Giyu vs Sanemi|Anime,Fan animation and Manga comparison [Demon slayer season 4 hashira training arc]
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 сен 2024
- #anime #art #demonslayer #drawing #kimetsunoyaiba #demonslayerseason4 #demonslayeredit
comparison of giyu vs sanemi in anime, fan Animation and in manga
i hope you liked my fan animation
stay tune for part 3 of tanjiro giyu vs akaza let me cook...im cooking it so good
the fan animation deservers a lot of respect, but there's no comparison, the anime is just the peak
Agreed
it's because the fan animation focused too much on being faithful instead of adding to the original and adding some visual flair.
My eyes: ⬆️⬅️⬇️↗️↖️↙️➡️⬆️🔁🔄🔃
frr
Looks like a cheat code 😅
Of course anime is way better but I love your fan Animation it is amazing and it reminds me the season 1 style(sanemi's hair long and old drawing style for anime)
Yeahhh sanemi looks so brutal in season 1 style..the new season he looks handsome..pure testosterone
@@pelayokenn-xw9uw season 1 Sanemi looks like this edgy try hard angry kid smth like middle-school Bakugo while now in season 4 he looks like angry hardened warrior. Pure testosterone.
@@pelayokenn-xw9uwconfirmo
Fan is fan, air conditioner is air conditioner, you can not compare the two, each is unique
Fan animations always deserve respect
The difference is that the anime is using 3d animation with 3d model, while the fan animation is clearly an 2D.
@@Lol-dw5xbbro most of the Anime’s animation is 2D as well, it’s mostly just the backgrounds that are CGI
@@MrJDFallon Well in demon slayer they mostly use 3d animation
@@Lol-dw5xb Not for the characters and effects, they are all in 2D (unless they’re in the background, which doesn’t really count).
@@MrJDFallon Bruhhh you are not an animator aren't you?
Really respect that ufotable doesnt just copy the manga panels back to back
I love the way you did Giyu’s 7th form. The build up was great
Given Giyu's personality I think they gave a good call for changing Giyu's expression a little like even he's surprised he won't show it that easily.
Love all three of them but anime were perfect.
1- anime 🥇
2- manga 🥈
3- fan animation 🥉
Honestly not bad. One of the best thing about the demon slayer anime is that it gets added scenes that fleshes out the manga. So your fan animation was rather accurate to the manga
The fact that I'm even considering it is pretty fucking amazing.
Anime but Fan animation is so good
it's terrible
@@NaghmanaAshrafit our opinion bro if you think it terrible or don't like Don't comment
@@richrichy9369still terrible
@CABS728 i tell it our opinion bro
@@NaghmanaAshraf sorry2
Fan animation is better than Manga .Anime is way better than Fan animation but as one person you made it very well in my opinion.Giyuu was shocked while his wood sword got broke but in the anime he doesn't seem very suprised. Fan animation beats anime for that scene.
*sorry for my bad english . There might be grammer mistakes pls ignore it*
If anyone is still wondering which scene I'm talking about 0:11 - 0:12 Giyuu's face
Yeah coz in the end giyu was TOTALLY not surprised in any form or media
Only slightly in the manga
@@ShowMeTheBadies He isn't surprised even in the manga, that's gotouge's artstyle.
I see no difference in his face expression
Very very VERY good work my man
That fan animation is on a different level
0:45 HELP THE FAN ANIMATION LOL 😭 GIYUU LOOKS GOOFY
Since it doesn’t make us wait for years, I love fan animations
Yours is like manga so the, the animé has à real view of what's happening good job.
Eye flowing technique: arrow of salvation! ⬆️➡️⬇️
The fan animation was great, but I burst out laughing with how surreal their fight was at 0:18
Ufotable version is best but
I love the fan animation
THIS IS SOO GOOD!
They actually cooked with the spar im crying
The fidelity of fan animation scenes with the manga is simply magnificent. But the anime actually always has better quality...
Anybody saying the fan animation is bad has either never drawn or never animated in their life’s. You can only say it’s bad if u can make it yourself, if u cant your only saying it’s bad because you are comparing it, it still was great. I do still like the anime a lot more though but that’s just because the animators that make demon slayer are insane.
This argument is dumb because I'll say its worse than the official animation because I am in fact comparing it. And because internet is dumb they'll assume that I think that the fan-animation is bad.
critiques aren’t a bd thing, also the more you talk this way the more people would look down on the creator
This is crap
Criticism are valid
I liked this fan animation a lot
Obviously it's not gonna compare to ufotable
@@wvn9957 ok and I that’s not what I’m saying? I’m saying don’t say it’s bad if ur comparing it ok? I don’t get ur point.
@@amogussus21 I said not to say it’s bad because ur comparing it u can still compare it but it’s not bad.
OmG guys they fought each other and had an eye contact 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🤫🥺🥺🥺🥺 they should be a couple I cannnnntttttt aaahhhh
(MY STOMACH LITERALLY DID THE THING🦋🦋🦋)🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖😖😖😖😖😖😖😖😖😖💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💝💝💗💖💗💖💖💗💖💗💖💗💖💗💖💖💗💖💗💖💗💖🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🦋😭💖💓💓💗😖💗😖💗💓💗😖💗😖💗
Edit: OH MY WAFFLES GUYS TYSM FOR THE 100 LIKES IM FAMOUS NOW 💖💗💖💗💓💗💖💗💖💗💖💓💖💖💝💝💖🦋💝💓🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋
Fan animation ate bc he keep the emotions
Hate people saying it’s bad when they don’t know nothing abt animation and how hard it is. They forget it’s a FAN animation. Made by one person. The anime’s are made by multiple and yall act like you could do better
Zoro enjoying their fight 😂😂
anime is another level
when sanemi said wind breathing first form in fan animation I laughed so hard like I thought I died
Anime🥇
Fan animation🥈
Manga🥉
I've never seen an anime is better than the manga
Amazing work
Ufotable🗿👍👍👍👍👍👍
The Demon Slayer anime is being supervised by the author. It includes ideas that didn't make it into the manga but would be useful in the anime.
To be honest, I miss the animation like the "fan animation" did. It has dramatic feeling that anime is uniquely always have so its fun to watch. Don't get me wrong, the official animation is great and facsinating but I would like to see the old fashioned way cause every "lack" detail and dramatation is actually what makes it exciting. No need to be said, the fan one is more accurate to the manga than the official - pose and drawing style wise, giyu looks so hot in the fan's one, lol. I think the fan animation can reach a greater great if given a proper tools. It looks so good! Good job!
Generally i think you can still improve since i think your problem is relying too much manga and turning it like a story boaed for the animation. Maybe try making your own story board for the animation while getting some ideas on the manga panel
@@normalguy4166 yeah thats what im doing on my tanjiro giyu vs akaza part 3 hehe
Nahhh manga giyuu is just there 🧍🏻 0:01
The fact that Giyuu wasn’t fighting seriously while Sanemi fought relentlessly shows how strong Giyuu is.
Honestly the part where he was about to hit the leg was done better than the anime version, didn't even know he was going for the leg in the anime, and the pose Sanemi does in the anime makes it look like hes dodging the stream of water behind Giyu.
Fan animation is the raw visualization, the real anime is the perfect version.
I love the Fan Animation but the Actual Anime has some Better Amazing Effects! 😅
The anime IS Fire! But i love thé ways thé fan animation Following the manga
The fan animation is great and definitely took a lot of time to make however the anime version had professional slaves working on that thing non stop
Actually, ufotable is one of the few companies that doesn't enslave their employees
@@satoshiryusei3995 i was about to make fan animation of JJK but i Dont wanna risk my life
People who say this is bad can’t do it themselves prove me wrong
Ofc fan animation gets the respect for doing that but the anime it just peak ngl
gotta give my respect for whoever made the fan animation simply for being manga accurate, but you just can't compare to Ufotable animations with their added scenes. Being accurate doesn't mean it's better
Anyone notice zoro in the fan animation 😭
I was looking for this comment 😂
ofc the anime but the fan animation deserves respect
Part 3 akaza vs tanjiro and Giyu
Omg 👀
Sanemi and Giyu looks better in fan animation. I'm bias, I just like their old looks more.
Demon slayer fans animations are different level
We have to rely on them in case the anime hasn't come yet which is considered to be doing well.
OMG I never saw that man fuck that sword fights
Anime negs all that. But you did an incredibly job with the animation, so congrats 👏
Lets finish with our fist now 😂 i love sanemi
Fan animation is of the same quality that seven deadly frames had with a whole team and budget
😂
Like!
The fan animation is accurate to manga and their is extremely fine work but if you ask me i will definitely choose the accurate one even if it's not have 8k quality
Cofee budget vs 100000$ budget
all the work of this fan animation, i can respect it, i would watch fan animations all the way than studios ones, for people who thinks this is terrible are bunch of kids, who never touch drawing, are jealous of you doing this kind of work, and they can't
El Haircut le pego good a Sanemi a comparación de la primera temporada
love your animation
both are best
the fan anomation is way more better in terms of "budget"
I feel like the fan animation express a bit better than the anime where giyuu looks expresionless
эта манга не заслужила ТАКУЮ адаптацию
I'm not a manga reader so I don't know any manga panel or manga scenes. I love that anime style. 😊
All hashira die except giyu
Not the menacing signs from jojo XD
Remember u all , all those water and wind effects are non existent
Demon Slayer is one of the animes who actually do better than the fan animation 😂
Ngl I think Giyuu looks better in manga when it comes to close shots of his face
The live action adaptation
Zoro just got lost again.
Anime > manga > fan anim(but good considering you had like no budget)
Zoro got lost again the fan animation..
anime the best
Demon slayer is where the anime is way better than the manga
Fan animation was more relative the manga. But the anime did it better
Same same but different
*Manga VS Fan Animation VS Anime official*
0:11
anime made giyuu looked bored lmao
atleast in the manga and fan animation, his face went: oh shit
in the anime: oh
The anime is infinite better but I would like the anime were more expressive on face expression I feel like there need more exaggerations
Of course anime❤
BRO!
Can Zoro go to different multiverses?
The fan animation and manga giyuu looks worried when his stick start to break but anime he looks 😐
C'est dans quel épisode
The anime 7th form was very unflashly, tengen would disaaprove
Ni siquiera un grak estidio de animación se podría comparar a ufotable
Who did better!?
Can I asked you who seems to did better!???
Ofcrs Ufotable..nahh my fan animation is just trash..but im proud of it cuz im doing it just for fun
@@pelayokenn-xw9uw There you go .. the answer for your video title.
Who else is not watching the manga part😂
Anime
Is no one talking about zoro in the background?
Why the heck was Zoro in the first few seconds
who did it better? XD
Sharingan 👀
Anime skipped some scenes and added extras