Sir, i am big fan of you. And a student of your RUclips platform. Sir, you are giving us vast knowledge at no price at all. if i weigh the knowledge you gave us with price, even mukesh ambani will become poor. Very straight forward and deep knowledge lectures. Thank you sir.
Dr. Faizan Mustafa great fan of you , a personal request if you post a video in Hindi can you provide English subtitles as non Hindi speakers can also watch them . Thank you
Sir, my father is a govt employee and I also have quite good enough experience of interviews. The caste prejudices still exist deep in the system. With reservations there exists preferential promotions and that is we see only high caste men in secretariat. Without reservations no one of lower cast will ever get an entry let alone being promoted.
@@Solo-hf7fr because the govt BJP or Cong do not want cast concious people who will then endanger the undeclared high cast reservations for decision making posts.
@@Solo-hf7fr exactly. We should ask it from the government. Unfortunately, they have not given the data about the population of OBC either. Data is very important to make an opinion and government is trying to hide those data from us.
@@amitattri6942 and what about the discrimination by the so called upper casteist low mentality. Who's gonna end that. A social evil is prevailing in our society for which reservation was demanded to end casteism. The day when the root cause will be eliminated, reservation will end too.
Ye baat m phle hi jaanta tha.. Ye saari cheezein mujhe pta thi.. But aaj FAIZAN MUSTAFA sir ne bhut acchi trh se logon ko samjhaaya h aur shayad logon ko samjh bhi aana chahiye... Hamein bs RIGHT TO EDUCATION, RIGHT TO EQUALITY, RIGHT TO INFORMATION.. Jaise rights milein hain.. Reservation ko apni kamyaabi ki seedi nhi bnaani hogi.. Humein society m rhne aur izzat se jeene k liye satta p baithna hoga.. Reservation hta paana naamumkin jaisi baat h kyunki 70% population ko reservation milta h....15 marks km aane se ek naukri nhi milegi lekin dusri naukri m 15 marks jyada aayenge aur selection UR m hi hoga.... Reservation mile to bhi thik nhi mile to bhi koi dikkat nhi.... Jise naukri chahiye wo le k rhega.. Only 15 marks k difference ki wajah se koi apna Destination nhi bdlega....yahan education acchi honi chahiye desh m.. Kyunki poor aaj bhi acchi education haasil nhi kr paate.. Govt. Schools m padte hain.. Jahan quality of education h hi nhi.. Power aise logon k haath m h jo chahte hi nhi ki desh ki samasyaaein solve ho.. Inhi problems se wo apna pet bharte hain.. Govt. Ab ek aayi h jo society ko change kregi.. AAP.. Definitely use jitaao aur ek mauka do.. Taaki wo apne aap ko saabit kr sake.. INDIAN CONSTITUTION n THE FATHER OF INDIAN CONSTITUTION DR. B. R. AMBEDKAR JI ZINDABAD... 😊😊
आप बहुत अच्छे से समझाते हैं। खुदा आपको लंबी उम्र दे इतनी अच्छी तरीके से समझाया और जो आपने यह सीन शुरू की है उसके लिए आपको बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद सर खुदा हाफिज।
sir finally finally i have finished this great video ye thi to 26 mints ki but maine itni bar back kar kar ke dekhi shyd 45 minutes laga ke samajh kar suni bhut bhut bhut maza aya sir seriously ur amazing thnkuuuuuuu soooooo mucchhhhhhh first time i saw u at ravinsh kumar sir's prime time show tqqqqq
आरक्षण नही 90 प्रतिशत जनता के प्रतिनिधित्व की बात होनी चाहिये। आजादी से पहले जाति के कारण एसी एसटी और ओबीसी को जमीन सम्पत्ति और व्यवपार से दूर थे आजादी के बाद बाबा साहेब के पूना पैक्ट के समझौते द्वारा ब्राहम्ण नेतृत्व देश मे वे इस शर्त पर शामिल हुये कि इनको सम्पति शिक्षा और व्यवपार मे विकास के लिये अवसर मिलेगा जो सरकारी शिक्षण संस्था एवं कम्पनी मे आरक्षण की बदौलत विकास का अवसर मिला।पर अब भी समाजिक और आर्थिक आधार पर पिछडे जाति के कारण इनके सभी हक मारे जा रहे है।जाति न होती तो इनका हक न छीना जाता। हक न मारा जाता तो आरक्षण की जरूरत न होता।इसलिये इस देश से पहले जात पात खत्म करनी चाहिये फिर जात पात आधारित आरक्षण स्वतः खत्म हो जायेगे।जनेऊधारी बीमारी की बजाय इलाज को ही खत्म करने की बात करते है।
आदिवासी देश के कितने कैबिनेट स्तर के सचिव है।इनकी देश की सरकारी नौकरिये मे सॅख्या मतलब प्रतिनिधित्व कितनी है।ये भी हर क्षेत्रो मे हजारो जातियो मे क्यो बॅटे हुये है।फिर ये एसी या ओबीसी से अलग कैसे हुये।इनके रहनेवाले ज्यादातर क्षेत्रो को वनक्षेत्र क्यो है।इनके पास खेती की कितनी जमीने मिली है।ये देश की कितनी बडी कम्पनियो के मालिक है।
@@pawankumar-jr1kb यकीन करो , ब्राह्मण और दूसरे सवर्ण कभी भी वर्ण और जाति व्यवस्था को खत्म नही होने देंगे। भविष्य में हम देखेंगे कि जिस तरह से राष्ट्रवाद का सहारा लेकर 370 को हटाया गया और caa को लागू किया गया उसी तरह देशभक्ति और राष्ट्रवाद का सहारा लेकर आरक्षण को भी समाप्त कर दिया जाएगा और जो भी उस वक़्त आरक्षण समाप्त किये जाने का विरोध करेगा उसे एन्टी नेशनल का लेबल चिपका कर चुप करा दिया जाएगा और जो ज्यादा उछल-कूद मचाएंगे उनके लिए फर्जी केस है ही उनको जेल में डालने के लिए। 👍
my sir, Mr sandeep manudhane has said to hear you to understand the legal and constitutional issues. you are very lagal in your view without any bias. thank you sir, a true source of knowledge.
Reservations is inevitable for upliftment of unequal . But those are getting reservation they are getting benefit of this reservation again and again and ultimately they become obstacles for those who have no accessibility to resources in their community itself. Once who got benefit must be excluded so other in their community would get benefit. Sir, how you see this?
Reservations to sc/st is not to uplift them economically but socially. Social discrimination is not bases on a person’s job or bank balance. -_- do IAS/IPS who are SC/ST dont face social discrimination? Are they no called ‘chamars’ etc ? Reservations to sc/st is to be given as long as there is social discrimination based on caste exists. 1st understand reservations before giving your opinions on it -_-.
Thank you very much for awakening us. I belong to schedule caste...I am a government employee ..if I make a small mistake it is highlighted too much but the major mistake of the person belonging to the general category is ignored. This is also a new type of inequality..
Sir I request you to mention those articles on screen when you are explaining that particular article. Sir this series is very helpful...please continue it. THANK YOU
We need these type of neutral web series for other competitive examination specialy for UPSC(CSE) in english language. Amalgamation of FRs, DPSP, SC judgement cases helps us understand various cases more adequately. Thanku sir
Jazakallah ul khairan, Sir Your videos are finest example of your service towards society. Please make video for the recent supreme court's decision on making a larger bench for harmonising between cultural, religious and individual right.
shatter gee Sabhi to wahi hai cabinet secretary ....SC judge inme 1 bhi SC nahi hai hai... DU professor Every top position..... SC ST get discriminated during promotion.....
shatter gee 15% IAS bante hai SC ke upsc se... Seniority se promotion hoke 15% cabinet secretary hone chahiye SC ke.....lekin 1 bhi cabinet secretary nahi hai SC ka.... Everyone knows and its well documented that SC get dicriminated during promotion but matter of D fact people dont want to accept it because of their political reasons
shatter gee you sound like hitler nazisum....😀😀 Bramhans were racists ....bramhan are racist ...and they will be racist.... Bramhans metained their hegemony through political outfit ....holding key position promote only their bramhan frat....and suppressing other OBC SC ST.....
shatter gee just like Dronacharya didn't allow Eklavya to learn .... And Ram killed Shambhuk just because. """ Dalit cant be intellectual in eamrajya""" Stretigicaly Bramhan maintain their hegemony......
Very nice initiative to educate people... Waise v bahot logo ke pass legal awareness bahot km hai,, i think article aur constitution ka basic part school level se hi padhay jana chaiye... Love you so much sir for spreading legal awareness...
Dr Faijan Mustafa Sir, you are learned and wise man. Please find out a solution of recruitment of judges in judiciary because one particular class occupies larger representation in it. There should be proportionate representation in judiciary. The poor must approach judiciary easily. Presently it is impossible to approach to get the justice. When live to right is fundamental principle, justice also must be a fundamental right.
Real problem is people like him are diminishing day by day and the intellects Belonging to diff pol. Parties cannot be trusted. Knowledge of such a great level where things are put to most genuine and lucid manner is almost impossible to find. Hatts off to you sir.
Dear Sir As we all know that in our country if someone get defeat in District Court, he/she moves to High court, if he/she capable. If he/she defeat in High Court, he/she moves towards Apex Court. Only incapable person easily accept the court decisions. The matter is that slowly and gradually people capabilities increase day by day that's why in upcoming time period supreme court will get more cases and workload will be definately increase. So please think about two things, first one is : Set a proper limitations or boundaries where the decisions of lower court will be final in most of matter, or Second Option is : Increase the number's of supreme court area wise as separate for North East, South etc.
thank you so much sir .. Reservation me efficiency kaise effect hoti hai.. is par aapki video ka inzaar hai.. Thank you so much again for this fabulous video...
रिजर्वेशन जरूर मिले जिसको उसकी जरूरत है , अगर किसी को रिजर्वेशन से नौकरी मिली तो उसको प्रमोशन में रिजर्वशन ना मिले, 130 करोड़ लोग है सबको उपर उठने का लिए रिजर्वेशन को सही से देना चाहिए| अगर किसी को एक बार रिजर्वेशन मिलता है किसी लेवल पर फिर उसको नहीं बल्कि किसी और को मिलना चाहिए| सही से रिजर्वेशन देने होंगे|
धन्यवाद सर,,इन सब विवादित मुद्दों पर कभी कोई सीधी बात नही करता ,,हिंदी अखबारों,न्यूज़ चैनल में भी नही।।इसपर संवैधानिकता और संविधान की मूलभावना आप ही समझा सकते हैं
जब संविधान में साफ-साफ लिखा है कि अनुसूचित जाति के समाज की आर्थिक और इकोनामिक कमजोरी को दूर करने के लिए अलग से व्यवस्था की जाए फिर क्यों ऐसा होता है क्योंकि न्याय विभाग पर एक ही जाति का कब्जा है
Reservation (affirmative action) is extremely important for ensuring substantive equality, although (arguably) it can compromise efficiency and merit. In the same capitation fees also compromise efficiency and merit. But that is taken almost as a fundamental right that the rich can pay capitation fees to get their sons and daughters admitted to engineering and medical colleges. On grounds of efficiency and merit has that been ever challenged? Perhaps, Prof. Mustafa can explain whether this has ever been challenged in our nation's history?
I am not against 'genuine' reservation but when it comes to entrance exams then these things impact a student who is just about to step into the real world. How fair it is that because of reservation, general candidates get rejected at a cut off on which a reserved category student gets elected!! How can these exams claim to select on merit when a candidate much below merit gets a seat. How do you console your child whom you see drowning in a flood of grief every day!!! How do you select on the basis of reservation when a less meritorious candidate coming from a rich background shows a certificate of reservation and becomes eligible for admission!! Reservation based on caste, religion, gender, domicile!!!??? How much more?! Where will those general candidates go? You belong to a section of lawmakers, you are teaching the future lawmakers..... how do you resolve this paradox sir?! Life comes to a standstill after every such result and when you know this is not the end...generation after generation will question, fight and then give in!! Those who are marginalised must get reservation but not on the basis of cut off, rather their fees should be exempted completely. Let the dent be felt by the government, not the young students!!!
जो पिक्चर आप इस्तमाल कर रहे हैं वो रिजर्वेशन के खिलाफ नजर आती है जो ठीक नही है। सच्चर समिति की रिपोर्ट से आप ये समझ सकते है किस प्रकार इस देश के भ्रष्ट लोग जाति के आधार पर कार्य करते है और अपनी ही जाति के समर्थन में कार्य करते हैं
@@AJABGAJABCOLOR इस पिक्चर में सभी समान डिग्री धारक व् समान दौड़ में है जो गलत है दलित ओबीसी समाज को सरकार में प्राथमिकता नही मिली उदाहरण इसी से लें की सेंट्रल यूनिवर्सिटी में 1 भी प्रो ओबीसी नही है
@ajay ये संविधान को लागू करने की बात नही कर रहे हैं बात ये है कि संविधान क्यो है क्या है किस लिए बस। कैसे लागू किया गया उसमें क्या परिणाम रहा इस पर बात नही करी। वेसे इनके काफी विडियो को देख चुका हूं ये बहुत ही अच्छी जानकारी देते हैं
Detailed study should be done which elaborate in detail about backwardness whether (Educational/Economic/Social),then on these reservation should be given.It will solve the reservation issue completely.
I'm Raja the king. But I totally condemned the decision of our Honorable Supreme Court. I'm crying. Jab Raja dukh hota hai janta dukh hota hai. JAB JANTA DUKH HOTA HAI RAJA rota hai. Kabhi kabhi Mar bhi jaata hai.
@@niteshkumar-fz9hu ku bhaii mere village me sabse jyda land to dalit bhaii ka hai or gupta ka hamlog ye land ke chakkar me nhi rahte islea fir Uttrakhand aa gye padhne ke liye ..aise mai bihar ka rahne wala tha
Sir I want to seek your attention here, research which was carried out by prof Ashwini Deshpande and thomas weiskopff in 2014, title of research is "does affirmative action policy affect productivity in railways" it states that reservation policy does not affect the productivity and rural poor dalit are major beneficiaries of the reservation, it is said by higher caste Hindus that efficiency disturbs due to reservation but it is not true on the contrary reserved candidates are much efficient than UR candidates because they have been stigmatized that u entered through reservation policy therefore they have pressure over them and they work hard.
but affirmative action acc to to article 14 and 16 should have time limit too otherwise it is reverse discriminication sir in nagraj case reservation issue was for prpmotion ,not for initial recruitment as you have pointed out in video
Thanks sir I first saw you on ndtv at Ravishs show. After that I started liking your thoughts which are very clear and conceptual. Sir , My friend who belongs to scheduled caste class 1 officer was denied promotion with some of his fellow sc candidates despite having good credentials. And those from upper hindu caste were promoted this was very disgusting for me . Sir what do you think about promotion in reservation ??
No it will not...if proportional representation is guven then the upper caste will cry because they are by proportion very less but in services they dominate. Also SC will not do so..because it negates right to equality. Reservation is for providing fair chance to those who are depressed
Hatts off .. sir u have very well explained d matter of reservation...But narrow minds can't understand.. Ever..
Thanks sir...you atleast heard to me
true
Very very good mustafa
I have learnt more from teachers on youtube than i learnt from school or college.
Some credits goto Anil Ambani and Digital India Mission i. e. NaMo
@@realnileshpawar qqqa
NOTHING CAN BE AS BRILLIANT AS THIS ONE TO SIMPLIFY RESERVATION ISSUE. great WORK !!!
Sir, i am big fan of you. And a student of your RUclips platform. Sir, you are giving us vast knowledge at no price at all. if i weigh the knowledge you gave us with price, even mukesh ambani will become poor.
Very straight forward and deep knowledge lectures.
Thank you sir.
Sir, thanks for explaining the act in detail. India needs Prof. like you. God bless you.🙏
Dr. Faizan Mustafa great fan of you , a personal request if you post a video in Hindi can you provide English subtitles as non Hindi speakers can also watch them . Thank you
Yes
Please request on Faizan Mustafa Aap
He can provide
saleh mabni thanks I will. Check
72 hoor yup they did !
Sir, my father is a govt employee and I also have quite good enough experience of interviews. The caste prejudices still exist deep in the system. With reservations there exists preferential promotions and that is we see only high caste men in secretariat. Without reservations no one of lower cast will ever get an entry let alone being promoted.
Then why government didn't revealed the data for urban SECC (Socio economic caste census)?
@@Solo-hf7fr because the govt BJP or Cong do not want cast concious people who will then endanger the undeclared high cast reservations for decision making posts.
@@Solo-hf7fr exactly. We should ask it from the government. Unfortunately, they have not given the data about the population of OBC either. Data is very important to make an opinion and government is trying to hide those data from us.
Manzoor Athar , correct the cast to caste.
Now you know why we need merit based systems only.
Fuck the reservation
@@amitattri6942 and what about the discrimination by the so called upper casteist low mentality. Who's gonna end that. A social evil is prevailing in our society for which reservation was demanded to end casteism. The day when the root cause will be eliminated, reservation will end too.
first time in life came to know the meanings of formal and substantive... thanks sir
Ye baat m phle hi jaanta tha.. Ye saari cheezein mujhe pta thi.. But aaj FAIZAN MUSTAFA sir ne bhut acchi trh se logon ko samjhaaya h aur shayad logon ko samjh bhi aana chahiye... Hamein bs RIGHT TO EDUCATION, RIGHT TO EQUALITY, RIGHT TO INFORMATION.. Jaise rights milein hain.. Reservation ko apni kamyaabi ki seedi nhi bnaani hogi.. Humein society m rhne aur izzat se jeene k liye satta p baithna hoga.. Reservation hta paana naamumkin jaisi baat h kyunki 70% population ko reservation milta h....15 marks km aane se ek naukri nhi milegi lekin dusri naukri m 15 marks jyada aayenge aur selection UR m hi hoga.... Reservation mile to bhi thik nhi mile to bhi koi dikkat nhi.... Jise naukri chahiye wo le k rhega.. Only 15 marks k difference ki wajah se koi apna Destination nhi bdlega....yahan education acchi honi chahiye desh m.. Kyunki poor aaj bhi acchi education haasil nhi kr paate.. Govt. Schools m padte hain.. Jahan quality of education h hi nhi.. Power aise logon k haath m h jo chahte hi nhi ki desh ki samasyaaein solve ho.. Inhi problems se wo apna pet bharte hain.. Govt. Ab ek aayi h jo society ko change kregi.. AAP.. Definitely use jitaao aur ek mauka do.. Taaki wo apne aap ko saabit kr sake.. INDIAN CONSTITUTION n THE FATHER OF INDIAN CONSTITUTION DR. B. R. AMBEDKAR JI ZINDABAD... 😊😊
Sir feeling glad to watch you on RUclips. I am your fan. Your articles in Hindu newspaper are very fruitful for UPSC aspirants.
आप बहुत अच्छे से समझाते हैं। खुदा आपको लंबी उम्र दे इतनी अच्छी तरीके से समझाया और जो आपने यह सीन शुरू की है उसके लिए आपको बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद सर खुदा हाफिज।
Dr. Mustafa, absolutely make these at technical as you’d like. We need that first on a high level everything is clear.
I am very fortunate that still we have great law scholar like you Sir who give clear explaination with any fear. Your name should be Fearless Mustafa.
sir finally finally i have finished this great video ye thi to 26 mints ki but maine itni bar back kar kar ke dekhi shyd 45 minutes laga ke samajh kar suni bhut bhut bhut maza aya sir seriously ur amazing thnkuuuuuuu soooooo mucchhhhhhh first time i saw u at ravinsh kumar sir's prime time show tqqqqq
आरक्षण नही 90 प्रतिशत जनता के प्रतिनिधित्व की बात होनी चाहिये। आजादी से पहले जाति के कारण एसी एसटी और ओबीसी को जमीन सम्पत्ति और व्यवपार से दूर थे आजादी के बाद बाबा साहेब के पूना पैक्ट के समझौते द्वारा ब्राहम्ण नेतृत्व देश मे वे इस शर्त पर शामिल हुये कि इनको सम्पति शिक्षा और व्यवपार मे विकास के लिये अवसर मिलेगा जो सरकारी शिक्षण संस्था एवं कम्पनी मे आरक्षण की बदौलत विकास का अवसर मिला।पर अब भी समाजिक और आर्थिक आधार पर पिछडे जाति के कारण इनके सभी हक मारे जा रहे है।जाति न होती तो इनका हक न छीना जाता। हक न मारा जाता तो आरक्षण की जरूरत न होता।इसलिये इस देश से पहले जात पात खत्म करनी चाहिये फिर जात पात आधारित आरक्षण स्वतः खत्म हो जायेगे।जनेऊधारी बीमारी की बजाय इलाज को ही खत्म करने की बात करते है।
आदिवासी देश के कितने कैबिनेट स्तर के सचिव है।इनकी देश की सरकारी नौकरिये मे सॅख्या मतलब प्रतिनिधित्व कितनी है।ये भी हर क्षेत्रो मे हजारो जातियो मे क्यो बॅटे हुये है।फिर ये एसी या ओबीसी से अलग कैसे हुये।इनके रहनेवाले ज्यादातर क्षेत्रो को वनक्षेत्र क्यो है।इनके पास खेती की कितनी जमीने मिली है।ये देश की कितनी बडी कम्पनियो के मालिक है।
@@pawankumar-jr1kb यकीन करो , ब्राह्मण और दूसरे सवर्ण कभी भी वर्ण और जाति व्यवस्था को खत्म नही होने देंगे।
भविष्य में हम देखेंगे कि जिस तरह से राष्ट्रवाद का सहारा लेकर 370 को हटाया गया और caa को लागू किया गया उसी तरह देशभक्ति और राष्ट्रवाद का सहारा लेकर आरक्षण को भी समाप्त कर दिया जाएगा और जो भी उस वक़्त आरक्षण समाप्त किये जाने का विरोध करेगा उसे एन्टी नेशनल का लेबल चिपका कर चुप करा दिया जाएगा और जो ज्यादा उछल-कूद मचाएंगे उनके लिए फर्जी केस है ही उनको जेल में डालने के लिए। 👍
my sir, Mr sandeep manudhane has said to hear you to understand the legal and constitutional issues.
you are very lagal in your view without any bias. thank you sir, a true source of knowledge.
السلام علیکم
Sir aap ne bhot achche tareeke se samjhaya hai..... 🌹 🌹 🌹 🌹 🌹 🌹 🌹 Shukriya sir
Wow! Love your talks sir! Big fan & admirer. Loved your take on substantive equality!
No reservation. End reservation. To save India🇮🇳.
End Brahminism
@@awaazindia499 End dirty islaam.
Faizan sir ji, very informative video sir
U r absolutely correct
Excellently explained
Good 👌👍
Great!
From ur analysis, we come to know who have merits. We also know that the supreme Court judges come from a Gali n not on merits.
Very good explanation
सर भारी भरकम अंग्रेजी शब्दो का अर्थ हिंदी में भी बताया करे
Kyon padhna likhna Nahin Aata
Respected Sir ,You are really so genuine person .I am also Student of Constitution .so thanks for Such nice interpretation of Constitution
..so thanks
कांलेजियम खत्म होना चाहिए सर्व समाज की भागीदारी सुनस्ची
त होनी चाहिए
Sir i like this video very much
* सर , आपके वीडियो विषयवस्तु व प्रस्तुति की दृष्टि से शानदार है ।
Reservations is inevitable for upliftment of unequal . But those are getting reservation they are getting benefit of this reservation again and again and ultimately they become obstacles for those who have no accessibility to resources in their community itself. Once who got benefit must be excluded so other in their community would get benefit. Sir, how you see this?
sunil kumar
Any stats for again and again ?
I am an epidemiologist by training.
Don’t give me any BS reason.
Reservations to sc/st is not to uplift them economically but socially. Social discrimination is not bases on a person’s job or bank balance.
-_- do IAS/IPS who are SC/ST dont face social discrimination? Are they no called ‘chamars’ etc ?
Reservations to sc/st is to be given as long as there is social discrimination based on caste exists. 1st understand reservations before giving your opinions on it -_-.
@@gamingsingh4004 agar ias ips banne ke baad bhi discrimination ho hi rha he then reservation is a failure. koi dusra law hona chahiye
Thank you very much for awakening us. I belong to schedule caste...I am a government employee ..if I make a small mistake it is highlighted too much but the major mistake of the person belonging to the general category is ignored. This is also a new type of inequality..
Yes bro
Discrimination will never end in india
Government employee kaam bhi karte hai kya
Sir I request you to mention those articles on screen when you are explaining that particular article.
Sir this series is very helpful...please continue it.
THANK YOU
Resp.Sir your language is lucid and as a student i find your lectures extremely helpful
सुप्रीम कोर्ट का ये मनुवादी सोच से प्रेरित फैसला नक्सली बनने ओर गृहयुद्ध करने के लिए उकसाता है लाल सलाम
vaibhav gond tu Mat ban Jana naxali warna yeh sarkar goli Marr degi. Mehnat kar reservation se kuch aagey bad
We need these type of neutral web series for other competitive examination specialy for UPSC(CSE) in english language. Amalgamation of FRs, DPSP, SC judgement cases helps us understand various cases more adequately. Thanku sir
बेहतरीन टेक्निकल विश्लेषण
I salute you and your efforts ,definitely we will be able to save our and our people rights
Explanation is merely correct but we can't deny equality of status and opportunity and also in representations.
👍👍
Amazing explaination ... thanks a lot respected sir
सर जी , आप upsc के लिए संविधान पर कुछ पुस्तकें लिखिए।
j N pandey जैसी।
ROHIT KUMAR jai hind bhai Panday ( Brahmin) ka samvidhan bhi manusmariti jaisa hi hoga
@@AbhijeetSinghs chutiya castism ka promoter h tu
Jazakallah ul khairan,
Sir Your videos are finest example of your service towards society.
Please make video for the recent supreme court's decision on making a larger bench for harmonising between cultural, religious and individual right.
Best teacher because of detailed explain with truth☺☺☺
Sir your view very important thanks for awareness with bravely
Wonderful descussion
Keep it up!
Jay Bhim
Jay bharat
Ccompetive ,
You are literate, domination position ..
Power not to re flex on society.
Man ki baat.
Only Bramhan have exclusive fundamental right to top position .....
Manuwadi BJP régime
shatter gee
Sabhi to wahi hai cabinet secretary ....SC judge inme 1 bhi SC nahi hai hai...
DU professor
Every top position.....
SC ST get discriminated during promotion.....
shatter gee
15% IAS bante hai SC ke upsc se...
Seniority se promotion hoke 15% cabinet secretary hone chahiye SC ke.....lekin 1 bhi cabinet secretary nahi hai SC ka....
Everyone knows and its well documented that SC get dicriminated during promotion but matter of D fact people dont want to accept it because of their political reasons
shatter gee
Bro 22% SC ST hold only 4% of economics share
While 3% bramhans hold 35% of economic share
Well documented but no one cares
shatter gee you sound like hitler nazisum....😀😀 Bramhans were racists ....bramhan are racist ...and they will be racist....
Bramhans metained their hegemony through political outfit ....holding key position promote only their bramhan frat....and suppressing other OBC SC ST.....
shatter gee just like Dronacharya didn't allow Eklavya to learn ....
And Ram killed Shambhuk just because. """ Dalit cant be intellectual in eamrajya"""
Stretigicaly Bramhan maintain their hegemony......
Very Nice Analysis ...liked it very much 👌👌👌
Very nice initiative to educate people... Waise v bahot logo ke pass legal awareness bahot km hai,, i think article aur constitution ka basic part school level se hi padhay jana chaiye... Love you so much sir for spreading legal awareness...
Hello I am an alumni of National Law University Odisha, your lecture reminds me of our Constitution law faculty Uday Raj Rai Sir
Dr Faijan Mustafa Sir, you are learned and wise man. Please find out a solution of recruitment of judges in judiciary because one particular class occupies larger representation in it. There should be proportionate representation in judiciary. The poor must approach judiciary easily. Presently it is impossible to approach to get the justice. When live to right is fundamental principle, justice also must be a fundamental right.
Real problem is people like him are diminishing day by day and the intellects Belonging to diff pol. Parties cannot be trusted.
Knowledge of such a great level where things are put to most genuine and lucid manner is almost impossible to find.
Hatts off to you sir.
Thank you so much sir for excellent information of judgments in simple language
Thanks for awareness. Most of people don't understand that they are puppet of power people.
Dear Sir
As we all know that in our country if someone get defeat in District Court, he/she moves to High court, if he/she capable. If he/she defeat in High Court, he/she moves towards Apex Court. Only incapable person easily accept the court decisions. The matter is that slowly and gradually people capabilities increase day by day that's why in upcoming time period supreme court will get more cases and workload will be definately increase. So please think about two things, first one is : Set a proper limitations or boundaries where the decisions of lower court will be final in most of matter, or Second Option is : Increase the number's of supreme court area wise as separate for North East, South etc.
Thank you sir Great information and great work
thank you so much sir ..
Reservation me efficiency kaise effect hoti hai.. is par aapki video ka inzaar hai..
Thank you so much again for this fabulous video...
Very nice video I like it very much.
रिजर्वेशन जरूर मिले जिसको उसकी जरूरत है , अगर किसी को रिजर्वेशन से नौकरी मिली तो उसको प्रमोशन में रिजर्वशन ना मिले, 130 करोड़ लोग है सबको उपर उठने का लिए रिजर्वेशन को सही से देना चाहिए|
अगर किसी को एक बार रिजर्वेशन मिलता है किसी लेवल पर फिर उसको नहीं बल्कि किसी और को मिलना चाहिए|
सही से रिजर्वेशन देने होंगे|
Right
Very good analysis. Thanks.
last 6 minutes was like a climax of a great movie itna acha tha cant explain sir love uuu
So lucid and helpful for civil service preparation. Great sir keep up.
धन्यवाद सर,,इन सब विवादित मुद्दों पर कभी कोई सीधी बात नही करता ,,हिंदी अखबारों,न्यूज़ चैनल में भी नही।।इसपर संवैधानिकता और संविधान की मूलभावना आप ही समझा सकते हैं
जब संविधान में साफ-साफ लिखा है कि अनुसूचित जाति के समाज की आर्थिक और इकोनामिक कमजोरी को दूर करने के लिए अलग से व्यवस्था की जाए फिर क्यों ऐसा होता है
क्योंकि न्याय विभाग पर एक ही जाति का कब्जा है
I m eagerly waiting for ur next video on reservation.. Thank u for this applaudable video..
बहुत ही अच्छी जनकारी दी है साहब जी
Hypocrasy of Judicial verdict
Pahle hipocracy ki spelling to seekh le
@@OmprakashSharma-bs8ql tere ko acchey se aati hai 😅😅😅😂😂😂...... sanghi ....hip..... uss ne toh shuruvat sahi ki ...hyp
@@lifeforever1665 abe bewkoof naam dekh k sanghi bol rhe ho shame on you
Brahman atankwadi judge chor
@@rajunayakb.r7158 bro u r true face of cast based reservation
Great explanation regarding reservation Sir .
Reservation (affirmative action) is extremely important for ensuring substantive equality, although (arguably) it can compromise efficiency and merit.
In the same capitation fees also compromise efficiency and merit. But that is taken almost as a fundamental right that the rich can pay capitation fees to get their sons and daughters admitted to engineering and medical colleges. On grounds of efficiency and merit has that been ever challenged? Perhaps, Prof. Mustafa can explain whether this has ever been challenged in our nation's history?
I am not against 'genuine' reservation but when it comes to entrance exams then these things impact a student who is just about to step into the real world. How fair it is that because of reservation, general candidates get rejected at a cut off on which a reserved category student gets elected!! How can these exams claim to select on merit when a candidate much below merit gets a seat. How do you console your child whom you see drowning in a flood of grief every day!!! How do you select on the basis of reservation when a less meritorious candidate coming from a rich background shows a certificate of reservation and becomes eligible for admission!! Reservation based on caste, religion, gender, domicile!!!??? How much more?! Where will those general candidates go? You belong to a section of lawmakers, you are teaching the future lawmakers..... how do you resolve this paradox sir?! Life comes to a standstill after every such result and when you know this is not the end...generation after generation will question, fight and then give in!! Those who are marginalised must get reservation but not on the basis of cut off, rather their fees should be exempted completely. Let the dent be felt by the government, not the young students!!!
Great awareness sir
जो पिक्चर आप इस्तमाल कर रहे हैं वो रिजर्वेशन के खिलाफ नजर आती है
जो ठीक नही है। सच्चर समिति की रिपोर्ट से आप ये समझ सकते है किस प्रकार इस देश के भ्रष्ट लोग जाति के आधार पर कार्य करते है और अपनी ही जाति के समर्थन में कार्य करते हैं
Right
@@mr.tushar6875 right
नही बिल्कुल नही बल्कि इन्होंने बिल्कुल साफ साफ पक्ष और विपक्ष की बात की है।
@@AJABGAJABCOLOR इस पिक्चर में सभी समान डिग्री धारक व् समान दौड़ में है जो गलत है दलित ओबीसी समाज को सरकार में प्राथमिकता नही मिली
उदाहरण इसी से लें की सेंट्रल यूनिवर्सिटी में 1 भी प्रो ओबीसी नही है
@ajay ये संविधान को लागू करने की बात नही कर रहे हैं
बात ये है कि संविधान क्यो है क्या है किस लिए बस।
कैसे लागू किया गया उसमें क्या परिणाम रहा इस पर बात नही करी।
वेसे इनके काफी विडियो को देख चुका हूं ये बहुत ही अच्छी जानकारी देते हैं
Hatts of sir! Big fan of u... Always given 360degree view of any issue
One request sir
If possible please attach pdf of video lecture in written
....reservations..reservations :
".....fariyaad kiye jaa ay akbar."
{....kudos FAIZAN SAAB,
TRY-TRY-TILL-YOU-SUCCEED.}
Reservation ka kya karo gai jab
Govt ,goverment jobs cut kar rahi hai 😂😂😂😂
The picture in background says everything
देश की सर्वोच्च न्याय पंचायत का आरक्षण के संबंध में सराहनीय एवं ऐतिहासिक फैसला इस निर्णय की जितनी तारीफ़ किया जाए उतनी ही कम है।
Which one is not fundamental right
1- Right to education
2- RTI
3- Right to life
4-Right to speech
Thank you sir... For very important information and I'm waiting for all reservation series... Very very thanks
Detailed study should be done which elaborate in detail about backwardness whether (Educational/Economic/Social),then on these reservation should be given.It will solve the reservation issue completely.
यह वीडियो काफी है रिजर्वेशन को समझने के लिए ।
Nice विश्लेषण
Thankyou sir. Thanks a lot .
May God bless you.
I'm Preparing for competitive exams. Your videos are very helpful. Thank you sir.
I'm Raja the king. But I totally condemned the decision of our Honorable Supreme Court.
I'm crying.
Jab Raja dukh hota hai janta dukh hota hai.
JAB JANTA DUKH HOTA HAI RAJA rota hai. Kabhi kabhi Mar bhi jaata hai.
Economic condition should be the only criteria for reservation.This will definitely help in reducing social tension and conflict.
Wrong
@@humanitylover2156 how wrong plz explain dont just throw and go
gautam basu jab bhi train me travel karta hu koi na koi jaat zarur puchta he
Bahut bahut dhaynbad sir ji
Wah sir aapka analysis shandar hota hai 👌👌👌👌👌👌
Very nice sir we proud of u ...
it is the plain of brahmin judge to abolition of reservation
Kab tak muft me khoge..kavi hardworking se compete karo exam me
singh unequal society me competition nahi hota h
@@bittubhardwaj685 land ka distribution equal karo
@@niteshkumar-fz9hu ku bhaii mere village me sabse jyda land to dalit bhaii ka hai or gupta ka hamlog ye land ke chakkar me nhi rahte islea fir Uttrakhand aa gye padhne ke liye ..aise mai bihar ka rahne wala tha
victor singh muft ka to tum logo ne khaya he hazaro saalo se
Tukde karna he shyad tumhe desh ka
Very nicely and clearly articulated sir.
Sir I want to seek your attention here, research which was carried out by prof Ashwini Deshpande and thomas weiskopff in 2014, title of research is "does affirmative action policy affect productivity in railways" it states that reservation policy does not affect the productivity and rural poor dalit are major beneficiaries of the reservation, it is said by higher caste Hindus that efficiency disturbs due to reservation but it is not true on the contrary reserved candidates are much efficient than UR candidates because they have been stigmatized that u entered through reservation policy therefore they have pressure over them and they work hard.
PSA mean public Safety act. what happened in 2010 with Bar Council Chairman. for which he detentes in 2019
Your video is very informative 👍
Thanks sir you have defined very well
but affirmative action acc to to article 14 and 16 should have time limit too otherwise it is reverse discriminication
sir in nagraj case reservation issue was for prpmotion ,not for initial recruitment as you have pointed out in video
Thanks sir
I first saw you on ndtv at Ravishs show. After that I started liking your thoughts which are very clear and conceptual.
Sir , My friend who belongs to scheduled caste class 1 officer was denied promotion with some of his fellow sc candidates despite having good credentials. And those from upper hindu caste were promoted this was very disgusting for me .
Sir what do you think about promotion in reservation ??
Bohot achha vislesan
Substituting "reservation" with "proportionate representation" as was the case in J&K Reservation law may be better for public acceptance.
Good point. Public perception is crucial in public perception. In USA there is a term called "affirmative action" - we can use something like that
@@radioactivedetective6876 Thank you.
No it will not...if proportional representation is guven then the upper caste will cry because they are by proportion very less but in services they dominate. Also SC will not do so..because it negates right to equality. Reservation is for providing fair chance to those who are depressed
@@wethepeople1680 Not depressed instead it is repressed.
@@wethepeople1680 That's why I suggested 'affirmative action' as a term
We want to end casteism by reservation 🙏🏻 wah
Excellent sir ,your efforts are defininitely valuable 👍🏻