Roger Waters - Time (Official Lyric Video, DSOTM REDUX)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- The Dark Side Of The Moon Redux, out now. Available on double LP, CD, download and with exclusive bundles in the official store: RWaters.lnk.to...
All songs including 'Us And Them', 'Speak To Me', 'Breathe', 'Time' & 'Money’ available to stream now: RWaters.lnk.to...
Official Website: rogerwaters.com/
Listen to Roger Waters on your favorite platform: rogerwaters.ln...
Follow Roger Waters on Social Media:
Facebook: / rogerwaters
Instagram: / rogerwaters
Twitter: / rogerwaters
Subscribe to Roger Waters’ Channel: / @rogerwaters
Lyrics
The voice had been there all along - Hidden in the stones in the rivers - Hidden in all the books - Hidden in plain sight - It was the voice - of reason
[TIME] Ticking away the moments that make up a dull day - You fritter and waste the hours in an offhand way - Kicking around on a piece of ground in your hometown - Waiting for someone or something to show you the way - Tired of lying in the sunshine, staying home to watch the rain - You are young and life is long, and there is time to kill today - And then one day you find ten years have got behind you - No one told you when to run, you missed the starting gun - And you run and you run to catch up with the sun but it’s sinking - And racing around to come up behind you again - The sun is the same in a relative way but you’re older - Shorter of breath and one day closer to death - Every year is getting shorter, never seem to find the time - Plans that either come to naught or half a page of scribbled lines - Hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way - The time is gone, the song is over - Thought I’d something more to say - Home, home again - I like to be here when I can - And when I come home cold and tired - It’s good to warm my bones beside the fire - Far away across the field - The tolling of the iron bell - Calls the faithful to their knees - To hear the softly spoken magic spells.
#RogerWaters
The more I listen, the more fantastic it becomes!
fantastic performance of time Roger is an unrivaled genius
Introducing The Dark Side Of The Moon Redux - ruclips.net/video/dhUOLJAeXx4/видео.htmlsi=wwa6tI6J68K72cRM
Shine on u crazy diamond 💎
Very interesting version, but the original is just perfect
I feel at one with the universe right now. I feel like, for once, I'm not at the mercy of my depression and anxiety. Another triumph, Roger, well done! 💖💖💖🌹🌹🌹😍
Happy Birthday Roger Waters 💎
The Early version with Pink Floyd had the sound of time on it's hands, of youth with a lifetime ahead. This version sounds like it's now at it's graveside and reflecting on how quickly time went by and how life is over. Where the early version had the sound of vibrant youth, this version has the sound of old age at the end of life where a lifetime of regret and missed opportunities meet the grave. It's sound is sad and gripping and a reminder to wake up and live what life you have left.
From the time I first bought Dark Side of the Moon in jr.high to now, this is reality. I love them both for different ages and different times.
Exactly how i felt when i heard this version - made me cry !
В точку.
Love this
Yeah I agree. The difficulty is separating the new recording and listening to it on it's own merits from the drama and Waters egoistic comments.
How do people not understand it's "different", not better, not worse. Each version is its own entity. The two releases are like siblings, they are not meant to compete for some abstract/baseless "title of best one" but instead they compliment each other. It's really quite simple, almost
Very hearth-warming! As I mentioned, this is how Pink Floyd should sound in 2023. The classic smell of truth and self-reflection points the mirror towards us. The split of Roger and David was gift to us. Every time one of them released new song, it is a magic, doubled!
BS. Are you Waters' publicist. That is a song that goes nowhere without tbe guitar. Empty and nearly vacuous compared to the original.
A lentificação própria da versão "redux" produz uma sensação mais agoniante ainda da passagem fugidia e inexorável do tempo, tão bem retratada pela letra escrita por Roger. Esse inimigo do qual a desventura humana não consegue fugir, que carrega consigo tão apressadamente o pouco de vida que nos resta, está, de modo brilhante, representado neste novo time. Genial, como de costume. Parabéns, Roger.
The spoken word has no comparison to singing. Love ya Roger but you have to know when to gracefully step back
This took one of the greatest songs of all time with an amazing guitar solo and made it slower and boring
it was time for a slow and intenseTime 😍🥰
You are the best in the world 👏👏👏Sublime suggestions ❤
It is scary to like this version with the lyrics as powerful as ever and when it's 50 years of growing up on the original!
Roger's divorce with Floyd seems complete (without any need for his band mates to express himself). Every element of the band's contribution is dismembered except the lyrics and the basic melody. He stands by himself as he resets or rearranges the time/ Time till we're sane...
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 hermoso
Awesome
I've hardly heard anything less musical that tries to be musical, if you know what I mean.
The flat side of the moon
Martin...KING of the Illuminati....
A shame he is doing all of this out of spite and that he claims he wrote all of the DSOTM album which he did not.
The original song makes me cry... This also makes me cry, just in a different way.
😂😂😂
Yeah this makes me cry cause it's shit
LOL
we have lots of reasons to cry right now. Any one that smiles is delusional
@@jessicaf2655stop crying and hating and go listen to new artists with autotune and be happy..
Dear Roger, it is time to think about an honest retirement.
The fact that you participated in the writing of this masterpiece does not give you the right to rape it.
Enough, please. I would like to remember you as a pillar of music and not as a grudging old man. You without the Floyd are a boring strummer, the Floyd without you are decent musicians who can't write lyrics. The magic was your union.
I repeat. Enough. For all the love I feel for you
Dear sir! Please don't deny Mr. Waters to try to make something different out of this music. If he fails, it will be his failure, if he wins, it will be his victory.
@@Schwarzman812 Something different? In this piece he sounds like a dull Leonard Cohen
I still can't believe he tried this. This is such a pity.
The original is perfect, however I appreciate what Roger has done here. For everyone upset, the original still exists, it hasn't disappeared, you can still listen to it.
Hey if you want a version that sounds like a bunch of old guys in a cover band..:this is for you!!!
@@WhiteWizzard Meh. DSOTM doesn't exist without Roger. If anything hearing him in his older years talk about time getting behind you is fitting. Honestly, this version speak to me in ways the original does not in my own later years.
@@16vjohnny hey good for you….this does nothing for me. I never had a problem hearing the lyrics on the original. Once the album was put in the world it wasn’t Rogers anymore…..it was the worlds. Every fan of it can come to their concisions. Everybody that loves this hey god bless ‘em. I think it sounds like a lounge cover band and I’m not into it. YMMV
@@WhiteWizzard Yet here you are shitting on it... lol. Best of luck my dude.
The view is amasingly wonderfull! Who could meke this masterpeace whithout Storm Torgison?
At last some real appreciation being shown by good people who understand and can read behind the lines that they didn't when they were 18 . This man stands as the greatest rock showman of all time with a passion for truth change and opposition to these hall of fools and pathological killer in charge of us all . Forever Roger .
Unpopular opinion, but these remixes are terrible. The songs feel stripped of everything that makes them classics.
To me if Roger had an interesting idea for the 50th it should had been a music film of the album.
Wish i could show it to my dad who showed it to me 45 years ago and we loved it together
I also don't have anyone left who cares and/or knows enough to fully enjoy this, the first song I ever heard. Perhaps we can enjoy it together!? 🙂
Não, não faça isso com ele!
Here's to all the cool dads out there. You will all meet them again one day. We are all part of a much bigger story that we could ever imagine. I promise you you'll be jamming with your dad again someday 🍀✌️
Im sure he will be listening still with you!!
Don’t show that crappy version
This version of 'Time' is phenomenal! It brings a deep, introspective vibe that contrasts with the original one energy. It’s a fresh take that really hits home.
The part about being young and having time to kill is much more meaningful when I hear it now at almost 60 than it was when I first heard this in high school.
It's a strange contrast actually. It was meaningful when I was in high school, but at nearly 60 it can be appreciated with more depth. Wisdom is an odd talent.
Would it be any less meaningful if you only had the original DSOTM to listen to, and not this?
@@EddieG1888 Truth be told, I never could understand all of the words in lyrics until this version.
@@Cards-In-The-Closet But that's precisely what Roger is playing on; the people who were kids when DSOTM was released hearing this and going _"it makes more sense to me now that I'm old"_ .
But Roger didn't write the lyric when he was an old man, and the lyric isn't even written from an old character's perspective. The song is written from a young man's perspective on life and his opinion _at that age_ on what it is to get old, and its very disingenuous of Roger to say in interviews that this recording much better conveys the message he doesn't think the original managed to.
This album would have been much less dishonest and quite frankly a better piece of work if he'd kept the musical themes, and updated the lyrics according to his thoughts and feelings on the song subjects as a man of almost 80.
@@EddieG1888perhaps he still gels with the lyrics, but finds the new music more fitting for his message
How such a young man in 1973 came up with these lyrics is beyond me, only now at 48 does this really start to resonate.
I believe the word is genius
He was 30, not so young
Lot's of LSD.
@@superLuckyMari
Is 28 the same as 30 to you?
@@AMEER-114- According to Wikipedia, he was born in 1943.
It's like bumping into a dear old friend you haven't seen for years. It is wonderful to see how they have changed in all that time, but also wonderful to be able to still see what originally made you love them in the first place.
It’s like that dear old friend and a bunch of old guys started a lounge cover act.
WELL SAID !!
@@WhiteWizzardMore like the dear old friend turned fat and bald and you don't know what to say to him, but you want to say it. But can't. So you sit and stare at his head where gorgeous Motley Crue-like hair once was.
@@samanthagilmour4402 we are sadly witnessing the dark side of Rogers old sagging tea bag I am afraid….and it’s not pretty
Exactly!
Always will prefer the original but hearing this redux with roger being this old is just so nostalgic for real. Music is such a pivotal part of life
It really is
Thanks for identifying something positive in this!
Stesso tuo pensiero!
A masterpiece of an already bonafide masterpiece. Time has only made this song ever more precious and poignant than the first time I heard "Time."
Is this whole album going to be Roger doing jazz poetry over stripped down versions of the songs? C'mon, man.
Yes.
Wow. Roger took a great Pink Floyd song and made it sound just like every other Roger Waters' song.
wich means it's a very beautiful song.
@@mohamedalimahfoudh3339 but not as good as the original recording.
@@toonerfische6237 we have different tastes, we should just enjoy the music...
Just be thankful that mr gilmour and Mr wright were able to add their touches before he recrafted it.
Audio Ambien
Cant wait to hear roger sing great gig in the sky lol.
(In Rogers deep tone)
Whoah....oh...oh...oh...oooo...oh...oh. Aaaahhh
Having played the original 10,000 times, I thoroughly enjoyed and appreciate this version.
Somewhere, David Gilmour is wondering whether Roger Waters has finally gone mad.
@@lightfight8r Gilmour is too busy not doing anything for the last 30 years.
@@illegalewahrheiten2911 As opposed to your boy Roger busily whining about everything and everyone.
@@lightfight8r A musician who cares is a musician who still has creative power. Gilmour is an empty shell. Hasn't written a song since 1974.
@@illegalewahrheiten2911he made rattle that lock from zero, wich is a pretty good álbum. This is justo another version . Almost copy paste
No no no…No…and No. This is like listening to the funeral of a bad lounge lizard.
Majestic. Roger and his music have aged elegantly. Only time will tell if the basement dwellers, critics, and naysayers have the ability to mature as they age.
Bloody neo natzy
Anti Zionist isn't Nazi - being Zionist is more related to Nazism.
Why come here to comment what you did?
The original is 100 times better, sorry Roger 🙂
This version is delivered precisely the way one would expect an 80 year old man would. It was an insightful poem written by a 30 year old but now delivered by a world weary man who has revolved 50 times around the sun since. Outstanding! Bravo Mr. Waters!
This version is delivered precisely the way one would expect an 80 year old man would. This is the fact.
It still sucks
@@Pulse360TVschifo.anche a me....però mi piace una parte di us and them che ha postato....però non piace anche a me
Хорошо сказано!
@@Volkaibn
Спасибо
It is a great reinterpretation of this song. The "No one told when to run" resonate so often in my head, anytime I have to take an important decision, it pops up. The contrast between the energy of the youth and the wisdom of the elder is so well expressed with this new arrangement.. Thanks !
Yep, it makes much more sense as you get older. When you're a teenager and in twenties, it feels like you have all the time in the world. And what feels like the blink of an eye, its twenty years later. Then you realize another 20 will go by even faster. So yeah, time to start running.
Yeah, the wisdom of ruining a masterpiece! This is a lazy and boring arrangement, truly disrespectful to Gilmour and Mason (he completely erased the guitar track e redid the percussion that now sound awfully fake)
I actually love this version... It sound like Time, but with nostalgic tone to it. It's like Roger is talking to his younger self.
thats exactly what I thought
👍
Yeah Roger is reduced to whispering to himself. Probably the onset of Alzheimer's.
Nope. More like he is doing everything in his power to erase Gilmour. Just like his last concert that opened up with a redux version of Comfortably Numb that was horrible.
I thought the feud had ended?
This is ridiculous! 'The Idiot' look should in the mirror, and be certain that he committed a crime!!!! with the music he wrote and helped him consecrate it with bad singer and wonder composed!!!.
I tried, but nope.
Like Time itself, it hasn’t changed and the message is still relevant today. I thoroughly enjoyed this version.
Time was always my favourite track on DSOTM and this is a beguiling take on the original. The idea of an 80 year old man performing lyrics he wrote in his late 20s really adds a sense of poignancy to the song and the musical arrangement enhances the whole thing .
Can't wait to hear his take on Great Gig in the Sky ...suspect it will be
similar to The Mortality Sequence from the early live versions of Dark Side .
Pre ordered !
I thought this was absolutely brilliant. Great Gig in the Sky is by far my favorite song on DSOTM. I play it on my piano when I can't figure out how to handle my emotions....there's no "words", but it expresses everything. So on that dramatic note, I'm a little nervous about it...but I haven't been disappointed yet. I'm really glad he did this.
Probably the most perfect song ever written. Everybody should listen to it at early age. It is a life lesson that will remain forever in the memory.
I agree with you!
Agree
I listened to it as a teenager, love it, never took its advice though...
An appreciation of our limited time is essential.
It can help us be more respectful, grateful & intentional with what we do have.
I was too scattered as a teenager / young adult to really appreciate this music.
I knew I liked it, but didn't really take in the lyrics until much later.
Yep at one day when i was a child my dad took me next to him and he told me to listen this song and the lesson it has. But I willl take the original version to teach my children.
This was a nice surprise. Good desicion to do somenting completely different with the song. Hard to believe it was 50 years ago I unknowingly bought what would become one of the best albums in the history of modern music. I already knew Pink Floyd then, and at first I thought Dark Side was too polished and mainstream. But it didn't take long to revise that premature opinion.
I feel like Roger Waters just likes to hear himself talk not gonna lie. I can see why Gilmour couldn't stand him.
Bro took out the greatest part of this song, the guitar. What's next Roger, taking the guitar solo out of Comfortably Numb?
Yep he definitely reduced the original.
time is the greatest song ever made, full stop. i actually love what he adds to it, especially in the beginning. nothing has or ever will match the original but it’s great to see such a masterpiece be re-examined by an older roger. it’s much much better than what we heard on money.
It's ok, but I miss Gilmour guitars, Mason drums and Wright keyboards on it! I don't think the original needed a reinterpretation because it was, and is, simply PERFECT..
@@xavierlluch702 oh i mean yeah, like i said, the original version of time is the best song ever made. the lyrics are so strong and relatable and it has the best guitar solo of all time. rogers version obviously isn’t anywhere near the original, nothing has or ever will maybe beat it, but he’s still made a good song here
Sorry the original is by far the best. This version sucks
Have you ever wondered what Pink Floyd would have been like without Gilmour, Mason and Wright? This is it! and its pure rubbish unfortunately. Waters is a great lyricist and bass player, that’s the genius he brought to Pink Floyd. A talent that when mixed with the other band mates exploded into extraordinary unparalleled masterpieces that will live on forever as some of the greatest musical work ever done. But sadly, without the collaboration of his previous band mates, his talent alone isn’t enough to create anything extraordinary or even close. Tbh, had he never been part of Pink Floyd, his solo career would have never been as big as it was (which it wasn’t). But everyone has to keep on making a living, I get it.
The lyrics are his, he can do what he wants with it. Being about mortality, there is a timelessness to it, ironically enough. I can see him performing this in his last phase of life, though the original recording had more life to it. It will be an interesting outreach to those who were there when the band launched, as Waters turns 80. He's the master of the Leitmotif, so he's circling around again. The same in a relative way, but he's older. And in his singing you can hear that he is indeed shorter of breath.
Clever Wordplay there
Yeah the song is his to butcher all he wants trying to be Leonard Cohen her it’s a piece of crap, just because he’s not written anything worth listening to since he left Floyd
Just because he can, doesn't mean he should. What he obviously can't do is come up with anything worth listening to since 1981.
I never missed the starting gun .....and had a great life , and onwards ....
@@michaeldobbs4249 A piece of crap?
The original is so beautiful that nothing can compare
This is the lyrics. it's like a poem, it's less of music, more of poem. I love it. More please. More redux
Why compare if we can apreciate both versions... the original one and the minimal one
I think I know how the rest of the album will sound like
I never would have dreamed as a schoolkid that I'd still be listening to him releasing new material, rehashed or not, when I'm in my 50s. Makes me happy. Long Live Roger Waters!
It has been 50 years since I bought Dark side of the Moon. I love both versions for different times. Listen to the 1st version and in 50 years listen to this. You will probably appreciate this version. I’m just happy that people still appreciate the great music that I grew up with.
It's outstanding. I am 63 years old, and this version perfectly expresses my feelings at my age. "One day closer to death" is a sentence I should start every new day with and live by. My eyes well up with tears towards the middle section.
From Hungary, best wishes!
Your daughter is rolling her eyeballs in the next room.
Yup.
After listening to both Money and Time by Roger on headphones I decided I really like them. I’m looking forward to hearing the full album.
Don't care what anyone says, this is ace. Course it doesn't replace the original, but it's an amazing reinterpretation by the man himself!
He's off his rocker- it's horrible. I see this as nothing but a cash grab and a way to piss Glimour off. Guy cant sing anymore- he just going to talk his way through the whole album?
"How to destroy a masterpiece, Chapter II", by Roger Waters
Horrible, tragedy, bottom line
OMG this is terrible, one of the worst ideas in music history.
This is just terrible. Give me the original
I respect that Roger is owning the cover of the album that he is doing. Do I like the two songs I have heard so far, no, I do not, but I don’t have to like it. Without Rick, David, and Nick, there is just something missing, the magic is not there. For those of you who like it, I’m glad you like it, more power to you; for those of us who aren’t really liking it, there is always the original to go back to, or even the live version from Pulse. Let’s also be perfectly clear about one thing, the album was not completely Rogers baby conceived from whole cloth, at least two of the songs wouldn’t exist. If Richard Wright hadn’t been there.
The concept, production, hiring of Alan Parsons (who was also brilliant) and David Gilmore were all Roger's ideas. Yes, Wright contributed but the performances changed to accomodate stronger guitar work. That was David's input and he was great. This is just closer to what Water's originally wanted, I think. It might be that Roger tries to restrain Gilmore and that is the fundamental fault line.
@@rainmanjr2007 not to nitpick, but Parsons was assigned to the album project by the studio, so claims Nick Mason, several different authors, and several different reporters over the years. There is also still a quite active debate as to who’s ultimate production vision for the album was actually fulfilled, david’s or Roger’s. Yes, the songs changed and evolved through the couple of years that the album was being formulated by the band, but I will still maintain that without Richard Wright we would not have The Great Gig in the Sky, or Us and Them.
I have no disagreement with Wright's part. As for production value, Floyd wasn't much about guitars before Gilmore so I think Waters tends to look for other noises. Gilmore's guitar was going to make them famous, however. It seems to me Waters is trying to rectify that change of plan. @@christianschoenewald
OK nice, but how many times can we really listen to this version? Once or twice personally - what is this all about? Getting credits, recognition, money, art, removing guitars? I don't know anymore but my preferred instrument is guitar from the guitar heroes as they are inimitable and bring music to another level...
@@watersmoke1114 I only listened once and I thought Roger ruined it. (Well, to be honest, there's not anything anyone can do to make the original better.)
A time stamp of an artist, inspiring in a sense of how to be creative. The music and lyrics as the art of expression after all.
I was 13 when this was new. Have heard all different versions over the years. It's natural for things, everything, to evolve, mature. Kudos!
The lyrics hit me harder today than they ever have.... I'm less than a month from 52.... Brilliant words and a true unshakeable realization of things i never really had to think about.
You're old! I turned 52 just 2 weeks ago, cheers!!! 😂
🤣@@jalzate 👍
Happy Birthday,btw!!!@@jalzate
Haunting and brilliant version, well done remake to celebrate 50 years since the original release.
Happy Birthday Roger! 🇷🇺 Greetings from Russia!
When I listened to this I realized that I've been listening to DSOTM for so long that the very chord changes are a part of my DNA. I've been listening to DSOTM since I was about 8 years old (I'm in the late 50s now). It was one of my first albums. I love this. And if I can love this, all these youngins who are doing their performative hate dances can get over it. When you grow up you realize that a reinterpretation of one of your favorite works is not a replacement. It's not one or the other, sunshine. And trust me, no one cares whether you like the original album better. You won't get points for complaining. There are no prizes for being the loudest whiner. It's simple. I'm not a fan of Jay-Z. You know how I deal with that? I don't buy Jay-Z. And guess what? No one cares.
This is a work which is being reinterpreted by the guy who wrote it and recorded it with the help of his band. If anybody has the right to reinterpret DSOTM, it's Roger Waters. Read the credits, folks. If you actually ever did that you might realize why you sound so silly to old timers like me.
You should have ended with "now get off my lawn!" 😂
You clearly care a whole lot to be writing this much.
As a 20 year old Floyd fan who's been listening practically my whole life I agree with everything you said.
@@Pulse2AM - The "get off my lawn" is implied.
That is the most boring snare sound ever recorded.
How depressing this now sounds in a time when we all need a lift.
People keep comparing these redux versions to the originals, saying that these new versions are bad, and depressing, and not as good. They aren't though. These aren't just songs, they are messages, and they don't require flashy musical numbers to be understood, and that's exactly how you should appreciate them whether you prefer the old or the new. Catchy upbeat guitar riffs are fun to hear, but if you never peel them away, and take in the messages of these songs then you're missing the point, and you're simply just wasting time.
When I heard the Money redux I was negatively surprised and I wondered why he did it. Listening to Time redux I have to admit that it is genius and unique.
The string arrangements are just INSANE!!! The Hammond is amazing. I love it
wow i am shocked you are saying this
But the voice is awful !
This version produced from the jealousy Woger has towards David Gilmore is simply TERRIBLE! Even with knowing the original it's simply a very boroming and SH!T song with terrible terrible "singing"!
I thought the strings reminded me of Abbey Road Studio/The Beatles/I am the walrus.
@@mephisto4383it's not awful, it's just weathered and old. Reminds me of latter day leonard cohen. Suits the reflective nature of this recording by an 80 year old.
The beautiful thing about this version is that it raises a magnifying glass the message of the original. I can actually feel my time being wasted and slipping away as I'm listening to it.
Very well put
That has to be the slickest insult I’ve ever read on RUclips. 😉
Boring. You're not doing the masterpiece any favors.
Really dig the mellow feeling of it, the organ and strings are delightful
Can't agree about the orgam - lacklustre and soulless, not a patch on Rick Wright's playing. As it's meant to be, I suspect - Rog wouldn't want to deflect attention away from his own parts now, would he. Way to neuter an absolutely classic track.
@@copperfield3629 You still have the original song, Roger wanted to make a version he feels encapsulates better the feeling of what he wrote back then. You guys are overly sensitive over stuff that doesn’t affect you in any way
@@bruce000000070000000exactly that
@@bruce000000070000000 Not sensitive at all. You posted your reaction, I posted mine. Isn't that how this commenting thing is supposed to work??? Or are dissenting opinions not a thing where you come from?
@@copperfield3629 “way to neuter” you’re acting like the original doesn’t exist anymore, this isn’t a difference in opinion, couldn’t care less if you disliked it
So Roger making it his own involves stripping it of anything pleasing to the the ear and jamming in a load of pretentious spoken word drivel
"Time" marcou a minha adolescência pois, quando ia jogar fliperama num comércio perto de casa, o proprietário só tocava praticamente, essa música, o dia inteiro. Isso em 1990.
Ainda bem que não conheci esse lugar kkk Sem PF eu já passava o dia no Street Fighter escondido
@@andrewsbelo8194 kkkkkkk
this is truly insanely tasteless when compared to the original Pink Floyd version. I really do not understand what was the need to do something similar to a crime.
Así como Roger recuerda cuando crearon este álbum, así recuerdo cuando lo escuché por vez primera. Es el tiempo que me trajo acá. Grande Pink Floyd.
Meh .. this version lacks soul. The brilliant words deserve a brilliant interpretation; that was the beauty of DG's original vocal. This monotone interpretation leaves nothing to the imagination. No regret, no warning, no higher knowledge. Even the animation is unimaginative (or perhaps the retro look is intentional..?).
Pretty much sonambulant. .. sorry.
Still looking forward to the entire album (but this doesn't bode well...).
I finally think I'll make a comment here. I grew up listening to Pink Floyd with my father in the car and I grew to love the band, the members, and their individual traits in songwriting and composition. I understand the purpose of what Roger is wanting to do, and in some ways I agree that the songs here have a different purpose than before.
However, these variations just don't feel the same. I've watched people call these new takes soulful and deep, but to me, it's missing all of the emotion in the song. The adding of passages takes away from the actual musical meaning behind the song. If Roger could open up still like he used to, I think the songs would be better recovered by everyone, but instead he stays rather focused in the storytelling approach like a distant grandfather who forgot his own story and has changed it for the tenth time.
The music is fine, but this is no masterpiece.
Sua palavras são as mesma que eu escreveria. Senti a mesma coisa...um senhor de quase 80 anos tentando fazer algo que fez a 50 anos atrás com a ajuda de companheiros, mas agora sozinho não lembra muito bem como é que era.
Then don't listen it it. Rather than bitch about it listen to the original.
Simple.
@@imatitlover You seem to missing the point. It is worth giving it a shot, however, why change something that it took four people to seemingly fine. Time, as far as I can remember, was one of the last songs from Pink Floyd to credit all four composers. Again, nothing in particular is wrong with what Roger has done, it just isn't what the song was meant to be.
Don't understand why ppl can not just listen and shut up, instead of always thinking about what it could or couldn't be
@@bigscrapes98 I think Roger knows better than anyone what the song was meant to be.
Congratulations (MIKLOS)!!
I did it with my SON are 15 years old in SÃO PAULO - Brazil! Today he is 35 years old and I remember this at all TIME!!! ROGER, you broken and stole my SOUL with this version. Please, ROGER, don't STOP your career you'll live until the 120 years and we too.
The orchestral atmosphere is just amazing
Heya you should look up The Doublejumps if you're a Pink Floyd fan
👍😃❤️☘️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️
The orchestral background is as depressing as this heavy-handed remake is pedantic, didactic, and super boring. Did I mention long? It is clear to me now what Rog and Gilmie had going on.
@@andreesengillies4427 it's a wonder how some people don't genuinely understand good music.
I'm sure you find classical music boring too
Amazingly beautiful. 👏 💗
Beautiful...Roger is Correct this reinterpretation is all about the lyrics and getting the ear to understand them and after 50 years he does a fantastic job of making them shine...👏
The melody of a song is important as well, but Roger Waters wasn't any good at writing melodies. That was down to David Gilmour.
@70ad89 Gilmours a brilliant musician and upto Wish you were here the whole band worked together beautifully until the cracks appeared..But to say Waters is no good at Melodies is ridiculous you obviously don't rate his solo work...
Many of us understood them before.
I always found them pretty easy to understand back when the song had incredible music and great vocals. Not sure why we needed a boring spoken word version set to cheap synthesizer from a meditation video.
@@JeromeAnselmo-c5eThis ain’t about music. This about songwriting. Please let one of the greatest songwriters OF ALL TIME, do his thing. His giving you poetry, if you want guitar solos go listen to David Gilmour solo music.
I'd love it if Roger's made his own album in this format, his voice like a storyteller and the echoes of other voices. No guitar but that synth/keyboard. It doesn't show well when it's put against their best selling album but it could hold its own as an original album
I find this version shines more of a spotlight on those beautiful,poetic lyrics. He just wants to get his message across to all of us ,young and old. A message I wish I would've paid more attention to as a kid in the 70's.
The lyrics do get lost in the original at times.
Awful. He destroyed the legendary album. 🙉
What was the need to destroy a masterpiece... this version is horrible!!
It’s crap. Roger is trying but not doing it.
At almost his 80s, Roger is still doing a great piece of art, concurrent with modern trends and unique. I admire this man greatly!!!
Me too
100% rock icon legend
Shame this country of birth (England don't recognise his decades of musical.. via a knighthood... but lolol!.. could you see RW accepting it, I defiantly can't, bless that man made angel) huge world loving heart, I love all his music..his voice!!!...woah!!!
Not to mention how he trys his bestest to help achieve world unity & peace,
Bless him, he's my true hero
No. It's like he heard becks sea change and said I'm going to do this with a 50 year old piece of music I did as a collab with 3 other musicians and call it my own work of art.
Yes, he never did much compromise...
what modern trend is this concurrent with?
@@goranpope6008 how about modern world dystopia and the current political trends to lack empathy and reason
Wasting time is the greatest sin. I love both versions.🖤
You speak of sin.
In the Jewish tradition, they live by a set of commandments. Mitzvahs.
What is the 1st of these? A thing called "Rosh Chodesh". To observe the New Moon, and treat that event as holy.
This leaves many scratching their heads. Ok, we are to make a calendar, and live by it. But of all the teachings in the Torah, why would that be the FIRST?
I have heard it explained by a Rabbi somewhere here on the youtubes...
Rosh Chodesh is primary, because we are taught to sanctify our time. The teaching is to not waste the time we have been given.
So in this light, Pink Floyd is sharing the same wisdom as taught by Moses. The same message as your comment.
This is just freakin' amazing and grabbed my attention in no time at all. Different but pure magic!
“no time” that’s the entire song?