdym RDR2 is so good it feels like a movie.
Basically all of the rdr cast can play their characters
Micah - woody harelson.
Cast looks good tho
I thought I was the only one that thought of Bradley Cooper as Arthur Morgan. Especially with his performance in a star is born
My fav part about all these people is that they look like there characters in irl
I agree except I think Sebastian Stan as John would be better
Bro if this happens I am 100% sure that Pedro pascal will be recommended for a roll in this film
Wow this cast would be brilliant 😳🙌
Bro this would be a fucking phenomenal casting for a live action film or series ...Good eye 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Ben barns was honestly a surprise I think he did amazing as billy Russo in punisher
Aren’t they all based off the voice actors? Like all the voice actors look exactly like their own characters
I think Clint Eastwood would make a great Hosea, and jack black would be a good pearson
Keanu reeves is a good john.
No need to add anyone or to replace/remove anyone they are perfect
pretty good casting man
Lauren was spot on. Plus she can do the southern accent
Is it just me or do I think some parts of this would go hard in a tycoon game
Imagine brad pitt as arthur morgan
If they make a red dead movie each chapter (besides 1) will be the whole movie
If they make a live action version of that zombie DLC than Lauren would be a perfect fit
They should make John Hugh Jackmen
This is the most let’s think of the most popular celebs who resemble the bare minimum of the character video I’ve ever seen
Ok so this is the most expensive show of all time
I had a thought about a RDR movie. What I thought about was that they make Red dead 2 and name it red dead redemption i and RDR I could be named Red Dead Redemption II
am i the only one who thinks Chris Hemsworth looks like Arthur morgan
Same! Chris Hemsworth all the way man.
if only there were people who had the same speech, mannerisms, and mocap! it’s almost like there were VAs!
I think if they ever do a live action the voice actors should be the actors. And maybe they could add some stuff they didn’t or couldn’t use in the game
Holy shit bro most of these actually look accurate
Dutch's voice actor actually looks like the character