I think it's worth noting that the piano may have intentionally been animated incorrectly, considering Cuphead is based on 30's era cartoons, which never really payed attention to that stuff. Just a thought though.
People who made the show: just make it some what correct it's not like someone gonna check the exact cords that were played and see what was actually played, who does that? This guy: it's my time to shine! OMG 1K WHAT THE HECKERY 😱😱😱(*ˊᗜˋ*)ᵗᑋᵃᐢᵏ ᵞᵒᵘ
@@Tempus_Locus yea, but like they looked like they were in a rush anyways with getting this season out (it is still amazing tho), so i doubt they would’ve spent that much time on like a 5 minute scene
yea i think people who do this kinda stuff are aware of that just they correct it for people so they don’t think it’s actually how it’s played (ik it should be common sense for people but for non piano players it could be very hard for them to tell if it’s right or wrong because sometimes they take the time to animate it correctly and some don’t because of budget and it could be very hard like you said so yea)
I’m not kidding, it annoyed me so much when Mugman played chopsticks incorrectly, I spent HOURS and I mean HOURS fetching out my old piano books to play chopsticks correctly. Worth it 🤗
I'd like to make a joke about this in my future show. Something like : Character 1 : Do you wanna play the piano ? Character 2 : Nah. They're never animated correctly anyway. Yes it would break the fourth wall a lot.
THANK GOSH SOMEONE NOTICED IT!! I WAS WAITING FOR SOMEONE TO CORRECT THEM BUT IDK HOW TO PLAY PIANO BUT I ONLY SAW CUPHEAD'S SOUND PLAYING IS GOOD BUT THE PIANO PLAYED IS WRONG THANK YOU FOR CORRECTING IT
Honestly it doesnt take much to animate correctly the animating doesnt change you just gotta stop for like 30 seconds to think what note should the characters hit next
As a tutorial could you do shut up by madness? It's not quite the piano played correctly theme as done by you recently but I don't doubt you'd do it correctly anyways
Pianos are truly never correctly animated. Not even Chuzzle 2's Chuzzarium piano (which you can get by completing a certain spot on the Fuzzlectric Symphony puzzle). I'm talking about the 2 Chuzzles version.
Imagine how long it would take for them to actually animate it correctly tho, it would be pain
true
Trueeee
yeah! its not like the animators cant do it, its just it would take a lot of time
Cartoons from the 1940s could animate pianos properly, and they had to HAND DRAW the animation…
@@SomePerson_Online if the cuphead show was hand drawn it would evaporate netflix’s budget instantly
We all knew that it was played incorrectly, which is why we wanted a video of this with a new season of CupHead, incredible! 😎👍
Vince army
L daffy pfp
Hehe ruined the likes:)
@@TheNumberOneInternet_Angel Hehe you must be a Jellybean fan, loser! :)
Vince army representative
I think it's worth noting that the piano may have intentionally been animated incorrectly, considering Cuphead is based on 30's era cartoons, which never really payed attention to that stuff. Just a thought though.
Bruh a Tom and Jerry cartoon from that era is literally praised for playing the accurate chords…
@@graysonwells21 Wasn't that T&J cartoon from the 1940s though? That's a little later than what Cuphead is referencing.
@@ernovincze2900 got me there…
@@ernovincze2900 yes buuuut in a 1929 mickey mouse cartoon mickey and minnie play piano correctly
it doesn't matter if it's not played right, besides these cartoons have 4 fingers on each hand
Animator: “WELL YOU TRY TO ANIMATE THOSE RUBBER HOSE FINGERS. HUH? EVER THOUGHT OF THAT?!”
I think this whole channel’s community gets triggered over a slight error
@@supertails0246 "triggered"
Idk man, I think most of them are just chuckling a bit.
I laughed way harder than I thought I would
3 words:
Tom and Jerry
We can't forget that Mugman tried to play Chopsticks but he pressed a "wrong note" which played F, F# and G on a B key
I don’t even know how he managed to mess up chopsticks lol
You mean
Moogman
It actually sounded pretty accurate, way to go Cuphead show
So real
I’m sorry, but I love your pfp! It’s so cute!
is this supposed to be a joke
Cup mozart☠️
People who made the show: just make it some what correct it's not like someone gonna check the exact cords that were played and see what was actually played, who does that?
This guy: it's my time to shine!
OMG 1K WHAT THE HECKERY 😱😱😱(*ˊᗜˋ*)ᵗᑋᵃᐢᵏ ᵞᵒᵘ
they actually did it once for the cuphead nintendo switch announcement, cuphead was actually playing cuphead using the exact controls in the video
I don’t think they could’ve done it accurately anyway, the piano in said episode had less than 3 octaves ,but it’s still kinda funny
@@froggsandstuff also they have 4 fingers on each hand.
Literally though I don't think half of these creator's give a frack-
a
as soon as i saw that scene, i knew it was wrong, and that u would make a vid about it lol
Not even a pianist and it was that obvious 😭
@@Tempus_Locus yea, but like they looked like they were in a rush anyways with getting this season out (it is still amazing tho), so i doubt they would’ve spent that much time on like a 5 minute scene
Same
Me too lmao
@UCvSLgllZFnlqQBHOug11sow actually, idc
I mean. The “what he actually played” sounds cool
Ikr
The opening scene of Dream Mugman playing has good shots of his hands too!
Just the fact that they got freakin chopsticks wrong already makes it 1000% more hilarious
When I saw this episode, I immediately thought of your channel, and how accurate the piano may have been. XD
Same! XD
@@samy3361 Good to know I'm not the only one. XD
0:11 It still sounds good.
I agree
You know that animating people who play a piano is hard
yea i think people who do this kinda stuff are aware of that just they correct it for people so they don’t think it’s actually how it’s played (ik it should be common sense for people but for non piano players it could be very hard for them to tell if it’s right or wrong because sometimes they take the time to animate it correctly and some don’t because of budget and it could be very hard like you said so yea)
Ok and
@@dankboi_ you are not Chad
@@spyfyre1618 :(
@@dankboi_ you are the the the the the G
What cuphead really played actually sounds good
when i first saw this scene i really expected someone to do a video if they animated the piano correctly. I KNEW IT
POV: you actually tried to play Cuphead's version and everything goes wrong, and you were calling yourself dumb
I’m not kidding, it annoyed me so much when Mugman played chopsticks incorrectly, I spent HOURS and I mean HOURS fetching out my old piano books to play chopsticks correctly. Worth it 🤗
That red one was Cuphead
@@twizzitchbuttinier no not him ik the difference in that episode mugman does play chopsticks and he plays it incorrectly
@@strawberrystarsss oh yeah, sorry
I actually think both versions sound good
As an animator actually drawing it perfect is PAIN. Months of no sleep.
I honestly thought The Cuphead Show was the kind of show that wouldn't get the piano wrong.
Ikr considering their animation is always so smooth and fluid
But it is what it is
When I saw this episode, I immediately knew there would be one of these
They should hire this guy so that the animators will know what key will cup head press
Glad they had a pretty head-on view of the piano for this!
"Their pianos are not long enough"
I was waiting for this moment for quite a while and now IT'S HERE
Just think of it as whenever a cartoon animates their piano playing wrong, it’s just that pianos in their world are built differently-
Even the way it should sound is still pretty good.
I'd like to make a joke about this in my future show. Something like :
Character 1 : Do you wanna play the piano ?
Character 2 : Nah. They're never animated correctly anyway.
Yes it would break the fourth wall a lot.
That was so talented how you played the piano
I love this scene in the show
Now, do it with four fingers - like the Cuphead characters have ;) - might be a lot harder to pull it off then XD
Since you showed us this you deserve more viewers
"pianos are never animated correctly 🤓"
Fun fact: the tom and jerry creator got a award for animating the piano (CORRECTLY)
0:10 was aucctally good
Now if this were the animation for a piano in the actual Cuphead game then it’d be a different story!
I haven't studied music since highschool but even I could tell that the same keys played different notes...
I knew that they would make this as soon as I saw this episode
Animators: crunched to the point of being hospitalized
Instrument Players: YOU COULDN'T ANIMATE THE INSTRUMENT RIGHT I'M TRIGGERED
I got a simply piano ad before this like they need that
THANK GOSH SOMEONE NOTICED IT!! I WAS WAITING FOR SOMEONE TO CORRECT THEM BUT IDK HOW TO PLAY PIANO BUT I ONLY SAW CUPHEAD'S SOUND PLAYING IS GOOD BUT THE PIANO PLAYED IS WRONG THANK YOU FOR CORRECTING IT
I knew this would show up. What I didn't expect was that it would be so soon.
Yes
Everyone should like it
as soon as i saw him play i knew you were gonna make a video on it
IVE BEEN WAITING FIR THIS YESS
You should do a part2 for the rest of the scene
Honestly it doesnt take much to animate correctly
the animating doesnt change
you just gotta stop for like 30 seconds to think what note should the characters hit next
I WAS WAITING FOR THIS
Cuphead: "teaching" his brother a piano lesson
Amosdoll: you should take piano lessons from me
When I watched this scene I knew it was going to get into one of these vids
Even though he wasn't playing the right notes, Cuphead is very talented when it comes to playing piano.
They're both actually pretty good
Imagine how long he had to practice the right sounds for this
I already knew it wasn't correct. I was just waiting for this video.
As a tutorial could you do shut up by madness? It's not quite the piano played correctly theme as done by you recently but I don't doubt you'd do it correctly anyways
I was waiting for this to happen
What he actually played would still be kinda impressive considering he’s never played the piano
when they have 4 fingers while all of us has 5 fingers
Bro I was just waiting for someone to do this cause I knew it would pop up eventually
Song name:chop stick
I love the fact it kinda sounded good for the: “what he actually played”
That's pretty good for a cup
Yeah tru dat
“I was waiting for this”
I’ve been waiting for someone to do this, lol
It came,It came, *IT CAME*
I can understand some flubs in the show considering they have 4 fingers... but Cups only needed 2 for the chopsticks part.
I was waiting for it
Pianos are truly never correctly animated. Not even Chuzzle 2's Chuzzarium piano (which you can get by completing a certain spot on the Fuzzlectric Symphony puzzle). I'm talking about the 2 Chuzzles version.
0:20 this reminds of one ringtone that my father has when he is going to work
The phone started ringing it was a banger!
can’t wait
you are goated at piano
Half of the comments: pianos are never animated correctly
Tom and jerry and mickey mouse: I am four parallel universes ahead of you
When you are at work, and you thought that you've typed a perfect report, but it really wasn't.
This guy always corrects music on the piano
I knew this day would come.
i knew this was going to happen!!!
They have a short keyboard for the piano which is really understandable.
the way how Cuphead play piano turns out to be an anime default song
Cuphead: ima gonna do some pianos
Org Music: lets play a bit of street fighter
*me realizing he was gonna play chopsticks made my niziu😭❤*
OMG THANK YOUUU NOW I CAN PLAYY ITTTTT =DD
Another to check can be
Angry birds: piggy tales (the keyboard imitating ringtones)
Grizzy and the lemmings: Sonata in bear major
Wouldn’t be surprised if the animators of the show saw your videos and purposely animated it wrong so you could make a video about it
my life will never be the same knowing that some cartoon didn't animate a piano correctly to save lots of time. How dare they.
It's still beautiful
I like the song choopsticks, it is also easy to play in the piano.
The mug man staring he's so good
I got an ad for simply piano before this 💀
What he actually played sounded good until that last note
Cuphead’s extreme dumb luck probably ended up causing him to somehow play if perfectly despite the fact he was just hitting keys at random
They're doing the best they can yaknow
Saw this the other day and I knew this trend was gonna have a field day with this 🤣
I saw the scene and thought this. XD
I guess Tom is the only animated character who really know how to play the piano.
10:00 That piano can't even have enough keys too small...
Larry’s reply is: true
SO COOL AT 0:17
I knew you were gonna do this-
Cant believe a tv show about talking cups that owe their souls to the devil doesn’t perfectly fit reality.
When I saw the episode when it came out I knew it was gonna end up here