Does Kinesio Tape Actually Work? | Expert Physio Reviews the Evidence on K-Tape

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 авг 2024
  • In this tutorial, we review the evidence to determine if there is any clinical benefit in using Kinesio tape in the treatment of musculoskeletal conditions.
    References
    *Parreira et al., 2014: doi.org/10.1016/j.jphys.2013....
    *Mostafavifar, Wertz and Borchers, 2012: doi.org/10.3810/psm.2012.11.1986
    *Reneker et al., 2018: doi.org/10.1016/j.ptsp.2017.1...
    *Jarecki et al., 2021: doi.org/10.3390/jcm10132992
    ⭐Clinical Physio Videos of interest:
    *Acupuncture: • Does Acupuncture Work ...
    *Shockwave therapy: • Does Shockwave Therapy...
    ⭐ WEBSITE: www.clinicalphysio.com
    ➡️ Here you can find all our best content including Live Webinars, On-Demand Webinars, Courses and More!!
    ⭐ MEMBERSHIP: member.clinicalphysio.com/mem...
    ➡️ Monthly subscription, cancel anytime, access to all our best content including Live Webinars, On-Demand Webinars, Courses and More!
    ⭐ INSTAGRAM: / clinicalphysio
    ➡️ For Daily Quizzes and Superb Content!
    ⭐ SUBSCRIBE TO OUR RUclips: / @clinicalphysio

Комментарии • 172

  • @mistertdotcom786
    @mistertdotcom786 Год назад +28

    I’m new to K-Tape. Last Thursday April 13, I was on vacation, walking the downtown area of Guadalajara Jal Mexico. I was approached by a man who claimed to be a chiropractor for the Mexican football team “Las Chivas” he suggested I k-tape my knee because he could see I was in pain while walking, I responded by telling him that my problem was actually Plantar Fasciitis, he then suggested I take my shoes and socks off because in his kit he happened to have K-Tape. I was very suspicious of this man and his intentions, but being that I was safe in a group, in the middle of a very busy place I allowed him to tape my foot. Now I had been in severe pain for about 3 years and had recently made an appointment to consult the possibility of surgery since my cortisol shot had not worked. Well here I am 4 days later April 17, looking up why K-tape works so well. I Can honestly say I have zero pain and am enjoying walking like I did 3 years ago. I wish I could find this man to thank him.

  • @laura1962ism
    @laura1962ism Год назад +65

    I'm just one opinion, but whether it's a perceived benefit or real benefit, I know when my knee, lower back and neck and shoulders are taped they do not have as much pain. If it's just my mind, I'm okay with that because opioid only work on your mind also, so I would rather be dependent on Ktape than the other option.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад +8

      There’s no problem with that at all Laura! Most importantly I’m glad to hear it’s going well when you use it!

    • @123sisters
      @123sisters Год назад +3

      Exactly! It shows the power of our minds in healing. Placebo effect is the proof that what we believe in is very important and manifests into real life.

    • @rushodai929
      @rushodai929 Год назад

      Laura I feel the same. Also, for me, a lot of times the tape is a physical reminder to go a little easier on the affected area. Aka-you’re hurt, don’t make it worse.

    • @aztkdiva
      @aztkdiva Год назад +1

      I feel the same and my mother does too. Mind you, she was against us taping her because she had never heard of it and didn’t understand how it worked. But after going through physical therapy that did not help her, a few weeks of ktaping and she was feeling better. So now she swears by it. Placebo affect? Maybe or maybe not. Whatever it was, it gave her, her mobility back.

    • @caroltaylor4942
      @caroltaylor4942 8 месяцев назад

      Ps, the relief and support KT tape provides is not a placebo effect.

  • @lillticky
    @lillticky Год назад +15

    I use KT for my wrist injury and it has helped significantly with pain. Whether it's a placebo or not I don't see the problem, it's working and that's all I care about. I don't get when people shut down placebos if it works.

    • @OxysLokiMoros
      @OxysLokiMoros 7 месяцев назад

      It's actually a nocebo if you work a lot with passive Treatments

  • @ph4t88
    @ph4t88 Год назад +3

    Love the content. You where the only RUclipsr I found talking about studies in regards of KT 🙏

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      😊😊🙏🏼🙏🏼 Thank you so much! Glad it was useful!

  • @samiulamin2159
    @samiulamin2159 2 года назад +7

    This is an amazing watch, amazing review and well balanced! Thank you for help clearing up a big misconception in the PT world. Would love to see similar videos on mobs and Manips (the popular cracking stuff) and also the scraping that seems to be a trend also

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  2 года назад +1

      Thank you so much for your kind words! Will do our best!

  • @ahmedel-zayat3561
    @ahmedel-zayat3561 2 года назад +19

    This channel is a goldmine! Please never stop what you're doing ❤

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  2 года назад

      Thank you so much for your kind words 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

    • @wenhuiliu5893
      @wenhuiliu5893 Месяц назад

      ​@@ClinicalPhysio I completely agree

  • @aboodfaris966
    @aboodfaris966 2 года назад +17

    Honestly I've never seen a physiotherapist like you great work great job fantastic review everything is just perfect...keep it up

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  2 года назад +3

      Thank you so much for your kind words! Really appreciate your support!

  • @mildziute
    @mildziute 2 года назад +15

    The studies are the strangest thing. I use taping a lot, the perceived comfort after application ranges from “maybe feels better”, to “wow! the pain is gone!”. And for me personally it is a remedy #1 if I have a back pain. I now think the effects fall into the category of influencing the nervous system - providing it with more information from the site as a person moves. Maybe as manual therapy would? I love taping:)

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  2 года назад +2

      Absolutely agree with “influencing the nervous system!”

    • @OxysLokiMoros
      @OxysLokiMoros 7 месяцев назад

      K-Taping is bullshit, like manual therapy, blackrolls, electro therapy, cupping, most passive treatments in general...
      What works is:
      -Education about pain
      -Training(Graded activity etc.)
      -Lifestyle changes(nutrition, activity, sleep, stress)

  • @user-np1pq8po9b
    @user-np1pq8po9b Год назад

    Always great clips, thanks

  • @honuman39
    @honuman39 Год назад +19

    I've been a manual therapist for awhile and I remember when I started seeing k tape. There were courses being taught about how to use it and there were people who were very enthusiastic about its benefits. I couldn't figure out how or why it could possibly have a dramatic impact in performance or healing. The only thought I had that made any sense was that it would provide a sensory reminder of the joint/ muscle being taped so the person could be more aware of proper movement. This video helped confirm it's placebo effect.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад +1

      🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼 glad it helped!

    • @aurelianspodarec2629
      @aurelianspodarec2629 Год назад

      And now you ruined the placebo effect for me xD

    • @OxysLokiMoros
      @OxysLokiMoros 7 месяцев назад

      K-Taping is bullshit, like manual therapy, blackrolls, electro therapy, cupping, most passive treatments in general...
      What works is:
      -Education about pain
      -Training(Graded activity etc.)
      -Lifestyle changes(nutrition, activity, sleep, stress)

  • @Nat-mk7gb
    @Nat-mk7gb 2 года назад +2

    Really good discussion to have 👍🏻

  • @gavinrhodes8474
    @gavinrhodes8474 Год назад

    Trying to recover from a wrist injury and have little clue where to start because of all the conflicting information everywhere, but I'm very thankful for your very informative video about this product! Thank You😁

  • @SunriseTherapySpain
    @SunriseTherapySpain 11 месяцев назад

    Very balance analysis. Can't ignore the psychosomatic effect of any treatment. Cheers !

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  11 месяцев назад

      Thank you so much for your thoughts and kind words!

  • @panagiotiskapodistrias9817
    @panagiotiskapodistrias9817 2 года назад +1

    Really nice, thanks a lot!

  • @bstayings
    @bstayings Год назад

    Excellent lit review!

  • @raghadsalim2069
    @raghadsalim2069 Год назад

    Thank you Dr. Khalid so much, we need review for dry cupping also

  • @johnkapcoe8861
    @johnkapcoe8861 Год назад +5

    I don’t know anything about what other athletes do… but I can say that I ran into a video that suggested it for my Achilles pain… I got it and it immediately felt better. Then I did a search on RUclips and viewed some of the for/against videos and found tons of conflicting info. But, in the end, my Achilles feels much better with it so I will keep using it…

  • @muleimoo
    @muleimoo 2 года назад +5

    Great stuff, thanks! A review of message and/or manual techniques would be valuable too

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  2 года назад +2

      Thank you! It’s on the list!

    • @vasileiospetropoulos2046
      @vasileiospetropoulos2046 2 года назад

      @@ClinicalPhysio including thrust please! Grade 5! Thanks

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  2 года назад +1

      @@vasileiospetropoulos2046 🙏🏼

    • @OxysLokiMoros
      @OxysLokiMoros 7 месяцев назад

      K-Taping is bullshit, like manual therapy, blackrolls, electro therapy, cupping, most passive treatments in general...
      What works is:
      -Education about pain
      -Training(Graded activity etc.)
      -Lifestyle changes(nutrition, activity, sleep, stress)

  • @vasileiospetropoulos2046
    @vasileiospetropoulos2046 2 года назад

    Thanks mate! Thanks!

  • @kaseyhair6779
    @kaseyhair6779 Год назад +7

    I have a very long history of knee injuries and live with general pain, discomfort, and severe crepitus in them both daily...about 1.5 years ago a chiropractor told me about kt tape and i laughed at him, but allowed him to tape my knees...skeptical is an understatement for my thoughts about "a dumb piece of cloth tape", but i left it on like he said...within about 12 hours of wearing it i noticed a small difference in my pain level...when i woke the next morning it was almost a night and day difference...been a believer in it ever since

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад +1

      That’s awesome! I’m very pleased to hear you have had such a benefit from it!

    • @mikhaillastname8719
      @mikhaillastname8719 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@ClinicalPhysio I second that. I had major improvement for my ACL injury, which I treated conservatively (which is generally advised for amateurs). The effect certainly can't be attributed to placebo or superstitions. Not only did it reduce swelling and aching after the activity (football match), but the stability, painless range of motion, etc. during the game also improved significantly. Maybe the same effect could be achieved by using 'athletic tape' (?) but it is certainly better than elastic band or knee supports. I was advised to use K-tape by a sports therapist who works for a top-level football club. I can't imagine that in the area where big money is involved, people rely so heavily on practices that are questionable. (NB. there's a difference from amateurs in that pros usually opt for surgical help in treating knee injuries because maximum performance is of essence, but still K-tape is used extensively for muscular issues). So while KT might not have long-term effects on recovery just the very thing that they reduce pain and improve range of motion in short-term (Mehran Mostafavifar et al.) is very important especially for amateurs doing sports. And i wish you've stressed that more in the video.

  • @SuperNictastic
    @SuperNictastic 11 месяцев назад +6

    I was a massive sceptic about kinesiology tape, I just looked at athletes using it and thought that can't possibly work. Fast forward a few years and I am doing ultra marathons and decided to try it for a dodgy Achilles and knee. It worked. It certainly helped alleviate some of the pain whether that is real or just in the head I dont know but I am a convert.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  11 месяцев назад

      Great news! Glad it’s working for you!

    • @fylbike
      @fylbike 9 месяцев назад +1

      Have to agree, I've laughed at this for years, then, I strained a MCL prior to a cycling holiday and I thought I'd try it out of desperation, applied the tape to 'reinforce' the ligament, using three strips at different angles and....... yes, it helped, support the knee. - Granted only one persons view, but, I'm sold

    • @OxysLokiMoros
      @OxysLokiMoros 7 месяцев назад

      K-Taping is bullshit, like manual therapy, blackrolls, electro therapy, cupping, most passive treatments in general...
      What works is:
      -Education about pain
      -Training(Graded activity etc.)
      -Lifestyle changes(nutrition, activity, sleep, stress)

  • @kabeloramavhoya5004
    @kabeloramavhoya5004 2 года назад +5

    I use KT a lot with the athletes whether as a placebo or for treatment, I usually find that it gives that proprioceptive/tactile input and makes a difference in athletes psychologically, but with swelling and contusion it works magic. Recovery time is shorter

  • @dewabius
    @dewabius Год назад +1

    Indeed, how it works is not known with certainty. But that doesn't mean there's no effect at all because in fact it helps a lot.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      Absolutely! This is what I have confirmed in the video even if the effect is psychological/placebo

  • @caroltaylor4942
    @caroltaylor4942 8 месяцев назад

    I started using KT tape a few years ago due to various injuries and atrophy from undiagnosed injuries from my mid-thoracic spine to my right foot. KT tape has saved me from the years of agony I was dealing with. 80% of the atrophy and pain are gone!! I am able to do more and move better than I have since my devastating car wreck 20 years ago, which also caused a devastating fall several years later. I am so thankful for the inventor of this tape. I thank them from the bottom of my heart!❤❤❤

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  8 месяцев назад

      Hi Carol I’m really glad to hear that it has helped you! Wish you all the best 😊

    • @OxysLokiMoros
      @OxysLokiMoros 7 месяцев назад

      Placebo.
      K-Taping is bullshit, like manual therapy, blackrolls, electro therapy, cupping, most passive treatments in general...
      What works is:
      -Education about pain
      -Training(Graded activity etc.)
      -Lifestyle changes(nutrition, activity, sleep, stress)

  • @nataschamalta4366
    @nataschamalta4366 2 месяца назад

    The point about swelling is definitely worth future exploration! I used it to best effect with a breast cancer survivor to help maintain her lympathics after having some lymph nodes removed, and it was excellent for this use! I also gave a roll to my partner, and he uses it to help manage chronic edema from an ankle injury to good effect. Love your videos, they're so well researched but accessible at the same time.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  2 месяца назад

      Very kind of you thank you! And some fabulous points about swelling! Great to hear of your successes with it

  • @gepardiari8710
    @gepardiari8710 4 месяца назад +1

    Hey Khalid, you gotta use more visuals and b rolls for more retention. Nice video

  • @mkg304
    @mkg304 Год назад +3

    It would be interesting to see if it helps in preventing injury. That seems to be an area where it could be effective.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      Hi! This was part of the research that we went through in the video, have a listen back … the evidence does not suggest it prevents injury

  • @Soggz7785
    @Soggz7785 3 месяца назад

    Hello.
    I find it relieves the pain in my knee, from a bursa sac which has become inflamed, providing it has been put on correctly.
    It lifts the skin off of the bursa sac, so no friction on it.
    All the best.👍🏾🇬🇧

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  3 месяца назад

      Thanks for sharing! I’m glad to hear it helped you!

  • @ValhallaGuild
    @ValhallaGuild 7 месяцев назад +1

    I had k tape because of runners knee and patella tracking problem. It it work! no pain!

  • @neithanm
    @neithanm Год назад +1

    Thank you! As a science person I'm at my wits end when it comes to physiotherapists and their shams: k-taping, dry needling, power balances and on and on. It might've been perfect to mention impact factor but your succint conclusion was spot on. Society needs less bullshit. Thanks a bunch.

  • @adamfeerst2575
    @adamfeerst2575 Год назад +2

    The studies are about preventing injury (presumably in an otherwise healthy athlete), rehab/healing, or improving performance (again in an otherwise healthy athlete). Those don't seem to address how I use it. If I have a strained calf or hamstring, for example, does kinesio tape provide support/protection to allow me to run safely?

  • @dr.shaileshkamble1820
    @dr.shaileshkamble1820 2 года назад

    I really like ur videos.. love u🙂🙂

  • @Asiatranceboy
    @Asiatranceboy Год назад +2

    Thanks for this review. My concern is, now that we know from the evidence that K-tape doesn’t really confer any meaningful clinical benefit, there is an opportunity cost to spending time applying & promoting such less effective treatments, whereas we could be focusing instead on other treatments that have been proven to be more effective.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад +2

      Absolutely my friend - that is always the consideration and you make an excellent point. The best thing you can do is put this idea into your own practice and be the best you want to be 😊👍🏼

    • @gimygaming8655
      @gimygaming8655 Год назад +2

      Unfortunately, I have not found any treatments for constant dislocations due to EDS. So, while it might be pointless, if it helps someone with a chronic illness that they haven't found a viable, cheap solution then go for it

  • @The1Helleri
    @The1Helleri Год назад +2

    My physical therapist put tape on me for my left shoulder (impingement and possible torn tendons from innate hypermobility). There is a notable reduction of pain for me. But I think it's because of the way she put it on. It restricts my mobility slightly. I feel the tug of my skin when my arm is about to move in a way that she recorded causes me the most pain and it cues me to stop moving my arm that way and correct my posture.

  • @dinaguzman120
    @dinaguzman120 Год назад +8

    Hi, I been using the KT for more that 13 year, my chiropractor recommend for me for my back pain and work. I never have to use pills. Everybody is different. When you use something you have to believe too. Some people prefer medication that have secondary effects.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      Thank you so much for your thoughts!

    • @1MaximusDecimusMeridius1
      @1MaximusDecimusMeridius1 Год назад

      Personally- I use both as needed. They’re both effective.

    • @mrvikingsfan8498
      @mrvikingsfan8498 Год назад

      If something works you don't have to believe it for it to actually work, can't believe those words actually came out of your mouth. That's ridiculous. What you're describing is a placebo effect.

  • @jeffd8465
    @jeffd8465 10 месяцев назад

    For my calf ktape seemed to help me by holding things so they wouldn't jiggle as I walked give the muscles time to cool down. It also gave me the feedback to help cancel out the pain I had since the tape felt like it was hugging that area.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  10 месяцев назад +1

      That’s great! Glad to hear it helped you!

  • @vaishnavidhumal5165
    @vaishnavidhumal5165 Год назад +1

    I really want to do some research on kinesio taping can you suggest what should I do

  • @taralets5386
    @taralets5386 Год назад +2

    THANK YOU! This is my opinion ever since I used K tape back in 2000. It is all about psychological effect that people keeps on using the tape. I play basketball and K taping has no effect in any ways. It is just for looks or even design into your body. Once you use it, your mind will tell you that the tape is working? I don’t think so!

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад +1

      Thank you for your message! Wishing you all the best with your basketball 👍🏼

  • @tracy2762
    @tracy2762 Год назад

    what about copper infused tape? i have had good results with copper infused wraps.

  • @skylaralexander-brown9515
    @skylaralexander-brown9515 Год назад +1

    The evidence in helping with swelling makes sense as to why it helps my knee. I've had a lifelong injury and I hear about k tape. Naturally, I looked at studies and saw that there was no evidence (at the time) that it worked for anything. I have a lifelong injury from childhood and I've always been desperate for any help with swelling and pain, so I decided just to try it and see. It actually helps my knee a lot. Braces never worked for me. Now that I think a out the swelling correlation, my knee doesn't swell as much, or at all when I wear the tape. I can't take nsaids that actually help with my pain, so the k tape is a life saver for me. I often wondered if it was a placebo effect, but it helps, so I don't question it.
    For my shoulder issues, my physical therapist uses it as a reminder to patients about posture or whatever they need to focus on for recovery, and that's helpful too.

    • @skylaralexander-brown9515
      @skylaralexander-brown9515 Год назад

      Thank you for this video! It was very informative ☺️

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      @@skylaralexander-brown9515 you’re very welcome!

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад +1

      Hi Skylar! Thank you so much for sharing your story - more than anything I’m so pleased to hear that you feel it is helping you, which is the most important thing!

  • @DeepikaAditya
    @DeepikaAditya Год назад

    I like the colours

  • @muuubiee
    @muuubiee Год назад

    Just started to try to use it to help with posture.
    Are there any studies on posture correction rather than "damage healing"? Seems like it'd give your body some more signals to go along with to help with correcting bad posture.
    good that sham taping is as good as "professional", since I'm not paying anyone to do this for me.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      Hi! I know what you mean - are there studies that show that it genuinely changes posture… but I don’t honestly think there are

  • @ixlr8395
    @ixlr8395 Год назад

    I’m a firm believer in KT Tape. I’ve used the tape for my plantar fasciitis on both feet for about a year.These past two weeks I have not used it since I have no pain .

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      Glad to hear it’s helping you!

    • @OxysLokiMoros
      @OxysLokiMoros 7 месяцев назад

      K-Taping is bullshit, like manual therapy, blackrolls, electro therapy, cupping, most passive treatments in general...
      What works is:
      -Education about pain
      -Training(Graded activity etc.)
      -Lifestyle changes(nutrition, activity, sleep, stress)

  • @spaulinit
    @spaulinit 7 месяцев назад

    For achilles tendonitis, k tape has been a godsend for me. I've used it after strengthening, massage and stretching before sport. I play and referee football. If I start without the tape, pain is almost instant throughout and recovery is long. With the tape, pain is nonexistent, however it starts again after removal. It then stops immediately after stretching and massage.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  7 месяцев назад +1

      Very pleased to hear that you are doing well!

  • @z0uLess
    @z0uLess Год назад

    My physiotherapist applied a small strap of such tape under my kneecap (lifting it up) after an hour session of training and examining my jumper knee and the band that is creates applies pressure to the inflamed tendon and it allowed my brain to use the muscle instead of easing off it and letting it become weak while training. The pressure that it creates on the tendon kinda reprograms the pain signals so that you are still able to activate the muscle and not overcompensate with other muscles. Seems logical enough for me, and my experience from taping it myself and moving about speaks to the same results. I've been working out with weights for 20 years and I know how hard it is to access consciously the muscle activation and how good the body is at compensating with other muscles, especially while doing sports and balancing acts.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      Glad to hear it has been useful for you!

    • @z0uLess
      @z0uLess Год назад

      @@ClinicalPhysio my point is that the video does not do the subject of "human experience" justice because such experiencea has real world effects ... and I would prefer it if you got into the methods being used in the studies an how they came to their conclusions rather than just saying it was a randomized trial. All I got from this is that I dont have to be so accurate in where I place the tape so long as it stretches the skin and interrupts the neurological signals.

  • @maddang1797
    @maddang1797 Год назад

    I wondered if this was useful as a support for carpal tunnel syndrom rather than the splint which I find difficult to use as it limits a lot of my daily tasks

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      No reason why not to try if you really want to… but I imagine it may not be firm enough to stop you being able to bend your wrist

  • @Alexdiaz727
    @Alexdiaz727 9 месяцев назад

    Kinesio Tape on bruise. Google images. Pretty clear it has some kind of effect on reducing the bruise area.

  • @sateesh666
    @sateesh666 Год назад

    My personal experience it works acute conditions,trigger point area , female patients ..in developing countries it generate amount to physio

  • @jessicabrauman
    @jessicabrauman Месяц назад

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but none of the literature you've linked seems to address taping for joint instability and hypermobility, and for pain associated with that. Would you be willing to summarise the research in that regard? I can't seem to find any research on it. I have hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome and the podiatrist I saw recently suggested either taping with medical tape or using compression braces until I can get some orthotics made, to reduce pain and increase stability.
    And also, if I understand correctly, kinesio tape is different from regular sports tape or medical tape. Are the use of these supported by evidence, and in what cases?

  • @chasehaynie879
    @chasehaynie879 Год назад

    In my experience, admittedly limited relative to many, Ktape has no biomech advantages like these studies/ this video says however it does seem (i haven't done formal studies so i don't feel confident using stronger language ha) to have decent/good benefits with fascia like plantar fasciitis or MFR because of essentially the prolonged low-mid grade stretch it provides, posture corrections mainly due to providing cuing, and for edema/brusing where in assuming it's stimulating bloodflow to the area.
    Like MFR, dry needling, cupping, scraping, etc it is simply a tool that serves a fairly specific purpose but often gets touted as a cureall like Flexseal. Modalities are meant to be used to facilitate correction, they don't correct the MSK issues themselves

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад +1

      This is a really well made point! Thank you! I agree that as you said it shouldn’t be seen as the cure, and perhaps studies try and see if was the cure rather than just something that helps 🙏🏼

  • @rlshultz5841
    @rlshultz5841 8 месяцев назад

    None of the studies address the question does KT tape help PREVENT injury or further injury. This is a different question and important. It’s more about muscle support than improvement

  • @MDTAR15
    @MDTAR15 Год назад

    Personally, i have had zero luck with K-Tape actually providing any pain relief. I had an elbow injury from an impact sustained while playing a little football with some friends. I watched about 2 dozen "how to videos" on using KT properly on the elbow... felt no difference other than the hair being tugged on. Fast forward 2 years (Sept 2022) and somehow, no clue how really, i went to bed and woke up with knee pain. Doc said it was a Grade II MCL and meniscus tear with a strained/sprained ACL (i'm truly clueless as to how this much damage happened). Doc gave me hinged knee brace and a 6" wide ACE bandage to use for stability, along with some pain killers and advice to use ice 3-5 times a day.... however, the brace was cumbersome and the bandage only provided support when it was tight, but that caused me to lose feeling in my lower leg. Once again, i turned to KT and RUclips for advice on properly using the tape for support/pain relief in these areas...once again, i felt no benefit (actually hurt a bit more)...but i did shave the hair this time, so i didn't suffer from hair being pulled out of my leg :) ... At my next visit to the docs, i asked him how to properly use it and he said he didnt use in unless it was requested. He had a Sports Med guy come in and show me how to tape it...he actually taped me up the first time (it was exactly how i was taping it), and just like before, it actually hurt worse when walking out of the office. So, i have basically been wearing nothing, just icing it 3-5 times a day, using 800Mg of Ibuprofen once or twice a day and following the theory of "If it hurts like heck...dont do it". So far i havent seen much improvement in 12 days...we shall see. I have never hurt my knee this bad so i dont know if this type of injury has a 4...6...10...16...20 week healing time or what. Comments are appreciated if you have any insight. AND, if i'm being a dumbbell for doing it my way, let me know as well...i can take polite criticism. Have a great day and i hope everybody watching this is recovering well or has recovered already.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      I don’t think you are being a dumbbell at all! K-Tape absolutely isn’t necessarily designed to instantly relieve pain, and I can totally appreciate the Sports Doc was using same method as you… so don’t beat yourself up 😊🙏🏼

  • @sidrens5292
    @sidrens5292 2 года назад +1

    Isn’t K-tape also used to help in the correction of joint position? I.e positioning the joint in a better rested position, in order to provide a cue for the patient? I find this very beneficial.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  2 года назад +2

      Is K-tape strong enough to truly provide enough force that it will stop a joint moving in an “incorrect” direction?

    • @sidrens5292
      @sidrens5292 2 года назад +2

      @@ClinicalPhysio it’s not meant for that - used to simply cue the patient regards what a ‘good’ rested position should feel like- example: taping shoulder to find a good anatomically sound position in which to move joint. Not used to help generate force or stop the joint moving.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  2 года назад +2

      @@sidrens5292 Sure! As we said in the video, this probably comes under the Neuromodulation concept … I suppose we just have to be careful with how we phrase it to ensure patients do not think it’s something they will always need e.g. “We’re hoping to see if this tape gives your skin and muscles some feedback so that they remember to do their job”…
      A gentle consideration therefore if saying “this tape will help stabilise/correct your joint position” as this may lead patients to believe that it’s the tape that’s doing the “correcting”, rather than themselves

    • @sidrens5292
      @sidrens5292 2 года назад +2

      @@ClinicalPhysio absolutely agree! I only use it as a cue mechanism, so the patient understands what ‘good rested posture’ feels like and also reinforces how important strength and mobility are to restore efficient mechanics 😀

    • @user-vw8rh2rh6q
      @user-vw8rh2rh6q Год назад

      @@ClinicalPhysio Leukotape can achieve 😃😃😃The k-tape only gives sensory input

  • @paulinesroczynski7505
    @paulinesroczynski7505 Год назад +1

    I have a rotator cuff injury a detached supraspinatus tendon. Have suffered intense pain for 3 years and have regular steroid injections which can last 4 to 5 months. Have just had my shoulder taped and the difference is amazing - has taken all the pain away and I can do nearly all the movements I need to do without any sharp pains.. Does KT tape work - yes 100%.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      That’s great! I’m very pleased to hear it has helped your symptoms!

    • @aurelianspodarec2629
      @aurelianspodarec2629 Год назад

      @@ClinicalPhysio You are giving too much "bot" like answers.

  • @mta01ajd
    @mta01ajd Год назад +1

    I suffer with inflammation after running, without a doubt taping helps to reduce my swelling. Example is the bottom end of the IT band, so above the knee on the outside, it just works.
    Surely it also has a pain relief mechanism similar to a TENS machine? (Or a parent rubbing a child's painful knee!)

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад +1

      Hi Andrew! The evidence doesn’t highlight a pain relieving effect although I appreciate what you are suggesting… In order to have that pain relieving mechanism (neuromodulation as we sometimes call it), the amount of signal applied by the tape would have to reach above a certain threshold so that it is “loud enough” for the body to pay attention. TENS is a great example of this as you can have it on very low intensity which is not “loud enough” or a higher intensity which is loud enough and thus goes beyond that threshold. K-tape I imagine does not provide enough of a pain changing stimulus to go above that threshold

    • @mta01ajd
      @mta01ajd Год назад

      @@ClinicalPhysio Thanks for the detailed reply! That does make a lot of sense, appreciate you humouring my speculation!
      I saw one video suggesting if you were to apply it over a large haematoma the colour under the tape would dissipate much quicker, I'm sure I even saw an example... In my head it didn't seem a huge stretch to think it could therefore affect inflammation. Not scientific I know!
      If I read too deeply I might knock out any placebo effect 😂

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад +1

      @@mta01ajd no you are right there absolutely pictures around that show the change in colour of bruising and swelling with k-tape - that’s definitely true …… I suppose the next question is, “is that a genuine deep change?” Or “just a change in colour on the surface and actually it doesn’t actually change much deep below the tissue?”…. This I do not know the answer to!

    • @mta01ajd
      @mta01ajd Год назад +1

      @@ClinicalPhysio Hmmm, it would be an interesting study!

  • @gordanaivanisevic7325
    @gordanaivanisevic7325 Год назад

    Well, I use it stabilize my bad ankle when I hike. Even if it is placebo, my ankle feels more stable.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  Год назад

      That’s absolutely great! If it helps you then good news

  • @jrichey10
    @jrichey10 9 месяцев назад

    I don’t understand this part though. If it helps with swelling, wouldn’t that then also help with pain and mobility? These three variables are directly related to one another. If an area is swollen, your mobility is reduced, and your pain is increased. If it helps with swelling, it seems obvious that it will help with pain and mobility.
    Aside from that, I know for sure at the very least my pain and mobility are greatly improved instantly once kt-tape is applied. I know that’s anecdotal, but I can’t be the only one! Perhaps these studies were done on people with more acute injuries? Like obviously kt-tape isn’t gonna do much for a broken limb or a ruptured/torn ligament, but for a simple sprain, it can definitely provide a significant degree of pain relief and mobility.
    Idk, to me this video kinda seems like contrarian bait. People love to feel like they have the “real” knowledge and that everyone else is full of shit. It’s an ego boost. The studies cited here aren’t the only studies done on kt-tape. Idk. I’m gonna keep taping my ankle when it flares up bc it immediately provides relief and allows me to work without even thinking about it whereas without it, it’s the *only* thing I’m thinking about.

  • @RhonTaeKwon
    @RhonTaeKwon Год назад +2

    Yes it works. I fractured my pinky toe last year and due to my work requirements they wouldn't let me wear my medical boot so I used K tape and wrapped my foot up so I could go to work and it really healed my fractured toe. I also do TaeKwonDo and K tape does wonders there.

  • @elijones93
    @elijones93 Год назад +3

    It 100% works... It supports whilst training or being active.

  • @jacobrahe8726
    @jacobrahe8726 6 месяцев назад

    My physical therapist just wrapped my knee with ktape….i have a meniscus tear

  • @climberguy10001
    @climberguy10001 2 года назад +1

    High school athletes swear by it, so it must work on everything.

  • @surfcoasttherapeuticmassag9518
    @surfcoasttherapeuticmassag9518 2 года назад

    I hardly use it

  • @MemeGang420
    @MemeGang420 2 года назад

    Spinal manipulation has to be the next hot take 👀

  • @badboidenis
    @badboidenis 7 месяцев назад

    Pain is generated by movement. K tape significantly reduces movements and keeps muscles/joints more compact. Therefore I can’t understand these conclusions.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  7 месяцев назад

      Pain may not always be generated by movement! But I think the other consideration is “does k tape SIGNIFICANTLY reduce movement”. I suppose the evidence suggests not

    • @badboidenis
      @badboidenis 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@ClinicalPhysio what I meant that is pain increases with movement when there’s already an injury with its own causes. For the meniscus for example. I can run probably 50% better with the tape on.

  • @yn9861
    @yn9861 3 месяца назад

    I think the tape makes my pain worse 😢

  • @bitethebook249
    @bitethebook249 Год назад

    When ever I K Tape my Knee I am able to do pistol squats. I hope this aint the placebo effect 🤣🤣

  • @OffRadarPro_3768
    @OffRadarPro_3768 4 месяца назад

    Don't know about other people but i feel some increase in performance while wearing these not by much tho but feels better than not wearing it while working out. Not saying you'll be a fuckin athlete while wearing this....just my personal opinion

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  4 месяца назад

      That’s awesome! Thank you for sharing!

  • @fiderdvis4714
    @fiderdvis4714 Месяц назад

    As a very active judo player kt tape is trash give me sport tape everyday

  • @miauv833
    @miauv833 10 месяцев назад

    The conclusion seems a bit punishing on the athletes as if all of them could be just superstitious, there was reduced inflammation proven, inflammation causes pain, pain needs to be taken seriously. Best of lucks.

    • @ClinicalPhysio
      @ClinicalPhysio  10 месяцев назад

      Certainly not punishing on athletes! It’s the same for every human on the planet… it’s just that we see k-tape used a lot with athletes!

    • @miauv833
      @miauv833 10 месяцев назад

      @@ClinicalPhysio Then implying all humans are superstitious, which is inaccurate, dangerous and dismissive, I would definitely address the later part, that there was reduced inflammation proven, inflammation causes pain, pain needs to be taken seriously.
      I think therapists would benefit a lot from visiting different countries where physiotherapy is patient orientated and not provider orientated.
      You dont cite your credentials in your page, what are they?

  • @davidbuckner6454
    @davidbuckner6454 11 месяцев назад

    I’d like to reach out to Khalid if he should find this reach out plz